TED2005
Thomas Barnett: Let's rethink America's military strategy
Filmed:
Readability: 4
1,329,270 views
In this bracingly honest talk, international security strategist Thomas Barnett outlines a post-Cold War solution for the foundering U.S. military that is both sensible and breathtaking in its simplicity: Break it in two.
Thomas Barnett - Military strategist
Strategic planner Thomas Barnett has advised US leaders on national security since the end of the Cold War. His bold ideas about the future of warfare and the military are spelled out in his best-selling book The Pentagon's New Map. Full bio
Strategic planner Thomas Barnett has advised US leaders on national security since the end of the Cold War. His bold ideas about the future of warfare and the military are spelled out in his best-selling book The Pentagon's New Map. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:26
I get asked a lot what the difference between my work is
0
1000
2000
00:28
and typical Pentagon long-range strategic planners.
1
3000
4000
00:32
And the answer I like to offer is
2
7000
1000
00:33
what they typically do is they think about the future of wars
3
8000
3000
00:36
in the context of war.
4
11000
2000
00:38
And what I've spent 15 years doing in this business --
5
13000
3000
00:41
and it's taken me almost 14 to figure it out --
6
16000
2000
00:43
is I think about the future of wars in the context of everything else.
7
18000
5000
00:48
So I tend to specialize on the scene between war and peace.
8
23000
4000
00:52
The material I'm going to show you is one idea from a book
9
27000
3000
00:55
with a lot of ideas.
10
30000
1000
00:56
It's the one that takes me around the world right now
11
31000
2000
00:58
interacting with foreign militaries quite a bit.
12
33000
2000
01:01
The material was generated in two years of work I did
13
36000
2000
01:03
for the Secretary of Defense,
14
38000
1000
01:04
thinking about a new national grand strategy
15
39000
3000
01:07
for the United States.
16
42000
1000
01:09
I'm going to present a problem
17
44000
1000
01:10
and try to give you an answer.
18
45000
2000
01:13
Here's my favorite bonehead concept from the 1990s in the Pentagon:
19
48000
4000
01:17
the theory of anti-access, area-denial asymmetrical strategies.
20
52000
4000
01:21
Why do we call it that?
21
56000
1000
01:22
Because it's got all those A's lined up I guess.
22
57000
4000
01:30
This is gobbledygook for
23
65000
2000
01:32
if the United States fights somebody we're going to be huge.
24
67000
3000
01:35
They're going to be small.
25
70000
1000
01:36
And if they try to fight us in the traditional, straight-up manner
26
71000
2000
01:38
we're going to kick their ass,
27
73000
1000
01:39
which is why people don't try to do that any more.
28
74000
3000
01:42
I met the last Air Force General who had actually
29
77000
3000
01:45
shot down an enemy plane in combat.
30
80000
2000
01:47
He's now a one star General.
31
82000
2000
01:49
That's how distant we are from even meeting an air force
32
84000
4000
01:53
willing to fly against ours.
33
88000
2000
01:55
So that overmatched capability creates problems --
34
90000
3000
01:58
catastrophic successes the White House calls them.
35
93000
3000
02:01
(Laughter)
36
96000
3000
02:04
And we're trying to figure that out,
37
99000
2000
02:06
because it is an amazing capability.
38
101000
2000
02:08
The question is, what's the good you can do with it?
39
103000
3000
02:11
OK?
40
106000
2000
02:13
The theory of anti-access, area-denial asymmetrical strategies --
41
108000
4000
02:17
gobbledygook that we sell to Congress,
42
112000
2000
02:19
because if we just told them we can kick anybody's asses
43
114000
3000
02:22
they wouldn't buy us all the stuff we want.
44
117000
2000
02:24
So we say, area-denial, anti-access asymmetrical strategies
45
119000
4000
02:28
and their eyes glaze over.
46
123000
2000
02:30
(Laughter)
47
125000
3000
02:33
And they say, "Will you build it in my district?"
48
128000
3000
02:36
(Laughter)
49
131000
2000
02:38
(Applause)
50
133000
4000
02:42
Here's my parody and it ain't much of one.
51
137000
1000
02:43
Let's talk about a battle space.
52
138000
1000
02:44
I don't know, Taiwan Straits 2025.
53
139000
2000
02:46
Let's talk about an enemy embedded within that battle space.
54
141000
3000
02:49
I don't know, the Million Man Swim.
55
144000
2000
02:51
(Laughter)
56
146000
3000
02:54
The United States has to access that battle space instantaneously.
57
149000
3000
02:57
They throw up anti-access, area-denial asymmetrical strategies.
58
152000
4000
03:01
A banana peel on the tarmac.
59
156000
2000
03:03
(Laughter)
60
158000
1000
03:04
Trojan horses on our computer networks
61
159000
2000
03:06
reveal all our Achilles' heels instantly.
62
161000
3000
03:09
We say, "China, it's yours."
63
164000
2000
03:11
Prometheus approach, largely a geographic definition,
64
166000
3000
03:14
focuses almost exclusively on the start of conflict.
65
169000
2000
03:16
We field the first-half team in a league
66
171000
2000
03:18
that insists on keeping score until the end of the game.
67
173000
3000
03:21
That's the problem.
68
176000
2000
03:23
We can run the score up against anybody,
69
178000
2000
03:25
and then get our asses kicked in the second half --
70
180000
2000
03:27
what they call fourth generation warfare.
71
182000
3000
03:30
Here's the way I like to describe it instead.
72
185000
2000
03:32
There is no battle space the U.S. Military cannot access.
73
187000
3000
03:35
They said we couldn't do Afghanistan. We did it with ease.
74
190000
2000
03:37
They said we couldn't do Iraq.
75
192000
2000
03:39
We did it with 150 combat casualties in six weeks.
76
194000
4000
03:43
We did it so fast we weren't prepared for their collapse.
77
198000
4000
03:47
There is nobody we can't take down.
78
202000
3000
03:50
The question is, what do you do with the power?
79
205000
2000
03:52
So there's no trouble accessing battle spaces.
80
207000
2000
03:54
What we have trouble accessing is the transition space
81
209000
3000
03:57
that must naturally follow,
82
212000
2000
03:59
and creating the peace space that allows us to move on.
83
214000
3000
04:03
Problem is, the Defense Department over here
84
218000
2000
04:05
beats the hell out of you.
85
220000
2000
04:08
The State Department over here says,
86
223000
1000
04:09
"Come on boy, I know you can make it."
87
224000
2000
04:12
And that poor country runs off that ledge,
88
227000
2000
04:14
does that cartoon thing and then drops.
89
229000
2000
04:16
(Laughter)
90
231000
6000
04:22
This is not about overwhelming force, but proportional force.
91
237000
2000
04:24
It's about non-lethal technologies,
92
239000
2000
04:26
because if you fire real ammo into a crowd
93
241000
3000
04:29
of women and children rioting
94
244000
2000
04:32
you're going to lose friends very quickly.
95
247000
2000
04:34
This is not about projecting power, but about staying power,
96
249000
2000
04:36
which is about legitimacy with the locals.
97
251000
3000
04:39
Who do you access in this transition space?
98
254000
2000
04:41
You have to create internal partners. You have to access coalition partners.
99
256000
3000
04:44
We asked the Indians for 17,000 peace keepers.
100
259000
3000
04:47
I know their senior leadership, they wanted to give it to us.
101
262000
3000
04:50
But they said to us, "You know what?
102
265000
2000
04:52
In that transition space you're mostly hat not enough cattle.
103
267000
3000
04:56
We don't think you can pull it off,
104
271000
1000
04:57
we're not going to give you our 17,000 peace keepers for fodder."
105
272000
2000
04:59
We asked the Russians for 40,000.
106
274000
3000
05:02
They said no.
107
277000
1000
05:03
I was in China in August, I said,
108
278000
1000
05:04
"You should have 50,000 peace keepers in Iraq.
109
279000
3000
05:07
It's your oil, not ours."
110
282000
2000
05:10
Which is the truth. It's their oil.
111
285000
2000
05:12
And the Chinese said to me, "Dr. Barnett, you're absolutely right.
112
287000
3000
05:15
In a perfect world we'd have 50,000 there.
113
290000
3000
05:18
But it's not a perfect world,
114
293000
2000
05:20
and your administration isn't getting us any closer."
115
295000
3000
05:24
But we have trouble accessing our outcomes.
116
299000
2000
05:27
We lucked out, frankly, on the selection.
117
302000
2000
05:29
We face different opponents across these three.
118
304000
3000
05:32
And it's time to start admitting
119
307000
1000
05:33
you can't ask the same 19-year-old to do it all, day in and day out.
120
308000
4000
05:37
It's just too damn hard.
121
312000
2000
05:39
We have an unparalleled capacity to wage war.
122
314000
3000
05:43
We don't do the everything else so well.
123
318000
3000
05:46
Frankly, we do it better than anybody and we still suck at it.
124
321000
2000
05:48
We have a brilliant Secretary of War.
125
323000
2000
05:50
We don't have a Secretary of Everything Else.
126
325000
3000
05:53
Because if we did, that guy would be in front of the Senate,
127
328000
2000
05:55
still testifying over Abu Ghraib.
128
330000
3000
05:58
The problem is he doesn't exist.
129
333000
3000
06:01
There is no Secretary of Everything Else.
130
336000
2000
06:04
I think we have an unparalleled capacity to wage war.
131
339000
3000
06:07
I call that the Leviathan Force.
132
342000
2000
06:09
What we need to build is a force for the Everything Else.
133
344000
2000
06:11
I call them the System Administrators.
134
346000
2000
06:13
What I think this really represents
135
348000
2000
06:15
is lack of an A to Z rule set for the world as a whole
136
350000
2000
06:17
for processing politically bankrupt states.
137
352000
2000
06:19
We have one for processing economically bankrupt states.
138
354000
3000
06:22
It's the IMF Sovereign Bankruptcy Plan, OK?
139
357000
4000
06:26
We argue about it every time we use it.
140
361000
2000
06:28
Argentina just went through it, broke a lot of rules.
141
363000
2000
06:30
They got out on the far end, we said, "Fine, don't worry about it."
142
365000
3000
06:33
It's transparent. A certain amount of certainty
143
368000
3000
06:36
gives the sense of a non-zero outcome.
144
371000
2000
06:38
We don't have one for processing politically bankrupt states
145
373000
2000
06:40
that, frankly, everybody wants gone.
146
375000
3000
06:43
Like Saddam, like Mugabe, like Kim Jong-Il --
147
378000
3000
06:47
people who kill in hundreds of thousands or millions.
148
382000
4000
06:51
Like the 250,000 dead so far in Sudan.
149
386000
3000
06:55
What would an A to Z system look like?
150
390000
2000
06:57
I'm going to distinguish between what I call
151
392000
2000
06:59
front half and back half.
152
394000
2000
07:02
And let's call this red line, I don't know, mission accomplished.
153
397000
4000
07:06
(Laughter)
154
401000
3000
07:09
(Applause)
155
404000
4000
07:13
What we have extant right now,
156
408000
2000
07:15
at the beginning of this system, is the U.N. Security Council as a grand jury.
157
410000
2000
07:17
What can they do?
158
412000
1000
07:18
They can indict your ass.
159
413000
2000
07:22
They can debate it. They can write it on a piece of paper.
160
417000
2000
07:24
They can put it in an envelope and mail it to you,
161
419000
2000
07:26
and then say in no uncertain terms, "Please cut that out."
162
421000
5000
07:31
(Laughter)
163
426000
5000
07:36
That gets you about four million dead in Central Africa over the 1990s.
164
431000
3000
07:39
That gets you 250,000 dead in the Sudan in the last 15 months.
165
434000
4000
07:44
Everybody's got to answer their grandchildren some day
166
439000
1000
07:45
what you did about the holocaust in Africa,
167
440000
2000
07:48
and you better have an answer.
168
443000
2000
07:53
We don't have anything to translate that will into action.
169
448000
4000
07:57
What we do have is the U.S.-enabled Leviathan Force that says,
170
452000
3000
08:00
"You want me to take that guy down? I'll take that guy down.
171
455000
3000
08:03
I'll do it on Tuesday. It will cost you 20 billion dollars."
172
458000
3000
08:06
(Laughter)
173
461000
5000
08:11
But here's the deal.
174
466000
2000
08:13
As soon as I can't find anybody else to air out,
175
468000
2000
08:15
I leave the scene immediately.
176
470000
2000
08:17
That's called the Powell Doctrine.
177
472000
3000
08:21
Way downstream we have the International Criminal Court.
178
476000
2000
08:23
They love to put them on trial. They've got Milosevic right now.
179
478000
2000
08:25
What are we missing?
180
480000
2000
08:27
A functioning executive that will translate will into action,
181
482000
3000
08:30
because we don't have it.
182
485000
2000
08:32
Every time we lead one of these efforts
183
487000
2000
08:34
we have to whip ourselves into this imminent threat thing.
184
489000
3000
08:38
We haven't faced an imminent threat since
185
493000
2000
08:40
the Cuban missile crisis in 1962.
186
495000
2000
08:42
But we use this language from a bygone era
187
497000
1000
08:43
to scare ourselves into doing something
188
498000
3000
08:46
because we're a democracy and that's what it takes.
189
501000
2000
08:48
And if that doesn't work we scream, "He's got a gun!"
190
503000
2000
08:50
just as we rush in.
191
505000
2000
08:52
(Laughter)
192
507000
8000
09:00
And then we look over the body
193
515000
1000
09:01
and we find an old cigarette lighter and we say,
194
516000
2000
09:03
"Jesus, it was dark."
195
518000
2000
09:05
(Laughter)
196
520000
2000
09:07
Do you want to do it, France?
197
522000
2000
09:09
France says, "No, but I do like to criticize you after the fact."
198
524000
5000
09:14
What we need downstream is a great power enabled --
199
529000
3000
09:17
what I call that Sys Admin Force.
200
532000
2000
09:19
We should have had 250,000 troops streaming into Iraq
201
534000
2000
09:21
on the heels of that Leviathan sweeping towards Baghdad.
202
536000
3000
09:24
What do you get then?
203
539000
1000
09:25
No looting, no military disappearing,
204
540000
2000
09:27
no arms disappearing, no ammo disappearing,
205
542000
2000
09:29
no Muqtada al-Sadr -- I'm wrecking his bones --
206
544000
2000
09:31
no insurgency.
207
546000
2000
09:33
Talk to anybody who was over there in the first six months.
208
548000
2000
09:35
We had six months to feel the lob, to get the job done,
209
550000
3000
09:38
and we dicked around for six months.
210
553000
2000
09:40
And then they turned on us.
211
555000
2000
09:42
Why? Because they just got fed up.
212
557000
2000
09:44
They saw what we did to Saddam.
213
559000
2000
09:46
They said, "You're that powerful, you can resurrect this country.
214
561000
2000
09:48
You're America."
215
563000
2000
09:50
What we need is an international reconstruction fund --
216
565000
2000
09:52
Sebastian Mallaby, Washington Post, great idea.
217
567000
2000
09:54
Model on the IMF.
218
569000
2000
09:56
Instead of passing the hat each time, OK?
219
571000
3000
09:59
Where are we going to find this guy? G20, that's easy.
220
574000
3000
10:02
Check out their agenda since 9/11.
221
577000
2000
10:04
All security dominated.
222
579000
2000
10:06
They're going to decide up front how the money gets spent
223
581000
2000
10:08
just like in the IMF.
224
583000
1000
10:09
You vote according to how much money you put in the kitty.
225
584000
3000
10:13
Here's my challenge to the Defense Department.
226
588000
1000
10:14
You've got to build this force. You've got to seed this force.
227
589000
3000
10:17
You've got to track coalition partners. Create a record of success.
228
592000
3000
10:20
You will get this model.
229
595000
2000
10:22
You tell me it's too hard to do.
230
597000
2000
10:24
I'll walk this dog right through that six part series on the Balkans.
231
599000
4000
10:28
We did it just like that.
232
603000
2000
10:30
I'm talking about regularizing it, making it transparent.
233
605000
2000
10:32
Would you like Mugabe gone?
234
607000
2000
10:34
Would you like Kim Jong-Il, who's killed about two million people,
235
609000
2000
10:36
would you like him gone?
236
611000
2000
10:39
Would you like a better system?
237
614000
2000
10:42
This is why it matters to the military.
238
617000
2000
10:44
They've been experiencing an identity crisis since the end of the Cold War.
239
619000
4000
10:48
I'm not talking about the difference between reality and desire,
240
623000
3000
10:51
which I can do because I'm not inside the beltway.
241
626000
2000
10:53
(Laughter)
242
628000
3000
10:56
I'm talking about the 1990s.
243
631000
1000
10:57
The Berlin Wall falls. We do Desert Storm.
244
632000
3000
11:00
The split starts to emerge between those in the military
245
635000
2000
11:02
who see a future they can live with,
246
637000
2000
11:04
and those who see a future that starts to scare them,
247
639000
2000
11:06
like the U.S. submarine community,
248
641000
2000
11:08
which watches the Soviet Navy disappear overnight.
249
643000
2000
11:10
Ah!
250
645000
2000
11:12
(Laughter)
251
647000
2000
11:14
So they start moving from reality towards desire
252
649000
4000
11:18
and they create their own special language
253
653000
2000
11:20
to describe their voyage of self-discovery and self-actualization.
254
655000
3000
11:23
(Laughter)
255
658000
3000
11:26
The problem is you need a big, sexy opponent to fight against.
256
661000
2000
11:28
And if you can't find one you've got to make one up.
257
663000
2000
11:30
China, all grown up, going to be a looker!
258
665000
3000
11:33
(Laughter)
259
668000
4000
11:37
The rest of the military got dragged down into the muck
260
672000
2000
11:39
across the 1990s
261
674000
1000
11:40
and they developed this very derisive term to describe it:
262
675000
2000
11:42
military operations other than war.
263
677000
2000
11:45
I ask you, who joins the military to do things other than war?
264
680000
2000
11:47
Actually, most of them.
265
682000
3000
11:50
Jessica Lynch never planned on shooting back.
266
685000
3000
11:53
Most of them don't pick up a rifle.
267
688000
2000
11:57
I maintain this is code inside the Army for,
268
692000
2000
11:59
"We don't want to do this."
269
694000
3000
12:03
They spent the 1990s working the messy scene
270
698000
2000
12:05
between globalized parts of the world
271
700000
2000
12:07
What I call the core and the gap.
272
702000
4000
12:12
The Clinton administration wasn't interested in running this.
273
707000
2000
12:14
For eight years, after screwing up the relationship on day one --
274
709000
2000
12:16
inauguration day with gays in the military --
275
711000
3000
12:19
which was deft.
276
714000
2000
12:21
(Laughter)
277
716000
2000
12:23
So we were home alone for eight years.
278
718000
2000
12:25
And what did we do home alone?
279
720000
2000
12:27
We bought one military and we operated another.
280
722000
2000
12:29
It's like the guy who goes to the doctor and says,
281
724000
2000
12:31
"Doctor, it hurts when I do this."
282
726000
3000
12:34
(Laughter)
283
729000
3000
12:37
The doctor says, "Stop doing that you idiot."
284
732000
3000
12:40
I used to give this brief inside the Pentagon in the early 1990s.
285
735000
2000
12:42
I'd say, "You're buying one military and you're operating another,
286
737000
2000
12:44
and eventually it's going to hurt. It's wrong.
287
739000
2000
12:46
Bad Pentagon, bad!"
288
741000
2000
12:48
(Laughter)
289
743000
2000
12:50
And they'd say, "Dr. Barnett, you are so right.
290
745000
2000
12:52
Can you come back next year and remind us again?"
291
747000
2000
12:54
(Laughter)
292
749000
6000
13:00
Some people say 9/11 heals the rift --
293
755000
2000
13:02
jerks the long-term transformation gurus
294
757000
3000
13:05
out of their 30,000 foot view of history,
295
760000
2000
13:07
drags them down in to the muck and says, "You want a networked opponent?
296
762000
2000
13:09
I've got one, he's everywhere, go find him."
297
764000
3000
13:12
It elevates MOOTW -- how we pronounce that acronym --
298
767000
3000
13:15
from crap to grand strategy,
299
770000
3000
13:18
because that's how you're going to shrink that gap.
300
773000
2000
13:20
Some people put these two things together
301
775000
1000
13:21
and they call it empire, which I think is a boneheaded concept.
302
776000
3000
13:24
Empire is about the enforcement of not just minimal rule sets,
303
779000
2000
13:26
which you cannot do,
304
781000
2000
13:28
but maximum rule sets which you must do.
305
783000
2000
13:30
It's not our system of governance.
306
785000
2000
13:32
Never how we've sought to interact with the outside world.
307
787000
2000
13:34
I prefer that phrase System Administration.
308
789000
2000
13:36
We enforce the minimal rule sets
309
791000
2000
13:38
for maintaining connectivity to the global economy.
310
793000
2000
13:40
Certain bad things you cannot do.
311
795000
2000
13:45
How this impacts the way we think about the future of war.
312
800000
2000
13:47
This is a concept which gets me vilified throughout the Pentagon.
313
802000
3000
13:50
It makes me very popular as well.
314
805000
2000
13:52
Everybody's got an opinion.
315
807000
2000
13:54
Going back to the beginning of our country --
316
809000
2000
13:56
historically, defenses meant protection of the homeland.
317
811000
3000
14:00
Security has meant everything else.
318
815000
3000
14:03
Written into our constitution,
319
818000
2000
14:05
two different forces, two different functions.
320
820000
3000
14:08
Raise an army when you need it,
321
823000
2000
14:10
and maintain a navy for day-to-day connectivity.
322
825000
5000
14:15
A Department of War, a Department of Everything Else.
323
830000
4000
14:19
A big stick, a baton stick.
324
834000
3000
14:23
Can of whup ass,
325
838000
2000
14:26
the networking force.
326
841000
2000
14:28
In 1947 we merged these two things together
327
843000
2000
14:30
in the Defense Department.
328
845000
2000
14:32
Our long-term rationale becomes,
329
847000
2000
14:34
we're involved in a hair trigger stand off with the Soviets.
330
849000
3000
14:37
To attack America is to risk blowing up the world.
331
852000
3000
14:40
We connected national security to international security
332
855000
4000
14:44
with about a seven minute time delay.
333
859000
3000
14:48
That's not our problem now.
334
863000
2000
14:50
They can kill three million in Chicago tomorrow
335
865000
2000
14:52
and we don't go to the mattresses with nukes.
336
867000
3000
14:55
That's the scary part.
337
870000
2000
14:57
The question is how do we reconnect American national security
338
872000
4000
15:01
with global security to make the world a lot more comfortable,
339
876000
4000
15:05
and to embed and contextualize our employment
340
880000
3000
15:08
of force around the planet?
341
883000
2000
15:13
What's happened since is that bifurcation I described.
342
888000
3000
15:17
We talked about this going all the way back
343
892000
1000
15:18
to the end of the Cold War.
344
893000
2000
15:20
Let's have a Department of War, and a Department of Something Else.
345
895000
2000
15:22
Some people say, "Hell, 9/11 did it for you."
346
897000
4000
15:26
Now we've got a home game and an away game.
347
901000
2000
15:28
(Laughter)
348
903000
5000
15:34
The Department of Homeland Security is a strategic feel good measure.
349
909000
3000
15:38
It's going to be the Department of Agriculture for the 21st century.
350
913000
3000
15:42
TSA -- thousands standing around.
351
917000
3000
15:45
(Laughter)
352
920000
7000
15:52
Just be grateful Robert Reed didn't shove that bomb up his ass.
353
927000
3000
15:55
(Laughter)
354
930000
14000
16:09
Because we'd all be gay then.
355
944000
2000
16:12
I supported the war in Iraq.
356
947000
2000
16:14
He was a bad guy with multiple priors.
357
949000
2000
16:16
It's not like we had to find him
358
951000
2000
16:18
actually killing somebody live to arrest him.
359
953000
4000
16:23
I knew we'd kick ass in the war with the Leviathan Force.
360
958000
2000
16:25
I knew we'd have a hard time with what followed.
361
960000
3000
16:28
But I know this organization doesn't change until it experiences failure.
362
963000
3000
16:32
What do I mean by these two different forces?
363
967000
2000
16:35
This is the Hobbesian Force.
364
970000
2000
16:37
I love this force. I don't want to see it go.
365
972000
2000
16:39
That plus nukes rules out great power war.
366
974000
2000
16:41
This is the military the rest of the world wants us to build.
367
976000
2000
16:43
It's why I travel all over the world talking to foreign militaries.
368
978000
3000
16:46
What does this mean?
369
981000
3000
16:49
It means you've got to stop pretending
370
984000
2000
16:51
you can do these two very disparate skill sets with the same 19-year-old.
371
986000
3000
16:54
Switching back, morning, afternoon, evening,
372
989000
3000
16:57
morning, afternoon, evening.
373
992000
2000
16:59
Handing out aid, shooting back,
374
994000
2000
17:01
handing out aid, shooting back.
375
996000
2000
17:03
It's too much.
376
998000
2000
17:05
The 19-year-olds get tired from the switching, OK?
377
1000000
3000
17:08
(Laughter)
378
1003000
2000
17:10
That force on the left, you can train a 19-year-old to do that.
379
1005000
3000
17:13
That force on the right is more like a 40-year-old cop.
380
1008000
3000
17:16
You need the experience.
381
1011000
2000
17:19
What does this mean in terms of operations?
382
1014000
2000
17:23
The rule is going to be this.
383
1018000
2000
17:26
That Sys Admin force is the force that never comes home,
384
1021000
3000
17:29
does most of your work.
385
1024000
2000
17:31
You break out that Leviathan Force only every so often.
386
1026000
3000
17:34
But here's the promise you make to the American public,
387
1029000
2000
17:36
to your own people, to the world.
388
1031000
2000
17:38
You break out that Leviathan Force,
389
1033000
2000
17:40
you promise, you guarantee that you're going to mount
390
1035000
3000
17:43
one hell of a -- immediately -- follow-on Sys Admin effort.
391
1038000
4000
17:47
Don't plan for the war unless you plan to win the peace.
392
1042000
2000
17:49
(Applause)
393
1044000
6000
17:55
Other differences. Leviathan
394
1050000
2000
17:57
traditional partners, they all look like the Brits
395
1052000
2000
17:59
and their former colonies.
396
1054000
2000
18:01
(Laughter)
397
1056000
2000
18:03
Including us, I would remind you.
398
1058000
2000
18:05
The rest -- wider array of partners.
399
1060000
2000
18:07
International organizations, non-governmental organizations,
400
1062000
2000
18:09
private voluntary organizations, contractors.
401
1064000
2000
18:11
You're not going to get away from that.
402
1066000
2000
18:13
Leviathan Force, it's all about joint operations between the military services.
403
1068000
3000
18:16
We're done with that.
404
1071000
2000
18:18
What we need to do is inter-agency operations,
405
1073000
3000
18:21
which frankly Condi Rice was in charge of.
406
1076000
2000
18:23
And I'm amazed nobody asked her that question when she was confirmed.
407
1078000
3000
18:26
I call the Leviathan Force your dad's military.
408
1081000
3000
18:29
I like them young, male, unmarried, slightly pissed off.
409
1084000
4000
18:33
(Laughter)
410
1088000
7000
18:40
I call the Sys Admin Force your mom's military.
411
1095000
2000
18:42
It's everything the man's military hates.
412
1097000
2000
18:44
Gender balanced much more, older, educated, married with children.
413
1099000
5000
18:49
The force on the left, up or out.
414
1104000
3000
18:52
The force on the right, in and out.
415
1107000
2000
18:55
The force on the left respects Posse Comitatus restrictions
416
1110000
3000
18:58
on the use of force inside the U.S.
417
1113000
2000
19:00
The force on the right's going to obliterate it.
418
1115000
2000
19:02
That's where the National Guard's going to be.
419
1117000
1000
19:03
The force on the left is never coming under the purview
420
1118000
2000
19:05
of the International Criminal Court.
421
1120000
2000
19:07
Sys Admin Force has to.
422
1122000
2000
19:11
Different definitions of network centricity.
423
1126000
3000
19:14
One takes down networks, one puts them up.
424
1129000
3000
19:17
And you've got to wage war here in such a way to facilitate that.
425
1132000
4000
19:21
Do we need a bigger budget?
426
1136000
2000
19:23
Do we need a draft to pull this off?
427
1138000
3000
19:26
Absolutely not.
428
1141000
2000
19:30
I've been told by the Revolution of Military Affairs crowd for years,
429
1145000
3000
19:34
we can do it faster, cheaper, smaller, just as lethal.
430
1149000
3000
19:37
I say, "Great, I'm going to take the Sys Admin budget out of your hide."
431
1152000
4000
19:41
Here's the larger point.
432
1156000
2000
19:43
You're going to build the Sys Admin Force inside the U.S. Military first.
433
1158000
2000
19:45
But ultimately you're going to civilianize it, probably two thirds.
434
1160000
4000
19:49
Inter agency-ize it, internationalize it.
435
1164000
4000
19:53
So yes, it begins inside the Pentagon,
436
1168000
2000
19:55
but over time it's going to cross that river.
437
1170000
3000
19:58
(Laughter)
438
1173000
3000
20:01
I have been to the mountain top. I can see the future.
439
1176000
3000
20:04
I may not live long enough to get you there, but it's going to happen.
440
1179000
3000
20:07
We're going to have a Department of Something Else
441
1182000
2000
20:09
between war and peace.
442
1184000
2000
20:11
Last slide.
443
1186000
1000
20:12
Who gets custody of the kids?
444
1187000
2000
20:14
This is where the Marines in the audience get kind of tense.
445
1189000
2000
20:16
(Laughter)
446
1191000
7000
20:23
And this is when they think about beating the crap out of me
447
1198000
2000
20:25
after the talk.
448
1200000
2000
20:27
(Laughter)
449
1202000
1000
20:28
Read Max Boon.
450
1203000
2000
20:30
This is the history of the marines -- small wars, small arms.
451
1205000
2000
20:32
The Marines are like my West Highland Terrier.
452
1207000
2000
20:34
They get up every morning, they want to dig a hole
453
1209000
2000
20:36
and they want to kill something.
454
1211000
2000
20:38
(Laughter)
455
1213000
2000
20:40
I don't want my Marines handing out aid.
456
1215000
3000
20:43
I want them to be Marines.
457
1218000
2000
20:46
That's what keeps the Sys Admin Force from being a pussy force.
458
1221000
2000
20:48
It keeps it from being the U.N.
459
1223000
2000
20:50
You shoot at these people the Marines are going to come over and kill you.
460
1225000
2000
20:52
(Laughter)
461
1227000
3000
20:55
(Applause)
462
1230000
3000
20:58
Department of Navy, strategic subs go this way,
463
1233000
3000
21:01
surface combatants are over there,
464
1236000
2000
21:03
and the news is they may actually be that small.
465
1238000
2000
21:05
(Laughter)
466
1240000
3000
21:08
I call it the Smart Dust Navy.
467
1243000
2000
21:10
I tell young officers, "You may command 500 ships in your career.
468
1245000
2000
21:12
Bad news is they may not have anybody on them."
469
1247000
4000
21:17
Carriers go both ways because they're a swing asset.
470
1252000
3000
21:21
You'll see the pattern -- airborne, just like carriers.
471
1256000
3000
21:24
Armor goes this way.
472
1259000
2000
21:26
Here's the dirty secret of the Air Force,
473
1261000
1000
21:27
you can win by bombing.
474
1262000
2000
21:29
But you need lots of these guys on the ground to win the peace.
475
1264000
3000
21:32
Shinseki was right with the argument.
476
1267000
3000
21:36
Air force, strategic airlift goes both ways.
477
1271000
4000
21:40
Bombers, fighters go over here.
478
1275000
4000
21:45
Special Operations Command down at Tampa.
479
1280000
2000
21:47
Trigger-pullers go this way.
480
1282000
3000
21:51
Civil Affairs, that bastard child, comes over here.
481
1286000
3000
21:54
Return to the Army.
482
1289000
2000
21:56
The point about the trigger-pullers and Special Operations Command.
483
1291000
3000
21:59
No off season, these guys are always active.
484
1294000
2000
22:02
They drop in, do their business, disappear.
485
1297000
6000
22:08
See me now. Don't talk about it later.
486
1303000
2000
22:10
(Laughter)
487
1305000
4000
22:14
I was never here.
488
1309000
2000
22:16
(Laughter)
489
1311000
3000
22:19
The world is my playground.
490
1314000
2000
22:21
(Laughter)
491
1316000
4000
22:25
I want to keep trigger-pullers trigger-happy.
492
1320000
2000
22:27
I want the rules to be as loose as possible.
493
1322000
2000
22:29
Because when the thing gets prevented in Chicago
494
1324000
2000
22:31
with the three million dead
495
1326000
2000
22:33
that perverts our political system beyond all recognition,
496
1328000
2000
22:35
these are the guys who are going to kill them first.
497
1330000
2000
22:38
So it's better off to have them make some mistakes along the way
498
1333000
2000
22:40
than to see that.
499
1335000
2000
22:42
Reserve component --
500
1337000
2000
22:44
National Guard reserves overwhelmingly Sys Admin.
501
1339000
3000
22:47
How are you going to get them to work for this force?
502
1342000
2000
22:49
Most firemen in this country do it for free.
503
1344000
2000
22:51
This is not about money.
504
1346000
2000
22:53
This is about being up front with these guys and gals.
505
1348000
3000
22:58
Last point, intelligence community --
506
1353000
2000
23:00
the muscle and the defense agencies go this way.
507
1355000
4000
23:04
What should be the CIA, open, analytical, open source
508
1359000
3000
23:07
should come over here.
509
1362000
2000
23:09
The information you need to do this is not secret.
510
1364000
3000
23:12
It's not secret.
511
1367000
2000
23:14
Read that great piece in the New Yorker
512
1369000
1000
23:15
about how our echo boomers, 19 to 25, over in Iraq
513
1370000
3000
23:18
taught each other how to do Sys Admin work,
514
1373000
3000
23:21
over the Internet in chat rooms.
515
1376000
2000
23:23
They said, "Al Qaeda could be listening."
516
1378000
2000
23:25
They said, "Well, Jesus, they already know this stuff."
517
1380000
2000
23:27
(Laughter)
518
1382000
3000
23:30
Take a gift in the left hand.
519
1385000
2000
23:32
These are the sunglasses that don't scare people, simple stuff.
520
1387000
4000
23:38
Censors and transparency, the overheads go in both directions.
521
1393000
3000
23:41
Thanks.
522
1396000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Thomas Barnett - Military strategistStrategic planner Thomas Barnett has advised US leaders on national security since the end of the Cold War. His bold ideas about the future of warfare and the military are spelled out in his best-selling book The Pentagon's New Map.
Why you should listen
Thomas P.M. Barnett's bracing confidence and radical recommendations make him a powerful force shaping the future of the US military.
In his book The Pentagon's New Map: War and Peace in the Twenty-First Century, Barnett draws on a fascinating combination of economic, political and cultural factors to predict and explain the nature of modern warfare. He presents concrete, world-changing strategies for transforming the US military -- adrift in the aftermath of the Cold War and 9/11 -- into a two-tiered power capable not only of winning battles, but of promoting and preserving international peace.
Thomas has been a senior adviser to military and civilian leaders in a range of offices, including the Office of the Secretary of Defense, the Joint Staff, Central Command and Special Operations Command. During the tumultuous period from November 2001 to June 2003, he advised the Pentagon on transforming military capabilities to meet future threats. He led the five-year NewRuleSet.Project, which studied how globalization is transforming warfare. The study found, among other things, that when a country's per-capita income rises above ~$3,000, war becomes much less likely.
Barnett is unusually outspoken in a field cloaked in secrecy. His follow-up book is Blueprint for Action: A Future Worth Creating, and he writes regular columns for Esquire and the Knoxville News Sentinel. He also maintains a prolific blog, where he covers current global events.
Thomas Barnett | Speaker | TED.com