Alex Edmans: What to trust in a "post-truth" world
Alex Edmans uses rigorous academic research to influence real-life business practices -- in particular, how companies can pursue purpose as well as profit. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
and she loved skateboarding.
brain cancer and four months to live.
and radiotherapy had no effect.
for her brother, who had autism,
who had multiple sclerosis.
with meditation
for fruit and vegetables.
shared and reached millions of people.
traditional medicine
a healthy eating app,
in the first month.
without ever checking if it was true.
of confirmation bias.
if it confirms what we'd like to be true.
that contradicts it.
that we share and we ignore?
in health advice.
word of 2016 was "post-truth."
in a post-truth world
on checking the facts.
the facts is not enough.
fundamental techniques in statistics.
support the theory?"
that the theory is true?
"Is the data consistent with the theory?"
supports the theory.
but forgotten third term --
with rival theories.
we never consider the rival theories,
of our own pet theory.
Does Belle's story support the theory
with diet curing cancer?"
we'd see stories like Belle's.
a patient apparently self-cured
in the first place.
was bad for your health,
who lived until 100.
was good for your income,
who didn't go to university.
is not that it was false.
where diet alone failed,
because they are new,
they're what normally happens.
99 percent that we ignore.
listen to the one percent,
of confirmation bias.
that we live in a post-truth world;
they're vivid, they bring it to life.
every talk with a story.
is meaningless and misleading
with rival theories.
by psychologist Peter Wason
that generated them.
it's successive even numbers.
of successive even numbers:
of successive even numbers also work,
with rival theories.
is any three even numbers.
of confirmation bias:
with rival theories.
one theory and rules out others.
to play devil's advocate.
that would disprove your theory
"any three even numbers"
but not rule out yours.
of testing the 4, 12, 26,
and prove their pet theory to be wrong.
about failing to search for new data,
data once you receive it.
to important, real-world problems.
admissions director
students with good grades
with the rival theory.
with good grades do well,
because you never let in poor students
because it may not be true.
if it's only one data point.
if it's consistent with rival theories.
the inflection points of life,
that you don't have a story
other viewpoints.
you flagrantly disagree with.
may be wrong, in your view.
who challenge you,
that actively encourages dissent.
management's lending decisions,
to be devil's advocate
is something to learn from
forgotten terms in Bayesian inference.
to a starting point.
that your pet theory must be true,
to the possibility of being wrong
slow-witted man
any idea of them already.
to the most intelligent man
that he knows already."
unpopular advice that I could give you.
famously said that people in this country
would trust their hairdresser --
the health service and even charities.
discovered by a mom,
on vaccination.
who go with their gut,
water to a baby with diarrhea,
flow out the other end.
to the man on the street.
who spent years doing surgery
to every major decision.
is they're seen as out of touch.
speak for the man on the street.
for the man on the street
from imposing their own view
why experts are not trusted
say different things.
the EU would be bad for Britain,
will be wrong.
written by experts are wrong.
the evidence doesn't actually support.
an expert's word for it.
on executive pay hit national headlines.
who covered the study
just handpick any study
that if seven studies show A
the credentials of the authors.
the credentials of a potential surgeon.
in the top academic journals.
of being detached from the real world.
years to spend on a study.
from causation.
the higher the standard.
reject 95 percent of papers.
mistakes are made.
with something checked
because we like the findings,
or whether it's even been vetted,
that that study is misleading.
of our analysis.
or predict something with certainty,
a sweeping, unqualified statement.
or to be tweeted in 140 characters.
it may not apply in every setting.
causes longer life,"
is correlated with longer life.
who exercise as well.
is "pause before sharing anything."
"First, do no harm."
to get likes or retweets.
we don't challenge anyone's thinking.
by large-scale evidence?
what are their credentials?
how rigorous is the journal?
the million-dollar question:
authors with the same credentials
to believe it and to share it?
or an individual's health problem,
the very best evidence to guide us.
can it be data.
can it be evidence.
can we move from a post-truth world
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alex Edmans - Finance professor, editorAlex Edmans uses rigorous academic research to influence real-life business practices -- in particular, how companies can pursue purpose as well as profit.
Why you should listen
Alex Edmans is professor of finance at London Business School and managing editor of the Review of Finance, the leading academic finance journal in Europe. He is an expert in corporate governance, executive compensation, corporate social responsibility and behavioral economics.
Edmans has a unique combination of deep academic rigor and practical business experience. He's particularly passionate about translating complex academic research into practical ideas that can then be applied to real-life problems. He has spoken at the World Economic Forum in Davos, at the World Bank Distinguished Speaker Series and in the UK House of Commons. Edmans is heavily involved in the ongoing reform of corporate governance, in particular to ensure that both the diagnosis of problems and suggested solutions are based on rigorous evidence rather than anecdote. He was appointed by the UK government to study the effect of share buybacks on executive pay and investment. Edmans also serves on the Steering Group of The Purposeful Company, which aims to embed purpose into the heart of business, and on Royal London Asset Management's Responsible Investment Advisory Committee.
Edmans has been interviewed by Bloomberg, BBC, CNBC, CNN, ESPN, Fox, ITV, NPR, Reuters, Sky News and Sky Sports, and has written for the Wall Street Journal, Financial Times and Harvard Business Review. He runs a blog, Access to Finance, that makes academic research accessible to a general audience, and was appointed Mercers' School Memorial Professor of Business by Gresham College, to give free lectures to the public. Edmans was previously a tenured professor at Wharton, where he won 14 teaching awards in six years. At LBS, he won the Excellence in Teaching award, LBS's highest teaching accolade.
Alex Edmans | Speaker | TED.com