TEDMED 2012
Diane Kelly: What we didn't know about penis anatomy
Filmed:
Readability: 4.7
4,493,138 views
We're not done with anatomy. We know a tremendous amount about genomics, proteomics and cell biology, but as Diane Kelly makes clear at TEDMED, there are basic facts about the human body we're still learning. Case in point: How does the mammalian erection work?
Diane Kelly - Biologist
Diane Kelly studies vertebrate anatomy, in particular the connection between the design and the function of reproductive organs. Full bio
Diane Kelly studies vertebrate anatomy, in particular the connection between the design and the function of reproductive organs. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:15
When I go to parties,
0
0
1575
00:17
it doesn't usually take very long
1
1575
1784
00:19
for people to find out
2
3359
1040
00:20
that I'm a scientist and I study sex.
3
4399
3108
00:23
And then I get asked questions.
4
7507
4901
00:28
And the questions usually have a very particular format.
5
12408
3167
00:31
They start with the phrase,
6
15575
1232
00:32
"A friend told me,"
7
16807
1901
00:34
and then they end with the phrase,
8
18708
1900
00:36
"Is this true?"
9
20608
1917
00:38
And most of the time
10
22525
1386
00:39
I'm glad to say that I can answer them,
11
23911
2119
00:41
but sometimes I have to say,
12
26030
1847
00:43
"I'm really sorry,
13
27877
1133
00:44
but I don't know
14
29010
1184
00:46
because I'm not that kind of a doctor."
15
30194
3084
00:49
That is, I'm not a clinician,
16
33278
1916
00:51
I'm a comparative biologist who studies anatomy.
17
35194
3191
00:54
And my job is to look at lots of different species of animals
18
38385
2933
00:57
and try to figure out how their tissues and organs work
19
41318
3317
01:00
when everything's going right,
20
44635
1501
01:02
rather than trying to figure out
21
46136
1618
01:03
how to fix things when they go wrong,
22
47754
1583
01:05
like so many of you.
23
49337
1201
01:06
And what I do is I look for similarities and differences
24
50538
2399
01:08
in the solutions that they've evolved
25
52937
2267
01:11
for fundamental biological problems.
26
55204
1584
01:12
So today I'm here to argue
27
56788
1849
01:14
that this is not at all
28
58637
3866
01:18
an esoteric Ivory Tower activity
29
62503
1901
01:20
that we find at our universities,
30
64404
1317
01:21
but that broad study
31
65721
1983
01:23
across species, tissue types and organ systems
32
67704
2952
01:26
can produce insights
33
70656
1635
01:28
that have direct implications for human health.
34
72291
3384
01:31
And this is true both of my recent project
35
75675
2498
01:34
on sex differences in the brain,
36
78173
1724
01:35
and my more mature work
37
79897
1919
01:37
on the anatomy and function of penises.
38
81816
2834
01:40
And now you know why I'm fun at parties.
39
84650
2630
01:43
(Laughter)
40
87280
968
01:44
So today I'm going to give you an example
41
88248
2283
01:46
drawn from my penis study
42
90531
1717
01:48
to show you how knowledge
43
92248
1617
01:49
drawn from studies of one organ system
44
93865
1767
01:51
provided insights into a very different one.
45
95632
2981
01:54
Now I'm sure as everyone in the audience already knows --
46
98613
3018
01:57
I did have to explain it to my nine-year-old late last week --
47
101631
3516
02:01
penises are structures that transfer sperm
48
105147
3751
02:04
from one individual to another.
49
108898
1300
02:06
And the slide behind me
50
110198
1500
02:07
barely scratches the surface
51
111698
1733
02:09
of how widespread they are in animals.
52
113431
1965
02:11
There's an enormous amount of anatomical variation.
53
115396
1985
02:13
You find muscular tubes, modified legs, modified fins,
54
117381
3874
02:17
as well as the mammalian fleshy, inflatable cylinder
55
121255
3846
02:21
that we're all familiar with --
56
125101
1635
02:22
or at least half of you are.
57
126736
2282
02:24
(Laughter)
58
129018
2401
02:27
And I think we see this tremendous variation
59
131419
2738
02:30
because it's a really effective solution
60
134157
3151
02:33
to a very basic biological problem,
61
137308
2166
02:35
and that is getting sperm in a position
62
139474
2483
02:37
to meet up with eggs and form zygotes.
63
141957
2552
02:40
Now the penis isn't actually required for internal fertiliztion,
64
144509
3949
02:44
but when internal fertilization evolves,
65
148458
2466
02:46
penises often follow.
66
150924
2000
02:48
And the question I get when I start talking about this most often is,
67
152924
4417
02:53
"What made you interested in this subject?"
68
157341
2916
02:56
And the answer is skeletons.
69
160257
3950
03:00
You wouldn't think that skeletons and penises
70
164207
2567
03:02
have very much to do with one another.
71
166774
1851
03:04
And that's because we tend to think of skeletons
72
168625
2132
03:06
as stiff lever systems
73
170757
1650
03:08
that produce speed or power.
74
172407
1683
03:09
And my first forays into biological research,
75
174090
3567
03:13
doing dinosaur paleontology as an undergraduate,
76
177657
2818
03:16
were really squarely in that realm.
77
180475
1551
03:17
But when I went to graduate school to study biomechanics,
78
182026
3117
03:21
I really wanted to find a dissertation project
79
185143
2465
03:23
that would expand our knowledge of skeletal function.
80
187608
2899
03:26
I tried a bunch of different stuff.
81
190507
1802
03:28
A lot of it didn't pan out.
82
192309
1648
03:29
But then one day I started thinking
83
193957
1834
03:31
about the mammalian penis.
84
195791
1782
03:33
And it's really an odd sort of structure.
85
197573
4018
03:37
Before it can be used for internal fertilization,
86
201591
2817
03:40
its mechanical behavior has to change
87
204408
1483
03:41
in a really dramatic fashion.
88
205891
1717
03:43
Most of the time it's a flexible organ.
89
207608
2598
03:46
It's easy to bend.
90
210206
1284
03:47
But before it's brought into use
91
211490
1994
03:49
during copulation
92
213484
1218
03:50
it has to become rigid,
93
214702
1758
03:52
it has to become difficult to bend.
94
216460
2015
03:54
And moreover, it has to work.
95
218475
2017
03:56
A reproductive system that fails to function
96
220492
2750
03:59
produces an individual that has no offspring,
97
223242
3315
04:02
and that individual is then kicked out of the gene pool.
98
226557
3171
04:05
And so I thought, "Here's a problem
99
229728
2461
04:08
that just cries out for a skeletal system --
100
232189
3248
04:11
not one like this one,
101
235437
3212
04:14
but one like this one --
102
238649
3057
04:17
because, functionally,
103
241706
2417
04:20
a skeleton is any system
104
244123
1567
04:21
that supports tissue and transmits forces.
105
245690
3032
04:24
And I already knew that animals like this earthworm,
106
248722
2350
04:26
indeed most animals,
107
251072
1446
04:28
don't support their tissues
108
252518
1293
04:29
by draping them over bones.
109
253811
1794
04:31
Instead they're more like reinforced water balloons.
110
255605
2833
04:34
They use a skeleton that we call a hydrostatic skeleton.
111
258438
3867
04:38
And a hydrostatic skeleton
112
262305
2066
04:40
uses two elements.
113
264371
1918
04:42
The skeletal support comes from an interaction
114
266289
2150
04:44
between a pressurized fluid
115
268439
1774
04:46
and a surrounding wall of tissue
116
270213
1606
04:47
that's held in tension and reinforced with fibrous proteins.
117
271819
4471
04:52
And the interaction is crucial.
118
276290
2248
04:54
Without both elements you have no support.
119
278538
3368
04:57
If you have fluid
120
281906
1282
04:59
with no wall to surround it
121
283188
2034
05:01
and keep pressure up,
122
285222
1434
05:02
you have a puddle.
123
286656
1904
05:04
And if you have just the wall
124
288560
2100
05:06
with no fluid inside of it to put the wall in tension,
125
290660
1734
05:08
you've got a little wet rag.
126
292394
1950
05:10
When you look at a penis in cross section,
127
294344
2632
05:12
it has a lot of the hallmarks
128
296976
2433
05:15
of a hydrostatic skeleton.
129
299409
2050
05:17
It has a central space
130
301459
1509
05:18
of spongy erectile tissue
131
302968
1520
05:20
that fills with fluid -- in this case blood --
132
304488
2578
05:22
surrounded by a wall of tissue
133
307066
2399
05:25
that's rich in a stiff structural protein called collagen.
134
309465
3851
05:29
But at the time when I started this project,
135
313316
2500
05:31
the best explanation I could find for penal erection
136
315816
3201
05:34
was that the wall surrounded these spongy tissues,
137
319017
4284
05:39
and the spongy tissues filled with blood
138
323301
1699
05:40
and pressure rose and voila! it became erect.
139
325000
3268
05:44
And that explained to me expansion --
140
328268
3965
05:48
made sense: more fluid, you get tissues that expand --
141
332233
3567
05:51
but it didn't actually explain erection.
142
335800
3017
05:54
Because there was no mechanism in this explanation
143
338817
3891
05:58
for making this structure hard to bend.
144
342708
2967
06:01
And no one had systematically looked at the wall tissue.
145
345675
2716
06:04
So I thought, wall tissue's important in skeletons.
146
348391
2602
06:06
It has to be part of the explanation.
147
350993
2366
06:09
And this was the point
148
353359
2535
06:11
at which my graduate adviser said,
149
355894
2597
06:14
"Whoa! Hold on. Slow down."
150
358491
3383
06:17
Because after about six months of me talking about this,
151
361874
3368
06:21
I think he finally figured out
152
365242
1316
06:22
that I was really serious about the penis thing.
153
366558
3049
06:25
(Laughter)
154
369607
3047
06:28
So he sat me down, and he warned me.
155
372654
2049
06:30
He was like, "Be careful going down this path.
156
374703
2176
06:32
I'm not sure this project's going to pan out."
157
376879
2767
06:35
Because he was afraid I was walking into a trap.
158
379646
2532
06:38
I was taking on a socially embarrassing question
159
382178
4817
06:42
with an answer that he thought
160
386995
2335
06:45
might not be particularly interesting.
161
389330
2382
06:47
And that was because
162
391712
1533
06:49
every hydrostatic skeleton
163
393245
1518
06:50
that we had found in nature up to that point
164
394763
2068
06:52
had the same basic elements.
165
396831
1797
06:54
It had the central fluid,
166
398628
1217
06:55
it had the surrounding wall,
167
399845
1800
06:57
and the reinforcing fibers in the wall
168
401645
3136
07:00
were arranged in crossed helices
169
404781
2418
07:03
around the long axis of the skeleton.
170
407199
2057
07:05
So the image behind me
171
409256
1321
07:06
shows a piece of tissue
172
410577
1629
07:08
in one of these cross helical skeletons
173
412206
2025
07:10
cut so that you're looking at the surface of the wall.
174
414231
2533
07:12
The arrow shows you the long axis.
175
416764
1718
07:14
And you can see two layers of fibers,
176
418482
1850
07:16
one in blue and one in yellow,
177
420332
1701
07:17
arranged in left-handed and right-handed angles.
178
422033
2798
07:20
And if you weren't just looking at a little section of the fibers,
179
424831
2249
07:22
those fibers would be going in helices
180
427080
2701
07:25
around the long axis of the skeleton --
181
429781
1750
07:27
something like a Chinese finger trap,
182
431531
2133
07:29
where you stick your fingers in and they get stuck.
183
433664
1901
07:31
And these skeletons have a particular set of behaviors,
184
435565
3083
07:34
which I'm going to demonstrate in a film.
185
438648
2032
07:36
It's a model skeleton
186
440680
1151
07:37
that I made out of a piece of cloth
187
441831
2183
07:39
that I wrapped around an inflated balloon.
188
444014
2553
07:42
The cloth's cut on the bias.
189
446567
1698
07:44
So you can see that the fibers wrap in helices,
190
448265
2749
07:46
and those fibers can reorient as the skeleton moves,
191
451014
4312
07:51
which means the skeleton's flexible.
192
455326
1429
07:52
It lengthens, shortens and bends really easily
193
456755
2473
07:55
in response to internal or external forces.
194
459228
3547
07:58
Now my adviser's concern
195
462775
1296
07:59
was what if the penile wall tissue
196
464071
2366
08:02
is just the same as any other hydrostatic skeleton.
197
466437
1674
08:04
What are you going to contribute?
198
468111
1927
08:05
What new thing are you contributing
199
470038
1467
08:07
to our knowledge of biology?
200
471505
1648
08:09
And I thought, "Yeah, he does have a really good point here."
201
473153
3418
08:12
So I spent a long, long time thinking about it.
202
476571
1750
08:14
And one thing kept bothering me,
203
478321
2134
08:16
and that's, when they're functioning,
204
480455
2450
08:18
penises don't wiggle.
205
482905
1933
08:20
(Laughter)
206
484838
2339
08:23
So something interesting had to be going on.
207
487177
2901
08:25
So I went ahead, collected wall tissue,
208
490078
3301
08:29
prepared it so it was erect,
209
493379
1599
08:30
sectioned it, put it on slides
210
494978
2199
08:33
and then stuck it under the microscope to have a look,
211
497177
2652
08:35
fully expecting to see crossed helices of collagen of some variety.
212
499829
5036
08:40
But instead I saw this.
213
504865
2398
08:43
There's an outer layer and an inner layer.
214
507263
3001
08:46
The arrow shows you the long axis of the skeleton.
215
510264
2550
08:48
I was really surprised at this.
216
512814
2569
08:51
Everyone I showed it
217
515383
945
08:52
was really surprised at this.
218
516328
1200
08:53
Why was everyone surprised at this?
219
517528
1537
08:54
That's because we knew theoretically
220
519065
2984
08:57
that there was another way
221
522049
2815
09:00
of arranging fibers in a hydrostatic skeleton,
222
524864
3034
09:03
and that was with fibers at zero degrees
223
527898
2271
09:06
and 90 degrees to the long axis of the structure.
224
530169
3866
09:09
The thing is, no one had ever seen it before in nature.
225
534035
3562
09:13
And now I was looking at one.
226
537597
2700
09:16
Those fibers in that particular orientation
227
540297
2734
09:18
give the skeleton a very, very different behavior.
228
543031
3215
09:22
I'm going to show a model
229
546246
1185
09:23
made out of exactly the same materials.
230
547431
1945
09:25
So it'll be made of the same cotton cloth,
231
549376
2058
09:27
same balloon, same internal pressure.
232
551434
3289
09:30
But the only difference
233
554723
2467
09:33
is that the fibers are arranged differently.
234
557190
2382
09:35
And you'll see that, unlike the cross helical model,
235
559572
2651
09:38
this model resists extension and contraction
236
562223
2950
09:41
and resists bending.
237
565173
1451
09:42
Now what that tells us
238
566624
1034
09:43
is that wall tissues are doing so much more
239
567658
2096
09:45
than just covering the vascular tissues.
240
569754
2503
09:48
They're an integral part of the penile skeleton.
241
572257
3494
09:51
If the wall around the erectile tissue wasn't there,
242
575751
2537
09:54
if it wasn't reinforced in this way,
243
578288
2165
09:56
the shape would change,
244
580453
1152
09:57
but the inflated penis would not resist bending,
245
581605
2384
09:59
and erection simply wouldn't work.
246
583989
2047
10:01
It's an observation with obvious medical applications
247
586036
2601
10:04
in humans as well,
248
588637
1782
10:06
but it's also relevant in a broad sense, I think,
249
590419
2935
10:09
to the design of prosthetics, soft robots,
250
593354
2432
10:11
basically anything
251
595786
1067
10:12
where changes of shape and stiffness are important.
252
596853
3318
10:16
So to sum up:
253
600171
1748
10:17
Twenty years ago,
254
601919
1217
10:19
I had a college adviser tell me,
255
603136
1750
10:20
when I went to the college and said,
256
604886
2051
10:22
"I'm kind of interested in anatomy,"
257
606937
1149
10:23
they said, "Anatomy's a dead science."
258
608086
1884
10:25
He couldn't have been more wrong.
259
609970
2617
10:28
I really believe that we still have a lot to learn
260
612587
2733
10:31
about the normal structure and function of our bodies.
261
615320
3133
10:34
Not just about its genetics and molecular biology,
262
618453
2814
10:37
but up here in the meat end of the scale.
263
621267
3399
10:40
We've got limits on our time.
264
624666
1435
10:42
We often focus on one disease,
265
626101
2265
10:44
one model, one problem,
266
628366
1184
10:45
but my experience suggests
267
629550
1574
10:47
that we should take the time
268
631124
1778
10:48
to apply ideas broadly between systems
269
632902
2565
10:51
and just see where it takes us.
270
635467
1874
10:53
After all, if ideas about invertebrate skeletons
271
637341
3600
10:56
can give us insights
272
640941
1466
10:58
about mammalian reproductive systems,
273
642407
2085
11:00
there could be lots of other wild and productive connections
274
644492
4049
11:04
lurking out there just waiting to be found.
275
648541
2449
11:06
Thank you.
276
650990
1852
11:08
(Applause)
277
652842
3388
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Diane Kelly - BiologistDiane Kelly studies vertebrate anatomy, in particular the connection between the design and the function of reproductive organs.
Why you should listen
Diane A. Kelly is a Senior Research Fellow at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst. Her research interests include the evolution of copulatory systems and sexual differentiation in the nervous system. She is best known for her original work on the anatomy and function of vertebrate penises, but has also written children’s books, created exhibits for science museums, helped exhume a mastodon, and designed and published a pair of quirky science card games. Kelly holds a Ph.D. in Zoology from Duke University and an A.B. in Biological Sciences from the University of Chicago.
She blogs at Science Made Cool -- where she wrote about what it was like to give this talk.
Listen to Diane's hilarious, thoughtful StoryCollider podcast, "Death on the Road" >>
Diane Kelly | Speaker | TED.com