ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Eli Pariser - Organizer and author
Pioneering online organizer Eli Pariser is the author of "The Filter Bubble," about how personalized search might be narrowing our worldview.

Why you should listen

Shortly after the September 11, 2001, attacks, Eli Pariser created a website calling for a multilateral approach to fighting terrorism. In the following weeks, over half a million people from 192 countries signed on, and Pariser rather unexpectedly became an online organizer. The website merged with MoveOn.org in November 2001, and Pariser -- then 20 years old -- joined the group to direct its foreign policy campaigns. He led what the New York Times Magazine called the "mainstream arm of the peace movement" -- tripling MoveOn's member base and demonstrating how large numbers of small donations could be mobilized through online engagement.

In 2004, Pariser became executive director of MoveOn. Under his leadership, MoveOn.org Political Action has grown to 5 million members and raised over $120 million from millions of small donors to support advocacy campaigns and political candidates. Pariser focused MoveOn on online-to-offline organizing, developing phone-banking tools and precinct programs in 2004 and 2006 that laid the groundwork for Barack Obama's extraordinary web-powered campaign. In 2008, Pariser transitioned the Executive Director role at MoveOn to Justin Ruben and became President of MoveOn’s board; he's now a senior fellow at the Roosevelt Institute.

His book The Filter Bubble is set for release May 12, 2011. In it, he asks how modern search tools -- the filter by which many of see the wider world -- are getting better and better and screening the wider world from us, by returning only the search results it "thinks" we want to see.

More profile about the speaker
Eli Pariser | Speaker | TED.com
TEDSummit 2019

Eli Pariser: What obligation do social media platforms have to the greater good?

Filmed:
1,378,802 views

Social media has become our new home. Can we build it better? Taking design cues from urban planners and social scientists, technologist Eli Pariser shows how the problems we're encountering on digital platforms aren't all that new -- and shares how, by following the model of thriving towns and cities, we can create trustworthy online communities.
- Organizer and author
Pioneering online organizer Eli Pariser is the author of "The Filter Bubble," about how personalized search might be narrowing our worldview. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
I was talking to a guy
at a party in California
0
809
3556
00:16
about tech platforms
1
4389
1452
00:17
and the problems
they're creating in society.
2
5865
2698
00:21
And he said, "Man, if the CEOs
just did more drugs
3
9429
3739
00:25
and went to Burning Man,
4
13192
1183
00:26
we wouldn't be in this mess."
5
14399
1642
00:28
(Laughter)
6
16065
1373
00:29
I said, "I'm not sure I agree with you."
7
17462
2769
00:33
For one thing, most of the CEOs
have already been to Burning Man.
8
21129
3094
00:36
(Laughter)
9
24247
1014
00:37
But also, I'm just not sure
that watching a bunch of half-naked people
10
25285
3327
00:40
run around and burn things
11
28636
1318
00:41
is really the inspiration
they need right now.
12
29978
2228
00:44
(Laughter)
13
32230
1680
00:45
But I do agree that things are a mess.
14
33934
2533
00:49
And so, we're going to come
back to this guy,
15
37037
2126
00:51
but let's talk about the mess.
16
39187
1467
00:53
Our climate's getting hotter and hotter.
17
41585
2373
00:55
It's getting harder and harder
to tell truth from fiction.
18
43982
2730
00:58
And we've got this global
migratory crisis.
19
46736
2468
01:01
And just at the moment
when we really need new tools
20
49625
3248
01:04
and new ways of coming
together as a society,
21
52897
2748
01:07
it feels like social media
is kind of tearing at our civic fabric
22
55669
4254
01:11
and setting us against each other.
23
59947
1960
01:14
We've got viral
misinformation on WhatsApp,
24
62411
2992
01:17
bullying on Instagram
25
65427
1976
01:19
and Russian hackers on Facebook.
26
67427
2285
01:22
And I think this conversation
that we're having right now
27
70633
3031
01:25
about the harms that
these platforms are creating
28
73688
2812
01:28
is so important.
29
76524
1150
01:30
But I also worry
30
78823
1794
01:32
that we could be letting a kind of good
existential crisis in Silicon Valley
31
80641
4396
01:37
go to waste
32
85061
1539
01:38
if the bar for success is just
that it's a little harder
33
86624
3058
01:41
for Macedonian teenagers
to publish false news.
34
89706
3584
01:46
The big question, I think, is not just
35
94489
2333
01:48
what do we want platforms to stop doing,
36
96846
2889
01:51
but now that they've effectively
taken control of our online public square,
37
99759
4501
01:56
what do we need from them
for the greater good?
38
104284
2825
01:59
To me, this is one of the most
important questions of our time.
39
107827
4151
02:05
What obligations
do tech platforms have to us
40
113161
3278
02:08
in exchange for the power we let them hold
over our discourse?
41
116463
4144
02:13
I think this question is so important,
42
121022
2015
02:15
because even if today’s platforms go away,
43
123061
2413
02:17
we need to answer this question
44
125498
1508
02:19
in order to be able to ensure
that the new platforms that come back
45
127030
3534
02:22
are any better.
46
130588
1150
02:24
So for the last year,
I've been working with Dr. Talia Stroud
47
132683
2961
02:27
at the University of Texas, Austin.
48
135668
1690
02:29
We've talked to sociologists
and political scientists
49
137382
2733
02:32
and philosophers
50
140139
1216
02:33
to try to answer this question.
51
141379
1809
02:35
And at first we asked,
52
143641
1319
02:36
"If you were Twitter or Facebook
and trying to rank content for democracy
53
144984
4362
02:41
rather than for ad clicks or engagement,
54
149370
2378
02:43
what might that look like?"
55
151772
1474
02:46
But then we realized,
56
154089
1485
02:47
this sort of suggests that
this is an information problem
57
155598
3535
02:51
or a content problem.
58
159157
1496
02:53
And for us, the platform crisis
is a people problem.
59
161585
3960
02:58
It's a problem about the emergent
weird things that happen
60
166721
3151
03:01
when large groups of people get together.
61
169896
2089
03:04
And so we turned to another, older idea.
62
172698
3585
03:08
We asked,
63
176307
1151
03:09
"What happens when we think
about platforms as spaces?"
64
177482
3116
03:13
We know from social psychology
that spaces shape behavior.
65
181442
3889
03:17
You put the same group of people
in a room like this,
66
185969
3595
03:21
and they're going to behave
really differently
67
189588
2166
03:23
than in a room like this.
68
191778
1317
03:25
When researchers put
softer furniture in classrooms,
69
193802
2886
03:28
participation rates rose by 42 percent.
70
196712
3039
03:32
And spaces even have
political consequences.
71
200712
2691
03:36
When researchers looked at
neighborhoods with parks
72
204157
3642
03:39
versus neighborhoods without,
73
207823
1484
03:41
after adjusting for socioeconomic factors,
74
209331
2632
03:43
they found that neighborhoods with parks
had higher levels of social trust
75
211987
3744
03:47
and were better able to advocate
for themselves politically.
76
215755
3096
03:51
So spaces shape behavior,
77
219549
2536
03:54
partly by the way they're designed
78
222109
2746
03:56
and partly by the way that they encode
certain norms about how to behave.
79
224879
4999
04:02
We all know that there are some behaviors
that are OK in a bar
80
230749
3646
04:06
that are not OK in a library,
81
234419
1719
04:08
and maybe vice versa.
82
236162
1658
04:10
And this gives us a little bit of a clue,
83
238130
2023
04:12
because there are online spaces
84
240177
1731
04:13
that encode these same kinds
of behavioral norms.
85
241932
3478
04:18
So, for example, behavior on LinkedIn
86
246244
2841
04:21
seems pretty good.
87
249109
1723
04:23
Why?
88
251419
1270
04:24
Because it reads as a workplace.
89
252713
1750
04:26
And so people follow workplace norms.
90
254871
2650
04:29
You can even see it in the way
they dress in their profile pictures.
91
257545
3621
04:33
(Laughter)
92
261190
1165
04:34
So if LinkedIn is a workplace,
93
262379
3146
04:37
what is Twitter like?
94
265549
1467
04:39
(Laughter)
95
267040
1394
04:40
Well, it's like a vast, cavernous expanse,
96
268458
3214
04:43
where there are people
talking about sports,
97
271696
2064
04:45
arguing about politics,
yelling at each other, flirting,
98
273784
2681
04:48
trying to get a job,
99
276489
1170
04:49
all in the same place,
with no walls, no divisions,
100
277683
2743
04:52
and the owner gets paid more
the louder the noise is.
101
280450
2849
04:55
(Laughter)
102
283323
1040
04:56
No wonder it's a mess.
103
284387
1467
04:58
And this raises another thing
that become obvious
104
286744
2635
05:01
when we think about platforms
in terms of physical space.
105
289403
2866
05:04
Good physical spaces
are almost always structured.
106
292997
3135
05:08
They have rules.
107
296640
1150
05:11
Silicon Valley is built on this idea
that unstructured space is conducive
108
299108
6621
05:17
for human behavior.
109
305753
1419
05:19
And I actually think
there's a reason for this myopia
110
307196
2651
05:21
built into the location
of Silicon Valley itself.
111
309871
3032
05:26
So, Michele Gelfand is a sociologist
112
314077
3160
05:29
who studies how norms
vary across cultures.
113
317261
2434
05:31
And she watches how cultures like Japan --
which she calls "tight" --
114
319719
4875
05:36
is very conformist, very rule-following,
115
324618
2340
05:38
and cultures like Brazil are very loose.
116
326982
2913
05:41
You can see this even in things like
117
329919
1929
05:43
how closely synchronized
the clocks are on a city street.
118
331872
2927
05:47
So as you can see, the United States
is one of the looser countries.
119
335244
4679
05:51
And the loosest state
in the United States is,
120
339947
3365
05:55
you got it, California.
121
343336
2164
05:58
And Silicon Valley culture came out
of the 1970s Californian counterculture.
122
346709
5597
06:04
So, just to recap:
123
352330
1175
06:05
the spaces that the world is living in
124
353529
2190
06:07
came out of the loosest culture
in the loosest state
125
355743
2503
06:10
in one of the loosest
countries in the world.
126
358270
2926
06:14
No wonder they undervalue structure.
127
362014
2793
06:17
And I think this really matters,
because people need structure.
128
365821
4007
06:22
You may have heard this word "anomie."
129
370749
2167
06:24
It literally means
"a lack of norms" in French.
130
372940
2820
06:27
It was coined by Émile Durkheim
131
375784
1804
06:29
to describe the vast, overwhelming feeling
132
377612
4230
06:33
that people have in spaces without norms.
133
381866
2454
06:37
Anomie has political consequences.
134
385278
2266
06:40
Because what Gelfand has found
is that, when things are too loose,
135
388317
4970
06:45
people crave order and structure.
136
393311
2335
06:48
And that craving for order and structure
correlates really strongly
137
396182
4760
06:52
with support for people like these guys.
138
400966
2247
06:55
(Laughter)
139
403237
1490
06:57
I don't think it's crazy to ask
140
405442
2310
06:59
if the structurelessness of online life
is actually feeding anxiety
141
407776
5436
07:05
that's increasing a responsiveness
to authoritarianism.
142
413236
2913
07:10
So how might platforms
bring people together
143
418561
3508
07:14
in a way that creates meaning
144
422093
1794
07:15
and helps people understand each other?
145
423911
2325
07:18
And this brings me back
to our friend from Burning Man.
146
426680
2830
07:22
Because listening to him, I realized:
147
430545
2151
07:24
it's not just that Burning Man
isn't the solution --
148
432720
3047
07:27
it's actually a perfect metaphor
for the problem.
149
435791
3262
07:31
(Laughter)
150
439077
1349
07:32
You know, it's a great place
to visit for a week,
151
440450
2310
07:34
this amazing art city,
rising out of nowhere in the dust.
152
442784
3888
07:39
But you wouldn't want to live there.
153
447387
1728
07:41
(Laughter)
154
449139
1039
07:42
There's no running water,
155
450202
1788
07:44
there's no trash pickup.
156
452014
1642
07:45
At some point, the hallucinogens run out,
157
453680
2584
07:48
and you're stuck with a bunch
of wealthy white guys
158
456288
2389
07:50
in the dust in the desert.
159
458701
1302
07:52
(Laughter)
160
460027
1182
07:53
Which, to me, is sometimes
how social media feels in 2019.
161
461233
4158
07:57
(Laughter)
162
465415
1621
07:59
A great, fun, hallucinatory place to visit
has become our home.
163
467060
4363
08:05
And so,
164
473147
1404
08:06
if we look at platforms
through the lens of spaces,
165
474575
2478
08:09
we can then ask ourselves:
166
477077
1587
08:10
Who knows how to structure spaces
for the public good?
167
478688
4119
08:16
And it turns out, this is a question
168
484053
1750
08:17
people have been thinking about
for a long time about cities.
169
485827
2961
08:21
Cities were the original platforms.
170
489855
2595
08:24
Two-sided marketplace?
171
492474
1486
08:25
Check.
172
493984
1292
08:27
Place to keep up with old friends
and distant relatives?
173
495300
3209
08:30
Check.
174
498533
1166
08:31
Vector for viral sharing?
175
499723
1937
08:33
Check.
176
501684
1365
08:35
In fact, cities have encountered
177
503073
2174
08:37
a lot of the same social
and political challenges
178
505271
3639
08:40
that platforms are now encountering.
179
508934
2087
08:43
They've dealt with massive growth
that overwhelmed existing communities
180
511871
4864
08:49
and the rise of new business models.
181
517656
2811
08:53
They've even had new,
frictionless technologies
182
521799
2906
08:56
that promised to connect everyone together
183
524729
2277
08:59
and that instead deepened
existing social and race divides.
184
527736
4196
09:05
But because of this history
of decay and renewal
185
533371
2995
09:08
and segregation and integration,
186
536390
2171
09:10
cities are the source
of some of our best ideas
187
538585
2698
09:13
about how to build functional,
thriving communities.
188
541307
3738
09:18
Faced with a top-down,
car-driven vision of city life,
189
546053
4199
09:22
pioneers like Jane Jacobs said,
190
550276
2682
09:24
let’s instead put human relationships
at the center of urban design.
191
552982
4214
09:30
Jacobs and her fellow travelers
like Holly Whyte, her editor,
192
558053
3478
09:33
were these really great observers
of what actually happened on the street.
193
561555
4695
09:38
They watched: Where did
people stop and talk?
194
566274
3707
09:42
When did neighbors become friends?
195
570005
2310
09:44
And they learned a lot.
196
572339
1534
09:46
For example, they noticed
that successful public places
197
574530
4547
09:51
generally have three different ways
that they structure behavior.
198
579101
3586
09:54
There's the built environment,
199
582711
2453
09:57
you know, that we're going to put
a fountain here or a playground there.
200
585188
4077
10:01
But then, there's programming,
201
589972
1913
10:03
like, let's put a band at seven
and get the kids out.
202
591909
4039
10:08
And there's this idea of mayors,
203
596917
2197
10:11
people who kind of take this
informal ownership of a space
204
599138
3169
10:14
to keep it welcoming and clean.
205
602331
2067
10:17
All three of these things
actually have analogues online.
206
605778
2982
10:21
But platforms mostly focus on code,
207
609331
2010
10:23
on what's physically
possible in the space.
208
611365
2746
10:26
And they focus much less on these
other two softer, social areas.
209
614810
4715
10:31
What are people doing there?
210
619549
1699
10:33
Who's taking responsibility for it?
211
621272
2086
10:36
So like Jane Jacobs did for cities,
212
624470
2679
10:39
Talia and I think we need
a new design movement
213
627173
3070
10:42
for online space,
214
630267
1651
10:43
one that considers
215
631942
1177
10:45
not just "How do we build products
that work for users or consumers?"
216
633143
5078
10:50
"How do we make something user-friendly?"
217
638245
2911
10:53
but "How do we make products
that are public-friendly?"
218
641180
2907
10:58
Because we need products
that don't serve individuals
219
646093
3831
11:01
at the expense of the social fabric
on which we all depend.
220
649948
3891
11:06
And we need it urgently,
221
654877
1159
11:08
because political scientists tell us
222
656060
2198
11:10
that healthy democracies
need healthy public spaces.
223
658282
4715
11:17
So, the public-friendly digital design
movement that Talia and I imagine
224
665416
4159
11:21
asks this question:
225
669599
1327
11:22
What would this interaction be like
if it was happening in physical space?
226
670950
4024
11:26
And it asks the reverse question:
227
674998
1590
11:28
What can we learn
from good physical spaces
228
676612
2629
11:31
about how to structure behavior
in the online world?
229
679265
2849
11:34
For example, I grew up
in a small town in Maine,
230
682138
3095
11:37
and I went to a lot of those
town hall meetings that you hear about.
231
685257
3825
11:41
And unlike the storybook version,
they weren't always nice.
232
689419
3428
11:45
Like, people had big conflicts,
big feelings ...
233
693315
3080
11:48
It was hard sometimes.
234
696419
1587
11:50
But because of the way
that that space was structured,
235
698030
2825
11:52
we managed to land it OK.
236
700879
2374
11:55
How?
237
703897
1412
11:57
Well, here's one important piece.
238
705333
2010
12:00
The downcast glance, the dirty look,
239
708349
2357
12:02
the raised eyebrow, the cough ...
240
710730
2000
12:05
When people went on too long
or lost the crowd,
241
713627
4177
12:09
they didn't get banned or blocked
or hauled out by the police,
242
717828
3603
12:13
they just got this soft,
negative social feedback.
243
721455
2894
12:16
And that was actually very powerful.
244
724903
2216
12:20
I think Facebook and Twitter
could build this,
245
728101
2661
12:22
something like this.
246
730786
2171
12:27
(Laughter)
247
735097
2804
12:31
I think there are some other things
that online spaces can learn
248
739136
3065
12:34
from offline spaces.
249
742225
1454
12:36
Holly Whyte observed
that in healthy public spaces,
250
744061
3246
12:39
there are often many different places
that afford different ways of relating.
251
747331
3651
12:43
So the picnic table
where you have lunch with your family
252
751006
4324
12:48
may not be suited for the romantic
walk with a partner
253
756830
3882
12:52
or the talk with some business colleagues.
254
760736
2754
12:55
And it's worth noting that in real space,
255
763514
2000
12:57
in none of these places are there big,
visible public signs of engagement.
256
765538
4275
13:02
So digital designers could think about
257
770919
2847
13:05
what kind of conversations
do we actually want to invite,
258
773790
2980
13:08
and how do we build specifically
for those kinds of conversations.
259
776794
3317
13:13
Remember the park that we talked about
that built social trust?
260
781056
3600
13:16
That didn't happen because people
were having these big political arguments.
261
784969
3669
13:20
Most strangers don't actually
even talk to each other
262
788662
2501
13:23
the first three or four
or five times they see each other.
263
791187
2992
13:27
But when people,
even very different people,
264
795378
2433
13:29
see each other a lot,
265
797835
1166
13:31
they develop familiarity,
266
799025
1222
13:32
and that creates
the bedrock for relationships.
267
800271
2468
13:35
And I think, actually, you know,
268
803887
3365
13:39
maybe that early idea of cyberspace
as kind of this bodiless meeting place
269
807276
5022
13:44
of pure minds and pure ideas
270
812322
1902
13:46
sent us off in the wrong direction.
271
814248
1816
13:48
Maybe what we need instead
is to find a way to be in proximity,
272
816913
3365
13:52
mostly talking amongst ourselves,
273
820302
2174
13:54
but all sharing the same warm sun.
274
822500
2705
13:58
And finally:
275
826391
1162
13:59
healthy public spaces create
a sense of ownership and equity.
276
827577
4199
14:04
And this is where the city metaphor
becomes challenging.
277
832494
3111
14:07
Because, if Twitter is a city,
278
835629
1473
14:09
it's a city that's owned
by just a few people
279
837126
3078
14:12
and optimized for financial return.
280
840228
2373
14:16
I think we really need
digital environments
281
844014
3095
14:19
that we all actually have
some real ownership of,
282
847133
2722
14:21
environments that respect
the diversity of human existence
283
849879
3992
14:25
and that give us some say
and some input into the process.
284
853895
2945
14:28
And I think we need this urgently.
285
856864
1920
14:30
Because Facebook right now --
286
858808
1865
14:32
I sort of think of, like, 1970s New York.
287
860697
2949
14:35
(Laughter)
288
863670
1246
14:36
The public spaces are decaying,
there's trash in the streets,
289
864940
3214
14:40
people are kind of, like,
mentally and emotionally
290
868178
2476
14:42
warming themselves over burning garbage.
291
870678
2090
14:44
(Laughter)
292
872792
1364
14:46
And --
293
874180
1150
14:48
(Applause)
294
876315
5284
14:53
And the natural response to this
is to hole up in your apartment
295
881623
3343
14:56
or consider fleeing for the suburbs.
296
884990
2385
15:00
It doesn't surprise me
297
888044
1500
15:01
that people are giving up
on the idea of online public spaces
298
889568
4269
15:05
the way that they've given up
on cities over their history.
299
893861
3485
15:10
And sometimes -- I'll be honest --
300
898268
1714
15:12
it feels to me like this whole project
of, like, wiring up a civilization
301
900006
4293
15:16
and getting billions of people
to come into contact with each other
302
904323
3159
15:19
is just impossible.
303
907506
1411
15:22
But modern cities tell us
that it is possible
304
910204
3030
15:25
for millions of people
who are really different,
305
913258
2246
15:27
sometimes living
right on top of each other,
306
915528
2881
15:30
not just to not kill each other,
307
918433
1674
15:32
but to actually build things together,
308
920131
2740
15:34
find new experiences,
309
922895
1333
15:36
create beautiful,
important infrastructure.
310
924252
3547
15:41
And we cannot give up on that promise.
311
929153
3881
15:45
If we want to solve the big,
important problems in front of us,
312
933855
4730
15:50
we need better online public spaces.
313
938609
2603
15:53
We need digital urban planners,
314
941893
2501
15:56
new Jane Jacobses,
315
944418
1151
15:57
who are going to build the parks
and park benches of the online world.
316
945593
4166
16:01
And we need digital,
public-friendly architects,
317
949783
3513
16:05
who are going to build
what Eric Klinenberg calls
318
953320
2530
16:07
"palaces for the people" --
libraries and museums and town halls.
319
955874
4343
16:12
And we need a transnational movement,
320
960241
2717
16:14
where these spaces
can learn from each other,
321
962982
2397
16:17
just like cities have,
322
965403
1216
16:18
about everything from urban farming
to public art to rapid transit.
323
966643
5171
16:25
Humanity moves forward
324
973215
2960
16:28
when we find new ways to rely on
and understand and trust each other.
325
976199
5442
16:34
And we need this now more than ever.
326
982207
2626
16:38
If online digital spaces
are going to be our new home,
327
986232
3793
16:42
let's make them a comfortable,
beautiful place to live,
328
990049
3619
16:45
a place we all feel not just included
329
993692
2302
16:48
but actually some ownership of.
330
996018
1816
16:50
A place we get to know each other.
331
998669
1819
16:53
A place you'd actually want
not just to visit
332
1001290
3283
16:56
but to bring your kids.
333
1004597
1440
16:59
Thank you.
334
1007127
1159
17:00
(Applause)
335
1008310
4586

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Eli Pariser - Organizer and author
Pioneering online organizer Eli Pariser is the author of "The Filter Bubble," about how personalized search might be narrowing our worldview.

Why you should listen

Shortly after the September 11, 2001, attacks, Eli Pariser created a website calling for a multilateral approach to fighting terrorism. In the following weeks, over half a million people from 192 countries signed on, and Pariser rather unexpectedly became an online organizer. The website merged with MoveOn.org in November 2001, and Pariser -- then 20 years old -- joined the group to direct its foreign policy campaigns. He led what the New York Times Magazine called the "mainstream arm of the peace movement" -- tripling MoveOn's member base and demonstrating how large numbers of small donations could be mobilized through online engagement.

In 2004, Pariser became executive director of MoveOn. Under his leadership, MoveOn.org Political Action has grown to 5 million members and raised over $120 million from millions of small donors to support advocacy campaigns and political candidates. Pariser focused MoveOn on online-to-offline organizing, developing phone-banking tools and precinct programs in 2004 and 2006 that laid the groundwork for Barack Obama's extraordinary web-powered campaign. In 2008, Pariser transitioned the Executive Director role at MoveOn to Justin Ruben and became President of MoveOn’s board; he's now a senior fellow at the Roosevelt Institute.

His book The Filter Bubble is set for release May 12, 2011. In it, he asks how modern search tools -- the filter by which many of see the wider world -- are getting better and better and screening the wider world from us, by returning only the search results it "thinks" we want to see.

More profile about the speaker
Eli Pariser | Speaker | TED.com