TEDGlobal 2007
Zeresenay Alemseged: The search for humanity's roots
Filmed:
Readability: 4
1,114,952 views
Paleoanthropologist Zeresenay Alemseged looks for the roots of humanity in Ethiopia's badlands. Here he talks about finding the oldest skeleton of a humanoid child -- and how Africa holds the clues to our humanity.
Zeresenay Alemseged - Paleoanthropologist
Zeresenay "Zeray" Alemseged digs in the Ethiopian desert, looking for the earliest signs of humanity. His most exciting find: the 3.3-million-year-old bones of Selam, a 3-year-old hominid child, from the species Australopithecus afarensis. Full bio
Zeresenay "Zeray" Alemseged digs in the Ethiopian desert, looking for the earliest signs of humanity. His most exciting find: the 3.3-million-year-old bones of Selam, a 3-year-old hominid child, from the species Australopithecus afarensis. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:25
I have 18 minutes to tell you what happened
0
0
2000
00:27
over the past six million years.
1
2000
3000
00:30
All right.
2
5000
2000
00:32
We all have come from a long way,
3
7000
3000
00:35
here in Africa, and converged in this region of Africa,
4
10000
3000
00:38
which is a place where 90 percent of our evolutionary process took place.
5
13000
6000
00:44
And I say that not because I am African,
6
19000
3000
00:47
but it's in Africa that you find the earliest evidence
7
22000
3000
00:50
for human ancestors, upright walking traces,
8
25000
5000
00:55
even the first technologies in the form of stone tools.
9
30000
3000
00:58
So we all are Africans, and welcome home.
10
33000
3000
01:01
All right.
11
36000
2000
01:03
I'm a paleoanthropologist, and my job is to define
12
38000
3000
01:06
man's place in nature and explore what makes us human.
13
41000
4000
01:10
And today, I will use Selam, the earliest child ever discovered,
14
45000
4000
01:14
to tell you a story of all of us.
15
49000
2000
01:16
Selam is our most complete skeleton of a three-year-old girl
16
51000
4000
01:20
who lived and died 3.3 million years ago.
17
55000
4000
01:24
She belongs to the species known as Australopithecus afarensis.
18
59000
4000
01:28
You don't need to remember that.
19
63000
2000
01:30
That's the Lucy species, and was found by my research team
20
65000
4000
01:34
in December of 2000 in an area called Dikika.
21
69000
3000
01:37
It's in the northeastern part of Ethiopia.
22
72000
2000
01:39
And Selam means peace in many Ethiopian languages.
23
74000
3000
01:42
We use that name to celebrate peace in the region and in the planet.
24
77000
6000
01:48
And the fact that it was the cover story of all these famous magazines
25
83000
4000
01:52
gives you already an idea of her significance, I think.
26
87000
3000
01:55
After I was invited by TED, I did some digging,
27
90000
3000
01:58
because that's what we do, to know about my host.
28
93000
3000
02:01
You don't just jump into an invitation.
29
96000
2000
02:03
And I learned that the first technology appeared
30
98000
2000
02:05
in the form of stone tools, 2.6 million years ago.
31
100000
3000
02:08
First entertainment comes evidence from flutes that are 35,000 years old.
32
103000
5000
02:13
And evidence for first design comes 75,000 years old -- beads.
33
108000
6000
02:19
And you can do the same with your genes and track them back in time.
34
114000
5000
02:24
And DNA analysis of living humans and chimpanzees
35
119000
4000
02:28
teaches us today that we diverged sometime around seven million years ago
36
123000
4000
02:32
and that these two species share over 98 percent of the same genetic material.
37
127000
6000
02:38
I think knowing this is a very useful context
38
133000
2000
02:40
within which we can think of our ancestry.
39
135000
4000
02:44
However, DNA analysis informs us only about
40
139000
4000
02:48
the beginning and the end, telling us nothing
41
143000
4000
02:52
about what happened in the middle.
42
147000
2000
02:54
So, for us, paleoanthropologists, our job is to find the hard evidence,
43
149000
5000
02:59
the fossil evidence, to fill in this gap
44
154000
3000
03:02
and see the different stages of development.
45
157000
3000
03:05
Because it's only when you do that, that you can talk about --
46
160000
3000
03:08
(Laughter) --
47
163000
4000
03:12
it's only when you do that, [that] you can talk about
48
167000
3000
03:15
how we looked like and how we behaved at different times,
49
170000
4000
03:19
and how those likes and looks and behaviors changed through time.
50
174000
5000
03:24
That then gives you an access
51
179000
2000
03:26
to explore the biological mechanisms
52
181000
3000
03:29
and forces that are responsible for this gradual change
53
184000
3000
03:32
that made us what we are today.
54
187000
3000
03:35
But finding the hard evidence is a very complicated endeavor.
55
190000
4000
03:39
It's a systematic and scientific approach,
56
194000
3000
03:42
which takes you to places that are remote, hot, hostile and often with no access.
57
197000
6000
03:48
Just to give you an example, when I went to Dikika,
58
203000
2000
03:50
where Selam was found, in '99 -- and it's about 500 kilometers
59
205000
4000
03:54
from Addis Ababa, the capital of Ethiopia.
60
209000
4000
03:58
It took us only seven hours to do the first 470 kilometers of the 500,
61
213000
7000
04:05
but took four, solid hours to do the last only 30 kilometers.
62
220000
5000
04:10
With the help of the locals and using just shovels and picks, I made my way.
63
225000
4000
04:14
I was the first person to actually drive a car to the spot.
64
229000
4000
04:18
When you get there, this is what you see,
65
233000
3000
04:21
and it's the vastness of the place which makes you feel helpless and vulnerable.
66
236000
5000
04:26
And once you make it there, the big question is where to start.
67
241000
4000
04:30
(Laughter)
68
245000
2000
04:32
And you find nothing for years and years.
69
247000
3000
04:35
When I go to places like this, which are paleontological sites,
70
250000
4000
04:39
it's like going to a game park, an extinct game park.
71
254000
4000
04:43
But what you find are not the human remains,
72
258000
3000
04:46
such as Selam and Lucy, on a day-to-day basis.
73
261000
3000
04:49
You find elephants, rhinos, monkeys, pigs, etc.
74
264000
4000
04:53
But you could ask, how could these large mammals
75
268000
2000
04:55
live in this desert environment?
76
270000
2000
04:57
Of course, they cannot, but I'm telling you already
77
272000
2000
04:59
that the environment and the carrying capacity
78
274000
3000
05:02
of this region was drastically different from what we have today.
79
277000
5000
05:07
A very important environmental lesson could be learned from this.
80
282000
4000
05:11
Anyway, once we made it there, then it's a game park, as I said, an extinct game park.
81
286000
6000
05:17
And our ancestors lived in that game park,
82
292000
3000
05:20
but were just the minorities. They were not as successful
83
295000
2000
05:22
and as widespread as the Homo sapiens that we are.
84
297000
5000
05:27
To tell you just an example, an anecdote about their rarity,
85
302000
3000
05:30
I was going to this place every year and would do fieldwork here,
86
305000
5000
05:35
and the assistants, of course, helped me do the surveys.
87
310000
3000
05:38
They would find a bone and tell me, "Here is what you're looking for."
88
313000
2000
05:40
I would say, "No, that's an elephant."
89
315000
1000
05:41
Again, another one, "That's a monkey." "That's a pig," etc.
90
316000
3000
05:44
So one of my assistants, who never went to school, said to me, "Listen, Zeray.
91
319000
3000
05:47
You either don't know what you're looking for,
92
322000
2000
05:49
or you're looking in the wrong place," he said.
93
324000
3000
05:52
(Laughter)
94
327000
1000
05:53
And I said, "Why?" "Because there were elephants and lions,
95
328000
3000
05:56
and the people were scared and went somewhere else.
96
331000
2000
05:58
Let's go somewhere else."
97
333000
2000
06:00
Well, he was very tired, and it's really tiring.
98
335000
2000
06:02
It was then, after such hard work and many frustrating years that we found Selam,
99
337000
5000
06:07
and you see the face here covered by sandstone.
100
342000
3000
06:10
And here is actually the spinal column
101
345000
2000
06:12
and the whole torso encased in a sandstone block,
102
347000
4000
06:16
because she was buried by a river.
103
351000
3000
06:19
What you have here seems to be nothing,
104
354000
2000
06:21
but contains an incredible amount of scientific information
105
356000
4000
06:25
that helps us explore what makes us human.
106
360000
3000
06:28
This is the earliest and most complete juvenile human ancestor
107
363000
4000
06:32
ever found in the history of paleoanthropology,
108
367000
2000
06:34
an amazing piece of our long, long history.
109
369000
4000
06:38
There were these three people and me, and I am taking the pictures,
110
373000
3000
06:41
that's why I am not in.
111
376000
2000
06:43
How would you feel if you were me? You have something extraordinary in your hand,
112
378000
3000
06:46
but you are in the middle of nowhere?
113
381000
2000
06:48
The feeling I had was a deep and quiet happiness and excitement,
114
383000
5000
06:53
of course accompanied by a huge sense of responsibility,
115
388000
3000
06:56
of making sure everything is safe.
116
391000
3000
06:59
Here is a close-up of the fossil, after five years of cleaning,
117
394000
5000
07:04
preparation and description, which was very long,
118
399000
4000
07:08
as I had to expose the bones from the sandstone block
119
403000
3000
07:11
I just showed you in the previous slide.
120
406000
2000
07:13
It took five years.
121
408000
1000
07:14
In a way, this was like the second birth for the child, after 3.3 million years,
122
409000
5000
07:19
but the labor was very long.
123
414000
3000
07:22
And here is full scale -- it's a tiny bone.
124
417000
4000
07:26
And in the middle is the minister of Ethiopian tourism,
125
421000
3000
07:29
who came to visit the National Museum of Ethiopia while I was working there.
126
424000
4000
07:33
And you see me worried and trying to protect my child,
127
428000
3000
07:36
because you don't leave anyone with this kind of child,
128
431000
3000
07:39
even a minister.
129
434000
3000
07:42
So then, once you've done that, the next stage is to know what it is.
130
437000
4000
07:46
(Laughter)
131
441000
3000
07:49
Once that was done, then it was possible to compare.
132
444000
4000
07:53
We were able to tell that she belonged
133
448000
2000
07:55
to the human family tree because the legs, the foot,
134
450000
4000
07:59
and some features clearly showed that she walked upright,
135
454000
4000
08:03
and upright walking is a hallmark in humanity.
136
458000
3000
08:06
But in addition, if you compare the skull
137
461000
3000
08:09
with a comparably aged chimpanzee and little George Bush here,
138
464000
3000
08:12
you see that you have vertical forehead.
139
467000
4000
08:16
And you see that in humans, because of the development
140
471000
3000
08:19
of the pre-frontal cortex, it's called.
141
474000
2000
08:21
You don't see that in chimpanzees,
142
476000
3000
08:24
and you don't see this very projecting canine.
143
479000
4000
08:28
So she belongs to our family tree, but within that, of course,
144
483000
3000
08:31
you do detailed analysis, and we know now
145
486000
2000
08:33
that she belongs to the Lucy species,
146
488000
2000
08:35
known as Australopithecus afarensis.
147
490000
3000
08:38
The next exciting question is, girl or boy?
148
493000
3000
08:41
And how old was she when she died?
149
496000
2000
08:43
You can determine the sex of the individual
150
498000
3000
08:46
based on the size of the teeth.
151
501000
3000
08:49
How?
152
504000
1000
08:50
You know, in primates, there is this phenomenon
153
505000
2000
08:52
called sexual dimorphism, which simply means
154
507000
2000
08:54
males are larger than females and males have larger teeth
155
509000
2000
08:56
than the females.
156
511000
2000
08:58
But to do that, you need the permanent dentition,
157
513000
2000
09:00
which you don't see here, because what you have here
158
515000
2000
09:02
are the baby teeth.
159
517000
2000
09:04
But using the CT scanning technology,
160
519000
2000
09:06
which is normally used for medical purposes,
161
521000
2000
09:08
you can go deep into the mouth and come up with this beautiful image
162
523000
3000
09:11
showing you both the baby teeth here
163
526000
2000
09:13
and the still-growing adult teeth here.
164
528000
4000
09:17
So when you measure those teeth,
165
532000
2000
09:19
it was clear that she turned out to be a girl
166
534000
3000
09:22
with very small canine teeth.
167
537000
3000
09:25
And to know how old she was when she died, what you do is
168
540000
2000
09:27
you do an informed estimate, and you say, how much time would be required
169
542000
6000
09:33
to form this amount of teeth, and the answer was three.
170
548000
5000
09:38
So, this girl died when she was about three,
171
553000
3000
09:41
3.3 million years ago.
172
556000
2000
09:43
So, with all that information, the big question is --
173
558000
3000
09:46
what do we actually -- what does she tell us?
174
561000
4000
09:50
To answer this question, we can phrase another question.
175
565000
2000
09:52
What do we actually know about our ancestors?
176
567000
3000
09:55
We want to know how they looked like, how they behaved,
177
570000
2000
09:57
how they walked around,
178
572000
2000
09:59
and how they lived and grew up.
179
574000
3000
10:02
And among the answers that you can get from this skeleton
180
577000
5000
10:07
are included: first, this skeleton documents,
181
582000
5000
10:12
for the first time, how infants looked over three million years ago.
182
587000
5000
10:17
And second, she tells us that she walked upright,
183
592000
3000
10:20
but had some adaptation for tree climbing.
184
595000
3000
10:23
And more interesting, however,
185
598000
2000
10:25
is the brain in this child was still growing.
186
600000
2000
10:27
At age three, if you have a still-growing brain,
187
602000
3000
10:30
it's a human behavior.
188
605000
2000
10:32
In chimps, by age three, the brain is formed over 90 percent.
189
607000
5000
10:37
That's why they can cope with their environment
190
612000
3000
10:40
very easily after birth -- faster than us, anyway.
191
615000
3000
10:43
But in humans, we continue to grow our brains.
192
618000
2000
10:45
That's why we need care from our parents.
193
620000
3000
10:48
But that care means also you learn.
194
623000
2000
10:50
You spend more time with your parents.
195
625000
2000
10:52
And that's very characteristic of humans and it's called childhood,
196
627000
3000
10:55
which is this extended dependence of human children
197
630000
3000
10:58
on their family or parents.
198
633000
3000
11:01
So, the still-growing brain in this individual
199
636000
4000
11:05
tells us that childhood, which requires
200
640000
3000
11:08
an incredible social organization,
201
643000
3000
11:11
a very complex social organization,
202
646000
2000
11:13
emerged over three million years ago.
203
648000
2000
11:15
So, by being at the cusp of our evolutionary history,
204
650000
4000
11:19
Selam unites us all and gives us a unique account
205
654000
5000
11:24
on what makes us human.
206
659000
3000
11:27
But not everything was human, and I will give you
207
662000
3000
11:30
a very exciting example.
208
665000
2000
11:32
This is called the hyoid bone. It's a bone which is right here.
209
667000
2000
11:34
It supports your tongue from behind.
210
669000
2000
11:36
It's, in a way, your voice box.
211
671000
3000
11:39
It determines the type of voice you produce.
212
674000
4000
11:43
It was not known in the fossil record,
213
678000
2000
11:45
and we have it in this skeleton.
214
680000
3000
11:48
When we did the analysis of this bone, it was clear
215
683000
4000
11:52
that it looked very chimp-like, chimpanzee-like.
216
687000
4000
11:56
So if you were there 3.3 million years ago,
217
691000
4000
12:00
to hear when this girl was crying out for her mother,
218
695000
3000
12:03
she would have sounded more like a chimpanzee than a human.
219
698000
3000
12:06
Maybe you're wondering, "So, you see this ape feature, human feature, ape feature.
220
701000
4000
12:10
What does that tell us?"
221
705000
2000
12:12
You know, that is very exciting for us,
222
707000
2000
12:14
because it demonstrates that things were changing slowly and progressively,
223
709000
3000
12:17
and that evolution is in the making.
224
712000
3000
12:20
To summarize the significance of this fossil,
225
715000
3000
12:23
we can say the following.
226
718000
2000
12:25
Up to now, the knowledge that we had about our ancestors
227
720000
4000
12:29
came essentially from adult individuals
228
724000
4000
12:33
because the fossils, the baby fossils, were missing.
229
728000
3000
12:36
They don't preserve well, as you know.
230
731000
2000
12:38
So the knowledge that we had about our ancestors,
231
733000
4000
12:42
on how they looked like, how they behaved,
232
737000
2000
12:44
was kind of biased toward adults.
233
739000
5000
12:49
Imagine somebody coming from Mars
234
744000
3000
12:52
and his job is to report on the type of people
235
747000
2000
12:54
occupying our planet Earth, and you hide all the babies,
236
749000
3000
12:57
the children, and he goes back and reports.
237
752000
4000
13:01
Can you imagine how much biased his report would be?
238
756000
4000
13:05
That's what somehow we were doing so far
239
760000
2000
13:07
in the absence of the fossil children,
240
762000
2000
13:09
so I think the new fossil fixes this problem.
241
764000
5000
13:14
So, I think the most important question at the end is,
242
769000
5000
13:19
what do we actually learn from specimens like this
243
774000
3000
13:22
and from our past in general?
244
777000
3000
13:25
Of course, in addition to extracting this huge amount
245
780000
3000
13:28
of scientific information as to what makes us human,
246
783000
3000
13:31
you know, the many human ancestors that have existed
247
786000
3000
13:34
over the past six million years -- and there are more than 10 --
248
789000
4000
13:38
they did not have the knowledge, the technology and sophistications
249
793000
3000
13:41
that we, Homo sapiens, have today.
250
796000
2000
13:43
But if this species, ancient species,
251
798000
4000
13:47
would travel in time and see us today,
252
802000
3000
13:50
they would very much be very proud of their legacy,
253
805000
5000
13:55
because they became the ancestors of
254
810000
2000
13:57
the most successful species in the universe.
255
812000
2000
13:59
And they were probably not aware of this future legacy,
256
814000
2000
14:01
but they did great.
257
816000
2000
14:03
Now the question is, we Homo sapiens today
258
818000
3000
14:06
are in a position to decide about the future of our planet, possibly more.
259
821000
6000
14:12
So the question is, are we up to the challenge?
260
827000
3000
14:15
And can we really do better than these primitive,
261
830000
3000
14:18
small-brained ancestors?
262
833000
3000
14:21
Among the most pressing challenges that our species
263
836000
4000
14:25
is faced with today are the chronic problems of Africa.
264
840000
5000
14:30
Needless to list them here, and there are more competent people
265
845000
3000
14:33
to talk about this.
266
848000
3000
14:36
Still, in my opinion, we have two choices.
267
851000
3000
14:42
One is to continue to see a poor, ill, crying Africa,
268
857000
6000
14:48
carrying guns, that depends on other people forever,
269
863000
5000
14:53
or to promote an Africa which is confident,
270
868000
5000
14:58
peaceful, independent, but cognizant of its huge problems
271
873000
4000
15:02
and great values at the same time.
272
877000
4000
15:06
I am for the second option, and I'm sure many of you are.
273
881000
5000
15:11
And the key is to promote a positive African attitude towards Africa.
274
886000
10000
15:21
That's because we Africans concentrate --
275
896000
4000
15:25
I am from Ethiopia, by the way --
276
900000
2000
15:27
we concentrate too much on how we are seen
277
902000
2000
15:29
from elsewhere, or from outside.
278
904000
3000
15:32
I think it's important to promote in a more positive way
279
907000
5000
15:37
on how we see ourselves.
280
912000
3000
15:40
That's what I call positive African attitude.
281
915000
3000
15:43
So finally, I would like to say,
282
918000
3000
15:46
so let's help Africa walk upright and forward,
283
921000
5000
15:51
then we all can be proud of our future legacy as a species.
284
926000
5000
15:56
Thank you.
285
931000
2000
15:58
(Applause)
286
933000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Zeresenay Alemseged - PaleoanthropologistZeresenay "Zeray" Alemseged digs in the Ethiopian desert, looking for the earliest signs of humanity. His most exciting find: the 3.3-million-year-old bones of Selam, a 3-year-old hominid child, from the species Australopithecus afarensis.
Why you should listen
Paleoanthropologist Zeresenay Alemseged studies the origins of humanity. Through his Dikika Research Project (DRP) in the Afar desert of Ethiopia, he has discovered the earliest known skeleton of a hominid child, the 3.3-million-year-old bones of Selam, a 3-year-old girl of the species Australopithecus afarensis. She is a member of the same species as Lucy, discovered nearby in 1974.
In studying Selam's tiny bones, Alemseged is searching for the points at which we humans diverged from apes. For instance, Selam may have had ape-like shoulders, made for climbing trees -- but her legs were angled for walking upright. Her young brain, at age 3, was still growing, which implies that she was set to have a long human-style childhood. And in the hyoid bone of her throat, Alemseged sees the beginning of human speech.
Born in Axum, Ethiopia, Alemseged is based in San Francisco at the California Academy of Sciences where is is the Director and Curator of the Anthropology department. Prior to this, he was a senior researcher at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig. To see more video from Alemseged, visit the video archives of Nature.
Zeresenay Alemseged | Speaker | TED.com