TEDxSummit
Cesar Harada: A novel idea for cleaning up oil spills
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
891,401 views
When TED Senior Fellow Cesar Harada heard about the devastating effects of the BP Oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010, he quit his dream job and moved to New Orleans to develop a more efficient way to soak up the oil. He designed a highly maneuverable, flexible boat capable of cleaning large tracts quickly. But rather than turn a profit, he has opted to open-source the design.
Cesar Harada - Inventor, environmentalist, educator
TED Senior Fellow Cesar Harada aims to harness the forces of nature as he invents innovative remedies for man-made problems like oil spills and radioactive leaks. Full bio
TED Senior Fellow Cesar Harada aims to harness the forces of nature as he invents innovative remedies for man-made problems like oil spills and radioactive leaks. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
In the ocean,
0
508
1032
00:17
what is the common point
1
1540
1840
00:19
between oil, plastic and radioactivity?
2
3380
5768
00:25
On the top line, this is the BP oil spill:
3
9148
5217
00:30
billions of barrels of oil gushing
4
14365
2023
00:32
in the Gulf of Mexico.
5
16388
1369
00:33
The middle line is millions of tons of
6
17757
2175
00:35
plastic debris accumulating in our ocean,
7
19932
2404
00:38
and the third line is radioactive material
8
22336
2720
00:40
leaking from Fukushima nuclear power plant
9
25056
2296
00:43
in the Pacific Ocean.
10
27352
1338
00:44
Well, the three big problems have in common
11
28690
4583
00:49
that they are man-made problems
12
33273
2815
00:51
but they are controlled by natural forces.
13
36088
2056
00:54
This should make us feel very, terribly awful
14
38144
4408
00:58
as much as it should make us feel hopeful,
15
42552
2327
01:00
because if we have the power to create these problems,
16
44879
2809
01:03
we may as well have the power
17
47688
1680
01:05
to remediate these problems.
18
49368
1432
01:06
But what about natural forces?
19
50800
1944
01:08
Well, that's exactly what I want to talk about today,
20
52744
2983
01:11
is how we can use these natural forces
21
55727
2305
01:13
to remediate these man-made problems.
22
58032
5223
01:19
When the BP oil spill happened,
23
63255
1226
01:20
I was working at MIT, and I was in charge
24
64481
2765
01:23
of developing an oil spill-cleaning technology.
25
67246
2397
01:25
And I had a chance to go in the Gulf of Mexico
26
69643
3413
01:28
and meet some fishermen and see
27
73056
2337
01:31
the terrible conditions in which they were working.
28
75393
1791
01:33
More than 700 of these boats,
29
77184
3081
01:36
which are fishermen boats repurposed
30
80265
2307
01:38
with oil absorbent in white
31
82572
2461
01:40
and oil containment in orange, were used,
32
85033
2395
01:43
but they only collected three percent of the oil on the surface,
33
87428
3259
01:46
and the health of the cleaners
34
90687
1712
01:48
were very deeply affected.
35
92399
1913
01:50
I was working on a very interesting technology
36
94312
3994
01:54
at MIT, but it was a very long-term view
37
98306
2309
01:56
of how to develop technology,
38
100615
1434
01:57
and it was going to be a very expensive technology,
39
102049
2518
02:00
and also it would be patented.
40
104567
2448
02:02
So I wanted to develop something that we could
41
107015
2632
02:05
develop very fast, that would be cheap,
42
109647
3400
02:08
and that would be open-source, so, because
43
113047
2440
02:11
oil spills are not only happening in the Gulf of Mexico,
44
115487
2168
02:13
and that would be using renewable energy.
45
117655
2616
02:16
So I quit my dream job,
46
120271
2400
02:18
and I moved to New Orleans,
47
122671
1616
02:20
and I kept on studying how the oil spill was happening.
48
124287
2944
02:23
Currently, what they were doing is
49
127231
2072
02:25
that they were using these small fishing boats,
50
129303
1646
02:26
and they were cleaning clean lines in an ocean of dirt.
51
130949
3160
02:30
If you're using the exact same amount of surface
52
134109
3713
02:33
of oil absorbent, but you're just paying attention
53
137822
2153
02:35
to natural patterns, and if you're going up the winds,
54
139975
2333
02:38
you can collect a lot more material.
55
142308
1768
02:39
If you're multiplying the rig,
56
144076
2121
02:42
so you multiply how many layers of absorbent
57
146197
2575
02:44
you're using, you can collect a lot more.
58
148772
1902
02:46
But it's extremely difficult to move oil absorbent
59
150674
2601
02:49
against the winds, the surface currents and the waves.
60
153275
3632
02:52
These are enormous forces.
61
156907
1464
02:54
So the very simple idea was to use the ancient technique
62
158371
3023
02:57
of sailing and tacking of the wind
63
161394
2253
02:59
to capture or intercept the oil
64
163647
2618
03:02
that is drifting down the wind.
65
166265
1342
03:03
So this didn't require any invention.
66
167607
3497
03:07
We just took a simple sailing boat
67
171104
1703
03:08
and we tried to pull something long and heavy,
68
172807
1897
03:10
but as we tacked back and forth,
69
174704
2312
03:12
what we lost was two things:
70
177016
1671
03:14
we were losing pulling power and direction.
71
178687
3377
03:17
And so, I thought, what about if we just take the rudder
72
182064
3832
03:21
from the back of the boat to the front,
73
185896
1512
03:23
would we have better control?
74
187408
1743
03:25
So I built this small sailing robot
75
189151
2216
03:27
with the rudder at the front,
76
191367
1248
03:28
and I was trying to pull something very long and heavy,
77
192615
2465
03:30
so that's a four-meter-long object just to pull,
78
195080
3207
03:34
and I was surprised with just a 14-centimeter rudder,
79
198287
2912
03:37
I could control four meters of absorbent.
80
201199
2352
03:39
Then I was so happy that I kept playing with the robot,
81
203551
3816
03:43
and so you see the robot has
82
207367
2464
03:45
a front rudder here.
83
209831
1672
03:47
Normally it's at the back.
84
211503
1216
03:48
And, playing, I realized that the maneuverability
85
212719
3615
03:52
of this was really amazing,
86
216334
1280
03:53
and I could avoid an obstacle at the very last second,
87
217614
1928
03:55
more maneuverable than a normal boat.
88
219542
1672
03:57
Then I started publishing online, and
89
221214
2864
03:59
some friends from Korea, they started being
90
224078
2912
04:02
interested in this, and we made a boat
91
226990
1729
04:04
which has a front rudder and a back rudder,
92
228719
1808
04:06
so we started interacting with this,
93
230527
2058
04:08
and it was slightly better,
94
232585
2119
04:10
although it was very small and a bit off balance,
95
234704
1924
04:12
but then we thought,
96
236628
1080
04:13
what if we have more than two points of control?
97
237708
1888
04:15
What if the entire boat becomes a point of control?
98
239596
1992
04:17
What if the entire boat changes shape?
99
241588
2120
04:19
So — (Applause)
100
243708
2440
04:22
Thank you very much. (Applause)
101
246148
1896
04:23
And so that's the beginning of Protei,
102
248044
2585
04:26
and that's the first boat in history
103
250629
1639
04:28
that completely changed the shape of the hull
104
252268
1624
04:29
in order to control it,
105
253892
1170
04:30
and the properties of sailing that we get
106
255062
2886
04:33
are very superior compared to a normal boat.
107
257948
2898
04:36
When we're turning, we have the feeling of surfing,
108
260846
2654
04:39
and the way it's going up-wind, it's very efficient.
109
263500
4116
04:43
This is low speed, low wind speed,
110
267616
2700
04:46
and the maneuverability is very increased,
111
270316
2073
04:48
and here I'm going to do a small jibe,
112
272389
2311
04:50
and look at the position of the sail.
113
274700
2096
04:52
What's happening is that, because the boat changes shape,
114
276796
3600
04:56
the position of the front sail and the main sail
115
280396
2340
04:58
are different to the wind.
116
282736
1177
04:59
We're catching wind from both sides.
117
283913
1883
05:01
And this is exactly what we're looking [for]
118
285796
2259
05:03
if we want to pull something long and heavy.
119
288055
1784
05:05
We don't want to lose pulling power, nor direction.
120
289839
2389
05:08
So, I wanted to know if this was possible
121
292228
2840
05:10
to put this at an industrial level,
122
295068
1471
05:12
so we made a large boat with a large sail,
123
296539
2512
05:14
and with a very light hull, inflatable,
124
299051
2696
05:17
very small footprint,
125
301747
1505
05:19
so we have a very big size and power ratio.
126
303252
2824
05:21
After this, we wanted to see if we could
127
306076
3231
05:25
implement this and automate the system,
128
309307
2297
05:27
so we used the same system but we added
129
311604
1672
05:29
a structure to it so we could activate the machine.
130
313276
2370
05:31
So, we used the same bladder-inflated system,
131
315646
3214
05:34
and we took it for testing.
132
318860
1984
05:36
So this is happening in the Netherlands.
133
320844
2311
05:39
We tried in the water without any skin or ballast
134
323155
2531
05:41
just to see how it works.
135
325686
2571
05:44
And then we mounted a camera for controlling it,
136
328257
2685
05:46
but quickly we saw that we would need
137
330942
2902
05:49
a lot more weight at the bottom,
138
333844
2149
05:51
so we had to take it back to the lab,
139
335993
1537
05:53
and then we built a skin around it,
140
337530
2088
05:55
we put batteries, remote controllers, and then
141
339618
3287
05:58
we put it in the water and then we
142
342905
1448
06:00
let it go in the water and see how well it would work,
143
344353
3161
06:03
so let some rope out, and hope it's going to work,
144
347514
3424
06:06
and it worked okay, but we still have a long way.
145
350938
3223
06:10
Our small prototype has given us good insight
146
354161
2436
06:12
that it's working very well,
147
356597
1346
06:13
but we still need to work a lot more on this.
148
357943
2685
06:16
So what we are doing is an accelerated evolution
149
360628
3869
06:20
of sailing technology.
150
364497
1448
06:21
We went from a back rudder to a front rudder
151
365945
1927
06:23
to two rudders to multiple rudders
152
367872
2011
06:25
to the whole boat changing shape,
153
369883
1671
06:27
and the more we are moving forward,
154
371554
1856
06:29
and the more the design looks simple and cute. (Laughter)
155
373410
6047
06:35
But I wanted to show you a fish because --
156
379457
2377
06:37
In fact, it's very different from a fish.
157
381834
3070
06:40
A fish will move because -- by changing like this,
158
384904
4400
06:45
but our boat is propelled by the wind still,
159
389304
3099
06:48
and the hull controls the trajectory.
160
392403
2407
06:50
So I brought to you for the first time on the TED stage
161
394810
3654
06:54
Protei Number Eight. It's not the last one,
162
398464
2385
06:56
but it's a good one for making demos.
163
400849
2249
06:58
So the first thing as I show you in the video is
164
403098
2276
07:01
that we may be able to control the trajectory
165
405374
3987
07:05
of a sailing boat better,
166
409361
1464
07:06
or we may be able to never be in irons,
167
410825
3061
07:09
so never facing the wind,
168
413886
1300
07:11
we always can catch the wind from both sides.
169
415186
2115
07:13
But new properties of a sailing boat.
170
417301
2560
07:15
So if you're looking at the boat from this side,
171
419861
4256
07:20
this might remind you of an airplane profile.
172
424117
2208
07:22
An airplane, when you're moving in this direction,
173
426325
2413
07:24
starts to lift, and that's how it takes off.
174
428738
2265
07:26
Now, if you're taking the same system,
175
431003
2175
07:29
and you're putting vertical, you're bending,
176
433178
2368
07:31
and if you're moving this way forward,
177
435546
2000
07:33
your instinct will tell you that you might go this way,
178
437546
3127
07:36
but if you're moving fast enough,
179
440673
1807
07:38
you might create what we call lateral lift,
180
442480
2019
07:40
so we could get further or closer to the wind.
181
444499
2925
07:43
Other property is this:
182
447424
2944
07:46
A normal sailing boat has a centerboard here
183
450368
3161
07:49
and a rudder at the back,
184
453529
1992
07:51
and these two things are what creates most
185
455521
2550
07:53
resistance and turbulence behind the boat,
186
458071
2654
07:56
but because this doesn't have either
187
460725
2271
07:58
a centerboard or a rudder,
188
462996
1536
08:00
we hope that if we keep working on this hull design
189
464532
2872
08:03
we can improve and have less resistance.
190
467404
2192
08:05
The other thing is, most boats, when they reach
191
469596
2655
08:08
a certain speed, and they are going on waves,
192
472251
2224
08:10
they start to hit and slap on the surface of the water,
193
474475
2439
08:12
and a lot of the energy moving forward is lost.
194
476914
3297
08:16
But if we're going with the flow,
195
480211
2088
08:18
if we pay attention to natural patterns
196
482299
2136
08:20
instead of trying to be strong,
197
484435
1611
08:21
but if you're going with the flow, we may absorb
198
486046
2399
08:24
a lot of environmental noises, so the wave energy,
199
488445
3197
08:27
to actually save some energy to move forward.
200
491642
3157
08:30
So we may have developed the technology
201
494799
4151
08:34
which is very efficient for pulling something long and heavy,
202
498950
2667
08:37
but the idea is, what is the purpose of technology
203
501617
4217
08:41
if it doesn't reach the right hands?
204
505834
1946
08:43
Normal technology or innovation happens like this:
205
507780
2946
08:46
Somebody has an interesting idea,
206
510726
2430
08:49
some other scientist or engineer,
207
513156
1962
08:51
they take it to the next level, they make a theory about it
208
515118
2504
08:53
and maybe they patent it,
209
517622
1256
08:54
and then some industry will make a contract
210
518878
2536
08:57
of exclusivity to manufacture and sell it,
211
521414
3144
09:00
and then, eventually, a buyer will buy it,
212
524558
2096
09:02
and we hope that they are going to use [it] for a good purpose.
213
526654
2768
09:05
What we really want is that this innovation happens
214
529422
3696
09:09
continuously. The inventor and engineers
215
533118
2336
09:11
and also the manufacturers and everybody
216
535454
1736
09:13
works at the same time, but this would be sterile
217
537190
2384
09:15
if this was happening in a parallel and uncrossed process.
218
539574
3632
09:19
What you really want is not a sequential,
219
543206
2040
09:21
not parallel development.
220
545246
1392
09:22
You want to have a network of innovation.
221
546638
1609
09:24
You want everybody, like we're doing now,
222
548247
2079
09:26
to work at the same time, and that can only happen
223
550326
3169
09:29
if these people all together decide to share the information,
224
553495
3391
09:32
and that's exactly what open hardware is about.
225
556886
2940
09:35
It's to replace competition by collaboration.
226
559826
3669
09:39
It's to transform any new product into a new market.
227
563495
4151
09:43
So what is open hardware?
228
567646
2441
09:45
Essentially, open hardware is a license.
229
570087
1783
09:47
It's just an intellectual property setup.
230
571870
2072
09:49
It means that everybody is free to use,
231
573942
3024
09:52
modify and distribute, and in exchange
232
576966
3153
09:56
we only ask for two things:
233
580119
1278
09:57
The name is credited -- the name of the project --
234
581397
2095
09:59
and also the people who make improvement,
235
583492
2736
10:02
they share back with the community.
236
586228
1328
10:03
So it's a very simple condition.
237
587556
1336
10:04
And I started this project alone in a garage in New Orleans,
238
588892
4024
10:08
but quickly after I wanted to publish and share
239
592916
2176
10:10
this information, so I made a Kickstarter,
240
595092
1744
10:12
which is a crowd-fundraising platform,
241
596836
2240
10:14
and in about one month we fundraised 30,000 dollars.
242
599076
2432
10:17
With this money, I hired a team of young engineers
243
601508
3312
10:20
from all over the world, and we rented a factory
244
604820
2528
10:23
in Rotterdam in the Netherlands.
245
607348
1520
10:24
We were peer-learning, we were engineering,
246
608868
3161
10:27
we were making things, prototyping,
247
612029
3183
10:31
but most importantly we were trying our prototypes
248
615212
2225
10:33
in the water as often as possible,
249
617437
1695
10:35
to fail as quickly as possible, to learn from.
250
619132
3152
10:38
This is a proud member of Protei from Korea,
251
622284
2512
10:40
and on the right side, this is a multiple-masts
252
624796
2460
10:43
design proposed by a team in Mexico.
253
627256
1933
10:45
This idea really appealed to Gabriella Levine
254
629189
3185
10:48
in New York, and so she decided to prototype
255
632374
2595
10:50
this idea that she saw, and she documented
256
634969
2530
10:53
every step of the process,
257
637499
1429
10:54
and she published it on Instructables,
258
638928
2249
10:57
which is a website for sharing inventions.
259
641177
2232
10:59
Less than one week after,
260
643409
1895
11:01
this is a team in Eindhoven, it's a school of engineering.
261
645304
4010
11:05
They made it, but they eventually published
262
649314
2330
11:07
a simplified design.
263
651644
1124
11:08
They also made it into an Instructable,
264
652768
1929
11:10
and in less than one week, they had
265
654697
1735
11:12
almost 10,000 views, and they got many new friends.
266
656432
2760
11:15
We're working on also simpler technology,
267
659192
2904
11:17
not that complex, with younger people
268
662096
1951
11:19
and also older people,
269
664047
1569
11:21
like this dinosaur is from Mexico. (Laughter)
270
665616
3151
11:24
So Protei is now an international network
271
668767
2817
11:27
of innovation for selling technology
272
671584
2848
11:30
using this shape-shifting hull.
273
674432
1792
11:32
And what puts us together is that we have a common,
274
676224
4035
11:36
at least, global understanding
275
680259
2789
11:38
of what the word "business" is, or what it should be.
276
683048
3072
11:42
This is how most work today.
277
686120
2233
11:44
Business as usual is saying, what's most important
278
688353
2374
11:46
is to make lots of profit, and you'll be using
279
690727
2239
11:48
technology for that, and people will be your work force,
280
692966
2825
11:51
instrumentalized,
281
695791
1248
11:52
and environment is usually the last priority.
282
697039
2672
11:55
It will be just a way to, say, greenwash your audience
283
699711
3878
11:59
and, say, increase your price tag.
284
703589
2231
12:01
What we're trying to do, or what we believe,
285
705820
2529
12:04
because this is how we believe the world really works,
286
708349
2416
12:06
is that without the environment you have nothing.
287
710765
2170
12:08
We have the people so we need to protect each other, yes,
288
712935
2885
12:11
and we're a technology company,
289
715820
1664
12:13
and profit is necessary to make this happen. (Applause)
290
717484
5185
12:18
Thank you very much. (Applause)
291
722669
3605
12:22
If we have the courage to understand or accept
292
726274
4081
12:26
that this actually how the world really works,
293
730355
1920
12:28
and this is the order of priority that we need to choose,
294
732275
3017
12:31
then it makes obvious why we need
295
735292
2141
12:33
to choose open hardware for developing environmental
296
737433
2339
12:35
technology, because we need to share information.
297
739772
1880
12:37
What's next for us?
298
741652
2080
12:39
So, this small machine that you've seen,
299
743732
2535
12:42
we're hoping to make small toys like
300
746267
2144
12:44
one-meter remote control Protei that you can upgrade --
301
748411
3493
12:47
so replace the remote control parts by Androids,
302
751904
2986
12:50
so the mobile phone, and Arduino micro-controller,
303
754890
3779
12:54
so you could be controlling this
304
758669
1223
12:55
from your mobile phone, your tablet.
305
759892
1488
12:57
Then what we want to do is create six-meter versions
306
761380
3566
13:00
so we can test the maximum performance of these machines,
307
764946
2328
13:03
so we can go at very, very high speed.
308
767274
1564
13:04
So imagine yourself.
309
768838
1263
13:06
You are laying down in a flexible torpedo,
310
770101
3185
13:09
sailing at high speed,
311
773286
1494
13:10
controlling the shape of the hull with your legs
312
774780
1845
13:12
and controlling the sail with your arms.
313
776625
2662
13:15
So that's what we're looking for developing. (Applause)
314
779287
4325
13:19
And we replace the human being --
315
783612
2214
13:21
to go, for example, for measuring radioactivity,
316
785826
2144
13:23
you don't want a human to be sailing those robots --
317
787970
2179
13:26
with batteries, motors, micro-controllers and sensors.
318
790149
3335
13:29
This is what our teammates, we dream of at night.
319
793484
3934
13:33
We hope that we can sometime clean up oil spills,
320
797418
2652
13:35
or we can gather or collect plastic in the ocean,
321
800070
3977
13:39
or we can have swarms of our machines
322
804047
3434
13:43
controlled by multi-player video game engines
323
807481
3182
13:46
to control many of these machines,
324
810663
1951
13:48
to monitor coral reefs
325
812614
1751
13:50
or to monitor fisheries.
326
814365
2139
13:52
Our hope is that we can use open hardware technology
327
816504
4490
13:56
to better understand and protect our oceans.
328
820994
3531
14:00
Thank you very much. (Applause)
329
824525
3712
14:04
(Applause)
330
828237
19262
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Cesar Harada - Inventor, environmentalist, educatorTED Senior Fellow Cesar Harada aims to harness the forces of nature as he invents innovative remedies for man-made problems like oil spills and radioactive leaks.
Why you should listen
Cesar Harada believes that ocean currents, the wind and other naturally occuring phenomenon can provide unique inspiration and novel solutions to mankind’s worst disasters, like oil spills and radioactive leaks. A French-Japanese inventor and TED senior fellow, he is the creator of Protei, a revolutionary sailing technology -- featuring a front rudder, flexible hull and open-soure hardware -- that allows for efficient clean up of both oil and plastics from the sea. Currently based in London, Harada recently traveled to Japan and is designing Protei to measure radioactivity along the country's coast.
The general coordinator of the future International Ocean Station, Harada teaches at Goldsmiths University London. A former project leader at MIT, he graduated form the Royal College of Arts Design Interactions in London and worked at the Southampton University Hydrodynamics laboratory on wave energy. Harada has also studied animantion, and his films and installations have been seen at festivals and events across the world, from the United States to Japan.
Cesar Harada | Speaker | TED.com