19:47
TEDGlobal 2012

Rachel Botsman: The currency of the new economy is trust

Filmed:

There's been an explosion of collaborative consumption -- web-powered sharing of cars, apartments, skills. Rachel Botsman explores the currency that makes systems like Airbnb and Taskrabbit work: trust, influence, and what she calls "reputation capital."

- Trust researcher
Rachel Botsman is a recognized expert on how collaboration and trust enabled by digital technologies will change the way we live, work, bank and consume. Full bio

So if someone asked you
00:16
for the three words that would sum up
00:17
your reputation, what would you say?
00:20
How would people describe your judgment,
00:24
your knowledge, your behaviors, in different situations?
00:27
Today I'd like to explore with you
00:30
why the answer to this question
00:33
will become profoundly important
00:34
in an age where reputation will be your most valuable asset.
00:36
I'd like to start by introducing you to someone
00:41
whose life has been changed by a marketplace
00:44
fueled by reputation.
00:47
Sebastian Sandys has been a bed and breakfast host
00:49
on Airbnb since 2008.
00:52
I caught up with him recently, where, over the course
00:55
of several cups of tea, he told me how
00:58
hosting guests from all over the world
01:01
has enriched his life.
01:03
More than 50 people have come to stay in the 18th-century
01:05
watchhouse he lives in with his cat, Squeak.
01:08
Now, I mention Squeak because Sebastian's first guest
01:11
happened to see a rather large mouse run across the kitchen,
01:15
and she promised that she would refrain from leaving
01:19
a bad review on one condition: he got a cat.
01:22
And so Sebastian bought Squeak to protect his reputation.
01:25
Now, as many of you know, Airbnb is a peer-to-peer
01:29
marketplace that matches people who have space to rent
01:33
with people who are looking for a place to stay
01:37
in over 192 countries.
01:39
The places being rented out are things that you might
01:42
expect, like spare rooms and holiday homes,
01:45
but part of the magic is the unique places
01:48
that you can now access: treehouses, teepees,
01:50
airplane hangars, igloos.
01:54
If you don't like the hotel, there's a castle down the road
01:56
that you can rent for 5,000 dollars a night.
02:00
It's a fantastic example of how technology
02:02
is creating a market
02:06
for things that never had a marketplace before.
02:08
Now let me show you these heat maps of Paris
02:10
to see how insanely fast it's growing.
02:13
This image here is from 2008.
02:16
The pink dots represent host properties.
02:18
Even four years ago, letting strangers stay in your home
02:22
seemed like a crazy idea.
02:26
Now the same view in 2010.
02:29
And now, 2012.
02:31
There is an Airbnb host on almost every main street in Paris.
02:34
Now, what's happening here is people are realizing
02:39
the power of technology to unlock the idling capacity
02:43
and value of all kinds of assets,
02:48
from skills to spaces to material possessions,
02:51
in ways and on a scale never possible before.
02:54
It's an economy and culture called collaborative consumption,
02:58
and, through it, people like Sebastian
03:01
are becoming micro-entrepreneurs.
03:04
They're empowered to make money and save money
03:06
from their existing assets.
03:08
But the real magic and the secret source behind
03:11
collaborative consumption marketplaces like Airbnb
03:14
isn't the inventory or the money.
03:16
It's using the power of technology to build trust
03:19
between strangers.
03:23
This side of Airbnb really hit home to Sebastian last summer
03:24
during the London riots.
03:28
He woke up around 9, and he checked his email
03:29
and he saw a bunch of messages all asking him
03:32
if he was okay.
03:35
Former guests from around the world had seen that
03:36
the riots were happening just down the street, and wanted
03:38
to check if he needed anything.
03:41
Sebastian actually said to me, he said, "Thirteen former guests
03:43
contacted me before my own mother rang." (Laughter)
03:46
Now, this little anecdote gets to the heart of why
03:50
I'm really passionate about collaborative consumption,
03:55
and why, after I finished my book, I decided
03:57
I'm going to try and spread this into a global movement.
04:00
Because at its core, it's about empowerment.
04:04
It's about empowering people to make meaningful connections,
04:07
connections that are enabling us to rediscover
04:11
a humanness that we've lost somewhere along the way,
04:14
by engaging in marketplaces like Airbnb, like Kickstarter,
04:18
like Etsy, that are built on personal relationships
04:22
versus empty transactions.
04:25
Now the irony is that these ideas are actually taking us back
04:28
to old market principles and collaborative behaviors
04:32
that are hard-wired in all of us.
04:35
They're just being reinvented in ways that are relevant
04:37
for the Facebook age.
04:39
We're literally beginning to realize that we have wired
04:41
our world to share, swap, rent, barter or trade
04:45
just about anything. We're sharing our cars on WhipCar,
04:49
our bikes on Spinlister, our offices on Loosecubes,
04:53
our gardens on Landshare. We're lending and borrowing
04:56
money from strangers on Zopa and Lending Club.
04:59
We are trading lessons on everything from sushi-making
05:02
to coding on Skillshare,
05:04
and we're even sharing our pets on DogVacay.
05:06
Now welcome to the wonderful world of collaborative consumption
05:10
that's enabling us to match wants with haves
05:14
in more democratic ways.
05:17
Now, collaborative consumption is creating the start
05:19
of a transformation in the way we think about supply and demand,
05:23
but it's also a part of a massive value shift underway,
05:26
where instead of consuming to keep up with the Joneses,
05:30
people are consuming to get to know the Joneses.
05:33
But the key reason why it's taking off now so fast
05:37
is because every new advancement of technology
05:41
increases the efficiency and the social glue of trust
05:44
to make sharing easier and easier.
05:48
Now, I've looked at thousands of these marketplaces,
05:52
and trust and efficiency are always the critical ingredients.
05:55
Let me give you an example.
05:59
Meet 46-year-old Chris Mok, who has, I bet,
06:01
the best job title here of SuperRabbit.
06:06
Now, four years ago, Chris lost his job, unfortunately,
06:09
as an art buyer at Macy's, and like so many people,
06:14
he struggled to find a new one during the recession.
06:17
And then he happened to stumble across a post about
06:20
TaskRabbit.
06:23
Now, the story behind TaskRabbit starts like so many
06:25
great stories with a very cute dog by the name of Kobe.
06:28
Now what happened was, in February 2008,
06:32
Leah and her husband were waiting for a cab to take them
06:36
out for dinner, when Kobe came trotting up to them
06:38
and he was salivating with saliva.
06:42
They realized they'd run out of dog food.
06:44
Kevin had to cancel the cab and trudge out in the snow.
06:47
Now, later that evening, the two self-confessed tech geeks
06:50
starting talking about how cool it would be if some kind of
06:53
eBay for errands existed.
06:57
Six months later, Leah quit her job,
06:59
and TaskRabbit was born.
07:02
At the time, she didn't realize that she was actually hitting
07:04
on a bigger idea she later called service networking.
07:08
It's essentially about how we use our online relationships
07:13
to get things done in the real world.
07:16
Now the way TaskRabbit works is, people outsource
07:20
the tasks that they want doing, name the price
07:22
they're willing to pay, and then vetted Rabbits
07:25
bid to run the errand.
07:28
Yes, there's actually a four-stage, rigorous interview process
07:29
that's designed to find the people that would make
07:34
great personal assistants and weed out the dodgy Rabbits.
07:35
Now, there's over 4,000 Rabbits across the United States
07:39
and 5,000 more on the waiting list.
07:44
Now the tasks being posted are things that you might
07:47
expect, like help with household chores
07:50
or doing some supermarket runs.
07:53
I actually learned the other day that 12 and a half thousand
07:55
loads of laundry have been cleaned and folded
07:58
through TaskRabbit.
08:01
But I love that the number one task posted,
08:03
over a hundred times a day, is something that many of us
08:07
have felt the pain of doing:
08:10
yes, assembling Ikea furniture. (Laughter) (Applause)
08:13
It's brilliant. Now, we may laugh, but Chris here
08:19
is actually making up to 5,000 dollars a month
08:23
running errands around his life.
08:25
And 70 percent of this new labor force
08:28
were previously unemployed or underemployed.
08:32
I think TaskRabbit and other examples of collaborative consumption
08:35
are like lemonade stands on steroids. They're just brilliant.
08:39
Now, when you think about it, it's amazing, right,
08:42
that over the past 20 years, we've evolved
08:46
from trusting people online to share information
08:49
to trusting to handing over our credit card information,
08:53
and now we're entering the third trust wave:
08:56
connecting trustworthy strangers to create all kinds
08:59
of people-powered marketplaces.
09:03
I actually came across this fascinating study
09:05
by the Pew Center this week that revealed
09:07
that an active Facebook user is three times as likely
09:09
as a non-Internet user to believe that most people are trustworthy.
09:13
Virtual trust will transform the way we trust one another
09:18
face to face.
09:22
Now, with all of my optimism, and I am an optimist,
09:24
comes a healthy dose of caution, or rather, an urgent need
09:27
to address some pressing, complex questions.
09:31
How to ensure our digital identities reflect our
09:35
real world identities? Do we want them to be the same?
09:38
How do we mimic the way trust is built face-to-face online?
09:41
How do we stop people who've behaved badly
09:45
in one community doing so under a different guise?
09:47
In a similar way that companies often use some kind of
09:51
credit rating to decide whether to give you a mobile plan,
09:54
or the rate of a mortgage, marketplaces that depend
09:57
on transactions between relative strangers
10:00
need some kind of device to let you know that Sebastian
10:03
and Chris are good eggs,
10:06
and that device is reputation.
10:08
Reputation is the measurement of how much a community trusts you.
10:11
Let's just take a look at Chris.
10:16
You can see that over 200 people have given him
10:18
an average rating over 4.99 out of 5.
10:21
There are over 20 pages of reviews of his work
10:24
describing him as super-friendly and fast,
10:26
and he's reached level 25, the highest level,
10:29
making him a SuperRabbit.
10:32
Now — (Laughter) -- I love that word, SuperRabbit.
10:34
And interestingly, what Chris has noted is that as his reputation
10:37
has gone up, so has his chances of winning a bid
10:41
and how much he can charge.
10:44
In other words, for SuperRabbits, reputation
10:46
has a real world value.
10:49
Now, I know what you might be thinking.
10:51
Well, this isn't anything new. Just think of power sellers
10:53
on eBay or star ratings on Amazon.
10:55
The difference today is that, with every trade we make,
10:59
comment we leave, person we flag, badge we earn,
11:02
we leave a reputation trail
11:06
of how well we can and can't be trusted.
11:08
And it's not just the breadth but the volume
11:11
of reputation data out there that is staggering.
11:14
Just consider this: Five million nights have been booked
11:16
on Airbnb in the past six months alone.
11:20
30 million rides have been shared on Carpooling.com.
11:23
This year, two billion dollars worth of loans
11:27
will go through peer-to-peer lending platforms.
11:29
This adds up to millions of pieces of reputation data
11:32
on how well we behave or misbehave.
11:36
Now, capturing and correlating the trails of information
11:39
that we leave in different places is a massive challenge,
11:43
but one we're being asked to figure out.
11:46
What the likes of Sebastian are starting to rightfully ask
11:49
is, shouldn't they own their reputation data?
11:52
Shouldn't the reputation that he's personally invested
11:55
on building on Airbnb mean that it should travel with him
11:58
from one community to another?
12:01
What I mean by this is, say he started selling second-hand
12:03
books on Amazon. Why should he have to start from scratch?
12:06
It's a bit like when I moved from New York to Sydney.
12:10
It was ridiculous. I couldn't get a mobile phone plan
12:14
because my credit history didn't travel with me.
12:17
I was essentially a ghost in the system.
12:21
Now I'm not suggesting that the next stage
12:24
of the reputation economy is about
12:27
adding up multiple ratings into some kind of empty score.
12:28
People's lives are too complex, and who wants to do that?
12:33
I also want to be clear that this isn't about adding up
12:36
tweets and likes and friends in a clout-like fashion.
12:39
Those guys are measuring influence, not behaviors
12:42
that indicate our trustworthiness.
12:46
But the most important thing that we have to keep in mind
12:47
is that reputation is largely contextual.
12:51
Just because Sebastian is a wonderful host
12:55
does not mean that he can assemble Ikea furniture.
12:58
The big challenge is figuring out what data
13:02
makes sense to pull, because the future's
13:05
going to be driven by a smart aggregation of reputation,
13:08
not a single algorithm.
13:11
It's only a matter of time before we'll be able to perform
13:14
a Facebook- or Google-like search
13:18
and see a complete picture of someone's behaviors
13:20
in different contexts over time.
13:23
I envision a realtime stream of who has trusted you,
13:26
when, where and why, your reliability on TaskRabbit,
13:30
your cleanliness as a guest on Airbnb,
13:34
the knowledge that you display on Quora or [unclear],
13:36
they'll all live together in one place,
13:39
and this will live in some kind of reputation dashboard
13:42
that will paint a picture of your reputation capital.
13:45
Now this is a concept that I'm currently researching
13:50
and writing my next book on, and currently define
13:53
as the worth of your reputation, your intentions,
13:55
capabilities and values across communities and marketplaces.
13:59
This isn't some far-off frontier.
14:03
There are actually a wave of startups like Connect.Me
14:06
and Legit and TrustCloud that are figuring out how
14:09
you can aggregate, monitor and use your online reputation.
14:13
Now, I realize that this concept may sound a little
14:18
Big Brother to some of you, and yes, there are some
14:22
enormous transparency and privacy issues to solve,
14:25
but ultimately, if we can collect our personal reputation,
14:28
we can actually control it more, and extract
14:32
the immense value that will flow from it.
14:35
Also, more so than our credit history,
14:38
we can actually shape our reputation.
14:41
Just think of Sebastian
14:43
and how he bought the cat to influence his.
14:45
Now privacy issues aside, the other really interesting issue
14:48
I'm looking at is how do we empower digital ghosts,
14:52
people [who] for whatever reason, are not active online,
14:55
but are some of the most trustworthy people in the world?
14:58
How do we take their contributions to their jobs,
15:01
their communities and their families,
15:04
and convert that value into reputation capital?
15:06
Ultimately, when we get it right, reputation capital
15:10
could create a massive positive disruption
15:14
in who has power, trust and influence.
15:17
A three-digit score, your traditional credit history,
15:21
that only 30 percent of us actually know what it is,
15:24
will no longer be the determining factor
15:27
in how much things cost, what we can access,
15:30
and, in many instances, limit what we can do in the world.
15:33
Indeed, reputation is a currency that I believe will become
15:36
more powerful than our credit history in the 21st century.
15:41
Reputation will be the currency that says
15:46
that you can trust me.
15:49
Now the interesting thing is, reputation
15:51
is the socioeconomic lubricant
15:54
that makes collaborative consumption work and scale,
15:56
but the sources it will be generated from,
16:01
and its applications, are far bigger than this space alone.
16:03
Let me give you one example from the world of recruiting,
16:07
where reputation data will make the résumé seem
16:10
like an archaic relic of the past.
16:14
Four years ago, tech bloggers and entrepreneurs
16:18
Joel Spolsky and Jeff Atwood, decided to start something
16:22
called Stack Overflow.
16:27
Now, Stack Overflow is basically a platform where
16:30
experienced programmers can ask
16:33
other good programmers highly detailed technical questions
16:36
on things like tiny pixels and chrome extensions.
16:40
This site receives five and a half thousand questions a day,
16:44
and 80 percent of these receive accurate answers.
16:48
Now users earn reputation in a whole range of ways,
16:52
but it's basically by convincing their peers
16:55
they know what they're talking about.
16:58
Now a few months after this site launched, the founders
17:00
heard about something interesting,
17:03
and it actually didn't surprise them.
17:05
What they heard was that users were putting
17:07
their reputation scores on the top of their résumés,
17:10
and that recruiters were searching the platform
17:14
to find people with unique talents.
17:17
Now thousands of programmers today are finding
17:19
better jobs this way, because Stack Overflow
17:22
and the reputation dashboards provide a priceless window
17:25
into how someone really behaves,
17:28
and what their peers think of them.
17:31
But the bigger principle of what's happening behind Stack Overflow,
17:33
I think, is incredibly exciting.
17:36
People are starting to realize that the reputation
17:38
they generate in one place has value
17:42
beyond the environments from which it was built.
17:45
You know, it's very interesting.
17:48
When you talk to super-users, whether that's SuperRabbits
17:50
or super-people on Stack Overflow, or Uberhosts,
17:53
they all talk about how having a high reputation
17:57
unlocks a sense of their own power.
18:00
On Stack Overflow, it creates a level playing field,
18:04
enabling the people with the real talent to rise to the top.
18:07
On Airbnb, the people often become more important
18:10
than the spaces. On TaskRabbit,
18:13
it gives people control of their economic activity.
18:15
Now at the end of my tea with Sebastian, he told me how,
18:19
on a bad, rainy day, when he hasn't had a customer
18:22
in his bookstore, he thinks of all the people around
18:25
the world who've said something wonderful about him,
18:29
and what that says about him as a person.
18:32
He's turning 50 this year, and he's convinced
18:34
that the rich tapestry of reputation he's built on Airbnb
18:38
will lead him to doing something interesting
18:41
with the rest of his life.
18:44
You know, there are only a few windows in history
18:47
where the opportunity exists to reinvent
18:51
part of how our socioeconomic system works.
18:54
We're living through one of those moments.
18:57
I believe that we are at the start of a collaborative revolution
19:00
that will be as significant as the Industrial Revolution.
19:03
In the 20th century, the invention of traditional credit
19:07
transformed our consumer system, and in many ways
19:11
controlled who had access to what.
19:14
In the 21st century, new trust networks,
19:17
and the reputation capital they generate, will reinvent
19:20
the way we think about wealth, markets, power
19:23
and personal identity, in ways we can't yet even imagine.
19:27
Thank you very much. (Applause)
19:32
(Applause)
19:35
Translated by Joseph Geni
Reviewed by Morton Bast

▲Back to top

About the Speaker:

Rachel Botsman - Trust researcher
Rachel Botsman is a recognized expert on how collaboration and trust enabled by digital technologies will change the way we live, work, bank and consume.

Why you should listen

Rachel Botsman is the co-author, with Roo Rogers, of the book What's Mine Is Yours (2010). In it, they developed the concept of "collaborative consumption", which was recognized by Time magazine as one of the "10 ideas that will change the world" and by Thinkers 50 as a Breakthrough Idea. Her newest work focuses on trust, which is the topic of her next book. In 2015, she designed the world’s first MBA course on the collaborative economy, which she teaches at Oxford University’s Saïd School of Business.

Named a "Young Global Leader" by the World Economic Forum, Botsman examines the growth and challenges of startups such as Airbnb, Taskrabbit and Uber, with a focus on technology's impact on trust and relationships, providing context for how and why the world is changing and the broader implications of this new economy.  

More profile about the speaker
Rachel Botsman | Speaker | TED.com