TEDSalon London Fall 2012
Molly Crockett: Beware neuro-bunk
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
1,295,218 views
Brains are ubiquitous in modern marketing: Headlines proclaim cheese sandwiches help with decision-making, while a “neuro” drink claims to reduce stress. There’s just one problem, says neuroscientist Molly Crockett: The benefits of these "neuro-enhancements" are not proven scientifically. In this to-the-point talk, Crockett explains the limits of interpreting neuroscientific data, and why we should all be aware of them.
Molly Crockett - Neuroscientist
Neuroscientist Molly Crockett studies altruism, morality and value-based decision-making in humans. Full bio
Neuroscientist Molly Crockett studies altruism, morality and value-based decision-making in humans. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
I'm a neuroscientist, and I study decision-making.
0
833
3877
00:20
I do experiments to test how different chemicals
1
4710
2307
00:22
in the brain influence the choices we make.
2
7017
3600
00:26
I'm here to tell you the secret to successful decision-making:
3
10617
6748
00:33
a cheese sandwich.
4
17365
2238
00:35
That's right. According to scientists, a cheese sandwich
5
19603
3660
00:39
is the solution to all your tough decisions.
6
23263
3622
00:42
How do I know? I'm the scientist who did the study.
7
26885
5057
00:47
A few years ago, my colleagues and I were interested
8
31942
2300
00:50
in how a brain chemical called serotonin
9
34242
2293
00:52
would influence people's decisions in social situations.
10
36535
3270
00:55
Specifically, we wanted to know how serotonin would affect
11
39805
3095
00:58
the way people react when they're treated unfairly.
12
42900
3815
01:02
So we did an experiment.
13
46715
1538
01:04
We manipulated people's serotonin levels by giving them
14
48253
3146
01:07
this really disgusting-tasting artificial lemon-flavored drink
15
51399
4623
01:11
that works by taking away the raw ingredient for serotonin
16
56022
3632
01:15
in the brain.
17
59654
1178
01:16
This is the amino acid tryptophan.
18
60832
2977
01:19
So what we found was, when tryptophan was low,
19
63809
2361
01:22
people were more likely to take revenge
20
66170
2452
01:24
when they're treated unfairly.
21
68622
3548
01:28
That's the study we did, and here are some of the headlines
22
72170
3823
01:31
that came out afterwards.
23
75993
2729
01:34
("A cheese sandwich is all you need for strong decision-making")
24
78722
2495
01:37
("What a friend we have in cheeses")
25
81217
2095
01:39
("Eating Cheese and Meat May Boost Self-Control") At this point, you might be wondering, did I miss something?
26
83312
3200
01:42
("Official! Chocolate stops you being grumpy") Cheese? Chocolate? Where did that come from?
27
86512
5395
01:47
And I thought the same thing myself when these came out,
28
91907
2133
01:49
because our study had nothing to do with cheese or chocolate.
29
94040
4245
01:54
We gave people this horrible-tasting drink
30
98285
2329
01:56
that affected their tryptophan levels.
31
100614
3202
01:59
But it turns out that tryptophan also happens to be found
32
103816
3681
02:03
in cheese and chocolate.
33
107497
2801
02:06
And of course when science says cheese and chocolate
34
110298
2310
02:08
help you make better decisions, well, that's sure to grab people's attention.
35
112608
4081
02:12
So there you have it:
36
116689
1967
02:14
the evolution of a headline.
37
118656
3507
02:18
When this happened, a part of me thought, well,
38
122163
2342
02:20
what's the big deal?
39
124505
2004
02:22
So the media oversimplified a few things, but in the end,
40
126509
3879
02:26
it's just a news story.
41
130388
2076
02:28
And I think a lot of scientists have this attitude.
42
132464
3353
02:31
But the problem is that this kind of thing happens all the time,
43
135817
3897
02:35
and it affects not just the stories you read in the news
44
139714
3127
02:38
but also the products you see on the shelves.
45
142841
2779
02:41
When the headlines rolled, what happened was,
46
145620
2667
02:44
the marketers came calling.
47
148287
2826
02:47
Would I be willing to provide a scientific endorsement
48
151113
3219
02:50
of a mood-boosting bottled water?
49
154332
3261
02:53
Or would I go on television to demonstrate,
50
157593
2144
02:55
in front of a live audience,
51
159737
1025
02:56
that comfort foods really do make you feel better?
52
160762
3599
03:00
I think these folks meant well, but had I taken them up on their offers,
53
164361
3961
03:04
I would have been going beyond the science,
54
168322
2374
03:06
and good scientists are careful not to do this.
55
170696
3257
03:09
But nevertheless, neuroscience is turning up more and more in marketing.
56
173953
4368
03:14
Here's one example: Neuro drinks,
57
178321
2560
03:16
a line of products, including Nuero Bliss here,
58
180881
3241
03:20
which according to its label helps reduce stress,
59
184122
2901
03:22
enhances mood, provides focused concentration,
60
187023
3426
03:26
and promotes a positive outlook.
61
190449
2688
03:29
I have to say, this sounds awesome. (Laughter)
62
193137
4625
03:33
I could totally have used this 10 minutes ago.
63
197762
3876
03:37
So when this came up in my local shop, naturally I was
64
201638
3430
03:40
curious about some of the research backing these claims.
65
205068
3549
03:44
So I went to the company's website looking to find
66
208617
2926
03:47
some controlled trials of their products.
67
211543
3426
03:50
But I didn't find any.
68
214969
1677
03:52
Trial or no trial, these claims are front and center
69
216646
3738
03:56
on their label right next to a picture of a brain.
70
220384
3962
04:00
And it turns out that pictures of brains have special properties.
71
224346
5703
04:05
A couple of researchers asked a few hundred people
72
230049
2462
04:08
to read a scientific article.
73
232511
2691
04:11
For half the people, the article included a brain image,
74
235202
3327
04:14
and for the other half, it was the same article
75
238529
1863
04:16
but it didn't have a brain image.
76
240392
2704
04:18
At the end — you see where this is going —
77
243096
1632
04:20
people were asked whether they agreed
78
244728
2110
04:22
with the conclusions of the article.
79
246838
3322
04:26
So this is how much people agree with the conclusions
80
250160
2273
04:28
with no image.
81
252433
1913
04:30
And this is how much they agree with the same article
82
254346
3647
04:33
that did include a brain image.
83
257993
2767
04:36
So the take-home message here is,
84
260760
1949
04:38
do you want to sell it? Put a brain on it.
85
262709
4907
04:43
Now let me pause here and take a moment to say that
86
267616
2113
04:45
neuroscience has advanced a lot in the last few decades,
87
269729
3698
04:49
and we're constantly discovering amazing things
88
273427
2453
04:51
about the brain.
89
275880
1273
04:53
Like, just a couple of weeks ago, neuroscientists at MIT
90
277153
3144
04:56
figured out how to break habits in rats
91
280297
2800
04:58
just by controlling neural activity in a specific part of their brain.
92
283097
3993
05:02
Really cool stuff.
93
287090
1590
05:04
But the promise of neuroscience has led to some really
94
288680
3293
05:07
high expectations and some overblown, unproven claims.
95
291973
5236
05:13
So what I'm going to do is show you how to spot
96
297209
3039
05:16
a couple of classic moves, dead giveaways, really,
97
300248
3546
05:19
for what's variously been called neuro-bunk,
98
303794
2796
05:22
neuro-bollocks, or, my personal favorite, neuro-flapdoodle.
99
306590
5692
05:28
So the first unproven claim is that you can use brain scans
100
312282
4338
05:32
to read people's thoughts and emotions.
101
316620
3912
05:36
Here's a study published by a team of researchers
102
320532
3047
05:39
as an op-ed in The New York Times.
103
323579
2833
05:42
The headline? "You Love Your iPhone. Literally."
104
326412
4245
05:46
It quickly became the most emailed article on the site.
105
330657
4450
05:51
So how'd they figure this out?
106
335107
2169
05:53
They put 16 people inside a brain scanner
107
337276
3028
05:56
and showed them videos of ringing iPhones.
108
340304
3282
05:59
The brain scans showed activation in a part of the brain
109
343586
3462
06:02
called the insula, a region they say
110
347048
2652
06:05
is linked to feelings of love and compassion.
111
349700
3784
06:09
So they concluded that because they saw activation in the insula,
112
353484
3660
06:13
this meant the subjects loved their iPhones.
113
357144
4287
06:17
Now there's just one problem with this line of reasoning,
114
361431
2144
06:19
and that's that the insula does a lot.
115
363575
3516
06:22
Sure, it is involved in positive emotions
116
367091
2305
06:25
like love and compassion,
117
369396
2342
06:27
but it's also involved in tons of other processes,
118
371738
2673
06:30
like memory, language, attention,
119
374411
3073
06:33
even anger, disgust and pain.
120
377484
4036
06:37
So based on the same logic, I could equally conclude
121
381520
4463
06:41
you hate your iPhone.
122
385983
2453
06:44
The point here is, when you see activation in the insula,
123
388436
2844
06:47
you can't just pick and choose your favorite explanation
124
391280
3026
06:50
from off this list, and it's a really long list.
125
394306
4666
06:54
My colleagues Tal Yarkoni and Russ Poldrack
126
398972
2334
06:57
have shown that the insula pops up in almost a third
127
401306
3122
07:00
of all brain imaging studies that have ever been published.
128
404428
4736
07:05
So chances are really, really good
129
409164
1514
07:06
that your insula is going off right now,
130
410678
3126
07:09
but I won't kid myself
131
413804
1622
07:11
to think this means you love me.
132
415426
3677
07:15
So speaking of love and the brain,
133
419103
2907
07:17
there's a researcher, known to some as Dr. Love,
134
422010
3865
07:21
who claims that scientists have found the glue
135
425875
3485
07:25
that holds society together,
136
429360
2647
07:27
the source of love and prosperity.
137
432007
3776
07:31
This time it's not a cheese sandwich.
138
435783
2189
07:33
No, it's a hormone called oxytocin.
139
437972
3857
07:37
You've probably heard of it.
140
441829
1867
07:39
So, Dr. Love bases his argument on studies showing
141
443696
2892
07:42
that when you boost people's oxytocin,
142
446588
2945
07:45
this increases their trust, empathy and cooperation.
143
449533
4173
07:49
So he's calling oxytocin "the moral molecule."
144
453706
4080
07:53
Now these studies are scientifically valid,
145
457786
2842
07:56
and they've been replicated, but they're not the whole story.
146
460628
4136
08:00
Other studies have shown that boosting oxytocin
147
464764
2713
08:03
increases envy. It increases gloating.
148
467477
4743
08:08
Oxytocin can bias people to favor their own group
149
472220
3316
08:11
at the expense of other groups.
150
475536
3092
08:14
And in some cases, oxytocin can even decrease cooperation.
151
478628
4252
08:18
So based on these studies, I could say oxytocin
152
482880
3820
08:22
is an immoral molecule, and call myself Dr. Strangelove.
153
486700
4751
08:27
(Laughter)
154
491451
3360
08:30
So we've seen neuro-flapdoodle all over the headlines.
155
494811
4110
08:34
We see it in supermarkets, on book covers.
156
498921
2778
08:37
What about the clinic?
157
501699
2671
08:40
SPECT imaging is a brain-scanning technology
158
504370
3415
08:43
that uses a radioactive tracer
159
507785
2069
08:45
to track blood flow in the brain.
160
509854
3040
08:48
For the bargain price of a few thousand dollars,
161
512894
3084
08:51
there are clinics in the U.S. that will give you
162
515978
4118
08:55
one of these SPECT scans and use the image
163
520096
3453
08:59
to help diagnose your problems.
164
523549
2637
09:02
These scans, the clinics say, can help
165
526186
2529
09:04
prevent Alzheimer's disease,
166
528715
2902
09:07
solve weight and addiction issues,
167
531617
2464
09:09
overcome marital conflicts,
168
534081
2672
09:12
and treat, of course, a variety of mental illnesses
169
536753
3150
09:15
ranging from depression to anxiety to ADHD.
170
539903
3579
09:19
This sounds great. A lot of people agree.
171
543482
2570
09:21
Some of these clinics are pulling in tens of millions
172
546052
2166
09:24
of dollars a year in business.
173
548218
3304
09:27
There's just one problem.
174
551522
2084
09:29
The broad consensus in neuroscience
175
553606
2677
09:32
is that we can't yet diagnose mental illness
176
556283
3185
09:35
from a single brain scan.
177
559468
2783
09:38
But these clinics have treated
178
562251
2231
09:40
tens of thousands of patients to date,
179
564482
2440
09:42
many of them children,
180
566922
1762
09:44
and SPECT imaging involves a radioactive injection,
181
568684
3478
09:48
so exposing people to radiation, potentially harmful.
182
572162
5997
09:54
I am more excited than most people, as a neuroscientist,
183
578159
3114
09:57
about the potential for neuroscience to treat mental illness
184
581273
4281
10:01
and even maybe to make us better and smarter.
185
585554
4724
10:06
And if one day we can say that cheese and chocolate
186
590278
2700
10:08
help us make better decisions, count me in.
187
592978
4304
10:13
But we're not there yet.
188
597282
2576
10:15
We haven't found a "buy" button inside the brain,
189
599858
3735
10:19
we can't tell whether someone is lying or in love
190
603593
3698
10:23
just by looking at their brain scans,
191
607291
3383
10:26
and we can't turn sinners into saints with hormones.
192
610674
4264
10:30
Maybe someday we will, but until then,
193
614938
2204
10:33
we have to be careful that we don't let overblown claims
194
617142
2843
10:35
detract resources and attention away from the real science
195
619985
3386
10:39
that's playing a much longer game.
196
623371
3759
10:43
So here's where you come in.
197
627130
2438
10:45
If someone tries to sell you something with a brain on it,
198
629568
3171
10:48
don't just take them at their word.
199
632739
2879
10:51
Ask the tough questions. Ask to see the evidence.
200
635618
3246
10:54
Ask for the part of the story that's not being told.
201
638864
3898
10:58
The answers shouldn't be simple, because the brain isn't simple.
202
642762
5088
11:03
But that's not stopping us from trying to figure it out anyway.
203
647850
4495
11:08
Thank you. (Applause)
204
652345
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Molly Crockett - NeuroscientistNeuroscientist Molly Crockett studies altruism, morality and value-based decision-making in humans.
Why you should listen
Can what you eat influence your sense of justice? Will a simple drug make you more likely to help a stranger on the street? Neuroscientist Molly Crockett asks and answers these and many other fascinating questions about the influence of neurotransmitters, like dopamine and serotonin, on altruism and decision-making. Neuroscience may hold the answer, says Crockett, but there are still limits to our ability to draw conclusions from neural research. Crockett received her PhD from the University of Cambridge in 2011, and she is currently working with support from the four-year Sir Henry Wellcome Postdoctoral Fellowship studying human altruism in labratories worldwide.
Molly Crockett | Speaker | TED.com