ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alexander Betts - Social scientist
Alexander Betts explores ways societies might empower refugees rather than pushing them to the margins.

Why you should listen

In media and in public debate, refugees are routinely portrayed as a burden. Professor Alexander Betts argues that refugees, who represent a wide spectrum of professional backgrounds, are in fact an untapped resource that could benefit nations willing to welcome them into their economies. 

Betts is the director of the Refugee Studies Centre at the University of Oxford, where he spearheads research on refugee and other forced migrant populations. His book, Survival Migration, explores the predicaments of people who are fleeing disaster yet fall outside legal definitions of refugee status.

More profile about the speaker
Alexander Betts | Speaker | TED.com
TEDSummit

Alexander Betts: Why Brexit happened -- and what to do next

Filmed:
3,574,234 views

We are embarrassingly unaware of how divided our societies are, and Brexit grew out of a deep, unexamined divide between those that fear globalization and those that embrace it, says social scientist Alexander Betts. How do we now address that fear as well as growing disillusionment with the political establishment, while refusing to give in to xenophobia and nationalism? Join Betts as he discusses four post-Brexit steps toward a more inclusive world.
- Social scientist
Alexander Betts explores ways societies might empower refugees rather than pushing them to the margins. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
I am British.
0
1600
1936
00:15
(Laughter)
1
3560
2136
00:17
(Applause)
2
5720
3136
00:20
Never before has the phrase
"I am British" elicited so much pity.
3
8880
3776
00:24
(Laughter)
4
12680
2096
00:26
I come from an island
where many of us like to believe
5
14800
2736
00:29
there's been a lot of continuity
over the last thousand years.
6
17560
3120
00:33
We tend to have historically
imposed change on others
7
21400
2736
00:36
but done much less of it ourselves.
8
24160
2320
00:39
So it came as an immense shock to me
9
27360
2456
00:41
when I woke up on the morning of June 24
10
29840
2776
00:44
to discover that my country
had voted to leave the European Union,
11
32640
3856
00:48
my Prime Minister had resigned,
12
36520
1856
00:50
and Scotland was considering a referendum
13
38400
2576
00:53
that could bring to an end
the very existence of the United Kingdom.
14
41000
4840
00:58
So that was an immense shock for me,
15
46920
2936
01:01
and it was an immense
shock for many people,
16
49880
2280
01:05
but it was also something
that, over the following several days,
17
53080
3456
01:08
created a complete political meltdown
18
56560
2736
01:11
in my country.
19
59320
1456
01:12
There were calls for a second referendum,
20
60800
2216
01:15
almost as if, following a sports match,
21
63040
2536
01:17
we could ask the opposition for a replay.
22
65600
2520
01:20
Everybody was blaming everybody else.
23
68880
2456
01:23
People blamed the Prime Minister
24
71360
1576
01:24
for calling the referendum
in the first place.
25
72960
2176
01:27
They blamed the leader of the opposition
for not fighting it hard enough.
26
75160
3456
01:30
The young accused the old.
27
78640
1256
01:31
The educated blamed
the less well-educated.
28
79920
2880
01:35
That complete meltdown was made even worse
29
83440
3096
01:38
by the most tragic element of it:
30
86560
2096
01:40
levels of xenophobia and racist abuse
in the streets of Britain
31
88680
3856
01:44
at a level that I have never seen before
32
92560
2256
01:46
in my lifetime.
33
94840
1240
01:49
People are now talking about whether
my country is becoming a Little England,
34
97800
4376
01:54
or, as one of my colleagues put it,
35
102200
2096
01:56
whether we're about to become
a 1950s nostalgia theme park
36
104320
4176
02:00
floating in the Atlantic Ocean.
37
108520
2016
02:02
(Laughter)
38
110560
2080
02:05
But my question is really,
39
113840
2536
02:08
should we have the degree of shock
that we've experienced since?
40
116400
4280
02:13
Was it something
that took place overnight?
41
121440
2376
02:15
Or are there deeper structural factors
that have led us to where we are today?
42
123840
4496
02:20
So I want to take a step back
and ask two very basic questions.
43
128360
4576
02:24
First, what does Brexit represent,
44
132960
2896
02:27
not just for my country,
45
135880
1536
02:29
but for all of us around the world?
46
137440
2736
02:32
And second, what can we do about it?
47
140200
3176
02:35
How should we all respond?
48
143400
2336
02:37
So first, what does Brexit represent?
49
145760
2520
02:40
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.
50
148960
2240
02:43
Brexit teaches us many things
about our society
51
151840
4056
02:47
and about societies around the world.
52
155920
2360
02:51
It highlights in ways
that we seem embarrassingly unaware of
53
159400
3216
02:54
how divided our societies are.
54
162640
1720
02:56
The vote split along lines of age,
education, class and geography.
55
164840
6336
03:03
Young people didn't turn out
to vote in great numbers,
56
171200
2896
03:06
but those that did wanted to remain.
57
174120
2216
03:08
Older people really wanted
to leave the European Union.
58
176360
3736
03:12
Geographically, it was London and Scotland
that most strongly committed
59
180120
3496
03:15
to being part of the European Union,
60
183640
2016
03:17
while in other parts of the country
there was very strong ambivalence.
61
185680
4120
03:23
Those divisions are things we really
need to recognize and take seriously.
62
191000
4376
03:27
But more profoundly,
the vote teaches us something
63
195400
2856
03:30
about the nature of politics today.
64
198280
2336
03:32
Contemporary politics
is no longer just about right and left.
65
200640
4256
03:36
It's no longer just about tax and spend.
66
204920
2736
03:39
It's about globalization.
67
207680
1936
03:41
The fault line of contemporary politics is
between those that embrace globalization
68
209640
4816
03:46
and those that fear globalization.
69
214480
3000
03:50
(Applause)
70
218320
2280
03:55
If we look at why
those who wanted to leave --
71
223680
2656
03:58
we call them "Leavers,"
as opposed to "Remainers" --
72
226360
2536
04:00
we see two factors in the opinion polls
73
228920
2216
04:03
that really mattered.
74
231160
1376
04:04
The first was immigration,
and the second sovereignty,
75
232560
3336
04:07
and these represent a desire for people
to take back control of their own lives
76
235920
5456
04:13
and the feeling that they
are unrepresented by politicians.
77
241400
3880
04:18
But those ideas are ones
that signify fear and alienation.
78
246560
5376
04:23
They represent a retreat
back towards nationalism and borders
79
251960
5016
04:29
in ways that many of us would reject.
80
257000
2079
04:31
What I want to suggest is the picture
is more complicated than that,
81
259600
3216
04:34
that liberal internationalists,
82
262840
1536
04:36
like myself, and I firmly
include myself in that picture,
83
264400
3216
04:39
need to write ourselves
back into the picture
84
267640
2536
04:42
in order to understand
how we've got to where we are today.
85
270200
4080
04:47
When we look at the voting patterns
across the United Kingdom,
86
275200
3096
04:50
we can visibly see the divisions.
87
278320
2200
04:53
The blue areas show Remain
88
281240
2336
04:55
and the red areas Leave.
89
283600
2096
04:57
When I looked at this,
90
285720
1256
04:59
what personally struck me
was the very little time in my life
91
287000
3856
05:02
I've actually spent
in many of the red areas.
92
290880
3216
05:06
I suddenly realized that,
looking at the top 50 areas in the UK
93
294120
5136
05:11
that have the strongest Leave vote,
94
299280
1856
05:13
I've spent a combined total
of four days of my life in those areas.
95
301160
5400
05:19
In some of those places,
96
307560
1496
05:21
I didn't even know the names
of the voting districts.
97
309080
3576
05:24
It was a real shock to me,
98
312680
1856
05:26
and it suggested that people like me
99
314560
2056
05:28
who think of ourselves
as inclusive, open and tolerant,
100
316640
4096
05:32
perhaps don't know
our own countries and societies
101
320760
2696
05:35
nearly as well as we like to believe.
102
323480
2616
05:38
(Applause)
103
326120
2880
05:48
And the challenge that comes from that
is we need to find a new way
104
336200
3776
05:52
to narrate globalization to those people,
105
340000
3096
05:55
to recognize that for those people who
have not necessarily been to university,
106
343120
4376
05:59
who haven't necessarily
grown up with the Internet,
107
347520
2416
06:01
that don't get opportunities to travel,
108
349960
2016
06:04
they may be unpersuaded
by the narrative that we find persuasive
109
352000
3856
06:07
in our often liberal bubbles.
110
355880
2200
06:10
(Applause)
111
358520
2520
06:15
It means that we need to reach out
more broadly and understand.
112
363880
3616
06:19
In the Leave vote, a minority have peddled
the politics of fear and hatred,
113
367520
6016
06:25
creating lies and mistrust
114
373560
2496
06:28
around, for instance,
the idea that the vote on Europe
115
376080
2936
06:31
could reduce the number of refugees
and asylum-seekers coming to Europe,
116
379040
4136
06:35
when the vote on leaving
had nothing to do with immigration
117
383200
3256
06:38
from outside the European Union.
118
386480
1960
06:41
But for a significant majority
of the Leave voters
119
389120
3536
06:44
the concern was disillusionment
with the political establishment.
120
392680
3656
06:48
This was a protest vote for many,
121
396360
2176
06:50
a sense that nobody represented them,
122
398560
2456
06:53
that they couldn't find
a political party that spoke for them,
123
401040
3416
06:56
and so they rejected
that political establishment.
124
404480
3240
07:01
This replicates around Europe
and much of the liberal democratic world.
125
409440
5056
07:06
We see it with the rise in popularity
of Donald Trump in the United States,
126
414520
4896
07:11
with the growing nationalism
of Viktor Orbán in Hungary,
127
419440
4056
07:15
with the increase in popularity
of Marine Le Pen in France.
128
423520
4696
07:20
The specter of Brexit
is in all of our societies.
129
428240
3880
07:25
So the question I think we need to ask
is my second question,
130
433080
3016
07:28
which is how should we
collectively respond?
131
436120
2520
07:31
For all of us who care about creating
liberal, open, tolerant societies,
132
439280
5976
07:37
we urgently need a new vision,
133
445280
2656
07:39
a vision of a more tolerant,
inclusive globalization,
134
447960
3696
07:43
one that brings people with us
rather than leaving them behind.
135
451680
3800
07:48
That vision of globalization
136
456640
1936
07:50
is one that has to start by a recognition
of the positive benefits of globalization.
137
458600
4816
07:55
The consensus amongst economists
138
463440
2576
07:58
is that free trade,
the movement of capital,
139
466040
2776
08:00
the movement of people across borders
140
468840
1936
08:02
benefit everyone on aggregate.
141
470800
2736
08:05
The consensus amongst
international relations scholars
142
473560
2696
08:08
is that globalization
brings interdependence,
143
476280
2616
08:10
which brings cooperation and peace.
144
478920
2936
08:13
But globalization
also has redistributive effects.
145
481880
4456
08:18
It creates winners and losers.
146
486360
2736
08:21
To take the example of migration,
147
489120
2136
08:23
we know that immigration is a net positive
for the economy as a whole
148
491280
3656
08:26
under almost all circumstances.
149
494960
2520
08:30
But we also have to be very aware
150
498360
2776
08:33
that there are
redistributive consequences,
151
501160
3056
08:36
that importantly, low-skilled immigration
152
504240
3456
08:39
can lead to a reduction in wages
for the most impoverished in our societies
153
507720
4415
08:44
and also put pressure on house prices.
154
512159
2137
08:46
That doesn't detract
from the fact that it's positive,
155
514320
2536
08:48
but it means more people
have to share in those benefits
156
516880
2895
08:51
and recognize them.
157
519799
1281
08:55
In 2002, the former Secretary-General
of the United Nations, Kofi Annan,
158
523200
4896
09:00
gave a speech at Yale University,
159
528120
2896
09:03
and that speech was on the topic
of inclusive globalization.
160
531040
3976
09:07
That was the speech
in which he coined that term.
161
535040
3056
09:10
And he said, and I paraphrase,
162
538120
2776
09:12
"The glass house of globalization
has to be open to all
163
540920
5336
09:18
if it is to remain secure.
164
546280
2560
09:21
Bigotry and ignorance
165
549280
3256
09:24
are the ugly face of exclusionary
and antagonistic globalization."
166
552560
6576
09:31
That idea of inclusive globalization
was briefly revived in 2008
167
559160
5176
09:36
in a conference on progressive governance
168
564360
2576
09:38
involving many of the leaders
of European countries.
169
566960
3440
09:43
But amid austerity
and the financial crisis of 2008,
170
571160
3976
09:47
the concept disappeared
almost without a trace.
171
575160
3096
09:50
Globalization has been taken
to support a neoliberal agenda.
172
578280
4456
09:54
It's perceived to be
part of an elite agenda
173
582760
2936
09:57
rather than something that benefits all.
174
585720
2576
10:00
And it needs to be reclaimed
on a far more inclusive basis
175
588320
3616
10:03
than it is today.
176
591960
1200
10:05
So the question is,
how can we achieve that goal?
177
593720
3736
10:09
How can we balance on the one hand
addressing fear and alienation
178
597480
4736
10:14
while on the other hand
refusing vehemently
179
602240
3416
10:17
to give in to xenophobia and nationalism?
180
605680
3776
10:21
That is the question for all of us.
181
609480
2136
10:23
And I think, as a social scientist,
182
611640
1816
10:25
that social science
offers some places to start.
183
613480
2800
10:29
Our transformation has to be about
both ideas and about material change,
184
617000
5216
10:34
and I want to give you four ideas
as a starting point.
185
622240
3616
10:37
The first relates to the idea
of civic education.
186
625880
4536
10:42
What stands out from Brexit
187
630440
1776
10:44
is the gap between public perception
and empirical reality.
188
632240
4056
10:48
It's been suggested that we've moved
to a postfactual society,
189
636320
3696
10:52
where evidence and truth no longer matter,
190
640040
2656
10:54
and lies have equal status
to the clarity of evidence.
191
642720
4096
10:58
So how can we --
192
646840
1256
11:00
(Applause)
193
648120
2696
11:02
How can we rebuild respect for truth
and evidence into our liberal democracies?
194
650840
5176
11:08
It has to begin with education,
195
656040
1936
11:10
but it has to start with the recognition
that there are huge gaps.
196
658000
3320
11:14
In 2014, the pollster Ipsos MORI
197
662440
4176
11:18
published a survey
on attitudes to immigration,
198
666640
3296
11:21
and it showed that as numbers
of immigrants increase,
199
669960
4016
11:26
so public concern
with immigration also increases,
200
674000
3216
11:29
although it obviously
didn't unpack causality,
201
677240
2416
11:31
because this could equally be to do
not so much with numbers
202
679680
3136
11:34
but the political
and media narrative around it.
203
682840
2400
11:37
But the same survey also revealed
204
685800
3776
11:41
huge public misinformation
205
689600
2136
11:43
and misunderstanding
about the nature of immigration.
206
691760
3736
11:47
For example, in these attitudes
in the United Kingdom,
207
695520
3216
11:50
the public believed that levels of asylum
208
698760
2736
11:53
were a greater proportion
of immigration than they were,
209
701520
3416
11:56
but they also believed
the levels of educational migration
210
704960
3456
12:00
were far lower as a proportion
of overall migration
211
708440
3096
12:03
than they actually are.
212
711560
1496
12:05
So we have to address this misinformation,
213
713080
2656
12:07
the gap between perception and reality
on key aspects of globalization.
214
715760
4496
12:12
And that can't just be something
that's left to our schools,
215
720280
2816
12:15
although that's important
to begin at an early age.
216
723120
2416
12:17
It has to be about lifelong
civic participation
217
725560
3056
12:20
and public engagement
that we all encourage as societies.
218
728640
4160
12:26
The second thing
that I think is an opportunity
219
734000
2776
12:28
is the idea to encourage more interaction
across diverse communities.
220
736800
4616
12:33
(Applause)
221
741440
2600
12:37
One of the things that stands out
for me very strikingly,
222
745760
2976
12:40
looking at immigration attitudes
in the United Kingdom,
223
748760
2856
12:43
is that ironically,
the regions of my country
224
751640
2776
12:46
that are the most tolerant of immigrants
225
754440
1905
12:48
have the highest numbers of immigrants.
226
756369
2767
12:51
So for instance, London and the Southeast
have the highest numbers of immigrants,
227
759160
4336
12:55
and they are also by far
the most tolerant areas.
228
763520
3136
12:58
It's those areas of the country
that have the lowest levels of immigration
229
766680
3616
13:02
that actually are the most exclusionary
and intolerant towards migrants.
230
770320
4520
13:07
So we need to encourage exchange programs.
231
775400
2336
13:09
We need to ensure that older generations
who maybe can't travel
232
777760
3456
13:13
get access to the Internet.
233
781240
2136
13:15
We need to encourage,
even on a local and national level,
234
783400
2696
13:18
more movement, more participation,
235
786120
1856
13:20
more interaction
with people who we don't know
236
788000
2696
13:22
and whose views we might
not necessarily agree with.
237
790720
2920
13:26
The third thing that I think
is crucial, though,
238
794880
2336
13:29
and this is really fundamental,
239
797240
1776
13:31
is we have to ensure that everybody shares
240
799040
2296
13:33
in the benefits of globalization.
241
801360
2240
13:36
This illustration from the Financial Times
post-Brexit is really striking.
242
804520
4736
13:41
It shows tragically that those people
who voted to leave the European Union
243
809280
3736
13:45
were those who actually
benefited the most materially
244
813040
2816
13:47
from trade with the European Union.
245
815880
2520
13:51
But the problem is
that those people in those areas
246
819080
2536
13:53
didn't perceive themselves
to be beneficiaries.
247
821640
2656
13:56
They didn't believe that they
were actually getting access
248
824320
2776
13:59
to material benefits of increased trade
and increased mobility around the world.
249
827120
5720
14:05
I work on questions
predominantly to do with refugees,
250
833800
3776
14:09
and one of the ideas
I spent a lot of my time preaching,
251
837600
2656
14:12
mainly to developing countries
around the world,
252
840280
2776
14:15
is that in order to encourage
the integration of refugees,
253
843080
3576
14:18
we can't just benefit
the refugee populations,
254
846680
2336
14:21
we also have to address the concerns
of the host communities in local areas.
255
849040
5040
14:27
But in looking at that,
256
855480
1336
14:28
one of the policy prescriptions
is that we have to provide
257
856840
3016
14:31
disproportionately better
education facilities, health facilities,
258
859880
3616
14:35
access to social services
259
863520
1776
14:37
in those regions of high immigration
260
865320
2256
14:39
to address the concerns
of those local populations.
261
867600
2816
14:42
But while we encourage that
around the developing world,
262
870440
2656
14:45
we don't take those lessons home
263
873120
1576
14:46
and incorporate them in our own societies.
264
874720
2840
14:50
Furthermore, if we're going
to really take seriously
265
878520
3016
14:53
the need to ensure people share
in the economic benefits,
266
881560
3336
14:56
our businesses and corporations
need a model of globalization
267
884920
3656
15:00
that recognizes that they, too,
have to take people with them.
268
888600
3600
15:05
The fourth and final idea
I want to put forward
269
893440
3056
15:08
is an idea that we need
more responsible politics.
270
896520
2880
15:12
There's very little
social science evidence
271
900080
3136
15:15
that compares attitudes on globalization.
272
903240
2816
15:18
But from the surveys that do exist,
273
906080
2536
15:20
what we can see is there's huge variation
across different countries
274
908640
4736
15:25
and time periods in those countries
275
913400
2296
15:27
for attitudes and tolerance
276
915720
1376
15:29
of questions like migration
and mobility on the one hand
277
917120
3696
15:32
and free trade on the other.
278
920840
2056
15:34
But one hypothesis that I think emerges
from a cursory look at that data
279
922920
5256
15:40
is the idea that polarized societies
are far less tolerant of globalization.
280
928200
6096
15:46
It's the societies
like Sweden in the past,
281
934320
2816
15:49
like Canada today,
282
937160
1416
15:50
where there is a centrist politics,
283
938600
1816
15:52
where right and left work together,
284
940440
2056
15:54
that we encourage supportive attitudes
towards globalization.
285
942520
4016
15:58
And what we see around the world today
is a tragic polarization,
286
946560
3816
16:02
a failure to have dialogue
between the extremes in politics,
287
950400
3016
16:05
and a gap in terms
of that liberal center ground
288
953440
2776
16:08
that can encourage communication
and a shared understanding.
289
956240
3816
16:12
We might not achieve that today,
290
960080
1616
16:13
but at the very least we have to call
upon our politicians and our media
291
961720
3816
16:17
to drop a language of fear
and be far more tolerant of one another.
292
965560
3776
16:21
(Applause)
293
969360
2880
16:29
These ideas are very tentative,
294
977800
2776
16:32
and that's in part because this needs
to be an inclusive and shared project.
295
980600
4400
16:38
I am still British.
296
986000
2400
16:40
I am still European.
297
988920
2160
16:43
I am still a global citizen.
298
991640
3000
16:47
For those of us who believe
299
995200
2016
16:49
that our identities
are not mutually exclusive,
300
997240
4096
16:53
we have to all work together
301
1001360
3016
16:56
to ensure that globalization
takes everyone with us
302
1004400
3696
17:00
and doesn't leave people behind.
303
1008120
2216
17:02
Only then will we truly reconcile
democracy and globalization.
304
1010360
5576
17:07
Thank you.
305
1015960
1216
17:09
(Applause)
306
1017200
12280

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alexander Betts - Social scientist
Alexander Betts explores ways societies might empower refugees rather than pushing them to the margins.

Why you should listen

In media and in public debate, refugees are routinely portrayed as a burden. Professor Alexander Betts argues that refugees, who represent a wide spectrum of professional backgrounds, are in fact an untapped resource that could benefit nations willing to welcome them into their economies. 

Betts is the director of the Refugee Studies Centre at the University of Oxford, where he spearheads research on refugee and other forced migrant populations. His book, Survival Migration, explores the predicaments of people who are fleeing disaster yet fall outside legal definitions of refugee status.

More profile about the speaker
Alexander Betts | Speaker | TED.com