TEDxBoulder
Ash Beckham: When to take a stand -- and when to let it go
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
1,623,269 views
Ash Beckham recently found herself in a situation that made her ask: who am I? She felt pulled between two roles — as an aunt and as an advocate. Each of us feels this struggle sometimes, she says -- and offers bold suggestions for how to stand up for your moral integrity when it isn't convenient.
Ash Beckham - Equality advocate
Ash Beckham approaches hard conversations from a place of compassion and empathy. Full bio
Ash Beckham approaches hard conversations from a place of compassion and empathy. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
This summer I was back
in Ohio for a family wedding,
in Ohio for a family wedding,
0
751
6885
00:19
and when I was there,
1
7784
2201
00:22
there was a meet and greet
with Anna and Elsa from "Frozen."
with Anna and Elsa from "Frozen."
2
9985
3353
00:25
Not the Anna and Elsa from "Frozen,"
3
13478
3625
00:29
as this was not a Disney-sanctioned event.
4
17103
2730
00:32
These two entrepreneurs had
a business of running princess parties.
a business of running princess parties.
5
19833
4600
00:36
Your kid is turning five?
6
24433
1584
00:38
They'll come sing some songs,
sprinkle some fairy dust, it's great.
sprinkle some fairy dust, it's great.
7
26017
3527
00:41
And they were not about
to miss out on the opportunity
to miss out on the opportunity
8
29554
3614
00:45
that was the phenomenon
and that was "Frozen."
and that was "Frozen."
9
33168
2635
00:48
So they get hired by a local toy store,
10
35804
1896
00:49
kids come in on a Saturday morning,
11
37701
1756
00:51
buy some Disney swag, get their
picture taken with the princesses,
picture taken with the princesses,
12
39458
3099
00:54
call it a day.
13
42557
1603
00:56
It's like Santa Claus
without the seasonal restrictions.
without the seasonal restrictions.
14
44160
2696
00:59
(Laughter)
15
46857
1605
01:00
And my three-and-a-half-year-old niece
Samantha was in the thick of it.
Samantha was in the thick of it.
16
48463
5087
01:05
She could care less that these two women
were signing posters and coloring books
were signing posters and coloring books
17
53550
5122
01:10
as Snow Queen and Princess Ana
with one N to avoid copyright lawsuits.
with one N to avoid copyright lawsuits.
18
58672
5284
01:16
(Laughter)
19
63956
1166
01:17
According to my niece and the 200-plus
kids in the parking lot that day,
kids in the parking lot that day,
20
65123
4695
01:22
this was the Anna and Elsa from "Frozen."
21
69819
4723
01:28
It is a blazing hot Saturday morning
in August in Ohio.
in August in Ohio.
22
75955
5642
01:33
We get there at 10 o'clock,
the scheduled start time,
the scheduled start time,
23
81598
3274
01:37
and we are handed number 59.
24
84873
2232
01:39
By 11 o'clock they had called
numbers 21 through 25;
numbers 21 through 25;
25
87106
4567
01:43
this was going to be a while,
26
91674
1752
01:45
and there is no amount
of free face painting or temporary tattoos
of free face painting or temporary tattoos
27
93427
4464
01:50
that could prevent the meltdowns
that were occurring outside of the store.
that were occurring outside of the store.
28
97892
3504
01:53
(Laughter)
29
101397
1574
01:55
So, by 12:30 we get called:
30
102972
4141
01:59
"56 to 63, please."
31
107114
3192
02:02
And as we walk in, it is a scene
I can only describe you
I can only describe you
32
110316
3361
02:05
as saying it looked like Norway threw up.
33
113678
2889
02:08
(Laughter)
34
116568
1379
02:10
There were cardboard
cut-out snowflakes covering the floor,
cut-out snowflakes covering the floor,
35
117948
4385
02:14
glitter on every flat surface,
and icicles all over the walls.
and icicles all over the walls.
36
122334
4918
02:20
And as we stood in line
37
127870
1193
02:21
in an attempt to give
my niece a better vantage point
my niece a better vantage point
38
129063
2533
02:23
than the backside
of the mother of number 58,
of the mother of number 58,
39
131596
2555
02:26
I put her up on my shoulders,
40
134151
1728
02:28
and she was instantly riveted
by the sight of the princesses.
by the sight of the princesses.
41
135880
4098
02:32
And as we moved forward,
her excitement only grew,
her excitement only grew,
42
139979
2540
02:34
and as we finally got
to the front of the line,
to the front of the line,
43
142520
2284
02:37
and number 58 unfurled her poster
to be signed by the princesses,
to be signed by the princesses,
44
144804
3693
02:40
I could literally feel the excitement
running through her body.
running through her body.
45
148498
3599
02:44
And let's be honest,
at that point, I was pretty excited too.
at that point, I was pretty excited too.
46
152098
2964
02:47
(Laughter)
47
155063
1394
02:48
I mean, the Scandinavian decadence
was mesmerizing.
was mesmerizing.
48
156458
2998
02:51
(Laughter)
49
159457
1168
02:52
So we get to the front of the line,
50
160626
1909
02:54
and the haggard clerk
turns to my niece and says,
turns to my niece and says,
51
162536
3009
02:57
"Hi, honey. You're next!
52
165546
1819
02:59
Do you want to get down,
or you're going to stay
or you're going to stay
53
167366
2289
03:01
on your dad's shoulders for the picture?'
54
169656
2256
03:04
(Laughter)
55
171913
1486
03:05
And I was, for a lack
of a better word, frozen.
of a better word, frozen.
56
173400
3861
03:09
(Laughter)
57
177262
1611
03:11
It's amazing that in an unexpected instant
we are faced with the question,
we are faced with the question,
58
178874
4792
03:15
who am I?
59
183667
1330
03:17
Am I an aunt? Or am I an advocate?
60
184998
3467
03:20
Millions of people have seen my video
about how to have a hard conversation,
about how to have a hard conversation,
61
188466
3830
03:24
and there one was, right in front of me.
62
192297
2316
03:26
At the same time,
63
194614
1071
03:27
there's nothing more important
to me than the kids in my life,
to me than the kids in my life,
64
195686
2909
03:30
so I found myself in a situation
that we so often find ourselves in,
that we so often find ourselves in,
65
198596
3947
03:34
torn between two things,
two impossible choices.
two impossible choices.
66
202544
3222
03:37
Would I be an advocate?
67
205767
2026
03:39
Would I take my niece off my shoulders
and turn to the clerk and explain to her
and turn to the clerk and explain to her
68
207794
4547
03:44
that I was in fact
her aunt, not her father,
her aunt, not her father,
69
212342
3137
03:47
and that she should be more careful
70
215480
2368
03:50
and not to jump to gender conclusions
based on haircuts and shoulder rides --
based on haircuts and shoulder rides --
71
217849
4755
03:54
(Laughter) --
72
222605
1135
03:55
and while doing that,
73
223741
1856
03:57
miss out on what was, to this point,
the greatest moment of my niece's life.
the greatest moment of my niece's life.
74
225598
4788
04:03
Or would I be an aunt?
75
231116
2089
04:05
Would I brush off that comment,
take a million pictures,
take a million pictures,
76
233206
3137
04:08
and not be distracted for an instant
from the pure joy of that moment,
from the pure joy of that moment,
77
236344
4977
04:13
and by doing that,
78
241322
1518
04:15
walk out with the shame that comes up
for not standing up for myself,
for not standing up for myself,
79
242841
3382
04:18
especially in front of my niece.
80
246224
2382
04:20
Who was I?
81
248607
1802
04:22
Which one was more important?
Which role was more worth it?
Which role was more worth it?
82
250410
4818
04:27
Was I an aunt? Or was I an advocate?
83
255230
2988
04:30
And I had a split second to decide.
84
258219
3216
04:34
We are taught right now
85
262235
1578
04:36
that we are living in a world
of constant and increasing polarity.
of constant and increasing polarity.
86
263814
4298
04:40
It's so black and white,
so us and them, so right and wrong.
so us and them, so right and wrong.
87
268113
4571
04:45
There is no middle,
there is no gray, just polarity.
there is no gray, just polarity.
88
273524
4167
04:49
Polarity is a state in which
two ideas or opinions
two ideas or opinions
89
277691
2440
04:52
are completely opposite from each other;
90
280132
2580
04:54
a diametrical opposition.
91
282712
2154
04:58
Which side are you on?
92
286127
2454
05:00
Are you unequivocally and without question
antiwar, pro-choice, anti-death penalty,
antiwar, pro-choice, anti-death penalty,
93
288581
4065
05:04
pro-gun regulation, proponent
of open borders and pro-union?
of open borders and pro-union?
94
292646
3458
05:08
Or, are you absolutely
and uncompromisingly
and uncompromisingly
95
296104
5233
05:13
pro-war, pro-life, pro-death penalty,
96
301337
2185
05:15
a believer that the Second
Amendment is absolute,
Amendment is absolute,
97
303522
2316
05:18
anti-immigrant and pro-business?
98
305838
1704
05:19
It's all or none, you're with us
or against us.
or against us.
99
307542
2245
05:21
That is polarity.
100
309787
1720
05:24
The problem with polarity
and absolutes is that
and absolutes is that
101
312247
4943
05:29
it eliminates the individuality
of our human experience
of our human experience
102
317191
5164
05:34
and that makes it contradictory
to our human nature.
to our human nature.
103
322355
4026
05:39
But if we are pulled
in these two directions,
in these two directions,
104
327187
2110
05:41
but it's not really where we exist --
105
329297
1780
05:43
polarity is not our actual reality --
106
331077
2430
05:45
where do we go from there?
107
333507
1380
05:47
What's at the other end of that spectrum?
108
334887
3480
05:50
I don't think it's an unattainable,
harmonious utopia,
harmonious utopia,
109
338368
4039
05:54
I think the opposite
of polarity is duality.
of polarity is duality.
110
342408
3433
05:58
Duality is a state of having two parts,
111
345842
2604
06:00
but not in diametrical opposition,
112
348446
3283
06:03
in simultaneous existence.
113
351730
2945
06:06
Don't think it's possible?
114
354676
1986
06:08
Here are the people I know:
115
356663
1670
06:10
I know Catholics who are pro-choice,
and feminists who wear hijabs,
and feminists who wear hijabs,
116
358334
3163
06:13
and veterans who are antiwar,
117
361497
1704
06:15
and NRA members who think
I should be able to get married.
I should be able to get married.
118
363202
2784
06:18
Those are the people I know,
those are my friends and family,
those are my friends and family,
119
365987
3035
06:21
that is the majority of our society,
that is you, that is me.
that is you, that is me.
120
369023
2976
06:24
(Applause)
121
372000
1657
06:32
Duality is the ability
to hold both things.
to hold both things.
122
380717
5168
06:38
But the question is:
Can we own our duality?
Can we own our duality?
123
385886
4121
06:42
Can we have the courage
to hold both things?
to hold both things?
124
390008
3722
06:46
I work at a restaurant in town,
125
394230
2192
06:48
I became really good friends
with the busser.
with the busser.
126
396422
2610
06:51
I was a server and we had
a great relationship,
a great relationship,
127
399032
3018
06:54
we had a really great time together.
128
402050
1940
06:56
Her Spanish was great
129
403990
3618
06:59
because she was from Mexico.
130
407609
1841
07:01
(Laughter)
131
409451
1861
07:03
That line actually went the other way.
132
411313
2433
07:05
Her English was limited,
but significantly better than my Spanish.
but significantly better than my Spanish.
133
413747
3921
07:12
But we were united by our similarities,
134
419848
3829
07:15
not separated by our differences.
135
423678
2900
07:18
And we were close, even though
we came from very different worlds.
we came from very different worlds.
136
426578
3120
07:21
She was from Mexico,
137
429698
1140
07:23
she left her family behind
so she could come here
so she could come here
138
430838
3331
07:26
and afford them a better life back home.
139
434169
1980
07:28
She was a devout conservative Catholic,
140
436166
2940
07:31
a believer in traditional family values,
141
439106
2720
07:34
stereotypical roles of men and women,
142
441826
2106
07:36
and I was, well, me.
143
443933
2794
07:38
(Laughter)
144
446728
1904
07:40
But the things that bonded us
were when she asked about my girlfriend,
were when she asked about my girlfriend,
145
448633
3685
07:44
or she shared pictures that she had
from her family back home.
from her family back home.
146
452319
3468
07:47
Those were the things
that brought us together.
that brought us together.
147
455788
2627
07:50
So one day, we were in the back,
148
458416
1586
07:52
scarfing down food as quickly as we could,
gathered around a small table,
gathered around a small table,
149
460003
3679
07:55
during a very rare lull,
150
463683
1630
07:57
and a new guy
from the kitchen came over --
from the kitchen came over --
151
465313
2010
07:59
who happened to be her cousin --
152
467323
1662
08:01
and sat down with all
the bravado and machismo
the bravado and machismo
153
468985
2802
08:03
that his 20-year-old body could hold.
154
471788
2161
08:06
(Laughter)
155
473950
1821
08:07
And he said to her,
[in Spanish] "Does Ash have a boyfriend?"
[in Spanish] "Does Ash have a boyfriend?"
156
475772
4972
08:14
And she said,
[in Spanish] "No, she has a girlfriend."
[in Spanish] "No, she has a girlfriend."
157
481904
3952
08:19
And he said,
[in Spanish] "A girlfriend?!?"
[in Spanish] "A girlfriend?!?"
158
487386
3525
08:23
And she set down her fork,
and locked eyes with him,
and locked eyes with him,
159
490912
3112
08:26
and said, [in Spanish] "Yes,
a girlfriend. That is all."
a girlfriend. That is all."
160
494025
5022
08:31
And his smug smile quickly dropped
to one of maternal respect,
to one of maternal respect,
161
499048
4892
08:36
grabbed his plate, walked off,
went back to work.
went back to work.
162
503941
3202
08:39
She never made eye contact with me.
163
507144
1734
08:41
She left, did the same thing --
164
509668
1715
08:43
it was a 10-second conversation,
such a short interaction.
such a short interaction.
165
511384
3270
08:46
And on paper, she had
so much more in common with him:
so much more in common with him:
166
514655
2536
08:49
language, culture, history, family,
her community was her lifeline here,
her community was her lifeline here,
167
517191
5098
08:54
but her moral compass trumped all of that.
168
522289
4171
08:58
And a little bit later, they were joking
around in the kitchen in Spanish,
around in the kitchen in Spanish,
169
526461
3662
09:02
that had nothing to do with me,
170
530124
1900
09:04
and that is duality.
171
532025
2444
09:06
She didn't have to choose some P.C. stance
on gayness over her heritage.
on gayness over her heritage.
172
534470
4513
09:11
She didn't have to choose
her family over our friendship.
her family over our friendship.
173
538983
3150
09:14
It wasn't Jesus or Ash.
174
542134
2274
09:16
(Laughter)
175
544409
1967
09:20
(Applause)
176
548556
1937
09:27
Her individual morality
was so strongly rooted
was so strongly rooted
177
555183
4577
09:31
that she had the courage
to hold both things.
to hold both things.
178
559761
3381
09:35
Our moral integrity is our responsibility
179
563143
3181
09:38
and we must be prepared to defend it
even when it's not convenient.
even when it's not convenient.
180
566325
4231
09:42
That's what it means to be an ally,
and if you're going to be an ally,
and if you're going to be an ally,
181
570557
3313
09:46
you have to be an active ally:
182
573870
2287
09:48
Ask questions, act when you hear
something inappropriate,
something inappropriate,
183
576158
3887
09:52
actually engage.
184
580046
2028
09:54
I had a family friend who for years
used to call my girlfriend my lover.
used to call my girlfriend my lover.
185
582075
4433
10:00
Really? Lover?
186
588531
2444
10:03
So overly sexual,
187
590976
2024
10:05
so '70s gay porn.
188
593001
2045
10:07
(Laughter)
189
595047
1206
10:11
But she was trying, and she asked.
190
599293
2495
10:13
She could have called her my friend,
191
601789
1783
10:15
or my "friend," or my "special friend" --
192
603573
4134
10:19
(Laughter) --
193
607708
1384
10:21
or even worse, just not asked at all.
194
609093
2965
10:24
Believe me, we would rather have you ask.
195
612059
3630
10:27
I would rather have her say lover,
than say nothing at all.
than say nothing at all.
196
615690
5241
10:33
People often say to me,
"Well, Ash, I don't care.
"Well, Ash, I don't care.
197
620932
3031
10:36
I don't see race
or religion or sexuality.
or religion or sexuality.
198
623964
3792
10:39
It doesn't matter to me. I don't see it."
199
627757
2843
10:44
But I think the opposite of homophobia
and racism and xenophobia is not love,
and racism and xenophobia is not love,
200
631910
5334
10:49
it's apathy.
201
637245
1613
10:51
If you don't see my gayness,
then you don't see me.
then you don't see me.
202
638859
4103
10:55
If it doesn't matter to you
who I sleep with,
who I sleep with,
203
642963
2985
10:58
then you cannot imagine what it feels like
204
645949
2185
11:00
when I walk down the street
late at night holding her hand,
late at night holding her hand,
205
648135
2876
11:03
and approach a group of people
and have to make the decision
and have to make the decision
206
651011
2818
11:06
if I should hang on to it
or if I should I drop it
or if I should I drop it
207
653829
2345
11:08
when all I want to do
is squeeze it tighter.
is squeeze it tighter.
208
656175
2318
11:10
And the small victory I feel
209
658494
2517
11:13
when I make it by
and don't have to let go.
and don't have to let go.
210
661012
2707
11:15
And the incredible cowardice
and disappointment I feel when I drop it.
and disappointment I feel when I drop it.
211
663720
5118
11:21
If you do not see that struggle
212
668839
1948
11:22
that is unique to my human experience
because I am gay, then you don't see me.
because I am gay, then you don't see me.
213
670788
6475
11:29
If you are going to be an ally,
I need you to see me.
I need you to see me.
214
677264
5414
11:34
As individuals, as allies, as humans,
215
682679
2943
11:37
we need to be able to hold both things:
216
685622
3000
11:40
both the good and the bad,
217
688622
2448
11:43
the easy and the hard.
218
691070
1830
11:45
You don't learn how to hold
two things just from the fluff,
two things just from the fluff,
219
692900
4471
11:49
you learn it from the grit.
220
697372
2401
11:51
And what if duality
is just the first step?
is just the first step?
221
699774
3384
11:56
What if through compassion
and empathy and human interaction
and empathy and human interaction
222
704308
4829
12:01
we are able to learn to hold two things?
223
709138
2394
12:03
And if we can hold
two things, we can hold four,
two things, we can hold four,
224
711533
2314
12:06
and if we can hold four,
we can hold eight,
we can hold eight,
225
713848
2010
12:08
and if we can hold eight,
we can hold hundreds.
we can hold hundreds.
226
715859
2240
12:10
We are complex individuals,
227
718100
2462
12:12
swirls of contradiction.
228
720562
1800
12:14
You are all holding
so many things right now.
so many things right now.
229
722362
2605
12:18
What can you do to hold just a few more?
230
725888
3442
12:22
So, back to Toledo, Ohio.
231
730100
2137
12:24
I'm at the front of the line,
232
732237
2180
12:26
niece on my shoulders,
the frazzled clerk calls me Dad.
the frazzled clerk calls me Dad.
233
734417
4102
12:30
Have you ever been mistaken
for the wrong gender?
for the wrong gender?
234
738520
3560
12:35
Not even that.
235
743111
2198
12:37
Have you ever been called
something you are not?
something you are not?
236
745310
4449
12:43
Here's what it feels like for me:
237
751509
2530
12:46
I am instantly an internal storm
of contrasting emotions.
of contrasting emotions.
238
754040
4073
12:50
I break out into a sweat that is
a combination of rage and humiliation,
a combination of rage and humiliation,
239
758114
5542
12:55
I feel like the entire store
is staring at me,
is staring at me,
240
763657
2960
12:58
and I simultaneously feel invisible.
241
766618
2560
13:01
I want to explode in a tirade of fury,
242
769179
2943
13:04
and I want to crawl under a rock.
243
772123
2593
13:06
And top all of that off
with the frustration that I'm wearing
with the frustration that I'm wearing
244
774717
3102
13:10
an out-of-character
tight-fitting purple t-shirt,
tight-fitting purple t-shirt,
245
777820
3598
13:13
so this whole store can see my boobs,
246
781418
2038
13:15
to make sure this exact
same thing doesn't happen.
same thing doesn't happen.
247
783456
3001
13:18
(Laughter)
248
786458
2182
13:20
But, despite my best efforts
to be seen as the gender I am,
to be seen as the gender I am,
249
788640
4322
13:25
it still happens.
250
792962
1841
13:27
And I hope with every ounce
of my body that no one heard --
of my body that no one heard --
251
794804
4692
13:31
not my sister, not my girlfriend,
and certainly not my niece.
and certainly not my niece.
252
799497
4553
13:36
I am accustomed to this familiar hurt,
253
804050
2441
13:38
but I will do whatever I need to do
to protect the people I love from it.
to protect the people I love from it.
254
806491
4075
13:44
But then I take my niece off my shoulders,
255
811906
2534
13:46
and she runs to Elsa and Anna --
256
814441
2174
13:48
the thing she's been
waiting so long for --
waiting so long for --
257
816616
2566
13:51
and all that stuff goes away.
258
819183
2087
13:53
All that matters is the smile on her face.
259
821270
3710
13:57
And as the 30 seconds we waited
two and a half hours for comes to a close
two and a half hours for comes to a close
260
824980
5657
14:02
we gather up our things,
and I lock eyes with the clerk again;
and I lock eyes with the clerk again;
261
830638
5203
14:08
and she gives me
an apologetic smile and mouths,
an apologetic smile and mouths,
262
835842
3136
14:11
"I am so sorry!"
263
838979
2296
14:13
(Laughter)
264
841276
2109
14:15
And her humanity, her willingness to admit
her mistake disarms me immediately,
her mistake disarms me immediately,
265
843386
5856
14:21
then I give her a: "It's okay,
it happens. But thanks."
it happens. But thanks."
266
849243
5172
14:26
And I realize in that moment
267
854416
2990
14:29
that I don't have to be
268
857407
2037
14:31
either an aunt
or an advocate, I can be both.
or an advocate, I can be both.
269
859445
4198
14:37
I can live in duality,
and I can hold two things.
and I can hold two things.
270
864903
5348
14:42
And if I can hold two things
in that environment,
in that environment,
271
870252
2937
14:45
I can hold so many more things.
272
873190
2352
14:47
As my girlfriend and my niece hold hands
and skip out the front of the door,
and skip out the front of the door,
273
875543
3752
14:51
I turn to my sister and say,
"Was it worth it?"
"Was it worth it?"
274
879296
2743
14:54
And she said, "Are you kidding me?
275
882040
1774
14:56
Did you see the look on her face?
This was the greatest day of her life!"
This was the greatest day of her life!"
276
883815
3887
14:59
(Laughter)
277
887703
1097
15:01
"It was worth the two
and a half hours in the heat,
and a half hours in the heat,
278
888801
2957
15:03
it was worth the overpriced coloring book
that we already had a copy of."
that we already had a copy of."
279
891759
4387
15:08
(Laughter)
280
896147
1707
15:10
"It was even worth you
getting called Dad."
getting called Dad."
281
897855
3654
15:13
(Laughter)
282
901510
1105
15:17
And for the first time ever
in my life, it actually was.
in my life, it actually was.
283
905205
5714
15:23
Thank you, Boulder. Have a good night.
284
910920
2178
15:25
(Applause)
285
913099
1520
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Ash Beckham - Equality advocateAsh Beckham approaches hard conversations from a place of compassion and empathy.
Why you should listen
Ash Beckham is no stranger to hard conversations. In her work, she shares how coming out as a lesbian helped her appreciate our common humanity and better understand the hardships that we all face. This equality advocate mixes personal experience and wisdom to help everyone bravely face their demons.
Ash Beckham | Speaker | TED.com