ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Veerle Provoost - Bioethicist
Veerle Provoost studies genetic and social parenthood in the context of donor conception.

Why you should listen

Veerle Provoost is a professor at the Bioethics Institute Ghent of Ghent University and a member of the Network on Ethics of Families. For her current research she coordinates a team of researchers who work on a study about genetic and social parenthood in the context of donor conception.

Using empirical research methods and Socratic conversation techniques, Provoost studies how professionals and ordinary people reason about health and how they make decisions in health-related contexts. In her courses on empirical research methods for ethics and bioethics, she teaches students how to look beyond mere experiences or general attitudes and to explore the principles and values that guide people's reasoning and decision-making. Her research shows that patients may bring their own sets of principles when making medical decisions, principles that may be very different from what medical staff anticipated and may feature around moral elements that may completely escape the attention of ethicists. For one, the moral reasoning of everyday people is centered more around relationships than around the principles that are at the core of scholarly bioethics.

In her talk TEDxGhent talk, she explains how we can gain valuable insights from families of children conceived with donor sperm and their views about what a family really is. These alternative families teach us what matters most in the decisions we all make for our children, whether or not they are genetically related to us. The parents and children she studied created their own family stories (about how their families were made) in highly diverse but very creative ways. However, some parents thought that they should strictly follow the advice of experts in their communication with their children. Because of that, they discounted their own competence. Based on her research experience, Provoost warns us for the negative effects of problematizing these families. Because no matter what a family looks like, or how it is made, parents should believe in their abilities and their creativity. As they know their families best, they are the real experts in how to find the best way to tell their own family story to their own child.

More profile about the speaker
Veerle Provoost | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxGhent

Veerle Provoost: Do kids think of sperm donors as family?

Filmed:
1,144,738 views

How do we define a parent -- or a family? Bioethicist Veerle Provoost explores these questions in the context of non-traditional families, ones brought together by adoption, second marriages, surrogate mothers and sperm donations. In this talk, she shares stories of how parents and children create their own family narratives.
- Bioethicist
Veerle Provoost studies genetic and social parenthood in the context of donor conception. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
What is a parent?
0
842
2162
00:15
What is a parent?
1
3999
1607
00:19
It's not an easy question.
2
7043
2108
00:21
Today we have adoption,
3
9630
2374
00:24
stepfamilies,
4
12028
1576
00:25
surrogate mothers.
5
13628
1457
00:27
Many parents face tough questions
6
15846
2413
00:31
and tough decisions.
7
19151
1529
00:33
Shall we tell our child
about the sperm donation?
8
21888
3253
00:39
If so, when?
9
27322
1375
00:41
What words to use?
10
29176
1600
00:43
Sperm donors are often referred
to as "biological fathers,"
11
31522
5861
00:49
but should we really
be using the word "father?"
12
37407
2999
00:53
As a philosopher and social scientist,
13
41843
2405
00:56
I have been studying these questions
about the concept of parenthood.
14
44272
4222
01:01
But today, I will talk to you
about what I learned
15
49088
3028
01:04
from talking to parents and children.
16
52140
2140
01:07
I will show you that they know
what matters most in a family,
17
55377
4354
01:11
even though their family
looks a little different.
18
59755
2531
01:15
I will show you their creative ways
of dealing with tough questions.
19
63133
5001
01:21
But I will also show you
the parents' uncertainties.
20
69287
3750
01:27
We interviewed couples
21
75284
1531
01:28
who received fertility treatment
at Ghent University Hospital,
22
76839
3402
01:33
using sperm from a donor.
23
81075
1739
01:35
In this treatment timeline,
24
83183
1567
01:36
you can see two points
at which we conducted interviews.
25
84774
3292
01:40
We included heterosexual couples,
26
88994
2433
01:44
where the man for some reason
did not have good-quality sperm,
27
92055
3872
01:48
and lesbian couples who obviously
needed to find sperm elsewhere.
28
96435
5118
01:54
We also included children.
29
102996
2198
01:58
I wanted to know
30
106878
1483
02:00
how those children define concepts
like parenthood and family.
31
108385
4633
02:06
In fact, that is what I asked them,
32
114150
2801
02:10
only not in that way.
33
118259
1439
02:13
I drew an apple tree instead.
34
121437
2659
02:17
This way, I could ask abstract,
philosophical questions
35
125056
3347
02:20
in a way that did not make them run off.
36
128427
3273
02:25
So as you can see,
37
133332
1652
02:27
the apple tree is empty.
38
135008
1542
02:29
And that illustrates my research approach.
39
137630
2613
02:32
By designing techniques like this,
40
140659
2283
02:34
I can bring as little meaning and content
as possible to the interview,
41
142966
4773
02:40
because I want to hear that from them.
42
148533
2018
02:44
I asked them:
43
152362
1332
02:46
What would your family look like
if it were an apple tree?
44
154738
3090
02:50
And they could take a paper apple
for everyone who, in their view,
45
158739
3750
02:54
was a member of the family,
46
162513
1607
02:56
write a name on it
and hang it wherever they wanted.
47
164144
3174
02:59
And I would ask questions.
48
167342
1570
03:02
Most children started
with a parent or a sibling.
49
170153
3125
03:05
One started with "Boxer,"
50
173806
2164
03:08
the dead dog of his grandparents.
51
176667
2508
03:11
At this point, none of the children
started mentioning the donor.
52
179830
3858
03:16
So, I asked them about their birth story.
53
184465
4338
03:21
I said, "Before you were born,
54
189161
2022
03:23
it was just your mom and dad,
55
191207
2363
03:25
or mom and mommy.
56
193594
1278
03:27
Can you tell me how you came
into the family?"
57
195421
3057
03:31
And they explained.
58
199282
1439
03:33
One said,
59
201602
1206
03:35
"My parents did not have good seeds,
60
203691
2473
03:38
but there are friendly men out there
who have spare seeds.
61
206865
4022
03:43
They bring them to the hospital,
62
211386
1750
03:45
and they put them in a big jar.
63
213160
2214
03:48
My mommy went there,
64
216249
1237
03:49
and she took two from the jar,
65
217510
2571
03:52
one for me and one for my sister.
66
220786
2138
03:55
She put the seeds in her belly --
67
223725
2049
03:58
somehow --
68
226161
1192
04:00
and her belly grew really big,
69
228236
2307
04:02
and there I was."
70
230567
1252
04:05
Hmm.
71
233289
1150
04:08
So only when they started
mentioning the donor,
72
236123
4068
04:12
I asked questions about him,
using their own words.
73
240215
3225
04:15
I said,
74
243926
1399
04:17
"If this would be an apple
for the friendly man with the seeds,
75
245349
4466
04:21
what would you do with it?"
76
249839
1333
04:24
And one boy was thinking out loud,
77
252069
2358
04:26
holding the apple.
78
254451
1368
04:27
And he said,
79
255843
1245
04:29
"I won't put this one
up there with the others.
80
257890
2694
04:33
He's not part of my family.
81
261239
1893
04:36
But I will not put him on the ground.
82
264191
2194
04:38
That's too cold and too hard.
83
266409
1910
04:41
I think he should be in the trunk,
84
269024
2301
04:44
because he made my family possible.
85
272207
2343
04:47
If he would not have done this,
86
275264
1954
04:49
that would really be sad
because my family would not be here,
87
277242
3958
04:53
and I would not be here."
88
281224
1596
04:57
So also, parents
constructed family tales --
89
285845
3528
05:01
tales to tell their children.
90
289397
1757
05:04
One couple explained their insemination
91
292660
3127
05:07
by taking their children to a farm
92
295811
2523
05:11
to watch a vet inseminate cows.
93
299291
2561
05:15
And why not?
94
303656
1371
05:17
It's their way of explaining;
95
305051
2440
05:19
their do-it-yourself
with family narratives.
96
307515
3026
05:22
DIY.
97
310981
1180
05:24
And we had another couple
who made books --
98
312533
2368
05:26
a book for each child.
99
314925
1455
05:28
They were really works of art
100
316752
1522
05:30
containing their thoughts and feelings
throughout the treatment.
101
318298
3476
05:34
They even had the hospital
parking tickets in there.
102
322192
2614
05:37
So it is DIY:
103
325553
1621
05:39
finding ways, words and images
104
327198
2382
05:41
to tell your family story to your child.
105
329604
2750
05:45
And these stories were highly diverse,
106
333717
2815
05:48
but they all had one thing in common:
107
336940
2936
05:53
it was a tale of longing for a child
108
341913
3221
05:57
and a quest for that child.
109
345885
1678
06:00
It was about how special
and how deeply loved their child was.
110
348370
5067
06:07
And research so far shows
that these children are doing fine.
111
355142
4648
06:11
They do not have
more problems than other kids.
112
359814
2594
06:14
Yet, these parents also wanted
to justify their decisions
113
362854
4421
06:19
through the tales they tell.
114
367299
1662
06:21
They hoped that their children
would understand their reasons
115
369505
3134
06:24
for making the family in this way.
116
372663
1835
06:27
Underlying was a fear
that their children might disapprove
117
375865
3954
06:31
and would reject the non-genetic parent.
118
379843
2242
06:34
And that fear is understandable,
119
382511
2620
06:37
because we live in a very heteronormative
120
385155
3041
06:40
and geneticized society --
121
388220
1738
06:42
a world that still believes
122
390438
1492
06:43
that true families consist
of one mom, one dad
123
391954
4152
06:48
and their genetically related children.
124
396130
2337
06:51
Well.
125
399738
1155
06:54
I want to tell you about a teenage boy.
126
402165
3101
06:57
He was donor-conceived
but not part of our study.
127
405290
2769
07:00
One day, he had an argument
with his father,
128
408658
2618
07:03
and he yelled,
129
411300
1292
07:05
"You're telling me what to do?
130
413305
2097
07:07
You're not even my father!"
131
415426
1881
07:11
That was exactly what
the parents in our study feared.
132
419601
3382
07:15
Now, the boy soon felt sorry,
and they made up.
133
423984
3229
07:19
But it is the reaction of his father
that is most interesting.
134
427629
3771
07:24
He said,
135
432169
1173
07:25
"This outburst had nothing to do
with the lack of a genetic link.
136
433772
5362
07:31
It was about puberty --
137
439765
2877
07:35
being difficult.
138
443005
1441
07:36
It's what they do at that age.
139
444470
1763
07:38
It will pass."
140
446792
1274
07:41
What this man shows us
141
449462
1856
07:43
is that when something goes wrong,
142
451342
2588
07:46
we should not immediately think
143
454564
1601
07:48
it is because the family
is a little different.
144
456189
2407
07:51
These things happen in all families.
145
459330
3086
07:55
And every now and then,
146
463936
1490
07:57
all parents may wonder:
147
465818
1677
08:00
Am I a good enough parent?
148
468412
2029
08:03
These parents, too.
149
471164
1324
08:05
They, above all, wanted to do
what's best for their child.
150
473099
4093
08:09
But they also sometimes wondered:
151
477748
1895
08:12
Am I a real parent?
152
480034
1776
08:14
And their uncertainties were present
long before they even were parents.
153
482288
3969
08:18
At the start of treatment,
154
486281
1432
08:19
when they first saw the counselor,
155
487737
1715
08:22
they paid close attention
to the counselor,
156
490146
2695
08:24
because they wanted to do it right.
157
492865
2007
08:27
Even 10 years later,
158
495853
1478
08:30
they still remember
the advice they were given.
159
498053
2619
08:36
So when they thought about the counselor
160
504981
2901
08:40
and the advice they were given,
161
508854
1799
08:42
we discussed that.
162
510677
1163
08:43
And we saw one lesbian couple who said,
163
511864
3564
08:48
"When our son asks us,
164
516627
1604
08:50
'Do I have a dad?'
165
518255
2049
08:53
we will say 'No, you do not have a dad.'
166
521482
2812
08:56
But we will say nothing more,
not unless he asks,
167
524839
3068
09:00
because he might not be ready for that.
168
528287
2028
09:02
The counselor said so."
169
530339
1500
09:05
Well.
170
533350
1170
09:07
I don't know; that's quite different
171
535091
1902
09:09
from how we respond
to children's questions.
172
537017
2693
09:12
Like, "Milk -- is that made in a factory?"
173
540473
2801
09:15
We will say, "No, it comes from cows,"
174
543783
3162
09:18
and we will talk about the farmer,
175
546969
1756
09:20
and the way the milk ends up in the shop.
176
548749
2223
09:23
We will not say,
177
551806
1547
09:26
"No, milk is not made in a factory."
178
554102
3608
09:32
So something strange happened here,
179
560042
2430
09:34
and of course these children noticed that.
180
562496
2358
09:37
One boy said,
181
565571
1285
09:39
"I asked my parents loads of questions,
182
567445
2392
09:41
but they acted really weird.
183
569861
1809
09:44
So, you know, I have a friend at school,
and she's made in the same way.
184
572788
3944
09:49
When I have a question,
I just go and ask her."
185
577241
3000
09:53
Clever guy.
186
581760
1208
09:55
Problem solved.
187
583630
1297
09:57
But his parents did not notice,
188
585765
2584
10:00
and it certainly was not
what they had in mind,
189
588875
2582
10:03
nor what the counselor had in mind
190
591481
1934
10:05
when they were saying how important
it is to be an open-communication family.
191
593439
5197
10:12
And that's the strange thing about advice.
192
600462
2254
10:14
When we offer people pills,
we gather evidence first.
193
602740
3296
10:18
We do tests,
194
606536
1256
10:19
we do follow-up studies.
195
607816
1301
10:21
We want to know, and rightly so,
what this pill is doing
196
609141
3927
10:25
and how it affects people's lives.
197
613092
2496
10:28
And advice?
198
616035
1321
10:30
It is not enough for advice,
199
618748
1846
10:32
or for professionals to give advice
that is theoretically sound,
200
620618
4823
10:37
or well-meant.
201
625465
1301
10:39
It should be advice
that there is evidence for --
202
627447
3381
10:42
evidence that it actually
improves patients' lives.
203
630852
3901
10:48
So the philosopher in me
would now like to offer you a paradox:
204
636174
4563
10:54
I advise you to stop following advice.
205
642308
4084
10:59
But, yes.
206
647897
1392
11:02
(Applause)
207
650221
2917
11:06
I will not end here with what went wrong;
208
654591
2563
11:09
I would not be doing justice
to the warmth we found in those families.
209
657178
4236
11:14
Remember the books
and the trip to the farmer?
210
662931
2630
11:17
When parents do things that work for them,
211
665585
3614
11:21
they do brilliant things.
212
669572
1573
11:24
What I want you to remember
as members of families,
213
672391
3643
11:28
in no matter what form or shape,
214
676058
2491
11:30
is that what families need
are warm relationships.
215
678930
5347
11:37
And we do not need to be
professionals to create those.
216
685409
3461
11:41
Most of us do just fine,
217
689644
2302
11:44
although it may be hard work,
218
692986
1709
11:47
and from time to time,
we can do with some advice.
219
695038
2870
11:51
In that case,
220
699209
1271
11:52
bear in mind three things.
221
700504
2023
11:55
Work with advice
that works for your family.
222
703760
3287
12:00
Remember -- you're the expert,
because you live your family life.
223
708008
5478
12:06
And finally,
224
714681
1284
12:08
believe in your abilities
and your creativity,
225
716478
3990
12:13
because you can do it yourself.
226
721027
3345
12:17
Thank you.
227
725259
1154
12:18
(Applause)
228
726437
6478

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Veerle Provoost - Bioethicist
Veerle Provoost studies genetic and social parenthood in the context of donor conception.

Why you should listen

Veerle Provoost is a professor at the Bioethics Institute Ghent of Ghent University and a member of the Network on Ethics of Families. For her current research she coordinates a team of researchers who work on a study about genetic and social parenthood in the context of donor conception.

Using empirical research methods and Socratic conversation techniques, Provoost studies how professionals and ordinary people reason about health and how they make decisions in health-related contexts. In her courses on empirical research methods for ethics and bioethics, she teaches students how to look beyond mere experiences or general attitudes and to explore the principles and values that guide people's reasoning and decision-making. Her research shows that patients may bring their own sets of principles when making medical decisions, principles that may be very different from what medical staff anticipated and may feature around moral elements that may completely escape the attention of ethicists. For one, the moral reasoning of everyday people is centered more around relationships than around the principles that are at the core of scholarly bioethics.

In her talk TEDxGhent talk, she explains how we can gain valuable insights from families of children conceived with donor sperm and their views about what a family really is. These alternative families teach us what matters most in the decisions we all make for our children, whether or not they are genetically related to us. The parents and children she studied created their own family stories (about how their families were made) in highly diverse but very creative ways. However, some parents thought that they should strictly follow the advice of experts in their communication with their children. Because of that, they discounted their own competence. Based on her research experience, Provoost warns us for the negative effects of problematizing these families. Because no matter what a family looks like, or how it is made, parents should believe in their abilities and their creativity. As they know their families best, they are the real experts in how to find the best way to tell their own family story to their own child.

More profile about the speaker
Veerle Provoost | Speaker | TED.com