TEDxCaltech
David Anderson: Your brain is more than a bag of chemicals
Filmed:
Readability: 5
1,482,186 views
Modern psychiatric drugs treat the chemistry of the whole brain, but neurobiologist David Anderson has a more nuanced view of how the brain functions. He shares new research that could lead to targeted psychiatric medications -- that work better and avoid side effects. How's he doing it? For a start, by making a bunch of fruit flies angry.
David Anderson - Neurobiologist
Through his lab at the California Institute of Technology, David Anderson seeks to find the neural underpinnings of emotions like fear, anxiety and anger. Full bio
Through his lab at the California Institute of Technology, David Anderson seeks to find the neural underpinnings of emotions like fear, anxiety and anger. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
So raise your hand if you know someone
0
630
3228
00:19
in your immediate family or circle of friends
1
3858
2647
00:22
who suffers from some form of mental illness.
2
6505
3488
00:25
Yeah. I thought so. Not surprised.
3
9993
2784
00:28
And raise your hand if you think that
4
12777
2295
00:30
basic research on fruit flies has anything to do
5
15072
2825
00:33
with understanding mental illness in humans.
6
17897
4462
00:38
Yeah. I thought so. I'm also not surprised.
7
22359
2793
00:41
I can see I've got my work cut out for me here.
8
25152
3320
00:44
As we heard from Dr. Insel this morning,
9
28472
2588
00:46
psychiatric disorders like autism, depression and schizophrenia
10
31060
4213
00:51
take a terrible toll on human suffering.
11
35273
2875
00:54
We know much less about their treatment
12
38148
3213
00:57
and the understanding of their basic mechanisms
13
41361
2606
00:59
than we do about diseases of the body.
14
43967
2619
01:02
Think about it: In 2013,
15
46586
2643
01:05
the second decade of the millennium,
16
49229
1955
01:07
if you're concerned about a cancer diagnosis
17
51184
2365
01:09
and you go to your doctor, you get bone scans,
18
53549
2519
01:11
biopsies and blood tests.
19
56068
2928
01:14
In 2013, if you're concerned about a depression diagnosis,
20
58996
3865
01:18
you go to your doctor, and what do you get?
21
62861
1963
01:20
A questionnaire.
22
64824
1987
01:22
Now, part of the reason for this is that we have
23
66811
2429
01:25
an oversimplified and increasingly outmoded view
24
69240
3823
01:28
of the biological basis of psychiatric disorders.
25
73063
3887
01:32
We tend to view them --
26
76950
1243
01:34
and the popular press aids and abets this view --
27
78193
2845
01:36
as chemical imbalances in the brain,
28
81038
3016
01:39
as if the brain were some kind of bag of chemical soup
29
84054
3684
01:43
full of dopamine, serotonin and norepinephrine.
30
87738
4200
01:47
This view is conditioned by the fact
31
91938
2327
01:50
that many of the drugs that are prescribed to treat these disorders,
32
94265
3406
01:53
like Prozac, act by globally changing brain chemistry,
33
97671
4671
01:58
as if the brain were indeed a bag of chemical soup.
34
102342
3976
02:02
But that can't be the answer,
35
106318
1901
02:04
because these drugs actually don't work all that well.
36
108219
3237
02:07
A lot of people won't take them, or stop taking them,
37
111456
3176
02:10
because of their unpleasant side effects.
38
114632
2657
02:13
These drugs have so many side effects
39
117289
2060
02:15
because using them to treat a complex psychiatric disorder
40
119349
3956
02:19
is a bit like trying to change your engine oil
41
123305
2689
02:21
by opening a can and pouring it all over the engine block.
42
125994
4113
02:26
Some of it will dribble into the right place,
43
130107
2150
02:28
but a lot of it will do more harm than good.
44
132257
3101
02:31
Now, an emerging view
45
135358
2238
02:33
that you also heard about from Dr. Insel this morning,
46
137596
2950
02:36
is that psychiatric disorders are actually
47
140546
2570
02:39
disturbances of neural circuits that mediate
48
143116
3474
02:42
emotion, mood and affect.
49
146590
3519
02:46
When we think about cognition,
50
150109
1762
02:47
we analogize the brain to a computer. That's no problem.
51
151871
3576
02:51
Well it turns out that the computer analogy
52
155447
2581
02:53
is just as valid for emotion.
53
158028
2383
02:56
It's just that we don't tend to think about it that way.
54
160411
2786
02:59
But we know much less about the circuit basis
55
163197
3283
03:02
of psychiatric disorders
56
166480
1899
03:04
because of the overwhelming dominance
57
168379
2070
03:06
of this chemical imbalance hypothesis.
58
170449
3352
03:09
Now, it's not that chemicals are not important
59
173801
3827
03:13
in psychiatric disorders.
60
177628
1537
03:15
It's just that they don't bathe the brain like soup.
61
179165
3972
03:19
Rather, they're released in very specific locations
62
183137
3649
03:22
and they act on specific synapses
63
186786
2725
03:25
to change the flow of information in the brain.
64
189511
3688
03:29
So if we ever really want to understand
65
193199
2437
03:31
the biological basis of psychiatric disorders,
66
195636
2705
03:34
we need to pinpoint these locations in the brain
67
198341
3032
03:37
where these chemicals act.
68
201373
1734
03:39
Otherwise, we're going to keep pouring oil all over our mental engines
69
203107
3479
03:42
and suffering the consequences.
70
206586
2957
03:45
Now to begin to overcome our ignorance
71
209543
3059
03:48
of the role of brain chemistry in brain circuitry,
72
212602
3534
03:52
it's helpful to work on what we biologists call
73
216136
2680
03:54
"model organisms,"
74
218816
1579
03:56
animals like fruit flies and laboratory mice,
75
220395
3334
03:59
in which we can apply powerful genetic techniques
76
223729
3425
04:03
to molecularly identify and pinpoint
77
227154
3625
04:06
specific classes of neurons,
78
230779
1563
04:08
as you heard about in Allan Jones's talk this morning.
79
232342
2903
04:11
Moreover, once we can do that,
80
235245
2461
04:13
we can actually activate specific neurons
81
237706
2749
04:16
or we can destroy or inhibit the activity of those neurons.
82
240455
4211
04:20
So if we inhibit a particular type of neuron,
83
244666
2714
04:23
and we find that a behavior is blocked,
84
247380
2465
04:25
we can conclude that those neurons
85
249845
2214
04:27
are necessary for that behavior.
86
252059
2964
04:30
On the other hand, if we activate a group of neurons
87
255023
2382
04:33
and we find that that produces the behavior,
88
257405
2814
04:36
we can conclude that those neurons are sufficient for the behavior.
89
260219
4074
04:40
So in this way, by doing this kind of test,
90
264293
3009
04:43
we can draw cause and effect relationships
91
267302
3523
04:46
between the activity of specific neurons
92
270825
2356
04:49
in particular circuits and particular behaviors,
93
273181
2913
04:51
something that is extremely difficult, if not impossible,
94
276094
2437
04:54
to do right now in humans.
95
278531
5051
04:59
But can an organism like a fruit fly, which is --
96
283582
2837
05:02
it's a great model organism
97
286419
2200
05:04
because it's got a small brain,
98
288619
2538
05:07
it's capable of complex and sophisticated behaviors,
99
291157
3787
05:10
it breeds quickly, and it's cheap.
100
294944
3150
05:13
But can an organism like this
101
298094
1795
05:15
teach us anything about emotion-like states?
102
299889
3843
05:19
Do these organisms even have emotion-like states,
103
303732
3300
05:22
or are they just little digital robots?
104
307032
3363
05:26
Charles Darwin believed that insects have emotion
105
310395
3200
05:29
and express them in their behaviors, as he wrote
106
313595
2550
05:32
in his 1872 monograph on the expression of the emotions in man and animals.
107
316145
5193
05:37
And my eponymous colleague, Seymour Benzer, believed it as well.
108
321338
3519
05:40
Seymour is the man that introduced the use of drosophila
109
324857
3414
05:44
here at CalTech in the '60s as a model organism
110
328271
3523
05:47
to study the connection between genes and behavior.
111
331794
3597
05:51
Seymour recruited me to CalTech in the late 1980s.
112
335391
3607
05:54
He was my Jedi and my rabbi while he was here,
113
338998
4434
05:59
and Seymour taught me both to love flies
114
343432
2388
06:01
and also to play with science.
115
345820
3049
06:04
So how do we ask this question?
116
348869
3116
06:07
It's one thing to believe that flies have emotion-like states,
117
351985
4060
06:11
but how do we actually find out whether that's true or not?
118
356045
3163
06:15
Now, in humans we often infer emotional states,
119
359208
3950
06:19
as you'll hear later today, from facial expressions.
120
363158
3905
06:22
However, it's a little difficult to do that in fruit flies.
121
367063
3720
06:26
(Laughter)
122
370783
3313
06:29
It's kind of like landing on Mars
123
374096
3137
06:33
and looking out the window of your spaceship
124
377233
2705
06:35
at all the little green men who are surrounding it
125
379938
2470
06:38
and trying to figure out, "How do I find out
126
382408
2406
06:40
if they have emotions or not?"
127
384814
2355
06:43
What can we do? It's not so easy.
128
387169
3543
06:46
Well, one of the ways that we can start
129
390712
2185
06:48
is to try to come up with some general characteristics
130
392897
4125
06:52
or properties of emotion-like states
131
397022
3748
06:56
such as arousal, and see if we can identify
132
400770
3464
07:00
any fly behaviors that might exhibit some of those properties.
133
404234
5376
07:05
So three important ones that I can think of
134
409610
2820
07:08
are persistence, gradations in intensity, and valence.
135
412430
4672
07:13
Persistence means long-lasting.
136
417102
2334
07:15
We all know that the stimulus that triggers an emotion
137
419436
3961
07:19
causes that emotion to last long after the stimulus is gone.
138
423397
5016
07:24
Gradations of intensity means what it sounds like.
139
428413
3090
07:27
You can dial up the intensity or dial down the intensity of an emotion.
140
431503
4583
07:31
If you're a little bit unhappy, the corners of your mouth
141
436086
2600
07:34
turn down and you sniffle,
142
438686
1687
07:36
and if you're very unhappy, tears pour down your face
143
440373
3138
07:39
and you might sob.
144
443511
1832
07:41
Valence means good or bad, positive or negative.
145
445343
4379
07:45
So we decided to see if flies could be provoked into showing
146
449722
4452
07:50
the kind of behavior that you see
147
454174
2451
07:52
by the proverbial wasp at the picnic table,
148
456625
2810
07:55
you know, the one that keeps coming back to your hamburger
149
459435
2685
07:58
the more vigorously you try to swat it away,
150
462120
2529
08:00
and it seems to keep getting irritated.
151
464649
2284
08:02
So we built a device, which we call a puff-o-mat,
152
466933
3647
08:06
in which we could deliver little brief air puffs to fruit flies
153
470580
4345
08:10
in these plastic tubes in our laboratory bench
154
474925
2776
08:13
and blow them away.
155
477701
1725
08:15
And what we found is that if we gave these flies
156
479426
3239
08:18
in the puff-o-mat several puffs in a row,
157
482665
2848
08:21
they became somewhat hyperactive
158
485513
2689
08:24
and continued to run around for some time after the air puffs actually stopped
159
488202
4435
08:28
and took a while to calm down.
160
492637
2864
08:31
So we quantified this behavior
161
495501
2189
08:33
using custom locomotor tracking software
162
497690
3012
08:36
developed with my collaborator Pietro Perona,
163
500702
2800
08:39
who's in the electrical engineering division here at CalTech.
164
503502
3612
08:43
And what this quantification showed us is that,
165
507114
2814
08:45
upon experiencing a train of these air puffs,
166
509928
3224
08:49
the flies appear to enter a kind of state of hyperactivity
167
513152
4314
08:53
which is persistent, long-lasting,
168
517466
2598
08:55
and also appears to be graded.
169
520064
2504
08:58
More puffs, or more intense puffs,
170
522568
2859
09:01
make the state last for a longer period of time.
171
525427
3913
09:05
So now we wanted to try to understand something
172
529340
2036
09:07
about what controls the duration of this state.
173
531376
3714
09:10
So we decided to use our puff-o-mat
174
535090
2851
09:13
and our automated tracking software
175
537941
2055
09:15
to screen through hundreds of lines of mutant fruit flies
176
539996
3782
09:19
to see if we could find any that showed abnormal responses to the air puffs.
177
543778
5079
09:24
And this is one of the great things about fruit flies.
178
548857
2347
09:27
There are repositories where you can just pick up the phone
179
551204
2793
09:29
and order hundreds of vials of flies of different mutants
180
553997
3641
09:33
and screen them in your assay and then find out
181
557638
2172
09:35
what gene is affected in the mutation.
182
559810
3319
09:39
So doing the screen, we discovered one mutant
183
563129
3512
09:42
that took much longer than normal to calm down
184
566641
3474
09:46
after the air puffs,
185
570115
2277
09:48
and when we examined the gene that was affected in this mutation,
186
572392
3950
09:52
it turned out to encode a dopamine receptor.
187
576342
3605
09:55
That's right -- flies, like people, have dopamine,
188
579947
3011
09:58
and it acts on their brains and on their synapses
189
582958
2772
10:01
through the same dopamine receptor molecules
190
585730
2550
10:04
that you and I have.
191
588280
2389
10:06
Dopamine plays a number of important functions in the brain,
192
590669
3486
10:10
including in attention, arousal, reward,
193
594155
3113
10:13
and disorders of the dopamine system have been linked
194
597268
3413
10:16
to a number of mental disorders including drug abuse,
195
600681
3100
10:19
Parkinson's disease, and ADHD.
196
603781
4234
10:23
Now, in genetics, it's a little counterintuitive.
197
608015
2790
10:26
We tend to infer the normal function of something
198
610805
3260
10:29
by what doesn't happen when we take it away,
199
614065
3710
10:33
by the opposite of what we see when we take it away.
200
617775
3003
10:36
So when we take away the dopamine receptor
201
620778
3013
10:39
and the flies take longer to calm down,
202
623791
2557
10:42
from that we infer that the normal function of this receptor and dopamine
203
626348
3846
10:46
is to cause the flies to calm down faster after the puff.
204
630194
4485
10:50
And that's a bit reminiscent of ADHD,
205
634679
2950
10:53
which has been linked to disorders of the dopamine system in humans.
206
637629
3975
10:57
Indeed, if we increase the levels of dopamine in normal flies
207
641604
4606
11:02
by feeding them cocaine
208
646210
1710
11:03
after getting the appropriate DEA license
209
647920
2972
11:06
— oh my God -- (Laughter) —
210
650892
4000
11:10
we find indeed that these cocaine-fed flies
211
654892
3172
11:13
calm down faster than normal flies do,
212
658064
3042
11:17
and that's also reminiscent of ADHD,
213
661106
3199
11:20
which is often treated with drugs like Ritalin
214
664305
2045
11:22
that act similarly to cocaine.
215
666350
3019
11:25
So slowly I began to realize that what started out
216
669369
3149
11:28
as a rather playful attempt to try to annoy fruit flies
217
672518
3649
11:32
might actually have some relevance to a human psychiatric disorder.
218
676167
3976
11:36
Now, how far does this analogy go?
219
680143
2226
11:38
As many of you know, individuals afflicted with ADHD
220
682369
3122
11:41
also have learning disabilities.
221
685491
2337
11:43
Is that true of our dopamine receptor mutant flies?
222
687828
3566
11:47
Remarkably, the answer is yes.
223
691394
2720
11:50
As Seymour showed back in the 1970s,
224
694114
2628
11:52
flies, like songbirds, as you just heard,
225
696742
2451
11:55
are capable of learning.
226
699193
1733
11:56
You can train a fly to avoid an odor, shown here in blue,
227
700926
4443
12:01
if you pair that odor with a shock.
228
705369
2388
12:03
Then when you give those trained flies the chance to choose
229
707757
3384
12:07
between a tube with the shock-paired odor and another odor,
230
711141
3154
12:10
it avoids the tube containing the blue odor that was paired with shock.
231
714295
4200
12:14
Well, if you do this test on dopamine receptor mutant flies,
232
718495
3502
12:17
they don't learn. Their learning score is zero.
233
721997
2465
12:20
They flunk out of CalTech.
234
724462
3811
12:24
So that means that these flies have two abnormalities,
235
728273
4748
12:28
or phenotypes, as we geneticists call them,
236
733021
3050
12:31
that one finds in ADHD: hyperactivity and learning disability.
237
736071
5512
12:37
Now what's the causal relationship, if anything, between these phenotypes?
238
741583
4363
12:41
In ADHD, it's often assumed that the hyperactivity
239
745946
3913
12:45
causes the learning disability.
240
749859
1906
12:47
The kids can't sit still long enough to focus, so they don't learn.
241
751765
3719
12:51
But it could equally be the case that it's the learning disabilities
242
755484
3296
12:54
that cause the hyperactivity.
243
758780
1872
12:56
Because the kids can't learn, they look for other things to distract their attention.
244
760652
4470
13:01
And a final possibility is that there's no relationship at all
245
765122
3057
13:04
between learning disabilities and hyperactivity,
246
768179
2404
13:06
but that they are caused by a common underlying mechanism in ADHD.
247
770583
4915
13:11
Now people have been wondering about this for a long time
248
775498
2342
13:13
in humans, but in flies we can actually test this.
249
777840
3488
13:17
And the way that we do this is to delve deeply into the mind
250
781328
3084
13:20
of the fly and begin to untangle its circuitry using genetics.
251
784412
4266
13:24
We take our dopamine receptor mutant flies
252
788678
2462
13:27
and we genetically restore, or cure, the dopamine receptor
253
791140
4564
13:31
by putting a good copy of the dopamine receptor gene
254
795704
3235
13:34
back into the fly brain.
255
798939
2051
13:36
But in each fly, we put it back only into certain neurons
256
800990
3835
13:40
and not in others, and then we test each of these flies
257
804825
3714
13:44
for their ability to learn and for hyperactivity.
258
808539
3668
13:48
Remarkably, we find we can completely dissociate these two abnormalities.
259
812207
4818
13:52
If we put a good copy of the dopamine receptor back
260
817025
2663
13:55
in this elliptical structure called the central complex,
261
819688
2961
13:58
the flies are no longer hyperactive, but they still can't learn.
262
822649
4077
14:02
On the other hand, if we put the receptor back in a different structure
263
826726
2726
14:05
called the mushroom body,
264
829452
1518
14:06
the learning deficit is rescued, the flies learn well,
265
830970
3085
14:09
but they're still hyperactive.
266
834055
1830
14:11
What that tells us is that dopamine
267
835885
2250
14:14
is not bathing the brain of these flies like soup.
268
838135
3392
14:17
Rather, it's acting to control two different functions
269
841527
3162
14:20
on two different circuits,
270
844689
1634
14:22
so the reason there are two things wrong with our dopamine receptor flies
271
846323
3904
14:26
is that the same receptor is controlling two different functions
272
850227
4175
14:30
in two different regions of the brain.
273
854402
2863
14:33
Whether the same thing is true in ADHD in humans
274
857265
3062
14:36
we don't know, but these kinds of results
275
860327
2376
14:38
should at least cause us to consider that possibility.
276
862703
3477
14:42
So these results make me and my colleagues more convinced than ever
277
866180
3973
14:46
that the brain is not a bag of chemical soup,
278
870153
3412
14:49
and it's a mistake to try to treat complex psychiatric disorders
279
873565
3527
14:52
just by changing the flavor of the soup.
280
877092
2711
14:55
What we need to do is to use our ingenuity and our scientific knowledge
281
879803
4217
14:59
to try to design a new generation of treatments
282
884020
2708
15:02
that are targeted to specific neurons and specific regions of the brain
283
886728
4288
15:06
that are affected in particular psychiatric disorders.
284
891016
3338
15:10
If we can do that, we may be able to cure these disorders
285
894354
3200
15:13
without the unpleasant side effects,
286
897554
2047
15:15
putting the oil back in our mental engines,
287
899601
2746
15:18
just where it's needed. Thank you very much.
288
902347
3184
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
David Anderson - NeurobiologistThrough his lab at the California Institute of Technology, David Anderson seeks to find the neural underpinnings of emotions like fear, anxiety and anger.
Why you should listen
How is emotional behavior encoded in the brain? And what parts of the brain are affected by depression, ADHD and anxiety? This is what neurobiologist David Anderson researches in his lab at the California Institute for Technology by studying the brains of lab mice and fruit flies. By looking at how neural circuits give rise to emotions, Anderson hopes to advance a more nuanced view of psychiatric disorders -- that they aren’t the result of a simple “chemical imbalance,” but of a chemical imbalance at a specific site that has a specific emotional consequences. By researching these cause-and-effect relationships, Anderson hopes to pave the way for the development of new treatments for psychiatric disorders that are far more targeted and have far fewer side effects.
Trained by two Nobel laureates, Gunter Blobel and Richard Axel, Anderson is also an investigator at the Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
David Anderson | Speaker | TED.com