Taste3 2008
Dennis vanEngelsdorp: A plea for bees
Filmed:
Readability: 3.4
752,294 views
Bees are dying in droves. Why? Leading apiarist Dennis vanEngelsdorp looks at the gentle, misunderstood creature's important place in nature and the mystery behind its alarming disappearance.
Dennis vanEngelsdorp - Bee expert
Dennis vanEngelsdorp is Acting State Apiarist for Pennsylvania's Department of Agriculture, studying colony collapse disorder -- the alarming, worldwide disappearance of worker bees and Western honey bees. Full bio
Dennis vanEngelsdorp is Acting State Apiarist for Pennsylvania's Department of Agriculture, studying colony collapse disorder -- the alarming, worldwide disappearance of worker bees and Western honey bees. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
What I'd like you to do is, just really quickly,
0
0
2000
00:18
is just, sort of, nod to the person on your right,
1
2000
3000
00:21
and then nod to the person on your left.
2
5000
3000
00:24
(Laughter)
3
8000
4000
00:28
Now, chances are that over the last winter,
4
12000
4000
00:32
if you had been a beehive, either you or one of the two people
5
16000
3000
00:35
you just nodded at would have died.
6
19000
4000
00:39
Now, that's an awful lot of bees.
7
23000
4000
00:43
And this is the second year in a row we have lost over 30 percent
8
27000
4000
00:47
of the colonies, or we estimate we've lost 30 percent of the colonies over the winter.
9
31000
4000
00:51
Now, that's a lot, a lot of bees, and that's really important.
10
35000
6000
00:57
And most of those losses are because of things we know.
11
41000
3000
01:00
We know that there are these varroa mites that have introduced
12
44000
3000
01:03
and caused a lot of losses, and we also have this new phenomenon,
13
47000
3000
01:06
which I talked about last year, Colony Collapse Disorder.
14
50000
3000
01:09
And here we see a picture on top of a hill in Central Valley last December.
15
53000
5000
01:14
And below, you can see all these out yards,
16
58000
2000
01:16
or temporary yards, where the colonies are brought in until February,
17
60000
5000
01:21
and then they're shipped out to the almonds.
18
65000
3000
01:24
And one documentary writer, who was here and looked at this two months
19
68000
3000
01:27
after I was here, described this not as beehives
20
71000
3000
01:30
but as a graveyard, with these empty white boxes with no bees left in them.
21
74000
6000
01:36
Now, I'm going to sum up a year's worth of work in two sentences
22
80000
4000
01:40
to say that we have been trying to figure out
23
84000
2000
01:42
what the cause of this is.
24
86000
2000
01:44
And what we know is that it's as if the bees have caught a flu.
25
88000
3000
01:47
And this flu has wiped through the population of bees.
26
91000
5000
01:52
In some cases, and in fact in most cases in one year,
27
96000
4000
01:56
this flu was caused by a new virus to us,
28
100000
3000
01:59
or newly identified by us, called Israeli Acute Paralysis virus.
29
103000
4000
02:03
It was called that because a guy in Israel first found it,
30
107000
2000
02:05
and he now regrets profoundly calling it that disease, because,
31
109000
4000
02:09
of course, there's the implication.
32
113000
1000
02:10
But we think this virus is pretty ubiquitous.
33
114000
3000
02:13
It's also pretty clear that the bees sometimes catch other viruses
34
117000
3000
02:16
or other flus, and so the question we're still struggling with,
35
120000
4000
02:20
and the question that keeps us up at night,
36
124000
2000
02:22
is why have the bees suddenly become so susceptible to this flu,
37
126000
5000
02:27
and why are they so susceptible to these other diseases?
38
131000
5000
02:32
And we don't have the answer to that yet,
39
136000
2000
02:34
and we spend a lot of time trying to figure that out.
40
138000
3000
02:37
We think perhaps it's a combination of factors.
41
141000
2000
02:39
We know from the work of a very large and dynamic working team
42
143000
4000
02:43
that, you know, we're finding a lot of different pesticides
43
147000
4000
02:47
in the hive, and surprisingly, sometimes the healthiest hives
44
151000
3000
02:50
have the most pesticides. And so we discover all these
45
154000
3000
02:53
very strange things that we can't begin to understand.
46
157000
4000
02:57
And so this opens up the whole idea of looking at colony health.
47
161000
5000
03:02
Now of course, if you lose a lot of colonies,
48
166000
3000
03:05
beekeepers can replace them very quickly.
49
169000
2000
03:07
And that's why we've been able to recover from a lot of loss.
50
171000
3000
03:10
If we lost one in every three cows in the winter, you know,
51
174000
4000
03:14
the National Guard would be out.
52
178000
1000
03:15
But what beekeepers can do is, if they have one surviving colony,
53
179000
4000
03:19
they can split that colony in two.
54
183000
3000
03:22
And then the one half that doesn't have a queen, they can buy a queen.
55
186000
3000
03:25
It comes in the mail; it can come from Australia or Hawaii or Florida,
56
189000
4000
03:29
and you can introduce that queen.
57
193000
2000
03:31
And in fact, America was the first country
58
195000
2000
03:33
that ever did mail-delivery queens and in fact,
59
197000
3000
03:36
it's part of the postal code that you have to deliver queens by mail
60
200000
7000
03:43
in order to make sure that we have enough bees in this country.
61
207000
5000
03:48
If you don't just want a queen, you can buy, actually,
62
212000
2000
03:50
a three-pound package of bees, which comes in the mail, and of course,
63
214000
4000
03:54
the Postal Office is always very concerned when they get,
64
218000
3000
03:57
you know, your three-pound packages of bees.
65
221000
2000
03:59
And you can install this in your hive and replace that dead-out.
66
223000
4000
04:03
So it means that beekeepers are very good at replacing dead-outs,
67
227000
4000
04:07
and so they've been able to cover those losses.
68
231000
3000
04:10
So even though we've lost 30 percent of the colonies every year,
69
234000
3000
04:13
the same number of colonies have existed in the country,
70
237000
4000
04:17
at about 2.4 million colonies.
71
241000
3000
04:20
Now, those losses are tragic on many fronts,
72
244000
4000
04:24
and one of those fronts is for the beekeeper.
73
248000
2000
04:26
And it's really important to talk about beekeepers first,
74
250000
3000
04:29
because beekeepers are among the most fascinating people you'll ever meet.
75
253000
3000
04:32
If this was a group of beekeepers, you would have everyone
76
256000
3000
04:35
from the card-carrying NRA member who's, you know, live free or die,
77
259000
5000
04:40
to the, you know, the self-expressed quirky San Francisco
78
264000
3000
04:43
backyard pig farmer.
79
267000
2000
04:45
(Laughter)
80
269000
2000
04:47
And you get all of these people in the same room,
81
271000
3000
04:50
and they're all engaged and they're getting along,
82
274000
4000
04:54
and they're all there because of the passion for bees.
83
278000
3000
04:57
Now, there's another part of that community
84
281000
2000
04:59
which are the commercial beekeepers,
85
283000
1000
05:00
the ones who make their livelihood from beekeeping alone.
86
284000
3000
05:03
And these tend to be some of the most independent, tenacious,
87
287000
8000
05:11
intuitive, you know, inventive people you will ever meet.
88
295000
4000
05:15
They're just fascinating. And they're like that all over the world.
89
299000
3000
05:18
I had the privilege of working in Haiti just for two weeks earlier this year.
90
302000
4000
05:22
And Haiti, if you've ever been there, is just a tragedy.
91
306000
3000
05:25
I mean, there may be 100 explanations
92
309000
2000
05:27
for why Haiti is the impoverished nation it is,
93
311000
3000
05:30
but there is no excuse to see that sort of squalor.
94
314000
3000
05:33
But you meet this beekeeper, and I met this beekeeper here,
95
317000
3000
05:36
and he is one of the most knowledgeable beekeepers I've ever met.
96
320000
2000
05:38
No formal education, but very knowledgeable.
97
322000
2000
05:40
We needed beeswax for a project we were working on; he was so capable,
98
324000
5000
05:45
he was able to render the nicest block of beeswax I have ever seen
99
329000
4000
05:49
from cow dung, tin cans and his veil, which he used as a screening,
100
333000
5000
05:54
right in this meadow. And so that ingenuity is inspiring.
101
338000
4000
05:58
We also have Dave Hackenberg, who is the poster child of CCD.
102
342000
3000
06:01
He's the one who first identified this condition
103
345000
2000
06:03
and raised the alarm bells.
104
347000
2000
06:05
And he has a history of these trucks,
105
349000
2000
06:07
and he's moved these bees up and down the coast.
106
351000
3000
06:10
And a lot of people talk about trucks and moving bees,
107
354000
3000
06:13
and that being bad, but we've done that for thousands of years.
108
357000
3000
06:16
The ancient Egyptians used to move bees up and down the Nile on rafts,
109
360000
3000
06:19
so this idea of a movable bee force is not new at all.
110
363000
6000
06:25
And one of our real worries with Colony Collapse Disorder
111
369000
4000
06:29
is the fact that it costs so much money to replace those dead-out colonies.
112
373000
4000
06:33
And you can do that one year in a row,
113
377000
3000
06:36
you may be able to do it two years in a row.
114
380000
2000
06:38
But if you're losing 50 percent to 80 percent of your colonies,
115
382000
4000
06:42
you can't survive three years in a row. And we're really worried
116
386000
3000
06:45
about losing this segment of our industry.
117
389000
4000
06:49
And that's important for many fronts,
118
393000
2000
06:51
and one of them is because of that culture that's in agriculture.
119
395000
4000
06:55
And these migratory beekeepers are the last nomads of America.
120
399000
5000
07:00
You know, they pick up their hives;
121
404000
1000
07:01
they move their families once or twice in a year.
122
405000
3000
07:04
And if you look at Florida, in Dade City, Florida,
123
408000
3000
07:07
that's where all the Pennsylvania beekeepers go.
124
411000
2000
07:09
And then 20 miles down the road is Groveland,
125
413000
2000
07:11
and that's where all the Wisconsin beekeepers go.
126
415000
2000
07:13
And if you're ever in Central Valley in February, you go to this café
127
417000
5000
07:18
at 10 o'clock in the morning, Kathy and Kate's.
128
422000
3000
07:21
And that's where all the beekeepers come after a night of moving bees
129
425000
3000
07:24
into the almond groves.
130
428000
1000
07:25
They all have their breakfast
131
429000
1000
07:26
and complain about everyone right there. And it's a great experience,
132
430000
5000
07:31
and I really encourage you to drop in at that diner during that time,
133
435000
3000
07:34
because that's quite essential American experience.
134
438000
3000
07:37
And we see these families, these nomadic families, you know,
135
441000
4000
07:41
father to son, father to son, and these guys are hurting.
136
445000
4000
07:45
And they're not people who like to ask for help,
137
449000
3000
07:48
although they are the most helpful people ever.
138
452000
2000
07:50
If there's one guy who loses all his bees because of a truck overhaul,
139
454000
4000
07:54
everyone pitches in and gives 20 hives
140
458000
2000
07:56
to help him replace those lost colonies.
141
460000
2000
07:58
And so, it's a very dynamic, and I think,
142
462000
2000
08:00
historic and exciting community to be involved with.
143
464000
6000
08:07
Of course, the real importance for bees is not the honey.
144
471000
3000
08:10
And although I highly encourage you, all use honey.
145
474000
2000
08:12
I mean, it's the most ethical sweetener,
146
476000
3000
08:15
and you know, it's a dynamic and fun sweetener.
147
479000
3000
08:18
But we estimate that about one in three bites of food we eat
148
482000
4000
08:22
is directly or indirectly pollinated by honeybees.
149
486000
5000
08:27
Now, I want to just illustrate that in the fact
150
491000
2000
08:29
that if we look at the breakfast I had yesterday morning --
151
493000
4000
08:33
a little cranberry juice, some fruits, some granola,
152
497000
3000
08:36
I should have had whole wheat bread, I realized, but you know,
153
500000
3000
08:39
jam on my Wonderbread, and some coffee --
154
503000
4000
08:43
and had we taken out all those ingredients,
155
507000
5000
08:48
-- except for the almonds I wasn't going to pick out from the granola --
156
512000
2000
08:50
if we had taken out all those ingredients
157
514000
3000
08:53
the bees had indirectly or directly pollinated,
158
517000
3000
08:56
we wouldn't have much on our plate.
159
520000
2000
08:58
So if we did not have bees, it's not like we would starve,
160
522000
3000
09:01
but clearly our diet would be diminished.
161
525000
5000
09:06
It's said that for bees, the flower is the fountain of life,
162
530000
3000
09:09
and for flowers bees are the messengers of love.
163
533000
3000
09:12
And that's a really great expression, because really,
164
536000
3000
09:15
bees are the sex workers for flowers. They are, you know --
165
539000
3000
09:18
they get paid for their services.
166
542000
2000
09:20
They get paid by pollen and nectar,
167
544000
2000
09:22
to move that male sperm, the pollen, from flower to flower.
168
546000
4000
09:26
And there are flowers that are self-infertile. That means they can't --
169
550000
3000
09:29
the pollen in their bloom can't fertilize themselves.
170
553000
4000
09:33
So in an apple orchard, for instance, you'll have rows of 10 apples
171
557000
3000
09:36
of one variety, and then you have another apple tree
172
560000
3000
09:39
that's a different type of pollen.
173
563000
2000
09:41
And bees are very faithful.
174
565000
1000
09:42
When they're out pollinating or gathering pollen from one flower,
175
566000
4000
09:46
they stay to that crop exclusively, in order to help generate.
176
570000
4000
09:50
And of course, they're made to carry this pollen.
177
574000
4000
09:54
They build up a static electric charge and the pollen jumps on them
178
578000
3000
09:57
and helps spread that pollen from bloom to bloom.
179
581000
4000
10:01
However, honeybees are a minority.
180
585000
2000
10:03
Honeybees are not native to America; they were introduced
181
587000
3000
10:06
with the colonialists.
182
590000
1000
10:07
And there are actually more species of bees
183
591000
3000
10:10
than there are mammals and birds combined.
184
594000
2000
10:12
In Pennsylvania alone, we have been surveying bees for 150 years,
185
596000
5000
10:17
and very intensely in the last three years.
186
601000
3000
10:20
We have identified over 400 species of bees in Pennsylvania.
187
604000
5000
10:25
Thirty-two species have not been identified or found in the state since 1950.
188
609000
6000
10:31
Now, that could be because we haven't been sampling right,
189
615000
3000
10:34
but it does, I think, suggest that something's wrong
190
618000
2000
10:36
with the pollinator force. And these bees are fascinating.
191
620000
3000
10:39
We have bumblebees on the top.
192
623000
2000
10:41
And bumblebees are what we call eusocial: they're not truly social,
193
625000
3000
10:44
because only the queen is, over winter.
194
628000
3000
10:47
We also have the sweat bees, and these are little gems flying around.
195
631000
3000
10:50
They're like tiny little flies and they fly around.
196
634000
3000
10:53
And then you have another type of bee, which we call kleptoparasites,
197
637000
4000
10:57
which is a very fancy way of saying, bad-minded, murdering --
198
641000
8000
11:05
what's the word I'm looking for? Murdering --
199
649000
3000
11:08
Audience: Bee?
200
652000
1000
11:09
Dennis vanEngelsdorp: Bee. Okay, thanks.
201
653000
1000
11:10
(Laughter)
202
654000
2000
11:12
What these bees do is, they sit there. These solitary bees,
203
656000
7000
11:19
they drill a hole in the ground or drill a hole in a branch,
204
663000
3000
11:22
and they collect pollen and make it into a ball,
205
666000
2000
11:24
and they lay an egg on it.
206
668000
2000
11:26
Well, these bees hang out at that hole,
207
670000
1000
11:27
and they wait for that mother to fly away, they go in, eat the egg,
208
671000
4000
11:31
and lay their own egg there. So they don't do any work.
209
675000
3000
11:34
And so, in fact, if you know you have these kleptoparasitic bees,
210
678000
5000
11:39
you know that your environment is healthy,
211
683000
2000
11:41
because they're top-of-the-food-chain bees.
212
685000
3000
11:44
And in fact, there is now a red list of pollinators
213
688000
4000
11:48
that we're worried have disappeared, and on top of that list
214
692000
4000
11:52
are a lot of these kleptoparasites, but also these bumblebees.
215
696000
3000
11:55
And in fact, if you guys live on the West Coast,
216
699000
2000
11:57
go to these websites here, and they're really looking for people
217
701000
3000
12:00
to look for some of these bumblebees, because we think
218
704000
3000
12:03
some have gone extinct. Or some, the population has declined.
219
707000
4000
12:07
And so it's not just honeybees that are in trouble,
220
711000
3000
12:10
but we don't understand these native pollinators
221
714000
3000
12:13
or all those other parts of our community.
222
717000
3000
12:16
And of course, bees are not the only important factor here.
223
720000
4000
12:20
There are other animals that pollinate, like bats,
224
724000
2000
12:22
and bats are in trouble too.
225
726000
2000
12:24
And I'm glad I'm a bee man and not a bat man,
226
728000
2000
12:26
because there's no money to research the bat problems.
227
730000
4000
12:30
And bats are dying at an extraordinary rate.
228
734000
3000
12:33
White-nose syndrome has wiped out populations of bats.
229
737000
3000
12:36
If there's a cave in New York that had 15,000 bats in it,
230
740000
5000
12:41
and there are 1,000 left. That's like San Francisco
231
745000
4000
12:45
becoming the population of half of this county in three years.
232
749000
5000
12:50
And so that's incredible. And there's no money to do that.
233
754000
2000
12:52
But I'm glad to say that I think we know the cause
234
756000
2000
12:54
of all these conditions, and that cause is NDD:
235
758000
4000
12:58
Nature Deficit Disorder.
236
762000
2000
13:00
And that is that I think that what we have in our society is,
237
764000
4000
13:04
we forgot our connection with nature.
238
768000
2000
13:06
And I think if we reconnect to nature,
239
770000
3000
13:09
we'll be able to have the resources and that interest
240
773000
3000
13:12
to solve these problems.
241
776000
2000
13:14
And I think that there is an easy cure for NDD.
242
778000
3000
13:17
And that is, make meadows and not lawns.
243
781000
4000
13:21
And I think we have lost our connection,
244
785000
2000
13:23
and this is a wonderful way of reconnecting to our environment.
245
787000
4000
13:27
I've had the privilege of living by a meadow
246
791000
2000
13:29
for the last little while, and it is terribly engaging.
247
793000
4000
13:33
And if we look at the history of lawns, it's actually rather tragic.
248
797000
5000
13:38
It used to be, two, three hundred years ago,
249
802000
2000
13:40
that a lawn was a symbol of prestige,
250
804000
2000
13:42
and so it was only the very rich that could keep these green
251
806000
3000
13:45
actually, deserts: they're totally sterile.
252
809000
3000
13:48
Americans spent, in 2001 -- 11 percent of all pesticide use was done on lawns.
253
812000
5000
13:53
Five percent of our greenhouse gases are produced by mowing our lawns.
254
817000
6000
13:59
And so it's incredible the amount of resources we've spent
255
823000
3000
14:02
keeping our lawns, which are these useless biosystems.
256
826000
4000
14:06
And so we need to rethink this idea.
257
830000
3000
14:09
In fact, you know, the White House
258
833000
2000
14:11
used to have sheep in front in order to help fund
259
835000
2000
14:13
the war effort in World War I, which probably is not a bad idea;
260
837000
3000
14:16
it wouldn't be a bad idea.
261
840000
1000
14:17
I want to say this not because I'm opposed completely to mowing lawns.
262
841000
3000
14:20
I think that there is perhaps some advantage to keeping lawns
263
844000
4000
14:24
at a limited scale, and I think we're encouraged to do that.
264
848000
4000
14:28
But I also want to reinforce some of the ideas we've heard here,
265
852000
2000
14:30
because having a meadow or living by a meadow is transformational.
266
854000
5000
14:35
That it is amazing that connection we can have with what's there.
267
859000
4000
14:39
These milkweed plants have grown up in my meadow
268
863000
2000
14:41
over the last four years. Add to watch the different plants,
269
865000
4000
14:45
or insects, that come to these flowers, to watch that --
270
869000
4000
14:49
and we've heard about, you know, this relationship you can have with wine,
271
873000
3000
14:52
this companion you can have as it matures
272
876000
3000
14:55
and as it has these different fragrances.
273
879000
2000
14:57
And this is a companion,
274
881000
2000
14:59
and this is a relationship that never dries up.
275
883000
3000
15:02
You never run out of that companion as you drink this wine, too.
276
886000
4000
15:06
And I encourage you to look at that.
277
890000
3000
15:09
Now, not all of us have meadows,
278
893000
2000
15:11
or lawns that we can convert, and so you can always, of course,
279
895000
3000
15:14
grow a meadow in a pot.
280
898000
2000
15:16
Bees apparently, can be the gateway to, you know, other things.
281
900000
3000
15:19
So I'm not saying that you should plant a meadow of pot,
282
903000
4000
15:23
but a pot in a meadow.
283
907000
3000
15:26
But you can also have this great community of city
284
910000
3000
15:29
or building-top beekeepers, these beekeepers that live --
285
913000
3000
15:32
This is in Paris where these beekeepers live.
286
916000
3000
15:35
And everyone should open a beehive,
287
919000
2000
15:37
because it is the most amazing, incredible thing.
288
921000
3000
15:40
And if we want to cure ourselves of NDD, or Nature Deficit Disorder,
289
924000
3000
15:43
I think this is a great way of doing it.
290
927000
2000
15:45
Get a beehive and grow a meadow,
291
929000
2000
15:47
and watch that life come back into your life.
292
931000
3000
15:50
And so with that, I think that what we can do, if we do this,
293
934000
4000
15:54
we can make sure that our future -- our more perfect future --
294
938000
3000
15:57
includes beekeepers and it includes bees and it includes those meadows.
295
941000
5000
16:02
And that journey -- that journey of transformation that occurs
296
946000
3000
16:05
as you grow your meadow and as you keep your bees
297
949000
3000
16:08
or you watch those native bees there -- is an extremely exciting one.
298
952000
4000
16:12
And I hope that you experience it
299
956000
1000
16:13
and I hope you tell me about it one day.
300
957000
3000
16:16
So thank you very much for being here.
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much.
301
960000
2000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Dennis vanEngelsdorp - Bee expertDennis vanEngelsdorp is Acting State Apiarist for Pennsylvania's Department of Agriculture, studying colony collapse disorder -- the alarming, worldwide disappearance of worker bees and Western honey bees.
Why you should listen
"Imagine if one of every three cows died. The National Guard would be out." It's a grim premise, but a favorite of Dennis vanEngelsdorp, who in 2008 watched the same percentage of bees vanish in North America. A leading apiarist, vanEngelsdorp knows the disturbing consequences of the bee die-off. Colony collapse disorder (its official name) is complex and mysterious, driven by pesticides, toxins and disease, and threatens not only the existence of the insect but also the food they pollinate -- a third of what we eat.
But vanEngelsdorp is not a pessimist, however worrisome the situation. Since finding his love for bees in an undergraduate beekeeping course, he's steadily chewed through new degree programs, becoming an outspoken bee crusader, generating global buzz -- sorry -- for the fascinating critters: their workers' dance, their convenient chronic case of static cling ...
To fight recent losses, he's now advocating urban beekeeping and honeymaking (sadly, illegal in some cities), drive-by-night repopulation programs, and emergency queen bee delivery by express mail (legal -- really).
Dennis vanEngelsdorp | Speaker | TED.com