Brian Goldman: Doctors make mistakes. Can we talk about that?
November 11, 2011
Every doctor makes mistakes. But, says physician Brian Goldman, medicine's culture of denial (and shame) keeps doctors from ever talking about those mistakes, or using them to learn and improve. Telling stories from his own long practice, he calls on doctors to start talking about being wrong.
(Filmed at TEDxToronto.)
- Physician, broadcaster
Brian Goldman is an emergency-room physician in Toronto, and the host of CBC Radio’s "White Coat, Black Art." Full bio
Double-click the English subtitles below to play the video.
I think we have to do something
about a piece of the culture of medicine that has to change.
And I think it starts with one physician, and that's me.
And maybe I've been around long enough
that I can afford to give away some of my false prestige
to be able to do that.
Before I actually begin the meat of my talk,
let's begin with a bit of baseball.
Hey, why not?
We're near the end, we're getting close to the World Series.
We all love baseball, don't we?
Baseball is filled with some amazing statistics.
And there's hundreds of them.
"Moneyball" is about to come out, and it's all about statistics
and using statistics to build a great baseball team.
I'm going to focus on one stat
that I hope a lot of you have heard of.
It's called batting average.
So we talk about a 300, a batter who bats 300.
That means that ballplayer batted safely, hit safely
three times out of 10 at bats.
That means hit the ball into the outfield,
it dropped, it didn't get caught,
and whoever tried to throw it to first base didn't get there in time
and the runner was safe.
Three times out of 10.
Do you know what they call a 300 hitter
in Major League Baseball?
Good, really good,
maybe an all-star.
Do you know what they call
a 400 baseball hitter?
That's somebody who hit, by the way,
four times safely out of every 10.
as in Ted Williams legendary --
the last Major League Baseball player
to hit over 400 during a regular season.
Now let's take this back into my world of medicine
where I'm a lot more comfortable,
or perhaps a bit less comfortable
after what I'm going to talk to you about.
Suppose you have appendicitis
and you're referred to a surgeon
who's batting 400 on appendectomies.
Somehow this isn't working out, is it?
Now suppose you live
in a certain part of a certain remote place
and you have a loved one
who has blockages in two coronary arteries
and your family doctor refers that loved one to a cardiologist
who's batting 200 on angioplasties.
But, but, you know what?
She's doing a lot better this year. She's on the comeback trail.
And she's hitting a 257.
Somehow this isn't working.
But I'm going to ask you a question.
What do you think a batting average
for a cardiac surgeon or a nurse practitioner
or an orthopedic surgeon,
an OBGYN, a paramedic
is supposed to be?
1,000, very good.
Now truth of the matter is,
nobody knows in all of medicine
what a good surgeon
or physician or paramedic
is supposed to bat.
What we do though is we send each one of them, including myself,
out into the world
with the admonition, be perfect.
Never ever, ever make a mistake,
but you worry about the details, about how that's going to happen.
And that was the message that I absorbed
when I was in med school.
I was an obsessive compulsive student.
In high school, a classmate once said
that Brian Goldman would study for a blood test.
And so I did.
And I studied in my little garret
at the nurses' residence at Toronto General Hospital,
not far from here.
And I memorized everything.
I memorized in my anatomy class
the origins and exertions of every muscle,
every branch of every artery that came off the aorta,
differential diagnoses obscure and common.
I even knew the differential diagnosis
in how to classify renal tubular acidosis.
And all the while,
I was amassing more and more knowledge.
And I did well, I graduated with honors,
And I came out of medical school
with the impression
that if I memorized everything and knew everything,
or as much as possible,
as close to everything as possible,
that it would immunize me against making mistakes.
And it worked
for a while,
until I met Mrs. Drucker.
I was a resident at a teaching hospital here in Toronto
when Mrs. Drucker was brought to the emergency department
of the hospital where I was working.
At the time I was assigned to the cardiology service
on a cardiology rotation.
And it was my job,
when the emergency staff called for a cardiology consult,
to see that patient in emerg.
and to report back to my attending.
And I saw Mrs. Drucker, and she was breathless.
And when I listened to her, she was making a wheezy sound.
And when I listened to her chest with a stethoscope,
I could hear crackly sounds on both sides
that told me that she was in congestive heart failure.
This is a condition in which the heart fails,
and instead of being able to pump all the blood forward,
some of the blood backs up into the lung, the lungs fill up with blood,
and that's why you have shortness of breath.
And that wasn't a difficult diagnosis to make.
I made it and I set to work treating her.
I gave her aspirin. I gave her medications to relieve the strain on her heart.
I gave her medications that we call diuretics, water pills,
to get her to pee out the access fluid.
And over the course of the next hour and a half or two,
she started to feel better.
And I felt really good.
And that's when I made my first mistake;
I sent her home.
Actually, I made two more mistakes.
I sent her home
without speaking to my attending.
I didn't pick up the phone and do what I was supposed to do,
which was call my attending and run the story by him
so he would have a chance to see her for himself.
And he knew her,
he would have been able to furnish additional information about her.
Maybe I did it for a good reason.
Maybe I didn't want to be a high-maintenance resident.
Maybe I wanted to be so successful
and so able to take responsibility
that I would do so
and I would be able to take care of my attending's patients
without even having to contact him.
The second mistake that I made was worse.
In sending her home,
I disregarded a little voice deep down inside
that was trying to tell me,
"Goldman, not a good idea. Don't do this."
In fact, so lacking in confidence was I
that I actually asked the nurse
who was looking after Mrs. Drucker,
"Do you think it's okay if she goes home?"
And the nurse thought about it
and said very matter-of-factly, "Yeah, I think she'll do okay."
I can remember that like it was yesterday.
So I signed the discharge papers,
and an ambulance came, paramedics came to take her home.
And I went back to my work on the wards.
All the rest of that day,
I had this kind of gnawing feeling inside my stomach.
But I carried on with my work.
And at the end of the day, I packed up to leave the hospital
and walked to the parking lot
to take my car and drive home
when I did something that I don't usually do.
I walked through the emergency department on my way home.
And it was there that another nurse,
not the nurse who was looking after Mrs. Drucker before, but another nurse,
said three words to me
that are the three words
that most emergency physicians I know dread.
Others in medicine dread them as well,
but there's something particular about emergency medicine
because we see patients so fleetingly.
The three words are:
Do you remember?
"Do you remember that patient you sent home?"
the other nurse asked matter-of-factly.
"Well she's back,"
in just that tone of voice.
Well she was back all right.
She was back and near death.
About an hour after she had arrived home,
after I'd sent her home,
she collapsed and her family called 911
and the paramedics brought her back to the emergency department
where she had a blood pressure of 50,
which is in severe shock.
And she was barely breathing and she was blue.
And the emerg. staff pulled out all the stops.
They gave her medications to raise her blood pressure.
They put her on a ventilator.
And I was shocked
and shaken to the core.
And I went through this roller coaster,
because after they stabilized her,
she went to the intensive care unit,
and I hoped against hope that she would recover.
And over the next two or three days,
it was clear that she was never going to wake up.
She had irreversible brain damage.
And the family gathered.
And over the course of the next eight or nine days,
they resigned themselves to what was happening.
And at about the nine day mark, they let her go --
a wife, a mother
and a grandmother.
They say you never forget the names
of those who die.
And that was my first time to be acquainted with that.
Over the next few weeks,
I beat myself up
and I experienced for the first time
the unhealthy shame that exists
in our culture of medicine --
where I felt alone, isolated,
not feeling the healthy kind of shame that you feel,
because you can't talk about it with your colleagues.
You know that healthy kind,
when you betray a secret that a best friend made you promise never to reveal
and then you get busted
and then your best friend confronts you
and you have terrible discussions,
but at the end of it all that sick feeling guides you
and you say, I'll never make that mistake again.
And you make amends and you never make that mistake again.
That's the kind of shame that is a teacher.
The unhealthy shame I'm talking about
is the one that makes you so sick inside.
It's the one that says,
not that what you did was bad,
but that you are bad.
And it was what I was feeling.
And it wasn't because of my attending; he was a doll.
He talked to the family, and I'm quite sure that he smoothed things over
and made sure that I didn't get sued.
And I kept asking myself these questions.
Why didn't I ask my attending? Why did I send her home?
And then at my worst moments:
Why did I make such a stupid mistake?
Why did I go into medicine?
Slowly but surely,
I began to feel a bit better.
And on a cloudy day,
there was a crack in the clouds and the sun started to come out
and I wondered,
maybe I could feel better again.
And I made myself a bargain
that if only I redouble my efforts to be perfect
and never make another mistake again,
please make the voices stop.
And they did.
And I went back to work.
And then it happened again.
Two years later I was an attending in the emergency department
at a community hospital just north of Toronto,
and I saw a 25 year-old man with a sore throat.
It was busy, I was in a bit of a hurry.
He kept pointing here.
I looked at his throat, it was a little bit pink.
And I gave him a prescription for penicillin
and sent him on his way.
And even as he was walking out the door,
he was still sort of pointing to his throat.
And two days later I came to do my next emergency shift,
and that's when my chief asked to speak to me quietly in her office.
And she said the three words:
Do you remember?
"Do you remember that patient you saw with the sore throat?"
Well it turns out, he didn't have a strep throat.
He had a potentially life-threatening condition
You can Google it,
but it's an infection, not of the throat, but of the upper airway,
and it can actually cause the airway to close.
And fortunately he didn't die.
He was placed on intravenous antibiotics
and he recovered after a few days.
And I went through the same period of shame and recriminations
and felt cleansed and went back to work,
until it happened again and again and again.
Twice in one emergency shift, I missed appendicitis.
Now that takes some doing,
especially when you work in a hospital
that at the time saw but 14 people a night.
Now in both cases, I didn't send them home
and I don't think there was any gap in their care.
One I thought had a kidney stone.
I ordered a kidney X-ray. When it turned out to be normal,
my colleague who was doing a reassessment of the patient
noticed some tenderness in the right lower quadrant and called the surgeons.
The other one had a lot of diarrhea.
I ordered some fluids to rehydrate him
and asked my colleague to reassess him.
And he did
and when he noticed some tenderness in the right lower quadrant, called the surgeons.
In both cases,
they had their operations and they did okay.
But each time,
they were gnawing at me, eating at me.
And I'd like to be able to say to you
that my worst mistakes only happened in the first five years of practice
as many of my colleagues say, which is total B.S.
Some of my doozies have been in the last five years.
Alone, ashamed and unsupported.
Here's the problem:
If I can't come clean
and talk about my mistakes,
if I can't find the still-small voice
that tells me what really happened,
how can I share it with my colleagues?
How can I teach them about what I did
so that they don't do the same thing?
If I were to walk into a room --
like right now, I have no idea what you think of me.
When was the last time you heard somebody talk
about failure after failure after failure?
Oh yeah, you go to a cocktail party
and you might hear about some other doctor,
but you're not going to hear somebody
talking about their own mistakes.
If I were to walk into a room filled with my colleages
and ask for their support right now
and start to tell what I've just told you right now,
I probably wouldn't get through two of those stories
before they would start to get really uncomfortable,
somebody would crack a joke,
they'd change the subject and we would move on.
And in fact, if I knew and my colleagues knew
that one of my orthopedic colleagues took off the wrong leg in my hospital,
believe me, I'd have trouble
making eye contact with that person.
That's the system that we have.
It's a complete denial of mistakes.
It's a system
in which there are two kinds of physicians --
those who make mistakes
and those who don't,
those who can't handle sleep deprivation and those who can,
those who have lousy outcomes
and those who have great outcomes.
And it's almost like an ideological reaction,
like the antibodies begin to attack that person.
And we have this idea
that if we drive the people who make mistakes
out of medicine,
what will we be left with, but a safe system.
But there are two problems with that.
In my 20 years or so
of medical broadcasting and journalism,
I've made a personal study of medical malpractice and medical errors
to learn everything I can,
from one of the first articles I wrote for the Toronto Star
to my show "White Coat, Black Art."
And what I've learned
is that errors are absolutely ubiquitous.
We work in a system
where errors happen every day,
where one in 10 medications
are either the wrong medication given in hospital
or at the wrong dosage,
where hospital-acquired infections are getting more and more numerous,
causing havoc and death.
In this country,
as many as 24,000 Canadians die
of preventable medical errors.
In the United States, the Institute of Medicine pegged it at 100,000.
In both cases, these are gross underestimates,
because we really aren't ferreting out the problem
as we should.
And here's the thing.
In a hospital system
where medical knowledge is doubling
every two or three years, we can't keep up with it.
Sleep deprivation is absolutely pervasive.
We can't get rid of it.
We have our cognitive biases,
so that I can take a perfect history on a patient with chest pain.
Now take the same patient with chest pain,
make them moist and garrulous
and put a little bit of alcohol on their breath,
and suddenly my history is laced with contempt.
I don't take the same history.
I'm not a robot;
I don't do things the same way each time.
And my patients aren't cars;
they don't tell me their symptoms in the same way each time.
Given all of that, mistakes are inevitable.
So if you take the system, as I was taught,
and weed out all the error-prone health professionals,
well there won't be anybody left.
And you know that business
about people not wanting
to talk about their worst cases?
On my show, on "White Coat, Black Art,"
I made it a habit of saying, "Here's my worst mistake,"
I would say to everybody
from paramedics to the chief of cardiac surgery,
"Here's my worst mistake," blah, blah, blah, blah, blah,
"What about yours?" and I would point the microphone towards them.
And their pupils would dilate,
they would recoil,
then they would look down and swallow hard
and start to tell me their stories.
They want to tell their stories. They want to share their stories.
They want to be able to say,
"Look, don't make the same mistake I did."
What they need is an environment to be able to do that.
What they need is a redefined medical culture.
And it starts with one physician at a time.
The redefined physician is human,
knows she's human,
accepts it, isn't proud of making mistakes,
but strives to learn one thing
from what happened
that she can teach to somebody else.
She shares her experience with others.
She's supportive when other people talk about their mistakes.
And she points out other people's mistakes,
not in a gotcha way,
but in a loving, supportive way
so that everybody can benefit.
And she works in a culture of medicine
that human beings run the system,
and when human beings run the system, they will make mistakes from time to time.
So the system is evolving
to create backups
that make it easier to detect those mistakes
that humans inevitably make
and also fosters in a loving, supportive way
places where everybody who is observing
in the health care system
can actually point out things that could be potential mistakes
and is rewarded for doing so,
and especially people like me, when we do make mistakes,
we're rewarded for coming clean.
My name is Brian Goldman.
I am a redefined physician.
I'm human. I make mistakes.
I'm sorry about that,
but I strive to learn one thing
that I can pass on to other people.
I still don't know what you think of me,
but I can live with that.
And let me close with three words of my own:
I do remember.
- Physician, broadcaster
Brian Goldman is an emergency-room physician in Toronto, and the host of CBC Radio’s "White Coat, Black Art."Why you should listen
Brian Goldman is an emergency room physician who has worked at Mount Sinai Hospital in downtown Toronto for more than 20 years. He is also a prominent medical journalist and the host of CBC Radio’s White Coat, Black Art. In Dr. Goldman’s first book, The Night Shift, published in 2010, he shares his experiences of working through the witching hours at Mount Sinai, as well as at the other hospitals where he has spent his long career.
The original video is available on TED.com