TEDGlobal 2012
Elyn Saks: A tale of mental illness -- from the inside
Filmed:
Readability: 4.1
4,034,245 views
"Is it okay if I totally trash your office?" It's a question Elyn Saks once asked her doctor, and it wasn't a joke. A legal scholar, in 2007 Saks came forward with her own story of schizophrenia, controlled by drugs and therapy but ever-present. In this powerful talk, she asks us to see people with mental illness clearly, honestly and compassionately.
Elyn Saks - Mental health law scholar
Elyn Saks asks bold questions about how society treats people with mental illness. Full bio
Elyn Saks asks bold questions about how society treats people with mental illness. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
So I'm a woman with chronic schizophrenia.
0
819
1951
00:18
I've spent hundreds of days
1
2770
1809
00:20
in psychiatric hospitals.
2
4579
1487
00:21
I might have ended up spending
3
6066
1805
00:23
most of my life on the back ward of a hospital,
4
7871
1827
00:25
but that isn't how my life turned out.
5
9698
2200
00:27
In fact, I've managed to stay clear of hospitals
6
11898
3448
00:31
for almost three decades,
7
15346
1489
00:32
perhaps my proudest accomplishment.
8
16835
1943
00:34
That's not to say that I've remained clear
9
18778
2194
00:36
of all psychiatric struggles.
10
20972
1607
00:38
After I graduated from the Yale Law School and
11
22579
2425
00:40
got my first law job, my New Haven analyst, Dr. White,
12
25004
3006
00:43
announced to me that he was going to close his practice
13
28010
2585
00:46
in three months, several years
14
30595
1880
00:48
before I had planned to leave New Haven.
15
32475
1697
00:50
White had been enormously helpful to me,
16
34172
2769
00:52
and the thought of his leaving
17
36941
1057
00:53
shattered me.
18
37998
1886
00:55
My best friend Steve,
19
39884
1470
00:57
sensing that something was terribly wrong,
20
41354
1752
00:59
flew out to New Haven to be with me.
21
43106
1832
01:00
Now I'm going to quote from some of my writings:
22
44938
2088
01:02
"I opened the door to my studio apartment.
23
47026
2515
01:05
Steve would later tell me that,
24
49541
2173
01:07
for all the times he had seen me psychotic, nothing
25
51714
2736
01:10
could have prepared him for what he saw that day.
26
54450
2001
01:12
For a week or more, I had barely eaten.
27
56451
2673
01:15
I was gaunt. I walked
28
59124
2560
01:17
as though my legs were wooden.
29
61684
1614
01:19
My face looked and felt like a mask.
30
63298
3027
01:22
I had closed all the curtains in the apartment, so
31
66325
2844
01:25
in the middle of the day
32
69169
955
01:26
the apartment was in near total darkness.
33
70124
2014
01:28
The air was fetid, the room a shambles.
34
72138
2752
01:30
Steve, both a lawyer and a psychologist, has treated
35
74890
3316
01:34
many patients with severe mental illness, and to this day
36
78206
3133
01:37
he'll say I was as bad as any he had ever seen.
37
81339
2688
01:39
'Hi,' I said, and then I returned to the couch,
38
84027
3079
01:43
where I sat in silence for several moments.
39
87106
2124
01:45
'Thank you for coming, Steve.
40
89230
1845
01:46
Crumbling world, word, voice.
41
91075
4051
01:51
Tell the clocks to stop.
42
95126
1869
01:52
Time is. Time has come.'
43
96995
1791
01:54
'White is leaving,' Steve said somberly.
44
98786
3241
01:57
'I'm being pushed into a grave. The situation is grave,' I moan.
45
102027
3431
02:01
'Gravity is pulling me down.
46
105458
1627
02:02
I'm scared. Tell them to get away.'"
47
107085
2133
02:05
As a young woman, I was in a psychiatric hospital
48
109218
3712
02:08
on three different occasions for lengthy periods.
49
112930
2504
02:11
My doctors diagnosed me with chronic schizophrenia,
50
115434
2792
02:14
and gave me a prognosis of "grave."
51
118226
2595
02:16
That is, at best, I was expected to live in a board and care,
52
120821
3430
02:20
and work at menial jobs.
53
124251
1704
02:21
Fortunately, I did not actually
54
125955
2000
02:23
enact that grave prognosis.
55
127955
1775
02:25
Instead, I'm a chaired Professor of Law, Psychology
56
129730
2841
02:28
and Psychiatry at the USC Gould School of Law,
57
132571
2625
02:31
I have many close friends
58
135196
1630
02:32
and I have a beloved husband, Will, who's here with us today.
59
136826
3185
02:35
(Applause) Thank you.
60
140011
4527
02:42
He's definitely the star of my show.
61
146554
3258
02:45
I'd like to share with you how that happened, and also
62
149812
2798
02:48
describe my experience of being psychotic.
63
152610
2769
02:51
I hasten to add that it's my experience,
64
155379
2480
02:53
because everyone becomes psychotic in his or her own way.
65
157859
2656
02:56
Let's start with the definition of schizophrenia.
66
160515
3061
02:59
Schizophrenia is a brain disease.
67
163576
2221
03:01
Its defining feature is psychosis, or being
68
165797
2425
03:04
out of touch with reality.
69
168222
1592
03:05
Delusions and hallucinations
70
169814
1822
03:07
are hallmarks of the illness.
71
171636
1554
03:09
Delusions are fixed and false beliefs that aren't responsive
72
173190
2752
03:11
to evidence, and hallucinations are false sensory experiences.
73
175942
3816
03:15
For example, when I'm psychotic I often have
74
179758
2350
03:18
the delusion that I've killed hundreds of thousands
75
182108
2251
03:20
of people with my thoughts.
76
184359
1577
03:21
I sometimes have the idea that
77
185936
1705
03:23
nuclear explosions are about to be set off in my brain.
78
187641
2495
03:26
Occasionally, I have hallucinations,
79
190136
2336
03:28
like one time I turned around and saw a man
80
192472
1768
03:30
with a raised knife.
81
194240
1577
03:31
Imagine having a nightmare while you're awake.
82
195817
2792
03:34
Often, speech and thinking become disorganized
83
198609
3210
03:37
to the point of incoherence.
84
201819
1546
03:39
Loose associations involves putting together words
85
203365
2879
03:42
that may sound a lot alike but don't make sense,
86
206244
2783
03:44
and if the words get jumbled up enough, it's called "word salad."
87
209027
2390
03:47
Contrary to what many people think, schizophrenia is not
88
211417
4438
03:51
the same as multiple personality disorder or split personality.
89
215855
3415
03:55
The schizophrenic mind is not split, but shattered.
90
219270
3551
03:58
Everyone has seen a street person,
91
222821
2579
04:01
unkempt, probably ill-fed,
92
225400
2023
04:03
standing outside of an office building muttering
93
227423
2577
04:05
to himself or shouting.
94
230000
1813
04:07
This person is likely to have some form of schizophrenia.
95
231813
2597
04:10
But schizophrenia presents itself across a wide array
96
234410
2331
04:12
of socioeconomic status, and there are people
97
236741
2824
04:15
with the illness who are full-time professionals
98
239565
2530
04:17
with major responsibilities.
99
242095
2352
04:20
Several years ago, I decided
100
244447
1211
04:21
to write down my experiences and my personal journey,
101
245658
3435
04:24
and I want to share some more of that story with you today
102
249093
2298
04:27
to convey the inside view.
103
251391
1663
04:28
So the following episode happened the seventh week
104
253054
2785
04:31
of my first semester of my first year at Yale Law School.
105
255839
2863
04:34
Quoting from my writings:
106
258702
2205
04:36
"My two classmates, Rebel and Val, and I had made the date
107
260907
3469
04:40
to meet in the law school library on Friday night
108
264376
2961
04:43
to work on our memo assignment together.
109
267337
2284
04:45
But we didn't get far before I was talking in ways
110
269621
1802
04:47
that made no sense.
111
271423
1523
04:48
'Memos are visitations,' I informed them.
112
272946
3064
04:51
'They make certain points. The point is on your head.
113
276010
2520
04:54
Pat used to say that. Have you killed you anyone?'
114
278530
2455
04:56
Rebel and Val looked at me
115
280985
2016
04:58
as if they or I had been
116
283001
1671
05:00
splashed in the face with cold water.
117
284672
1580
05:02
'What are you talking about, Elyn?'
118
286252
1556
05:03
'Oh, you know, the usual. Who's what, what's who,
119
287808
3009
05:06
heaven and hell. Let's go out on the roof.
120
290817
2255
05:08
It's a flat surface. It's safe.'
121
293072
1576
05:10
Rebel and Val followed
122
294648
1584
05:12
and they asked what had gotten into me.
123
296232
1449
05:13
'This is the real me,' I announced,
124
297681
1863
05:15
waving my arms above my head.
125
299544
1545
05:16
And then, late on a Friday night, on the roof
126
301089
2775
05:19
of the Yale Law School,
127
303864
1157
05:20
I began to sing, and not quietly either.
128
305021
2292
05:23
'Come to the Florida sunshine bush.
129
307313
3104
05:26
Do you want to dance?'
130
310417
1311
05:27
'Are you on drugs?' one asked. 'Are you high?'
131
311728
2475
05:30
'High? Me? No way, no drugs.
132
314203
2456
05:32
Come to the Florida sunshine bush,
133
316659
2567
05:35
where there are lemons, where they make demons.'
134
319226
3273
05:38
'You're frightening me,' one of them said, and Rebel and Val
135
322499
2694
05:41
headed back into the library.
136
325193
1779
05:42
I shrugged and followed them.
137
326972
2117
05:44
Back inside, I asked my classmates if they were
138
329089
3367
05:48
having the same experience of words jumping around
139
332456
2217
05:50
our cases as I was.
140
334673
1344
05:51
'I think someone's infiltrated my copies of the cases,' I said.
141
336017
4023
05:55
'We've got to case the joint.
142
340040
1504
05:57
I don't believe in joints, but
143
341544
1583
05:59
they do hold your body together.'" --
144
343127
1465
06:00
It's an example of loose associations. --
145
344592
2369
06:02
"Eventually I made my way back to my dorm room,
146
346961
2384
06:05
and once there, I couldn't settle down.
147
349345
2359
06:07
My head was too full of noise,
148
351704
1825
06:09
too full of orange trees and law memos I could not write
149
353529
3687
06:13
and mass murders I knew I would be responsible for.
150
357216
2632
06:15
Sitting on my bed, I rocked back and forth,
151
359848
3345
06:19
moaning in fear and isolation."
152
363193
2032
06:21
This episode led to my first hospitalization in America.
153
365225
3127
06:24
I had two earlier in England.
154
368352
2240
06:26
Continuing with the writings:
155
370592
1561
06:28
"The next morning I went to my professor's office to ask
156
372153
2464
06:30
for an extension on the memo assignment,
157
374617
1577
06:32
and I began gibbering unintelligably
158
376194
2157
06:34
as I had the night before,
159
378351
1346
06:35
and he eventually brought me to the emergency room.
160
379697
1673
06:37
Once there, someone I'll just call 'The Doctor'
161
381370
3801
06:41
and his whole team of goons swooped down,
162
385171
1967
06:43
lifted me high into the air,
163
387138
1409
06:44
and slammed me down on a metal bed
164
388547
1673
06:46
with such force that I saw stars.
165
390220
2352
06:48
Then they strapped my legs and arms to the metal bed
166
392572
2558
06:51
with thick leather straps.
167
395130
1667
06:52
A sound came out of my mouth that I'd never heard before:
168
396797
3346
06:56
half groan, half scream,
169
400143
2028
06:58
barely human and pure terror.
170
402171
3344
07:01
Then the sound came again,
171
405515
1671
07:03
forced from somewhere deep inside my belly
172
407186
1924
07:05
and scraping my throat raw."
173
409110
1597
07:06
This incident resulted in my involuntary hospitalization.
174
410707
4279
07:10
One of the reasons the doctors gave for hospitalizing me
175
414986
3541
07:14
against my will was that I was
176
418527
1285
07:15
"gravely disabled."
177
419812
1407
07:17
To support this view, they wrote in my chart that I was unable
178
421219
3096
07:20
to do my Yale Law School homework.
179
424315
1792
07:22
I wondered what that meant about much of the rest of New Haven.
180
426107
3041
07:25
(Laughter)
181
429148
1606
07:26
During the next year, I would
182
430754
2689
07:29
spend five months in a psychiatric hospital.
183
433443
2152
07:31
At times, I spent up to 20 hours in mechanical restraints,
184
435595
3479
07:34
arms tied, arms and legs tied down,
185
439074
3490
07:38
arms and legs tied down with a net tied
186
442564
2519
07:40
tightly across my chest.
187
445083
1808
07:42
I never struck anyone.
188
446891
2047
07:44
I never harmed anyone. I never made any direct threats.
189
448938
2906
07:47
If you've never been restrained yourself, you may have
190
451844
2774
07:50
a benign image of the experience.
191
454618
2697
07:53
There's nothing benign about it.
192
457315
1975
07:55
Every week in the United States,
193
459290
1785
07:56
it's been estimated that one to three people die in restraints.
194
461075
2920
07:59
They strangle, they aspirate their vomit,
195
463995
2616
08:02
they suffocate, they have a heart attack.
196
466611
2153
08:04
It's unclear whether using mechanical restraints
197
468764
2526
08:07
is actually saving lives or costing lives.
198
471290
2520
08:09
While I was preparing to write my student note
199
473810
2794
08:12
for the Yale Law Journal on mechanical restraints,
200
476604
2200
08:14
I consulted an eminent law professor who was also
201
478804
2352
08:17
a psychiatrist,
202
481156
1085
08:18
and said surely he would agree
203
482241
1713
08:19
that restraints must be degrading,
204
483954
2296
08:22
painful and frightening.
205
486250
1536
08:23
He looked at me in a knowing way, and said,
206
487786
2111
08:25
"Elyn, you don't really understand:
207
489897
2329
08:28
These people are psychotic.
208
492226
1738
08:29
They're different from me and you.
209
493964
1521
08:31
They wouldn't experience restraints as we would."
210
495485
2764
08:34
I didn't have the courage to tell him in that moment that,
211
498249
2834
08:36
no, we're not that different from him.
212
501083
2001
08:38
We don't like to be strapped down to a bed
213
503084
2358
08:41
and left to suffer for hours any more than he would.
214
505442
2330
08:43
In fact, until very recently,
215
507772
2152
08:45
and I'm sure some people still hold it as a view,
216
509924
1982
08:47
that restraints help psychiatric patients feel safe.
217
511906
3032
08:50
I've never met a psychiatric patient
218
514938
2432
08:53
who agreed with that view.
219
517370
1394
08:54
Today, I'd like to say I'm very pro-psychiatry
220
518764
2711
08:57
but very anti-force.
221
521475
1503
08:58
I don't think force is effective as treatment, and I think
222
522978
2991
09:01
using force is a terrible thing to do to another person
223
525969
2737
09:04
with a terrible illness.
224
528706
1359
09:05
Eventually, I came to Los Angeles
225
530065
2721
09:08
to teach at the University of Southern California Law School.
226
532786
2498
09:11
For years, I had resisted medication,
227
535284
2320
09:13
making many, many efforts to get off.
228
537604
1990
09:15
I felt that if I could manage without medication,
229
539594
2675
09:18
I could prove that, after all,
230
542269
2038
09:20
I wasn't really mentally ill, it was some terrible mistake.
231
544307
2750
09:22
My motto was the less medicine, the less defective.
232
547057
3307
09:26
My L.A. analyst, Dr. Kaplan, was urging me
233
550364
3088
09:29
just to stay on medication and get on with my life,
234
553452
2500
09:31
but I decided I wanted to make one last college try to get off.
235
555952
3475
09:35
Quoting from the text:
236
559427
1432
09:36
"I started the reduction of my meds, and within a short time
237
560859
3640
09:40
I began feeling the effects.
238
564499
2112
09:42
After returning from a trip to Oxford, I marched into
239
566611
2841
09:45
Kaplan's office, headed straight for the corner, crouched down,
240
569452
3377
09:48
covered my face, and began shaking.
241
572829
2233
09:50
All around me I sensed evil beings poised with daggers.
242
575062
3155
09:54
They'd slice me up in thin slices
243
578217
2168
09:56
or make me swallow hot coals.
244
580385
1642
09:57
Kaplan would later describe me as 'writhing in agony.'
245
582027
3377
10:01
Even in this state, what he accurately described as
246
585404
3085
10:04
acutely and forwardly psychotic,
247
588489
1691
10:06
I refused to take more medication.
248
590180
2013
10:08
The mission is not yet complete.
249
592193
2800
10:10
Immediately after the appointment with Kaplan,
250
594993
2618
10:13
I went to see Dr. Marder, a schizophrenia expert
251
597611
2298
10:15
who was following me for medication side effects.
252
599909
2308
10:18
He was under the impression that I had a mild psychotic illness.
253
602217
3021
10:21
Once in his office, I sat on his couch, folded over,
254
605238
3428
10:24
and began muttering.
255
608666
1639
10:26
'Head explosions and people trying to kill.
256
610305
2230
10:28
Is it okay if I totally trash your office?'
257
612535
2465
10:30
'You need to leave if you think you're going to do that,'
258
615000
2632
10:33
said Marder.
259
617632
983
10:34
'Okay. Small. Fire on ice. Tell them not to kill me.
260
618615
3152
10:37
Tell them not to kill me. What have I done wrong?
261
621767
1648
10:39
Hundreds of thousands with thoughts, interdiction.'
262
623415
2577
10:41
'Elyn, do you feel like you're
263
625992
1735
10:43
dangerous to yourself or others?
264
627727
1497
10:45
I think you need to be in the hospital.
265
629224
2415
10:47
I could get you admitted right away, and the whole thing
266
631639
1857
10:49
could be very discrete.'
267
633496
1135
10:50
'Ha, ha, ha.
268
634631
1681
10:52
You're offering to put me in hospitals?
269
636312
2337
10:54
Hospitals are bad, they're mad, they're sad.
270
638649
2943
10:57
One must stay away. I'm God, or I used to be.'"
271
641592
3664
11:01
At that point in the text,
272
645256
1583
11:02
where I said "I'm God, or I used to be," my husband
273
646839
1905
11:04
made a marginal note.
274
648744
1025
11:05
He said, "Did you quit or were you fired?"
275
649769
1607
11:07
(Laughter)
276
651376
2231
11:09
"'I give life and I take it away.
277
653607
3752
11:13
Forgive me, for I know not what I do.'
278
657359
1697
11:14
Eventually, I broke down in front of friends, and
279
659056
3314
11:18
everybody convinced me to take more medication.
280
662370
2508
11:20
I could no longer deny the truth,
281
664878
1946
11:22
and I could not change it.
282
666824
1522
11:24
The wall that kept me, Elyn, Professor Saks,
283
668346
2649
11:26
separate from that insane woman hospitalized years past,
284
670995
3113
11:30
lay smashed and in ruins."
285
674108
2111
11:32
Everything about this illness says I shouldn't be here,
286
676219
2673
11:34
but I am. And I am, I think, for three reasons:
287
678892
2874
11:37
First, I've had excellent treatment.
288
681766
2392
11:40
Four- to five-day-a-week psychoanalytic psychotherapy
289
684158
2946
11:43
for decades and continuing, and excellent psychopharmacology.
290
687104
2984
11:45
Second, I have many close family members and friends who know me
291
690088
4044
11:50
and know my illness.
292
694132
1254
11:51
These relationships have given my life a meaning
293
695386
2324
11:53
and a depth, and they also helped me navigate
294
697710
2167
11:55
my life in the face of symptoms.
295
699877
1968
11:57
Third, I work at an enormously supportive workplace
296
701845
3168
12:00
at USC Law School.
297
705013
1585
12:02
This is a place that not only accommodates my needs
298
706598
3025
12:05
but actually embraces them.
299
709623
1391
12:06
It's also a very intellectually stimulating place,
300
711014
3031
12:09
and occupying my mind with complex problems
301
714045
2592
12:12
has been my best and most powerful and most reliable
302
716637
3433
12:15
defense against my mental illness.
303
720070
1720
12:17
Even with all that — excellent treatment, wonderful family and
304
721790
3303
12:20
friends, supportive work environment —
305
725093
1916
12:22
I did not make my illness public
306
727009
2333
12:25
until relatively late in life,
307
729342
1433
12:26
and that's because the stigma against mental illness
308
730775
2519
12:29
is so powerful that I didn't feel safe with people knowing.
309
733294
2608
12:31
If you hear nothing else today,
310
735902
2416
12:34
please hear this: There are not "schizophrenics."
311
738318
3434
12:37
There are people with schizophrenia, and these people
312
741752
3151
12:40
may be your spouse, they may be your child,
313
744903
2095
12:42
they may be your neighbor, they may be your friend,
314
746998
2424
12:45
they may be your coworker.
315
749422
1424
12:46
So let me share some final thoughts.
316
750846
2856
12:49
We need to invest more resources into research and treatment
317
753702
3432
12:53
of mental illness.
318
757134
1240
12:54
The better we understand these illnesses, the better
319
758374
2056
12:56
the treatments we can provide, and the better the treatments
320
760430
2208
12:58
we can provide, the more we can offer people care,
321
762638
2440
13:00
and not have to use force.
322
765078
1448
13:02
Also, we must stop criminalizing mental illness.
323
766526
2952
13:05
It's a national tragedy and scandal that the L.A. County Jail
324
769478
4048
13:09
is the biggest psychiatric facility in the United States.
325
773526
2642
13:12
American prisons and jails are filled with people who suffer
326
776168
3916
13:15
from severe mental illness, and many of them are there
327
780084
2484
13:18
because they never received adequate treatment.
328
782568
1977
13:20
I could have easily ended up there or on the streets myself.
329
784545
3429
13:23
A message to the entertainment industry and to the press:
330
787974
3224
13:27
On the whole, you've done a wonderful job fighting stigma
331
791198
4064
13:31
and prejudice of many kinds.
332
795262
1816
13:32
Please, continue to let us see characters in your movies,
333
797078
3000
13:35
your plays, your columns,
334
800078
2128
13:38
who suffer with severe mental illness.
335
802206
1824
13:39
Portray them sympathetically,
336
804030
1760
13:41
and portray them in all the richness and depth
337
805790
2639
13:44
of their experience as people and not as diagnoses.
338
808429
3527
13:47
Recently, a friend posed a question:
339
811956
2276
13:50
If there were a pill I could take
340
814232
1775
13:51
that would instantly cure me, would I take it?
341
816007
1811
13:53
The poet Rainer Maria Rilke
342
817818
2693
13:56
was offered psychoanalysis.
343
820511
1472
13:57
He declined, saying, "Don't take my devils away,
344
821983
2312
14:00
because my angels may flee too."
345
824295
1759
14:01
My psychosis, on the other hand,
346
826054
2193
14:04
is a waking nightmare in which my devils are so terrifying
347
828247
2672
14:06
that all my angels have already fled.
348
830919
1936
14:08
So would I take the pill? In an instant.
349
832855
3904
14:12
That said, I don't wish to be seen as regretting
350
836759
2681
14:15
the life I could have had if I'd not been mentally ill,
351
839440
2393
14:17
nor am I asking anyone for their pity.
352
841833
2282
14:20
What I rather wish to say is that the humanity we all share
353
844115
3131
14:23
is more important than the mental illness we may not.
354
847261
2618
14:25
What those of us who suffer with mental illness want
355
849879
2458
14:28
is what everybody wants:
356
852337
1454
14:29
in the words of Sigmund Freud, "to work and to love."
357
853791
2534
14:32
Thank you. (Applause)
358
856325
3023
14:35
(Applause)
359
859348
677
14:35
Thank you. Thank you. You're very kind. (Applause)
360
860025
4793
14:40
Thank you. (Applause)
361
864818
6607
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Elyn Saks - Mental health law scholarElyn Saks asks bold questions about how society treats people with mental illness.
Why you should listen
As a law scholar and writer, Elyn Saks speaks for the rights of mentally ill people. It's a gray area: Too often, society's first impulse is to make decisions on their behalf. But it's a slippery slope from in loco parentis to a denial of basic human rights. Saks has brilliantly argued for more autonomy -- and in many cases for a restoration of basic human dignity.
In 2007, deep into her career, she dropped a bombshell -- her autobiography, The Center Cannot Hold. In it, she reveals the depth of her own schizophrenia, now controlled by drugs and therapy. Clear-eyed and honest about her own condition, the book lent her new ammunition in the quest to protect the rights and dignity of the mentally ill.
In 2009, she was selected as a MacArthur Fellow.
Read more on io9.com: I’m Elyn Saks and this is what it’s like to live with schizophrenia »
Elyn Saks | Speaker | TED.com