ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Wendy Troxel - Sleep researcher
Wendy Troxel specializes in behavioral treatments for insomnia and other sleep disorders.

Why you should listen

Dr. Wendy Troxel is a Senior Behavioral and Social Scientist at RAND and Adjunct Professor of Psychiatry and Psychology at the University of Pittsburgh. She is a licensed clinical psychologist specializing in behavioral treatments for insomnia and other sleep disorders across the lifespan. Her research is funded by the National Heart Lung Blood Institute of the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Defense. Troxel's research focuses on the interface between sleep, social environment and health, as well as the implications for public policy. She is considered the leading authority on how sleep affects and is affected by close relationships.

Troxel has received several awards and honors for her research from national and international scientific societies, and her work has been published in top-tier medical and psychological journals. Her research has been widely cited in the national and international media, including print and television interviews on CBS Sunday Morning, Good Morning America, the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, MSNBC and CNN, and she has a regular blog on Huffington Post. Her research on sleep was also featured in two best-selling books: Arianna Huffington's Sleep Revolution and David Randall's Dreamland, and she was a featured expert in the National Geographic documentary Sleepless in America. She has published several highly influential RAND reports on sleep loss in the US military and the global economic implications of sleep loss. She recently was one of the co-organizers and presenters at the first-ever national conference on Adolescent Sleep, Health, and School Start Times, and she will serve as guest editor on an upcoming special issue in the journal Sleep Health on adolescent sleep and school start times.

More profile about the speaker
Wendy Troxel | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxManhattanBeach

Wendy Troxel: Why school should start later for teens

Filmed:
1,860,295 views

Teens don't get enough sleep, and it's not because of Snapchat, social lives or hormones -- it's because of public policy, says Wendy Troxel. Drawing from her experience as a sleep researcher, clinician and mother of a teenager, Troxel discusses how early school start times deprive adolescents of sleep during the time of their lives when they need it most.
- Sleep researcher
Wendy Troxel specializes in behavioral treatments for insomnia and other sleep disorders. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
It's six o'clock in the morning,
0
360
2216
00:14
pitch black outside.
1
2600
1320
00:16
My 14-year-old son
is fast asleep in his bed,
2
4640
3216
00:19
sleeping the reckless,
deep sleep of a teenager.
3
7880
3080
00:24
I flip on the light and physically
shake the poor boy awake,
4
12000
3976
00:28
because I know that,
like ripping off a Band-Aid,
5
16000
2616
00:30
it's better to get it over with quickly.
6
18640
1936
00:32
(Laughter)
7
20600
1656
00:34
I have a friend who yells "Fire!"
just to rouse her sleeping teen.
8
22280
4736
00:39
And another who got so fed up
9
27040
1976
00:41
that she had to dump cold water
on her son's head
10
29040
2856
00:43
just to get him out of bed.
11
31920
1920
00:46
Sound brutal ...
12
34600
1736
00:48
but perhaps familiar?
13
36360
1800
00:51
Every morning I ask myself,
14
39600
2856
00:54
"How can I --
15
42480
1576
00:56
knowing what I know
16
44080
1736
00:57
and doing what I do for a living --
17
45840
2416
01:00
be doing this to my own son?"
18
48280
2000
01:03
You see,
19
51040
1296
01:04
I'm a sleep researcher.
20
52360
1696
01:06
(Laughter)
21
54080
2176
01:08
So I know far too much about sleep
22
56280
1816
01:10
and the consequences of sleep loss.
23
58120
2696
01:12
I know that I'm depriving my son
of the sleep he desperately needs
24
60840
4096
01:16
as a rapidly growing teenager.
25
64959
1881
01:19
I also know that by waking him up
26
67360
2256
01:21
hours before his natural
biological clock tells him he's ready,
27
69640
4656
01:26
I'm literally robbing him
of his dreams --
28
74320
2400
01:29
the type of sleep most associated
with learning, memory consolidation
29
77400
5776
01:35
and emotional processing.
30
83200
1840
01:37
But it's not just my kid
that's being deprived of sleep.
31
85760
2880
01:41
Sleep deprivation among
American teenagers is an epidemic.
32
89760
3760
01:46
Only about one in 10 gets
the eight to 10 hours of sleep per night
33
94360
4496
01:50
recommended by sleep scientists
and pediatricians.
34
98880
3200
01:55
Now, if you're thinking to yourself,
35
103280
1736
01:57
"Phew, we're doing good,
my kid's getting eight hours,"
36
105040
3256
02:00
remember,
37
108320
1216
02:01
eight hours is
the minimum recommendation.
38
109560
3496
02:05
You're barely passing.
39
113080
2056
02:07
Eight hours is kind of like
getting a C on your report card.
40
115160
2840
02:10
There are many factors
contributing to this epidemic,
41
118960
2840
02:14
but a major factor preventing teens
from getting the sleep they need
42
122600
4536
02:19
is actually a matter of public policy.
43
127160
2319
02:22
Not hormones, social lives or Snapchat.
44
130160
3880
02:27
Across the country,
45
135520
1256
02:28
many schools are starting
around 7:30am or earlier,
46
136800
4856
02:33
despite the fact that major
medical organizations recommend
47
141680
4096
02:37
that middle and high school
start no earlier than 8:30am.
48
145800
4440
02:43
These early start policies
have a direct effect on how much --
49
151240
4136
02:47
or really how little sleep
American teenagers are getting.
50
155400
4000
02:52
They're also pitting
teenagers and their parents
51
160520
3896
02:56
in a fundamentally unwinnable fight
against their own bodies.
52
164440
4080
03:01
Around the time of puberty,
53
169360
1816
03:03
teenagers experience a delay
in their biological clock,
54
171200
3736
03:06
which determines when we feel most awake
and when we feel most sleepy.
55
174960
3680
03:11
This is driven in part by a shift
in the release of the hormone melatonin.
56
179520
3640
03:16
Teenagers' bodies wait to start releasing
melatonin until around 11pm,
57
184080
5536
03:21
which is two hours later than what
we see in adults or younger children.
58
189640
4320
03:27
This means that waking a teenager up
at 6am is the biological equivalent
59
195840
6016
03:33
of waking an adult up at 4am.
60
201880
2960
03:37
On the unfortunate days
when I have to wake up at 4am,
61
205760
3976
03:41
I'm a zombie.
62
209760
1336
03:43
Functionally useless.
63
211120
1736
03:44
I can't think straight,
64
212880
1616
03:46
I'm irritable,
65
214520
1496
03:48
and I probably shouldn't be driving a car.
66
216040
2440
03:51
But this is how many American
teenagers feel every single school day.
67
219680
4120
03:56
In fact, many of the, shall we say,
68
224280
3016
03:59
unpleasant characteristics
that we chalk up to being a teenager --
69
227320
4336
04:03
moodiness, irritability,
laziness, depression --
70
231680
3416
04:07
could be a product
of chronic sleep deprivation.
71
235120
2880
04:11
For many teens
battling chronic sleep loss,
72
239080
2736
04:13
their go-to strategy to compensate
is consuming large quantities of caffeine
73
241840
5496
04:19
in the form of venti frappuccinos,
74
247360
2176
04:21
or energy drinks and shots.
75
249560
1840
04:24
So essentially,
76
252080
1216
04:25
we've got an entire population
of tired but wired youth.
77
253320
6000
04:33
Advocates of sleep-friendly
start times know
78
261600
3616
04:37
that adolescence is a period
of dramatic brain development,
79
265240
3536
04:40
particularly in the parts of the brain
80
268800
2056
04:42
that are responsible for those
higher order thinking processes,
81
270880
3536
04:46
including reasoning, problem-solving
and good judgment.
82
274440
4280
04:51
In other words, the very type
of brain activity that's responsible
83
279320
3136
04:54
for reining in those impulsive
and often risky behaviors
84
282480
4576
04:59
that are so characteristic of adolescence
85
287080
2936
05:02
and that are so terrifying
to us parents of teenagers.
86
290040
3760
05:06
They know that like the rest of us,
87
294600
1896
05:08
when teenagers don't
get the sleep they need,
88
296520
2416
05:10
their brains, their bodies
and behaviors suffer
89
298960
3136
05:14
with both immediate and lasting effects.
90
302120
2640
05:17
They can't concentrate,
91
305280
1816
05:19
their attention plummets
92
307120
1896
05:21
and many will even show
behavioral signs that mimic ADHD.
93
309040
3760
05:26
But the consequences of teen sleep loss
go well beyond the classroom,
94
314320
4416
05:30
sadly contributing to many
of the mental health problems
95
318760
3616
05:34
that skyrocket during adolescence,
96
322400
2696
05:37
including substance use,
97
325120
1816
05:38
depression and suicide.
98
326960
2480
05:42
In our work with teens
from LA Unified School District,
99
330400
3176
05:45
we found that teens with sleep problems
100
333600
2216
05:47
were 55 percent more likely
to have used alcohol in the past month.
101
335840
4200
05:53
In another study with over
30,000 high school students,
102
341080
3896
05:57
they found that
for each hour of lost sleep,
103
345000
3576
06:00
there was a 38 percent increase
in feeling sad or hopeless,
104
348600
3720
06:05
and a 58 percent increase
in teen suicide attempts.
105
353400
3880
06:10
And if that's not enough,
106
358600
2256
06:12
teens who skip out on sleep
are at increased risk
107
360880
2536
06:15
for a host of physical health problems
that plague our country,
108
363440
4056
06:19
including obesity,
heart disease and diabetes.
109
367520
4080
06:24
Then there's the risk
of putting a sleep-deprived teen,
110
372760
2896
06:27
with a newly minted driver's license,
111
375680
2536
06:30
behind the wheel.
112
378240
1280
06:32
Studies have shown that getting five hours
or less of sleep per night
113
380160
4496
06:36
is the equivalent of driving with a blood
alcohol content above the legal limit.
114
384680
5680
06:48
Advocates of sleep-friendly start times,
115
396200
2496
06:50
and researchers in this area,
116
398720
2056
06:52
have produced tremendous science
117
400800
2176
06:55
showing the tremendous benefits
of later start times.
118
403000
3896
06:58
The findings are unequivocal,
119
406920
2296
07:01
and as a sleep scientist,
120
409240
1696
07:02
I rarely get to speak
with that kind of certainty.
121
410960
2720
07:07
Teens from districts
with later start times get more sleep.
122
415160
3816
07:11
To the naysayers who may think
that if schools start later,
123
419000
3496
07:14
teens will just stay up later,
124
422520
1640
07:16
the truth is,
125
424920
1256
07:18
their bedtimes stay the same,
126
426200
1936
07:20
but their wake-up times get extended,
127
428160
2256
07:22
resulting in more sleep.
128
430440
2160
07:25
They're more likely to show up for school;
129
433360
2376
07:27
school absences dropped
by 25 percent in one district.
130
435760
3896
07:31
And they're less likely to drop out.
131
439680
2576
07:34
Not surprisingly,
they do better academically.
132
442280
3496
07:37
So this has real implications
for reducing the achievement gap.
133
445800
4736
07:42
Standardized test scores
in math and reading
134
450560
2696
07:45
go up by two to three percentage points.
135
453280
2440
07:48
That's as powerful as reducing class sizes
by one-third fewer students,
136
456320
5576
07:53
or replacing a so-so teacher
in the classroom
137
461920
3176
07:57
with a truly outstanding one.
138
465120
2160
08:00
Their mental and physical health improves,
139
468440
2536
08:03
and even their families are happier.
140
471000
2336
08:05
I mean, who wouldn't enjoy a little
more pleasantness from our teens,
141
473360
4816
08:10
and a little less crankiness?
142
478200
1960
08:13
Even their communities are safer
143
481040
1856
08:14
because car crash rates go down --
144
482920
2536
08:17
a 70 percent reduction in one district.
145
485480
2840
08:21
Given these tremendous benefits,
146
489400
2416
08:23
you might think,
147
491840
1336
08:25
well, this is a no-brainer, right?
148
493200
2696
08:27
So why have we as a society
failed to heed this call?
149
495920
4280
08:33
Often the argument against later
start times goes something like this:
150
501680
3560
08:38
"Why should we delay
start times for teenagers?
151
506000
2296
08:40
We need to toughen them up
so they're ready for the real world!"
152
508320
3240
08:44
But that's like saying
to the parent of a two-year-old,
153
512200
2896
08:47
"Don't let Johnny nap,
154
515120
1496
08:48
or he won't be ready for kindergarten."
155
516640
2416
08:51
(Laughter)
156
519080
1200
08:53
Delaying start times also presents
many logistical challenges.
157
521880
3896
08:57
Not just for students and their families,
158
525800
2376
09:00
but for communities as a whole.
159
528200
2376
09:02
Updating bus routes,
160
530600
1576
09:04
increased transportation costs,
161
532200
2056
09:06
impact on sports,
162
534280
1536
09:07
care before or after school.
163
535840
2416
09:10
These are the same concerns
that come up in district after district,
164
538280
4576
09:14
time and again around the country
165
542880
1976
09:16
as school start times are debated.
166
544880
2080
09:19
And they're legitimate concerns,
167
547960
1680
09:22
but these are problems
we have to work through.
168
550640
2880
09:26
They are not valid excuses
169
554120
2256
09:28
for failing to do the right thing
for our children,
170
556400
2760
09:31
which is to start middle and high schools
no earlier than 8:30am.
171
559920
4880
09:37
And in districts around the country,
172
565760
1896
09:39
big and small,
who have made this change,
173
567680
2616
09:42
they found that these fears
are often unfounded
174
570320
3776
09:46
and far outweighed by the tremendous
benefits for student health
175
574120
4416
09:50
and performance,
176
578560
1656
09:52
and our collective public safety.
177
580240
1960
09:56
So tomorrow morning,
178
584160
1776
09:57
when coincidentally we get
to set our clocks back by an hour
179
585960
4720
10:03
and you get that delicious
extra hour of sleep,
180
591760
4320
10:09
and the day seems a little longer,
181
597280
1960
10:12
and a little more full of hope,
182
600080
1640
10:14
think about the tremendous power of sleep.
183
602760
3920
10:19
And think about what a gift it would be
184
607520
2576
10:22
for our children to be able
to wake up naturally,
185
610120
4016
10:26
in harmony with their own biology.
186
614160
2240
10:29
Thank you,
187
617400
1256
10:30
and pleasant dreams.
188
618680
1200
Translated by Leslie Gauthier
Reviewed by Joanna Pietrulewicz

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Wendy Troxel - Sleep researcher
Wendy Troxel specializes in behavioral treatments for insomnia and other sleep disorders.

Why you should listen

Dr. Wendy Troxel is a Senior Behavioral and Social Scientist at RAND and Adjunct Professor of Psychiatry and Psychology at the University of Pittsburgh. She is a licensed clinical psychologist specializing in behavioral treatments for insomnia and other sleep disorders across the lifespan. Her research is funded by the National Heart Lung Blood Institute of the National Institutes of Health and the Department of Defense. Troxel's research focuses on the interface between sleep, social environment and health, as well as the implications for public policy. She is considered the leading authority on how sleep affects and is affected by close relationships.

Troxel has received several awards and honors for her research from national and international scientific societies, and her work has been published in top-tier medical and psychological journals. Her research has been widely cited in the national and international media, including print and television interviews on CBS Sunday Morning, Good Morning America, the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, MSNBC and CNN, and she has a regular blog on Huffington Post. Her research on sleep was also featured in two best-selling books: Arianna Huffington's Sleep Revolution and David Randall's Dreamland, and she was a featured expert in the National Geographic documentary Sleepless in America. She has published several highly influential RAND reports on sleep loss in the US military and the global economic implications of sleep loss. She recently was one of the co-organizers and presenters at the first-ever national conference on Adolescent Sleep, Health, and School Start Times, and she will serve as guest editor on an upcoming special issue in the journal Sleep Health on adolescent sleep and school start times.

More profile about the speaker
Wendy Troxel | Speaker | TED.com