ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jim Al-Khalili - Quantum physicist
Physicist Jim Al-Khalili and co-author Johnjoe McFadden, a biologist, explore the far edges of quantum biology in their book "Life on the Edge."

Why you should listen
A professor of physics at the University of Surrey, Jim Al-Khalili doubles as a science communicator and broadcaster. He’s the co-author with Johnjoe McFadden of Life on the Edge: The Coming of Age of Quantum Biology. The book explores this emerging -- and still largely speculative -- area of science suggesting that quantum mechanics may play a role in biology. If so, it may help us understand what drives genetic mutations that lead to cancer, or how robins fly from Scandinavia to the Mediterranean.
More profile about the speaker
Jim Al-Khalili | Speaker | TED.com
TEDGlobalLondon

Jim Al-Khalili: How quantum biology might explain life's biggest questions

Filmed:
2,255,707 views

How does a robin know to fly south? The answer might be weirder than you think: Quantum physics may be involved. Jim Al-Khalili rounds up the extremely new, extremely strange world of quantum biology, where something Einstein once called "spooky action at a distance" helps birds navigate, and quantum effects might explain the origin of life itself.
- Quantum physicist
Physicist Jim Al-Khalili and co-author Johnjoe McFadden, a biologist, explore the far edges of quantum biology in their book "Life on the Edge." Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
I'd like to introduce you
to an emerging area of science,
0
1190
4528
00:17
one that is still speculative
but hugely exciting,
1
5742
3943
00:21
and certainly one
that's growing very rapidly.
2
9709
2629
00:25
Quantum biology
asks a very simple question:
3
13448
4048
00:29
Does quantum mechanics --
4
17520
1350
00:30
that weird and wonderful
and powerful theory
5
18894
3302
00:34
of the subatomic world
of atoms and molecules
6
22220
2688
00:36
that underpins so much
of modern physics and chemistry --
7
24932
3488
00:40
also play a role inside the living cell?
8
28444
3412
00:43
In other words: Are there processes,
mechanisms, phenomena
9
31880
4079
00:47
in living organisms
that can only be explained
10
35983
3988
00:51
with a helping hand
from quantum mechanics?
11
39995
2743
00:55
Now, quantum biology isn't new;
12
43546
1637
00:57
it's been around since the early 1930s.
13
45207
2401
00:59
But it's only in the last decade or so
that careful experiments --
14
47928
3715
01:03
in biochemistry labs,
using spectroscopy --
15
51667
3464
01:07
have shown very clear, firm evidence
that there are certain specific mechanisms
16
55155
6863
01:14
that require quantum mechanics
to explain them.
17
62042
2511
01:17
Quantum biology brings together
quantum physicists, biochemists,
18
65674
3329
01:21
molecular biologists --
it's a very interdisciplinary field.
19
69027
3641
01:24
I come from quantum physics,
so I'm a nuclear physicist.
20
72692
3929
01:28
I've spent more than three decades
21
76645
2265
01:30
trying to get my head
around quantum mechanics.
22
78934
2929
01:33
One of the founders
of quantum mechanics, Niels Bohr,
23
81887
2493
01:36
said, If you're not astonished by it,
then you haven't understood it.
24
84404
3350
01:40
So I sort of feel happy
that I'm still astonished by it.
25
88237
2843
01:43
That's a good thing.
26
91104
1745
01:44
But it means I study the very
smallest structures in the universe --
27
92873
6885
01:51
the building blocks of reality.
28
99782
2075
01:53
If we think about the scale of size,
29
101881
3215
01:57
start with an everyday object
like the tennis ball,
30
105120
2952
02:00
and just go down orders
of magnitude in size --
31
108096
2901
02:03
from the eye of a needle down to a cell,
down to a bacterium, down to an enzyme --
32
111021
5197
02:08
you eventually reach the nano-world.
33
116242
1729
02:09
Now, nanotechnology may be
a term you've heard of.
34
117995
2495
02:12
A nanometer is a billionth of a meter.
35
120841
2853
02:16
My area is the atomic nucleus,
which is the tiny dot inside an atom.
36
124560
4370
02:20
It's even smaller in scale.
37
128954
1932
02:22
This is the domain of quantum mechanics,
38
130910
1918
02:24
and physicists and chemists
have had a long time
39
132852
2516
02:27
to try and get used to it.
40
135392
1301
02:29
Biologists, on the other hand,
have got off lightly, in my view.
41
137248
4457
02:34
They are very happy with their
balls-and-sticks models of molecules.
42
142071
4331
02:38
(Laughter)
43
146426
1082
02:39
The balls are the atoms, the sticks
are the bonds between the atoms.
44
147532
3198
02:42
And when they can't build them
physically in the lab,
45
150754
2494
02:45
nowadays, they have
very powerful computers
46
153272
2392
02:47
that will simulate a huge molecule.
47
155688
1967
02:49
This is a protein made up
of 100,000 atoms.
48
157679
3664
02:54
It doesn't really require much in the way
of quantum mechanics to explain it.
49
162003
4335
02:59
Quantum mechanics
was developed in the 1920s.
50
167695
2889
03:02
It is a set of beautiful and powerful
mathematical rules and ideas
51
170965
6880
03:09
that explain the world of the very small.
52
177869
2608
03:12
And it's a world that's very different
from our everyday world,
53
180501
3372
03:15
made up of trillions of atoms.
54
183897
1519
03:17
It's a world built
on probability and chance.
55
185440
3557
03:21
It's a fuzzy world.
56
189818
1302
03:23
It's a world of phantoms,
57
191144
1730
03:24
where particles can also behave
like spread-out waves.
58
192898
3348
03:30
If we imagine quantum mechanics
or quantum physics, then,
59
198157
2862
03:33
as the fundamental
foundation of reality itself,
60
201043
5214
03:38
then it's not surprising that we say
61
206281
1730
03:40
quantum physics underpins
organic chemistry.
62
208035
2420
03:42
After all, it gives us
the rules that tell us
63
210479
2120
03:44
how the atoms fit together
to make organic molecules.
64
212623
2641
03:47
Organic chemistry,
scaled up in complexity,
65
215288
3239
03:50
gives us molecular biology,
which of course leads to life itself.
66
218551
3322
03:54
So in a way, it's sort of not surprising.
67
222174
1977
03:56
It's almost trivial.
68
224175
1214
03:57
You say, "Well, of course life ultimately
must depend of quantum mechanics."
69
225413
4220
04:02
But so does everything else.
70
230141
2390
04:04
So does all inanimate matter,
made up of trillions of atoms.
71
232555
3615
04:08
Ultimately, there's a quantum level
72
236501
4878
04:13
where we have to delve into
this weirdness.
73
241403
2183
04:15
But in everyday life,
we can forget about it.
74
243610
2416
04:18
Because once you put together
trillions of atoms,
75
246404
3199
04:21
that quantum weirdness
just dissolves away.
76
249627
2615
04:27
Quantum biology isn't about this.
77
255288
2569
04:29
Quantum biology isn't this obvious.
78
257881
2556
04:32
Of course quantum mechanics
underpins life at some molecular level.
79
260461
4229
04:37
Quantum biology is about looking
for the non-trivial --
80
265254
6004
04:43
the counterintuitive ideas
in quantum mechanics --
81
271282
4476
04:47
and to see if they do, indeed,
play an important role
82
275782
3015
04:50
in describing the processes of life.
83
278821
2452
04:54
Here is my perfect example
of the counterintuitiveness
84
282653
5220
04:59
of the quantum world.
85
287897
1446
05:01
This is the quantum skier.
86
289367
1251
05:02
He seems to be intact,
he seems to be perfectly healthy,
87
290642
2640
05:05
and yet, he seems to have gone around
both sides of that tree at the same time.
88
293306
4127
05:09
Well, if you saw tracks like that
89
297457
1663
05:11
you'd guess it was some
sort of stunt, of course.
90
299144
2309
05:13
But in the quantum world,
this happens all the time.
91
301477
2591
05:16
Particles can multitask,
they can be in two places at once.
92
304864
3026
05:19
They can do more than one thing
at the same time.
93
307914
2328
05:22
Particles can behave
like spread-out waves.
94
310266
2643
05:25
It's almost like magic.
95
313298
1599
05:27
Physicists and chemists have had
nearly a century
96
315538
2749
05:30
of trying to get used to this weirdness.
97
318311
2646
05:33
I don't blame the biologists
98
321445
1350
05:34
for not having to or wanting
to learn quantum mechanics.
99
322819
2635
05:37
You see, this weirdness is very delicate;
100
325478
3198
05:40
and we physicists work very hard
to maintain it in our labs.
101
328700
4450
05:45
We cool our system down
to near absolute zero,
102
333174
4204
05:49
we carry out our experiments in vacuums,
103
337402
1945
05:51
we try and isolate it
from any external disturbance.
104
339371
3527
05:55
That's very different from the warm,
messy, noisy environment of a living cell.
105
343602
5078
06:01
Biology itself, if you think of
molecular biology,
106
349960
2787
06:04
seems to have done very well
in describing all the processes of life
107
352771
3457
06:08
in terms of chemistry --
chemical reactions.
108
356252
2486
06:10
And these are reductionist,
deterministic chemical reactions,
109
358762
4850
06:15
showing that, essentially, life is made
of the same stuff as everything else,
110
363636
5114
06:20
and if we can forget about quantum
mechanics in the macro world,
111
368774
3060
06:23
then we should be able to forget
about it in biology, as well.
112
371858
3246
06:27
Well, one man begged
to differ with this idea.
113
375706
3364
06:32
Erwin Schrödinger,
of Schrödinger's Cat fame,
114
380062
3469
06:35
was an Austrian physicist.
115
383555
1317
06:36
He was one of the founders
of quantum mechanics in the 1920s.
116
384896
3183
06:40
In 1944, he wrote a book
called "What is Life?"
117
388663
2707
06:43
It was tremendously influential.
118
391839
1731
06:45
It influenced Francis Crick
and James Watson,
119
393594
2881
06:48
the discoverers of the double-helix
structure of DNA.
120
396499
2523
06:51
To paraphrase a description
in the book, he says:
121
399343
3668
06:55
At the molecular level,
living organisms have a certain order,
122
403035
5786
07:00
a structure to them that's very different
123
408845
3232
07:04
from the random thermodynamic jostling
of atoms and molecules
124
412101
4736
07:08
in inanimate matter
of the same complexity.
125
416861
3706
07:13
In fact, living matter seems to behave
in this order, in a structure,
126
421504
5014
07:18
just like inanimate matter
cooled down to near absolute zero,
127
426542
3834
07:22
where quantum effects
play a very important role.
128
430400
3033
07:26
There's something special
about the structure -- the order --
129
434280
4160
07:30
inside a living cell.
130
438464
1560
07:32
So, Schrödinger speculated that maybe
quantum mechanics plays a role in life.
131
440048
5293
07:38
It's a very speculative,
far-reaching idea,
132
446096
3425
07:41
and it didn't really go very far.
133
449545
2873
07:45
But as I mentioned at the start,
134
453536
1533
07:47
in the last 10 years, there have been
experiments emerging,
135
455093
2799
07:49
showing where some of these
certain phenomena in biology
136
457916
4055
07:53
do seem to require quantum mechanics.
137
461995
1763
07:55
I want to share with you
just a few of the exciting ones.
138
463782
3123
08:00
This is one of the best-known
phenomena in the quantum world,
139
468215
3707
08:03
quantum tunneling.
140
471946
1701
08:05
The box on the left shows
the wavelike, spread-out distribution
141
473671
4389
08:10
of a quantum entity --
a particle, like an electron,
142
478084
2761
08:12
which is not a little ball
bouncing off a wall.
143
480869
3637
08:16
It's a wave that has a certain probability
of being able to permeate
144
484530
4739
08:21
through a solid wall, like a phantom
leaping through to the other side.
145
489293
3406
08:24
You can see a faint smudge of light
in the right-hand box.
146
492723
4098
08:29
Quantum tunneling suggests that a particle
can hit an impenetrable barrier,
147
497773
4612
08:34
and yet somehow, as though by magic,
148
502409
2460
08:36
disappear from one side
and reappear on the other.
149
504893
2444
08:39
The nicest way of explaining it is
if you want to throw a ball over a wall,
150
507658
4251
08:43
you have to give it enough energy
to get over the top of the wall.
151
511933
3577
08:47
In the quantum world,
you don't have to throw it over the wall,
152
515534
3058
08:50
you can throw it at the wall,
and there's a certain non-zero probability
153
518616
3407
08:54
that it'll disappear on your side,
and reappear on the other.
154
522047
3323
08:57
This isn't speculation, by the way.
155
525394
1678
08:59
We're happy -- well, "happy"
is not the right word --
156
527096
3396
09:02
(Laughter)
157
530516
2045
09:04
we are familiar with this.
158
532585
1618
09:06
(Laughter)
159
534227
2745
09:08
Quantum tunneling
takes place all the time;
160
536996
2294
09:11
in fact, it's the reason our Sun shines.
161
539314
2667
09:14
The particles fuse together,
162
542655
1509
09:16
and the Sun turns hydrogen
into helium through quantum tunneling.
163
544188
3698
09:21
Back in the 70s and 80s, it was discovered
that quantum tunneling also takes place
164
549464
5220
09:26
inside living cells.
165
554708
1192
09:28
Enzymes, those workhorses of life,
the catalysts of chemical reactions --
166
556290
6266
09:34
enzymes are biomolecules that speed up
chemical reactions in living cells,
167
562580
4166
09:38
by many, many orders of magnitude.
168
566770
1703
09:40
And it's always been a mystery
how they do this.
169
568497
2784
09:43
Well, it was discovered
170
571650
1189
09:44
that one of the tricks that enzymes
have evolved to make use of,
171
572863
4852
09:49
is by transferring subatomic particles,
like electrons and indeed protons,
172
577739
5228
09:54
from one part of a molecule
to another via quantum tunneling.
173
582991
4661
10:00
It's efficient, it's fast,
it can disappear --
174
588333
2851
10:03
a proton can disappear from one place,
and reappear on the other.
175
591208
3111
10:06
Enzymes help this take place.
176
594343
1629
10:08
This is research that's been
carried out back in the 80s,
177
596548
2683
10:11
particularly by a group
in Berkeley, Judith Klinman.
178
599255
4037
10:15
Other groups in the UK
have now also confirmed
179
603316
2205
10:17
that enzymes really do this.
180
605545
1411
10:21
Research carried out by my group --
181
609048
2549
10:23
so as I mentioned,
I'm a nuclear physicist,
182
611621
2434
10:26
but I've realized I've got these tools
of using quantum mechanics
183
614079
3055
10:29
in atomic nuclei, and so can apply
those tools in other areas as well.
184
617158
5085
10:35
One question we asked
185
623404
1810
10:37
is whether quantum tunneling
plays a role in mutations in DNA.
186
625238
4298
10:41
Again, this is not a new idea;
it goes all the way back to the early 60s.
187
629843
3660
10:45
The two strands of DNA,
the double-helix structure,
188
633527
2961
10:48
are held together by rungs;
it's like a twisted ladder.
189
636512
2823
10:51
And those rungs of the ladder
are hydrogen bonds --
190
639359
3507
10:54
protons, that act as the glue
between the two strands.
191
642890
3790
10:58
So if you zoom in, what they're doing
is holding these large molecules --
192
646704
4750
11:03
nucleotides -- together.
193
651478
1607
11:06
Zoom in a bit more.
194
654130
1150
11:07
So, this a computer simulation.
195
655304
1916
11:09
The two white balls
in the middle are protons,
196
657855
3542
11:13
and you can see that
it's a double hydrogen bond.
197
661421
2299
11:15
One prefers to sit on one side;
the other, on the other side
198
663744
3314
11:19
of the two strands of the vertical lines
going down, which you can't see.
199
667082
4558
11:24
It can happen that
these two protons can hop over.
200
672410
3395
11:27
Watch the two white balls.
201
675829
1436
11:29
They can jump over to the other side.
202
677748
1998
11:32
If the two strands of DNA then separate,
leading to the process of replication,
203
680239
5646
11:37
and the two protons
are in the wrong positions,
204
685909
3199
11:41
this can lead to a mutation.
205
689132
1763
11:43
This has been known for half a century.
206
691204
1872
11:45
The question is: How likely
are they to do that,
207
693100
2343
11:47
and if they do, how do they do it?
208
695467
2378
11:49
Do they jump across,
like the ball going over the wall?
209
697869
3019
11:52
Or can they quantum-tunnel across,
even if they don't have enough energy?
210
700912
3502
11:57
Early indications suggest that
quantum tunneling can play a role here.
211
705089
4252
12:01
We still don't know yet
how important it is;
212
709365
2124
12:03
this is still an open question.
213
711513
1792
12:06
It's speculative,
214
714199
1150
12:07
but it's one of those questions
that is so important
215
715373
2643
12:10
that if quantum mechanics
plays a role in mutations,
216
718040
2446
12:12
surely this must have big implications,
217
720510
2299
12:14
to understand certain types of mutations,
218
722833
2694
12:17
possibly even those that lead
to turning a cell cancerous.
219
725551
3756
12:22
Another example of quantum mechanics
in biology is quantum coherence,
220
730803
5299
12:28
in one of the most
important processes in biology,
221
736126
2353
12:30
photosynthesis: plants
and bacteria taking sunlight,
222
738503
3941
12:34
and using that energy to create biomass.
223
742468
2954
12:38
Quantum coherence is the idea
of quantum entities multitasking.
224
746215
4152
12:42
It's the quantum skier.
225
750912
1604
12:44
It's an object that behaves like a wave,
226
752540
2952
12:47
so that it doesn't just move
in one direction or the other,
227
755516
2902
12:50
but can follow multiple pathways
at the same time.
228
758442
3320
12:54
Some years ago,
the world of science was shocked
229
762708
3916
12:58
when a paper was published
showing experimental evidence
230
766648
3584
13:02
that quantum coherence
takes place inside bacteria,
231
770256
3776
13:06
carrying out photosynthesis.
232
774056
1686
13:07
The idea is that the photon,
the particle of light, the sunlight,
233
775766
3064
13:10
the quantum of light
captured by a chlorophyll molecule,
234
778854
3344
13:14
is then delivered to what's called
the reaction center,
235
782222
2591
13:16
where it can be turned into
chemical energy.
236
784837
2064
13:18
And in getting there,
it doesn't just follow one route;
237
786925
2648
13:21
it follows multiple pathways at once,
238
789597
2215
13:23
to optimize the most efficient way
of reaching the reaction center
239
791836
4337
13:28
without dissipating as waste heat.
240
796197
1721
13:31
Quantum coherence taking place
inside a living cell.
241
799228
3309
13:34
A remarkable idea,
242
802561
2120
13:36
and yet evidence is growing almost weekly,
with new papers coming out,
243
804705
6235
13:42
confirming that this
does indeed take place.
244
810964
2212
13:45
My third and final example
is the most beautiful, wonderful idea.
245
813555
4739
13:50
It's also still very speculative,
but I have to share it with you.
246
818318
4063
13:54
The European robin
migrates from Scandinavia
247
822405
4612
13:59
down to the Mediterranean, every autumn,
248
827041
2635
14:01
and like a lot of other
marine animals and even insects,
249
829700
3373
14:05
they navigate by sensing
the Earth's magnetic field.
250
833097
4300
14:10
Now, the Earth's magnetic field
is very, very weak;
251
838968
2427
14:13
it's 100 times weaker
than a fridge magnet,
252
841419
2080
14:15
and yet it affects the chemistry --
somehow -- within a living organism.
253
843523
5601
14:21
That's not in doubt --
a German couple of ornithologists,
254
849932
3806
14:25
Wolfgang and Roswitha Wiltschko,
in the 1970s, confirmed that indeed,
255
853762
4260
14:30
the robin does find its way by somehow
sensing the Earth's magnetic field,
256
858046
3977
14:34
to give it directional information --
a built-in compass.
257
862047
3327
14:37
The puzzle, the mystery was:
How does it do it?
258
865398
2249
14:40
Well, the only theory in town --
259
868351
3030
14:43
we don't know if it's the correct theory,
but the only theory in town --
260
871405
3436
14:46
is that it does it via something
called quantum entanglement.
261
874865
2984
14:50
Inside the robin's retina --
262
878567
2374
14:52
I kid you not -- inside the robin's retina
is a protein called cryptochrome,
263
880965
4232
14:57
which is light-sensitive.
264
885221
1380
14:58
Within cryptochrome, a pair of electrons
are quantum-entangled.
265
886625
3939
15:02
Now, quantum entanglement
is when two particles are far apart,
266
890588
3232
15:05
and yet somehow remain
in contact with each other.
267
893844
2834
15:08
Even Einstein hated this idea;
268
896991
1446
15:10
he called it "spooky action
at a distance."
269
898461
2039
15:12
(Laughter)
270
900524
1881
15:14
So if Einstein doesn't like it,
then we can all be uncomfortable with it.
271
902429
3443
15:17
Two quantum-entangled electrons
within a single molecule
272
905896
2853
15:20
dance a delicate dance
273
908773
1471
15:22
that is very sensitive
to the direction the bird flies
274
910268
2541
15:24
in the Earth's magnetic field.
275
912833
1531
15:26
We don't know if it's
the correct explanation,
276
914848
2610
15:29
but wow, wouldn't it be exciting
if quantum mechanics helps birds navigate?
277
917482
4544
15:35
Quantum biology is still in it infancy.
278
923069
2721
15:37
It's still speculative.
279
925814
3484
15:41
But I believe it's built on solid science.
280
929742
3849
15:45
I also think that
in the coming decade or so,
281
933917
3809
15:49
we're going to start to see
that actually, it pervades life --
282
937750
4841
15:54
that life has evolved tricks
that utilize the quantum world.
283
942615
4596
16:00
Watch this space.
284
948026
1428
16:01
Thank you.
285
949478
1157
16:02
(Applause)
286
950659
2202

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jim Al-Khalili - Quantum physicist
Physicist Jim Al-Khalili and co-author Johnjoe McFadden, a biologist, explore the far edges of quantum biology in their book "Life on the Edge."

Why you should listen
A professor of physics at the University of Surrey, Jim Al-Khalili doubles as a science communicator and broadcaster. He’s the co-author with Johnjoe McFadden of Life on the Edge: The Coming of Age of Quantum Biology. The book explores this emerging -- and still largely speculative -- area of science suggesting that quantum mechanics may play a role in biology. If so, it may help us understand what drives genetic mutations that lead to cancer, or how robins fly from Scandinavia to the Mediterranean.
More profile about the speaker
Jim Al-Khalili | Speaker | TED.com