TED2007
Murray Gell-Mann: Beauty, truth and ... physics?
莫瑞‧蓋曼(Murray Gell-Mann)談物理之美與真相
Filmed:
Readability: 4
1,420,558 views
諾貝爾獎得主莫瑞‧蓋曼(Murray Gell-Mann)以幽默及科普的口吻, 震撼了TED的成員對粒子物理的知識. 物理定律的方程式定是簡潔優美的嗎?
Murray Gell-Mann - Physicist
Murray Gell-Mann brings visibility to a crucial aspect of our existence that we can't actually see: elemental particles. He won the Nobel Prize in Physics for introducing quarks, one of two fundamental ingredients for all matter in the universe. Full bio
Murray Gell-Mann brings visibility to a crucial aspect of our existence that we can't actually see: elemental particles. He won the Nobel Prize in Physics for introducing quarks, one of two fundamental ingredients for all matter in the universe. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Thank you for putting up these pictures of my colleagues over here.
0
0
4000
謝謝你在旁邊掛上我"同事"的相片.
00:16
(Laughter) We'll be talking about them.
1
4000
5000
(笑聲). 等一下會談到他們.
00:21
Now, I'm going try an experiment. I don't do experiments, normally. I'm a theorist.
2
9000
5000
現在, 我想作個實驗. 但我平時不作實驗的, 我是搞理論的.
00:26
But I'm going see what happens if I press this button.
3
14000
4000
來看看按下這個按鈕會發生什麼現象.
00:30
Sure enough. OK. I used to work in this field of elementary particles.
4
18000
5000
果然如此. 好的. 我曾研究過基本粒子.
00:35
What happens to matter if you chop it up very fine?
5
23000
4000
若你將它切成很小塊會發生什麼事呢?
00:39
What is it made of?
6
27000
2000
它是由什麼組成的?
00:41
And the laws of these particles are valid throughout the universe,
7
29000
5000
這些粒子的物理定律放諸宇宙各處都是正確的,
00:46
and they're very much connected with the history of the universe.
8
34000
3000
且它們與宇宙的歷史是息息相關的.
00:49
We know a lot about four forces. There must be a lot more,
9
37000
3000
我們雖了解四種基本力(強,弱作用,電磁,重力). 但一定還有更多種未知力,
00:52
but those are at very, very small distances,
10
40000
2000
只是其作用距離非常, 非常小,
00:54
and we haven't really interacted with them very much yet.
11
42000
3000
我們還未真的接觸過它們.
00:57
The main thing I want to talk about is this:
12
45000
4000
我主要想談的是:
01:01
that we have this remarkable experience in this field of fundamental physics
13
49000
4000
對於探究基本的物理定律, 我們有一個神奇的經驗法則,
01:05
that beauty is a very successful criterion for choosing the right theory.
14
53000
7000
就是若方程式越"簡潔優美", 往往越有希望是正確的理論.
01:12
And why on earth could that be so?
15
60000
5000
但這未免也太扯了吧?
01:17
Well, here's an example from my own experience.
16
65000
3000
好吧, 舉一個我個人的經驗為例.
01:20
It's fairly dramatic, actually, to have this happen.
17
68000
5000
其實還蠻 戲劇化的.
01:25
Three or four of us, in 1957,
18
73000
3000
1957年時, 包括我共三或四位
01:28
put forward a partially complete theory of one of these forces, this weak force.
19
76000
5000
對四種力之一的弱作用力, 提出了一個半完成的理論.
01:33
And it was in disagreement with seven -- seven, count them, seven experiments.
20
81000
6000
但是當時與七個實驗結果不相符. (七, 沒錯, 竟有七個)
01:39
Experiments were all wrong.
21
87000
3000
那些實驗結果全錯了.
01:42
And we published before knowing that,
22
90000
2000
但我們早在被證實前, 照樣敢發表那理論
01:44
because we figured it was so beautiful, it's gotta be right!
23
92000
3000
因為我們覺得那理論太美了, 它非得要對才行!
01:47
The experiments had to be wrong, and they were.
24
95000
3000
所以那些實驗非得是錯的, 果不其然.
01:50
Now our friend over there, Albert Einstein,
25
98000
3000
現在來談談我們的一位老友, 愛因斯坦,
01:53
used to pay very little attention when people said,
26
101000
4000
他總是毫不在意當有人對他說:
01:57
"You know, there's a man with an experiment that seems to disagree with special relativity.
27
105000
5000
"你聽說了嗎, DC Miller作出一項實驗似乎與相對論矛盾,
02:02
DC Miller. What about that?" And he would say, "Aw, that'll go away." (Laughter)
28
110000
9000
你有什麼看法?" 他總是答: "喔, 那會過去的." (笑聲)
02:11
Now, why does stuff like that work? That's the question.
29
119000
3000
所以, 到底為什麼簡潔優美如此成功? 這是關鍵問題.
02:14
Now, yeah, what do we mean by beautiful? That's one thing.
30
122000
5000
現在, 對, 至於我所指的"美"是什麼意思? 這是另一個問題,
02:19
I'll try to make that clear -- partially clear.
31
127000
3000
我會試著解釋清楚, 大致上清楚.
02:22
Why should it work, and is this something to do with human beings?
32
130000
5000
為何美如此成功, 這跟人類的心靈有關嗎?
02:27
I'll let you in on the answer to the last one that I offer,
33
135000
3000
這答案我就直接講了,
02:30
and that is, it has nothing to do with human beings.
34
138000
2000
答案就是, 它跟人類心靈一點關係都沒有.
02:32
Somewhere in some other planet, orbiting some very distant star,
35
140000
5000
假設有另一個繞著某個太陽的地球, 或許在另一個銀河系裡,
02:37
maybe in a another galaxy,
36
145000
2000
在那星球上的某處,
02:39
there could well be entities that are at least as intelligent as we are,
37
147000
4000
住著與我們至少並論的智慧生物,
02:43
and are interested in science. It's not impossible; I think there probably are lots.
38
151000
5000
且它們對科學也有興趣. 這非不可能, 我覺得還蠻有機會的.
02:48
Very likely, none is close enough to interact with us.
39
156000
3000
顯而易見的, 我們相隔過遠無法互動.
02:51
But they could be out there, very easily.
40
159000
5000
但是它們現在可能就在外面, 輕而易舉地.
02:56
And suppose they have, you know, very different sensory apparatus, and so on.
41
164000
6000
假設它們存在, 你也知道, 有著奇特的感覺器官等.
03:02
They have seven tentacles, and they have 14 little funny-looking compound eyes,
42
170000
5000
可能有七肢觸手, 14個可笑的複眼, 及
03:07
and a brain shaped like a pretzel.
43
175000
4000
一個長得像中國繩結的腦.
03:11
Would they really have different laws?
44
179000
3000
那它們會有不同的物理定律嗎?
03:14
There are lots of people who believe that, and I think it is utter baloney.
45
182000
4000
有許多人是這樣認為的, 但我認為那是一派胡言.
03:18
I think there are laws out there,
46
186000
2000
我認為世上存在著終極正確的物理定律組,
03:20
and we of course don't understand them at any given time very well
47
188000
6000
當然人類至今從未真正的掌握它們,
03:26
-- but we try. And we try to get closer and closer.
48
194000
3000
但我們不斷嘗試. 試著去揭開它層層面紗.
03:29
And someday, we may actually figure out the fundamental unified theory
49
197000
4000
或許有那麼一天, 我們真的解出有關粒子與其作用力
03:33
of the particles and forces, what I call the "fundamental law."
50
201000
5000
的 終極 統一 基本物理理論, 我稱之為"基本定律".
03:38
We may not even be terribly far from it.
51
206000
2000
我們離此目標也許已非遙不可及.
03:40
But even if we don't run across it in our lifetimes,
52
208000
3000
但就算在我們有生之年還未能達成,
03:43
we can still think there is one out there,
53
211000
3000
我們可以相信那是存在的,
03:46
and we're just trying to get closer and closer to it.
54
214000
2000
並朝此目標慢慢靠近.
03:48
I think that's the main point to be made.
55
216000
3000
我覺得這就是我想傳達的.
03:51
We express these things mathematically.
56
219000
3000
我們用數學去描述定律.
03:54
And when the mathematics is very simple --
57
222000
2000
當我指數學型式很簡潔時,
03:56
when in terms of some mathematical notation,
58
224000
4000
只要利用一些已知數學符號,
04:00
you can write the theory in a very brief space, without a lot of complication --
59
228000
6000
就可以將整個理論寫下來, 且用很小的空間, 也不會很複雜.
04:06
that's essentially what we mean by beauty or elegance.
60
234000
4000
這就是我所指的美或優雅.
04:10
Here's what I was saying about the laws. They're really there.
61
238000
6000
這裡是我剛才對於物理定律所談的. 它們真的存在.
04:16
Newton certainly believed that.
62
244000
2000
牛頓也深信不疑.
04:18
And he said, here, "It is the business of natural philosophy to find out those laws."
63
246000
10000
他說過, 在這, "找出那些定律是科學的主要工作."
04:28
The basic law, let's say -- here's an assumption.
64
256000
3000
讓我們對"基本定律"作個假設:
04:31
The assumption is that the basic law really takes the form
65
259000
3000
"假定基本定律真的將
04:34
of a unified theory of all the particles.
66
262000
3000
所有基本力與粒子的量子理論 統一了."
04:37
Now, some people call that a theory of everything.
67
265000
3000
現在, 有些人稱它為 無所不知理論(上帝不擲骰子).
04:40
That's wrong because the theory is quantum mechanical.
68
268000
5000
那是錯的, 因為這理論與量子力學有關.
04:45
And I won't go into a lot of stuff about quantum mechanics and what it's like, and so on.
69
273000
4000
我不會講一堆量子力學的東西, 或試著去解釋它之類的.
04:49
You've heard a lot of wrong things about it anyway. (Laughter)
70
277000
5000
反正你們早就聽過許多, 但錯誤, 的訊息了. (笑聲)
04:54
There are even movies about it with a lot of wrong stuff.
71
282000
3000
甚至連許多相關的電影也充斥著錯誤.
04:57
But the main thing here is that it predicts probabilities.
72
285000
5000
但量子力學最主要一點就是: 它與機率有關,(測不準, 上帝擲骰子)
05:02
Now, sometimes those probabilities are near certainties.
73
290000
3000
好 ,有時候測不準的範圍非常小, 接近準確.
05:05
And in a lot of familiar cases, they of course are.
74
293000
3000
對許多日常熟悉的現象, 一像也都是如此準確.
05:08
But other times they're not, and you have only probabilities for different outcomes.
75
296000
6000
但其他時候可不是, 你只能知道各種可能發生的結果的機率而已.
05:14
So what that means is that the history of the universe is not determined just by the fundamental law.
76
302000
6000
所以這表示, 宇宙至今天的歷史不全由單單基本定律所決定的,
05:20
It's the fundamental law and this incredibly long series of accidents,
77
308000
5000
是由基本定律, "和"無時無刻不斷的意外,
05:25
or chance outcomes, that are there in addition.
78
313000
5000
或說"機率下的結果", 兩者交互參雜所致.
05:30
And the fundamental theory doesn't include those chance outcomes; they are in addition.
79
318000
6000
基本定律並"不能算出"隨機下的結果,
05:36
So it's not a theory of everything. And in fact, a huge amount of the information
80
324000
4000
所以它不是"無所不知理論". 事實上, 在宇宙中
05:40
in the universe around us comes from those accidents,
81
328000
4000
有非常大量的資訊都是因種種意外產生
05:44
and not just from the fundamental laws.
82
332000
3000
而不僅僅基本定律在作用而已.
05:47
Now, it's often said that getting closer and closer
83
335000
8000
現在, 常有人提到, 為了要越來越接近基本定律,
05:55
to the fundamental laws by examining phenomena at low energies, and then higher energies,
84
343000
5000
需要研究低能量物理, 而後是高能量,
06:00
and then higher energies, or short distances, and then shorter distances,
85
348000
3000
接著再更高, 或是縮小量測尺度, 然後再小一點,
06:03
and then still shorter distances, and so on, is like peeling the skin of an onion.
86
351000
4000
接著再更小, 等等. 類似剝洋蔥皮.
06:07
And we keep doing that,
87
355000
2000
我們奉行不渝,
06:09
and build more powerful machines, accelerators for particles.
88
357000
4000
建造更強大的機器, 例粒子加速器.
06:13
We look deeper and deeper into the structure of particles,
89
361000
5000
我們越來越深入研究粒子的內在結構.
06:18
and in that way we get probably closer and closer to this fundamental law.
90
366000
7000
如此這般, 我們或許越來越接近所謂基本定律.
06:25
Now, what happens is that as we do that, as we peel these skins of the onion,
91
373000
6000
現在, 當我們實行這些事, 或剝掉層層洋蔥皮時,
06:31
and we get closer and closer to the underlying law,
92
379000
3000
也越來越靠近其蘊藏的定律,
06:34
we see that each skin has something in common with the previous one,
93
382000
5000
我們發現每一層皮與前一層有某些相似之處,
06:39
and with the next one. We write them out mathematically,
94
387000
4000
對下一層也是. 當用數學表示時,
06:43
and we see they use very similar mathematics.
95
391000
3000
發現它們使用的數學很類似.
06:46
They require very similar mathematics.
96
394000
3000
所需的數學工具很類似.
06:49
That is absolutely remarkable, and that is a central feature
97
397000
4000
這是絕對值得關注的, 這也是我今天
06:53
of what I'm trying to say today.
98
401000
5000
試著想表達的重點.
06:58
Newton called it -- that's Newton, by the way -- that one.
99
406000
3000
牛頓稱其為, (順便說一下, 他是牛頓, 那一位.
07:01
This one is Albert Einstein. Hi, Al! And anyway,
100
409000
7000
這位是愛因斯坦. 嗨, 小愛! 言歸正傳),
07:08
he said, "nature conformable to herself" -- personifying nature as a female.
101
416000
7000
他說:"大自然遵循她自己". (將大自然擬人化為女性)
07:15
And so what happens is that the new phenomena,
102
423000
5000
所以當我們探究新的現象時,
07:20
the new skins, the inner skins of the slightly smaller skins of the onion
103
428000
6000
也就是洋蔥新的一層皮 (稍小且位於內層的皮,
07:26
that we get to, resemble the slightly larger ones.
104
434000
4000
相較於稍大的舊皮).
07:30
And the kind of mathematics that we had for the previous skin
105
438000
6000
我們研究舊皮所得的數學知識,
07:36
is almost the same as what we need for the next skin.
106
444000
4000
與瞭解新皮所需的數學知識大致相等.
07:40
And that's why the equations look so simple.
107
448000
4000
由於所需的數學已被研究過了,
07:44
Because they use mathematics we already have.
108
452000
3000
這也是為什麼物理定理方程式看起來非常簡潔.
07:47
A trivial example is this: Newton found the law of gravity,
109
455000
5000
舉個平凡的例子: 牛頓發現了重力,
07:52
which goes like one over the square of the distance between the things gravitated.
110
460000
5000
其力的強弱隨兩物體間距的平方衰減.
07:57
Coulomb, in France, found the same law for electric charges.
111
465000
5000
庫倫, 法國人, 發現電荷間的作用力 也是依間距平方衰減.
08:02
Here's an example of this similarity.
112
470000
2000
這就是一個數學相似例子.
08:04
You look at gravity, you see a certain law.
113
472000
3000
當你看重力時, 你得到一個定律.
08:07
Then you look at electricity. Sure enough. The same rule.
114
475000
3000
當你看電力時. 當然, 也是同樣一個定律.
08:10
It's a very simple example.
115
478000
2000
這是一個簡單的例子.
08:12
There are lots of more sophisticated examples.
116
480000
4000
還有許多複雜的例子,
08:16
Symmetry is very important in this discussion.
117
484000
2000
其中, "對稱性"非常重要.
08:18
You know what it means. A circle, for example,
118
486000
3000
你也知道的. 比如說, 一個圓
08:21
is symmetric under rotations about the center of the circle.
119
489000
4000
就轉動而言, 是對稱於其圓心.
08:25
You rotate around the center of the circle, the circle remains unchanged.
120
493000
5000
當你將它繞著其圓心旋轉, 其外形不會改變.
08:30
You take a sphere, in three dimensions, you rotate around the center of the sphere,
121
498000
3000
或是有一個三維立體的球殼, 將之繞其球心旋轉,
08:33
and all those rotations leave the sphere alone.
122
501000
4000
不管怎麼轉, 它的外形還是不變.
08:37
They are symmetries of the sphere.
123
505000
1000
這就是球殼的對稱性.
08:38
So we say, in general, that there's a symmetry
124
506000
4000
所以我們可將之推廣: "若某物在一特定的操作下,
08:42
under certain operations if those operations leave the phenomenon,
125
510000
4000
其本身持有的現象或特徵沒有改變,
08:46
or its description, unchanged.
126
514000
3000
我們就說它, 在那操作之下是對稱的."
08:49
Maxwell's equations are of course symmetrical
127
517000
3000
麥克斯威(Maxwell)方程組, 當然,
08:52
under rotations of all of space.
128
520000
2000
在空間中的旋轉下是對稱的.
08:54
Doesn't matter if we turn the whole of space around by some angle,
129
522000
4000
也就是說, 我們可以任意改變觀察的角度,
08:58
it doesn't leave the -- doesn't change the phenomenon of electricity or magnetism.
130
526000
4000
但不會讓...不會改變電磁效應的實驗結果.
09:02
There's a new notation in the 19th century that expressed this,
131
530000
4000
19世紀時, 對於這種 旋轉對稱 有新的數學符號,
09:06
and if you use that notation, the equations get a lot simpler.
132
534000
4000
若你使用了這種符號, 麥克斯威方程組 可被大大的簡化.
09:10
Then Einstein, with his special theory of relativity,
133
538000
3000
接著, 愛因斯坦 透過特殊的座標轉換理論,
09:13
looked at a whole set of symmetries of Maxwell's equations,
134
541000
3000
更看到了 麥克斯威方程組 裡新的對稱性,
09:16
which are called special relativity.
135
544000
3000
也就是狹義相對論.
09:19
And those symmetries, then, make the equations even shorter, and even prettier, therefore.
136
547000
5000
這些對稱性, 使得此方程組更簡短, 更美, 因此....
09:24
Let's look. You don't have to know what these things mean, doesn't make any difference.
137
552000
3000
你來看. 你不須要瞭解這些東西的意義, 沒什麼差.
09:27
But you can just look at the form. (Laughter) You can look at the form.
138
555000
4000
你只須看它的外形. (笑聲) 你可以看它的外形.
09:31
You see above, at the top, a long list
139
559000
2000
看上面, 在頂端, 有一長列清單
09:33
of equations with three components for the three directions of space: x, y and z.
140
561000
6000
表示麥克斯威方程式, 在三維空間中的不同方向, 可寫成不同的式子.
09:39
Then, using vector analysis, you use rotational symmetry, and you get this next set.
141
567000
6000
接著, 利用向量分析, 旋轉的對稱性 來簡化, 你可得到到第二組.
09:45
Then you use the symmetry of special relativity and you get an even simpler set
142
573000
4000
若再運用 狹義相對論 裡的對稱性, 甚至能更加精簡至
09:49
down here, showing that symmetry exhibits better and better.
143
577000
4000
在下面這, 其對稱性已展露無遺.
09:53
The more and more symmetry you have, the better you exhibit the simplicity and elegance of the theory.
144
581000
6000
若方程式有越多種類的對稱性, 你越能展現出那個理論的精簡與優美.
09:59
The last two, the first equation says that electric charges and currents
145
587000
4000
最後兩行, 第一個方程式表示電荷與電流會
10:03
give rise to all the electric and magnetic fields.
146
591000
4000
產生電場及磁場.
10:07
The next -- second -- equation says that there is no magnetism other than that.
147
595000
5000
下一個...第二個方程式表示, 沒有其它辦法可以生成磁場.
10:12
The only magnetism comes from electric charges and currents.
148
600000
3000
磁場產生唯一的來源, 就只能是電流.
10:15
Someday we may find some slight hole in that argument.
149
603000
5000
或許有天我們能找出此論點的小漏洞,
10:20
But for the moment, that's the case.
150
608000
4000
但目前為止, 就是這樣.
10:24
Now, here is a very exciting development that many people have not heard of.
151
612000
4000
好, 物理有一個非常另人興奮的突破, 許多人可能沒聽過.
10:28
They should have heard of it, but it's a little tricky to explain in technical detail,
152
616000
5000
但都應該要知道. 只不過若要解釋其中技術上的細節, 有一點微妙,
10:33
so I won't do it. I'll just mention it. (Laughter)
153
621000
3000
所以我不幹. 我只會帶過. (笑聲)
10:36
But Chen Ning Yang, called by us "Frank" Yang -- (Laughter)
154
624000
10000
楊振寧(英名: 富蘭克林), 我們稱他"阿富", (笑聲)
10:46
-- and Bob Mills put forward, 50 years ago,
155
634000
4000
與 米爾斯(Bob Mills) 50年前提出
10:50
this generalization of Maxwell's equations, with a new symmetry.
156
638000
4000
更廣義的 麥克斯威方程式 與其蘊涵的新的對稱性質.
10:54
A whole new symmetry.
157
642000
2000
前所未見的對稱性.
10:56
Mathematics very similar, but there was a whole new symmetry.
158
644000
3000
數學上很類似, 不過是全新的對稱性.
10:59
They hoped that this would contribute somehow to particle physics
159
647000
5000
他們希望這能對 粒子物理 多少有些貢獻,
11:04
-- didn't. It didn't, by itself, contribute to particle physics.
160
652000
4000
可惜. 光靠那還不足以幫助到 粒子物理理論.
11:08
But then some of us generalized it further. And then it did!
161
656000
5000
後來有些粒子物理學家將之更進一步推廣, 終於成功了!
11:13
And it gave a very beautiful description of the strong force and of the weak force.
162
661000
5000
對於強, 弱作用力 給出了非常漂亮的解釋.
11:18
So here we say, again, what we said before:
163
666000
3000
所以我們可以說, 老話一句:
11:21
that each skin of the onion shows a similarity to the adjoining skins.
164
669000
4000
相鄰的洋蔥皮保有許多相似處.
11:25
So the mathematics for the adjoining skins is very similar to what we need for the new one.
165
673000
5000
所以探究新的皮所需俱備的數學工具, 與舊皮非常相似.
11:30
And therefore it looks beautiful
166
678000
2000
理論看起來很美,
11:32
because we already know how to write it in a lovely, concise way.
167
680000
4000
是因為我們早知道如何將其數學化簡, 美化.
11:36
So here are the themes. We believe there is a unified theory underlying all the regularities.
168
684000
9000
總而言之, 我們相信, 在所有這些規律性之下, 存在一個大統一的理論.
11:45
Steps toward unification exhibit the simplicity.
169
693000
4000
理論相互不斷地統合導致簡化.
11:49
Symmetry exhibits the simplicity.
170
697000
2000
對稱性也使之趨向簡化.
11:51
And then there is self-similarity across the scales -- in other words,
171
699000
4000
且物理在不同的尺度下, 都有許多相似處. 換句話說,
11:55
from one skin of the onion to another one.
172
703000
2000
對不同層的洋蔥皮,
11:57
Proximate self-similarity. And that accounts for this phenomenon.
173
705000
5000
彼此類似. 這解釋了一個現象,
12:02
That will account for why beauty is a successful criterion for selecting the right theory.
174
710000
7000
解釋了為什麼"美"對於正確的理論這麼重要.
12:09
Here's what Newton himself said:
175
717000
1000
這裡是牛頓他説曾說的:
12:10
"Nature is very consonant and conformable to her self."
176
718000
4000
"大自然始終如一的遵循她自己."
12:14
One thing he was thinking of is something that most of us take for granted today,
177
722000
4000
他當初提出了一個東西, 如今大部分人覺得理所當然,
12:18
but in his day it wasn't taken for granted.
178
726000
3000
但在當時可不一樣.
12:21
There's the story, which is not absolutely certain to be right, but a lot of people told it.
179
729000
6000
這個故事就是, (可能不全然事實, 但流傳很廣,
12:27
Four sources told it. That when they had the plague in Cambridge,
180
735000
4000
故事來源有四處.) 當時劍橋瘟疫流行,
12:31
and he went down to his mother's farm -- because the university was closed --
181
739000
4000
牛頓就回到他母親的農場. (因為大學暫時停課)
12:35
he saw an apple fall from a tree, or on his head or something.
182
743000
4000
他看到一顆蘋果從樹上落下, 不知道有沒有砸到他的頭或什麼.
12:39
And he realized suddenly that the force that drew the apple down to the earth
183
747000
4000
他突然頓悟, 將蘋果從樹上拉下來的力與
12:43
could be the same as the force regulating the motions of the planets and the moon.
184
751000
6000
控制行星及月亮移動的力是相同的.
12:49
That was a big unification for those days, although today we take it for granted.
185
757000
5000
這在當時可是個大膽的統合, 雖然如今看似理所當然.
12:54
It's the same theory of gravity.
186
762000
4000
那些力都可以用重力來解釋.
12:58
So he said that this principle of nature, consonance:
187
766000
5000
所以他覺得大自然的原理, 始終如一, 他說:
13:03
"This principle of nature being very remote from the conceptions of philosophers,
188
771000
5000
"大自然的原理與哲學家所想的差很多,
13:08
I forbore to describe it in that book,
189
776000
3000
我克制自己不將之公布在那本書裡,
13:11
lest I should be accounted an extravagant freak ... "
190
779000
4000
以免我被形容成狂妄的怪胎..."
13:15
That's what we all have to watch out for, (Laughter) especially at this meeting.
191
783000
5000
( 這也是我們所要提防的.(笑聲) 特別是在這個聚會. )
13:20
" ... and so prejudice my readers against all those things which were the main design of the book."
192
788000
5000
"...或令讀者對書中主要想傳達的理念有偏見."
13:25
Now, who today would claim that as a mere conceit of the human mind?
193
793000
4000
好, 如今有誰會認為這些僅是人類心靈下的產物?
13:29
That the force that causes the apple to fall to the ground
194
797000
4000
例如"讓蘋果落下的力與
13:33
is the same force that causes the planets and the moon to move around,
195
801000
3000
控制行星及月亮移動的力是相同的."
13:36
and so on? Everybody knows that. It's a property of gravitation.
196
804000
5000
之類的. 這是常識了. 這就是重力的性質.
13:41
It's not something in the human mind. The human mind can, of course, appreciate it
197
809000
4000
這與人類心靈無關. 人類心靈可以, 當然, 理解它
13:45
and enjoy it, use it, but it's not -- it doesn't stem from the human mind.
198
813000
5000
欣賞它, 應用它. 但它不是... 它不源自於人類的心靈.
13:50
It stems from the character of gravity.
199
818000
2000
它就是重力的性質.
13:52
And that's true of all the things we're talking about.
200
820000
2000
我們剛在談論的其它物理也一樣適用.
13:54
They are properties of the fundamental law.
201
822000
2000
它們都是"基本定律"的性質.
13:56
The fundamental law is such that the different skins of the onion resemble one another,
202
824000
6000
基本定律使得不同層的洋蔥皮彼此相似,
14:02
and therefore the math for one skin allows you to express beautifully and simply
203
830000
4000
因而前一層皮所運用到的數學工具可以用在下一層皮,
14:06
the phenomenon of the next skin.
204
834000
3000
以致描述的美而簡潔.
14:09
I say here that Newton did a lot of things that year:
205
837000
3000
1665年夏天, 所謂牛頓的不可思義年:
14:12
gravity, the laws of motion, the calculus, white light composed of all the colors of the rainbow.
206
840000
6000
萬有引力定律, 三大運動定律, 微積分, 白光是由彩虹色的光組成的.
14:18
And he could have written quite an essay on "What I Did Over My Summer Vacation."
207
846000
6000
他應該有許多事情可以寫進 "我的暑假活動" .
14:24
(Laughter)
208
852000
4000
(笑聲)
14:28
So we don't have to assume these principles as separate metaphysical postulates.
209
856000
10000
所以我們不必妄言 大自然, 美,與數學 皆各行其是, 或僅是純哲學下的公理.
14:38
They follow from the fundamental theory.
210
866000
6000
它們可能都源自於同一個基本理論.
14:44
They are what we call emergent properties.
211
872000
2000
這就是我們稱的"衍生"性質.
14:46
You don't need -- you don't need something more to get something more.
212
874000
7000
你不需要...你不需要再多, 以得到更多.
14:53
That's what emergence means.
213
881000
2000
這就是"衍生"的含意.
14:55
Life can emerge from physics and chemistry, plus a lot of accidents.
214
883000
9000
生命是由物理及化學伴隨著許多隨機的意外衍生出來.
15:04
The human mind can arise from neurobiology and a lot of accidents,
215
892000
5000
人類的心靈是由神經生物學及許多意外所產生的.
15:09
the way the chemical bond arises from physics and certain accidents.
216
897000
7000
化學鍵是由物理及某些意外所產生的.
15:16
It doesn't diminish the importance of these subjects
217
904000
4000
知道這些事物是由許多更基本的事物及
15:20
to know that they follow from more fundamental things, plus accidents.
218
908000
6000
意外所衍生的, 並不會削弱它們的重要性.
15:26
That's a general rule, and it's critically important to realize that.
219
914000
5000
這只是個通則, 但領悟這點是極其重要的.
15:31
You don't need something more in order to get something more.
220
919000
4000
你不需要再多, 以得到更多.
15:35
People keep asking that when they read my book, "The Quark and the Jaguar,"
221
923000
4000
當人們在讀我的書"夸克與美洲豹"時,總會問:
15:39
and they say, "Isn't there something more beyond what you have there?"
222
927000
4000
"有沒有某些東西是遠超出存在的事物?"
15:43
Presumably, they mean something supernatural.
223
931000
4000
想必, 他們指的是某種超自然現象.
15:47
Anyway, there isn't. (Laughter)
224
935000
2000
嗯, 無論如何, 沒有. (笑聲)
15:49
You don't need something more to explain something more.
225
937000
5000
你不需再多, 以解釋更多.
15:54
Thank you very much. (Applause)
226
942000
3000
非常謝謝大家. (鼓掌)
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Murray Gell-Mann - PhysicistMurray Gell-Mann brings visibility to a crucial aspect of our existence that we can't actually see: elemental particles. He won the Nobel Prize in Physics for introducing quarks, one of two fundamental ingredients for all matter in the universe.
Why you should listen
He's been called "the man with five brains" -- and Murray Gell-Mann has the resume to prove it. In addition to being a Nobel laureate, he is an accomplished physicist who's earned numerous awards, medals and honorary degrees for his work with subatomic particles, including the groundbreaking theory that the nucleus of an atom comprises 100 or so fundamental building blocks called quarks.
Gell-Mann's influence extends well beyond his field: He's a member of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and the Council on Foreign Relations. He also serves on the board of the Wildlife Conservation Society and is a director of Encyclopedia Britannica. Gell-Mann, a professor emeritus of Caltech, now heads the evolution of human languages program at the Santa Fe Institute, which he cofounded in 1984.
A prolific writer -- he's penned scores of academic papers and several books, including The Quark and the Jaguar -- Gell-Mann is also the subject of the popular science biography Strange Beauty: Murray Gell-Mann and the Revolution in 20th-Century Physics.
Murray Gell-Mann | Speaker | TED.com