TEDSalon 2009 Compassion
Jackie Tabick: The balancing act of compassion
Filmed:
Readability: 3.3
212,916 views
While we all agree that compassion is a great idea, Rabbi Tabick acknowledges there are challenges to its execution. She explains how a careful balance of compassion and justice allows us to do good deeds, and keep our sanity.
Jackie Tabick - Spiritual leader
As the first woman in the UK to be ordained in the Jewish faith, Rabbi Jackie Tabick has forged a path of inclusiveness from her work’s beginning. Full bio
As the first woman in the UK to be ordained in the Jewish faith, Rabbi Jackie Tabick has forged a path of inclusiveness from her work’s beginning. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:13
One of my favorite cartoon characters is Snoopy.
0
1000
5000
00:18
I love the way he sits and lies on his kennel and contemplates the great things of life.
1
6000
7000
00:25
So when I thought about compassion,
2
13000
2000
00:27
my mind immediately went to one of the cartoon strips,
3
15000
4000
00:31
where he's lying there and he says,
4
19000
4000
00:35
"I really understand, and I really appreciate
5
23000
3000
00:38
how one should love one's neighbor as one love's oneself.
6
26000
5000
00:43
The only trouble is the people next door; I can't stand them."
7
31000
5000
00:48
This, in a way, is one of the challenges
8
36000
5000
00:53
of how to interpret a really good idea.
9
41000
4000
00:57
We all, I think, believe in compassion.
10
45000
3000
01:00
If you look at all the world religions, all the main world religions,
11
48000
4000
01:04
you'll find within them some teaching concerning compassion.
12
52000
5000
01:09
So in Judaism, we have, from our Torah,
13
57000
3000
01:12
that you should love your neighbor as you love yourself.
14
60000
4000
01:16
And within Jewish teachings, the rabbinic teachings, we have Hillel,
15
64000
5000
01:21
who taught that you shouldn't do to others what you don't like being done to yourself.
16
69000
5000
01:26
And all the main religions have similar teachings.
17
74000
5000
01:31
And again, within Judaism,
18
79000
2000
01:33
we have a teaching about God,
19
81000
3000
01:36
who is called the compassionate one, Ha-rachaman.
20
84000
3000
01:39
After all, how could the world exist without God being compassionate?
21
87000
5000
01:44
And we, as taught within the Torah that we are made in the image of God,
22
92000
5000
01:49
so we too have to be compassionate.
23
97000
4000
01:53
But what does it mean? How does it impact on our everyday life?
24
101000
4000
01:57
Sometimes, of course, being compassionate
25
105000
4000
02:01
can produce feelings within us that are very difficult to control.
26
109000
7000
02:08
I know there are many times when I've gone and conducted a funeral,
27
116000
6000
02:14
or when I have been sitting with the bereaved, or with people who are dying,
28
122000
6000
02:20
and I am overwhelmed by the sadness, by the difficulty,
29
128000
9000
02:29
the challenge that is there for the family, for the person.
30
137000
4000
02:33
And I'm touched, so that tears come to my eyes.
31
141000
5000
02:38
And yet, if I just allowed myself to be overwhelmed by these feelings,
32
146000
5000
02:43
I wouldn't be doing my job --
33
151000
3000
02:46
because I have to actually be there for them
34
154000
2000
02:48
and make sure that rituals happen, that practicalities are seen to.
35
156000
8000
02:56
And yet, on the other hand, if I didn't feel this compassion,
36
164000
5000
03:01
then I feel that it would be time for me to hang up my robe
37
169000
5000
03:06
and give up being a rabbi.
38
174000
3000
03:09
And these same feelings are there for all of us as we face the world.
39
177000
5000
03:14
Who cannot be touched by compassion
40
182000
4000
03:18
when we see the terrible horrors of the results of war,
41
186000
7000
03:25
or famine, or earthquakes, or tsunamis?
42
193000
5000
03:30
I know some people who say
43
198000
2000
03:32
"Well, you know there's just so much out there -- I can't do anything,
44
200000
4000
03:36
I'm not going to even begin to try."
45
204000
4000
03:40
And there are some charity workers who call this compassion fatigue.
46
208000
6000
03:46
There are others who feel they can't confront compassion anymore,
47
214000
7000
03:53
and so they turn off the television and don't watch.
48
221000
5000
03:58
In Judaism, though, we tend to always say, there has to be a middle way.
49
226000
7000
04:05
You have to, of course, be aware of the needs of others,
50
233000
7000
04:12
but you have to be aware in such a way that you can carry on with your life
51
240000
5000
04:17
and be of help to people.
52
245000
3000
04:20
So part of compassion has to be an understanding of what makes people tick.
53
248000
9000
04:29
And, of course, you can't do that unless you understand yourself a bit more.
54
257000
3000
04:32
And there's a lovely rabbinic interpretation of the beginnings of creation,
55
260000
7000
04:39
which says that when God created the world,
56
267000
4000
04:43
God thought that it would be best to create the world
57
271000
6000
04:49
only with the divine attribute of justice.
58
277000
4000
04:53
Because, after all, God is just.
59
281000
2000
04:55
Therefore, there should be justice throughout the world.
60
283000
5000
05:00
And then God looked to the future and realized,
61
288000
2000
05:02
if the world was created just with justice, the world couldn't exist.
62
290000
5000
05:07
So, God thought, "Nope, I'm going to create the world just with compassion."
63
295000
6000
05:13
And then God looked to the future and realized that,
64
301000
4000
05:17
in fact, if the world were just filled with compassion,
65
305000
4000
05:21
there would be anarchy and chaos.
66
309000
4000
05:25
There had to be limits to all things.
67
313000
3000
05:28
The rabbis describe this as being like a king
68
316000
5000
05:33
who has a beautiful, fragile glass bowl.
69
321000
6000
05:39
If you put too much cold water in, it will shatter.
70
327000
4000
05:43
If you put boiling water in, it will shatter.
71
331000
2000
05:45
What do you have to do? Put in a mixture of the two.
72
333000
5000
05:50
And so God put both of these possibilities into the world.
73
338000
8000
05:58
There is something more though that has to be there.
74
346000
4000
06:02
And that is the translation of the feelings
75
350000
5000
06:07
that we may have about compassion
76
355000
3000
06:10
into the wider world, into action.
77
358000
4000
06:14
So, like Snoopy, we can't just lie there
78
362000
3000
06:17
and think great thoughts about our neighbors.
79
365000
3000
06:20
We actually have to do something about it.
80
368000
3000
06:23
And so there is also, within Judaism, this notion of love and kindness
81
371000
5000
06:28
that becomes very important: "chesed."
82
376000
5000
06:33
All these three things, then, have to be melded together.
83
381000
5000
06:38
The idea of justice, which gives boundaries to our lives
84
386000
6000
06:44
and gives us a feeling of what's right about life, what's right about living,
85
392000
7000
06:51
what should we be doing, social justice.
86
399000
4000
06:55
There has to be a willingness to do good deeds,
87
403000
5000
07:00
but not, of course, at the expense of our own sanity.
88
408000
4000
07:04
You know, there's no way that you can do anything for anyone
89
412000
3000
07:07
if you overdo things.
90
415000
2000
07:09
And balancing them all in the middle is this notion of compassion,
91
417000
6000
07:15
which has to be there, if you like, at our very roots.
92
423000
6000
07:21
This idea of compassion comes to us
93
429000
5000
07:26
because we're made in the image of God,
94
434000
3000
07:29
who is ultimately the compassionate one.
95
437000
4000
07:33
What does this compassion entail?
96
441000
2000
07:35
It entails understanding the pain of the other.
97
443000
5000
07:40
But even more than that,
98
448000
2000
07:42
it means understanding one's connection to the whole of creation:
99
450000
8000
07:50
understanding that one is part of that creation,
100
458000
4000
07:54
that there is a unity that underlies all that we see,
101
462000
4000
07:58
all that we hear, all that we feel.
102
466000
4000
08:02
I call that unity God.
103
470000
3000
08:05
And that unity is something that connects all of creation.
104
473000
5000
08:10
And, of course, in the modern world, with the environmental movement,
105
478000
3000
08:13
we're becoming even more aware of the connectivity of things,
106
481000
5000
08:18
that something I do here actually does matter in Africa,
107
486000
5000
08:23
that if I use too much of my carbon allowance,
108
491000
4000
08:27
it seems to be that we are causing
109
495000
2000
08:29
a great lack of rain in central and eastern Africa.
110
497000
7000
08:36
So there is a connectivity,
111
504000
2000
08:38
and I have to understand that -- as part of the creation,
112
506000
6000
08:44
as part of me being made in the image of God.
113
512000
5000
08:49
And I have to understand that my needs
114
517000
4000
08:53
sometimes have to be sublimated to other needs.
115
521000
4000
08:57
This "18 minutes" business, I find quite fascinating.
116
525000
5000
09:02
Because in Judaism, the number 18, in Hebrew letters,
117
530000
5000
09:07
stands for life -- the word "life."
118
535000
3000
09:10
So, in a sense, the 18 minutes is challenging me to say,
119
538000
5000
09:15
"In life, this is what's important in terms of compassion."
120
543000
4000
09:19
But, something else as well:
121
547000
2000
09:21
actually, 18 minutes is important.
122
549000
3000
09:24
Because at Passover, when we have to eat unleavened bread,
123
552000
6000
09:30
the rabbis say, what is the difference between dough that is made into bread,
124
558000
4000
09:34
and dough that is made into unleavened bread, or "matzah"?
125
562000
3000
09:37
And they say "It's 18 minutes."
126
565000
3000
09:40
Because that's how long they say it takes for this dough to become leaven.
127
568000
5000
09:45
What does it mean, "dough becomes leaven"?
128
573000
3000
09:48
It means it gets filled with hot air.
129
576000
3000
09:51
What's matzah? What's unleavened bread? You don't get it.
130
579000
4000
09:55
Symbolically, what the rabbis say is that at Passover,
131
583000
5000
10:00
what we have to do is try to get rid of our hot air -- our pride,
132
588000
6000
10:06
our feeling that we are the most important people in the whole entire world,
133
594000
4000
10:10
and that everything should revolve round us.
134
598000
4000
10:14
So we try and get rid of those,
135
602000
3000
10:17
and so doing, try to get rid of the habits, the emotions, the ideas
136
605000
7000
10:24
that enslave us, that make our eyes closed, give us tunnel vision
137
612000
6000
10:30
so we don't see the needs of others --
138
618000
3000
10:33
and free ourselves and free ourselves from that.
139
621000
4000
10:37
And that too is a basis for having compassion,
140
625000
5000
10:42
for understanding our place in the world.
141
630000
6000
10:48
Now there is, in Judaism, a gorgeous story
142
636000
5000
10:53
of a rich man who sat in synagogue one day.
143
641000
6000
10:59
And, as many people do, he was dozing off during the sermon.
144
647000
6000
11:05
And as he was dozing off, they were reading from the book of Leviticus in the Torah.
145
653000
6000
11:11
And they were saying that in the ancient times in the temple in Jerusalem,
146
659000
6000
11:17
the priests used to have bread,
147
665000
2000
11:19
which they used to place into a special table in the temple in Jerusalem.
148
667000
8000
11:27
The man was asleep, but he heard the words bread, temple, God, and he woke up.
149
675000
7000
11:34
He said, "God wants bread. That's it. God wants bread. I know what God wants."
150
682000
5000
11:39
And he rushed home. And after the Sabbath, he made 12 loaves of bread,
151
687000
7000
11:46
took them to the synagogue, went into the synagogue,
152
694000
3000
11:49
opened the ark and said, "God, I don't know why you want this bread, but here you are."
153
697000
4000
11:53
And he put it in the ark with the scrolls of the Torah.
154
701000
5000
11:58
Then he went home.
155
706000
3000
12:01
The cleaner came into the synagogue.
156
709000
3000
12:04
"Oh God, I'm in such trouble. I've got children to feed.
157
712000
4000
12:08
My wife's ill. I've got no money. What can I do?"
158
716000
4000
12:12
He goes into the synagogue. "God, will you please help me?
159
720000
4000
12:16
Ah, what a wonderful smell."
160
724000
2000
12:18
He goes to the ark. He opens the ark.
161
726000
2000
12:20
"There's bread! God, you've answered my plea. You've answered my question."
162
728000
5000
12:25
Takes the bread and goes home.
163
733000
3000
12:28
Meanwhile, the rich man thinks to himself,
164
736000
3000
12:31
"I'm an idiot. God wants bread?
165
739000
3000
12:34
God, the one who rules the entire universe, wants my bread?"
166
742000
5000
12:39
He rushes to the synagogue. "I'll get it out of the ark before anybody finds it."
167
747000
3000
12:42
He goes in there, and it's not there.
168
750000
3000
12:45
And he says, "God, you really did want it. You wanted my bread.
169
753000
5000
12:50
Next week, with raisins."
170
758000
3000
12:53
This went on for years.
171
761000
2000
12:55
Every week, the man would bring bread with raisins,
172
763000
3000
12:58
with all sorts of good things, put it into the ark.
173
766000
3000
13:01
Every week, the cleaner would come. "God you've answered my plea again."
174
769000
4000
13:05
Take the bread. Take it home.
175
773000
2000
13:07
Went on until a new rabbi came. Rabbis always spoil things.
176
775000
3000
13:10
The rabbi came in and saw what was going on.
177
778000
5000
13:15
And he called the two of them to his office.
178
783000
2000
13:17
And he said, you know, "This is what's happening."
179
785000
3000
13:20
And the rich man -- oh, dear -- crestfallen.
180
788000
6000
13:26
"You mean God didn't want my bread?"
181
794000
4000
13:30
And the poor man said, "And you mean God didn't answer my pleas?"
182
798000
7000
13:37
And the rabbi said, "You've misunderstood me.
183
805000
4000
13:41
You've misunderstood totally," he said.
184
809000
3000
13:44
"Of course, what you are doing," he said to the rich man,
185
812000
4000
13:48
"is answering God's plea that we should be compassionate.
186
816000
6000
13:54
And God," he said to the poor man, "is answering your plea
187
822000
4000
13:58
that people should be compassionate and give."
188
826000
4000
14:02
He looked at the rich man. He held the rich man's hands and said,
189
830000
6000
14:08
"Don't you understand?" He said, "These are the hands of God."
190
836000
6000
14:19
So that is the way I feel:
191
847000
6000
14:25
that I can only try to approach this notion of being compassionate,
192
853000
7000
14:32
of understanding that there is a connectivity, that there is a unity in this world;
193
860000
6000
14:38
that I want to try and serve that unity,
194
866000
5000
14:43
and that I can try and do that by understanding, I hope,
195
871000
4000
14:47
trying to understand something of the pain of others;
196
875000
5000
14:52
but understanding that there are limits, that people have to bear responsibility
197
880000
3000
14:55
for some of the problems that come upon them;
198
883000
5000
15:00
and that I have to understand that there are limits to my energy,
199
888000
3000
15:03
to the giving I can give.
200
891000
3000
15:06
I have to reevaluate them,
201
894000
3000
15:09
try and separate out the material things
202
897000
5000
15:14
and my emotions that may be enslaving me,
203
902000
4000
15:18
so that I can see the world clearly.
204
906000
4000
15:22
And then I have to try to see in what ways
205
910000
5000
15:27
I can make these the hands of God.
206
915000
5000
15:32
And so try to bring compassion to life in this world.
207
920000
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jackie Tabick - Spiritual leaderAs the first woman in the UK to be ordained in the Jewish faith, Rabbi Jackie Tabick has forged a path of inclusiveness from her work’s beginning.
Why you should listen
Rabbi Jackie Tabick is known for being the first female rabbi in the UK and for her remarkable efforts to reach out to distinct faiths. She serves as chair to the World Congress of Faiths, working with patrons such as Rev. Desmond Tutu and the Dali Lama towards deepening religious understanding, respect and co-operation. To this end, Rabbi Tabick also serves as an executive member of the Inter Faith Network, and the Three Faiths Forum, as well acting as patron for the Jewish Council for Racial Equality (JCORE).
While reaching across religions, she continues rabbinical duties at the North West Surrey Synagogue and is well known for her engaging and down-to-earth sermons. Her synagogue is part of the Movement of Reform Judaism. Rabbi Tabick has also held the positions of Chair of the Assembly of Rabbis, of the Council of Reform and Liberal Rabbis and Vice president of the Movement for Reform Judaism.
Jackie Tabick | Speaker | TED.com