TEDGlobal 2009
Elaine Morgan: I believe we evolved from aquatic apes
Elaine Morgan tvrdi da smo evoluirali od vodenih majmuna
Filmed:
Readability: 3.6
1,427,832 views
Elaine Morgan je gorljivi pobornik hipoteze o vodenom majmunu: ideja da su ljudi evoluirali od predaka primata koji su nastanjivali vodena staništa. Poslušaj njenu odlučnu odbranu ove ideje -- i njenu teoriju o tome zašto današnja nauka ovu ideju ne shvaća ozbiljno.
Elaine Morgan - Aquatic ape theorist
Elaine Morgan, armed with an arsenal of television writing credits and feminist credentials, spent her life on a mission to prove humans evolved in water. Full bio
Elaine Morgan, armed with an arsenal of television writing credits and feminist credentials, spent her life on a mission to prove humans evolved in water. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Well, this is 2009.
0
0
5000
Godina je 2009.
00:17
And it's the Bicentenary of Charles Darwin.
1
5000
5000
I dvjestota je godišnjica rođenja Charlesa Darwina.
00:22
And all over the world, eminent evolutionists
2
10000
3000
I po cijelom svijetu, poznati evolucionisti
00:25
are anxious to celebrate this.
3
13000
2000
je uzbuđeno obilježavaju.
00:27
And what they're planning to do is to enlighten us
4
15000
4000
I namjeravaju osvijetliti
00:31
on almost every aspect
5
19000
2000
gotovo svaki aspekt
00:33
of Darwin and his life,
6
21000
2000
Darwina i njegovog života
00:35
and how he changed our thinking.
7
23000
2000
i kako je promijenio način na koji razmišljamo.
00:37
I say almost every aspect,
8
25000
3000
Kažem gotovo svaki aspekt,
00:40
because there is one aspect of this story
9
28000
3000
jer postoji jedan aspekt ove priče
00:43
which they have thrown no light on.
10
31000
3000
koji nisu osvijetlili.
00:46
And they seem anxious to skirt around it and step over it
11
34000
3000
I čini se da ga stalno preskaču i obilaze
00:49
and to talk about something else.
12
37000
2000
kako bi pričali o nečem drugom.
00:51
So I'm going to talk about it.
13
39000
2000
Zato ću ja pričati o tome.
00:53
It's the question of, why are we so different from the chimpanzees?
14
41000
6000
Pitanje je, zašto smo toliko drukčiji od čimpanzi?
00:59
We get the geneticists keeping on telling us
15
47000
2000
Genetičari nam stalno govore
01:01
how extremely closely we are related -- hardly any genes of difference,
16
49000
4000
kako smo izuzetno bliski, skoro bez razlike u genima,
01:05
very, very closely related.
17
53000
3000
vrlo vrlo blisko srodni.
01:08
And yet, when you look at the phenotypes,
18
56000
3000
Opet, kada se pogledaju fenotipovi
01:11
there's a chimp, there's a man;
19
59000
2000
imamo čimpanzu, imamo čovjeka,
01:13
they're astoundingly different,
20
61000
2000
zapanjujuče su različiti,
01:15
no resemblance at all.
21
63000
2000
bez ikakvih sličnosti.
01:17
I'm not talking about airy-fairy stuff
22
65000
2000
Ne govorim o nevidljivim stvarima
01:19
about culture or psychology, or behavior.
23
67000
4000
o kulturi, psihologiji ili ponašanju.
01:23
I'm talking about ground-base, nitty-gritty,
24
71000
3000
Govorim o temeljnim, suštinskim,
01:26
measurable physical differences.
25
74000
2000
mjerljivim fizičkim razlikama.
01:28
They, that one,
26
76000
2000
Onaj je dlakav
01:30
is hairy and walking on four legs.
27
78000
2000
i hoda na četiri noge.
01:32
That one is a naked biped. Why?
28
80000
4000
Ovaj je goli dvonožac. Zašto?
01:36
I mean --
29
84000
2000
Mislim --
01:38
(Laughter)
30
86000
1000
(Smijeh)
01:39
if I'm a good Darwinist, I've got to believe
31
87000
2000
Ako sam dobar darvinist, moram vjerovati
01:41
there's a reason for that.
32
89000
2000
da za to postoji razlog.
01:43
If we changed so much, something must have happened.
33
91000
3000
Ako smo se toliko promijenili, nešto se moralo dogoditi.
01:46
What happened?
34
94000
2000
Šta se dogodilo?
01:48
Now 50 years ago, that was a laughably simple question.
35
96000
3000
Prije 50 godina, to je bilo smiješno jednostavno pitanje.
01:51
Everybody knew the answer.
36
99000
2000
Svi su znali odgovor.
01:53
They knew what happened.
37
101000
2000
Znali su što se dogodilo.
01:55
The ancestor of the apes stayed in the trees;
38
103000
2000
Preci majmuna ostali su u drveću.
01:57
our ancestors went out onto the plain.
39
105000
3000
Naši preci prešli su na ravnicu.
02:00
That explained everything.
40
108000
3000
To je sve objašnjavalo.
02:03
We had to get up on our legs to peer over the tall grass,
41
111000
3000
Morali smo se dići na noge da bi vidjeli preko visoke trave,
02:06
or to chase after animals,
42
114000
2000
ili da bi hvatali životinje,
02:08
or to free our hands for weapons.
43
116000
2000
ili da bi oslobodili ruke za oružje.
02:10
And we got so overheated in the chase
44
118000
4000
I toliko bi se pregrijavali loveći
02:14
that we had to take off that fur coat and throw it away.
45
122000
4000
da smo morali odbaciti svoje krzno.
02:18
Everybody knew that, for generations.
46
126000
3000
To su svi znali, generacijama.
02:21
But then, in the '90s, something began to unravel.
47
129000
4000
Ali onda, devedesetih, nešto se počelo otkrivati.
02:25
The paleontologists themselves looked a bit more closely
48
133000
4000
Paleontolozi su malo pomnije pregledali
02:29
at the accompanying microfauna
49
137000
4000
popratnu mikrofaunu
02:33
that lived in the same time and place as the hominids.
50
141000
4000
koja je živjela u isto vrijeme i na istom mjestu kao i hominidi.
02:37
And they weren't savanna species.
51
145000
3000
I to nisu bila bića savane.
02:40
And they looked at the herbivores. And they weren't savanna herbivores.
52
148000
4000
I pregledali su biljojede. I to nisu bili biljojedi savane.
02:44
And then they were so clever, they found a way to analyze
53
152000
3000
I bili su toliko pametni, da su našli način analiziranja
02:47
fossilized pollen.
54
155000
2000
fosilizovanog polena.
02:49
Shock, horror.
55
157000
2000
Šok, nevjerica.
02:51
The fossilized pollen was not of savanna vegetation.
56
159000
5000
Fosilizovani polen nije dio vegetacije savane.
02:56
Some of it even came from lianas,
57
164000
2000
Dio je čak bio od lijana,
02:58
those things that dangle in the middle of the jungle.
58
166000
3000
onih koje vise svuda po džungli.
03:01
So we're left with a situation where
59
169000
2000
I tako smo došli u situaciju
03:03
we know that our earliest ancestors
60
171000
4000
da znamo kako su se naši najraniji preci
03:07
were moving around on four legs in the trees,
61
175000
4000
kretali na četiri noge po drveću,
03:11
before the savanna ecosystem even came into existence.
62
179000
5000
prije nego što je ekosisitem savane uopšte nastao.
03:16
This is not something I've made up.
63
184000
3000
Ovo nisam ja izmislila
03:19
It's not a minority theory.
64
187000
2000
Ovo nije manjinska teorija.
03:21
Everybody agrees with it.
65
189000
2000
Sa time se svi slažu.
03:23
Professor Tobias came over from South Africa
66
191000
4000
Profesor Tobias je došao iz Južne Afrike
03:27
and spoke to University College London.
67
195000
3000
i govorio na University College-u u Londonu.
03:30
He said, "Everything I've been telling you for the last 20 years,
68
198000
3000
Rekao je, sve što sam vam govorio zadnjih 20 godina,
03:33
forget about it. It was wrong.
69
201000
3000
zanemarite. Pogriješio sam.
03:36
We've got to go back to square one and start again."
70
204000
4000
Moramo se vratiti na početak i početi od početka.
03:40
It made him very unpopular. They didn't want to go back to square one.
71
208000
6000
To ga je učinilo nepopularnim. Nisu se htjeli vratiti na početak.
03:46
I mean, it's a terrible thing to happen.
72
214000
2000
Mislim, to što se dogodilo je grozno.
03:48
You've got this beautiful paradigm.
73
216000
3000
Imate jednu dobru paradigmu.
03:51
You've believed it through generations.
74
219000
2000
Vjerujete u nju generacijama.
03:53
Nobody has questioned it.
75
221000
2000
Nitko ju ne dovodi u pitanje.
03:55
You've been constructing fanciful things on top of it,
76
223000
4000
Nadograđivao si je zgodnim stvarima,
03:59
relying on it to be as solid as a rock.
77
227000
2000
oslanjajući se na nju kao na stijenu.
04:01
And now it's whipped away from under you.
78
229000
3000
I sad ju izvuku pod tobom.
04:04
What do you do? What does a scientist do in that case?
79
232000
3000
I šta napraviš? Šta naučnik u tom slučaju napravi?
04:07
Well, we know the answer because
80
235000
2000
Pa znamo odgovor, jer je
04:09
Thomas S. Kuhn
81
237000
3000
Thomas S. Kuhn
04:12
wrote a seminal treatise
82
240000
4000
napisao poticajnu tezu
04:16
about this back in 1962.
83
244000
2000
o tome 1962.
04:18
He said what scientists do
84
246000
2000
Rekao je da
04:20
when a paradigm fails
85
248000
4000
kada paradigma propadne,
04:24
is, guess what -- they carry on as if nothing had happened.
86
252000
3000
naučnici nastavljaju kao da se ništa nije dogodilo.
04:27
(Laughter)
87
255000
3000
(Smijeh)
04:30
If they haven't got a paradigm they can't ask the question.
88
258000
3000
Ako nemaju paradigmu ne mogu postavljati pitanja.
04:33
So they say, "Yes it's wrong,
89
261000
2000
Pa kažu, "Da, paradigma je kriva,
04:35
but supposing it was right ..."
90
263000
2000
ali da nije ..."
04:37
(Laughter)
91
265000
2000
(Smijeh)
04:39
And the only other option open to them
92
267000
4000
I jedini izbor koji imaju
04:43
is to stop asking the questions.
93
271000
2000
jest da prestanu pitati pitanja.
04:45
So that is what they have done now.
94
273000
4000
I to su i napravili i ovaj put.
04:49
That's why you don't hear them talking about it. It's yesterday's question.
95
277000
3000
Zato ne pričaju o tome. To je prošlo pitanje.
04:52
Some of them have even elevated it into a principle.
96
280000
3000
Neki su čak iz toga napravili i princip.
04:55
It's what we ought to be doing.
97
283000
2000
Time se moramo baviti.
04:57
Aaron Filler from Harvard said,
98
285000
3000
Aaron Filler sa Harvarda je rekao,
05:00
"Isn't it time we stopped talking about selective pressures?
99
288000
4000
"Nije li vrijeme da prestanemo pričati o selekcijskom pritisku?
05:04
I mean, why don't we talk about, well, there's chromosomes, and there's genes.
100
292000
3000
Zašto ne bismo pričali o hromozomima i genima.
05:07
And we just record what we see."
101
295000
3000
Pa da bilježimo ono što vidimo."
05:10
Charles Darwin must be spinning in his grave!
102
298000
3000
Charles Darwin se okreće u grobu!
05:13
He knew all about that kind of science.
103
301000
3000
On je znao sve o takvoj vrsti nauke.
05:16
And he called it hypothesis-free science.
104
304000
3000
On je zvao, nauka bez hipoteza.
05:19
And he despised it from the bottom of his heart.
105
307000
3000
I prezirao je iz dna duše.
05:22
And if you're going to say,
106
310000
3000
I ako kažete,
05:25
"I'm going to stop talking about selective pressures,"
107
313000
2000
"Neću više pričati o selekcijskim pritiscima,"
05:27
you can take "The Origin of Species" and throw it out of the window,
108
315000
4000
možete uzeti "Porijeklo vrsta" i baciti ga kroz prozor.
05:31
for it's about nothing else but selective pressures.
109
319000
2000
Jer u njima piše jedino o selektivnim pritiscima.
05:33
And the irony of it is,
110
321000
2000
A ironija jest u tome,
05:35
that this is one occasion of a paradigm collapse
111
323000
3000
da je ovo rijedak slučaj pada paradigme
05:38
where we didn't have to wait for a new paradigm to come up.
112
326000
4000
kada ne trebamo čekati pojavu nove paradigme.
05:42
There was one waiting in the wings.
113
330000
2000
Postoji jedna i čeka na svoj red.
05:44
It had been waiting there since 1960
114
332000
2000
Čeka u pozadini od 1960.
05:46
when Alister Hardy, a marine biologist,
115
334000
3000
kad je Alister Hardy, morski biolog,
05:49
said, "I think what happened,
116
337000
2000
rekao, "Mislim da su možda,
05:51
perhaps our ancestors
117
339000
2000
naši preci
05:53
had a more aquatic existence
118
341000
2000
dio vremena
05:55
for some of the time."
119
343000
3000
provodili u vodenom okolišu."
05:58
He kept it to himself for 30 years.
120
346000
2000
Držao je to za sebe 30 godina.
06:00
But then the press got hold of it and all hell broke loose.
121
348000
3000
Ali onda su to saznale novine i nastao je haos.
06:03
All his colleagues said, "This is outrageous.
122
351000
3000
Sve njegove kolege rekli su, "Ovo je nečuveno.
06:06
You've exposed us to public ridicule!
123
354000
4000
Izložio si nas javnom ismijavanju!
06:10
You must never do that again."
124
358000
2000
Nikada više to ne smiješ uraditi."
06:12
And at that time, it became set in stone:
125
360000
3000
I od tada je uklesano u kamenu
06:15
the aquatic theory should be dumped
126
363000
3000
vodena teorija se mora odbaciti
06:18
with the UFOs and the yetis,
127
366000
2000
zajedno sa NLO-ima i jetijima,
06:20
as part of the lunatic fringe of science.
128
368000
4000
kao dio ludih teorija u nauci.
06:24
Well I don't think that.
129
372000
2000
Ja nisam tako mislila.
06:26
I think that Hardy had a lot going for him.
130
374000
2000
Mislim da je puno išlo u prilog Hardyevoj tezi.
06:28
I'd like to talk about just a handful
131
376000
3000
Željela bih vam pričati o nekoliko,
06:31
of what have been called the
132
379000
2000
što bi se reklo,
06:33
hallmarks of mankind,
133
381000
2000
znakova čovječanstva.
06:35
the things that made us different from everybody else,
134
383000
2000
Stvari koje nas razlikuju od svih drugih,
06:37
and all our relatives.
135
385000
2000
i od svih naših predaka.
06:39
Let's look at our naked skin.
136
387000
4000
Pogledajmo našu golu kožu.
06:43
It's obvious that most of the things we think about
137
391000
4000
Očito je da većina bića
06:47
that have lost their body hair, mammals without body hair,
138
395000
3000
koja su izgubila dlake na tijelu, sisavci bez tjelesnih dlaka,
06:50
are aquatic ones, like the dugong, the walrus,
139
398000
3000
su vodena bića, kao gugong, morž,
06:53
the dolphin, the hippopotamus, the manatee.
140
401000
4000
delfin, nilski konj, morska krava.
06:57
And a couple of wallowers-in-mud like the babirusa.
141
405000
6000
I nekoliko onih koji se valjaju u blatu, kao babyrousa.
07:03
And you're tempted to think, well perhaps,
142
411000
2000
I vuče vas da pomislite,
07:05
could that be why we are naked?
143
413000
3000
možda su zato goli?
07:08
I suggested it and people said, "No no no.
144
416000
2000
To bih predložila, i ljudi bi rekli, "Ne ne ne.
07:10
I mean, look at the elephant.
145
418000
2000
Pogledaj slona.
07:12
You've forgotten all about the elephant haven't you?"
146
420000
2000
Zaboravila si na slona, zar ne?"
07:14
So back in 1982 I said,
147
422000
3000
Još 1982. sam rekla,
07:17
"Well perhaps the elephant had an aquatic ancestor."
148
425000
3000
"Pa možda slon ima vodenog pretka."
07:20
Peals of merry laughter!
149
428000
3000
Svi su se smijali!
07:23
"That crazy woman. She's off again. She'll say anything won't she?"
150
431000
3000
"Ta luda žena. Opet ona po svome."
07:26
But by now, everybody agrees that the elephant had an aquatic ancestor.
151
434000
6000
Ali sada se svi slažu da je slon imao vodenog pretka.
07:32
This has come 'round to be that all those naked pachyderms
152
440000
3000
I sve se vratilo na to da svi goli debelokošci
07:35
have aquatic ancestors.
153
443000
2000
imaju vodenog pretka.
07:37
The last exception was supposed to be the rhinoceros.
154
445000
2000
Zadnji izuzetak je bio nosorog.
07:39
Last year in Florida they found extinct ancestor of a rhinoceros
155
447000
4000
Lani su na Floridi našli izumrlog pretka nosoroga
07:43
and said, "Seems to have spent most of its time in the water."
156
451000
4000
i rekli, "Čini se da je većinu vremena provodio u vodi."
07:47
So this is a close connection between nakedness and water.
157
455000
5000
Znači postoji bliska veza između golosti i vode.
07:52
As an absolute connection, it only works one way.
158
460000
3000
Ali kao apsolutna veza; radi samo u jednom smjeru.
07:55
You can't say all aquatic animals are naked,
159
463000
4000
Nisu sve vodene životinje gole.
07:59
because look at the sea otter.
160
467000
2000
Jer imamo morsku vidru.
08:01
But you can say
161
469000
2000
Ali može se reći
08:03
that every animal that has become naked
162
471000
4000
da je svaka životinja koja je postala gola
08:07
has been conditioned by water, in its own lifetime,
163
475000
3000
bila uvjetovana vodom, u svojem životnom vijeku
08:10
or the lifetime of its ancestors. I think this is significant.
164
478000
4000
ili životnom vjeku svojih predaka. Mislim da je ovo značajno.
08:14
The only exception is the naked Somalian mole-rat,
165
482000
4000
Jedina iznimka je gola Somalijska krtica.
08:18
which never puts its nose above the surface of the ground.
166
486000
4000
Koja nikada ne izlazi na površinu.
08:22
And take bipedality.
167
490000
2000
Pogledajmo dvonožnost.
08:24
Here you can't find anybody to compare it with,
168
492000
3000
To ne možemo uporediti sa bilo kojom životinjom.
08:27
because we're the only animal that walks upright on two legs.
169
495000
5000
Jer smo jedina životinja koja hoda uspravno na dvije noge.
08:32
But you can say this: all the apes and all the monkeys
170
500000
3000
Ali možemo reći i ovo, svi majmuni
08:35
are capable of walking on two legs,
171
503000
2000
imaju sposobnost hodati na dvije noge,
08:37
if they want to, for a short time.
172
505000
2000
ako žele, na kratko vrijeme.
08:39
There is only one circumstance in which they
173
507000
3000
Postoji samo jedan slučaj u kojem oni,
08:42
always, all of them, walk on two legs,
174
510000
3000
uvijek, svi, hodaju na dvije noge,
08:45
and that is when they are wading through water.
175
513000
3000
a to je kad gaze kroz vodu.
08:48
Do you think that's significant?
176
516000
2000
Mislite li da je to značajno?
08:50
David Attenborough thinks it's significant,
177
518000
2000
David Attenborough misli da je značajno.
08:52
as the possible beginning of our bipedalism.
178
520000
4000
Kao mogući začetak dvonožnosti.
08:56
Look at the fat layer.
179
524000
2000
Pogledajmo sloj sala.
08:58
We have got, under our skin, a layer of fat, all over:
180
526000
4000
Pod kožom imamo sloj sala, posvuda.
09:02
nothing in the least like that in any other primate.
181
530000
4000
Ništa kao bilo koji drugi primat.
09:06
Why should it be there?
182
534000
2000
Zašto ga imamo?
09:08
Well they do know, that if you look at other aquatic mammals,
183
536000
3000
Znaju, da ako pogledamo druge vodene sisavce,
09:11
the fat that in most land mammals
184
539000
2000
salo koje je kod kopnenih sisavaca
09:13
is deposited inside the body wall,
185
541000
3000
naslagano unutar tijela,
09:16
around the kidneys and the intestines and so on,
186
544000
4000
oko bubrega, crijeva i slično,
09:20
has started to migrate to the outside,
187
548000
2000
se počelo kretati prema van,
09:22
and spread out in a layer inside the skin.
188
550000
4000
te se nataložilo u sloju pod kožom.
09:26
In the whale it's complete:
189
554000
2000
Kod kita je prešlo do kraja.
09:28
no fat inside at all, all in blubber outside.
190
556000
3000
Nema sala unutra, svo je vani pod kožom.
09:31
We cannot avoid the suspicion
191
559000
3000
Ne možemo zaobići pretpostavku
09:34
that in our case it's started to happen.
192
562000
3000
da se to kod nas počelo događati.
09:37
We have got skin lined with this layer.
193
565000
4000
Imamo sloj koji leži pod kožom.
09:41
It's the only possible explanation of why humans,
194
569000
3000
To je jedino moguće objašnjenje zašto ljudi,
09:44
if they're very unlucky,
195
572000
3000
ako nemaju sreće,
09:47
can become grossly obese,
196
575000
3000
mogu postati pretjerano gojazni,
09:50
in a way that would be totally impossible for any other primate, physically impossible.
197
578000
4000
na način koji je fizički nemoguć kod bilo kojeg drugog primata.
09:54
Something very odd, matter-of-factly, never explained.
198
582000
4000
To je nešto vrlo čudno, i nikad objašnjeno.
09:58
The question of why we can speak.
199
586000
2000
Pitanje zašto mi možemo govoriti.
10:00
We can speak.
200
588000
2000
Možemo govoriti.
10:02
And the gorilla can't speak. Why?
201
590000
3000
A gorila ne može. Zašto?
10:05
Nothing to do with his teeth or his tongue or his lungs or anything like that --
202
593000
4000
To nema veze sa njezinim zubima, jezikom, plućima ili tako nečim.
10:09
purely has to do with its conscious control of its breath.
203
597000
5000
To ima veze sa svjesnim kontroliranjem disanja.
10:14
You can't even train a gorilla to say "Ah" on request.
204
602000
5000
Gorilu se ne može naučiti niti da kaže "Ah" na komandu.
10:19
The only creatures that have got conscious control of their breath
205
607000
5000
Jedina bića koja imaju svjesnu kontrolu disanja
10:24
are the diving animals and the diving birds.
206
612000
3000
su životinje i ptice koje rone.
10:27
It was an absolute precondition for our being able to speak.
207
615000
5000
To je apsolutni preduslov za mogućnost govora.
10:32
And then again, there is the fact that we are streamlined.
208
620000
4000
Postoji i činjenica da smo aerodinamični.
10:36
Trying to imagine a diver
209
624000
2000
Pokušajte zamisliti skakača u vodi
10:38
diving into water -- hardly makes a splash.
210
626000
2000
koji kod ulaska u vodu jedva zapljusne.
10:40
Try to imagine a gorilla
211
628000
3000
Pokušajte zamisliti gorilu
10:43
performing the same maneuver,
212
631000
3000
da to isto napravi.
10:46
and you can see that, compared with gorilla,
213
634000
2000
Možete vidjeti da je naša građa, u porđenju sa gorilom,
10:48
we are halfway to being shaped like a fish.
214
636000
3000
na pola puta da smo građeni kao riba.
10:51
I am trying to suggest that, for 40-odd years,
215
639000
3000
Pokušavam reći da je već 40tak godina,
10:54
this aquatic idea has been miscategorized as lunatic fringe,
216
642000
5000
ova vodena teorija pogrešno kategorizirana kao luda ideja,
10:59
and it is not lunatic fringe.
217
647000
3000
a nije luda ideja.
11:02
And the ironic thing about it is that
218
650000
3000
A ironija je u tome da
11:05
they are not staving off the aquatic theory
219
653000
3000
oni ne sprječavaju vodenu teoriju
11:08
to protect a theory of their own,
220
656000
2000
da bi zaštitili svoju teoriju,
11:10
which they've all agreed on, and they love.
221
658000
2000
s kojom se svi slažu i svi vole.
11:12
There is nothing there.
222
660000
2000
Te teorije nema.
11:14
They are staving off the aquatic theory
223
662000
2000
Oni sprječavaju vodenu teoriju
11:16
to protect a vacuum.
224
664000
2000
kako bi zaštitili vakuum.
11:18
(Laughter)
225
666000
3000
(Smijeh)
11:21
(Applause)
226
669000
5000
(Pljesak)
11:26
How do they react when I say these things?
227
674000
3000
Kako reaguju kad kažem ove stvari?
11:29
One very common reaction I've heard about 20 times
228
677000
4000
Česta reakcija koju sam čula dvadesetak puta
11:33
is, "But it was investigated.
229
681000
2000
je, "Ali to je istraženo.
11:35
They conducted a serious investigation of this at the beginning,
230
683000
4000
Provodili su ozbiljne studije o ovome na početku,
11:39
when Hardy put forward his article."
231
687000
4000
kad je Hardy izdao svoj članak."
11:43
I don't believe it.
232
691000
3000
Ne vjerujem u to.
11:46
For 35 years I've been looking for any evidence
233
694000
3000
35 godina sam tražila dokaze
11:49
of any incident of that kind,
234
697000
2000
o takvom slučaju
11:51
and I've concluded that that's one of the urban myths.
235
699000
3000
i zaključila sam, da je to urbani mit.
11:54
It's never been done.
236
702000
3000
To se nikad nije dogodilo.
11:57
I ask people sometimes, and they say,
237
705000
2000
Ponekad pitam ljude, i oni kažu,
11:59
"I like the aquatic theory!
238
707000
2000
"Sviđa mi se vodena teorija!
12:01
Everybody likes the aquatic theory.
239
709000
2000
Svima se sviđa vodena teorija.
12:03
Of course they don't believe it, but they like it."
240
711000
2000
Naravno da ne vjeruju u nju, ali im se sviđa."
12:05
Well I say, "Why do you think it's rubbish?"
241
713000
4000
Onda ih pitam, "Zašto misliš da je pogrešna?"
12:09
They say "Well ...
242
717000
2000
Oni kažu "Pa ...
12:11
everybody I talk to says it's rubbish.
243
719000
3000
svi sa kojima pričam kažu da je pogrešna.
12:14
And they can't all be wrong, can they?"
244
722000
2000
A ne mogu svi biti u krivu, zar ne?"
12:16
The answer to that, loud and clear, is, "Yes! They can all be wrong."
245
724000
4000
Odgovor na to, jasan i glasan, je, "Da! Mogu svi biti u krivu."
12:20
History is strewn with the cases when they've all got it wrong.
246
728000
4000
Historija je prepuna slučajeva kad su svi u krivu.
12:24
(Applause)
247
732000
8000
(Pljesak)
12:32
And if you've got a scientific problem like that,
248
740000
2000
I kada imate naučni problem poput ovoga,
12:34
you can't solve it by holding a head count,
249
742000
3000
ne možete ga riješiti brojeći glasove,
12:37
and saying, "More of us say yes than say no."
250
745000
3000
i zaključivanjem, "Više nas kaže da nego ne."
12:40
(Laughter)
251
748000
1000
(Smijeh)
12:41
Apart from that, some of the heads count more than others.
252
749000
4000
Osim toga, neki glasovi znače više od drugih.
12:45
Some of them have come over.
253
753000
3000
Neki su promjenili stranu.
12:48
There was Professor Tobias. He's come over.
254
756000
3000
Kao Profesor Tobias. On je promjenio stranu.
12:51
Daniel Dennett, he's come over.
255
759000
2000
Daniel Dennett, on je promjenio stranu.
12:53
Sir David Attenborough, he's come over.
256
761000
4000
Sir David Attenborough, on je promjenio stranu.
12:57
Anybody else out there? Come on in.
257
765000
2000
Još neko? Slobodno uđite.
12:59
The water is lovely.
258
767000
2000
Voda je ugodna.
13:01
(Applause)
259
769000
3000
(Pljesak)
13:04
And now we've got to look to the future.
260
772000
5000
Sad moramo pogledati prema budućnosti.
13:09
Ultimately one of three things is going to happen.
261
777000
4000
Na kraju će se dogoditi jedna od tri stvari.
13:13
Either they will go on for the next 40 years, 50 years, 60 years.
262
781000
5000
Nastaviti će ovako slijedećih 40, 50, 60 godina.
13:18
"Yeah well we don't talk about that. Let's talk about something interesting."
263
786000
4000
"Nećemo pričati o tome. Pričajmo o nečemu zanimljivom."
13:22
That would be very sad.
264
790000
2000
To bi bilo jako tužno.
13:24
The second thing that could happen
265
792000
2000
Druga stvar koja bi se mogla dogoditi
13:26
is that some young genius will arrive,
266
794000
2000
jest da dođe kakav mladi genije,
13:28
and say, "I've found it.
267
796000
2000
i kaže, "Našao sam.
13:30
It was not the savanna, it was not the water, it was this!"
268
798000
4000
Nije bila savana, nije bila voda, bilo je ovo!"
13:34
No sign of that happening either.
269
802000
3000
Nema naznake da će se to dogoditi.
13:37
I don't think there is a third option.
270
805000
2000
Mislim da nema treće opcije.
13:39
So the third thing that might happen is
271
807000
3000
Pa bi treća stvar koja bi se dogodila mogla biti
13:42
a very beautiful thing.
272
810000
3000
jedna jako lijepa stvar.
13:45
If you look back at the early years of the last century,
273
813000
3000
Ako pogledamo unazad na rane godine prošlog stoljeća,
13:48
there was a stand-off, a lot of bickering and bad feeling
274
816000
4000
imali smo svađe i nerazumjevanje
13:52
between the believers in Mendel,
275
820000
2000
između pobornika Mendela,
13:54
and the believers in Darwin.
276
822000
3000
i pobornika Darwina.
13:57
It ended with a new synthesis:
277
825000
3000
Završilo je novom sintezom.
14:00
Darwin's ideas and Mendel's ideas
278
828000
3000
Darwinove i Mendelove ideje
14:03
blending together.
279
831000
2000
stopile su se u jednu.
14:05
And I think the same thing will happen here.
280
833000
3000
I mislim da će se isto dogoditi ovdje.
14:08
You'll get a new synthesis.
281
836000
3000
Dobit ćemo novu sintezu.
14:11
Hardy's ideas and Darwin's ideas
282
839000
2000
Hardyeve i Darwinove ideje
14:13
will be blended together.
283
841000
2000
stopit će se u jednu.
14:15
And we can move forward from there,
284
843000
2000
I onda možemo krenuti dalje,
14:17
and really get somewhere.
285
845000
2000
i stvarno doći nekuda.
14:19
That would be a beautiful thing.
286
847000
3000
To bi bilo jako lijepo.
14:22
It would be very nice for me if it happened soon.
287
850000
3000
Meni bi bilo drago da se to desi uskoro.
14:25
(Laughter)
288
853000
11000
(Smijeh)
14:36
Because I'm older now than George Burns was when he said,
289
864000
5000
Jer sam starija od George Burnsa kad je rekao,
14:41
"At my age, I don't even buy green bananas."
290
869000
4000
"U mojim godinama, više ne kupujem ni zelene banane."
14:45
(Laughter)
291
873000
6000
(Smijeh)
14:51
So if it's going to come and it's going to happen,
292
879000
3000
Zato ako će se to desiti,
14:54
what's holding it up?
293
882000
2000
šta ga zadržava?
14:56
I can tell you that in three words.
294
884000
3000
Mogu vam to reći u tri riječi.
14:59
Academia says no.
295
887000
4000
Akademija kaže ne.
15:03
They decided in 1960,
296
891000
2000
Odlučili su 1960.,
15:05
"That belongs with the UFOs and the yetis."
297
893000
3000
"To spada sa NLO-ima i jetijima."
15:08
And it's not easy to change their minds.
298
896000
4000
A nije lako promijeniti njihovo mišljenje.
15:12
The professional journals
299
900000
2000
Naučni časopisi
15:14
won't touch it with a barge pole.
300
902000
2000
neće to dirnuti ni štapom.
15:16
The textbooks don't mention it.
301
904000
3000
Udžbenici to ne spominju.
15:19
The syllabus doesn't mention even the fact that we're naked,
302
907000
3000
U nastavnom planu se ne spominje niti to da smo goli,
15:22
let alone look for a reason to it.
303
910000
3000
a kamoli da traže razlog za to.
15:25
"Horizon," which takes its cue from the academics,
304
913000
3000
TV emisijia "Horizon", koja sluša samo akademiju,
15:28
won't touch it with a barge pole.
305
916000
2000
to ne želi dirati ni štapom.
15:30
So we never hear the case put for it,
306
918000
4000
Zato nikada ne čujemo za taj slučaj,
15:34
except in jocular references
307
922000
3000
osim u šaljivim referencama
15:37
to people on the lunatic fringe.
308
925000
2000
na račun ljudi na granici ludila.
15:39
I don't know quite where this diktat comes from.
309
927000
6000
Ne znam otkuda dolazi ovaj diktat.
15:45
Somebody up there
310
933000
2000
Neko odozgo
15:47
is issuing the commandment,
311
935000
4000
daje naredbe,
15:51
"Thou shalt not believe in the aquatic theory.
312
939000
4000
"Ne smiješ vjerovati u vodenu teoriju."
15:55
And if you hope to make progress in this profession,
313
943000
3000
I ako se nadaš napretku u ovom zanimanju,
15:58
and you do believe it, you'd better keep it to yourself,
314
946000
4000
i vjeruješ u to, bolje da držiš to za sebe.
16:02
because it will get in your way."
315
950000
2000
Jer će ti to smetati u napretku.
16:04
So I get the impression that some parts
316
952000
3000
Zato imam osjećaj da se neki dijelovi
16:07
of the scientific establishment
317
955000
3000
naučnog establišmenta
16:10
are morphing into a kind of priesthood.
318
958000
4000
pretvaraju u neku vrstu sveštenstva.
16:14
But you know, that makes me feel good,
319
962000
4000
Ali znate, to me čini sretnom.
16:18
because Richard Dawkins has told us
320
966000
3000
Jer Richard Dawkins je rekao
16:21
how to treat a priesthood.
321
969000
2000
kako se odnosi prema sveštenstvu.
16:23
(Laughter)
322
971000
2000
(Smjeh)
16:25
He says, "Firstly, you've got to refuse to give it
323
973000
3000
Rekao je, "Prvo im moraš uskratiti
16:28
all the excessive awe and reverence
324
976000
3000
svo strahopoštovanje
16:31
it's been trained to receive."
325
979000
2000
na koje su naučeni."
16:33
Right. I'll go ahead with that.
326
981000
2000
Dobro. To ću napraviti.
16:35
And secondly, he says,
327
983000
2000
I drugo, kaže,
16:37
"You must never be afraid to rock the boat."
328
985000
3000
"Nikada se ne smiješ bojati dići prašinu."
16:40
I'll go along with that too.
329
988000
2000
I to ću napraviti.
16:42
Thank you very much.
330
990000
2000
Puno vam hvala.
16:44
(Applause)
331
992000
20000
(Pljesak)
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Elaine Morgan - Aquatic ape theoristElaine Morgan, armed with an arsenal of television writing credits and feminist credentials, spent her life on a mission to prove humans evolved in water.
Why you should listen
Television writer and scientific theorist Elaine Morgan may have been known for penning the popular British TV series Dr. Finlay's Casebook, but for decades the Welsh feminist writer championed human evolutionary theories using aquatic species. She wrote six books about the aquatic ape theory, derived from ancient Greek philosophies about human evolution.
Taking a less male-centric approach to evolutionary theory, Morgan's adventure was chronicled in the 1998 BBC documentary The Aquatic Ape. She was an award-winning television writer (she won two BAFTAs and Writers' Guild honors) for Campion, How Green Was My Valley and Testament of Youth. Morgan died in July 2013 at age 92.
Elaine Morgan | Speaker | TED.com