TED2017
Danny Hillis: Should we create a solar shade to cool the earth?
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
1,261,967 views
In this perspective-shifting talk, Danny Hillis prompts us to approach global issues like climate change with creative scientific solutions. Taking a stand for solar geoengineering, he looks at controversial solutions with open-minded curiosity.
Danny Hillis - Computer theorist
Inventor, scientist, author, engineer -- over his broad career, Danny Hillis has turned his ever-searching brain on an array of subjects, with surprising results. Full bio
Inventor, scientist, author, engineer -- over his broad career, Danny Hillis has turned his ever-searching brain on an array of subjects, with surprising results. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
[A provocation from Danny Hillis:]
0
261
1644
00:13
[It's time to start talking
about engineering our climate]
about engineering our climate]
1
1929
2944
00:16
What if there was a way
to build a thermostat
to build a thermostat
2
4897
3469
00:20
that allowed you to turn down
the temperature of the earth
the temperature of the earth
3
8390
2743
00:23
anytime you wanted?
4
11157
1267
00:25
Now, you would think if somebody
had a plausible idea about how to do that,
had a plausible idea about how to do that,
5
13695
4390
00:30
everybody would be very excited about it,
6
18109
2254
00:32
and there would be lots
of research on how to do it.
of research on how to do it.
7
20387
2595
00:35
But in fact, a lot of people
do understand how to do that.
do understand how to do that.
8
23450
4508
00:40
But there's not much support
for research in this area.
for research in this area.
9
28711
4151
00:45
And I think part of it
10
33444
2187
00:47
is because there are some real
misunderstandings about it.
misunderstandings about it.
11
35655
3009
00:51
So I'm not going to try to convince you
today that this is a good idea.
today that this is a good idea.
12
39021
3876
00:55
But I am going to try to get
your curiosity going about it
your curiosity going about it
13
43863
4683
01:00
and clear up some
of the misunderstandings.
of the misunderstandings.
14
48570
3166
01:04
So, the basic idea of solar geoengineering
15
52266
4121
01:08
is that we can cool things down
16
56411
2627
01:11
just by reflecting
a little bit more sunlight
a little bit more sunlight
17
59062
2738
01:13
back into space.
18
61824
1154
01:15
And ideas about how to do this
have been around literally for decades.
have been around literally for decades.
19
63728
5302
01:22
Clouds are a great way to do that,
these low-lying clouds.
these low-lying clouds.
20
70023
4459
01:26
Everybody knows it's cooler under a cloud.
21
74506
2522
01:29
I like this cloud because it has exactly
the same water content
the same water content
22
77475
4301
01:33
as the transparent air around it.
23
81800
1878
01:36
And it just shows that even a little bit
of a change in the flow of the air
of a change in the flow of the air
24
84093
4246
01:40
can cause a cloud to form.
25
88363
1417
01:42
We make artificial clouds all the time.
26
90482
2600
01:45
These are contrails,
which are artificial water clouds
which are artificial water clouds
27
93823
3357
01:49
that are made by the passing
of a jet engine.
of a jet engine.
28
97204
2491
01:52
And so, we're already changing
the clouds on earth.
the clouds on earth.
29
100251
5342
01:57
By accident.
30
105617
1317
01:58
Or, if you like to believe it,
by supersecret government conspiracy.
by supersecret government conspiracy.
31
106958
4577
02:03
(Laughter)
32
111559
2075
02:05
But we are already doing this quite a lot.
33
113658
3125
02:08
This is a NASA picture of shipping lanes.
34
116807
3572
02:12
Passing ships actually cause
clouds to form,
clouds to form,
35
120403
3428
02:15
and this is a big enough effect
36
123855
2111
02:17
that it actually helps reduce
global warming already by about a degree.
global warming already by about a degree.
37
125990
4998
02:23
So we already are doing solar engineering.
38
131513
2934
02:27
There's lots of ideas
about how to do this.
about how to do this.
39
135347
2047
02:29
People have looked at everything,
40
137418
1980
02:31
from building giant parasols
out into space
out into space
41
139422
3424
02:34
to fizzing bubble waters in the ocean.
42
142870
2924
02:38
And some of these are actually
very plausible ideas.
very plausible ideas.
43
146306
3215
02:42
One that was published recently
by David Keith at Harvard
by David Keith at Harvard
44
150656
4358
02:47
is to take chalk and put dust
up into the stratosphere,
up into the stratosphere,
45
155038
3689
02:50
where it reflects off sunlight.
46
158751
2261
02:53
And that's a really neat idea,
47
161036
1453
02:54
because chalk is one of the most
common minerals on earth,
common minerals on earth,
48
162513
3421
02:57
and it's very safe -- it's so safe,
we put it into baby food.
we put it into baby food.
49
165958
3701
03:02
And basically, if you throw chalk
up into the stratosphere,
up into the stratosphere,
50
170665
4199
03:06
it comes down in a couple of years
all by itself, dissolved in rainwater.
all by itself, dissolved in rainwater.
51
174888
4816
03:12
Now, before you start worrying
about all this chalk in your rainwater,
about all this chalk in your rainwater,
52
180587
4127
03:16
let me explain to you
how little of it it actually takes.
how little of it it actually takes.
53
184738
4211
03:21
And that turns out to be
very easy to calculate.
very easy to calculate.
54
189453
2770
03:25
This is a back-of-the-envelope
calculation I made.
calculation I made.
55
193118
2737
03:27
(Laughter)
56
195879
1366
03:29
(Applause)
57
197269
2190
03:31
I assure you, people have done
much more careful calculations,
much more careful calculations,
58
199483
4468
03:35
and it comes out with the same answer,
59
203975
1851
03:37
which is that you have to put chalk up
at the rate of about 10 teragrams a year
at the rate of about 10 teragrams a year
60
205850
5763
03:43
to undo the effects of the CO2
that we've already done --
that we've already done --
61
211637
3806
03:47
just in terms of temperature,
not all the effects, but the temperature.
not all the effects, but the temperature.
62
215467
3445
03:51
So what does that look like?
63
219339
2199
03:53
I can't visualize 10 teragrams per year.
64
221562
2977
03:57
So I asked the Cambridge
Fire Department and Taylor Milsal
Fire Department and Taylor Milsal
65
225593
6206
04:03
to lend me a hand.
66
231823
1492
04:06
This is a hose pumping water
at 10 teragrams a year.
at 10 teragrams a year.
67
234965
4569
04:12
And that is how much
68
240506
2754
04:15
you would have to pump
into the stratosphere
into the stratosphere
69
243284
3579
04:18
to cool the earth back down
to pre-industrial levels.
to pre-industrial levels.
70
246887
3841
04:23
And it's amazingly little;
it's like one hose for the entire earth.
it's like one hose for the entire earth.
71
251815
4891
04:29
Now of course, you wouldn't
really use a hose,
really use a hose,
72
257244
2245
04:31
you'd fly it up in airplanes
or something like that.
or something like that.
73
259513
2508
04:34
But it's so little, it would be like
putting a handful of chalk
putting a handful of chalk
74
262442
5095
04:39
into every Olympic
swimming pool full of rain.
swimming pool full of rain.
75
267561
2836
04:42
It's almost nothing.
76
270886
1333
04:45
So why don't people like this idea?
77
273192
4353
04:49
Why isn't it taken more seriously?
78
277569
1722
04:51
And there are some
very good reasons for that.
very good reasons for that.
79
279315
2794
04:55
A lot of people really don't think
we should be talking about this at all.
we should be talking about this at all.
80
283323
5049
05:00
And, in fact, I have some
very good friends in the audience
very good friends in the audience
81
288396
4440
05:04
who I respect a lot,
82
292860
1405
05:07
who really don't think
I should be talking about this.
I should be talking about this.
83
295130
3331
05:11
And the reason is that they're concerned
84
299056
2842
05:13
that if people imagine
there's some easy way out,
there's some easy way out,
85
301922
3452
05:17
that we won't give up
our addiction to fossil fuels.
our addiction to fossil fuels.
86
305398
3587
05:21
And I do worry about that.
87
309553
1734
05:23
I think it's actually a serious problem.
88
311871
2230
05:26
But there's also, I think,
a deeper problem,
a deeper problem,
89
314927
4987
05:32
which is: nobody likes the idea
of messing with the entire earth --
of messing with the entire earth --
90
320657
5375
05:38
I certainly don't.
91
326056
1200
05:39
I love this planet, I really do.
92
327779
2372
05:42
And I don't want to mess with it.
93
330175
2039
05:44
But we're already changing our atmosphere,
94
332630
3840
05:48
we're already messing with it.
95
336494
1555
05:51
And so I think it makes sense
for us to look for ways
for us to look for ways
96
339000
6261
05:57
to mitigate that impact.
97
345285
1845
05:59
And we need to do research to do that.
98
347519
1913
06:01
We need to understand
the science behind that.
the science behind that.
99
349456
2524
06:04
I've noticed that there's a theme
that's kind of developed at TED,
that's kind of developed at TED,
100
352878
5310
06:10
which is kind of, "fear versus hope,"
101
358212
4340
06:14
or "creativity versus caution."
102
362576
3395
06:19
And of course, we need both of those.
103
367026
2019
06:21
So there aren't any silver bullets.
104
369747
2484
06:24
This is certainly not a silver bullet.
105
372255
2278
06:28
But we need science to tell us
what our options are;
what our options are;
106
376331
3804
06:32
that informs both
our creativity and our caution.
our creativity and our caution.
107
380159
4315
06:37
So I am an optimist
about our future selves,
about our future selves,
108
385293
4514
06:42
but I'm not an optimist
because I think our problems are small.
because I think our problems are small.
109
390426
4000
06:47
I'm an optimist because I think
our capacity to deal with our problems
our capacity to deal with our problems
110
395204
5992
06:53
is much greater than we imagine.
111
401220
2133
06:55
Thank you very much.
112
403859
1299
06:57
(Applause)
113
405182
1017
06:58
This talk sparked
a lot of controversy at TED2017,
a lot of controversy at TED2017,
114
406215
2158
07:00
and we encourage you
to look at discussions online
to look at discussions online
115
408403
2050
07:02
to see other points of view.
116
410483
1300
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Danny Hillis - Computer theoristInventor, scientist, author, engineer -- over his broad career, Danny Hillis has turned his ever-searching brain on an array of subjects, with surprising results.
Why you should listen
Danny Hillis is an inventor, scientist, author and engineer. While completing his doctorate at MIT, he pioneered the concept of parallel computers that is now the basis for graphics processors and cloud computing. He holds more than 300 US patents, covering parallel computers, disk arrays, forgery prevention methods, various electronic and mechanical devices, and the pinch-to-zoom display interface. He has recently been working on problems in medicine as well. He is also the designer of a 10,000-year mechanical clock, and he gave a TED Talk in 1994 that is practically prophetic. Throughout his career, Hillis has worked at places like Disney, and now MIT and Applied Invention, always looking for the next fascinating problem.
Danny Hillis | Speaker | TED.com