TED2013
Robert Gordon: The death of innovation, the end of growth
Filmed:
Readability: 4.3
1,198,030 views
The US economy has been expanding wildly for two centuries. Are we witnessing the end of growth? Economist Robert Gordon lays out 4 reasons US growth may be slowing, detailing factors like epidemic debt and growing inequality, which could move the US into a period of stasis we can't innovate our way out of. Be sure to watch the opposing viewpoint from Erik Brynjolfsson.
Robert J. Gordon - Economist
Robert J. Gordon is among the most influential macroeconomists in the world. And the big picture he sees is not altogether rosy. Full bio
Robert J. Gordon is among the most influential macroeconomists in the world. And the big picture he sees is not altogether rosy. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
That's how we traveled in the year 1900.
0
713
2709
00:15
That's an open buggy. It doesn't have heating.
1
3422
2369
00:17
It doesn't have air conditioning.
2
5791
1629
00:19
That horse is pulling it along
3
7420
2057
00:21
at one percent of the speed of sound,
4
9477
2298
00:23
and the rutted dirt road
5
11775
1752
00:25
turns into a quagmire of mud anytime it rains.
6
13527
4382
00:29
That's a Boeing 707.
7
17909
2745
00:32
Only 60 years later, it travels
8
20654
2301
00:34
at 80 percent of the speed of sound,
9
22955
2217
00:37
and we don't travel any faster today
10
25172
2633
00:39
because commercial supersonic air travel
11
27805
3139
00:42
turned out to be a bust.
12
30944
1969
00:44
So I started wondering and pondering,
13
32913
2552
00:47
could it be that the best years of American economic growth
14
35465
3022
00:50
are behind us?
15
38487
1659
00:52
And that leads to the suggestion, maybe economic growth
16
40146
4479
00:56
is almost over.
17
44625
2227
00:58
Some of the reasons for this are not really very controversial.
18
46852
3762
01:02
There are four headwinds that are just hitting
19
50614
2374
01:04
the American economy in the face.
20
52988
2385
01:07
They're demographics, education, debt and inequality.
21
55373
4658
01:12
They're powerful enough to cut growth in half.
22
60031
3633
01:15
So we need a lot of innovation to offset this decline.
23
63664
4658
01:20
And here's my theme: Because of the headwinds,
24
68322
2768
01:23
if innovation continues to be as powerful as it has been
25
71090
2681
01:25
in the last 150 years, growth is cut in half.
26
73771
3867
01:29
If innovation is less powerful,
27
77638
2711
01:32
invents less great, wonderful things,
28
80349
2454
01:34
then growth is going to be even lower than half of history.
29
82803
4010
01:38
Now here's eight centuries of economic growth.
30
86813
3155
01:41
The vertical axis is just percent per year of growth,
31
89968
3664
01:45
zero percent a year, one percent a year, two percent a year.
32
93632
3123
01:48
The white line is for the U.K., and then the U.S.
33
96755
2900
01:51
takes over as the leading nation in the year 1900,
34
99655
2531
01:54
when the line switches to red.
35
102186
1491
01:55
You'll notice that, for the first four centuries,
36
103677
1986
01:57
there's hardly any growth at all, just 0.2 percent.
37
105663
3870
02:01
Then growth gets better and better.
38
109533
1619
02:03
It maxes out in the 1930s, '40s and '50s,
39
111152
2978
02:06
and then it starts slowing down, and here's a cautionary note.
40
114130
3757
02:09
That last downward notch in the red line
41
117887
2496
02:12
is not actual data.
42
120383
2231
02:14
That is a forecast that I made six years ago
43
122614
3140
02:17
that growth would slow down to 1.3 percent.
44
125754
2629
02:20
But you know what the actual facts are?
45
128383
2010
02:22
You know what the growth in per-person income has been
46
130393
1813
02:24
in the United States in the last six years?
47
132206
2892
02:27
Negative.
48
135098
2340
02:29
This led to a fantasy.
49
137438
2271
02:31
What if I try to fit a curved line to this historical record?
50
139709
5246
02:36
I can make the curved line end anywhere I wanted,
51
144955
3968
02:40
but I decided I would end it at 0.2,
52
148923
2794
02:43
just like the U.K. growth for the first four centuries.
53
151717
4825
02:48
Now the history that we've achieved is that we've grown
54
156542
3364
02:51
at 2.0 percent per year over the whole period,
55
159906
4061
02:55
1891 to 2007,
56
163967
3188
02:59
and remember it's been a little bit negative since 2007.
57
167155
3624
03:02
But if growth slows down,
58
170779
2305
03:05
instead of doubling our standard of living every generation,
59
173084
3983
03:09
Americans in the future can't expect to be twice as well off as their parents,
60
177067
4838
03:13
or even a quarter [more well off than] their parents.
61
181905
2970
03:16
Now we're going to change and look at the level of per capita income.
62
184875
4365
03:21
The vertical axis now is thousands of dollars in today's prices.
63
189240
3364
03:24
You'll notice that in 1891, over on the left,
64
192604
2576
03:27
we were at about 5,000 dollars.
65
195180
1730
03:28
Today we're at about 44,000 dollars of total output
66
196910
2905
03:31
per member of the population.
67
199815
2667
03:34
Now what if we could achieve that historic
68
202482
2418
03:36
two-percent growth for the next 70 years?
69
204900
2983
03:39
Well, it's a matter of arithmetic.
70
207883
1332
03:41
Two-percent growth quadruples your standard of living in 70 years.
71
209215
4140
03:45
That means we'd go from 44,000 to 180,000.
72
213355
3701
03:49
Well, we're not going to do that,
73
217056
2451
03:51
and the reason is the headwinds.
74
219507
1826
03:53
The first headwind is demographics.
75
221333
1641
03:54
It's a truism that your standard of living
76
222974
2338
03:57
rises faster than productivity, rises faster than output per hour,
77
225312
3512
04:00
if hours per person increased.
78
228824
2610
04:03
And we got that gift back in the '70s and '80s
79
231434
2502
04:05
when women entered the labor force.
80
233936
2518
04:08
But now it's turned around.
81
236454
2237
04:10
Now hours per person are shrinking,
82
238691
2200
04:12
first because of the retirement of the baby boomers,
83
240891
2874
04:15
and second because there's been a very significant
84
243765
4154
04:19
dropping out of the labor force of prime age adult males
85
247919
3997
04:23
who are in the bottom half of the educational distribution.
86
251916
3938
04:27
The next headwind is education.
87
255854
2161
04:30
We've got problems all over our educational system
88
258015
2645
04:32
despite Race to the Top.
89
260660
1521
04:34
In college, we've got cost inflation in higher education
90
262181
4082
04:38
that dwarfs cost inflation in medical care.
91
266263
2912
04:41
We have in higher education a trillion dollars of student debt,
92
269175
4256
04:45
and our college completion rate
93
273431
2987
04:48
is 15 points, 15 percentage points below Canada.
94
276418
6951
04:55
We have a lot of debt.
95
283369
2107
04:57
Our economy grew from 2000 to 2007
96
285476
4982
05:02
on the back of consumers massively overborrowing.
97
290458
3232
05:05
Consumers paying off that debt is one of the main reasons
98
293690
2936
05:08
why our economic recovery is so sluggish today.
99
296626
2736
05:11
And everybody of course knows
100
299362
1586
05:12
that the federal government debt is growing
101
300948
2129
05:15
as a share of GDP at a very rapid rate,
102
303077
3329
05:18
and the only way that's going to stop is some combination
103
306406
3162
05:21
of faster growth in taxes or slower growth in entitlements,
104
309568
5077
05:26
also called transfer payments.
105
314645
2085
05:28
And that gets us down from the 1.5,
106
316730
2169
05:30
where we've reached for education, down to 1.3.
107
318899
3401
05:34
And then we have inequality.
108
322300
2418
05:36
Over the 15 years before the financial crisis,
109
324718
2753
05:39
the growth rate of the bottom 99 percent
110
327471
3266
05:42
of the income distribution was half a point slower
111
330737
3123
05:45
than the averages we've been talking about before.
112
333860
2776
05:48
All the rest went to the top one percent.
113
336636
2286
05:50
So that brings us down to 0.8.
114
338922
2352
05:53
And that 0.8 is the big challenge.
115
341274
3375
05:56
Are we going to grow at 0.8?
116
344649
2214
05:58
If so, that's going to require that our inventions
117
346863
2455
06:01
are as important as the ones that happened
118
349318
2347
06:03
over the last 150 years.
119
351665
2918
06:06
So let's see what some of those inventions were.
120
354583
4039
06:10
If you wanted to read in 1875 at night,
121
358622
3502
06:14
you needed to have an oil or a gas lamp.
122
362124
3322
06:17
They created pollution, they created odors,
123
365446
2157
06:19
they were hard to control, the light was dim,
124
367603
2405
06:22
and they were a fire hazard.
125
370008
2148
06:24
By 1929, electric light was everywhere.
126
372156
5095
06:29
We had the vertical city, the invention of the elevator.
127
377251
4149
06:33
Central Manhattan became possible.
128
381400
2985
06:36
And then, in addition to that, at the same time,
129
384385
3247
06:39
hand tools were replaced by massive electric tools
130
387632
3496
06:43
and hand-powered electric tools,
131
391128
2708
06:45
all achieved by electricity.
132
393836
2858
06:48
Electricity was also very helpful in liberating women.
133
396694
4213
06:52
Women, back in the late 19th century,
134
400907
2688
06:55
spent two days a week doing the laundry.
135
403595
2656
06:58
They did it on a scrub board.
136
406251
1715
06:59
Then they had to hang the clothes out to dry.
137
407966
2068
07:02
Then they had to bring them in.
138
410034
1532
07:03
The whole thing took two days out of the seven-day week.
139
411566
2953
07:06
And then we had the electric washing machine.
140
414519
3587
07:10
And by 1950, they were everywhere.
141
418106
3074
07:13
But the women still had to shop every day,
142
421180
3028
07:16
but no they didn't, because electricity
143
424208
2292
07:18
brought us the electric refrigerator.
144
426500
2901
07:21
Back in the late 19th century, the only source of heat in most homes
145
429401
3192
07:24
was a big fireplace in the kitchen that was used for cooking and heating.
146
432593
4529
07:29
The bedrooms were cold. They were unheated.
147
437122
2316
07:31
But by 1929, certainly by 1950,
148
439438
2680
07:34
we had central heating everywhere.
149
442118
3892
07:38
What about the internal combustion engine,
150
446010
2592
07:40
which was invented in 1879?
151
448602
2340
07:42
In America, before the motor vehicle,
152
450942
3818
07:46
transportation depended entirely on the urban horse,
153
454760
3972
07:50
which dropped, without restraint,
154
458732
2886
07:53
25 to 50 pounds of manure on the streets every day
155
461618
3805
07:57
together with a gallon of urine.
156
465423
1924
07:59
That comes out at five to 10 tons daily
157
467347
3213
08:02
per square mile in cities.
158
470560
2433
08:04
Those horses also ate up fully one quarter of American agricultural land.
159
472993
5941
08:10
That's the percentage of American agricultural land
160
478934
2398
08:13
it took to feed the horses.
161
481332
2193
08:15
Of course, when the motor vehicle was invented,
162
483525
3962
08:19
and it became almost ubiquitous by 1929,
163
487487
3204
08:22
that agricultural land could be used for human consumption
164
490691
3095
08:25
or for export.
165
493786
1534
08:27
And here's an interesting ratio: Starting from zero in 1900,
166
495320
3640
08:30
only 30 years later, the ratio of motor vehicles to the number of households
167
498960
4916
08:35
in the United States reached 90 percent in just 30 years.
168
503876
6584
08:42
Back before the turn of the century,
169
510460
2811
08:45
women had another problem.
170
513271
1401
08:46
All the water for cooking, cleaning and bathing
171
514672
4595
08:51
had to be carried in buckets and pails in from the outside.
172
519267
4670
08:55
It's a historical fact that in 1885,
173
523937
2475
08:58
the average North Carolina housewife
174
526412
2314
09:00
walked 148 miles a year carrying 35 tons of water.
175
528726
5370
09:06
But by 1929, cities around the country
176
534096
4404
09:10
had put in underground water pipes.
177
538500
3015
09:13
They had put in underground sewer pipes,
178
541515
3426
09:16
and as a result, one of the great scourges of the late 19th century,
179
544941
5182
09:22
waterborne diseases like cholera, began to disappear.
180
550123
4246
09:26
And an amazing fact for techno-optimists
181
554369
3602
09:29
is that in the first half of the 20th century,
182
557971
2572
09:32
the rate of improvement of life expectancy
183
560543
2712
09:35
was three times faster than it was
184
563255
2801
09:38
in the second half of the 19th century.
185
566056
2871
09:40
So it's a truism that things can't be more than 100 percent of themselves.
186
568927
5086
09:46
And I'll just give you a few examples.
187
574013
2182
09:48
We went from one percent to 90 percent of the speed of sound.
188
576195
3268
09:51
Electrification, central heat, ownership of motor cars,
189
579463
3608
09:55
they all went from zero to 100 percent.
190
583071
2363
09:57
Urban environments make people more productive than on the farm.
191
585434
3650
10:01
We went from 25 percent urban to 75 percent
192
589084
2842
10:03
by the early postwar years.
193
591926
4128
10:08
What about the electronic revolution?
194
596054
2243
10:10
Here's an early computer.
195
598297
2121
10:12
It's amazing. The mainframe computer was invented in 1942.
196
600418
3310
10:15
By 1960 we had telephone bills, bank statements
197
603728
4553
10:20
were being produced by computers.
198
608281
1771
10:22
The earliest cell phones, the earliest personal computers
199
610052
2864
10:24
were invented in the 1970s.
200
612916
2915
10:27
The 1980s brought us Bill Gates, DOS,
201
615831
3255
10:31
ATM machines to replace bank tellers,
202
619086
2785
10:33
bar code scanning to cut down on labor in the retail sector.
203
621871
3893
10:37
Fast forward through the '90s,
204
625764
1867
10:39
we had the dotcom revolution
205
627631
1568
10:41
and a temporary rise in productivity growth.
206
629199
3124
10:44
But I'm now going to give you an experiment.
207
632323
2452
10:46
You have to choose either option A or option B.
208
634775
3088
10:49
(Laughter)
209
637863
2515
10:52
Option A is you get to keep everything invented up till 10 years ago.
210
640378
3341
10:55
So you get Google, you get Amazon,
211
643719
2910
10:58
you get Wikipedia, and you get running water and indoor toilets.
212
646629
3087
11:01
Or you get everything invented to yesterday,
213
649716
1829
11:03
including Facebook and your iPhone,
214
651545
2076
11:05
but you have to give up, go out to the outhouse,
215
653621
2359
11:07
and carry in the water.
216
655980
2864
11:10
Hurricane Sandy caused a lot of people to lose the 20th century,
217
658844
3450
11:14
maybe for a couple of days,
218
662294
1523
11:15
in some cases for more than a week,
219
663817
2126
11:17
electricity, running water, heating, gasoline for their cars,
220
665943
3540
11:21
and a charge for their iPhones.
221
669483
2916
11:24
The problem we face is that all these great inventions,
222
672399
3511
11:27
we have to match them in the future,
223
675910
3004
11:30
and my prediction that we're not going to match them
224
678914
2588
11:33
brings us down from the original two-percent growth
225
681502
3195
11:36
down to 0.2, the fanciful curve that I drew you at the beginning.
226
684697
5070
11:41
So here we are back to the horse and buggy.
227
689767
3007
11:44
I'd like to award an Oscar
228
692774
2321
11:47
to the inventors of the 20th century,
229
695095
3653
11:50
the people from Alexander Graham Bell
230
698748
2741
11:53
to Thomas Edison to the Wright Brothers,
231
701489
1703
11:55
I'd like to call them all up here,
232
703192
1723
11:56
and they're going to call back to you.
233
704915
1870
11:58
Your challenge is, can you match what we achieved?
234
706785
3663
12:02
Thank you.
235
710448
1534
12:03
(Applause)
236
711982
5031
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Robert J. Gordon - EconomistRobert J. Gordon is among the most influential macroeconomists in the world. And the big picture he sees is not altogether rosy.
Why you should listen
Robert J. Gordon has written prolifically about the problems facing contemporary economic growth, casting a sobering doubt on the ability of our current innovations (what he calls the "third industrial revolution," including all our fancy gadgets) to power the economy the way previous waves of invention. In a recent paper, he suggests that the repeated doubling of economic growth that characterized the 20th century and was arguably the bedrock for modern society may be decelerating at an alarming rate -- especially for the bottom 99 percent of the income distribution. While innovation is continuing apace, he sees the economy buffeted by six headwinds, and a different mix of obstacles for the US economy than for Canada and Europe.
Over the past four decades, he's also done fascinating work on the economics of the airline industry. He's authored hundreds of scholarly articles and five books, including his most recent, Productivity Growth, Inflation, and Unemployment: The Collected Essays of Robert J. Gordon, as well as the textbook Macroeconomics, now in its 12th edition. Two key papers to start: "Is US economic growth over? Faltering innovation confronts the six headwinds," NBER Working Paper 18315; and “Why Innovation Won’t Save Us,” from the Wall Street Journal.
Robert J. Gordon | Speaker | TED.com