ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Sandel - Political philosopher
Michael Sandel teaches political philosophy at Harvard, exploring some of the most hotly contested moral and political issues of our time.

Why you should listen

Michael Sandel is one of the best known American public intellectuals. The London Observer calls him "one of the most popular teachers in the world" and indeed his lectures at Harvard draw thousands of students eager to discuss big questions of modern political life: bioethics, torture, rights versus responsibilities, the value we put on things. Sandel's class is a primer on thinking through the hard choices we face as citizens. The course has been turned into a public TV series with companion website and book: Justice: What’s the Right Thing to Do? In his newest book, What Money Can't Buy, he challenges the idea that markets are morally neutral.
 
"To understand the importance of his purpose," a Guardian reviewer wrote of the book, "you first have to grasp the full extent of the triumph achieved by market thinking in economics, and the extent to which that thinking has spread to other domains. This school sees economics as a discipline that has nothing to do with morality, and is instead the study of incentives, considered in an ethical vacuum. Sandel's book is, in its calm way, an all-out assault on that idea, and on the influential doctrine that the economic approach to "utility maximisation" explains all human behaviour."

Read more about his thinking on markets and morality: "Lunch with Michael Sandel" on FT.com >>  

More profile about the speaker
Michael Sandel | Speaker | TED.com
TEDGlobal 2013

Michael Sandel: Why we shouldn't trust markets with our civic life

迈克尔·桑德尔: 为什么我们不能把公民生活托付给市场

Filmed:
2,044,888 views

迈克尔·桑德尔(Michael Sandel)表示:过去30年,美国已从市场经济漂流到市场社会。美国人的公民生活端赖身家财产,这种说法不失公允。(三个重要的例子:教育、司法、政治影响力)在这场听众参与讨论的演说,桑德尔请大家诚实思考一个问题:现行的民主社会,是否凡事都可以出售?
- Political philosopher
Michael Sandel teaches political philosophy at Harvard, exploring some of the most hotly contested moral and political issues of our time. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:13
Here's这里的 a question we need to rethink反思 together一起:
0
1459
4227
我们需要共同反思一个问题
00:17
What should be the role角色 of money
1
5686
2441
金钱和市场
00:20
and markets市场 in our societies社会?
2
8127
3486
在社会上应该扮演什么角色?
00:23
Today今天, there are very few少数 things
3
11613
2494
现在极少东西
00:26
that money can't buy购买.
4
14107
2688
是金钱买不到的
00:28
If you're sentenced判刑 to a jail监狱 term术语
5
16795
1657
如果你被判刑
00:30
in Santa圣诞老人 Barbara芭芭拉, California加州,
6
18452
2451
在加州圣巴巴拉入监
00:32
you should know
7
20903
1352
你应该知道
00:34
that if you don't like the standard标准 accommodations宿舍,
8
22255
2715
如果不喜欢标准牢房
00:36
you can buy购买 a prison监狱 cell细胞 upgrade升级.
9
24970
4343
可以花钱升级
00:41
It's true真正. For how much, do you think?
10
29313
2846
没错!你们猜要花多少钱?
00:44
What would you guess猜测?
11
32159
1941
猜猜看?
00:46
Five hundred dollars美元?
12
34100
1705
500美元?
00:47
It's not the Ritz-Carlton丽思卡尔顿. It's a jail监狱!
13
35805
3335
监狱可不是丽思卡尔顿酒店
00:51
Eighty-two八十二 dollars美元 a night.
14
39140
2024
82元一晚
00:53
Eighty-two八十二 dollars美元 a night.
15
41164
2372
每晚收费82美元
00:55
If you go to an amusement娱乐 park公园
16
43536
2200
如果你去游乐园
00:57
and don't want to stand in the long lines线
17
45736
2692
不愿为了热门游乐设施
01:00
for the popular流行 rides游乐设施,
18
48428
1456
大排长龙
01:01
there is now a solution.
19
49884
2887
现在有办法解决
01:04
In many许多 theme主题 parks公园, you can pay工资 extra额外
20
52771
4264
许多主题公园,你只要多付钱
01:09
to jump to the head of the line线.
21
57035
1614
就可以不用排队
01:10
They call them Fast快速 Track跟踪 or VIP要人 tickets门票.
22
58649
4515
这叫快速通道或VIP票
01:15
And this isn't only happening事件 in amusement娱乐 parks公园.
23
63164
3589
这种现象不限于游乐园
01:18
In Washington华盛顿, D.C., long lines线,
24
66753
3216
在华盛顿特区
01:21
queues队列 sometimes有时 form形成
25
69969
1940
偶尔也要大排长龙
01:23
for important重要 Congressional国会 hearings听证会.
26
71909
3869
才能参加重要的国会听证会
01:27
Now some people don't like to wait in long queues队列,
27
75778
3505
可是有些人不喜欢排长队
01:31
maybe overnight过夜, even in the rain.
28
79283
2505
可能是彻夜排队,甚至会淋雨
01:33
So now, for lobbyists说客 and others其他
29
81788
1997
游说者和一些人
01:35
who are very keen敏锐 to attend出席 these hearings听证会
30
83785
1806
非常想参加听证会
01:37
but don't like to wait, there are companies公司,
31
85591
2719
但不想排队,有公司因应而生
01:40
line-standing线站立 companies公司,
32
88310
2043
这叫排队公司
01:42
and you can go to them.
33
90353
1863
你可以找他们
01:44
You can pay工资 them a certain某些 amount of money,
34
92216
1889
只要付合适的价钱
01:46
they hire聘请 homeless无家可归 people and others其他 who need a job工作
35
94105
3265
公司就雇用游民或需要工作的人
01:49
to stand waiting等候 in the line线 for as long as it takes,
36
97370
3283
这个队需要排多久他们就等多久
01:52
and the lobbyist说客, just before the hearing听力 begins开始,
37
100653
2868
游说者只要在听证会开始前
01:55
can take his or her place地点 at the head of the line线
38
103521
2879
取代排在最前面的人
01:58
and a seat座位 in the front面前 of the room房间.
39
106400
2745
就可以坐在会场的前排
02:01
Paid付费 line线 standing常设.
40
109145
3079
这是付费排队服务
02:04
It's happening事件, the recourse追索权 to market市场 mechanisms机制
41
112224
3582
市场机制运用技巧
02:07
and market市场 thinking思维 and market市场 solutions解决方案,
42
115806
2674
市场思维方式和市场解决方案技巧
02:10
in bigger arenas竞技场.
43
118480
2632
在更大舞台也看得到
02:13
Take the way we fight斗争 our wars战争.
44
121112
2671
例如我们的作战方式
02:15
Did you know that, in Iraq伊拉克 and Afghanistan阿富汗,
45
123783
3067
你知不知道,在伊拉克和阿富汗
02:18
there were more private私人的 military军事 contractors承包商 on the ground地面
46
126850
4045
私营军事承包商的数量
02:22
than there were U.S. military军事 troops军队?
47
130895
3820
多于美国军队人数
02:26
Now this isn't because we had a public上市 debate辩论
48
134715
3119
并非因为我们公开辩论过
02:29
about whether是否 we wanted to outsource外包 war战争
49
137834
2977
是否要外包战争
02:32
to private私人的 companies公司,
50
140811
2171
给私人公司
02:34
but this is what has happened发生.
51
142982
2707
但这是既成事实
02:37
Over the past过去 three decades几十年,
52
145689
2428
过去三十年
02:40
we have lived生活 through通过 a quiet安静 revolution革命.
53
148117
4098
我们经历了一场宁静革命
02:44
We've我们已经 drifted漂流 almost几乎 without realizing实现 it
54
152215
4967
几乎未察觉我们已经
02:49
from having a market市场 economy经济
55
157182
3248
从市场经济
02:52
to becoming变得 market市场 societies社会.
56
160430
3967
渐渐变成市场社会
02:56
The difference区别 is this: A market市场 economy经济 is a tool工具,
57
164397
3585
二者差别在于:市场经济是工具
02:59
a valuable有价值 and effective有效 tool工具,
58
167982
1662
一种有用、有效的工具
03:01
for organizing组织 productive生产的 activity活动,
59
169644
3058
用于组织生产活动
03:04
but a market市场 society社会 is a place地点 where
60
172702
3058
但是市场社会
03:07
almost几乎 everything is up for sale拍卖.
61
175760
2848
几乎凡事都可以出售
03:10
It's a way of life, in which哪一个 market市场 thinking思维
62
178608
3452
市场社会是一种生活方式
03:14
and market市场 values begin开始 to dominate支配
63
182060
2721
市场的思维和价值开始主导
03:16
every一切 aspect方面 of life:
64
184781
3524
生活的每个层面:
03:20
personal个人 relations关系, family家庭 life, health健康, education教育,
65
188305
4735
私人关系、家庭生活、健康、教育
03:25
politics政治, law, civic公民 life.
66
193040
3299
政治、法律、公民生活
03:28
Now, why worry担心? Why worry担心 about our becoming变得
67
196339
5491
为什么要担心?我们何必担心
03:33
market市场 societies社会?
68
201830
2546
变成市场社会?
03:36
For two reasons原因, I think.
69
204376
3104
我认为原因有两个
03:39
One of them has to do with inequality不等式.
70
207480
4681
原因之一是不平等
03:44
The more things money can buy购买,
71
212161
3333
钱能买到的东西越多
03:47
the more affluence富裕, or the lack缺乏 of it, matters事项.
72
215494
4294
富裕与否就越重要
03:51
If the only thing that money determined决心
73
219788
2857
如果钱只能让人
03:54
was access访问 to yachts游艇 or fancy幻想 vacations休假 or BMWs宝马,
74
222645
5689
买游艇、宝马或是享受豪华假期
04:00
then inequality不等式 wouldn't不会 matter very much.
75
228334
4352
不平等就没那么重要
04:04
But when money comes increasingly日益 to govern治理
76
232686
3427
但是当金钱越来越能够支配
04:08
access访问 to the essentials要领 of the good life --
77
236113
4837
美好生活的要素--
04:12
decent正经 health健康 care关心, access访问 to the best最好 education教育,
78
240950
3926
像样的医疗服务,优良的教育
04:16
political政治 voice语音 and influence影响 in campaigns活动 --
79
244876
4870
选举中的政治话语权和影响力--
04:21
when money comes to govern治理 all of those things,
80
249746
3580
当金钱完全支配了这些要素
04:25
inequality不等式 matters事项 a great deal合同.
81
253326
2550
不平等就事关重大
04:27
And so the marketization市场化 of everything
82
255876
2255
因此,全面市场化
04:30
sharpens锐化 the sting of inequality不等式
83
258131
3570
使不平等及其社会和公民效应
04:33
and its social社会 and civic公民 consequence后果.
84
261701
2184
刺痛更为尖锐
04:35
That's one reason原因 to worry担心.
85
263885
2986
不平等只是原因之一
04:38
There's a second第二 reason原因
86
266871
2237
另一个原因
04:41
apart距离 from the worry担心 about inequality不等式,
87
269108
3899
也令人担心
04:45
and it's this:
88
273007
2319
那就是
04:47
with some social社会 goods产品 and practices做法,
89
275326
3924
有些社会商品和常规
04:51
when market市场 thinking思维 and market市场 values enter输入,
90
279250
5466
一旦被市场思维和价值介入
04:56
they may可能 change更改 the meaning含义 of those practices做法
91
284716
2772
那些常规的意义可能因此会改变
04:59
and crowd人群 out attitudes态度 and norms规范
92
287488
3349
值得我们关心的态度和规范
05:02
worth价值 caring爱心 about.
93
290837
1949
也可能被排挤
05:04
I'd like to take an example
94
292786
2624
我想举一个
05:07
of a controversial争论的 use of a market市场 mechanism机制,
95
295410
3726
运用市场机制而受争议的例子
05:11
a cash现金 incentive激励, and see what you think about it.
96
299136
4745
即金钱奖励机制,看看你们怎么想的
05:15
Many许多 schools学校 struggle斗争 with the challenge挑战
97
303881
3165
许多学校面临严峻挑战
05:19
of motivating激励 kids孩子, especially特别 kids孩子
98
307046
2539
怎样才能鼓励孩子用功读书
05:21
from disadvantaged劣势 backgrounds背景, to study研究 hard,
99
309585
3955
尤其是来自弱势背景的孩子
05:25
to do well in school学校, to apply应用 themselves他们自己.
100
313540
3039
怎样才能表现良好,努力向上
05:28
Some economists经济学家 have proposed建议 a market市场 solution:
101
316579
3488
一些经济学家提出市场解决方案
05:32
Offer提供 cash现金 incentives奖励 to kids孩子 for getting得到 good grades等级
102
320067
4059
提供金钱奖励,只要孩子成绩好
05:36
or high test测试 scores分数
103
324126
2374
或考试分数高
05:38
or for reading books图书.
104
326500
1951
或阅读书籍
05:40
They've他们已经 tried试着 this, actually其实.
105
328451
1782
事实上他们尝试过这个办法
05:42
They've他们已经 doneDONE some experiments实验
106
330233
1285
在美国一些主要城市
05:43
in some major重大的 American美国 cities城市.
107
331518
3431
他们做过实验
05:46
In New York纽约, in Chicago芝加哥, in Washington华盛顿, D.C.,
108
334949
3647
在纽约、芝加哥、华盛顿特区
05:50
they've他们已经 tried试着 this, offering 50 dollars美元 for an A,
109
338596
3711
他们的做法是:成绩A给50美元
05:54
35 dollars美元 for a B.
110
342307
2192
B则给35美元
05:56
In Dallas达拉斯, Texas德州, they have a program程序 that offers报价
111
344499
3174
德州达拉斯有这样一个计划
05:59
eight-year-olds八岁的孩子 two dollars美元 for each book they read.
112
347673
4420
八岁的学童每读一本书奖励两美元
06:04
So let's see what -- Some people are in favor偏爱,
113
352093
2919
有些人支持这个方法
06:07
some people are opposed反对 to this cash现金 incentive激励
114
355012
3390
有些人反对利用金钱
06:10
to motivate刺激 achievement成就.
115
358402
1698
鼓励学生向上
06:12
Let's see what people here think about it.
116
360100
2637
我想知道你们的看法
06:14
Imagine想像 that you are the head of a major重大的 school学校 system系统,
117
362737
4508
假设你是一个主要学区的主管
06:19
and someone有人 comes to you with this proposal提案.
118
367245
2985
有人向你提出这种建议
06:22
And let's say it's a foundation基础. They will provide提供 the funds资金.
119
370230
2637
假设是基金会的提议,他们出钱
06:24
You don't have to take it out of your budget预算.
120
372867
1866
学校不用出钱
06:26
How many许多 would be in favor偏爱
121
374733
1282
有多少人会赞成
06:28
and how many许多 would be opposed反对 to giving it a try?
122
376015
3594
多少人会反对对此进行尝试
06:31
Let's see by a show显示 of hands.
123
379609
1596
请举手回答
06:33
First, how many许多 think it might威力 at least最小 be worth价值 a try
124
381205
3594
认为至少值得一试的人
06:36
to see if it would work? Raise提高 your hand.
125
384799
3896
请举手
06:40
And how many许多 would be opposed反对? How many许多 would --
126
388695
2731
反对的人有多少?
06:43
So the majority多数 here are opposed反对,
127
391426
2814
看来多数人反对
06:46
but a sizable可观 minority少数民族 are in favor偏爱.
128
394240
2982
但赞成的也不少
06:49
Let's have a discussion讨论.
129
397222
1569
我们讨论一下
06:50
Let's start开始 with those of you who object目的,
130
398791
3043
从反方开始
06:53
who would rule规则 it out even before trying.
131
401834
2881
你们连试都不愿意试
06:56
What would be your reason原因?
132
404715
1621
理由何在?
06:58
Who will get our discussion讨论 started开始? Yes?
133
406336
3872
谁愿意起个头?你?
07:02
Heike海克 Moses摩西: Hello你好 everyone大家, I'm Heike海克,
134
410208
1898
Heike Moses:大家好,我是Heike
07:04
and I think it just kills杀死 the intrinsic固有 motivation动机,
135
412106
2767
我认为那会抹杀内在的动力
07:06
so in the respect尊重 that children孩子, if they would like to read,
136
414873
5148
如果学童想要读书
07:12
you just take this incentive激励 away
137
420021
2117
钱只会驱除内在的动力
07:14
in just paying付款 them, so it just changes变化 behavior行为.
138
422138
3452
给钱只能改变行为
07:17
Michael迈克尔 Sandel桑德尔: Takes the intrinsic固有 incentive激励 away.
139
425590
3418
Michael Sandel:驱除内在的动力
07:21
What is, or should be, the intrinsic固有 motivation动机?
140
429008
4235
内在的动力是什么?应该是什么?
07:25
HMHM: Well, the intrinsic固有 motivation动机
141
433243
1690
HM:内在动力嘛
07:26
should be to learn学习.
142
434933
1677
应该是学习
07:28
MS女士: To learn学习.
HMHM: To get to know the world世界.
143
436610
3143
MS:学习
HM:为了认识世界
07:31
And then, if you stop paying付款 them, what happens发生 then?
144
439753
2894
要是停止给钱,结果会怎样?
07:34
Then they stop reading?
145
442647
1747
他们会不会停止阅读?
07:36
MS女士: Now, let's see if there's someone有人 who favors好处,
146
444394
3000
MS:现在看看有没有赞成的
07:39
who thinks it's worth价值 trying this.
147
447394
2348
谁认为值得一试
07:41
Elizabeth伊丽莎白 Loftus洛夫特斯: I'm Elizabeth伊丽莎白 Loftus洛夫特斯,
148
449742
1972
Elizabeth Loftus:我是Elizabeth Loftus
07:43
and you said worth价值 a try, so why not try it
149
451714
4130
你问是否值得一试,试试看又何妨
07:47
and do the experiment实验 and measure测量 things?
150
455844
4123
何妨做做实验,衡量结果
07:51
MS女士: And measure测量. And what would you measure测量?
151
459967
2173
MS:衡量。衡量什么?
07:54
You'd measure测量 how many许多 --
152
462140
1721
你要衡量有多少...
07:55
ELEL: How many许多 books图书 they read
153
463861
1844
EL:他们读了多少书
07:57
and how many许多 books图书 they continued继续 to read
154
465705
2690
停止给钱之后
08:00
after you stopped停止 paying付款 them.
155
468395
1715
又继续读了多少书
08:02
MS女士: Oh, after you stopped停止 paying付款.
156
470110
2357
MS:哦,不给钱以后读了多少
08:04
All right, what about that?
157
472467
1354
行,这可以嘛?
08:05
HMHM: To be frank坦率, I just think
158
473821
1977
HM:老实说,我认为
08:07
this is, not to offend得罪 anyone任何人, a very American美国 way.
159
475798
4633
我无意冒犯,这非常美国作风
08:12
(Laughter笑声) (Applause掌声)
160
480431
6472
(笑声)(掌声)
08:18
MS女士: All right. What's emerged出现 from this discussion讨论
161
486903
2203
MS:好,这个讨论
08:21
is the following以下 question:
162
489106
2120
点出了一个问题:
08:23
Will the cash现金 incentive激励 drive驾驶 out or corrupt腐败
163
491226
4251
金钱奖励会不会驱除或败坏
08:27
or crowd人群 out the higher更高 motivation动机,
164
495477
3189
或排挤更高层次的动力?
08:30
the intrinsic固有 lesson that we hope希望 to convey传达,
165
498666
4794
我们希望传达的内在动力
08:35
which哪一个 is to learn学习 to love to learn学习 and to read
166
503460
4087
就是培养对学习的热爱
08:39
for their own拥有 sakes缘故?
167
507547
2003
以及为阅读而阅读
08:41
And people disagree不同意 about what the effect影响 will be,
168
509550
4097
市场机制的效果,大家意见不同
08:45
but that seems似乎 to be the question,
169
513647
2657
但这似乎是问题之所在
08:48
that somehow不知何故 a market市场 mechanism机制
170
516304
2036
市场机制或金钱奖励
08:50
or a cash现金 incentive激励 teaches the wrong错误 lesson,
171
518340
4861
似乎是错误的教学
08:55
and if it does, what will become成为 of these children孩子 later后来?
172
523201
3607
如果真的错了,学童将来会怎样?
08:58
I should tell you what's happened发生 with these experiments实验.
173
526808
3373
我应该告诉你们实验的结果
09:02
The cash现金 for good grades等级 has had very mixed results结果,
174
530181
4518
用钱奖励好成绩,毁誉参半
09:06
for the most part部分 has not resulted导致 in higher更高 grades等级.
175
534699
3147
大体上不会导致更佳的成绩
09:09
The two dollars美元 for each book
176
537846
2371
读一本书给两美元
09:12
did lead those kids孩子 to read more books图书.
177
540217
3301
学童确实读更多书
09:15
It also led them to read shorter books图书.
178
543518
2644
也因此看页数较少的书
09:18
(Laughter笑声)
179
546162
4178
(笑声)
09:22
But the real真实 question is,
180
550340
1650
但真正的问题是
09:23
what will become成为 of these kids孩子 later后来?
181
551990
2572
这些孩子将来会怎样
09:26
Will they have learned学到了 that reading is a chore苦差事,
182
554562
2114
会不会认定阅读是苦差事
09:28
a form形成 of piecework计件工作 to be doneDONE for pay工资, that's the worry担心,
183
556676
2972
是按件计酬的工作,那就令人担心
09:31
or may可能 it lead them to read maybe for the wrong错误 reason原因 initially原来
184
559648
4617
也可能他们开始或许动机不正
09:36
but then lead them to fall秋季 in love with reading for its own拥有 sake清酒?
185
564265
4746
但日后会爱上阅读的乐趣
09:41
Now, what this, even this brief简要 debate辩论, brings带来 out
186
569011
4821
连这小小的辩论也指出了
09:45
is something that many许多 economists经济学家 overlook俯瞰.
187
573832
3818
许多经济学家疏忽之处
09:49
Economists经济学家 often经常 assume承担
188
577650
2096
经济学家通常认为
09:51
that markets市场 are inert惰性的,
189
579746
2624
市场是钝化的
09:54
that they do not touch触摸 or taint污点 the goods产品 they exchange交换.
190
582370
4366
不会影响或污染其交易的商品
09:58
Market市场 exchange交换, they assume承担,
191
586736
3104
他们以为市场的交易
10:01
doesn't change更改 the meaning含义 or value
192
589840
2460
改变不了
10:04
of the goods产品 being存在 exchanged交换.
193
592300
1283
商品的意义和价值
10:05
This may可能 be true真正 enough足够
194
593583
1576
这种假设可能成立
10:07
if we're talking about material材料 goods产品.
195
595159
2417
如果指的是物质商品
10:09
If you sell me a flat平面 screen屏幕 television电视
196
597576
2506
例如你卖给我平面电视
10:12
or give me one as a gift礼品,
197
600082
2178
或是送给我当礼物
10:14
it will be the same相同 good.
198
602260
1360
东西质量都一样好
10:15
It will work the same相同 either way.
199
603620
2486
功能怎么都一样
10:18
But the same相同 may可能 not be true真正
200
606106
2776
但未必事事如此
10:20
if we're talking about nonmaterial非物质 goods产品
201
608882
2332
如果是非物质商品
10:23
and social社会 practices做法 such这样 as teaching教学 and learning学习
202
611214
3950
例如执教和学习等社会常规
10:27
or engaging together一起 in civic公民 life.
203
615164
3732
或是共同参与公民生活
10:30
In those domains, bringing使 market市场 mechanisms机制
204
618896
3421
在这些领域引进市场机制
10:34
and cash现金 incentives奖励 may可能 undermine破坏
205
622317
3918
和金钱奖励可能会破坏
10:38
or crowd人群 out nonmarket非市场 values and attitudes态度
206
626235
4320
或排挤我们该关心的
10:42
worth价值 caring爱心 about.
207
630555
2359
非市场价值和态度
10:44
Once一旦 we see
208
632914
2224
一旦我们了解
10:47
that markets市场 and commerce商业,
209
635138
3711
市场和交易
10:50
when extended扩展 beyond the material材料 domain,
210
638849
3661
跨越物质领域的时候
10:54
can change更改 the character字符 of the goods产品 themselves他们自己,
211
642510
5450
可以改变商品本身的特质
10:59
can change更改 the meaning含义 of the social社会 practices做法,
212
647960
2561
可以改变社会常规的意义
11:02
as in the example of teaching教学 and learning学习,
213
650521
3464
执教和学习就是例子
11:05
we have to ask where markets市场 belong属于
214
653985
4646
我们就要问,哪些地方适合市场
11:10
and where they don't,
215
658631
1931
哪些地方不适合
11:12
where they may可能 actually其实 undermine破坏
216
660562
2373
哪些地方其实可能会破坏
11:14
values and attitudes态度 worth价值 caring爱心 about.
217
662935
3003
我们该关心的价值和态度
11:17
But to have this debate辩论,
218
665938
3262
但是要辩论
11:21
we have to do something we're not very good at,
219
669200
3498
就必须去做我们不太擅长的事
11:24
and that is to reason原因 together一起 in public上市
220
672698
3482
那就是一起公开讨论
11:28
about the value and the meaning含义
221
676180
3240
我们珍惜的社会常规
11:31
of the social社会 practices做法 we prize,
222
679420
4004
其价值和意义
11:35
from our bodies身体 to family家庭 life
223
683424
2505
从自己的身体到家庭生活
11:37
to personal个人 relations关系 to health健康
224
685929
1953
从私人关系到健康
11:39
to teaching教学 and learning学习 to civic公民 life.
225
687882
3713
从执教和学习到公民生活
11:43
Now these are controversial争论的 questions问题,
226
691595
2984
这些问题都有争议
11:46
and so we tend趋向 to shrink收缩 from them.
227
694579
2760
所以我们较易退缩
11:49
In fact事实, during the past过去 three decades几十年,
228
697339
2920
事实上过去30年来
11:52
when market市场 reasoning推理 and market市场 thinking思维
229
700259
2497
市场论据和市场思维
11:54
have gathered云集 force and gained获得 prestige声望,
230
702756
3488
已经凝聚力量并且受到尊崇
11:58
our public上市 discourse演讲 during this time
231
706244
3482
同时我们的公共谈话
12:01
has become成为 hollowed挖空 out,
232
709726
2235
却已空洞化
12:03
empty of larger moral道德 meaning含义.
233
711961
3706
缺乏更宏大的道德意义
12:07
For fear恐惧 of disagreement异议, we shrink收缩 from these questions问题.
234
715667
3212
因为害怕争论,我们避而不谈
12:10
But once一旦 we see that markets市场
235
718879
3527
不过一旦我们了解
12:14
change更改 the character字符 of goods产品,
236
722406
2173
市场会改变商品的特质
12:16
we have to debate辩论 among其中 ourselves我们自己
237
724579
4567
我们就必须讨论
12:21
these bigger questions问题
238
729146
2337
这些更大的问题
12:23
about how to value goods产品.
239
731483
1960
关于商品价值的问题
12:25
One of the most corrosive腐蚀性的 effects效果
240
733443
2995
凡事标价
12:28
of putting a price价钱 on everything
241
736438
2787
很严重的腐蚀了
12:31
is on commonality共性,
242
739225
2369
我们的共性
12:33
the sense that we are all in it together一起.
243
741594
3178
也就是同舟共济的感觉
12:36
Against反对 the background背景 of rising升起 inequality不等式,
244
744772
4723
在不平等激增的背景下
12:41
marketizing不断开创 every一切 aspect方面 of life
245
749495
3867
把生活各层面市场化
12:45
leads引线 to a condition条件 where those who are affluent富裕的
246
753362
5551
导致富裕的人
12:50
and those who are of modest谦虚 means手段
247
758913
1850
和资源有限的人
12:52
increasingly日益 live生活 separate分离 lives生活.
248
760763
4382
日益分道扬镳
12:57
We live生活 and work and shop and play
249
765145
3219
无论生活、工作、购物、娱乐
13:00
in different不同 places地方.
250
768364
1731
都在不同的地方
13:02
Our children孩子 go to different不同 schools学校.
251
770095
3116
子女进入不同的学校
13:05
This isn't good for democracy民主,
252
773211
2549
这对民主是不利的
13:07
nor也不 is it a satisfying满意的 way to live生活,
253
775760
2923
也不是令人满意的生活方式
13:10
even for those of us who can afford给予
254
778683
3280
即使我们能够花钱
13:13
to buy购买 our way to the head of the line线.
255
781963
2755
排在队列最前,也不例外
13:16
Here's这里的 why.
256
784718
1773
原因是
13:18
Democracy民主 does not require要求 perfect完善 equality平等,
257
786491
4929
民主虽然不必完全平等
13:23
but what it does require要求
258
791420
1763
但必要的是
13:25
is that citizens公民 share分享 in a common共同 life.
259
793183
3628
公民能分享共同的生活
13:28
What matters事项 is that people
260
796811
2629
重要的是
13:31
of different不同 social社会 backgrounds背景
261
799440
1769
不同社会背景的人
13:33
and different不同 walks散步 of life
262
801209
1724
不同身分的人
13:34
encounter遭遇 one another另一个,
263
802933
2284
互相接触
13:37
bump磕碰 up against反对 one another另一个
264
805217
2023
碰到一起
13:39
in the ordinary普通 course课程 of life,
265
807240
3490
而且是在日常生活之中
13:42
because this is what teaches us
266
810730
2724
因为这样我们才能学会
13:45
to negotiate谈判 and to abide遵守 our differences分歧.
267
813454
3672
协商以及容忍差异
13:49
And this is how we come to care关心 for the common共同 good.
268
817126
4214
这样我们才会关心共同利益
13:53
And so, in the end结束, the question of markets市场
269
821340
3350
所以到头来市场的问题
13:56
is not mainly主要 an economic经济 question.
270
824690
4140
主要不是经济问题
14:00
It's really a question of how we want to live生活 together一起.
271
828830
4088
关键是我们要如何共同生活
14:04
Do we want a society社会 where everything is up for sale拍卖,
272
832918
4540
我们想要凡事标价的社会?
14:09
or are there certain某些 moral道德 and civic公民 goods产品
273
837458
3512
或者某些道德和公民商品
14:12
that markets市场 do not honor荣誉
274
840970
1929
是市场不重视
14:14
and money cannot不能 buy购买?
275
842899
2794
金钱买不到的?
14:17
Thank you very much.
276
845693
1462
非常感谢
14:19
(Applause掌声)
277
847155
5185
(掌声)
Translated by Ron Chao
Reviewed by Shengwei Cai

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Michael Sandel - Political philosopher
Michael Sandel teaches political philosophy at Harvard, exploring some of the most hotly contested moral and political issues of our time.

Why you should listen

Michael Sandel is one of the best known American public intellectuals. The London Observer calls him "one of the most popular teachers in the world" and indeed his lectures at Harvard draw thousands of students eager to discuss big questions of modern political life: bioethics, torture, rights versus responsibilities, the value we put on things. Sandel's class is a primer on thinking through the hard choices we face as citizens. The course has been turned into a public TV series with companion website and book: Justice: What’s the Right Thing to Do? In his newest book, What Money Can't Buy, he challenges the idea that markets are morally neutral.
 
"To understand the importance of his purpose," a Guardian reviewer wrote of the book, "you first have to grasp the full extent of the triumph achieved by market thinking in economics, and the extent to which that thinking has spread to other domains. This school sees economics as a discipline that has nothing to do with morality, and is instead the study of incentives, considered in an ethical vacuum. Sandel's book is, in its calm way, an all-out assault on that idea, and on the influential doctrine that the economic approach to "utility maximisation" explains all human behaviour."

Read more about his thinking on markets and morality: "Lunch with Michael Sandel" on FT.com >>  

More profile about the speaker
Michael Sandel | Speaker | TED.com