TEDGlobal 2005
Jacqueline Novogratz: Invest in Africa's own solutions
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
1,016,168 views
Jacqueline Novogratz applauds the world's heightened interest in Africa and poverty, but argues persuasively for a new approach.
Jacqueline Novogratz - Investor and advocate for moral leadership
Jacqueline Novogratz works to enable human flourishing. Her organization, Acumen, invests in people, companies and ideas that see capital and networks as means, not ends, to solving the toughest issues of poverty. Full bio
Jacqueline Novogratz works to enable human flourishing. Her organization, Acumen, invests in people, companies and ideas that see capital and networks as means, not ends, to solving the toughest issues of poverty. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:25
I want to start with a story, a la Seth Godin,
0
0
3000
00:28
from when I was 12 years old.
1
3000
2000
00:30
My uncle Ed gave me a beautiful blue sweater --
2
5000
3000
00:33
at least I thought it was beautiful.
3
8000
2000
00:35
And it had fuzzy zebras walking across the stomach,
4
10000
3000
00:38
and Mount Kilimanjaro and Mount Meru were kind of
5
13000
3000
00:41
right across the chest, that were also fuzzy.
6
16000
2000
00:43
And I wore it whenever I could,
7
18000
1000
00:44
thinking it was the most fabulous thing I owned.
8
19000
3000
00:47
Until one day in ninth grade,
9
22000
2000
00:49
when I was standing with a number of the football players.
10
24000
3000
00:52
And my body had clearly changed, and Matt Mussolina,
11
27000
4000
00:56
who was undeniably my nemesis in high school,
12
31000
4000
01:00
said in a booming voice that
13
35000
1000
01:01
we no longer had to go far away to go on ski trips,
14
36000
4000
01:05
but we could all ski on Mount Novogratz.
15
40000
2000
01:07
(Laughter)
16
42000
1000
01:08
And I was so humiliated and mortified
17
43000
3000
01:11
that I immediately ran home to my mother and chastised her
18
46000
4000
01:15
for ever letting me wear the hideous sweater.
19
50000
1000
01:16
We drove to the Goodwill and we threw the sweater away
20
51000
3000
01:19
somewhat ceremoniously,
21
54000
2000
01:21
my idea being that I would never have to think about the sweater
22
56000
3000
01:24
nor see it ever again.
23
59000
1000
01:25
Fast forward -- 11 years later, I'm a 25-year-old kid.
24
60000
4000
01:29
I'm working in Kigali, Rwanda, jogging through the steep slopes,
25
64000
7000
01:36
when I see, 10 feet in front of me, a little boy -- 11 years old --
26
71000
4000
01:40
running toward me, wearing my sweater.
27
75000
3000
01:43
And I'm thinking, no, this is not possible.
28
78000
2000
01:45
But so, curious, I run up to the child -- of course
29
80000
4000
01:49
scaring the living bejesus out of him --
30
84000
2000
01:51
grab him by the collar, turn it over, and there is my name
31
86000
3000
01:54
written on the collar of this sweater.
32
89000
2000
01:56
I tell that story, because it has served and continues to serve
33
91000
5000
02:01
as a metaphor to me about the level of connectedness
34
96000
4000
02:05
that we all have on this Earth.
35
100000
2000
02:07
We so often don't realize what our action and our inaction
36
102000
4000
02:11
does to people we think we will never see and never know.
37
106000
3000
02:15
I also tell it because it tells a larger contextual story
38
110000
3000
02:18
of what aid is and can be.
39
113000
2000
02:20
That this traveled into the Goodwill in Virginia,
40
115000
4000
02:24
and moved its way into the larger industry,
41
119000
3000
02:27
which at that point was giving millions of tons of secondhand clothing to Africa and Asia.
42
122000
4000
02:31
Which was a very good thing, providing low cost clothing.
43
126000
4000
02:35
And at the same time, certainly in Rwanda,
44
130000
2000
02:37
it destroyed the local retailing industry.
45
132000
2000
02:39
Not to say that it shouldn't have,
46
134000
2000
02:41
but that we have to get better at answering the questions
47
136000
3000
02:44
that need to be considered when we think about consequences
48
139000
3000
02:47
and responses.
49
142000
2000
02:49
So, I'm going to stick in Rwanda, circa 1985, 1986,
50
144000
5000
02:54
where I was doing two things.
51
149000
1000
02:55
I had started a bakery with 20 unwed mothers.
52
150000
3000
02:58
We were called the "Bad News Bears," and our notion was
53
153000
2000
03:00
we were going to corner the snack food business in Kigali,
54
155000
3000
03:03
which was not hard because there were no snacks before us.
55
158000
3000
03:07
And because we had a good business model, we actually did it,
56
162000
3000
03:10
and I watched these women transform on a micro-level.
57
165000
2000
03:12
But at the same time, I started a micro-finance bank,
58
167000
3000
03:15
and tomorrow Iqbal Quadir is going to talk about Grameen,
59
170000
3000
03:18
which is the grandfather of all micro-finance banks,
60
173000
3000
03:21
which now is a worldwide movement -- you talk about a meme --
61
176000
2000
03:24
but then it was quite new, especially in an economy
62
179000
3000
03:27
that was moving from barter into trade.
63
182000
3000
03:30
We got a lot of things right.
64
185000
2000
03:32
We focused on a business model; we insisted on skin in the game.
65
187000
3000
03:35
The women made their own decisions at the end of the day
66
190000
3000
03:38
as to how they would use this access to credit
67
193000
2000
03:40
to build their little businesses, earn more income
68
195000
3000
03:43
so they could take care of their families better.
69
198000
2000
03:46
What we didn't understand, what was happening all around us,
70
201000
4000
03:50
with the confluence of fear, ethnic strife
71
205000
6000
03:57
and certainly an aid game, if you will, that was playing into
72
212000
4000
04:02
this invisible but certainly palpable movement inside Rwanda,
73
217000
6000
04:08
that at that time, 30 percent of the budget was all foreign aid.
74
223000
3000
04:11
The genocide happened in 1994,
75
226000
2000
04:13
seven years after these women all worked together
76
228000
2000
04:15
to build this dream.
77
230000
2000
04:17
And the good news was that the institution,
78
232000
2000
04:19
the banking institution, lasted.
79
234000
2000
04:21
In fact, it became the largest rehabilitation lender in the country.
80
236000
3000
04:25
The bakery was completely wiped out,
81
240000
2000
04:27
but the lessons for me were that accountability counts --
82
242000
4000
04:32
got to build things with people on the ground,
83
247000
2000
04:34
using business models where, as Steven Levitt would say,
84
249000
3000
04:37
the incentives matter.
85
252000
2000
04:39
Understand, however complex we may be, incentives matter.
86
254000
4000
04:43
So when Chris raised to me how wonderful everything
87
258000
4000
04:47
that was happening in the world,
88
262000
2000
04:49
that we were seeing a shift in zeitgeist,
89
264000
2000
04:51
on the one hand I absolutely agree with him,
90
266000
2000
04:53
and I was so thrilled to see what happened with the G8 --
91
268000
3000
04:56
that the world, because of people like Tony Blair and Bono
92
271000
4000
05:00
and Bob Geldof -- the world is talking about global poverty;
93
275000
4000
05:04
the world is talking about Africa
94
279000
2000
05:06
in ways I have never seen in my life.
95
281000
2000
05:08
It's thrilling.
96
283000
1000
05:09
And at the same time, what keeps me up at night
97
284000
3000
05:12
is a fear that we'll look at the victories of the G8 --
98
287000
4000
05:16
50 billion dollars in increased aid to Africa,
99
291000
3000
05:19
40 billion in reduced debt -- as the victory,
100
294000
3000
05:22
as more than chapter one, as our moral absolution.
101
297000
4000
05:26
And in fact, what we need to do is see that as chapter one,
102
301000
4000
05:30
celebrate it, close it, and recognize that we need a chapter two
103
305000
4000
05:34
that is all about execution, all about the how-to.
104
309000
2000
05:37
And if you remember one thing from what I want to talk about today,
105
312000
3000
05:40
it's that the only way to end poverty, to make it history,
106
315000
4000
05:44
is to build viable systems on the ground
107
319000
3000
05:47
that deliver critical and affordable goods and services to the poor,
108
322000
4000
05:51
in ways that are financially sustainable and scaleable.
109
326000
3000
05:54
If we do that, we really can make poverty history.
110
329000
3000
05:57
And it was that -- that whole philosophy --
111
332000
3000
06:00
that encouraged me to start my current endeavor
112
335000
4000
06:04
called "Acumen Fund,"
113
339000
2000
06:06
which is trying to build some mini-blueprints
114
341000
2000
06:08
for how we might do that in water, health and housing
115
343000
3000
06:11
in Pakistan, India, Kenya, Tanzania and Egypt.
116
346000
3000
06:14
And I want to talk a little bit about that, and some of the examples,
117
349000
5000
06:19
so you can see what it is that we're doing.
118
354000
2000
06:21
But before I do this -- and this is another one of my pet peeves --
119
356000
3000
06:24
I want to talk a little bit about who the poor are.
120
359000
2000
06:26
Because we too often talk about them as these
121
361000
4000
06:30
strong, huge masses of people yearning to be free,
122
365000
3000
06:33
when in fact, it's quite an amazing story.
123
368000
5000
06:38
On a macro level, four billion people on Earth make less than four dollars a day.
124
373000
5000
06:43
That's who we talk about when we think about "the poor."
125
378000
2000
06:45
If you aggregate it, it's the third largest economy on Earth,
126
380000
3000
06:48
and yet most of these people go invisible.
127
383000
2000
06:51
Where we typically work, there's people making between
128
386000
2000
06:53
one and three dollars a day.
129
388000
2000
06:55
Who are these people?
130
390000
2000
06:57
They are farmers and factory workers.
131
392000
3000
07:00
They work in government offices. They're drivers.
132
395000
2000
07:02
They are domestics.
133
397000
3000
07:05
They typically pay for critical goods and services like water,
134
400000
3000
07:08
like healthcare, like housing, and they pay 30 to 40 times
135
403000
4000
07:12
what their middleclass counterparts pay --
136
407000
2000
07:14
certainly where we work in Karachi and Nairobi.
137
409000
3000
07:18
The poor also are willing to make, and do make, smart decisions,
138
413000
4000
07:22
if you give them that opportunity.
139
417000
2000
07:24
So, two examples.
140
419000
2000
07:26
One is in India, where there are 240 million farmers,
141
421000
3000
07:29
most of whom make less than two dollars a day.
142
424000
2000
07:31
Where we work in Aurangabad, the land is extraordinarily parched.
143
426000
3000
07:35
You see people on average making 60 cents to a dollar.
144
430000
3000
07:38
This guy in pink is a social entrepreneur named Ami Tabar.
145
433000
3000
07:42
What he did was see what was happening in Israel, larger approaches,
146
437000
3000
07:45
and figure out how to do a drip irrigation,
147
440000
3000
07:48
which is a way of bringing water directly to the plant stock.
148
443000
4000
07:53
But previously it's only been created for large-scale farms,
149
448000
3000
07:56
so Ami Tabar took this and modularized it down to an eighth of an acre.
150
451000
5000
08:01
A couple of principles:
151
456000
2000
08:03
build small.
152
458000
2000
08:05
Make it infinitely expandable and affordable to the poor.
153
460000
2000
08:07
This family, Sarita and her husband, bought a 15-dollar unit
154
462000
5000
08:12
when they were living in a -- literally a three-walled lean-to
155
467000
3000
08:15
with a corrugated iron roof.
156
470000
2000
08:18
After one harvest, they had increased their income enough
157
473000
4000
08:22
to buy a second system to do their full quarter-acre.
158
477000
3000
08:25
A couple of years later, I meet them.
159
480000
2000
08:27
They now make four dollars a day, which is pretty much middle class for India,
160
482000
3000
08:30
and they showed me the concrete foundation they had just laid
161
485000
5000
08:35
to build their house.
162
490000
1000
08:36
And I swear, you could see the future in that woman's eyes.
163
491000
3000
08:39
Something I truly believe.
164
494000
2000
08:41
You can't talk about poverty today without talking about malaria bed nets,
165
496000
3000
08:44
and I again give Jeffrey Sachs of Harvard
166
499000
3000
08:47
huge kudos for bringing to the world
167
502000
3000
08:50
this notion of his rage -- for five dollars you can save a life.
168
505000
4000
08:54
Malaria is a disease that kills one to three million people a year.
169
509000
4000
08:58
300 to 500 million cases are reported.
170
513000
2000
09:00
It's estimated that Africa loses
171
515000
2000
09:02
about 13 billion dollars a year to the disease.
172
517000
2000
09:04
Five dollars can save a life.
173
519000
2000
09:06
We can send people to the moon; we can see if there's life on Mars --
174
521000
3000
09:09
why can't we get five-dollar nets to 500 million people?
175
524000
3000
09:13
The question, though, is not "Why can't we?"
176
528000
3000
09:16
The question is how can we help Africans do this for themselves?
177
531000
4000
09:21
A lot of hurdles.
178
536000
1000
09:22
One: production is too low. Two: price is too high.
179
537000
3000
09:25
Three: this is a good road in -- right near where our factory is located.
180
540000
5000
09:30
Distribution is a nightmare, but not impossible.
181
545000
3000
09:33
We started by making a 350,000-dollar loan
182
548000
3000
09:37
to the largest traditional bed net manufacturer in Africa
183
552000
2000
09:39
so that they could transfer technology from Japan
184
554000
5000
09:44
and build these long-lasting, five-year nets.
185
559000
2000
09:46
Here are just some pictures of the factory.
186
561000
2000
09:48
Today, three years later, the company has employed
187
563000
3000
09:51
another thousand women.
188
566000
2000
09:54
It contributes about 600,000 dollars in wages to the economy of Tanzania.
189
569000
5000
09:59
It's the largest company in Tanzania.
190
574000
2000
10:01
The throughput rate right now is 1.5 million nets,
191
576000
3000
10:04
three million by the end of the year.
192
579000
2000
10:06
We hope to have seven million at the end of next year.
193
581000
2000
10:09
So the production side is working.
194
584000
2000
10:11
On the distribution side, though,
195
586000
1000
10:12
as a world, we have a lot of work to do.
196
587000
2000
10:14
Right now, 95 percent of these nets are being bought by the U.N.,
197
589000
4000
10:18
and then given primarily to people around Africa.
198
593000
4000
10:22
We're looking at building
199
597000
2000
10:24
on some of the most precious resources of Africa: people.
200
599000
3000
10:27
Their women.
201
602000
2000
10:29
And so I want you to meet Jacqueline,
202
604000
2000
10:31
my namesake, 21 years old.
203
606000
2000
10:33
If she were born anywhere else but Tanzania,
204
608000
2000
10:35
I'm telling you, she could run Wall Street.
205
610000
2000
10:37
She runs two of the lines, and has already saved enough money
206
612000
4000
10:41
to put a down payment on her house.
207
616000
2000
10:43
She makes about two dollars a day, is creating an education fund,
208
618000
4000
10:47
and told me she is not marrying nor having children
209
622000
3000
10:50
until these things are completed.
210
625000
3000
10:53
And so, when I told her about our idea --
211
628000
2000
10:55
that maybe we could take a Tupperware model from the United States,
212
630000
3000
10:58
and find a way for the women themselves to go out
213
633000
3000
11:01
and sell these nets to others --
214
636000
2000
11:03
she quickly started calculating what she herself could make
215
638000
3000
11:06
and signed up.
216
641000
2000
11:08
We took a lesson from IDEO, one of our favorite companies,
217
643000
5000
11:13
and quickly did a prototyping on this,
218
648000
2000
11:15
and took Jacqueline into the area where she lives.
219
650000
3000
11:18
She brought 10 of the women with whom she interacts
220
653000
4000
11:22
together to see if she could sell these nets, five dollars apiece,
221
657000
2000
11:24
despite the fact that people say nobody will buy one,
222
659000
3000
11:27
and we learned a lot about how you sell things.
223
662000
3000
11:30
Not coming in with our own notions,
224
665000
2000
11:32
because she didn't even talk about malaria until the very end.
225
667000
2000
11:34
First, she talked about comfort, status, beauty.
226
669000
3000
11:37
These nets, she said, you put them on the floor, bugs leave your house.
227
672000
3000
11:40
Children can sleep through the night;
228
675000
2000
11:42
the house looks beautiful; you hang them in the window.
229
677000
2000
11:44
And we've started making curtains,
230
679000
2000
11:46
and not only is it beautiful, but people can see status --
231
681000
4000
11:50
that you care about your children.
232
685000
1000
11:51
Only then did she talk about saving your children's lives.
233
686000
4000
11:56
A lot of lessons to be learned in terms of how we sell
234
691000
3000
11:59
goods and services to the poor.
235
694000
3000
12:03
I want to end just by saying that there's enormous opportunity
236
698000
4000
12:08
to make poverty history.
237
703000
2000
12:10
To do it right, we have to build business models that matter,
238
705000
3000
12:13
that are scaleable and that work with Africans, Indians,
239
708000
4000
12:17
people all over the developing world
240
712000
2000
12:19
who fit in this category, to do it themselves.
241
714000
3000
12:22
Because at the end of the day, it's about engagement.
242
717000
3000
12:25
It's about understanding that people really don't want handouts,
243
720000
3000
12:28
that they want to make their own decisions;
244
723000
2000
12:30
they want to solve their own problems;
245
725000
2000
12:32
and that by engaging with them,
246
727000
2000
12:34
not only do we create much more dignity for them,
247
729000
3000
12:37
but for us as well.
248
732000
2000
12:39
And so I urge all of you to think next time
249
734000
3000
12:42
as to how to engage with this notion and this opportunity
250
737000
4000
12:46
that we all have -- to make poverty history --
251
741000
3000
12:49
by really becoming part of the process
252
744000
2000
12:51
and moving away from an us-and-them world,
253
746000
2000
12:53
and realizing that it's about all of us,
254
748000
2000
12:55
and the kind of world that we, together, want to live in and share.
255
750000
3000
12:58
Thank you.
256
753000
1000
12:59
(Applause)
257
754000
2000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Jacqueline Novogratz - Investor and advocate for moral leadershipJacqueline Novogratz works to enable human flourishing. Her organization, Acumen, invests in people, companies and ideas that see capital and networks as means, not ends, to solving the toughest issues of poverty.
Why you should listen
Jacqueline Novogratz writes: "I want to build a movement in which we define success based on the amount of human energy we release in the world.
"I started my career on Wall Street and soon discovered that markets are efficient, but by themselves they too often overlook or exploit the poor. So I moved to Rwanda in 1986 to help found the country’s first micro-finance bank. There I saw the humanitarian ethos of philanthropy, and also how often top-down solutions too often create dependency, the opposite of dignity. Through 30 years of working on solutions to poverty, I have come to redefine it for myself, seeing it not as how much income a person earns, but how free they are to make their own choices and decisions, how much agency they have over their own lives.
Acumen was founded to change the way the world tackles poverty in 2001. Our mission was simple – to raise philanthropy and invest it as patient capital – long-term investment in intrepid entrepreneurs willing to go where markets and government had failed the poor. We enable companies to experiment and fail, never wavering from a commitment to stand with the poor, yet understanding that profitability is necessary for sustainable solutions. We’ve invested more than $110M across South Asia, Africa, Latin America and the US, and have seen entire sectors disrupted and hundreds of millions served.
The work also taught that it was critical to invest in talent. To date, we’ve supported nearly 400 Acumen Fellows across lines of race, class, ethnicity, religion and ideology. They are a beautiful group, full of vision and grit, and a determination to do what is right, not easy. The group itself enables individual leaders to endure the loneliness that is part of the work.
And then we measure what matters rather than just what we can count. Take this all together and you see our mission to do what it takes to build a world in which all of us have the chance to dream and to flourish, not from a place of easy sentimentality but through a commitment to using the tools of capitalism and the attributes of moral leadership to focus on doing what it takes, and no less.
Jacqueline Novogratz | Speaker | TED.com