07:54
TEDCity2.0

Robin Nagle: What I discovered in New York City trash

Filmed:

New York City residents produce 11,000 tons of garbage every day. Every day! This astonishing statistic is just one of the reasons Robin Nagle started a research project with the city's Department of Sanitation. She walked the routes, operated mechanical brooms, even drove a garbage truck herself--all so she could answer a simple-sounding but complicated question: who cleans up after us?

- Trash anthropologist
Robin Nagle is an anthropologist with a very particular focus... garbage. Full bio

I was about 10 years old
00:12
on a camping trip with my dad
00:14
in the Adirondack Mountains, a wilderness area
00:16
in the northern part of New York State.
00:19
It was a beautiful day.
00:22
The forest was sparkling.
00:23
The sun made the leaves glow like stained glass,
00:25
and if it weren't for the path we were following,
00:28
we could almost pretend we were
00:32
the first human beings to ever walk that land.
00:33
We got to our campsite.
00:37
It was a lean-to on a bluff
00:38
looking over a crystal, beautiful lake,
00:40
when I discovered a horror.
00:43
Behind the lean-to was a dump,
00:46
maybe 40 feet square
00:49
with rotting apple cores
00:50
and balled-up aluminum foil,
00:53
and a dead sneaker.
00:54
And I was astonished,
00:56
I was very angry, and I was deeply confused.
00:59
The campers who were too lazy
01:02
to take out what they had brought in,
01:04
who did they think would clean up after them?
01:06
That question stayed with me,
01:09
and it simplified a little.
01:11
Who cleans up after us?
01:13
However you configure
01:16
or wherever you place the us,
01:17
who cleans up after us in Istanbul?
01:19
Who cleans up after us in Rio
01:21
or in Paris or in London?
01:24
Here in New York,
01:26
the Department of Sanitation cleans up after us,
01:28
to the tune of 11,000 tons of garbage
01:30
and 2,000 tons of recyclables every day.
01:33
I wanted to get to know them as individuals.
01:37
I wanted to understand who takes the job.
01:40
What's it like to wear the uniform
01:43
and bear that burden?
01:45
So I started a research project with them.
01:47
I rode in the trucks and walked the routes
01:50
and interviewed people in offices and facilities
01:52
all over the city,
01:55
and I learned a lot,
01:56
but I was still an outsider.
01:58
I needed to go deeper.
02:00
So I took the job as a sanitation worker.
02:02
I didn't just ride in the trucks now. I drove the trucks.
02:05
And I operated the mechanical brooms and I plowed the snow.
02:08
It was a remarkable privilege
02:11
and an amazing education.
02:13
Everyone asks about the smell.
02:16
It's there, but it's not as prevalent as you think,
02:18
and on days when it is really bad,
02:21
you get used to it rather quickly.
02:22
The weight takes a long time to get used to.
02:25
I knew people who were several years on the job
02:28
whose bodies were still adjusting to the burden
02:30
of bearing on your body
02:33
tons of trash every week.
02:35
Then there's the danger.
02:38
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics,
02:40
sanitation work is one of the 10 most dangerous
02:43
occupations in the country,
02:45
and I learned why.
02:47
You're in and out of traffic all day,
02:49
and it's zooming around you.
02:50
It just wants to get past you, so it's often
02:51
the motorist is not paying attention.
02:53
That's really bad for the worker.
02:55
And then the garbage itself is full of hazards
02:57
that often fly back out of the truck
02:59
and do terrible harm.
03:01
I also learned about the relentlessness of trash.
03:03
When you step off the curb
03:06
and you see a city from behind a truck,
03:07
you come to understand that trash
03:10
is like a force of nature unto itself.
03:12
It never stops coming.
03:14
It's also like a form of respiration or circulation.
03:17
It must always be in motion.
03:20
And then there's the stigma.
03:23
You put on the uniform, and you become invisible
03:25
until someone is upset with you for whatever reason
03:28
like you've blocked traffic with your truck,
03:31
or you're taking a break too close to their home,
03:33
or you're drinking coffee in their diner,
03:36
and they will come and scorn you,
03:39
and tell you that they don't want you anywhere near them.
03:41
I find the stigma especially ironic,
03:44
because I strongly believe that sanitation workers
03:47
are the most important labor force
03:50
on the streets of the city, for three reasons.
03:52
They are the first guardians of public health.
03:55
If they're not taking away trash
03:58
efficiently and effectively every day,
04:00
it starts to spill out of its containments,
04:02
and the dangers inherent to it threaten us
04:05
in very real ways.
04:09
Diseases we've had in check for decades and centuries
04:10
burst forth again and start to harm us.
04:13
The economy needs them.
04:16
If we can't throw out the old stuff,
04:17
we have no room for the new stuff,
04:20
so then the engines of the economy
04:22
start to sputter when consumption is compromised.
04:24
I'm not advocating capitalism, I'm just pointing out their relationship.
04:27
And then there's what I call
04:31
our average, necessary quotidian velocity.
04:33
By that I simply mean
04:37
how fast we're used to moving
04:39
in the contemporary day and age.
04:41
We usually don't care for, repair, clean, carry around
04:43
our coffee cup, our shopping bag,
04:48
our bottle of water.
04:51
We use them, we throw them out, we forget about them,
04:52
because we know there's a workforce
04:55
on the other side that's going to take it all away.
04:57
So I want to suggest today a couple of ways
05:00
to think about sanitation that will perhaps help
05:02
ameliorate the stigma
05:07
and bring them into this conversation
05:09
of how to craft a city that is sustainable and humane.
05:12
Their work, I think, is kind of liturgical.
05:17
They're on the streets every day, rhythmically.
05:21
They wear a uniform in many cities.
05:24
You know when to expect them.
05:26
And their work lets us do our work.
05:28
They are almost a form of reassurance.
05:32
The flow that they maintain
05:34
keeps us safe from ourselves,
05:36
from our own dross, our cast-offs,
05:38
and that flow must be maintained always
05:41
no matter what.
05:44
On the day after September 11 in 2001,
05:46
I heard the growl of a sanitation truck on the street,
05:49
and I grabbed my infant son and I ran downstairs
05:53
and there was a man doing his paper recycling route
05:55
like he did every Wednesday.
05:58
And I tried to thank him for doing his work
06:00
on that day of all days,
06:02
but I started to cry.
06:05
And he looked at me,
06:07
and he just nodded, and he said,
06:09
"We're going to be okay.
06:12
We're going to be okay."
06:15
It was a little while later that I started
06:18
my research with sanitation,
06:19
and I met that man again.
06:20
His name is Paulie, and we worked together many times,
06:22
and we became good friends.
06:25
I want to believe that Paulie was right.
06:27
We are going to be okay.
06:29
But in our effort to reconfigure
06:32
how we as a species exist on this planet,
06:34
we must include and take account of
06:37
all the costs, including the very real human cost
06:40
of the labor.
06:44
And we also would be well informed
06:45
to reach out to the people who do that work
06:48
and get their expertise
06:50
on how do we think about,
06:52
how do we create systems around sustainability
06:54
that perhaps take us from curbside recycling,
06:57
which is a remarkable success across 40 years,
07:01
across the United States and countries around the world,
07:03
and lift us up to a broader horizon
07:06
where we're looking at other forms of waste
07:09
that could be lessened
07:12
from manufacturing and industrial sources.
07:14
Municipal waste, what we think of when we talk about garbage,
07:16
accounts for three percent of the nation's waste stream.
07:20
It's a remarkable statistic.
07:24
So in the flow of your days,
07:27
in the flow of your lives,
07:29
next time you see someone whose job is
07:31
to clean up after you,
07:34
take a moment to acknowledge them.
07:37
Take a moment to say thank you.
07:39
(Applause)
07:44

▲Back to top

About the Speaker:

Robin Nagle - Trash anthropologist
Robin Nagle is an anthropologist with a very particular focus... garbage.

Why you should listen

Robin Nagle has been the anthropologist-in-residence at the Department of Sanitation in New York City since 2006.

Nagle's fascination with trash stems from her desire to understand the all-too-often invisible infrastructure that guides the flow of garbage through a megalopolis like New York. After all, the city produces 11,000 tons of rubbish each day... and all of that has to be dealt with somewhere and by someone. If not, damaging health problems and consequences for all. So why do sanitation workers experience such stigma, all too often scorned and berated while on the job? Nagle, who is also director of NYU's Draper Interdisciplinary Master's program in humanities and social thought, determined to find out. She got her sanitation worker license and has spent much time with workers on the job, getting an up-close view of the city's garbage and the systems in place to deal with it. 

Her book, Picking Up: On the Streets and Behind the Trucks with the Sanitation Workers of New York City was published in 2013 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux. See also the profile of her work -- and a photoessay of her favorite places in New York City.

More profile about the speaker
Robin Nagle | Speaker | TED.com