TEDxBoston 2012
Amos Winter: The cheap all-terrain wheelchair
Filmed:
Readability: 5
1,273,454 views
How do you build a wheelchair ready to blaze through mud and sand, all for under $200? MIT engineer Amos Winter guides us through the mechanics of an all-terrain wheelchair that's cheap and easy to build -- for true accessibility -- and gives us some lessons he learned along the road.
Amos Winter - Mechanical engineer
Amos Winter and his team at MIT built the Leveraged Freedom Chair, a cheap lever-powered wheelchair whose design and develop put the user first. Full bio
Amos Winter and his team at MIT built the Leveraged Freedom Chair, a cheap lever-powered wheelchair whose design and develop put the user first. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
Living with a physical disability isn't easy
0
656
3241
00:19
anywhere in the world,
1
3897
2223
00:22
but if you live in a country like the United States,
2
6120
2829
00:24
there's certain appurtenances available to you that do make life easier.
3
8949
3093
00:27
So if you're in a building, you can take an elevator.
4
12042
2673
00:30
If you're crossing the street, you have sidewalk cutouts.
5
14715
2280
00:32
And if you have to travel some distance farther
6
16995
2164
00:35
than you can do under your own power, there's accessible vehicles,
7
19159
2959
00:38
and if you can't afford one of those,
8
22118
2168
00:40
there's accessible public transportation.
9
24286
2373
00:42
But in the developing world, things are quite different.
10
26659
2481
00:45
There's 40 million people who need a wheelchair but don't have one,
11
29140
3429
00:48
and the majority of these people live in rural areas,
12
32569
3355
00:51
where the only connections to community, to employment, to education,
13
35924
3880
00:55
are by traveling long distances on rough terrain
14
39809
2483
00:58
often under their own power.
15
42292
2737
01:00
And the devices usually available to these people
16
45029
2112
01:03
are not made for that context, break down quickly,
17
47141
2704
01:05
and are hard to repair.
18
49845
2310
01:08
I started looking at wheelchairs in developing countries in 2005,
19
52155
4720
01:12
when I spent the summer assessing the state of technology in Tanzania,
20
56875
3816
01:16
and I talked to wheelchair users, wheelchair manufacturers, disability groups,
21
60691
3813
01:20
and what stood out to me
22
64504
1857
01:22
is that there wasn't a device available
23
66361
2452
01:24
that was designed for rural areas, that could go fast
24
68813
2256
01:26
and efficiently on many types of terrain.
25
71069
2908
01:29
So being a mechanical engineer,
26
73977
1783
01:31
being at MIT and having lots of resources available to me,
27
75760
2594
01:34
I thought I'd try to do something about it.
28
78354
2506
01:36
Now when you're talking about trying to travel
29
80860
2953
01:39
long distances on rough terrain,
30
83813
2206
01:41
I immediately thought of a mountain bike,
31
86019
1733
01:43
and a mountain bike's good at doing this
32
87752
1413
01:45
because it has a gear train,
33
89165
1839
01:46
and you can shift to a low gear if you have to climb a hill
34
91004
2748
01:49
or go through mud or sand
35
93752
1712
01:51
and you get a lot of torque but a low speed.
36
95464
2114
01:53
And if you want to go faster, say on pavement,
37
97578
2115
01:55
you can shift to a high gear,
38
99693
1299
01:56
and you get less torque, but higher speeds.
39
100992
1787
01:58
So the logical evolution here
40
102779
1972
02:00
is to just make a wheelchair with mountain bike components,
41
104751
2787
02:03
which many people have done.
42
107538
1272
02:04
But these are two products available in the U.S. that
43
108810
3315
02:08
would be difficult to transfer into developing countries
44
112125
2606
02:10
because they're much, much too expensive.
45
114731
2635
02:13
And the context I'm talking about is where
46
117366
2276
02:15
you need to have a product that is less than 200 dollars.
47
119642
3996
02:19
And this ideal product would also be able to go
48
123638
2431
02:21
about five kilometers a day so you could get to your job, get to school,
49
126069
4004
02:25
and do it on many, many different types of terrain.
50
130073
1852
02:27
But when you get home or want to go indoors at your work,
51
131925
2892
02:30
it's got to be small enough and maneuverable enough to use inside.
52
134817
4421
02:35
And furthermore, if you want it to last a long time out in rural areas,
53
139238
3361
02:38
it has to be repairable using the local tools, materials and knowledge
54
142599
4106
02:42
in those contexts.
55
146705
2816
02:45
So the real crux of the problem here is,
56
149521
2940
02:48
how do you make a system that's a simple device
57
152461
3148
02:51
but gives you a large mechanical advantage?
58
155609
2131
02:53
How do you make a mountain bike for your arms
59
157740
2187
02:55
that doesn't have the mountain bike cost and complexity?
60
159927
2595
02:58
So as is the case with simple solutions,
61
162522
2497
03:00
oftentimes the answer is right in front of your face, and for us it was levers.
62
165019
3482
03:04
We use levers all the time, in tools, doorknobs, bicycle parts.
63
168501
4938
03:09
And that moment of inspiration, that key invention moment,
64
173439
2737
03:12
was when I was sitting in front of my design notebook
65
176176
2369
03:14
and I started thinking about somebody grabbing a lever,
66
178545
3000
03:17
and if they grab near the end of the lever,
67
181545
2113
03:19
they can get an effectively long lever
68
183658
1633
03:21
and produce a lot of torque as they push back and forth,
69
185291
2825
03:24
and effectively get a low gear.
70
188116
2421
03:26
And as they slide their hand down the lever,
71
190537
2407
03:28
they can push with a smaller effective lever length,
72
192944
2836
03:31
but push through a bigger angle every stroke,
73
195780
1745
03:33
which makes a faster rotational speed, and gives you an effective high gear.
74
197525
4034
03:37
So what's exciting about this system
75
201559
1752
03:39
is that it's really, really mechanically simple,
76
203311
2603
03:41
and you could make it using technology
77
205914
1569
03:43
that's been around for hundreds of years.
78
207483
2247
03:45
So seeing this in practice,
79
209730
2185
03:47
this is the Leveraged Freedom Chair that,
80
211915
1553
03:49
after a few years of development,
81
213468
2164
03:51
we're now going into production with,
82
215632
1937
03:53
and this is a full-time wheelchair user --
83
217569
1873
03:55
he's paralyzed -- in Guatemala,
84
219442
1692
03:57
and you see he's able to traverse pretty rough terrain.
85
221134
3999
04:01
Again, the key innovation of this technology is that when he wants to go fast,
86
225133
4523
04:05
he just grabs the levers near the pivots and goes through a big angle every stroke,
87
229664
4055
04:09
and as the going gets tougher, he just slides his hands up the levers,
88
233719
2925
04:12
creates more torque, and kind of bench-presses his way
89
236644
2186
04:14
out of trouble through the rough terrain.
90
238830
2596
04:17
Now the big, important point here is that
91
241426
3012
04:20
the person is the complex machine in this system.
92
244438
2713
04:23
It's the person that's sliding his hands up and down the levers,
93
247151
3346
04:26
so the mechanism itself can be very simple
94
250497
2722
04:29
and composed of bicycle parts you can get anywhere in the world.
95
253219
3063
04:32
Because those bicycle parts
96
256282
1600
04:33
are so ubiquitously available, they're super-cheap.
97
257882
2506
04:36
They're made by the gazillions in China and India,
98
260388
2179
04:38
and we can source them anywhere in the world,
99
262567
1856
04:40
build the chair anywhere, and most importantly repair it,
100
264423
2433
04:42
even out in a village with a local bicycle mechanic
101
266856
2399
04:45
who has local tools, knowledge and parts available.
102
269255
4715
04:49
Now, when you want to use the LFC indoors,
103
273970
2677
04:52
all you have to do is pull the levers out of the drivetrain,
104
276647
3520
04:56
stow them in the frame, and it converts into a normal wheelchair
105
280167
3277
04:59
that you can use just like any other normal wheelchair,
106
283444
2515
05:01
and we sized it like a normal wheelchair,
107
285959
2146
05:04
so it's narrow enough to fit through a standard doorway,
108
288105
4135
05:08
it's low enough to fit under a table,
109
292240
3519
05:11
and it's small and maneuverable enough to fit in a bathroom
110
295759
3993
05:15
and this is important so the user can get up close to a toilet,
111
299752
2739
05:18
and be able to transfer off
112
302491
1989
05:20
just like he could in a normal wheelchair.
113
304480
5591
05:25
Now, there's three important points that I want to stress
114
310071
3092
05:29
that I think really hit home in this project.
115
313163
3632
05:32
The first is that this product works well because
116
316795
3204
05:35
we were effectively able to combine
117
319999
2031
05:37
rigorous engineering science and analysis with user-centered design
118
322030
4554
05:42
focused on the social and usage and economic factors
119
326584
3377
05:45
important to wheelchair users in the developing countries.
120
329961
2537
05:48
So I'm an academic at MIT, and I'm a mechanical engineer,
121
332498
2488
05:50
so I can do things like look at the type of terrain you want to travel on,
122
334986
3297
05:54
and figure out how much resistance it should impose,
123
338283
2899
05:57
look at the parts we have available and mix and match them
124
341182
3008
06:00
to figure out what sort of gear trains we can use,
125
344190
2645
06:02
and then look at the power and force you can get out of your upper body
126
346835
3102
06:05
to analyze how fast you should be able to go in this chair
127
349944
1963
06:07
as you put your arms up and down the levers.
128
351907
2371
06:10
So as a wet-behind-the-ears student, excited,
129
354278
3659
06:13
our team made a prototype,
130
357937
2125
06:15
brought that prototype to Tanzania, Kenya and Vietnam in 2008,
131
360062
4875
06:20
and found it was terrible
132
364937
2134
06:22
because we didn't get enough input from users.
133
367071
2437
06:25
So because we tested it with wheelchair users,
134
369508
3166
06:28
with wheelchair manufacturers, we got that feedback from them,
135
372674
2506
06:31
not just articulating their problems, but articulating their solutions,
136
375180
3454
06:34
and worked together to go back to the drawing board and make a new design,
137
378634
3478
06:38
which we brought back to East Africa in '09
138
382112
2220
06:40
that worked a lot better than a normal wheelchair on rough terrain,
139
384332
2845
06:43
but it still didn't work well indoors because it was too big,
140
387177
2585
06:45
it was heavy, it was hard to move around,
141
389762
2295
06:47
so again with that user feedback, we went back to the drawing board,
142
392057
3554
06:51
came up with a better design, 20 pounds lighter,
143
395611
2315
06:53
as narrow as a regular wheelchair, tested that in a field trial in Guatemala,
144
397926
3562
06:57
and that advanced the product to the point
145
401488
1847
06:59
where we have now that it's going into production.
146
403335
3529
07:02
Now also being engineering scientists,
147
406864
2246
07:05
we were able to quantify the performance benefits of the Leveraged Freedom Chair,
148
409110
3726
07:08
so here are some shots of our trial in Guatemala
149
412836
2796
07:11
where we tested the LFC on village terrain,
150
415632
3542
07:15
and tested people's biomechanical outputs,
151
419174
1828
07:16
their oxygen consumption, how fast they go,
152
421002
2383
07:19
how much power they're putting out,
153
423385
1318
07:20
both in their regular wheelchairs and using the LFC,
154
424703
3272
07:23
and we found that the LFC is about 80 percent faster
155
427975
2312
07:26
going on these terrains than a normal wheelchair.
156
430287
1961
07:28
It's also about 40 percent more efficient than a regular wheelchair,
157
432248
3961
07:32
and because of the mechanical advantage you get from the levers,
158
436217
2543
07:34
you can produce 50 percent higher torque
159
438760
1889
07:36
and really muscle your way through the really, really rough terrain.
160
440649
4024
07:40
Now the second lesson that we learned in this is that
161
444673
3436
07:44
the constraints on this design really push the innovation,
162
448109
2900
07:46
because we had to hit such a low price point,
163
451009
2264
07:49
because we had to make a device that could travel
164
453273
1901
07:51
on many, many types of terrain but still be usable indoors,
165
455174
3228
07:54
and be simple enough to repair,
166
458402
2291
07:56
we ended up with a fundamentally new product,
167
460693
2367
07:58
a new product that is an innovation
168
463060
2116
08:01
in a space that really hasn't changed in a hundred years.
169
465176
2917
08:03
And these are all merits that are not just good in the developing world.
170
468093
3415
08:07
Why not in countries like the U.S. too?
171
471508
2477
08:09
So we teamed up with Continuum,
172
473985
1736
08:11
a local product design firm here in Boston
173
475721
1644
08:13
to make the high-end version, the developed world version,
174
477365
3388
08:16
that we'll probably sell primarily in the U.S. and Europe,
175
480753
2745
08:19
but to higher-income buyers.
176
483498
2842
08:22
And the final point I want to make is that I think
177
486340
2986
08:25
this project worked well because we engaged
178
489326
2826
08:28
all the stakeholders that buy into this project and are important to consider
179
492152
4611
08:32
in bringing the technology from inception of an idea
180
496763
3343
08:36
through innovation, validation, commercialization and dissemination,
181
500106
4239
08:40
and that cycle has to start and end with end users.
182
504345
3745
08:43
These are the people that define the requirements of the technology,
183
508090
2775
08:46
and these are the people that have to give the thumbs-up at the end,
184
510865
2339
08:49
and say, "Yeah, it actually works. It meets our needs."
185
513204
2509
08:51
So people like me in the academic space,
186
515713
1907
08:53
we can do things like innovate and analyze and test,
187
517620
3528
08:57
create data and make bench-level prototypes,
188
521148
3096
09:00
but how do you get that bench-level prototype to commercialization?
189
524244
2792
09:02
So we need gap-fillers like Continuum that can work on commercializing,
190
527036
3787
09:06
and we started a whole NGO to bring our chair to market --
191
530823
2515
09:09
Global Research Innovation Technology --
192
533338
2436
09:11
and then we also teamed up with a big manufacturer in India, Pinnacle Industries,
193
535774
3732
09:15
that's tooled up now to make 500 chairs a month
194
539506
2215
09:17
and will make the first batch of 200 next month,
195
541721
1803
09:19
which will be delivered in India.
196
543524
2016
09:21
And then finally, to get this out to the people in scale,
197
545540
2704
09:24
we teamed up with the largest disability organization
198
548244
2312
09:26
in the world, Jaipur Foot.
199
550556
2558
09:29
Now what's powerful about this model
200
553114
2279
09:31
is when you bring together all these stakeholders
201
555393
2807
09:34
that represent each link in the chain
202
558200
1969
09:36
from inception of an idea
203
560169
2541
09:38
all the way to implementation in the field,
204
562710
2768
09:41
that's where the magic happens.
205
565478
1551
09:42
That's where you can take a guy like me, an academic,
206
567029
2454
09:45
but analyze and test and create a new technology
207
569483
3122
09:48
and quantitatively determine how much better the performance is.
208
572605
3536
09:52
You can connect with stakeholders like the manufacturers
209
576141
2411
09:54
and talk with them face-to-face and leverage their
210
578552
1884
09:56
local knowledge of manufacturing practices and their clients
211
580436
3497
09:59
and combine that knowledge with our engineering knowledge
212
583933
2609
10:02
to create something greater than either of us could have done alone.
213
586542
3460
10:05
And then you can also engage the end user
214
590002
2531
10:08
in the design process, and not just ask him what he needs,
215
592533
2710
10:11
but ask him how he thinks it can be achieved.
216
595243
3025
10:14
And this picture was taken in India in our last field trial,
217
598268
3057
10:17
where we had a 90-percent adoption rate where people
218
601325
2359
10:19
switched to using our Leveraged Freedom Chair over their normal wheelchair,
219
603684
3606
10:23
and this picture specifically is of Ashok,
220
607290
3103
10:26
and Ashok had a spinal injury when he fell out of a tree,
221
610393
3032
10:29
and he had been working at a tailor, but once he was injured
222
613425
2842
10:32
he wasn't able to transport himself from his house
223
616267
2923
10:35
over a kilometer to his shop in his normal wheelchair.
224
619190
2800
10:37
The road was too rough.
225
621990
1271
10:39
But the day after he got an LFC, he hopped in it,
226
623261
2921
10:42
rode that kilometer, opened up his shop
227
626182
2084
10:44
and soon after landed a contract to make school uniforms
228
628266
2716
10:46
and started making money, started providing for his family again.
229
630982
2822
10:49
Ashok: You also encouraged me to work.
230
633804
2147
10:51
I rested for a day at home.
231
635951
2724
10:54
The next day I went to my shop.
232
638675
4456
10:59
Now everything is back to normal.
233
643131
2978
11:02
Amos Winter: And thank you very much for having me today.
234
646109
4085
11:06
(Applause)
235
650194
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Amos Winter - Mechanical engineerAmos Winter and his team at MIT built the Leveraged Freedom Chair, a cheap lever-powered wheelchair whose design and develop put the user first.
Why you should listen
Amos Winter wants to know: How do you redesign the wheelchair, an essential aid for millions, to be even better, more affordable, adaptable for the developing world, and able to face any type of terrain or weather? The answer is: the Leveraged Freedom Chair. Integrating science, engineering and user-driven design, Winter has developed a wheelchair that uses arm-powered levers that yield surprisingly simple, highly effective mechanical results. Even better, cheap parts means the chair costs under $200 and can be repaired easily, even in rural communities where resources are scarce.
Amos Winter | Speaker | TED.com