TEDMED 2013
Amanda Bennett: We need a heroic narrative for death
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
1,164,686 views
Amanda Bennett and her husband were passionate and full of life all throughout their lives together -- and up until the final days, too. Bennett gives a sweet yet powerful talk on why, for the loved ones of the dying, having hope for a happy ending shouldn't warrant a diagnosis of "denial." She calls for a more heroic narrative for death -- to match the ones we have in life.
Amanda Bennett - Journalist
In "The Cost of Hope," Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Amanda Bennett brings an investigative angle to the conversation about end-of-life care. Full bio
In "The Cost of Hope," Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Amanda Bennett brings an investigative angle to the conversation about end-of-life care. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
So I'd like you to come back with me
0
498
2659
00:15
just for a few minutes
1
3157
1901
00:17
to a dark night in China,
2
5058
2869
00:19
the night I met my husband.
3
7927
2721
00:22
It was a city so long ago that it was still called
4
10648
3443
00:26
Peking.
5
14091
2113
00:28
So I went to a party.
6
16204
2621
00:30
I sat down next to a stout, middle-aged man
7
18825
3383
00:34
with owl glasses and a bow tie,
8
22208
3514
00:37
and he turned out to be a Fulbright scholar,
9
25722
2893
00:40
there in China specifically to study
10
28615
3564
00:44
Sino-Soviet relations.
11
32179
2091
00:46
What a gift it was to the eager,
12
34270
2400
00:48
young foreign correspondent that I was then.
13
36670
2758
00:51
I'd pump him for information,
14
39428
2008
00:53
I'm mentally scribbling notes
15
41436
1657
00:55
for the stories I plan to write.
16
43093
2309
00:57
I talk to him for hours.
17
45402
2485
00:59
Only months later,
18
47887
3511
01:03
I discover who he really was.
19
51398
2374
01:05
He was the China representative
20
53772
2773
01:08
for the American Soybean Association.
21
56545
4229
01:12
"I don't understand. Soybeans?
22
60774
3270
01:16
You told me you were a Fulbright scholar."
23
64044
2755
01:18
"Well, how long would you have talked to me
24
66799
1888
01:20
if I told you we're in soybeans?"
25
68687
2042
01:22
(Laughter)
26
70729
2481
01:25
I said, "You jerk."
27
73210
3292
01:28
Only jerk wasn't the word I used.
28
76502
3753
01:32
I said, "You could've gotten me fired."
29
80255
4147
01:36
And he said, "Let's get married."
30
84402
3537
01:39
(Laughter)
31
87939
1287
01:41
"Travel the world and have lots of kids."
32
89226
2896
01:44
So we did.
33
92122
2098
01:46
(Laughter)
34
94220
2045
01:48
(Applause)
35
96265
5242
01:53
And what an alive man Terence Bryan Foley
36
101507
3740
01:57
turned out to be.
37
105247
1447
01:58
He was a Chinese scholar
38
106694
1643
02:00
who later, in his 60s,
39
108337
1866
02:02
got a Ph.D. in Chinese history.
40
110203
2552
02:04
He spoke six languages,
41
112755
2488
02:07
he played 15 musical instruments,
42
115243
2488
02:09
he was a licensed pilot,
43
117731
1776
02:11
he had once been a San Francisco cable car operator,
44
119507
3171
02:14
he was an expert in swine nutrition,
45
122678
2834
02:17
dairy cattle, Dixieland jazz, film noir,
46
125512
3781
02:21
and we did travel the country, and the world,
47
129293
4184
02:25
and we did have a lot of kids.
48
133477
2229
02:27
We followed my job, and it seemed like
49
135706
1742
02:29
there was nothing that we couldn't do.
50
137448
3567
02:33
So when we found the cancer,
51
141015
3782
02:36
it doesn't seem strange to us at all
52
144797
2565
02:39
that without saying a word to each other,
53
147362
2633
02:41
we believed that,
54
149995
2426
02:44
if we were smart enough
55
152421
2259
02:46
and strong enough and brave enough,
56
154680
4331
02:51
and we worked hard enough,
57
159011
2473
02:53
we could keep him from dying ever.
58
161484
5278
02:58
And for years, it seemed like we were succeeding.
59
166762
3499
03:02
The surgeon emerged from the surgery.
60
170261
2879
03:05
What'd he say? He said what surgeons always say:
61
173140
2277
03:07
"We got it all."
62
175417
2002
03:09
Then there was a setback when the pathologists
63
177419
3043
03:12
looked at the kidney cancer closely.
64
180462
2373
03:14
It turned out to be a rare,
65
182835
1629
03:16
exceedingly aggressive type,
66
184464
1809
03:18
with a diagnosis that was almost universally fatal
67
186273
3082
03:21
in several weeks at most.
68
189355
2391
03:23
And yet, he did not die.
69
191746
3710
03:27
Mysteriously, he lived on.
70
195456
3510
03:30
He coached Little League for our son.
71
198966
2084
03:33
He built a playhouse for our daughter.
72
201050
2552
03:35
And meanwhile, I'm burying myself in the Internet
73
203602
3074
03:38
looking for specialists.
74
206676
1674
03:40
I'm looking for a cure.
75
208350
2561
03:42
So a year goes by
76
210911
2077
03:44
before the cancer, as cancers do,
77
212988
3206
03:48
reappears,
78
216194
2000
03:50
and with it comes another death sentence,
79
218194
2076
03:52
this time nine months.
80
220270
2193
03:54
So we try another treatment, aggressive, nasty.
81
222463
4014
03:58
It makes him so sick, he has to quit it,
82
226477
1820
04:00
yet still he lives on.
83
228297
3017
04:03
Then another year goes by.
84
231314
1896
04:05
Two years go by.
85
233210
1550
04:06
More specialists.
86
234760
1489
04:08
We take the kids to Italy.
87
236249
1920
04:10
We take the kids to Australia.
88
238169
2469
04:12
And then more years pass,
89
240638
2712
04:15
and the cancer begins to grow.
90
243350
2390
04:17
This time, there's new treatments on the horizon.
91
245740
2535
04:20
They're exotic. They're experimental.
92
248275
1936
04:22
They're going to attack the cancer in new ways.
93
250211
3208
04:25
So he enters a clinical trial, and it works.
94
253419
4326
04:29
The cancer begins to shrink,
95
257745
1929
04:31
and for the third time,
96
259674
2277
04:33
we've dodged death.
97
261951
3359
04:37
So now I ask you,
98
265310
3297
04:40
how do I feel
99
268607
2389
04:42
when the time finally comes
100
270996
2514
04:45
and there's another dark night,
101
273510
2506
04:48
sometime between midnight and 2 a.m.?
102
276016
2501
04:50
This time it's on the intensive care ward
103
278517
2974
04:53
when a twentysomething resident
104
281491
1838
04:55
that I've never met before
105
283329
2203
04:57
tells me that Terence is dying,
106
285532
2593
05:00
perhaps tonight.
107
288125
2199
05:02
So what do I say when he says,
108
290324
2793
05:05
"What do you want me to do?"
109
293117
2814
05:07
There's another drug out there.
110
295931
2012
05:09
It's newer. It's more powerful.
111
297943
1688
05:11
He started it just two weeks ago.
112
299631
2569
05:14
Perhaps there's still hope ahead.
113
302200
3109
05:17
So what do I say?
114
305309
1955
05:19
I say, "Keep him alive if you can."
115
307264
3356
05:22
And Terence died six days later.
116
310620
3515
05:26
So we fought, we struggled, we triumphed.
117
314135
4048
05:30
It was an exhilarating fight,
118
318183
1796
05:31
and I'd repeat the fight today
119
319979
1717
05:33
without a moment's hesitation.
120
321696
2649
05:36
We fought together, we lived together.
121
324345
2951
05:39
It turned what could have been
122
327296
2104
05:41
seven of the grimmest years of our life
123
329400
2734
05:44
into seven of the most glorious.
124
332134
3611
05:47
It was also an expensive fight.
125
335745
2775
05:50
It was the kind of fight and the kind of choices
126
338520
1961
05:52
that everyone here agrees
127
340481
1634
05:54
pump up the cost of end-of-life care,
128
342115
2405
05:56
and of healthcare for all of us.
129
344520
2286
05:58
And for me, for us,
130
346806
3082
06:01
we pushed the fight right over the edge,
131
349888
2082
06:03
and I never got the chance to say to him
132
351970
3225
06:07
what I say to him now almost every day:
133
355195
3420
06:10
"Hey, buddy, it was a hell of a ride."
134
358615
3077
06:13
We never got the chance to say goodbye.
135
361692
2488
06:16
We never thought it was the end.
136
364180
2279
06:18
We always had hope.
137
366459
5179
06:23
So what do we make of all of this?
138
371638
3864
06:27
Being a journalist, after Terence died,
139
375502
3578
06:31
I wrote a book, "The Cost Of Hope."
140
379080
3289
06:34
I wrote it because I wanted to know
141
382369
2150
06:36
why I did what I did,
142
384519
1686
06:38
why he did what he did,
143
386205
1801
06:40
why everyone around us did what they did.
144
388006
2555
06:42
And what did I discover?
145
390561
1636
06:44
Well, one of the things I discovered is that
146
392197
1574
06:45
experts think that one answer to
147
393771
3077
06:48
what I did at the end was a piece of paper,
148
396848
2750
06:51
the advance directive,
149
399598
2158
06:53
to help families get past the seemingly irrational choices.
150
401756
4340
06:58
Yet I had that piece of paper.
151
406096
4114
07:02
We both did.
152
410210
2053
07:04
And they were readily available.
153
412263
1690
07:05
I had them right at hand.
154
413953
1939
07:07
Both of them said the same thing:
155
415892
2359
07:10
Do nothing if there is no further hope.
156
418251
4501
07:14
I knew Terence's wishes
157
422752
2220
07:16
as clearly and as surely as I knew my own.
158
424972
3814
07:20
Yet we never got to no further hope.
159
428786
5204
07:25
Even with that clear-cut paper in our hands,
160
433990
2757
07:28
we just kept redefining hope.
161
436747
3256
07:32
I believed I could keep him from dying,
162
440003
5292
07:37
and I'd be embarrassed to say that if I hadn't seen
163
445295
2814
07:40
so many people and have talked to so many people
164
448109
2211
07:42
who have felt exactly the same way.
165
450320
2674
07:44
Right up until days before his death,
166
452994
3934
07:48
I felt strongly
167
456928
3326
07:52
and powerfully, and, you might say, irrationally,
168
460254
4043
07:56
that I could keep him from dying ever.
169
464297
5247
08:01
Now, what do the experts call this?
170
469544
3235
08:04
They say it's denial.
171
472779
2347
08:07
It's a strong word, isn't it?
172
475126
2191
08:09
Yet I will tell you that denial
173
477317
2397
08:11
isn't even close to a strong enough word
174
479714
5114
08:16
to describe what those of us
175
484828
2646
08:19
facing the death of our loved ones go through.
176
487474
3638
08:23
And I hear the medical professionals say,
177
491112
2341
08:25
"Well, we'd like to do such-and-such,
178
493453
2083
08:27
but the family's in denial.
179
495536
2451
08:29
The family won't listen to reason.
180
497987
2176
08:32
They're in denial.
181
500163
2022
08:34
How can they insist on this treatment at the end?
182
502185
2352
08:36
It's so clear, yet they're in denial."
183
504537
3304
08:39
Now, I think this maybe isn't
184
507841
2007
08:41
a very useful way of thinking.
185
509848
3004
08:44
It's not just families either.
186
512852
2278
08:47
The medical professionals too,
187
515130
2125
08:49
you out there, you're in denial too.
188
517255
3360
08:52
You want to help. You want to fix.
189
520615
2853
08:55
You want to do.
190
523468
1826
08:57
You've succeeded in everything you've done,
191
525294
2808
09:00
and having a patient die,
192
528102
2042
09:02
well, that must feel like failure.
193
530144
3579
09:05
I saw it firsthand.
194
533723
1844
09:07
Just days before Terence died,
195
535567
2702
09:10
his oncologist said,
196
538269
2018
09:12
"Tell Terence that better days are just ahead."
197
540287
3248
09:15
Days before he died.
198
543535
2382
09:17
Yet Ira Byock,
199
545917
1433
09:19
the director of palliative medicine at Dartmouth
200
547350
2348
09:21
said, "You know, the best doctor in the world
201
549698
2931
09:24
has never succeeded in making anyone immortal."
202
552629
4608
09:29
So what the experts call "denial," I call "hope,"
203
557237
6506
09:35
and I'd like to borrow a phrase
204
563743
2334
09:38
from my friends in software design.
205
566077
3221
09:41
You just redefine denial and hope,
206
569298
3562
09:44
and it becomes a feature of being human.
207
572860
3228
09:48
It's not a bug.
208
576088
1861
09:49
It's a feature.
209
577949
2326
09:52
(Laughter)
210
580275
3094
09:55
So we need to think more constructively
211
583369
3694
09:59
about this very common, very profound
212
587063
4312
10:03
and very powerful human emotion.
213
591375
3956
10:07
It's part of the human condition,
214
595331
2624
10:09
and yet our system and our thinking
215
597955
2177
10:12
isn't built to accommodate it.
216
600132
3169
10:15
So Terence told me a story on that long-ago night,
217
603301
3055
10:18
and I believed it.
218
606356
1905
10:20
Maybe I wanted to believe it.
219
608261
3114
10:23
And during Terence's illness, I, we,
220
611375
5329
10:28
we wanted to believe the story
221
616704
1722
10:30
of our fight together too.
222
618426
2595
10:33
Giving up the fight -- for that's how it felt,
223
621021
3736
10:36
it felt like giving up --
224
624757
1939
10:38
meant giving up not only his life
225
626696
2717
10:41
but also our story,
226
629413
3707
10:45
our story of us as fighters,
227
633120
2210
10:47
the story of us as invincible,
228
635330
2930
10:50
and for the doctors, the story of themselves
229
638260
2208
10:52
as healers.
230
640468
2558
10:55
So what do we need?
231
643026
2684
10:57
Maybe we don't need a new piece of paper.
232
645710
2939
11:00
Maybe we need a new story,
233
648649
2947
11:03
not a story about giving up the fight
234
651596
4009
11:07
or of hopelessness,
235
655605
2271
11:09
but rather a story of victory and triumph,
236
657876
3411
11:13
of a valiant battle and, eventually,
237
661287
4843
11:18
a graceful retreat,
238
666130
2320
11:20
a story that acknowledges
239
668450
3007
11:23
that not even the greatest general defeats every foe,
240
671457
3763
11:27
that no doctor has ever succeeded
241
675220
2621
11:29
in making anyone immortal,
242
677841
2390
11:32
and that no wife, no matter how hard she tried,
243
680231
6066
11:38
has ever stopped even the bravest,
244
686297
4685
11:42
wittiest and most maddeningly lovable husband
245
690982
4049
11:47
from dying when it was his time to go.
246
695031
4193
11:51
People did mention hospice,
247
699224
2313
11:53
but I wouldn't listen.
248
701537
3371
11:56
Hospice was for people who were dying,
249
704908
3925
12:00
and Terence wasn't dying.
250
708833
2773
12:03
As a result, he spent just four days in hospice,
251
711606
2910
12:06
which I'm sure, as you all know,
252
714516
1817
12:08
is a pretty typical outcome,
253
716333
2090
12:10
and we never said goodbye
254
718423
1512
12:11
because we were unprepared for the end.
255
719935
3055
12:14
We have a noble path to curing the disease,
256
722990
3747
12:18
patients and doctors alike,
257
726737
2330
12:21
but there doesn't seem to be
258
729067
2123
12:23
a noble path to dying.
259
731190
2600
12:25
Dying is seen as failing,
260
733790
3058
12:28
and we had a heroic narrative
261
736848
2652
12:31
for fighting together,
262
739500
2093
12:33
but we didn't have a heroic narrative for letting go.
263
741593
5030
12:38
So maybe we need a narrative
264
746623
4118
12:42
for acknowledging the end, and for saying goodbye,
265
750741
3476
12:46
and maybe our new story will be
266
754217
2562
12:48
about a hero's fight, and a hero's goodbye.
267
756779
4606
12:53
Terence loved poetry,
268
761385
2467
12:55
and the Greek poet Constantine Cavafy
269
763852
3227
12:59
is one of my favorite poets.
270
767079
2429
13:01
So I'll give you a couple lines from him.
271
769508
2884
13:04
This is a poem about Mark Antony.
272
772392
2216
13:06
You know Mark Antony, the conquering hero,
273
774608
2693
13:09
Cleopatra's guy?
274
777301
1865
13:11
Actually, one of Cleopatra's guys.
275
779166
2537
13:13
And he's been a pretty good general.
276
781703
2425
13:16
He's won all the fights,
277
784128
1060
13:17
he's eluded all the people that are out to get him,
278
785188
2455
13:19
and yet this time, finally,
279
787643
1788
13:21
he's come to the city of Alexandria
280
789431
1749
13:23
and realized he's lost.
281
791180
1682
13:24
The people are leaving. They're playing instruments.
282
792862
1716
13:26
They're singing.
283
794578
1323
13:27
And suddenly he knows he's been defeated.
284
795901
2600
13:30
And he suddenly knows
285
798501
2179
13:32
he's been deserted by the gods,
286
800680
2525
13:35
and it's time to let go.
287
803205
1940
13:37
And the poet tells him what to do.
288
805145
1967
13:39
He tells him how to say a noble goodbye,
289
807112
3266
13:42
a goodbye that's fit for a hero.
290
810378
3847
13:46
"As if long-prepared,
291
814225
2749
13:48
as if courageous,
292
816974
2679
13:51
as it becomes you
293
819653
2597
13:54
who were worthy of such a city,
294
822250
2172
13:56
approach the window with a firm step,
295
824422
2403
13:58
and with emotion,
296
826825
2535
14:01
but not with the entreaties
297
829360
2199
14:03
or the complaints of a coward,
298
831559
2761
14:06
as a last enjoyment,
299
834320
1971
14:08
listen to the sounds,
300
836291
2124
14:10
the exquisite instruments of the musical troops,
301
838415
3334
14:13
and bid her farewell,
302
841749
2281
14:16
the Alexandria you are losing."
303
844030
4415
14:20
That's a goodbye for a man who was larger than life,
304
848445
3690
14:24
a goodbye for a man
305
852135
2018
14:26
for whom anything,
306
854153
1974
14:28
well, almost anything,
307
856127
3108
14:31
was possible,
308
859235
1890
14:33
a goodbye for a man who kept hope alive.
309
861125
3140
14:36
And isn't that what we're missing?
310
864265
2193
14:38
How can we learn that people's decisions
311
866458
2059
14:40
about their loved ones
312
868517
1510
14:42
are often based strongly, powerfully,
313
870027
3929
14:45
many times irrationally,
314
873956
2852
14:48
on the slimmest of hopes?
315
876808
2344
14:51
The overwhelming presence of hope
316
879152
3022
14:54
isn't denial.
317
882174
1423
14:55
It's part of our DNA as humans,
318
883597
2820
14:58
and maybe it's time our healthcare system --
319
886417
2318
15:00
doctors, patients, insurance companies, us,
320
888735
4484
15:05
started accounting for the power of that hope.
321
893219
3974
15:09
Hope isn't a bug.
322
897193
2300
15:11
It's a feature.
323
899493
2369
15:13
Thank you.
324
901862
2495
15:16
(Applause)
325
904357
3055
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Amanda Bennett - JournalistIn "The Cost of Hope," Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Amanda Bennett brings an investigative angle to the conversation about end-of-life care.
Why you should listen
Amanda Bennett is the Executive Editor of Projects and Investigations for Bloomberg News. Previously she served for three years as the Managing Editor of projects for The Oregonian in Portland and was a reporter for The Wall Street Journal for more than 20 years.
In 1997 Bennett shared the Pulitzer Prize for national reporting for a Wall Street Journal investigation on the struggle against AIDS, and in 2001 received a second Pulitzer Prize, for public service, as the lead of a team at The Oregonian. In 2010 Bennett was elected as co-Chairman of the Pulitzer Prize Board.
Bennett has written six books. Her most recent book, The Cost of Hope, is part-memoir, part-investigative report, about her seven-year struggle within the American healthcare system to save her husband from cancer.
Amanda Bennett | Speaker | TED.com