TED@DuPont
Tina Arrowood: A circular economy for salt that keeps rivers clean
Filmed:
Readability: 4.6
1,339,651 views
During the winter of 2018-2019, one million tons of salt were applied to icy roads in the state of Pennsylvania alone. The salt from industrial uses like this often ends up in freshwater rivers, making their water undrinkable and contributing to a growing global crisis. How can we better protect these precious natural resources? Physical organic chemist Tina Arrowood shares a three-step plan to keep salt out of rivers -- and create a circular salt economy that turns industrial byproducts into valuable resources.
Tina Arrowood - Scientist, engineer
By combining science, circular thinking and disruptive innovation, Tina Arrowood helps envision a world in which fresh river water is not scarce, but well-managed. Full bio
By combining science, circular thinking and disruptive innovation, Tina Arrowood helps envision a world in which fresh river water is not scarce, but well-managed. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Growing up in northern Wisconsin,
0
873
1944
00:14
I've naturally developed a connection
to the Mississippi River.
to the Mississippi River.
1
2841
3809
00:19
When I was little,
2
7167
1174
00:20
my sister and I would have contests
to see who could spell
to see who could spell
3
8365
4147
00:24
"M-i-s-s-i-s-s-i-p-p-i" the fastest.
4
12536
3714
00:29
When I was in elementary school,
5
17115
1564
00:30
I got to learn about the early explorers
and their expeditions,
and their expeditions,
6
18703
4541
00:35
Marquette and Joliet, and how they used
the Great Lakes and the Mississippi River
the Great Lakes and the Mississippi River
7
23268
3810
00:39
and its tributaries
to discover the Midwest,
to discover the Midwest,
8
27102
3069
00:42
and to map a trade route
to the Gulf of Mexico.
to the Gulf of Mexico.
9
30195
3200
00:46
In graduate school,
10
34466
1444
00:47
I was fortunate to have
the Mississippi River
the Mississippi River
11
35934
2461
00:50
outside my research laboratory window
12
38419
2404
00:52
at the University of Minnesota.
13
40847
2067
00:55
During that five-year period,
I got to know the Mississippi River.
I got to know the Mississippi River.
14
43680
3400
00:59
I got to know its temperamental nature
15
47425
2317
01:01
and where it would flood
its banks at one moment,
its banks at one moment,
16
49766
3095
01:04
and then shortly thereafter,
17
52885
2301
01:07
you would see its dry shorelines.
18
55210
2200
01:10
Today, as a physical organic chemist,
19
58218
2762
01:13
I'm committed to use my training
20
61004
2031
01:15
to help protect rivers,
like the Mississippi,
like the Mississippi,
21
63059
3186
01:18
from excessive salt
that can come from human activity.
that can come from human activity.
22
66269
3130
01:22
Because, you know,
23
70374
1175
01:23
salt is something that can contaminate
freshwater rivers.
freshwater rivers.
24
71573
4347
01:28
And freshwater rivers,
they have only salt levels of .05 percent.
they have only salt levels of .05 percent.
25
76422
5842
01:34
And at this level, it's safe to drink.
26
82677
3023
01:38
But the majority of the water
on our planet is housed in our oceans,
on our planet is housed in our oceans,
27
86296
3980
01:42
and ocean water has a salinity level
of more than three percent.
of more than three percent.
28
90300
4022
01:46
And if you drank that,
you'd be sick very quick.
you'd be sick very quick.
29
94346
3160
01:50
So, if we are to compare
the relative volume of ocean water
the relative volume of ocean water
30
98427
4634
01:55
to that of the river water
that's on our planet,
that's on our planet,
31
103085
3278
01:58
and let's say we are able
to put the ocean water
to put the ocean water
32
106387
2944
02:01
into an Olympic-size swimming pool,
33
109355
2778
02:04
then our planet's river water
would fit in a one-gallon jug.
would fit in a one-gallon jug.
34
112157
4366
02:09
So you can see it's a precious resource.
35
117095
2912
02:12
But do we treat it
like a precious resource?
like a precious resource?
36
120031
2833
02:14
Or rather, do we treat it
like that old rug
like that old rug
37
122888
2269
02:17
that you put in your front doorway
and wipe your feet off on it?
and wipe your feet off on it?
38
125181
3213
02:21
Treating rivers like that old rug
has severe consequences.
has severe consequences.
39
129244
4159
02:25
Let's take a look.
40
133427
1200
02:27
Let's see what just one teaspoon
of salt can do.
of salt can do.
41
135022
4000
02:31
If we add one teaspoon of salt
42
139530
2264
02:33
to this Olympic-size
swimming pool of ocean water,
swimming pool of ocean water,
43
141818
3442
02:37
the ocean water stays ocean water.
44
145284
2266
02:40
But if we add that same
one teaspoon of salt
one teaspoon of salt
45
148085
2230
02:42
to this one-gallon jug
of fresh river water,
of fresh river water,
46
150339
2992
02:45
suddenly, it becomes too salty to drink.
47
153355
3047
02:49
So the point here is,
48
157149
1222
02:50
because rivers, the volume is so small
compared to the oceans,
compared to the oceans,
49
158395
5666
02:56
it is especially vulnerable
to human activity,
to human activity,
50
164085
2619
02:58
and we need to take care to protect them.
51
166728
2733
03:02
So recently, I surveyed the literature
52
170117
2365
03:04
to look at the river health
around the world.
around the world.
53
172506
3079
03:07
And I fully expected to see
ailing river health
ailing river health
54
175609
3230
03:10
in regions of water scarcity
and heavy industrial development.
and heavy industrial development.
55
178863
4873
03:15
And I saw that
in northern China and in India.
in northern China and in India.
56
183760
2867
03:19
But I was surprised
when I read a 2018 article
when I read a 2018 article
57
187736
4410
03:24
where there's 232 river-sampling sites
58
192170
4564
03:28
sampled across the United States.
59
196758
2563
03:31
And of those sites,
60
199345
1655
03:33
37 percent had increasing salinity levels.
61
201024
3491
03:37
What was more surprising
62
205204
1722
03:38
is that the ones
with the highest increases
with the highest increases
63
206950
2833
03:41
were found on the east part
of the United States,
of the United States,
64
209807
2905
03:44
and not the arid southwest.
65
212736
2031
03:47
The authors of this paper postulate
66
215480
2621
03:50
that this could be due
to using salt to deice roads.
to using salt to deice roads.
67
218125
4729
03:55
Potentially, another source of this salt
68
223751
2598
03:58
could come from salty
industrial wastewaters.
industrial wastewaters.
69
226373
3133
04:02
So as you see, human activities
can convert our freshwater rivers
can convert our freshwater rivers
70
230084
5298
04:07
into water that's more like our oceans.
71
235406
2500
04:09
So we need to act and do something
before it's too late.
before it's too late.
72
237930
3483
04:14
And I have a proposal.
73
242231
1825
04:16
We can take a three-step
river-defense mechanism,
river-defense mechanism,
74
244942
4309
04:21
and if industrial-water users
practice this defense mechanism,
practice this defense mechanism,
75
249275
5060
04:26
we can put our rivers
in a much safer position.
in a much safer position.
76
254359
4174
04:30
This involves, number one,
77
258899
2411
04:33
extracting less water from our rivers
78
261334
2489
04:35
by implementing water recycle
and reuse operations.
and reuse operations.
79
263847
3963
04:40
Number two,
80
268403
1158
04:41
we need to take the salt
out of these salty industrial wastewaters
out of these salty industrial wastewaters
81
269585
4008
04:45
and recover it and reuse it
for other purposes.
for other purposes.
82
273617
3515
04:49
And number three,
we need to convert salt consumers,
we need to convert salt consumers,
83
277695
4065
04:53
who currently source our salt from mines
84
281784
3055
04:56
into salt consumers that source our salt
from recycled salt sources.
from recycled salt sources.
85
284863
4584
05:01
This three-part defense mechanism
is already in play.
is already in play.
86
289942
3476
05:05
This is what northern China
and India are implementing
and India are implementing
87
293442
2939
05:08
to help to rehabilitate the rivers.
88
296405
2163
05:11
But the proposal here
89
299123
1524
05:12
is to use this defense mechanism
to protect our rivers,
to protect our rivers,
90
300671
4206
05:16
so we don't need to rehabilitate them.
91
304901
2534
05:20
And the good news is,
we have technology that can do this.
we have technology that can do this.
92
308159
3436
05:23
It's with membranes.
93
311619
1381
05:25
Membranes that can separate
salt and water.
salt and water.
94
313532
3230
05:29
Membranes have been around
for a number of years,
for a number of years,
95
317593
3135
05:32
and they're based on polymeric materials
that separate based on size,
that separate based on size,
96
320752
4962
05:37
or they can separate based on charge.
97
325738
2291
05:40
The membranes that are used
to separate salt and water
to separate salt and water
98
328371
3524
05:43
typically separate based on charge.
99
331919
3023
05:46
And these membranes
are negatively charged,
are negatively charged,
100
334966
2603
05:49
and help to repel the negatively
charged chloride ions
charged chloride ions
101
337593
2841
05:52
that are in that dissolved salt.
102
340458
2067
05:55
So, as I said, these membranes
have been around for a number of years,
have been around for a number of years,
103
343974
4452
06:00
and currently, they are purifying
25 million gallons of water every minute.
25 million gallons of water every minute.
104
348450
6983
06:07
Even more than that, actually.
105
355457
1915
06:09
But they can do more.
106
357770
1400
06:12
These membranes are based
under the principle of reverse osmosis.
under the principle of reverse osmosis.
107
360254
4698
06:17
Now osmosis is this natural process
that happens in our bodies --
that happens in our bodies --
108
365421
5005
06:22
you know, how our cells work.
109
370450
1818
06:24
And osmosis is where you have two chambers
110
372292
3422
06:27
that separate two levels
of salt concentration.
of salt concentration.
111
375738
3578
06:31
One with low salt concentration
112
379340
2070
06:33
and one with high salt concentration.
113
381434
2070
06:35
And separating the two chambers
is the semipermeable membrane.
is the semipermeable membrane.
114
383528
4034
06:39
And under the natural osmosis process,
115
387871
2436
06:42
what happens is the water naturally
transports across that membrane
transports across that membrane
116
390331
4010
06:46
from the area of low salt concentration
117
394365
1921
06:48
to the area of high salt concentration,
118
396310
2468
06:50
until an equilibrium is met.
119
398802
2507
06:54
Now reverse osmosis,
it's the reverse of this natural process.
it's the reverse of this natural process.
120
402437
3675
06:58
And in order to achieve this reversal,
121
406136
2124
07:00
what we do is we apply a pressure
to the high-concentration side
to the high-concentration side
122
408284
4854
07:05
and in doing so, we drive the water
the opposite direction.
the opposite direction.
123
413162
3579
07:09
And so the high-concentration side
becomes more salty,
becomes more salty,
124
417130
3429
07:12
more concentrated,
125
420583
1380
07:13
and the low-concentration side
becomes your purified water.
becomes your purified water.
126
421987
3996
07:18
So using reverse osmosis,
we can take an industrial wastewater
we can take an industrial wastewater
127
426436
4817
07:23
and convert up to 95 percent of it
into pure water,
into pure water,
128
431277
4602
07:27
leaving only five percent
as this concentrated salty mixture.
as this concentrated salty mixture.
129
435903
4213
07:33
Now, this five percent
concentrated salty mixture
concentrated salty mixture
130
441022
3317
07:36
is not waste.
131
444363
1150
07:37
So scientists have also
developed membranes
developed membranes
132
445879
2702
07:40
that are modified to allow
some salts to pass through
some salts to pass through
133
448605
4343
07:44
and not others.
134
452972
1150
07:46
Using these membranes,
135
454939
1334
07:48
which are commonly referred to
as nanofiltration membranes,
as nanofiltration membranes,
136
456297
3098
07:51
now this five percent
concentrated salty solution
concentrated salty solution
137
459419
3333
07:54
can be converted
into a purified salt solution.
into a purified salt solution.
138
462776
3491
07:58
So, in total, using reverse osmosis
and nanofiltration membranes,
and nanofiltration membranes,
139
466863
5071
08:03
we can convert industrial wastewater
140
471958
2476
08:06
into a resource of both water and salt.
141
474458
3770
08:10
And in doing so,
142
478633
1614
08:12
achieve pillars one and two
of this river-defense mechanism.
of this river-defense mechanism.
143
480271
4397
08:17
Now, I've introduced this
to a number of industrial-water users,
to a number of industrial-water users,
144
485557
4603
08:22
and the common response is,
145
490184
2687
08:24
"Yeah, but who is going to use my salt?"
146
492895
2666
08:28
So that's why pillar number three
is so important.
is so important.
147
496014
3000
08:31
We need to transform folks
that are using mine salt
that are using mine salt
148
499038
3780
08:34
into consumers of recycled salt.
149
502842
2706
08:38
So who are these salt consumers?
150
506080
2627
08:41
Well, in 2018 in the United States,
151
509056
2270
08:43
I learned that 43 percent of the salt
consumed in the US
consumed in the US
152
511350
4899
08:48
was used for road salt deicing purposes.
153
516273
3246
08:52
Thirty-nine percent
was used by the chemical industry.
was used by the chemical industry.
154
520289
3264
08:55
So let's take a look
at these two applications.
at these two applications.
155
523577
2833
08:58
So, I was shocked.
156
526927
3007
09:01
In the 2018-2019 winter season,
157
529958
3159
09:05
one million tons of salt
158
533141
2953
09:08
was applied to the roads
in the state of Pennsylvania.
in the state of Pennsylvania.
159
536118
4043
09:13
One million tons of salt is enough
160
541315
1799
09:15
to fill two-thirds
of an Empire State Building.
of an Empire State Building.
161
543138
3200
09:19
That's one million tons of salt
mined from the earth,
mined from the earth,
162
547030
3772
09:22
applied to our roads,
163
550826
1698
09:24
and then it washes off
into the environment and into our rivers.
into the environment and into our rivers.
164
552548
3942
09:29
So the proposal here
is that we could at least
is that we could at least
165
557625
3397
09:33
source that salt from a salty
industrial wastewater,
industrial wastewater,
166
561046
3620
09:36
and prevent that
from going into our rivers,
from going into our rivers,
167
564690
2412
09:39
and rather use that to apply to our roads.
168
567126
3054
09:42
So at least when the melt happens
in the springtime
in the springtime
169
570204
2750
09:44
and you have this high-salinity runoff,
170
572978
2750
09:47
the rivers are at least
in a better position
in a better position
171
575752
2254
09:50
to defend themselves against that.
172
578030
2547
09:54
Now, as a chemist,
173
582053
1381
09:55
the opportunity though
that I'm more psyched about
that I'm more psyched about
174
583458
4110
09:59
is the concept of introducing
circular salt into the chemical industry.
circular salt into the chemical industry.
175
587592
4682
10:05
And the chlor-alkali industry is perfect.
176
593052
4397
10:10
Chlor-alkali industry
is the source of epoxies,
is the source of epoxies,
177
598028
3470
10:13
it's the source of urethanes and solvents
178
601522
2854
10:16
and a lot of useful products
that we use in our everyday lives.
that we use in our everyday lives.
179
604400
3640
10:20
And it uses sodium chloride salt
as its key feed stack.
as its key feed stack.
180
608593
4335
10:25
So the idea here is,
181
613934
2302
10:28
well, first of all,
let's look at linear economy.
let's look at linear economy.
182
616260
2389
10:30
So in a linear economy,
they're sourcing that salt from a mine,
they're sourcing that salt from a mine,
183
618673
3333
10:34
it goes through this chlor-alkali process,
184
622030
2055
10:36
made into a basic chemical,
185
624109
1960
10:38
which then can get converted
into another new product,
into another new product,
186
626093
2738
10:40
or a more functional product.
187
628855
1933
10:43
But during that conversion process,
188
631300
2682
10:46
oftentimes salt is regenerated
as the by-product,
as the by-product,
189
634006
3809
10:49
and it ends up
in the industrial wastewater.
in the industrial wastewater.
190
637839
2398
10:53
So, the idea is that we can
introduce circularity,
introduce circularity,
191
641402
5095
10:58
and we can recycle the water and salt
from those industrial wastewater streams,
from those industrial wastewater streams,
192
646521
4850
11:03
from the factories,
193
651395
1420
11:04
and we can send it to the front end
of the chlor-alkali process.
of the chlor-alkali process.
194
652839
4071
11:10
Circular salt.
195
658388
1206
11:11
So how impactful is this?
196
659936
2142
11:14
Well, let's just take one example.
197
662420
2429
11:16
Fifty percent of the world's
production of propylene oxide
production of propylene oxide
198
664873
3486
11:20
is made through the chlor-alkali process.
199
668383
2452
11:23
And that's a total of about five million
tons of propylene oxide
tons of propylene oxide
200
671379
5237
11:28
on an annual basis, made globally.
201
676640
2209
11:31
So that's five million tons of salt
mined from the earth
mined from the earth
202
679768
4158
11:35
converted through the chlor-alkali process
into propylene oxide,
into propylene oxide,
203
683950
3889
11:39
and then during that process,
204
687863
1690
11:41
five million tons of salt
that ends up in wastewater streams.
that ends up in wastewater streams.
205
689577
4224
11:46
So five million tons
206
694547
1484
11:48
is enough salt to fill
three Empire State Buildings.
three Empire State Buildings.
207
696055
3397
11:51
And that's on an annual basis.
208
699794
2000
11:54
So you can see how circular salt
can provide a barrier
can provide a barrier
209
702157
5539
11:59
to our rivers from this excessive
salty discharge.
salty discharge.
210
707720
3917
12:04
So you might wonder,
211
712446
1589
12:06
"Well, gosh, these membranes
have been around for a number of years,
have been around for a number of years,
212
714059
3990
12:10
so why aren't people implementing
wastewater reuse?
wastewater reuse?
213
718073
4105
12:14
Well, the bottom line is,
214
722741
2031
12:16
it costs money to implement
wastewater reuse.
wastewater reuse.
215
724796
2913
12:20
And second,
216
728114
1586
12:21
water in these regions is undervalued.
217
729724
3162
12:25
Until it's too late.
218
733323
1334
12:27
You know, if we don't plan
for freshwater sustainability,
for freshwater sustainability,
219
735244
4539
12:31
there are some severe consequences.
220
739807
2357
12:34
You can just ask one of the world's
largest chemical manufacturers
largest chemical manufacturers
221
742188
3152
12:37
who last year took
a 280-million dollar hit
a 280-million dollar hit
222
745364
3663
12:41
due to low river levels
of the Rhine River in Germany.
of the Rhine River in Germany.
223
749051
3989
12:45
You can ask the residents
of Cape Town, South Africa,
of Cape Town, South Africa,
224
753995
3860
12:49
who experienced a year-over-year drought
drying up their water reserves,
drying up their water reserves,
225
757879
4198
12:54
and then being asked
not to flush their toilets.
not to flush their toilets.
226
762101
3267
12:58
So you can see,
227
766292
1785
13:00
we have solutions here, with membranes,
228
768101
2214
13:02
where we can provide pure water,
229
770339
4427
13:06
we can provide pure salt,
230
774790
2214
13:09
using these membranes, both of these,
231
777028
2144
13:11
to help to protect our rivers
for future generations.
for future generations.
232
779196
3237
13:14
Thank you.
233
782734
1159
13:15
(Applause)
234
783917
2694
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tina Arrowood - Scientist, engineerBy combining science, circular thinking and disruptive innovation, Tina Arrowood helps envision a world in which fresh river water is not scarce, but well-managed.
Why you should listen
Tina Arrowood understands that water is the world’s most valuable resource -- and one of the most finite. Her knowledge and expertise fuels her desire to drive effective water management strategies forward and inspires her to innovate breakthrough solutions that promote water reuse and recycling. Alongside her colleagues at DuPont Water Solutions, Arrowood -- a PhD Physical Organic Chemist and Principal Research Scientist -- focuses on her energy and passion to advance membrane technologies that enable wastewater to be converted into clean water sources used for a wide-range of applications.
In 2016, Arrowood's team commercialized the first series of reverse osmosis and nanofiltration elements designed to address wastewater challenges. With the award-winning FILMTEC™ FORTILIFE™ element portfolio continuing to make waves in the industry to minimize water discharge, Arrowood is now focused on mitigating the threat salt poses to water systems. She continues to teach industrial water users around the world about her findings. While doing so, she gathers insight on new and emerging water treatment challenges that help inform and shape membrane research and development.
Tina Arrowood | Speaker | TED.com