12:35
TEDGlobal 2012

Laura Snyder: The Philosophical Breakfast Club

Filmed:

In 1812, four men at Cambridge University met for breakfast. What began as an impassioned meal grew into a new scientific revolution, in which these men -- who called themselves “natural philosophers” until they later coined “scientist” -- introduced four major principles into scientific inquiry. Historian and philosopher Laura Snyder tells their intriguing story.

- Science historian
Laura Snyder weaves tales of Victorian-era scientists that have been described as “fit for Masterpiece Theater.” Full bio

I'd like you to come back with me for a moment
00:12
to the 19th century,
00:15
specifically to June 24, 1833.
00:17
The British Association for the Advancement of Science
00:21
is holding its third meeting at the University of Cambridge.
00:24
It's the first night of the meeting,
00:28
and a confrontation is about to take place
00:30
that will change science forever.
00:33
An elderly, white-haired man stands up.
00:37
The members of the Association are shocked to realize
00:40
that it's the poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge,
00:43
who hadn't even left his house in years until that day.
00:46
They're even more shocked by what he says.
00:51
"You must stop calling yourselves natural philosophers."
00:54
Coleridge felt that true philosophers like himself
01:00
pondered the cosmos from their armchairs.
01:03
They were not mucking around in the fossil pits
01:06
or conducting messy experiments with electrical piles
01:08
like the members of the British Association.
01:12
The crowd grew angry and began to complain loudly.
01:15
A young Cambridge scholar named William Whewell stood up
01:19
and quieted the audience.
01:23
He politely agreed that an appropriate name
01:25
for the members of the association did not exist.
01:28
"If 'philosophers' is taken to be too wide and lofty a term,"
01:31
he said, "then, by analogy with 'artist,'
01:37
we may form 'scientist.'"
01:42
This was the first time the word scientist
01:46
was uttered in public,
01:48
only 179 years ago.
01:50
I first found out about this confrontation when I was in graduate school,
01:54
and it kind of blew me away.
01:57
I mean, how could the word scientist
01:59
not have existed until 1833?
02:01
What were scientists called before?
02:05
What had changed to make a new name necessary
02:07
precisely at that moment?
02:10
Prior to this meeting, those who studied the natural world
02:13
were talented amateurs.
02:16
Think of the country clergyman or squire
02:19
collecting his beetles or fossils,
02:21
like Charles Darwin, for example,
02:23
or, the hired help of a nobleman, like Joseph Priestley,
02:26
who was the literary companion
02:30
to the Marquis of Lansdowne
02:32
when he discovered oxygen.
02:34
After this, they were scientists,
02:37
professionals with a particular scientific method,
02:40
goals, societies and funding.
02:44
Much of this revolution can be traced to four men
02:48
who met at Cambridge University in 1812:
02:51
Charles Babbage, John Herschel, Richard Jones and William Whewell.
02:54
These were brilliant, driven men
02:59
who accomplished amazing things.
03:01
Charles Babbage, I think known to most TEDsters,
03:04
invented the first mechanical calculator
03:07
and the first prototype of a modern computer.
03:10
John Herschel mapped the stars of the southern hemisphere,
03:14
and, in his spare time, co-invented photography.
03:18
I'm sure we could all be that productive
03:23
without Facebook or Twitter to take up our time.
03:25
Richard Jones became an important economist
03:28
who later influenced Karl Marx.
03:31
And Whewell not only coined the term scientist,
03:33
as well as the words anode, cathode and ion,
03:37
but spearheaded international big science
03:41
with his global research on the tides.
03:44
In the Cambridge winter of 1812 and 1813,
03:47
the four met for what they called philosophical breakfasts.
03:51
They talked about science
03:55
and the need for a new scientific revolution.
03:56
They felt science had stagnated
03:59
since the days of the scientific revolution that had happened
04:01
in the 17th century.
04:05
It was time for a new revolution,
04:07
which they pledged to bring about,
04:09
and what's so amazing about these guys is,
04:11
not only did they have these
04:14
grandiose undergraduate dreams,
04:16
but they actually carried them out,
04:18
even beyond their wildest dreams.
04:20
And I'm going to tell you today
04:23
about four major changes to science these men made.
04:24
About 200 years before,
04:29
Francis Bacon and then, later, Isaac Newton,
04:32
had proposed an inductive scientific method.
04:35
Now that's a method that starts from
04:38
observations and experiments
04:41
and moves to generalizations about nature called natural laws,
04:43
which are always subject to revision or rejection
04:47
should new evidence arise.
04:49
However, in 1809, David Ricardo muddied the waters
04:52
by arguing that the science of economics
04:57
should use a different, deductive method.
05:00
The problem was that an influential group at Oxford
05:03
began arguing that because it worked so well in economics,
05:07
this deductive method ought to be applied
05:11
to the natural sciences too.
05:14
The members of the philosophical breakfast club disagreed.
05:16
They wrote books and articles promoting inductive method
05:20
in all the sciences
05:23
that were widely read by natural philosophers,
05:25
university students and members of the public.
05:28
Reading one of Herschel's books
05:31
was such a watershed moment for Charles Darwin
05:33
that he would later say, "Scarcely anything in my life
05:36
made so deep an impression on me.
05:40
It made me wish to add my might
05:42
to the accumulated store of natural knowledge."
05:45
It also shaped Darwin's scientific method,
05:48
as well as that used by his peers.
05:51
[Science for the public good]
05:55
Previously, it was believed that scientific knowledge
05:57
ought to be used for the good of the king or queen,
06:00
or for one's own personal gain.
06:02
For example, ship captains needed to know
06:05
information about the tides in order to safely dock at ports.
06:08
Harbormasters would gather this knowledge
06:12
and sell it to the ship captains.
06:14
The philosophical breakfast club changed that,
06:17
working together.
06:20
Whewell's worldwide study of the tides
06:21
resulted in public tide tables and tidal maps
06:23
that freely provided the harbormasters' knowledge
06:26
to all ship captains.
06:29
Herschel helped by making tidal observations
06:32
off the coast of South Africa,
06:34
and, as he complained to Whewell,
06:36
he was knocked off the docks during a violent high tide for his trouble.
06:39
The four men really helped each other in every way.
06:44
They also relentlessly lobbied the British government
06:47
for the money to build Babbage's engines
06:50
because they believed these engines
06:52
would have a huge practical impact on society.
06:54
In the days before pocket calculators,
06:58
the numbers that most professionals needed --
07:01
bankers, insurance agents, ship captains, engineers —
07:04
were to be found in lookup books like this,
07:08
filled with tables of figures.
07:11
These tables were calculated
07:13
using a fixed procedure over and over
07:16
by part-time workers known as -- and this is amazing -- computers,
07:19
but these calculations were really difficult.
07:23
I mean, this nautical almanac
07:26
published the lunar differences for every month of the year.
07:28
Each month required 1,365 calculations,
07:32
so these tables were filled with mistakes.
07:37
Babbage's difference engine was the first mechanical calculator
07:40
devised to accurately compute any of these tables.
07:44
Two models of his engine were built in the last 20 years
07:48
by a team from the Science Museum of London
07:52
using his own plans.
07:54
This is the one now at the Computer History Museum in California,
07:56
and it calculates accurately. It actually works.
08:00
Later, Babbage's analytical engine
08:04
was the first mechanical computer in the modern sense.
08:07
It had a separate memory and central processor.
08:11
It was capable of iteration, conditional branching
08:14
and parallel processing,
08:17
and it was programmable using punched cards,
08:19
an idea Babbage took from Jacquard's loom.
08:22
Tragically, Babbage's engines never were built in his day
08:25
because most people thought that
08:29
non-human computers would have no usefulness
08:32
for the public.
08:35
[New scientific institutions]
08:36
Founded in Bacon's time, the Royal Society of London
08:38
was the foremost scientific society in England
08:42
and even in the rest of the world.
08:45
By the 19th century, it had become
08:47
a kind of gentleman's club
08:49
populated mainly by antiquarians, literary men and the nobility.
08:51
The members of the philosophical breakfast club
08:56
helped form a number of new scientific societies,
08:58
including the British Association.
09:01
These new societies required
09:04
that members be active researchers publishing their results.
09:06
They reinstated the tradition of the Q&A
09:10
after scientific papers were read,
09:12
which had been discontinued by the Royal Society
09:15
as being ungentlemanly.
09:17
And for the first time, they gave women a foot in the door of science.
09:20
Members were encouraged to bring their wives,
09:25
daughters and sisters to the meetings of the British Association,
09:27
and while the women were expected to attend
09:31
only the public lectures and the social events like this one,
09:34
they began to infiltrate the scientific sessions as well.
09:38
The British Association would later be the first
09:42
of the major national science organizations in the world
09:45
to admit women as full members.
09:49
[External funding for science]
09:51
Up to the 19th century,
09:53
natural philosophers were expected to pay
09:54
for their own equipment and supplies.
09:57
Occasionally, there were prizes,
09:59
such as that given to John Harrison in the 18th century,
10:01
for solving the so-called longitude problem,
10:05
but prizes were only given after the fact,
10:08
when they were given at all.
10:11
On the advice of the philosophical breakfast club,
10:12
the British Association began to use the extra money
10:15
generated by its meetings to give grants
10:19
for research in astronomy, the tides, fossil fish,
10:21
shipbuilding, and many other areas.
10:24
These grants not only allowed
10:27
less wealthy men to conduct research,
10:29
but they also encouraged thinking outside the box,
10:31
rather than just trying to solve one pre-set question.
10:34
Eventually, the Royal Society
10:38
and the scientific societies of other countries followed suit,
10:41
and this has become -- fortunately it's become --
10:44
a major part of the scientific landscape today.
10:47
So the philosophical breakfast club
10:52
helped invent the modern scientist.
10:55
That's the heroic part of their story.
10:58
There's a flip side as well.
11:01
They did not foresee at least one consequence
11:04
of their revolution.
11:07
They would have been deeply dismayed
11:10
by today's disjunction between science and the rest of culture.
11:12
It's shocking to realize
11:17
that only 28 percent of American adults
11:19
have even a very basic level of science literacy,
11:23
and this was tested by asking simple questions like,
11:26
"Did humans and dinosaurs inhabit the Earth at the same time?"
11:29
and "What proportion of the Earth is covered in water?"
11:33
Once scientists became members of a professional group,
11:38
they were slowly walled off from the rest of us.
11:42
This is the unintended consequence of the revolution
11:45
that started with our four friends.
11:49
Charles Darwin said,
11:52
"I sometimes think that general and popular treatises
11:54
are almost as important for the progress of science
11:58
as original work."
12:01
In fact, "Origin of Species" was written
12:02
for a general and popular audience,
12:05
and was widely read when it first appeared.
12:07
Darwin knew what we seem to have forgotten,
12:11
that science is not only for scientists.
12:15
Thank you.
12:20
(Applause)
12:21
Translated by Joseph Geni
Reviewed by Morton Bast

▲Back to top

About the Speaker:

Laura Snyder - Science historian
Laura Snyder weaves tales of Victorian-era scientists that have been described as “fit for Masterpiece Theater.”

Why you should listen

A work of history should be more than a collection of happenings, at least from Laura Snyder’s perspective. The Fulbright Scholar, historian of science and professor of philosophy at St. John's University believes histories should aim not only to tell a story, but also to transport a reader through time.

Snyder’s work presents three-dimensional characters that readers connect with. Her most recent book, The Philosophical Breakfast Club, traces the friendship of four 19th-century scientists who met at Cambridge: Charles Babbage (mathematics and computing), William Whewell (math economics), John Herschel (astronomy and photography) and Richard Jones (economy). Inspired by Francis Bacon's ideas, they coined the word “scientist” and were central in transforming science from the province of the amateur (practitioners were until then called "natural philosophers") to a professional system.

More profile about the speaker
Laura Snyder | Speaker | TED.com