TED2013
Denise Herzing: Could we speak the language of dolphins?
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
1,536,620 views
For 28 years, Denise Herzing has spent five months each summer living with a pod of Atlantic spotted dolphins, following three generations of family relationships and behaviors. It's clear they are communicating with one another -- but is it language? Could humans use it too? She shares a fascinating new experiment to test this idea.
Denise Herzing - Dolphin researcher
Denise Herzing has spent almost three decades researching and communicating with wild dolphins in their natural setting and on their own terms. The book "Dolphin Diaries" tells her remarkable story. Full bio
Denise Herzing has spent almost three decades researching and communicating with wild dolphins in their natural setting and on their own terms. The book "Dolphin Diaries" tells her remarkable story. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Well, now we're going to the Bahamas to meet
0
567
2277
00:14
a remarkable group of dolphins that I've been working with
1
2844
2243
00:17
in the wild for the last 28 years.
2
5087
3467
00:20
Now I'm interested in dolphins because of their large brains
3
8554
3195
00:23
and what they might be doing with all that brainpower
4
11749
2114
00:25
in the wild.
5
13863
1475
00:27
And we know they use some of that brainpower
6
15338
2272
00:29
for just living complicated lives,
7
17610
2164
00:31
but what do we really know about dolphin intelligence?
8
19774
2860
00:34
Well, we know a few things.
9
22634
1704
00:36
We know that their brain-to-body ratio,
10
24338
2189
00:38
which is a physical measure of intelligence,
11
26527
1970
00:40
is second only to humans.
12
28497
2496
00:42
Cognitively, they can understand
13
30993
1558
00:44
artificially-created languages.
14
32551
2429
00:46
And they pass self-awareness tests in mirrors.
15
34980
3141
00:50
And in some parts of the world, they use tools,
16
38121
2104
00:52
like sponges to hunt fish.
17
40225
2315
00:54
But there's one big question left:
18
42540
2651
00:57
do they have a language, and if so,
19
45191
1867
00:59
what are they talking about?
20
47058
2404
01:01
So decades ago, not years ago,
21
49462
3443
01:04
I set out to find a place in the world
22
52905
2163
01:07
where I could observe dolphins underwater
23
55068
1798
01:08
to try to crack the code of their communication system.
24
56866
3243
01:12
Now in most parts of the world, the water's pretty murky,
25
60109
2614
01:14
so it's very hard to observe animals underwater,
26
62723
3239
01:17
but I found a community of dolphins that live
27
65962
1759
01:19
in these beautiful, clear, shallow sandbanks of the Bahamas
28
67721
3026
01:22
which are just east of Florida.
29
70747
2242
01:24
And they spend their daytime resting and socializing
30
72989
2411
01:27
in the safety of the shallows, but at night,
31
75400
1870
01:29
they go off the edge and hunt in deep water.
32
77270
3799
01:33
Now, it's not a bad place to be a researcher, either.
33
81069
3824
01:36
So we go out for about five months every summer
34
84893
2176
01:39
in a 20-meter catamaran, and we live, sleep and work
35
87069
4202
01:43
at sea for weeks at a time.
36
91271
2078
01:45
My main tool is an underwater video with a hydrophone,
37
93349
2640
01:47
which is an underwater microphone, and this is so
38
95989
1950
01:49
I can correlate sound and behavior.
39
97939
2094
01:52
And most of our work's pretty non-invasive.
40
100033
1646
01:53
We try to follow dolphin etiquette while we're in the water,
41
101679
2822
01:56
since we're actually observing them physically in the water.
42
104501
3128
01:59
Now, Atlantic spotted dolphins are a really nice species
43
107629
3140
02:02
to work with for a couple of reasons.
44
110769
1964
02:04
They're born without spots, and they get spots with age,
45
112733
2931
02:07
and they go through pretty distinct developmental phases,
46
115664
3034
02:10
so that's fun to track their behavior.
47
118698
1942
02:12
And by about the age of 15, they're fully spotted black and white.
48
120640
3453
02:16
Now the mother you see here is Mugsy.
49
124093
2423
02:18
She's 35 years old in this shot,
50
126516
1985
02:20
but dolphins can actually live into their early 50s.
51
128501
3190
02:23
And like all the dolphins in our community,
52
131691
3303
02:26
we photographed Mugsy and tracked her little spots
53
134994
2771
02:29
and nicks in her dorsal fin,
54
137765
1742
02:31
and also the unique spot patterns
55
139507
2203
02:33
as she matured over time.
56
141710
2343
02:36
Now, young dolphins learn a lot as they're growing up,
57
144053
2659
02:38
and they use their teenage years to practice social skills,
58
146712
3075
02:41
and at about the age of nine, the females
59
149787
2353
02:44
become sexually mature, so they can get pregnant,
60
152140
2670
02:46
and the males mature quite a bit later,
61
154810
1971
02:48
at around 15 years of age.
62
156781
2115
02:50
And dolphins are very promiscuous,
63
158896
1740
02:52
and so we have to determine who the fathers are,
64
160636
2862
02:55
so we do paternity tests by collecting fecal material
65
163498
2454
02:57
out of the water and extracting DNA.
66
165952
2864
03:00
So what that means is, after 28 years,
67
168816
2464
03:03
we are tracking three generations,
68
171280
2408
03:05
including grandmothers and grandfathers.
69
173688
2344
03:08
Now, dolphins are natural acousticians.
70
176032
2616
03:10
They make sounds 10 times as high
71
178648
2284
03:12
and hear sounds 10 times as high as we do.
72
180932
2188
03:15
But they have other communication signals they use.
73
183120
2595
03:17
They have good vision, so they use body postures to communicate.
74
185715
3341
03:21
They have taste, not smell.
75
189056
2200
03:23
And they have touch.
76
191256
2040
03:25
And sound can actually be felt in the water,
77
193296
2196
03:27
because the acoustic impedance of tissue and water's about the same.
78
195492
3031
03:30
So dolphins can buzz and tickle each other at a distance.
79
198523
3630
03:34
Now, we do know some things about how sounds are used
80
202153
2540
03:36
with certain behaviors.
81
204693
1409
03:38
Now, the signature whistle is a whistle
82
206102
2099
03:40
that's specific to an individual dolphin, and it's like a name. (Dolphin whistling noises)
83
208201
4699
03:44
And this is the best-studied sound,
84
212900
2176
03:47
because it's easy to measure, really,
85
215076
1629
03:48
and you'd find this whistle when mothers and calves
86
216705
1957
03:50
are reuniting, for example.
87
218662
2137
03:52
Another well studied sound are echolocation clicks.
88
220799
3058
03:55
This is the dolphin's sonar. (Dolphin echolocation noises)
89
223857
3246
03:59
And they use these clicks to hunt and feed.
90
227103
3317
04:02
But they can also tightly pack these clicks together
91
230420
2388
04:04
into buzzes and use them socially.
92
232808
2135
04:06
For example, males will stimulate a female
93
234943
1978
04:08
during a courtship chase.
94
236921
2504
04:11
You know, I've been buzzed in the water.
95
239425
2327
04:13
(Laughter)
96
241752
1932
04:15
Don't tell anyone. It's a secret.
97
243684
2381
04:18
And you can really feel the sound. That was my point with that.
98
246065
2296
04:20
(Laughter)
99
248361
3732
04:24
So dolphins are also political animals,
100
252093
2525
04:26
so they have to resolve conflicts.
101
254618
2311
04:28
(Dolphin noises)
102
256929
1643
04:30
And they use these burst-pulsed sounds as well as
103
258572
2373
04:32
their head-to-head behaviors when they're fighting.
104
260945
2408
04:35
And these are very unstudied sounds
105
263353
2072
04:37
because they're hard to measure.
106
265425
2138
04:39
Now this is some video of a typical dolphin fight.
107
267563
2719
04:42
(Dolphin noises)
108
270282
2021
04:44
So you're going to see two groups,
109
272303
2090
04:46
and you're going to see the head-to-head posturing,
110
274393
2208
04:48
some open mouths,
111
276601
3344
04:51
lots of squawking.
112
279945
2156
04:54
There's a bubble.
113
282101
3585
04:57
And basically, one of these groups will kind of back off
114
285686
2583
05:00
and everything will resolve fine,
115
288269
1654
05:01
and it doesn't really escalate into violence too much.
116
289923
3660
05:05
Now, in the Bahamas, we also have resident bottlenose
117
293583
2304
05:07
that interact socially with the spotted dolphins.
118
295887
2944
05:10
For example, they babysit each other's calves.
119
298831
2711
05:13
The males have dominance displays that they use
120
301542
2177
05:15
when they're chasing each other's females.
121
303719
2400
05:18
And the two species actually form temporary alliances
122
306119
2422
05:20
when they're chasing sharks away.
123
308541
2378
05:22
And one of the mechanisms they use to communicate
124
310919
2911
05:25
their coordination is synchrony.
125
313830
2000
05:27
They synchronize their sounds and their body postures
126
315830
3111
05:30
to look bigger and sound stronger.
127
318941
2134
05:33
(Dolphins noises)
128
321075
1476
05:34
Now, these are bottlenose dolphins,
129
322551
2592
05:37
and you'll see them starting to synchronize
130
325143
1771
05:38
their behavior and their sounds.
131
326914
1901
05:40
(Dolphin noises)
132
328815
4368
05:45
You see, they're synchronizing with their partner
133
333183
2246
05:47
as well as the other dyad.
134
335429
3972
05:51
I wish I was that coordinated.
135
339401
2514
05:56
Now, it's important to remember that you're only hearing
136
344731
3074
05:59
the human-audible parts of dolphin sounds,
137
347805
1895
06:01
and dolphins make ultrasonic sounds,
138
349700
2163
06:03
and we use special equipment in the water
139
351863
1558
06:05
to collect these sounds.
140
353421
1737
06:07
Now, researchers have actually measured whistle complexity
141
355158
2565
06:09
using information theory,
142
357723
2063
06:11
and whistles rate very high relative to even human languages.
143
359786
3891
06:15
But burst-pulsed sounds is a bit of a mystery.
144
363677
3852
06:19
Now, these are three spectragrams.
145
367529
3087
06:22
Two are human words, and one is a dolphin vocalizing.
146
370616
2675
06:25
So just take a guess in your mind which one is the dolphin.
147
373291
3872
06:31
Now, it turns out burst-pulsed sounds actually look
148
379150
2593
06:33
a bit like human phonemes.
149
381743
2504
06:36
Now, one way to crack the code
150
384247
1266
06:37
is to interpret these signals and figure out what they mean,
151
385513
2545
06:40
but it's a difficult job, and we actually don't have a Rosetta Stone yet.
152
388058
3998
06:44
But a second way to crack the code
153
392056
2122
06:46
is to develop some technology,
154
394178
1965
06:48
an interface to do two-way communication,
155
396143
2180
06:50
and that's what we've been trying to do in the Bahamas
156
398323
2364
06:52
and in real time.
157
400687
2440
06:55
Now, scientists have used keyboard interfaces
158
403127
2656
06:57
to try to bridge the gap with species
159
405783
2064
06:59
including chimpanzees and dolphins.
160
407847
2088
07:01
This underwater keyboard in Orlando, Florida,
161
409935
3025
07:04
at the Epcot Center, was actually
162
412960
1742
07:06
the most sophisticated ever two-way interface designed
163
414702
2817
07:09
for humans and dolphins to work together under the water
164
417519
2864
07:12
and exchange information.
165
420383
1927
07:14
So we wanted to develop an interface like this
166
422310
2620
07:16
in the Bahamas, but in a more natural setting.
167
424930
2370
07:19
And one of the reasons we thought we could do this
168
427300
2167
07:21
is because the dolphins were starting to show us
169
429467
2022
07:23
a lot of mutual curiosity.
170
431489
1604
07:25
They were spontaneously mimicking our vocalizations
171
433093
2911
07:28
and our postures, and they were also inviting us
172
436004
2320
07:30
into dolphin games.
173
438324
2633
07:32
Now, dolphins are social mammals, so they love to play,
174
440957
2647
07:35
and one of their favorite games is to drag seaweed,
175
443604
3320
07:38
or sargassum in this case, around.
176
446924
3112
07:42
And they're very adept. They like to drag it
177
450036
2136
07:44
and drop it from appendage to appendage.
178
452172
4320
07:48
Now in this footage, the adult is Caroh.
179
456492
2696
07:51
She's 25 years old here, and this is her newborn, Cobalt,
180
459188
3872
07:55
and he's just learning how to play this game.
181
463060
2684
07:57
(Dolphin noises)
182
465744
1726
07:59
She's kind of teasing him and taunting him.
183
467470
4470
08:03
He really wants that sargassum.
184
471940
4429
08:08
Now, when dolphins solicit humans for this game,
185
476369
2911
08:11
they'll often sink vertically in the water,
186
479280
3051
08:14
and they'll have a little sargassum on their flipper,
187
482331
2429
08:16
and they'll sort of nudge it and drop it sometimes
188
484760
2619
08:19
on the bottom and let us go get it,
189
487379
1534
08:20
and then we'll have a little seaweed keep away game.
190
488913
2216
08:23
But when we don't dive down and get it,
191
491129
1836
08:24
they'll bring it to the surface
192
492965
1973
08:26
and they'll sort of wave it in front of us on their tail
193
494938
3174
08:30
and drop it for us like they do their calves,
194
498112
2086
08:32
and then we'll pick it up and have a game.
195
500198
2202
08:34
And so we started thinking, well, wouldn't it be neat
196
502400
2350
08:36
to build some technology that would allow the dolphins
197
504750
2818
08:39
to request these things in real time, their favorite toys?
198
507568
3275
08:42
So the original vision was to have a keyboard
199
510843
2370
08:45
hanging from the boat attached to a computer,
200
513213
2173
08:47
and the divers and dolphins would activate the keys
201
515386
2515
08:49
on the keypad and happily exchange information
202
517901
2890
08:52
and request toys from each other.
203
520791
2158
08:54
But we quickly found out that dolphins simply
204
522949
1794
08:56
were not going to hang around the boat using a keyboard.
205
524743
3126
08:59
They've got better things to do in the wild.
206
527869
2136
09:02
They might do it in captivity, but in the wild --
207
530005
2264
09:04
So we built a portable keyboard that we could push through the water,
208
532269
2725
09:06
and we labeled four objects they like to play with,
209
534994
2740
09:09
the scarf, rope, sargassum, and also had a bow ride,
210
537734
2941
09:12
which is a fun activity for a dolphin. (Whistle)
211
540675
2111
09:14
And that's the scarf whistle,
212
542786
1843
09:16
which is also associated with a visual symbol.
213
544629
2918
09:19
And these are artificially created whistles.
214
547547
2294
09:21
They're outside the dolphin's normal repertoire,
215
549841
2628
09:24
but they're easily mimicked by the dolphins.
216
552469
2420
09:26
And I spent four years with my colleagues Adam Pack and Fabienne Delfour,
217
554889
4179
09:31
working out in the field with this keyboard
218
559068
2221
09:33
using it with each other to do requests for toys
219
561289
2644
09:35
while the dolphins were watching.
220
563933
1659
09:37
And the dolphins could get in on the game.
221
565592
1367
09:38
They could point at the visual object,
222
566959
1935
09:40
or they could mimic the whistle.
223
568894
2474
09:43
Now this is video of a session.
224
571368
3368
09:46
The diver here has a rope toy,
225
574736
2201
09:48
and I'm on the keyboard on the left,
226
576937
2248
09:51
and I've just played the rope key,
227
579185
2648
09:53
and that's the request for the toy from the human.
228
581833
3211
09:57
So I've got the rope, I'm diving down,
229
585044
3203
10:00
and I'm basically trying to get the dolphin's attention,
230
588247
2634
10:02
because they're kind of like little kids.
231
590881
1068
10:03
You have to keep their attention.
232
591949
2557
10:06
I'm going to drop the rope, see if they come over.
233
594506
4687
10:11
Here they come,
234
599193
2504
10:13
and then they're going to pick up the rope
235
601697
1309
10:15
and drag it around as a toy.
236
603006
1606
10:16
Now, I'm at the keyboard on the left,
237
604612
1785
10:18
and this is actually the first time that we tried this.
238
606397
2310
10:20
I'm going to try to request this toy, the rope toy,
239
608707
2866
10:23
from the dolphins using the rope sound.
240
611573
2568
10:26
Let's see if they might actually understand what that means.
241
614141
4311
10:31
(Whistle)
242
619752
1226
10:32
That's the rope whistle.
243
620978
2700
10:35
Up come the dolphins,
244
623678
1297
10:36
and drop off the rope, yay. Wow.
245
624975
3605
10:40
(Applause)
246
628580
2984
10:43
So this is only once.
247
631564
1760
10:45
We don't know for sure if they really understand the function of the whistles.
248
633324
2808
10:48
Okay, so here's a second toy in the water.
249
636132
2468
10:50
This is a scarf toy, and I'm trying to lead the dolphin
250
638600
1789
10:52
over to the keyboard to show her
251
640389
2337
10:54
the visual and the acoustic signal.
252
642726
3190
10:57
Now this dolphin, we call her "the scarf thief,"
253
645916
3067
11:00
because over the years she's absconded
254
648983
3493
11:04
with about 12 scarves.
255
652476
2578
11:07
In fact, we think she has a boutique somewhere in the Bahamas.
256
655054
3774
11:10
So I'm reaching over. She's got the scarf on her right side.
257
658828
3694
11:14
And we try to not touch the animals too much,
258
662522
1764
11:16
we really don't want to over-habituate them.
259
664286
2136
11:18
And I'm trying to lead her back to the keyboard.
260
666422
2115
11:20
And the diver there is going to activate the scarf sound
261
668537
3946
11:24
to request the scarf.
262
672483
1811
11:26
So I try to give her the scarf.
263
674294
2749
11:29
Whoop. Almost lost it.
264
677043
2975
11:32
But this is the moment where everything becomes possible.
265
680018
2916
11:34
The dolphin's at the keyboard.
266
682934
1745
11:36
You've got full attention.
267
684679
1558
11:38
And this sometimes went on for hours.
268
686237
2256
11:40
And I wanted to share this video with you
269
688493
1455
11:41
not to show you any big breakthroughs,
270
689948
1785
11:43
because they haven't happened yet,
271
691733
1120
11:44
but to show you the level of intention and focus
272
692853
2626
11:47
that these dolphins have, and interest in the system.
273
695479
2647
11:50
And because of this, we really decided we needed
274
698126
2021
11:52
some more sophisticated technology.
275
700147
2094
11:54
So we joined forces with Georgia Tech,
276
702241
2200
11:56
with Thad Starner's wearable computing group,
277
704441
2676
11:59
to build us an underwater wearable computer
278
707117
1962
12:01
that we're calling CHAT. [CHAT: Cetacean Hearing And Telemetry]
279
709079
1866
12:02
Now, instead of pushing a keyboard through the water,
280
710945
2036
12:04
the diver's wearing the complete system, and it's acoustic only,
281
712981
3618
12:08
so basically the diver activates the sounds on a keypad
282
716599
3008
12:11
on the forearm,
283
719607
1179
12:12
the sounds go out through an underwater speaker,
284
720786
2188
12:14
if a dolphin mimics the whistle
285
722974
1410
12:16
or a human plays the whistle, the sounds come in
286
724384
2509
12:18
and are localized by two hydrophones.
287
726893
2576
12:21
The computer can localize who requested the toy
288
729469
3347
12:24
if there's a word match.
289
732816
2037
12:26
And the real power of the system is in the real-time
290
734853
2564
12:29
sound recognition, so we can respond to the dolphins
291
737417
1917
12:31
quickly and accurately.
292
739334
2127
12:33
And we're at prototype stage, but this is how we hope it will play out.
293
741461
4184
12:37
So Diver A and Diver B both have a wearable computer
294
745645
3278
12:40
and the dolphin hears the whistle as a whistle,
295
748923
2594
12:43
the diver hears the whistle as a whistle in the water,
296
751517
2480
12:45
but also as a word through bone conduction.
297
753997
2432
12:48
So Diver A plays the scarf whistle
298
756429
2249
12:50
or Diver B plays the sargassum whistle
299
758678
1896
12:52
to request a toy from whoever has it.
300
760574
2416
12:54
What we hope will happen is that the dolphin mimics the whistle,
301
762990
3209
12:58
and if Diver A has the sargassum, if that's the sound
302
766199
3170
13:01
that was played and requested,
303
769369
2745
13:04
then the diver will give the sargassum to the requesting dolphin
304
772114
3848
13:07
and they'll swim away happily into the sunset
305
775962
1816
13:09
playing sargassum for forever.
306
777778
3117
13:12
Now, how far can this kind of communication go?
307
780895
3380
13:16
Well, CHAT is designed specifically to empower the dolphins
308
784275
3889
13:20
to request things from us.
309
788164
1582
13:21
It's designed to really be two-way.
310
789746
2393
13:24
Now, will they learn to mimic the whistles functionally?
311
792139
3279
13:27
We hope so and we think so.
312
795418
1881
13:29
But as we decode their natural sounds,
313
797299
2144
13:31
we're also planning to put those back into the computerized system.
314
799443
3588
13:35
For example, right now we can put their own signature whistles
315
803031
3500
13:38
in the computer and request to interact with a specific dolphin.
316
806531
4095
13:42
Likewise, we can create our own whistles,
317
810626
3730
13:46
our own whistle names, and let the dolphins
318
814356
2319
13:48
request specific divers to interact with.
319
816675
2768
13:51
Now it may be that all our mobile technology
320
819443
2921
13:54
will actually be the same technology that helps us
321
822364
3136
13:57
communicate with another species down the road.
322
825500
3231
14:00
In the case of a dolphin, you know, it's a species that,
323
828731
3632
14:04
well, they're probably close to our intelligence in many ways
324
832363
3383
14:07
and we might not be able to admit that right now,
325
835746
2543
14:10
but they live in quite a different environment,
326
838289
1824
14:12
and you still have to bridge the gap with the sensory systems.
327
840113
4500
14:16
I mean, imagine what it would be like
328
844613
1684
14:18
to really understand the mind
329
846297
1609
14:19
of another intelligent species on the planet.
330
847906
3785
14:23
Thank you.
331
851691
1348
14:25
(Applause)
332
853039
4924
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Denise Herzing - Dolphin researcherDenise Herzing has spent almost three decades researching and communicating with wild dolphins in their natural setting and on their own terms. The book "Dolphin Diaries" tells her remarkable story.
Why you should listen
What better way to study an animal than in its natural habitat? Since 1985, Denise Herzing has been doing just that, spending each summer observing a pod of Atlantic spotted dolphins that live in the Bahamas as part of the Wild Dolphin Project. The work allows Herzing to better understand the pod's social structure, behavior, communication and habitat outside the confines of an aquarium or research facility.
Perhaps most remarkable is Herzing’s collaborative effort to design, build and use an interactive device to let humans communicate with the free-ranging dolphins. The 2011 book Dolphin Diaries tells her remarkable story.
Denise Herzing | Speaker | TED.com