ABOUT THE SPEAKER
David Casarett - Physician
David Casarett asks: What if mainstream health care operated more like a medical marijuana dispensary?

Why you should listen

In his third book, Stoned: A Doctor's Case for Medical Marijuana, palliative care physician David Casarett takes a first-person investigative journalist's approach to making sense of marijuana's therapeutic potential and adverse effects. He shares what he's learned about this chronically misunderstood drug -- including the control it gives patients over their health and the educational atmosphere of dispensaries -- and outlines what we still need to do to explore its potential health benefits.

Casarett is a professor of medicine at the Duke University School of Medicine and chief of palliative care for the Duke Health System. He is the author of more than 100 journal articles, numerous magazine articles, and Shocked, another nonfiction book about the science of resuscitation. Casarett's first novel in the Ethical Chiang Mai Detective Agency series, Murder at the House of Rooster Happiness, was published in September 2016. The next installment, The Missing Guests of the Magic Grove Hotel, will be published in the fall of 2017.

More profile about the speaker
David Casarett | Speaker | TED.com
TEDMED 2016

David Casarett: A doctor's case for medical marijuana

Filmed:
2,801,315 views

Physician David Casarett was tired of hearing hype and half-truths around medical marijuana, so he put on his skeptic's hat and investigated on his own. He comes back with a fascinating report on what we know and what we don't -- and what mainstream medicine could learn from the modern medical marijuana dispensary.
- Physician
David Casarett asks: What if mainstream health care operated more like a medical marijuana dispensary? Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
I would like to tell you
about the most embarrassing thing
0
1600
3816
00:17
that has ever happened to me in my years
of working as a palliative care physician.
1
5440
4800
00:22
This happened a couple of years ago.
2
10840
1736
00:24
I was asked as a consultant
to see a woman in her 70s --
3
12600
3936
00:28
retired English professor
who had pancreatic cancer.
4
16560
3896
00:32
I was asked to see her because
she had pain, nausea, vomiting ...
5
20480
4520
00:37
When I went to see her,
we talked about those symptoms
6
25920
2656
00:40
and in the course of that consultation,
7
28600
1896
00:42
she asked me whether I thought
that medical marijuana might help her.
8
30520
4720
00:48
I thought back to everything
9
36560
2096
00:50
that I had learned in medical school
about medical marijuana,
10
38680
3336
00:54
which didn't take very long
because I had learned absolutely nothing.
11
42040
3840
00:58
And so I told her that as far as I knew,
12
46760
2856
01:01
medical marijuana
had no benefits whatsoever.
13
49640
3456
01:05
And she smiled and nodded and reached
into the handbag next to the bed,
14
53120
4656
01:09
and pulled out a stack of about a dozen
randomized controlled trials
15
57800
4016
01:13
showing that medical
marijuana has benefits
16
61840
2655
01:16
for symptoms like nausea
and pain and anxiety.
17
64519
4257
01:20
She handed me those articles and said,
18
68800
2896
01:23
"Maybe you should read these
before offering an opinion ...
19
71720
4280
01:28
doctor."
20
76880
1216
01:30
(Laughter)
21
78120
1216
01:31
So I did.
22
79360
1856
01:33
That night I read all of those articles
and found a bunch more.
23
81240
3496
01:36
When I came to see her the next morning,
24
84760
2136
01:38
I had to admit that it looks like
there is some evidence
25
86920
3736
01:42
that marijuana can offer medical benefits
26
90680
3336
01:46
and I suggested that if she
really was interested,
27
94040
3656
01:49
she should try it.
28
97720
1520
01:51
You know what she said?
29
99800
1200
01:54
This 73-year-old,
retired English professor?
30
102160
3440
01:58
She said, "I did try it
about six months ago.
31
106200
2416
02:00
It was amazing.
32
108640
1536
02:02
I've been using it every day since.
33
110200
2696
02:04
It's the best drug I've discovered.
34
112920
2256
02:07
I don't know why it took me 73 years
to discover this stuff. It's amazing."
35
115200
4136
02:11
(Laughter)
36
119360
1016
02:12
That was the moment at which I realized
37
120400
2136
02:14
I needed to learn something
about medical marijuana
38
122560
3256
02:17
because what I was prepared for
in medical school
39
125840
2856
02:20
bore no relationship to reality.
40
128720
2440
02:23
So I started reading more articles,
I started talking to researchers,
41
131960
3496
02:27
I started talking to doctors,
42
135480
1416
02:28
and most importantly,
I started listening to patients.
43
136920
2760
02:32
I ended up writing a book
based on those conversations,
44
140360
2776
02:35
and that book really revolved
around three surprises --
45
143160
3096
02:38
surprises to me, anyway.
46
146280
1976
02:40
One I already alluded to --
47
148280
1536
02:41
that there really are some benefits
to medical marijuana.
48
149840
3136
02:45
Those benefits may not be
as huge or as stunning
49
153000
3736
02:48
as some of the most avid proponents
of medical marijuana
50
156760
2936
02:51
would have us believe,
51
159720
1216
02:52
but they are real.
52
160960
1280
02:54
Surprise number two:
53
162920
1416
02:56
medical marijuana does have some risks.
54
164360
2696
02:59
Those risks may not be
as huge and as scary
55
167080
3016
03:02
as some of the opponents of medical
marijuana would have us believe,
56
170120
3336
03:05
but they are real risks, nonetheless.
57
173480
2400
03:08
But it was the third surprise
that was most ...
58
176440
2456
03:10
surprising.
59
178920
1456
03:12
And that is that a lot
of the patients I talked with
60
180400
3016
03:15
who've turned to medical
marijuana for help,
61
183440
2696
03:18
weren't turning to medical marijuana
because of its benefits
62
186160
2936
03:21
or the balance of risks and benefits,
63
189120
2016
03:23
or because they thought
it was a wonder drug,
64
191160
2376
03:25
but because it gave them
control over their illness.
65
193560
3736
03:29
It let them manage their health
66
197320
2176
03:31
in a way that was productive and efficient
67
199520
3176
03:34
and effective and comfortable for them.
68
202720
2560
03:38
To show you what I mean,
let me tell you about another patient.
69
206200
2976
03:41
Robin was in her early 40s when I met her.
70
209200
2176
03:43
She looked though
like she was in her late 60s.
71
211400
3376
03:46
She had suffered from rheumatoid arthritis
for the last 20 years,
72
214800
3256
03:50
her hands were gnarled by arthritis,
73
218080
2416
03:52
her spine was crooked,
74
220520
1736
03:54
she had to rely
on a wheelchair to get around.
75
222280
2616
03:56
She looked weak and frail,
76
224920
1616
03:58
and I guess physically she probably was,
77
226560
2256
04:00
but emotionally,
cognitively, psychologically,
78
228840
2976
04:03
she was among the toughest
people I've ever met.
79
231840
3680
04:08
And when I sat down next to her
80
236240
1496
04:09
in a medical marijuana dispensary
in Northern California
81
237760
2656
04:12
to ask her about why she turned
to medical marijuana,
82
240440
3416
04:15
what it did for her and how it helped her,
83
243880
2976
04:18
she started out by telling me things
84
246880
1736
04:20
that I had heard
from many patients before.
85
248640
2016
04:22
It helped with her anxiety;
86
250680
1976
04:24
it helped with her pain;
87
252680
1376
04:26
when her pain was better,
she slept better.
88
254080
2056
04:28
And I'd heard all that before.
89
256160
1456
04:29
But then she said something
that I'd never heard before,
90
257640
2656
04:32
and that is that it gave her
control over her life
91
260320
3776
04:36
and over her health.
92
264120
1696
04:37
She could use it when she wanted,
93
265840
2096
04:39
in the way that she wanted,
94
267960
1416
04:41
at the dose and frequency
that worked for her.
95
269400
2416
04:43
And if it didn't work for her,
then she could make changes.
96
271840
3376
04:47
Everything was up to her.
97
275240
1416
04:48
The most important thing she said
98
276680
1696
04:50
was she didn't need
anybody else's permission --
99
278400
2656
04:53
not a clinic appointment,
not a doctor's prescription,
100
281080
2616
04:55
not a pharmacist's order.
101
283720
1536
04:57
It was all up to her.
102
285280
1896
04:59
She was in control.
103
287200
1800
05:01
And if that seems like a little thing
for somebody with chronic illness,
104
289800
3416
05:05
it's not -- not at all.
105
293240
1200
05:07
When we face a chronic serious illness,
106
295280
2176
05:09
whether it's rheumatoid arthritis
or lupus or cancer or diabetes,
107
297480
5296
05:14
or cirrhosis,
108
302800
1496
05:16
we lose control.
109
304320
1816
05:18
And note what I said: "when," not "if."
110
306160
2536
05:20
All of us at some point in our lives
will face a chronic serious illness
111
308720
4256
05:25
that causes us to lose control.
112
313000
2496
05:27
We'll see our function decline,
some of us will see our cognition decline,
113
315520
3856
05:31
we'll be no longer able
to care for ourselves,
114
319400
2656
05:34
to do the things that we want to do.
115
322080
2256
05:36
Our bodies will betray us,
116
324360
2096
05:38
and in that process, we'll lose control.
117
326480
2576
05:41
And that's scary.
118
329080
1896
05:43
Not just scary -- that's frightening,
119
331000
2136
05:45
it's terrifying.
120
333160
1576
05:46
When I talk to my patients,
my palliative care patients,
121
334760
2656
05:49
many of whom are facing illnesses
that will end their lives,
122
337440
3896
05:53
they have a lot of be frightened of --
123
341360
2056
05:55
pain, nausea, vomiting,
constipation, fatigue,
124
343440
3616
05:59
their impending mortality.
125
347080
1296
06:00
But what scares them
more than anything else
126
348400
2576
06:03
is this possibility that at some point,
127
351000
2176
06:05
tomorrow or a month from now,
128
353200
2176
06:07
they're going to lose
control of their health,
129
355400
3136
06:10
of their lives,
130
358560
1616
06:12
of their healthcare,
131
360200
1376
06:13
and they're going to become
dependent on others,
132
361600
2496
06:16
and that's terrifying.
133
364120
1880
06:18
So it's no wonder really
that patients like Robin,
134
366720
3536
06:22
who I just told you about,
135
370280
2016
06:24
who I met in that clinic,
136
372320
1416
06:25
turn to medical marijuana
137
373760
1536
06:27
to try to claw back
some semblance of control.
138
375320
3456
06:30
How do they do it though?
139
378800
1256
06:32
How do these medical
marijuana dispensaries --
140
380080
2656
06:34
like the one where I met Robin --
141
382760
1976
06:36
how do they give patients like Robin
back the sort of control that they need?
142
384760
6696
06:43
And how do they do it
143
391480
1296
06:44
in a way that mainstream
medical hospitals and clinics,
144
392800
4056
06:48
at least for Robin, weren't able to?
145
396880
2336
06:51
What's their secret?
146
399240
1816
06:53
So I decided to find out.
147
401080
2656
06:55
I went to a seedy clinic
in Venice Beach in California
148
403760
4136
06:59
and got a recommendation
149
407920
1296
07:01
that would allow me
to be a medical marijuana patient.
150
409240
3536
07:04
I got a letter of recommendation
that would let me buy medical marijuana.
151
412800
4016
07:08
I got that recommendation illegally,
152
416840
1816
07:10
because I'm not
a resident of California --
153
418680
2056
07:12
I should note that.
154
420760
1216
07:14
I should also note, for the record,
155
422000
1736
07:15
that I never used that letter
of recommendation to make a purchase,
156
423760
3536
07:19
and to all of you DEA agents out there --
157
427320
2696
07:22
(Laughter)
158
430040
1216
07:23
love the work that you're doing,
159
431280
1576
07:24
keep it up.
160
432880
1216
07:26
(Laughter)
161
434120
1016
07:27
Even though it didn't let me
make a purchase though,
162
435160
2429
07:30
that letter was priceless
because it let me be a patient.
163
438440
3856
07:34
It let me experience
what patients like Robin experience
164
442320
4216
07:38
when they go to a medical
marijuana dispensary.
165
446560
3016
07:41
And what I experienced --
166
449600
1416
07:43
what they experience every day,
167
451040
2216
07:45
hundreds of thousands
of people like Robin --
168
453280
3456
07:48
was really amazing.
169
456760
2216
07:51
I walked into the clinic,
170
459000
1256
07:52
and from the moment that I entered
many of these clinics and dispensaries,
171
460280
3656
07:55
I felt like that dispensary, that clinic,
172
463960
2576
07:58
was there for me.
173
466560
1640
08:00
There were questions
at the outset about who I am,
174
468880
2896
08:03
what kind of work I do,
175
471800
1856
08:05
what my goals are in looking
for a medical marijuana prescription,
176
473680
4056
08:09
or product,
177
477760
2816
08:12
what my goals are,
what my preferences are,
178
480600
2376
08:15
what my hopes are,
179
483000
1256
08:16
how do I think, how do I hope
this might help me,
180
484280
2656
08:18
what am I afraid of.
181
486960
1616
08:20
These are the sorts of questions
182
488600
1576
08:22
that patients like Robin
get asked all the time.
183
490200
2456
08:24
These are the sorts of questions
that make me confident
184
492680
2936
08:27
that the person I'm talking with
really has my best interests at heart
185
495640
3656
08:31
and wants to get to know me.
186
499320
1680
08:34
The second thing I learned
in those clinics
187
502200
2696
08:36
is the availability of education.
188
504920
2176
08:39
Education from the folks
behind the counter,
189
507120
2816
08:41
but also education
from folks in the waiting room.
190
509960
3216
08:45
People I met were more than happy,
as I was sitting next to them --
191
513200
3536
08:48
people like Robin --
192
516760
1255
08:50
to tell me about who they are,
why they use medical marijuana,
193
518039
3777
08:53
what helps them, how it helps them,
194
521840
2216
08:56
and to give me advice and suggestions.
195
524080
1936
08:58
Those waiting rooms really are
a hive of interaction, advice and support.
196
526040
5640
09:04
And third, the folks behind the counter.
197
532640
2256
09:06
I was amazed at how willing
those people were
198
534920
3376
09:10
to spend sometimes an hour or more
talking me through the nuances
199
538320
4536
09:14
of this strain versus that strain,
200
542880
2056
09:16
smoking versus vaporizing,
201
544960
1696
09:18
edibles versus tinctures --
202
546680
1736
09:20
all, remember, without me
making any purchase whatsoever.
203
548440
3760
09:25
Think about the last time
you went to any hospital or clinic
204
553240
3816
09:29
and the last time anybody spent an hour
explaining those sorts of things to you.
205
557080
4800
09:34
The fact that patients like Robin
are going to these clinics,
206
562680
3616
09:38
are going to these dispensaries
207
566320
1576
09:39
and getting that sort
of personalized attention
208
567920
2936
09:42
and education and service,
209
570880
1856
09:44
really should be a wake-up call
to the healthcare system.
210
572760
3416
09:48
People like Robin are turning away
from mainstream medicine,
211
576200
2976
09:51
turning to medical marijuana dispensaries
212
579200
2336
09:53
because those dispensaries
are giving them what they need.
213
581560
3880
09:58
If that's a wake-up call
to the medical establishment,
214
586440
2576
10:01
it's a wake-up call that many
of my colleagues are either not hearing
215
589040
3776
10:04
or not wanting to hear.
216
592840
1720
10:07
When I talk to my colleagues,
physicians in particular,
217
595240
2736
10:10
about medical marijuana,
218
598000
1336
10:11
they say, "Oh, we need more evidence.
219
599360
2656
10:14
We need more research into benefits,
we need more evidence about risks."
220
602040
3960
10:18
And you know what? They're right.
221
606600
1856
10:20
They're absolutely right.
222
608480
1256
10:21
We do need much more evidence
about the benefits of medical marijuana.
223
609760
4176
10:25
We also need to ask the federal government
to reschedule marijuana to Schedule II,
224
613960
5376
10:31
or to deschedule it entirely
to make that research possible.
225
619360
3560
10:35
We also need more research
into medical marijuana's risks.
226
623760
3656
10:39
Medical marijuana's risks --
227
627440
1376
10:40
we know a lot about
the risks of recreational use,
228
628840
2376
10:43
we know next to nothing
about the risks of medical marijuana.
229
631240
2896
10:46
So we absolutely do need research,
230
634160
2576
10:48
but to say that we need research
231
636760
2336
10:51
and not that we need
to make any changes now
232
639120
3056
10:54
is to miss the point entirely.
233
642200
1936
10:56
People like Robin
aren't seeking out medical marijuana
234
644160
2576
10:58
because they think it's a wonder drug,
235
646760
1856
11:00
or because they think
it's entirely risk-free.
236
648640
2736
11:03
They seek it out because the context
in which it's delivered and administered
237
651400
4656
11:08
and used,
238
656080
1216
11:09
gives them the sort of control
they need over their lives.
239
657320
3536
11:12
And that's a wake-up call
we really need to pay attention to.
240
660880
3040
11:17
The good news though is that
there are lessons we can learn today
241
665040
3736
11:20
from those medical marijuana dispensaries.
242
668800
2976
11:23
And those are lessons
we really should learn.
243
671800
2136
11:25
These are often small,
mom-and-pop operations
244
673960
2736
11:28
run by people with no medical training.
245
676720
2456
11:31
And while it's embarrassing to think
246
679200
2576
11:33
that many of these clinics
and dispensaries are providing services
247
681800
4056
11:37
and support and meeting patients' needs
248
685880
2376
11:40
in ways that billion-dollar
healthcare systems aren't --
249
688280
4016
11:44
we should be embarrassed by that --
250
692320
1696
11:46
but we can also learn from that.
251
694040
1896
11:47
And there are probably
three lessons at least
252
695960
2136
11:50
that we can learn
from those small dispensaries.
253
698120
2240
11:52
One: we need to find ways
to give patients more control
254
700840
3656
11:56
in small but important ways.
255
704520
2016
11:58
How to interact with healthcare providers,
256
706560
2056
12:00
when to interact
with healthcare providers,
257
708640
2176
12:02
how to use medications
in ways that work for them.
258
710840
3616
12:06
In my own practice,
259
714480
1216
12:07
I've gotten much more
creative and flexible
260
715720
2736
12:10
in supporting my patients
in using drugs safely
261
718480
3136
12:13
to manage their symptoms --
262
721640
1496
12:15
with the emphasis on safely.
263
723160
1376
12:16
Many of the drugs I prescribe
are drugs like opioids or benzodiazepines
264
724560
4456
12:21
which can be dangerous if overused.
265
729040
2776
12:23
But here's the point.
266
731840
1216
12:25
They can be dangerous if they're overused,
267
733080
2056
12:27
but they can also be ineffective
if they're not used in a way
268
735160
2896
12:30
that's consistent with
what patients want and need.
269
738080
2656
12:32
So that flexibility,
if it's delivered safely,
270
740760
3216
12:36
can be extraordinarily valuable
for patients and their families.
271
744000
3096
12:39
That's number one.
272
747120
1216
12:40
Number two: education.
273
748360
2016
12:42
Huge opportunities
274
750400
1216
12:43
to learn from some of the tricks
of those medical marijuana dispensaries
275
751640
3456
12:47
to provide more education
276
755120
1376
12:48
that doesn't require
a lot of physician time necessarily,
277
756520
2736
12:51
or any physician time,
278
759280
1736
12:53
but opportunities to learn
about what medications we're using
279
761040
4376
12:57
and why,
280
765440
1216
12:58
prognoses, trajectories of illness,
281
766680
2056
13:00
and most importantly,
282
768760
1216
13:02
opportunities for patients
to learn from each other.
283
770000
2736
13:04
How can we replicate what goes on
284
772760
1936
13:06
in those clinic and medical
dispensary waiting rooms?
285
774720
3416
13:10
How patients learn from each other,
how people share with each other.
286
778160
3680
13:14
And last but not least,
287
782480
1376
13:15
putting patients first the way
those medical marijuana dispensaries do,
288
783880
4056
13:19
making patients feel
legitimately like what they want,
289
787960
4816
13:24
what they need,
290
792800
1256
13:26
is why, as healthcare providers,
291
794080
1696
13:27
we're here.
292
795800
1200
13:29
Asking patients about their hopes,
their fears, their goals and preferences.
293
797640
4216
13:33
As a palliative care provider,
294
801880
1456
13:35
I ask all my patients what they're
hoping for and what they're afraid of.
295
803360
3520
13:39
But here's the thing.
296
807560
1256
13:40
Patients shouldn't have to wait
until they're chronically seriously ill,
297
808840
3496
13:44
often near the end of life,
298
812360
1816
13:46
they shouldn't have to wait
until they're seeing a physician like me
299
814200
4296
13:50
before somebody asks them,
300
818520
1736
13:52
"What are you hoping for?"
301
820280
1256
13:53
"What are you afraid of?"
302
821560
1256
13:54
That should be baked into the way
that healthcare is delivered.
303
822840
3400
13:59
We can do this --
304
827720
1456
14:01
we really can.
305
829200
1216
14:02
Medical marijuana dispensaries
and clinics all across the country
306
830440
3376
14:05
are figuring this out.
307
833840
1776
14:07
They're figuring this out
308
835640
1256
14:08
in ways that larger, more mainstream
health systems are years behind.
309
836920
5496
14:14
But we can learn from them,
310
842440
1376
14:15
and we have to learn from them.
311
843840
1536
14:17
All we have to do is swallow our pride --
312
845400
2336
14:19
put aside the thought for a minute
313
847760
1656
14:21
that because we have
lots of letters after our name,
314
849440
2496
14:23
because we're experts,
315
851960
1256
14:25
because we're chief medical officers
of a large healthcare system,
316
853240
3136
14:28
we know all there is to know
about how to meet patients' needs.
317
856400
4176
14:32
We need to swallow our pride.
318
860600
1416
14:34
We need to go visit
a few medical marijuana dispensaries.
319
862040
3056
14:37
We need to figure out what they're doing.
320
865120
1976
14:39
We need to figure out
why so many patients like Robin
321
867120
2576
14:41
are leaving our mainstream medical clinics
322
869720
2176
14:43
and going to these medical
marijuana dispensaries instead.
323
871920
3376
14:47
We need to figure out
what their tricks are,
324
875320
2096
14:49
what their tools are,
325
877440
1256
14:50
and we need to learn from them.
326
878720
2136
14:52
If we do,
327
880880
1256
14:54
and I think we can,
and I absolutely think we have to,
328
882160
2936
14:57
we can guarantee all of our patients
will have a much better experience.
329
885120
3400
15:01
Thank you.
330
889040
1216
15:02
(Applause)
331
890280
3400

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
David Casarett - Physician
David Casarett asks: What if mainstream health care operated more like a medical marijuana dispensary?

Why you should listen

In his third book, Stoned: A Doctor's Case for Medical Marijuana, palliative care physician David Casarett takes a first-person investigative journalist's approach to making sense of marijuana's therapeutic potential and adverse effects. He shares what he's learned about this chronically misunderstood drug -- including the control it gives patients over their health and the educational atmosphere of dispensaries -- and outlines what we still need to do to explore its potential health benefits.

Casarett is a professor of medicine at the Duke University School of Medicine and chief of palliative care for the Duke Health System. He is the author of more than 100 journal articles, numerous magazine articles, and Shocked, another nonfiction book about the science of resuscitation. Casarett's first novel in the Ethical Chiang Mai Detective Agency series, Murder at the House of Rooster Happiness, was published in September 2016. The next installment, The Missing Guests of the Magic Grove Hotel, will be published in the fall of 2017.

More profile about the speaker
David Casarett | Speaker | TED.com