TED@State
Stewart Brand: 4 environmental 'heresies'
Filmed:
Readability: 4.1
785,573 views
The man who helped usher in the environmental movement in the 1960s and '70s has been rethinking his positions on cities, nuclear power, genetic modification and geo-engineering. This talk at the US State Department is a foretaste of his major new book, sure to provoke widespread debate.
Stewart Brand - Environmentalist, futurist
Since the counterculture '60s, Stewart Brand has been creating our internet-worked world. Now, with biotech accelerating four times faster than digital technology, Stewart Brand has a bold new plan ... Full bio
Since the counterculture '60s, Stewart Brand has been creating our internet-worked world. Now, with biotech accelerating four times faster than digital technology, Stewart Brand has a bold new plan ... Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Because of what I'm about to say,
0
0
2000
00:18
I really should establish my green credentials.
1
2000
3000
00:21
When I was a small boy, I took my pledge
2
5000
2000
00:23
as an American, to save and faithfully defend from waste
3
7000
3000
00:26
the natural resources of my country,
4
10000
2000
00:28
its air, soil and minerals, its forests, waters and wildlife.
5
12000
3000
00:31
And I've stuck to that.
6
15000
2000
00:33
Stanford, I majored in ecology and evolution.
7
17000
4000
00:37
1968, I put out the Whole Earth Catalog. Was "mister natural" for a while.
8
21000
4000
00:41
And then worked for the Jerry Brown administration.
9
25000
3000
00:44
The Brown administration, and a bunch of my friends,
10
28000
3000
00:47
basically leveled the energy efficiency of California,
11
31000
3000
00:50
so it's the same now, 30 years later,
12
34000
3000
00:53
even though our economy has gone up 80 percent, per capita.
13
37000
4000
00:57
And we are putting out less greenhouse gasses than any other state.
14
41000
3000
01:00
California is basically the equivalent of Europe, in this.
15
44000
3000
01:03
This year, Whole Earth Catalog has a supplement that I'll preview today,
16
47000
5000
01:08
called Whole Earth Discipline.
17
52000
3000
01:11
The dominant demographic event of our time
18
55000
2000
01:13
is this screamingly rapid urbanization
19
57000
3000
01:16
that we have going on.
20
60000
2000
01:18
By mid-century we'll be about 80 percent urban,
21
62000
4000
01:22
and that's mostly in the developing world,
22
66000
3000
01:25
where that's happening.
23
69000
2000
01:27
It's interesting, because history is driven to a large degree
24
71000
3000
01:30
by the size of cities.
25
74000
2000
01:32
The developing world now has all of the biggest cities,
26
76000
3000
01:35
and they are developing three times faster than the developed countries,
27
79000
3000
01:38
and nine times bigger.
28
82000
2000
01:40
It's qualitatively different.
29
84000
3000
01:43
They are the drivers of history, as we see by looking at history.
30
87000
2000
01:45
1,000 years ago this is what the world looked like.
31
89000
4000
01:49
Well we now have a distribution of urban power
32
93000
3000
01:52
similar to what we had 1,000 years ago.
33
96000
3000
01:55
In other words, the rise of the West,
34
99000
2000
01:57
dramatic as it was, is over.
35
101000
4000
02:01
The aggregate numbers are absolutely overwhelming:
36
105000
3000
02:04
1.3 million people a week coming to town,
37
108000
3000
02:07
decade after decade.
38
111000
2000
02:09
What's really going on?
39
113000
2000
02:11
Well, what's going on is the villages of the world are emptying out.
40
115000
3000
02:14
Subsistence farming is drying up basically.
41
118000
3000
02:17
People are following opportunity into town.
42
121000
2000
02:19
And this is why.
43
123000
2000
02:21
I used to have a very romantic idea about villages,
44
125000
2000
02:23
and it's because I never lived in one.
45
127000
3000
02:26
(Laughter)
46
130000
1000
02:27
Because in town --
47
131000
2000
02:29
this is the bustling squatter city
48
133000
2000
02:31
of Kibera, near Nairobi --
49
135000
4000
02:35
they see action. They see opportunity.
50
139000
2000
02:37
They see a cash economy that they were not able to participate in
51
141000
3000
02:40
back in the subsistence farm.
52
144000
3000
02:43
As you go around these places there's plenty of aesthetics.
53
147000
2000
02:45
There is plenty going on.
54
149000
2000
02:47
They are poor, but they are intensely urban. And they are intensely creative.
55
151000
4000
02:51
The aggregate numbers now
56
155000
2000
02:53
are that basically squatters,
57
157000
3000
02:56
all one billion of them, are building the urban world,
58
160000
3000
02:59
which means they're building the world --
59
163000
3000
03:02
personally, one by one, family by family,
60
166000
2000
03:04
clan by clan, neighborhood by neighborhood.
61
168000
3000
03:07
They start flimsy and they get substantial as time goes by.
62
171000
4000
03:11
They even build their own infrastructure.
63
175000
2000
03:13
Well, steal their own infrastructure, at first.
64
177000
3000
03:16
Cable TV, water, the whole gamut, all gets stolen.
65
180000
3000
03:19
And then gradually gentrifies.
66
183000
4000
03:23
It is not the case that slums undermine prosperity,
67
187000
3000
03:26
not the working slums; they help create prosperity.
68
190000
4000
03:30
So in a town like Mumbai, which is half slums,
69
194000
3000
03:33
it's 1/6th of the GDP of India.
70
197000
3000
03:36
Social capital in the slums is at its most urban and dense.
71
200000
5000
03:41
These people are valuable as a group.
72
205000
3000
03:44
And that's how they work.
73
208000
2000
03:46
There is a lot of people who think about all these poor people,
74
210000
3000
03:49
"Oh there's terrible things. We've got to fix their housing."
75
213000
2000
03:51
It used to be, "Oh we've got to get them phone service."
76
215000
2000
03:53
Now they're showing us how they do their phone service.
77
217000
3000
03:56
Famine mostly is a rural event now.
78
220000
2000
03:58
There are things they care about.
79
222000
2000
04:00
And this is where we can help.
80
224000
3000
04:03
And the nations they're in can help.
81
227000
2000
04:05
And they are helping each other solve these issues.
82
229000
3000
04:08
And you go to a nice dense place like this slum in Mumbai.
83
232000
4000
04:12
You look at that lane on the right.
84
236000
2000
04:14
And you can ask, "Okay what's going on there?"
85
238000
2000
04:16
The answer is, "Everything."
86
240000
3000
04:19
This is better than a mall. It's much denser.
87
243000
3000
04:22
It's much more interactive.
88
246000
2000
04:24
And the scale is terrific.
89
248000
2000
04:26
The main event is, these are not people crushed by poverty.
90
250000
4000
04:30
These are people busy getting out of poverty
91
254000
2000
04:32
just as fast as they can.
92
256000
2000
04:34
They're helping each other do it.
93
258000
2000
04:36
They're doing it through an outlaw thing,
94
260000
2000
04:38
the informal economy.
95
262000
2000
04:40
The informal economy, it's sort of like dark energy in astrophysics:
96
264000
4000
04:44
it's not supposed to be there, but it's huge.
97
268000
2000
04:46
We don't understand how it works yet, but we have to.
98
270000
3000
04:49
Furthermore, people in the informal economy,
99
273000
2000
04:51
the gray economy --
100
275000
2000
04:53
as time goes by,
101
277000
2000
04:55
crime is happening around them. And they can join the criminal world,
102
279000
4000
04:59
or they can join the legitimate world.
103
283000
4000
05:03
We should be able to make that choice
104
287000
2000
05:05
easier for them to get toward the legitimate world,
105
289000
2000
05:07
because if we don't, they will go toward the criminal world.
106
291000
4000
05:11
There's all kinds of activity.
107
295000
3000
05:14
In Dharavi the slum performs not only
108
298000
2000
05:16
a lot of services for itself,
109
300000
2000
05:18
but it performs services for the city at large.
110
302000
3000
05:21
And one of the main events are these ad-hoc schools.
111
305000
3000
05:24
Parents pool their money to hire some local teachers
112
308000
4000
05:28
to a private, tiny, unofficial school.
113
312000
2000
05:30
Education is more possible in the cities, and that changes the world.
114
314000
5000
05:35
So you see some interesting, typical, urban things.
115
319000
3000
05:38
So one thing slammed up against another,
116
322000
2000
05:40
such as in Sao Paulo here.
117
324000
2000
05:42
That's what cities do. That's how they create value,
118
326000
2000
05:44
is by slamming things together.
119
328000
2000
05:46
In this case, supply right next to demand.
120
330000
2000
05:48
So the maids and the gardeners and the guards
121
332000
2000
05:50
that live in this lively part of town on the left
122
334000
3000
05:53
walk to work, in the boring, rich neighborhood.
123
337000
5000
05:58
Proximity is amazing.
124
342000
3000
06:01
We are learning about how dense proximity can be.
125
345000
3000
06:16
Connectivity between the city and the country
126
360000
3000
06:19
is what's going to keep the country good,
127
363000
3000
06:22
because the city has interesting ways of doing things.
128
366000
3000
06:34
This is what makes cities --
129
378000
2000
06:36
(Applause)
130
380000
4000
06:40
this is what makes cities so green in the developing world.
131
384000
3000
06:43
Because people leave the poverty trap, an ecological disaster
132
387000
3000
06:46
of subsistence farms, and head to town.
133
390000
3000
06:49
And when they're gone the natural environment
134
393000
2000
06:51
starts to come back very rapidly.
135
395000
2000
06:53
And those who remain in the village can shift over to cash crops
136
397000
3000
06:56
to send food to the new growing markets in town.
137
400000
4000
07:00
So if you want to save a village, you do it with a good road,
138
404000
3000
07:03
or with a good cell phone connection, and ideally some grid electrical power.
139
407000
4000
07:07
So the event is: we're a city planet. That just happened.
140
411000
3000
07:10
More than half.
141
414000
2000
07:12
The numbers are considerable. A billion live in the squatter cities now.
142
416000
3000
07:15
Another billion is expected.
143
419000
3000
07:18
That's more than a sixth of humanity living a certain way.
144
422000
3000
07:21
And that will determine a lot of how we function.
145
425000
4000
07:25
Now, for us environmentalists,
146
429000
2000
07:27
maybe the greenest thing about the cities is they diffuse the population bomb.
147
431000
3000
07:30
People get into town.
148
434000
3000
07:33
The immediately have fewer children.
149
437000
2000
07:35
They don't even have to get rich yet. Just the opportunity of
150
439000
3000
07:38
coming up in the world means they will have fewer, higher-quality kids,
151
442000
4000
07:42
and the birthrate goes down radically.
152
446000
2000
07:44
Very interesting side effect here,
153
448000
2000
07:46
here's a slide from Phillip Longman.
154
450000
2000
07:48
Shows what is happening.
155
452000
2000
07:50
As we have more and more old people, like me,
156
454000
2000
07:52
and fewer and fewer babies.
157
456000
2000
07:54
And they are regionally separated.
158
458000
3000
07:57
What you're getting is a world which is
159
461000
2000
07:59
old folks, and old cities, going around doing things the old way,
160
463000
5000
08:04
in the north.
161
468000
2000
08:06
And young people in brand new cities they're inventing,
162
470000
3000
08:09
doing new things, in the south.
163
473000
2000
08:11
Where do you think the action is going to be?
164
475000
3000
08:14
Shift of subject. Quickly drop by climate.
165
478000
3000
08:17
The climate news, I'm sorry to say, is going to keep getting worse
166
481000
2000
08:19
than we think, faster than we think.
167
483000
3000
08:22
Climate is a profoundly complex, nonlinear system,
168
486000
2000
08:24
full of runaway positive feedbacks,
169
488000
3000
08:27
hidden thresholds and irrevocable tipping points.
170
491000
2000
08:29
Here's just a few samples.
171
493000
3000
08:32
We're going to keep being surprised. And almost all
172
496000
2000
08:34
the surprises are going to be bad ones.
173
498000
2000
08:36
From your standpoint this means
174
500000
3000
08:39
a great increase in climate refugees
175
503000
2000
08:41
over the coming decades,
176
505000
2000
08:43
and what goes along with that, which is resource wars
177
507000
3000
08:46
and chaos wars,
178
510000
2000
08:48
as we're seeing in Darfur.
179
512000
2000
08:55
That's what drought does.
180
519000
2000
08:57
It brings carrying capacity down,
181
521000
2000
08:59
and there's not enough carrying capacity
182
523000
2000
09:01
to support the people. And then you're in trouble.
183
525000
2000
09:04
Shift to the power situation.
184
528000
3000
09:07
Baseload electricity is what it takes to run a city,
185
531000
3000
09:10
or a city planet.
186
534000
2000
09:12
So far there is only three sources of baseload electricity:
187
536000
4000
09:16
coal, some gas,
188
540000
3000
09:19
nuclear and hydro.
189
543000
2000
09:21
Of those, only nuclear and hydro are green.
190
545000
4000
09:25
Coal is what is causing the climate problems.
191
549000
2000
09:27
And everyone will keep burning it
192
551000
2000
09:29
because it's so cheap, until governments make it expensive.
193
553000
3000
09:32
Wind and solar can't help, because so far we don't have a way to store that energy.
194
556000
5000
09:37
So with hydro maxed out,
195
561000
3000
09:40
coal and lose the climate,
196
564000
3000
09:43
or nuclear, which is the current operating low-carbon source,
197
567000
3000
09:46
and maybe save the climate.
198
570000
2000
09:48
And if we can eventually get good solar in space,
199
572000
3000
09:51
that also could help.
200
575000
2000
09:53
Because remember, this is what drives the prosperity in the developing world
201
577000
5000
09:58
in the villages and in the cities.
202
582000
3000
10:01
So, between coal and nuclear,
203
585000
2000
10:03
compare their waste products.
204
587000
2000
10:05
If all of the electricity you used in your lifetime was nuclear,
205
589000
4000
10:09
the amount of waste that would be added up
206
593000
2000
10:11
would fit in a Coke can.
207
595000
3000
10:14
Whereas a coal-burning plant,
208
598000
2000
10:16
a normal one gigawatt coal plant, burns 80 rail cars of coal a day,
209
600000
4000
10:20
each car having 100 tons.
210
604000
3000
10:23
And it puts 18 thousand tons
211
607000
2000
10:25
of carbon dioxide in the air.
212
609000
4000
10:29
So and then when you compare the lifetime emissions
213
613000
2000
10:31
of these various energy forms,
214
615000
2000
10:33
nuclear is about even with solar and wind,
215
617000
2000
10:35
and ahead of solar --
216
619000
2000
10:37
oh, I'm sorry -- with hydro and wind, and ahead of solar.
217
621000
3000
10:40
And does nuclear really compete with coal?
218
624000
2000
10:42
Just ask the coal miners in Australia.
219
626000
2000
10:44
That's where you see some of the source,
220
628000
2000
10:46
not from my fellow environmentalists,
221
630000
2000
10:48
but from people who feel threatened by nuclear power.
222
632000
3000
10:51
Well the good news is that
223
635000
2000
10:53
the developing world, but frankly, the whole world,
224
637000
2000
10:55
is busy building, and starting to build, nuclear reactors.
225
639000
4000
10:59
This is good for the atmosphere.
226
643000
2000
11:01
It's good for their prosperity.
227
645000
2000
11:03
I want to point out one interesting thing,
228
647000
2000
11:05
which is that environmentalists like the thing we call micropower.
229
649000
3000
11:08
It's supposed to be, I don't know, local solar and wind and cogeneration,
230
652000
3000
11:11
and good things like that.
231
655000
2000
11:13
But frankly micro-reactors which are just now coming on,
232
657000
2000
11:15
might serve even better.
233
659000
2000
11:17
The Russians, who started this, are building floating reactors,
234
661000
2000
11:19
for their new passage, where the ice is melting, north of Russia.
235
663000
4000
11:23
And they're selling these floating reactors,
236
667000
3000
11:26
only 35 megawatts, to developing countries.
237
670000
4000
11:30
Here's the design of an early one from Toshiba.
238
674000
2000
11:32
It's interesting, say, to take a 25-megawatt,
239
676000
3000
11:35
25 million watts,
240
679000
2000
11:37
and you compare it to the standard big iron
241
681000
2000
11:39
of an ordinary Westinghouse or Ariva,
242
683000
4000
11:43
which is 1.2, 1.6 billion watts.
243
687000
3000
11:46
These things are way smaller. They're much more adaptable.
244
690000
4000
11:50
Here's an American design from Lawrence Livermore Lab.
245
694000
3000
11:53
Here's another American design that came out
246
697000
2000
11:55
of Los Alamos, and is now commercial.
247
699000
3000
11:58
Almost all of these are not only small, they are proliferation-proof.
248
702000
2000
12:00
They're typically buried in the ground.
249
704000
3000
12:03
And the innovation is moving very rapidly.
250
707000
2000
12:05
So I think microreactors is going to be important for the future.
251
709000
3000
12:08
In terms of proliferation,
252
712000
2000
12:10
nuclear energy has done more
253
714000
2000
12:12
to dismantle nuclear weapons than any other activity.
254
716000
3000
12:15
And that's why 10 percent of the electricity in this room,
255
719000
4000
12:19
20 percent of electricity
256
723000
2000
12:21
in this room is probably nuclear.
257
725000
2000
12:23
Half of that is coming from dismantled warheads from Russia,
258
727000
4000
12:27
soon to be joined by our dismantled warheads.
259
731000
3000
12:30
And so I would like to see the GNEP program,
260
734000
3000
12:33
that was developed in the Bush administration, go forward aggressively.
261
737000
3000
12:36
And I was glad to see that president Obama
262
740000
2000
12:38
supported the nuclear fuel bank strategy
263
742000
3000
12:41
when he spoke in Prague the other week.
264
745000
2000
12:43
One more subject. Genetically engineered food crops,
265
747000
3000
12:46
in my view, as a biologist,
266
750000
2000
12:48
have no reason to be controversial.
267
752000
2000
12:50
My fellow environmentalists, on this subject,
268
754000
2000
12:52
have been irrational, anti-scientific, and very harmful.
269
756000
4000
12:56
Despite their best efforts,
270
760000
2000
12:58
genetically engineered crops are the most
271
762000
2000
13:00
rapidly successful agricultural innovation in history.
272
764000
4000
13:04
They're good for the environment because they enable no-till farming,
273
768000
3000
13:07
which leaves the soil in place,
274
771000
2000
13:09
getting healthier from year to year --
275
773000
2000
13:11
slso keeps less carbon dioxide going from the soil
276
775000
2000
13:13
into the atmosphere.
277
777000
2000
13:15
They reduce pesticide use.
278
779000
2000
13:17
And they increase yield, which allows you to have your
279
781000
2000
13:19
agricultural area be smaller,
280
783000
3000
13:22
and therefore more wild area is freed up.
281
786000
3000
13:25
By the way, this map from 2006
282
789000
2000
13:27
is out of date because it shows Africa
283
791000
2000
13:29
still under the thumb of Greenpeace,
284
793000
2000
13:31
and Friends of the Earth from Europe,
285
795000
3000
13:34
and they're finally getting out from under that.
286
798000
2000
13:36
And biotech is moving rapidly in Africa, at last.
287
800000
3000
13:39
This is a moral issue.
288
803000
2000
13:41
The Nuffield Council on Bioethics
289
805000
2000
13:43
met on this issue twice in great detail
290
807000
2000
13:45
and said it is a moral imperative
291
809000
2000
13:47
to make genetically engineered crops readily available.
292
811000
3000
13:50
Speaking of imperatives, geoengineering is taboo now,
293
814000
3000
13:53
especially in government circles,
294
817000
2000
13:55
though I think there was a DARPA meeting on it a couple of weeks ago,
295
819000
2000
13:57
but it will be on your plate --
296
821000
2000
13:59
not this year but pretty soon,
297
823000
3000
14:02
because some harsh realizations are coming along.
298
826000
3000
14:05
This is a list of them.
299
829000
2000
14:07
Basically the news is going to keep getting more scary.
300
831000
3000
14:10
There will be events,
301
834000
2000
14:12
like 35,000 people dying of a heat wave,
302
836000
3000
14:15
which happened a while back.
303
839000
2000
14:17
Like cyclones coming up toward Bangladesh.
304
841000
3000
14:20
Like wars over water,
305
844000
2000
14:22
such as in the Indus.
306
846000
2000
14:24
And as those events keep happening
307
848000
2000
14:26
we're going to say, "Okay, what can we do about that really?"
308
850000
2000
14:28
But there's this little problem with geoengineering:
309
852000
5000
14:33
what body is going to decide
310
857000
4000
14:37
who gets to engineer? How much they do? Where they do it?
311
861000
2000
14:39
Because everybody is downstream,
312
863000
2000
14:41
downwind of whatever is done.
313
865000
3000
14:44
And if we just taboo it completely
314
868000
2000
14:46
we could lose civilization.
315
870000
2000
14:48
But if we just say "OK,
316
872000
3000
14:51
China, you're worried, you go ahead.
317
875000
2000
14:53
You geoengineer your way. We'll geoengineer our way."
318
877000
4000
14:57
That would be considered an act of war by both nations.
319
881000
3000
15:00
So this is very interesting diplomacy coming along.
320
884000
4000
15:04
I should say, it is more practical than people think.
321
888000
3000
15:07
Here is an example that climatologists like a lot,
322
891000
3000
15:10
one of the dozens of geoengineering ideas.
323
894000
2000
15:12
This one came from the sulfur dioxide
324
896000
2000
15:14
from Mount Pinatubo in 1991 --
325
898000
3000
15:17
cooled the earth by half a degree.
326
901000
4000
15:21
There was so much ice in 1992, the following year,
327
905000
2000
15:23
that there was a bumper crop of polar bear cubs
328
907000
3000
15:26
who were known as the Pinatubo cubs.
329
910000
2000
15:28
To put sulfur dioxide in the stratosphere
330
912000
2000
15:30
would cost on the order of a billion dollars a year.
331
914000
3000
15:33
That's nothing, compared to all of the other
332
917000
3000
15:36
things we may be trying to do about energy.
333
920000
2000
15:38
Just to run by another one:
334
922000
3000
15:41
this is a plan to brighten the reflectance of ocean clouds,
335
925000
3000
15:44
by atomizing seawater;
336
928000
2000
15:46
that would brighten the albedo of the whole planet.
337
930000
2000
15:48
A nice one, because it can happen
338
932000
2000
15:50
lots of little ways in lots of little places,
339
934000
2000
15:52
is by copying the ancient Amazon Indians
340
936000
2000
15:54
who made good agricultural soil
341
938000
2000
15:56
by pyrolizing, smoldering, plant waste,
342
940000
4000
16:00
and biochar fixes large quantities of carbon
343
944000
3000
16:03
while it's improving the soil.
344
947000
2000
16:05
So here is where we are.
345
949000
3000
16:08
Nobel Prize-winning climatologist Paul Crutzen
346
952000
3000
16:11
calls our geological era the Anthropocene,
347
955000
3000
16:14
the human-dominated era. We are stuck
348
958000
3000
16:17
with its obligations.
349
961000
3000
16:20
In the Whole Earth Catalog, my first words were,
350
964000
2000
16:22
"We are as Gods, and might as well get good at it."
351
966000
2000
16:24
The first words of Whole Earth Discipline
352
968000
3000
16:27
are, "We are as Gods, and have to get good at it."
353
971000
4000
16:31
Thank you.
354
975000
2000
16:33
(Applause)
355
977000
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Stewart Brand - Environmentalist, futuristSince the counterculture '60s, Stewart Brand has been creating our internet-worked world. Now, with biotech accelerating four times faster than digital technology, Stewart Brand has a bold new plan ...
Why you should listen
With biotech accelerating four times faster than digital technology, the revival of extinct species is becoming possible. Stewart Brand plans to not only bring species back but restore them to the wild.
Brand is already a legend in the tech industry for things he’s created: the Whole Earth Catalog, The WELL, the Global Business Network, the Long Now Foundation, and the notion that “information wants to be free.” Now Brand, a lifelong environmentalist, wants to re-create -- or “de-extinct” -- a few animals that’ve disappeared from the planet.
Granted, resurrecting the woolly mammoth using ancient DNA may sound like mad science. But Brand’s Revive and Restore project has an entirely rational goal: to learn what causes extinctions so we can protect currently endangered species, preserve genetic and biological diversity, repair depleted ecosystems, and essentially “undo harm that humans have caused in the past.”
Stewart Brand | Speaker | TED.com