TEDGlobal 2013
Benjamin Barber: Why mayors should rule the world
Filmed:
Readability: 4.6
815,036 views
It often seems like federal-level politicians care more about creating gridlock than solving the world's problems. So who's actually getting bold things done? City mayors. So, political theorist Benjamin Barber suggests: Let's give them more control over global policy. Barber shows how these "urban homeboys" are solving pressing problems on their own turf -- and maybe in the world.
Benjamin Barber - Political theorist
Benjamin Barber suggested that the future of the world may lie with the politicians who implement practical change every day: mayors. Full bio
Benjamin Barber suggested that the future of the world may lie with the politicians who implement practical change every day: mayors. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Democracy is in trouble, no question about that,
0
637
3503
00:16
and it comes in part from a deep dilemma
1
4140
3242
00:19
in which it is embedded.
2
7398
2672
00:22
It's increasingly irrelevant to the kinds of decisions
3
10070
3747
00:25
we face that have to do with global pandemics,
4
13817
3525
00:29
a cross-border problem;
5
17342
2109
00:31
with HIV, a transnational problem;
6
19451
3423
00:34
with markets and immigration,
7
22874
2075
00:36
something that goes beyond national borders;
8
24949
2554
00:39
with terrorism, with war,
9
27503
2273
00:41
all now cross-border problems.
10
29776
2647
00:44
In fact, we live in a 21st-century world
11
32423
3755
00:48
of interdependence,
12
36178
2205
00:50
and brutal interdependent problems,
13
38383
3523
00:53
and when we look for solutions in politics and in democracy,
14
41906
5644
00:59
we are faced with political institutions
15
47550
3188
01:02
designed 400 years ago,
16
50738
3453
01:06
autonomous, sovereign nation-states
17
54191
4478
01:10
with jurisdictions and territories
18
58669
2562
01:13
separate from one another,
19
61231
1759
01:14
each claiming to be able to solve the problem
20
62990
2933
01:17
of its own people.
21
65923
2073
01:19
Twenty-first-century, transnational world
22
67996
3296
01:23
of problems and challenges,
23
71292
1742
01:25
17th-century world of political institutions.
24
73034
3976
01:29
In that dilemma lies the central problem of democracy.
25
77010
6380
01:35
And like many others, I've been thinking about
26
83390
1846
01:37
what can one do about this, this asymmetry
27
85236
3468
01:40
between 21st-century challenges
28
88704
1993
01:42
and archaic and increasingly dysfunctional
29
90697
4055
01:46
political institutions like nation-states.
30
94752
3499
01:50
And my suggestion is
31
98251
1704
01:51
that we change the subject,
32
99955
3621
01:55
that we stop talking about nations,
33
103576
4112
01:59
about bordered states,
34
107688
1416
02:01
and we start talking about cities.
35
109104
3967
02:05
Because I think you will find, when we talk about cities,
36
113071
3358
02:08
we are talking about the political institutions
37
116429
4057
02:12
in which civilization and culture were born.
38
120486
2821
02:15
We are talking about the cradle of democracy.
39
123307
3165
02:18
We are talking about the venues in which
40
126472
2558
02:21
those public spaces where we come together
41
129030
3213
02:24
to create democracy, and at the same time
42
132243
4067
02:28
protest those who would take our freedom, take place.
43
136310
4963
02:33
Think of some great names:
44
141273
2634
02:35
the Place de la Bastille,
45
143907
2693
02:38
Zuccotti Park,
46
146600
1967
02:40
Tahrir Square,
47
148567
2166
02:42
Taksim Square in today's headlines in Istanbul,
48
150733
4306
02:47
or, yes,
49
155039
2360
02:49
Tiananmen Square in Beijing.
50
157399
2792
02:52
(Applause)
51
160191
1706
02:53
Those are the public spaces
52
161897
2926
02:56
where we announce ourselves as citizens,
53
164823
3365
03:00
as participants, as people with the right
54
168188
3446
03:03
to write our own narratives.
55
171634
4275
03:07
Cities are not only the oldest of institutions,
56
175909
2678
03:10
they're the most enduring.
57
178587
1968
03:12
If you think about it,
58
180555
2172
03:14
Constantinople, Istanbul, much older than Turkey.
59
182727
3969
03:18
Alexandria, much older than Egypt.
60
186696
3110
03:21
Rome, far older than Italy.
61
189806
3950
03:25
Cities endure the ages.
62
193756
3608
03:29
They are the places where we are born,
63
197364
4783
03:34
grow up, are educated, work, marry,
64
202147
4336
03:38
pray, play, get old, and in time, die.
65
206483
4859
03:43
They are home.
66
211342
2128
03:45
Very different than nation-states,
67
213470
2056
03:47
which are abstractions.
68
215526
1341
03:48
We pay taxes, we vote occasionally,
69
216867
4122
03:52
we watch the men and women we choose rule
70
220989
3375
03:56
rule more or less without us.
71
224364
3224
03:59
Not so in those homes known as our towns
72
227588
4308
04:03
and cities where we live.
73
231896
1799
04:05
Moreover, today, more than half of the world's population
74
233695
5049
04:10
live in cities.
75
238744
2007
04:12
In the developed world, it's about 78 percent.
76
240751
3972
04:16
More than three out of four people
77
244723
1995
04:18
live in urban institutions, urban places,
78
246718
4040
04:22
in cities today.
79
250758
1608
04:24
So cities are where the action is.
80
252366
2776
04:27
Cities are us. Aristotle said in the ancient world,
81
255142
3116
04:30
man is a political animal.
82
258258
3581
04:33
I say we are an urban animal.
83
261839
3027
04:36
We are an urban species, at home in our cities.
84
264866
4865
04:41
So to come back to the dilemma,
85
269731
2152
04:43
if the dilemma is we have old-fashioned
86
271883
2518
04:46
political nation-states unable to govern the world,
87
274401
3784
04:50
respond to the global challenges that we face
88
278185
3014
04:53
like climate change,
89
281199
2160
04:55
then maybe it's time for mayors to rule the world,
90
283359
6042
05:01
for mayors and the citizens and the peoples they represent
91
289401
3209
05:04
to engage in global governance.
92
292610
5885
05:10
When I say if mayors ruled the world,
93
298495
1831
05:12
when I first came up with that phrase,
94
300326
2268
05:14
it occurred to me that actually, they already do.
95
302594
3906
05:18
There are scores of international, inter-city,
96
306500
4798
05:23
cross-border institutions, networks of cities
97
311298
4262
05:27
in which cities are already, quite quietly,
98
315560
3045
05:30
below the horizon, working together
99
318605
2827
05:33
to deal with climate change, to deal with security,
100
321432
2697
05:36
to deal with immigration,
101
324129
1388
05:37
to deal with all of those tough,
102
325517
1659
05:39
interdependent problems that we face.
103
327176
2806
05:41
They have strange names:
104
329982
3456
05:45
UCLG,
105
333438
3370
05:48
United Cities and Local Governments;
106
336808
4626
05:53
ICLEI,
107
341434
1800
05:55
the International Council for Local Environmental Issues.
108
343234
5516
06:00
And the list goes on:
109
348750
1210
06:01
Citynet in Asia; City Protocol, a new organization
110
349960
3547
06:05
out of Barcelona that is using the web
111
353507
3485
06:08
to share best practices among countries.
112
356992
3077
06:12
And then all the things we know a little better,
113
360069
1416
06:13
the U.S. Conference of Mayors,
114
361485
1291
06:14
the Mexican Conference of Mayors,
115
362776
2036
06:16
the European Conference of Mayors.
116
364812
3566
06:20
Mayors are where this is happening.
117
368378
4983
06:25
And so the question is,
118
373361
2529
06:27
how can we create a world
119
375890
1754
06:29
in which mayors and the citizens they represent
120
377644
3615
06:33
play a more prominent role?
121
381259
2466
06:35
Well, to understand that,
122
383725
2950
06:38
we need to understand why cities are special,
123
386675
3798
06:42
why mayors are so different
124
390473
1895
06:44
than prime ministers and presidents,
125
392368
1488
06:45
because my premise is that a mayor and a prime minister
126
393856
4348
06:50
are at the opposite ends of a political spectrum.
127
398204
4279
06:54
To be a prime minister or a president,
128
402483
2408
06:56
you have to have an ideology,
129
404891
2159
06:59
you have to have a meta-narrative,
130
407050
2062
07:01
you have to have a theory of how things work,
131
409112
2522
07:03
you have to belong to a party.
132
411634
2035
07:05
Independents, on the whole,
133
413669
1557
07:07
don't get elected to office.
134
415226
1750
07:08
But mayors are just the opposite.
135
416976
2233
07:11
Mayors are pragmatists, they're problem-solvers.
136
419209
4449
07:15
Their job is to get things done, and if they don't,
137
423658
1963
07:17
they're out of a job.
138
425621
2719
07:20
Mayor Nutter of Philadelphia said,
139
428340
2738
07:23
we could never get away here in Philadelphia
140
431078
3582
07:26
with the stuff that goes on in Washington,
141
434660
2310
07:28
the paralysis, the non-action, the inaction.
142
436970
5015
07:33
Why? Because potholes have to get filled,
143
441985
4459
07:38
because the trains have to run,
144
446444
1899
07:40
because kids have to be able to get to school.
145
448343
2949
07:43
And that's what we have to do,
146
451292
1296
07:44
and to do that is about pragmatism
147
452588
2939
07:47
in that deep, American sense,
148
455527
1972
07:49
reaching outcomes.
149
457499
1930
07:51
Washington, Beijing, Paris, as world capitals,
150
459429
6109
07:57
are anything but pragmatic,
151
465538
3312
08:00
but real city mayors have to be pragmatists.
152
468850
2919
08:03
They have to get things done,
153
471769
1724
08:05
they have to put ideology and religion and ethnicity aside
154
473493
3397
08:08
and draw their cities together.
155
476890
2364
08:11
We saw this a couple of decades ago
156
479254
2670
08:13
when Teddy Kollek, the great mayor of Jerusalem
157
481924
3075
08:16
in the '80s and the '90s,
158
484999
2105
08:19
was besieged one day in his office
159
487104
3303
08:22
by religious leaders from all of the backgrounds,
160
490407
4663
08:27
Christian prelates, rabbis, imams.
161
495070
2835
08:29
They were arguing with one another
162
497905
1499
08:31
about access to the holy sites.
163
499404
2126
08:33
And the squabble went on and on,
164
501530
1779
08:35
and Kollek listened and listened,
165
503309
1842
08:37
and he finally said, "Gentlemen,
166
505151
4302
08:41
spare me your sermons,
167
509453
2156
08:43
and I will fix your sewers."
168
511609
3044
08:46
(Laughter)
169
514653
1021
08:47
That's what mayors do.
170
515674
2064
08:49
They fix sewers, they get the trains running.
171
517738
3420
08:53
There isn't a left or a right way of doing.
172
521158
2548
08:55
Boris Johnson in London calls himself an anarcho-Tory.
173
523706
4477
09:00
Strange term, but in some ways, he is.
174
528183
1875
09:02
He's a libertarian. He's an anarchist.
175
530058
2433
09:04
He rides to work on a bike,
176
532491
1489
09:05
but at the same time, he's in some ways a conservative.
177
533980
2847
09:08
Bloomberg in New York was a Democrat,
178
536827
3240
09:12
then he was a Republican,
179
540067
818
09:12
and finally he was an Independent, and said
180
540885
1837
09:14
the party label just gets in the way.
181
542722
2421
09:17
Luzhkov, 20 years mayor in Moscow,
182
545143
3115
09:20
though he helped found a party, United Party with Putin,
183
548258
3460
09:23
in fact refused to be defined by the party
184
551718
3296
09:27
and finally, in fact, lost his job not under Brezhnev,
185
555014
3290
09:30
not under Gorbachev, but under Putin,
186
558304
2873
09:33
who wanted a more faithful party follower.
187
561177
4153
09:37
So mayors are pragmatists and problem-solvers.
188
565330
4114
09:41
They get things done.
189
569444
1373
09:42
But the second thing about mayors
190
570817
1409
09:44
is they are also what I like to call homeboys,
191
572226
4181
09:48
or to include the women mayors, homies.
192
576407
2640
09:51
They're from the neighborhood.
193
579047
2663
09:53
They're part of the neighborhood. They're known.
194
581710
1807
09:55
Ed Koch used to wander around New York City
195
583517
2275
09:57
saying, "How am I doing?"
196
585792
2516
10:00
Imagine David Cameron
197
588308
1655
10:01
wandering around the United Kingdom
198
589963
1950
10:03
asking, "How am I doing?" He wouldn't like the answer.
199
591913
2478
10:06
Or Putin. Or any national leader.
200
594391
2718
10:09
He could ask that because he knew New Yorkers
201
597109
2012
10:11
and they knew him.
202
599121
1876
10:12
Mayors are usually from the places they govern.
203
600997
3866
10:16
It's pretty hard to be a carpetbagger and be a mayor.
204
604863
2804
10:19
You can run for the Senate out of a different state,
205
607667
1814
10:21
but it's hard to do that as a mayor.
206
609481
2926
10:24
And as a result, mayors and city councillors
207
612407
3084
10:27
and local authorities
208
615491
1737
10:29
have a much higher trust level,
209
617228
2251
10:31
and this is the third feature about mayors,
210
619479
2528
10:34
than national governing officials.
211
622007
2373
10:36
In the United States, we know the pathetic figures:
212
624380
3585
10:39
18 percent of Americans approve of Congress
213
627965
4459
10:44
and what they do.
214
632424
1502
10:45
And even with a relatively popular president like Obama,
215
633926
3599
10:49
the figures for the Presidency run about 40, 45,
216
637525
3096
10:52
sometimes 50 percent at best.
217
640621
1785
10:54
The Supreme Court has fallen way down from what it used to be.
218
642406
3169
10:57
But when you ask, "Do you trust your city councillor,
219
645575
3450
11:01
do you trust your mayor?"
220
649025
2176
11:03
the rates shoot up to 70, 75, even 80 percent,
221
651201
5153
11:08
because they're from the neighborhood,
222
656354
2145
11:10
because the people they work with are their neighbors,
223
658499
2917
11:13
because, like Mayor Booker in Newark,
224
661416
3417
11:16
a mayor is likely to get out of his car on the way to work
225
664833
3199
11:20
and go in and pull people out of a burning building --
226
668032
2754
11:22
that happened to Mayor Booker --
227
670786
2338
11:25
or intervene in a mugging in the street as he goes to work
228
673124
2941
11:28
because he sees it.
229
676065
1332
11:29
No head of state would be permitted
230
677397
2383
11:31
by their security details to do it,
231
679780
1852
11:33
nor be in a position to do it.
232
681632
2218
11:35
That's the difference, and the difference
233
683850
1539
11:37
has to do with the character of cities themselves,
234
685389
2165
11:39
because cities are profoundly multicultural,
235
687554
6621
11:46
open, participatory, democratic,
236
694175
4335
11:50
able to work with one another.
237
698510
2654
11:53
When states face each other,
238
701164
2826
11:55
China and the U.S., they face each other like this.
239
703990
4290
12:00
When cities interact, they interact like this.
240
708280
4603
12:04
China and the U.S., despite the recent
241
712883
3307
12:08
meta-meeting in California,
242
716190
2611
12:10
are locked in all kinds of anger, resentment, and rivalry
243
718801
4765
12:15
for number one.
244
723566
1241
12:16
We heard more about who will be number one.
245
724807
2977
12:19
Cities don't worry about number one.
246
727784
2151
12:21
They have to work together, and they do work together.
247
729935
2183
12:24
They work together in climate change, for example.
248
732118
3611
12:27
Organizations like the C40, like ICLEI, which I mentioned,
249
735729
3506
12:31
have been working together
250
739235
1884
12:33
many, many years before Copenhagen.
251
741119
2190
12:35
In Copenhagen, four or five years ago,
252
743309
2521
12:37
184 nations came together to explain to one another
253
745830
3394
12:41
why their sovereignty didn't permit them
254
749224
2245
12:43
to deal with the grave, grave crisis of climate change,
255
751469
4302
12:47
but the mayor of Copenhagen had invited
256
755771
3276
12:51
200 mayors to attend.
257
759047
1722
12:52
They came, they stayed, and they found ways
258
760769
3060
12:55
and are still finding ways to work together,
259
763829
3091
12:58
city-to-city, and through inter-city organizations.
260
766920
3449
13:02
Eighty percent of carbon emissions come from cities,
261
770369
3777
13:06
which means cities are in a position
262
774146
1884
13:08
to solve the carbon problem, or most of it,
263
776030
3208
13:11
whether or not the states of which they are a part
264
779238
2788
13:14
make agreements with one another.
265
782026
2058
13:16
And they are doing it.
266
784084
1248
13:17
Los Angeles cleaned up its port,
267
785332
2300
13:19
which was 40 percent of carbon emissions,
268
787632
2575
13:22
and as a result got rid of about 20 percent of carbon.
269
790207
3781
13:25
New York has a program to upgrade its old buildings,
270
793988
2984
13:28
make them better insulated in the winter,
271
796972
3184
13:32
to not leak energy in the summer,
272
800156
1943
13:34
not leak air conditioning. That's having an impact.
273
802099
2947
13:37
Bogota, where Mayor Mockus,
274
805046
1894
13:38
when he was mayor, he introduced a transportation system
275
806940
4236
13:43
that saved energy, that allowed surface buses
276
811176
4452
13:47
to run in effect like subways,
277
815628
1535
13:49
express buses with corridors.
278
817163
1916
13:51
It helped unemployment, because people could get across town,
279
819079
3286
13:54
and it had a profound impact on climate as well as
280
822365
3856
13:58
many other things there.
281
826221
1071
13:59
Singapore, as it developed its high-rises
282
827292
2854
14:02
and its remarkable public housing,
283
830146
1705
14:03
also developed an island of parks,
284
831851
3493
14:07
and if you go there, you'll see how much of it
285
835344
1716
14:09
is green land and park land.
286
837060
1541
14:10
Cities are doing this, but not just one by one.
287
838601
2508
14:13
They are doing it together.
288
841109
1585
14:14
They are sharing what they do,
289
842694
3658
14:18
and they are making a difference by shared best practices.
290
846352
3969
14:22
Bike shares, many of you have heard of it,
291
850321
1632
14:23
started 20 or 30 years ago in Latin America.
292
851953
2303
14:26
Now it's in hundreds of cities around the world.
293
854256
2344
14:28
Pedestrian zones, congestion fees,
294
856600
3291
14:31
emission limits in cities like California cities have,
295
859891
3710
14:35
there's lots and lots that cities can do
296
863601
2304
14:37
even when opaque, stubborn nations refuse to act.
297
865905
9360
14:47
So what's the bottom line here?
298
875265
3968
14:51
The bottom line is, we still live politically
299
879233
3747
14:54
in a world of borders, a world of boundaries,
300
882980
2215
14:57
a world of walls,
301
885195
1598
14:58
a world where states refuse to act together.
302
886793
6160
15:04
Yet we know that the reality we experience
303
892953
3793
15:08
day to day is a world without borders,
304
896746
4197
15:12
a world of diseases without borders
305
900943
2474
15:15
and doctors without borders,
306
903417
2300
15:17
maladies sans frontières, Médecins Sans Frontières,
307
905717
4572
15:22
of economics and technology without borders,
308
910289
6071
15:28
of education without borders,
309
916360
2116
15:30
of terrorism and war without borders.
310
918476
3230
15:33
That is the real world, and unless we find a way
311
921706
3214
15:36
to globalize democracy or democratize globalization,
312
924920
5430
15:42
we will increasingly not only risk
313
930350
4368
15:46
the failure to address all of these transnational problems,
314
934718
4081
15:50
but we will risk losing democracy itself,
315
938799
3719
15:54
locked up in the old nation-state box,
316
942518
4626
15:59
unable to address global problems democratically.
317
947144
5693
16:04
So where does that leave us?
318
952837
2994
16:07
I'll tell you. The road to global democracy
319
955831
3011
16:10
doesn't run through states.
320
958842
1971
16:12
It runs through cities.
321
960813
2562
16:15
Democracy was born in the ancient polis.
322
963375
4800
16:20
I believe it can be reborn in the global cosmopolis.
323
968175
5508
16:25
In that journey from polis to cosmopolis,
324
973683
3944
16:29
we can rediscover the power
325
977627
2271
16:31
of democracy on a global level.
326
979898
2123
16:34
We can create not a League of Nations, which failed,
327
982021
4022
16:38
but a League of Cities,
328
986043
1388
16:39
not a United or a dis-United Nations,
329
987431
3112
16:42
but United Cities of the World.
330
990543
2258
16:44
We can create a global parliament of mayors.
331
992801
4087
16:48
That's an idea. It's in my conception of the coming world,
332
996888
4096
16:52
but it's also on the table in City Halls
333
1000984
2682
16:55
in Seoul, Korea, in Amsterdam,
334
1003666
2728
16:58
in Hamburg, and in New York.
335
1006394
2039
17:00
Mayors are considering that idea of how you can actually
336
1008433
2858
17:03
constitute a global parliament of mayors,
337
1011291
3159
17:06
and I love that idea, because a parliament of mayors
338
1014450
2880
17:09
is a parliament of citizens
339
1017330
2146
17:11
and a parliament of citizens is a parliament of us,
340
1019476
3895
17:15
of you and of me.
341
1023371
3131
17:18
If ever there were citizens without borders,
342
1026502
4790
17:23
I think it's the citizens of TED
343
1031292
2143
17:25
who show the promise to be those citizens without borders.
344
1033435
3191
17:28
I am ready to reach out and embrace
345
1036626
4930
17:33
a new global democracy,
346
1041556
2326
17:35
to take back our democracy.
347
1043882
3099
17:38
And the only question is,
348
1046981
2138
17:41
are you?
349
1049119
2059
17:43
Thank you so much, my fellow citizens.
350
1051178
1983
17:45
(Applause)
351
1053161
11190
17:56
Thank you. (Applause)
352
1064351
3766
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Benjamin Barber - Political theoristBenjamin Barber suggested that the future of the world may lie with the politicians who implement practical change every day: mayors.
Why you should listen
A passionate advocate of democracy’s power, Benjamin Barber explored bold solutions for dysfunctional systems and political paralysis. In his 2013 book If Mayors Ruled the World, he showed how decentralized local governments can be more flexible -- and more in tune with their constituents -- than their federal counterparts. The book led to the foundation of the Global Parliament of Mayors, a governance body of, by and for mayors from all continents. It builds on the experience, expertise and leadership of mayors in tackling local challenges resulting from global problems.
Barber burst into the media spotlight on September 11, 2001, when his book Jihad Vs. McWorld, published several years earlier, assumed new relevance. With his prophetic analysis of the emerging collision of tribalism and globalism, Barber established the parameters for 21st-century political debate.
His newest book is Cool Cities: Urban Sovereignty and the Fix for Global Warming.
Benjamin Barber | Speaker | TED.com