sponsored links
TED@BCG San Francisco

Dan Berkenstock: The world is one big dataset. Now, how to photograph it ...

October 30, 2013

We're all familiar with satellite imagery, but what we might not know is that much of it is out of date. That's because satellites are big and expensive, so there aren't that many of them up in space. As he explains in this fascinating talk, Dan Berkenstock and his team came up with a different solution, designing a cheap, lightweight satellite with a radically new approach to photographing what's going on on Earth.

Dan Berkenstock - Satellite designer
Dan Berkenstock and his team at Skybox Imaging are rethinking how to take photographs from space. Full bio

sponsored links
Double-click the English subtitles below to play the video.
Five years ago, I was a Ph.D. student
00:12
living two lives.
00:14
In one, I used NASA supercomputers
00:16
to design next-generation spacecraft,
00:18
and in the other I was a data scientist
00:21
looking for potential smugglers
00:24
of sensitive nuclear technologies.
00:26
As a data scientist, I did a lot of analyses,
00:29
mostly of facilities,
00:32
industrial facilities around the world.
00:34
And I was always looking for a better canvas
00:36
to tie these all together.
00:39
And one day, I was thinking about how
00:41
all data has a location,
00:43
and I realized that the answer
00:45
had been staring me in the face.
00:46
Although I was a satellite engineer,
00:48
I hadn't thought about using satellite imagery
00:51
in my work.
00:54
Now, like most of us, I'd been online,
00:56
I'd see my house, so I thought,
00:58
I'll hop in there and I'll start looking up
00:59
some of these facilities.
01:02
And what I found really surprised me.
01:03
The pictures that I was finding
01:05
were years out of date,
01:07
and because of that,
01:09
it had relatively little relevance
01:10
to the work that I was doing today.
01:11
But I was intrigued.
01:14
I mean, satellite imagery is pretty amazing stuff.
01:15
There are millions and millions of sensors
01:19
surrounding us today,
01:21
but there's still so much we
don't know on a daily basis.
01:22
How much oil is stored in all of China?
01:25
How much corn is being produced?
01:29
How many ships are in all of our world's ports?
01:32
Now, in theory, all of these questions
01:36
could be answered by imagery,
01:39
but not if it's old.
01:41
And if this data was so valuable,
01:43
then how come I couldn't get my hands
01:45
on more recent pictures?
01:47
So the story begins over 50 years ago
01:49
with the launch of the first generation
01:53
of U.S. government photo reconnaissance satellites.
01:55
And today, there's a handful
01:58
of the great, great grandchildren
02:00
of these early Cold War machines
02:02
which are now operated by private companies
02:04
and from which the vast majority of satellite imagery
02:06
that you and I see on a daily basis comes.
02:08
During this period, launching things into space,
02:11
just the rocket to get the satellite up there,
02:14
has cost hundreds of millions of dollars each,
02:17
and that's created tremendous pressure
02:21
to launch things infrequently
02:23
and to make sure that when you do,
02:25
you cram as much functionality in there as possible.
02:27
All of this has only made satellites
02:30
bigger and bigger and bigger
02:32
and more expensive,
02:34
now nearly a billion, with a b, dollars per copy.
02:36
Because they are so expensive,
02:41
there aren't very many of them.
02:43
Because there aren't very many of them,
02:44
the pictures that we see on a daily basis
02:46
tend to be old.
02:48
I think a lot of people actually
understand this anecdotally,
02:50
but in order to visualize just how sparsely
02:53
our planet is collected,
02:55
some friends and I put together a dataset
02:57
of the 30 million pictures that have been gathered
02:59
by these satellites between 2000 and 2010.
03:02
As you can see in blue, huge areas of our world
03:05
are barely seen, less than once a year,
03:08
and even the areas that are seen most frequently,
03:11
those in red, are seen at best once a quarter.
03:13
Now as aerospace engineering grad students,
03:17
this chart cried out to us as a challenge.
03:20
Why do these things have to be so expensive?
03:23
Does a single satellite really have to cost
03:27
the equivalent of three 747 jumbo jets?
03:29
Wasn't there a way to build a smaller,
03:34
simpler, new satellite design that could enable
03:36
more timely imaging?
03:40
I realize that it does sound a little bit crazy
03:42
that we were going to go out and just
03:45
begin designing satellites,
03:47
but fortunately we had help.
03:48
In the late 1990s, a couple of professors
03:50
proposed a concept for radically reducing the price
03:53
of putting things in space.
03:57
This was hitchhiking small satellites
03:59
alongside much larger satellites.
04:01
This dropped the cost of putting objects up there
04:04
by over a factor of 100,
04:07
and suddenly we could afford to experiment,
04:09
to take a little bit of risk,
04:12
and to realize a lot of innovation.
04:13
And a new generation of engineers and scientists,
04:15
mostly out of universities,
04:19
began launching these very small,
04:20
breadbox-sized satellites called CubeSats.
04:22
And these were built with electronics obtained
04:25
from RadioShack instead of Lockheed Martin.
04:27
Now it was using the lessons
learned from these early missions
04:31
that my friends and I began a series of sketches
04:34
of our own satellite design.
04:37
And I can't remember a specific day
04:39
where we made a conscious decision
04:41
that we were actually going to
go out and build these things,
04:43
but once we got that idea in our minds
04:46
of the world as a dataset,
04:48
of being able to capture millions of data points
04:50
on a daily basis describing the global economy,
04:53
of being able to unearth billions of connections
04:56
between them that had never before been found,
04:59
it just seemed boring
05:02
to go work on anything else.
05:03
And so we moved into a cramped,
05:06
windowless office in Palo Alto,
05:09
and began working to take our design
05:12
from the drawing board into the lab.
05:14
The first major question we had to tackle
05:17
was just how big to build this thing.
05:20
In space, size drives cost,
05:22
and we had worked with these very small,
05:25
breadbox-sized satellites in school,
05:27
but as we began to better
understand the laws of physics,
05:29
we found that the quality of pictures
05:32
those satellites could take was very limited,
05:34
because the laws of physics dictate
05:37
that the best picture you
can take through a telescope
05:39
is a function of the diameter of that telescope,
05:42
and these satellites had a very small,
05:44
very constrained volume.
05:46
And we found that the best picture we would
05:48
have been able to get looked something like this.
05:49
Although this was the low-cost option,
05:52
quite frankly it was just too blurry
05:54
to see the things that make
satellite imagery valuable.
05:56
So about three or four weeks later,
05:59
we met a group of engineers randomly
06:01
who had worked on the first
06:04
private imaging satellite ever developed,
06:06
and they told us that back in the 1970s,
06:08
the U.S. government had found a powerful
06:10
optimal tradeoff --
06:13
that in taking pictures at right
about one meter resolution,
06:14
being able to see objects one meter in size,
06:17
they had found that they could not
just get very high-quality images,
06:20
but get a lot of them at an affordable price.
06:23
From our own computer simulations,
06:26
we quickly found that one meter really was
06:28
the minimum viable product
06:30
to be able to see the drivers of our global economy,
06:32
for the first time, being able to count
06:35
the ships and cars and shipping
containers and trucks
06:36
that move around our world on a daily basis,
06:39
while conveniently still not
being able to see individuals.
06:42
We had found our compromise.
06:46
We would have to build something larger
06:47
than the original breadbox,
06:49
now more like a mini-fridge,
06:50
but we still wouldn't have to build a pickup truck.
06:52
So now we had our constraint.
06:55
The laws of physics dictated
06:57
the absolute minimum-sized
telescope that we could build.
06:59
What came next was making the rest of the satellite
07:02
as small and as simple as possible,
07:06
basically a flying telescope with four walls
07:07
and a set of electronics smaller than a phone book
07:10
that used less power than a 100 watt lightbulb.
07:13
The big challenge became actually taking
07:16
the pictures through that telescope.
07:18
Traditional imaging satellites use a line scanner,
07:20
similar to a Xerox machine,
07:23
and as they traverse the Earth, they take pictures,
07:25
scanning row by row by row
07:28
to build the complete image.
07:30
Now people use these because they get a lot of light,
07:31
which means less of the noise you see
07:34
in a low-cost cell phone image.
07:36
The problem with them is they require
07:39
very sophisticated pointing.
07:41
You have to stay focused on a 50-centimeter target
07:44
from over 600 miles away
07:46
while moving at more than
seven kilometers a second,
07:48
which requires an awesome degree of complexity.
07:50
So instead, we turned to a new
generation of video sensors,
07:53
originally created for use in night vision goggles.
07:56
Instead of taking a single, high quality image,
07:59
we could take a videostream
08:02
of individually noisier frames,
08:04
but then we could recombine
08:07
all of those frames together
08:08
into very high-quality images
08:10
using sophisticated pixel processing techniques
08:12
here on the ground,
08:14
at a cost of one one hundredth a traditional system.
08:16
And we applied this technique
08:19
to many of the other systems on the satellite as well,
08:20
and day by day, our design evolved
08:23
from CAD to prototypes
08:26
to production units.
08:30
A few short weeks ago,
08:32
we packed up SkySat 1,
08:34
put our signatures on it,
08:36
and waved goodbye for the last time on Earth.
08:38
Today, it's sitting in its final launch configuration
08:40
ready to blast off in a few short weeks.
08:43
And soon, we'll turn our attention to launching
08:47
a constellation of 24 or more of these satellites
08:49
and beginning to build the scalable analytics
08:52
that will allow us to unearth the insights
08:54
in the petabytes of data we will collect.
08:57
So why do all of this? Why build these satellites?
09:00
Well, it turns out imaging satellites
09:04
have a unique ability to provide global transparency,
09:07
and providing that transparency on a timely basis
09:10
is simply an idea whose time has come.
09:13
We see ourselves as pioneers of a new frontier,
09:16
and beyond economic data,
09:20
unlocking the human story, moment by moment.
09:22
For a data scientist
09:25
that just happened to go to space camp as a kid,
09:27
it just doesn't get much better than that.
09:30
Thank you.
09:32
(Applause)
09:34

sponsored links

Dan Berkenstock - Satellite designer
Dan Berkenstock and his team at Skybox Imaging are rethinking how to take photographs from space.

Why you should listen

Dan Berkenstock is an entrepreneur and engineer from Chicago, who fell into a classic tale of Silicon Valley innovation while taking a graduate entrepreneurship course at Stanford. That class led him and some others to found Skybox Imaging, of which Berkenstock is now executive vice president and chief product officer.

Skybox's mission is simple, if bold: they're working to design and launch small satellites that "hitchhike" to space in an effort to revolutionize the satellite imaging business. In 2013, SkySat-1, the first such satellite, was launched and is now beaming back images that are high-enough resolution to show the real-time state of global commerce. The idea: to "revolutionize the ways that consumers, businesses, and governments make decisions in their day-to-day lives."

In a previous life, Berkenstock worked in the Advanced Supercomputing Division at NASA's Ames Research Center, and also worked as a counterproliferation analyst at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, where he focused on trying to find and thwart potential potential smugglers of nuclear technologies. He is currently on leave from the Ph.D. program in aeronautics and astronautics at Stanford University.

sponsored links

If you need translations, you can install "Google Translate" extension into your Chrome Browser.
Furthermore, you can change playback rate by installing "Video Speed Controller" extension.

Data provided by TED.

This website is owned and operated by Tokyo English Network.
The developer's blog is here.