TEDSalon London Fall 2012
Wingham Rowan: A new kind of job market
Filmed:
Readability: 4.4
1,131,436 views
Plenty of people need jobs with very flexible hours -- but it's difficult for those people to connect with the employers who need them. Wingham Rowan is working on that. He explains how the same technology that powers modern financial markets can help employers book workers for slivers of time.
Wingham Rowan - Policy entrepreneur
Wingham Rowan's work bridges the gap between flexible work schedules and modern financial markets. Full bio
Wingham Rowan's work bridges the gap between flexible work schedules and modern financial markets. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
This is about a hidden corner of the labor market.
0
319
3583
00:19
It's the world of people who need to work ultra-flexibly,
1
3902
3633
00:23
if they're to work at all.
2
7535
1317
00:24
So think, for instance,
3
8852
1167
00:25
of someone who has a recurring but unpredictable medical condition,
4
10019
3618
00:29
or somebody who's caring for a dependent adult,
5
13637
2783
00:32
or a parent with complex child care needs.
6
16420
2847
00:35
Their availability for work can be such that it's,
7
19267
3158
00:38
"A few hours today.
8
22425
1693
00:40
Maybe I can work tomorrow, but I don't know if and when yet."
9
24118
3600
00:43
And it's extraordinarily difficult for these people
10
27718
2519
00:46
to find the work that they so often need very badly.
11
30237
3029
00:49
Which is a tragedy because there are employers
12
33266
2819
00:51
who can use pools of very flexible local people
13
36085
3306
00:55
booked completely ad hoc around when that person wants to work.
14
39391
3899
00:59
Imagine that you run a cafe.
15
43290
2601
01:01
It's mid-morning, the place is filling up.
16
45891
1667
01:03
You're going to have a busy lunchtime rush.
17
47558
1583
01:05
If you could get two extra workers for 90 minutes
18
49141
3317
01:08
to start in an hour's time,
19
52458
2654
01:11
you'd do it, but they'd have to be reliable, inducted in how your cafe works.
20
55112
4958
01:15
They'd have to be available at very competitive rates.
21
60070
1876
01:17
They'd have to be bookable in about the next minute.
22
61946
3167
01:21
In reality, no recruitment agency wants to handle that sort of business,
23
65113
3932
01:24
so you are going to muddle by, understaffed.
24
69045
3383
01:28
And it's not just caterers, it's hoteliers, it's retailers,
25
72428
2318
01:30
it's anyone who provides services to the public or businesses.
26
74746
3299
01:33
There's all sorts of organizations that can use these pools of very flexible people,
27
78045
4533
01:38
possibly already once they've been inducted.
28
82578
3151
01:41
At this level of the labor market,
29
85729
2033
01:43
what you need is a marketplace for spare hours.
30
87762
3850
01:47
They do exist. Here's how they work.
31
91612
2117
01:49
So in this example, a distribution company has said,
32
93729
3467
01:53
we've got a rush order that we've got to get out of the warehouse tomorrow morning.
33
97196
3283
01:56
Show us everyone who's available.
34
100479
1400
01:57
It's found 31 workers.
35
101879
1651
01:59
Everybody on this screen is genuinely available at those specific hours tomorrow.
36
103530
3532
02:02
They're all contactable in time for this booking.
37
107062
2334
02:05
They've all defined the terms on which they will accept bookings.
38
109396
4001
02:09
And this booking is within all the parameters for each individual.
39
113397
3414
02:12
And they would all be legally compliant by doing this booking.
40
116811
2561
02:15
Of course, they're all trained to work in warehouses.
41
119372
1924
02:17
You can select as many of them as you want.
42
121296
2215
02:19
They're from multiple agencies.
43
123511
1452
02:20
It's calculated the charge rate for each person for this specific booking.
44
124963
3932
02:24
And it's monitoring their reliability.
45
128895
2334
02:27
The people on the top row are the provenly reliable ones.
46
131229
3000
02:30
They're likely to be more expensive.
47
134229
1749
02:31
In an alternative view of this pool of local, very flexible people,
48
135978
3201
02:35
here's a market research company,
49
139179
1683
02:36
and it's inducted maybe 25 local people in how to do street interviewing.
50
140862
3950
02:40
And they've got a new campaign. They want to run it next week.
51
144812
2685
02:43
And they're looking at how many of the people they've inducted
52
147497
3399
02:46
are available each hour next week.
53
150896
2282
02:49
And they'll then decide when to do their street interviews.
54
153178
2734
02:51
But is there more that could be done
55
155912
2617
02:54
for this corner of the labor market?
56
158529
1750
02:56
Because right now there are so many people
57
160279
2686
02:58
who need whatever economic opportunity they can get.
58
162965
3598
03:02
Let's make it personal.
59
166563
2050
03:04
Imagine that a young woman -- base of the economic pyramid,
60
168613
2783
03:07
very little prospect of getting a job --
61
171396
2200
03:09
what economic activity could she theoretically engage in?
62
173596
3716
03:13
Well, she might be willing to work odd hours
63
177312
2284
03:15
in a call center, in a reception area, in a mail room.
64
179596
3300
03:18
She may be interested in providing local services to her community:
65
182896
3332
03:22
babysitting, local deliveries, pet care.
66
186228
2551
03:24
She may have possessions that she would like to trade
67
188779
3137
03:27
at times she doesn't need them.
68
191916
1246
03:29
So she might have a sofa bed in her front room that she would like to let out.
69
193162
3599
03:32
She might have a bike, a video games console she only uses occasionally.
70
196761
4168
03:36
And you're probably thinking -- because you're all very web-aware --
71
200929
3401
03:40
yes, and we're in the era of collaborative consumption,
72
204330
2565
03:42
so she can go online and do all this.
73
206895
1760
03:44
She can go to Airbnb to list her sofa bed,
74
208655
2658
03:47
she can go to TaskRabbit.com and say, "I want to do local deliveries," and so on.
75
211313
3884
03:51
These are good sites, but I believe we can go a step further.
76
215197
5350
03:56
And the key to that is a philosophy that we call modern markets for all.
77
220547
6614
04:03
Markets have changed beyond recognition in the last 20 years,
78
227161
4551
04:07
but only for organizations at the top of the economy.
79
231712
3684
04:11
If you're a Wall Street trader, you now take it for granted
80
235396
3000
04:14
that you sell your financial assets in a system of markets
81
238396
2916
04:17
that identifies the most profitable opportunities for you in real time,
82
241312
3583
04:20
executes on that in microseconds within the boundaries you've set.
83
244895
3653
04:24
It analyzes supply and demand and pricing
84
248548
3432
04:27
and tells you where your next wave of opportunities are coming from.
85
251980
2093
04:29
It manages counterparty risk in incredibly sophisticated ways.
86
254073
3550
04:33
It's all extremely low overhead.
87
257623
2434
04:35
What have we gained at the bottom of the economy
88
260057
3001
04:38
in terms of markets in the last 20 years?
89
263058
4094
04:43
Basically classified adverts with a search facility.
90
267152
6159
04:49
So why do we have this disparity
91
273311
2013
04:51
between these incredibly sophisticated markets at the top of the economy
92
275324
3550
04:54
that are increasingly sucking more and more activity and resource
93
278874
3616
04:58
out of the main economy into this rarefied level of trading,
94
282490
3449
05:01
and what the rest of us have?
95
285939
2384
05:04
A modern market is more than a website;
96
288323
3066
05:07
it's a web of interoperable marketplaces,
97
291389
2619
05:09
back office mechanisms, regulatory regimes,
98
294008
2534
05:12
settlement mechanisms, liquidity sources and so on.
99
296542
4897
05:17
And when a Wall Street trader comes into work in the morning,
100
301439
3151
05:20
she does not write a listing for every financial derivative she wants to sell today
101
304590
5199
05:25
and then post that listing on multiple websites
102
309789
2616
05:28
and wait for potential buyers to get in touch
103
312405
2500
05:30
and start negotiating the terms on which she might trade.
104
314905
3717
05:34
In the early days of this modern markets technology,
105
318622
2899
05:37
the financial institutions worked out
106
321521
2068
05:39
how they could leverage their buying power, their back office processes,
107
323589
3632
05:43
their relationships, their networks
108
327221
2300
05:45
to shape these new markets that would create all this new activity.
109
329521
4590
05:50
They asked governments for supporting regulatory regimes,
110
334111
3089
05:53
and in a lot of cases they got it.
111
337200
2634
05:55
But throughout the economy,
112
339834
1950
05:57
there are facilities that could likewise leverage
113
341784
2818
06:00
a new generation of markets
114
344602
1599
06:02
for the benefit of all of us.
115
346201
2733
06:04
And those facilities --
116
348934
1968
06:06
I'm talking about things like the mechanisms that prove our identity,
117
350902
3716
06:10
the licensing authorities
118
354618
2283
06:12
that know what each of us is allowed to do legally at any given time,
119
356901
3833
06:16
the processes by which we resolve disputes through official channels.
120
360734
3668
06:20
These mechanisms, these facilities
121
364402
2849
06:23
are not in the gift of Craigslist or Gumtree or Yahoo,
122
367251
3549
06:26
they're controlled by the state.
123
370800
3102
06:29
And the policymakers who sit on top of them
124
373902
2731
06:32
are, I suggest, simply not thinking about how those facilities could be used
125
376633
6218
06:38
to underpin a whole new era of markets.
126
382851
2783
06:41
Like everyone else, those policymakers are taking it for granted
127
385634
4717
06:46
that modern markets are the preserve
128
390351
2268
06:48
of organizations powerful enough to create them for themselves.
129
392619
7911
06:56
Suppose we stopped taking that for granted.
130
400530
3427
06:59
Suppose tomorrow morning the prime minister of Britain or the president of the U.S.,
131
403957
3166
07:03
or the leader of any other developed nation,
132
407123
2182
07:05
woke up and said, "I'm never going to be able to create
133
409305
3851
07:09
all the jobs I need in the current climate.
134
413156
2166
07:11
I have got to focus on whatever economic opportunity I can get to my citizens.
135
415322
5334
07:16
And for that they have to be able to access state-of-the-art markets.
136
420656
3967
07:20
How do I make that happen?"
137
424623
2368
07:22
And I think I can see a few eyes rolling.
138
426991
2749
07:25
Politicians in a big, complex, sophisticated I.T. project?
139
429740
3782
07:29
Oh, that's going to be a disaster waiting to happen.
140
433522
3530
07:32
Not necessarily.
141
437052
3005
07:35
There is a precedent for technology-enabled service
142
440057
2848
07:38
that has been initiated by politicians in multiple countries
143
442905
3702
07:42
and has been hugely successful:
144
446607
2816
07:45
national lotteries.
145
449423
2450
07:47
Let's take Britain as an example.
146
451873
1750
07:49
Our government didn't design the national lottery,
147
453623
2600
07:52
it didn't fund the national lottery, it doesn't operate the national lottery.
148
456223
2783
07:54
It simply passed the National Lottery Act and this is what followed.
149
459006
5151
08:00
This act defines what a national lottery will look like.
150
464157
3265
08:03
It specifies certain benefits
151
467422
1668
08:04
that the state can uniquely bestow on the operators.
152
469090
2683
08:07
And it puts some obligations on those operators.
153
471773
2699
08:10
In terms of spreading gambling activity to the masses,
154
474472
3350
08:13
this was an unqualified success.
155
477822
3034
08:16
But let's suppose that our aim
156
480856
1784
08:18
is to bring new economic activity to the base of the pyramid.
157
482640
3883
08:22
Could we use the same model?
158
486523
2150
08:24
I believe we could.
159
488673
1784
08:26
So imagine that policymakers outlined a facility.
160
490457
4116
08:30
Let's call it national e-markets, NEMs for short.
161
494573
3984
08:34
Think of it as a regulated public utility.
162
498557
1849
08:36
So it's on a par with the water supply or the road network.
163
500406
2884
08:39
And it's a series of markets for low-level trade
164
503290
4116
08:43
that can be fulfilled by a person or a small company.
165
507406
2817
08:46
And government has certain benefits
166
510223
2749
08:48
it can uniquely bestow on these markets.
167
512972
2550
08:51
It's about public spending going through these markets
168
515522
2784
08:54
to buy public services at the local level.
169
518306
2599
08:56
It's about interfacing these markets
170
520905
1735
08:58
direct into the highest official channels in the land.
171
522640
3650
09:02
It's about enshrining government's role as a publicist for these markets.
172
526290
3400
09:05
It's about deregulating some sectors
173
529690
2782
09:08
so that local people can enter them.
174
532472
1433
09:09
So, taxi journeys might be one example.
175
533905
2252
09:12
And there are certain obligations that should go with those benefits
176
536157
4782
09:16
to be placed on the operators,
177
540939
1601
09:18
and the key one is, of course,
178
542540
1500
09:19
that the operators pay for everything,
179
544040
2866
09:22
including all the interfacing into the public sector.
180
546906
3001
09:25
So imagine that the operators make their return
181
549907
3566
09:29
by building a percentage markup into each transaction.
182
553473
3183
09:32
Imagine that there's a concession period
183
556656
2434
09:34
defined of maybe 15 years
184
559090
2433
09:37
in which they can take all these benefits and run with them.
185
561523
4466
09:41
And imagine that the consortia who bid to run it are told,
186
565989
3317
09:45
whoever comes in at the lowest percentage markup on each transaction
187
569306
3633
09:48
to fund the whole thing
188
572939
1492
09:50
will get the deal.
189
574431
1375
09:51
So government then exits the frame.
190
575806
1800
09:53
This is now in the hands of the consortium.
191
577606
1633
09:55
Either they are going to unlock an awful lot of economic opportunity
192
579239
2551
09:57
and make a percentage on all of it
193
581790
2084
09:59
or it's all going to crash and burn,
194
583874
1599
10:01
which is tough on their shareholders.
195
585473
1617
10:02
It doesn't bother the taxpayer necessarily.
196
587090
2450
10:05
And there would be no constraints on alternative markets.
197
589540
4650
10:10
So this would just be one more choice
198
594190
2433
10:12
among millions of Internet forums.
199
596623
2816
10:15
But it could be very different,
200
599439
2550
10:17
because having access to those state-backed facilities
201
601989
3618
10:21
could incentivize this consortium
202
605607
2333
10:23
to seriously invest in the service.
203
607940
2117
10:25
Because they would have to get a lot of these small transactions going
204
610057
3067
10:29
to start making their return.
205
613124
1731
10:30
So we're talking about sectors like home hair care,
206
614855
4891
10:35
the hire of toys, farm work,
207
619746
3957
10:39
hire of clothes even, meals delivered to your door,
208
623703
3619
10:43
services for tourists, home care.
209
627322
1807
10:45
This would be a world of very small trades, but very well-informed,
210
629129
6783
10:51
because national e-markets will deliver data.
211
635912
3867
10:55
So this is a local person
212
639779
2633
10:58
potentially deciding whether to enter the babysitting market.
213
642412
3000
11:01
And they might be aware that they would have to fund vetting and training
214
645412
2849
11:04
if they wanted to go into that market.
215
648261
1400
11:05
They'd have to do assessment interviews with local parents
216
649661
2618
11:08
who wanted a pool of babysitters.
217
652279
1500
11:09
Is it worth their while?
218
653779
1401
11:11
Should they be looking at other sectors?
219
655180
1700
11:12
Should they be moving to another part of the country
220
656880
1884
11:14
where there's a shortage of babysitters?
221
658764
2249
11:16
This kind of data can become routine.
222
661013
2350
11:19
And this data can be used by investors.
223
663363
2034
11:21
So if there's a problem with a shortage of babysitters in some parts of the country
224
665397
3166
11:24
and the problem is nobody can afford the vetting and training,
225
668563
2899
11:27
an investor can pay for it
226
671462
1584
11:28
and the system will tithe back the enhanced earnings of the individuals
227
673046
3684
11:32
for maybe the next two years.
228
676730
1649
11:34
This is a world of atomized capitalism.
229
678379
3301
11:37
So it's small trades by small people,
230
681680
2032
11:39
but it's very informed, safe, convenient, low-overhead and immediate.
231
683712
6867
11:46
Some rough research suggests this could unlock
232
690579
2925
11:49
around 100 million pounds' worth a day of new economic activity
233
693504
4201
11:53
in a country the size of the U.K.
234
697705
1950
11:55
Does that sound improbable to you?
235
699655
2733
11:58
That's what a lot of people said about turbo trading
236
702388
4133
12:02
in financial exchanges 20 years ago.
237
706521
3052
12:05
Do not underestimate the transformative power
238
709573
3100
12:08
of truly modern markets.
239
712673
3156
12:11
Thank you.
240
715829
1626
12:13
(Applause)
241
717455
1585
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Wingham Rowan - Policy entrepreneurWingham Rowan's work bridges the gap between flexible work schedules and modern financial markets.
Why you should listen
As director of Britain's Beyond Jobs project, Wingham Rowan and his team develop the technology to enable official markets to run on irregular work hours. The project grew out of UK government funding for very flexible labor markets. He is also founder of the UltraFlexi social business.
Rowan is the former producer and presenter of the UK’s longest running television series about the Internet, cyber.cafe, and the presenter of the children’s TV program Rowan’s Report. He is the author of two books and multiple policy papers about the social potential of online markets.
Wingham Rowan | Speaker | TED.com