TED Salon: Border Stories
Paul A. Kramer: Our immigration conversation is broken -- here's how to have a better one
Filmed:
Readability: 5.1
1,334,849 views
How did the US immigration debate get to be so divisive? In this informative talk, historian and writer Paul A. Kramer shows how an "insider vs. outsider" framing has come to dominate the way people in the US talk about immigration -- and suggests a set of new questions that could reshape the conversation around whose life, rights and thriving matters.
Paul A. Kramer - Historian, writer
Paul A. Kramer's work focuses on the changing relationships between the United States and the wider world. Full bio
Paul A. Kramer's work focuses on the changing relationships between the United States and the wider world. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
We often hear these days
that the immigration system is broken.
that the immigration system is broken.
0
472
4458
00:16
I want to make the case today that
our immigration conversation is broken
our immigration conversation is broken
1
4954
4646
00:21
and to suggest some ways that, together,
we might build a better one.
we might build a better one.
2
9624
4344
00:26
In order to do that, I'm going
to propose some new questions
to propose some new questions
3
14735
2899
00:29
about immigration,
4
17658
1364
00:31
the United States
5
19046
1206
00:32
and the world,
6
20276
1323
00:33
questions that might move the borders
of the immigration debate.
of the immigration debate.
7
21623
5046
00:39
I'm not going to begin with the feverish
argument that we're currently having,
argument that we're currently having,
8
27495
4160
00:43
even as the lives and well-being
of immigrants are being put at risk
of immigrants are being put at risk
9
31679
4510
00:48
at the US border and far beyond it.
10
36213
2756
00:51
Instead, I'm going to begin
with me in graduate school
with me in graduate school
11
39567
2634
00:54
in New Jersey in the mid-1990s,
earnestly studying US history,
earnestly studying US history,
12
42225
3680
00:57
which is what I currently teach
as a professor at Vanderbilt University
as a professor at Vanderbilt University
13
45929
3415
01:01
in Nashville, Tennessee.
14
49368
1752
01:03
And when I wasn't studying,
15
51602
1486
01:05
sometimes to avoid
writing my dissertation,
writing my dissertation,
16
53112
2244
01:07
my friends and I would go into town
17
55380
2823
01:10
to hand out neon-colored flyers,
protesting legislation
protesting legislation
18
58227
4837
01:15
that was threatening to take away
immigrants' rights.
immigrants' rights.
19
63088
3445
01:19
Our flyers were sincere,
they were well-meaning,
they were well-meaning,
20
67481
2808
01:22
they were factually accurate ...
21
70313
2224
01:24
But I realize now, they were also
kind of a problem.
kind of a problem.
22
72561
2595
01:27
Here's what they said:
23
75642
1173
01:28
"Don't take away immigrant rights
to public education,
to public education,
24
76839
4503
01:33
to medical services,
to the social safety net.
to the social safety net.
25
81366
2724
01:36
They work hard.
26
84114
1547
01:37
They pay taxes.
27
85685
1896
01:39
They're law-abiding.
28
87605
1855
01:41
They use social services
less than Americans do.
less than Americans do.
29
89484
2967
01:45
They're eager to learn English,
30
93054
2057
01:47
and their children serve
in the US military all over the world."
in the US military all over the world."
31
95135
4404
01:52
Now, these are, of course, arguments
that we hear every day.
that we hear every day.
32
100419
3499
01:55
Immigrants and their advocates use them
33
103942
3478
01:59
as they confront those who would
deny immigrants their rights
deny immigrants their rights
34
107444
3730
02:03
or even exclude them from society.
35
111198
2523
02:06
And up to a certain point,
it makes perfect sense
it makes perfect sense
36
114453
2645
02:09
that these would be the kinds of claims
that immigrants' defenders would turn to.
that immigrants' defenders would turn to.
37
117122
4822
02:14
But in the long term,
and maybe even in the short term,
and maybe even in the short term,
38
122595
3829
02:18
I think these arguments
can be counterproductive.
can be counterproductive.
39
126448
2851
02:21
Why?
40
129996
1505
02:23
Because it's always an uphill battle
41
131525
2088
02:25
to defend yourself
on your opponent's terrain.
on your opponent's terrain.
42
133637
3251
02:29
And, unwittingly, the handouts
my friends and I were handing out
my friends and I were handing out
43
137669
3964
02:33
and the versions of these arguments
that we hear today
that we hear today
44
141657
3394
02:37
were actually playing
the anti-immigrants game.
the anti-immigrants game.
45
145075
2769
02:40
We were playing that game
in part by envisioning
in part by envisioning
46
148701
2736
02:43
that immigrants were outsiders,
47
151461
2229
02:45
rather than, as I'm hoping
to suggest in a few minutes,
to suggest in a few minutes,
48
153714
3141
02:48
people that are already,
in important ways, on the inside.
in important ways, on the inside.
49
156879
4051
02:54
It's those who are hostile
to immigrants, the nativists,
to immigrants, the nativists,
50
162303
3537
02:57
who have succeeded
in framing the immigration debate
in framing the immigration debate
51
165864
2794
03:00
around three main questions.
52
168682
2207
03:03
First, there's the question of whether
immigrants can be useful tools.
immigrants can be useful tools.
53
171588
5069
03:09
How can we use immigrants?
54
177235
3517
03:12
Will they make us richer and stronger?
55
180776
4023
03:17
The nativist answer
to this question is no,
to this question is no,
56
185751
2916
03:20
immigrants have little
or nothing to offer.
or nothing to offer.
57
188691
2627
03:24
The second question is whether
immigrants are others.
immigrants are others.
58
192993
4208
03:30
Can immigrants become more like us?
59
198201
3385
03:34
Are they capable of becoming more like us?
60
202705
2666
03:37
Are they capable of assimilating?
61
205395
1633
03:39
Are they willing to assimilate?
62
207052
1743
03:41
Here, again, the nativist answer is no,
63
209477
2335
03:43
immigrants are permanently
different from us and inferior to us.
different from us and inferior to us.
64
211836
4384
03:49
And the third question is whether
immigrants are parasites.
immigrants are parasites.
65
217157
4627
03:54
Are they dangerous to us?
And will they drain our resources?
And will they drain our resources?
66
222745
3614
03:59
Here, the nativist answer is yes and yes,
67
227177
3580
04:02
immigrants pose a threat
and they sap our wealth.
and they sap our wealth.
68
230781
3345
04:07
I would suggest that these three questions
and the nativist animus behind them
and the nativist animus behind them
69
235761
4085
04:11
have succeeded in framing the larger
contours of the immigration debate.
contours of the immigration debate.
70
239870
4090
04:15
These questions are anti-immigrant
and nativist at their core,
and nativist at their core,
71
243984
4851
04:20
built around a kind of hierarchical
division of insiders and outsiders,
division of insiders and outsiders,
72
248859
5894
04:26
us and them,
73
254777
1563
04:28
in which only we matter,
74
256364
2650
04:31
and they don't.
75
259038
1256
04:33
And what gives these questions
traction and power
traction and power
76
261201
3416
04:36
beyond the circle of committed nativists
77
264641
2164
04:38
is the way they tap into an everyday,
seemingly harmless sense
seemingly harmless sense
78
266829
4647
04:43
of national belonging
79
271500
1727
04:45
and activate it, heighten it
80
273251
2665
04:47
and inflame it.
81
275940
1686
04:50
Nativists commit themselves
to making stark distinctions
to making stark distinctions
82
278740
4441
04:55
between insiders and outsiders.
83
283205
2514
04:57
But the distinction itself is at the heart
of the way nations define themselves.
of the way nations define themselves.
84
285743
4437
05:02
The fissures between inside and outside,
85
290658
3758
05:06
which often run deepest
along lines of race and religion,
along lines of race and religion,
86
294440
4682
05:11
are always there to be
deepened and exploited.
deepened and exploited.
87
299146
3312
05:15
And that potentially
gives nativist approaches resonance
gives nativist approaches resonance
88
303370
4123
05:19
far beyond those who consider
themselves anti-immigrant,
themselves anti-immigrant,
89
307517
3835
05:23
and remarkably, even among some
who consider themselves pro-immigrant.
who consider themselves pro-immigrant.
90
311376
4174
05:28
So, for example,
when Immigrants Act allies
when Immigrants Act allies
91
316325
4406
05:32
answer these questions
the nativists are posing,
the nativists are posing,
92
320755
3202
05:35
they take them seriously.
93
323981
1337
05:37
They legitimate those questions
and, to some extent,
and, to some extent,
94
325342
3155
05:40
the anti-immigrant assumptions
that are behind them.
that are behind them.
95
328521
3020
05:44
When we take these questions seriously
without even knowing it,
without even knowing it,
96
332414
3716
05:48
we're reinforcing the closed,
exclusionary borders
exclusionary borders
97
336154
3821
05:51
of the immigration conversation.
98
339999
2181
05:55
So how did we get here?
99
343458
1167
05:56
How did these become the leading ways
that we talk about immigration?
that we talk about immigration?
100
344649
4283
06:01
Here, we need some backstory,
101
349523
1429
06:02
which is where my history
training comes in.
training comes in.
102
350976
2332
06:05
During the first century of the US's
status as an independent nation,
status as an independent nation,
103
353332
6206
06:11
it did very little to restrict
immigration at the national level.
immigration at the national level.
104
359562
3712
06:15
In fact, many policymakers
and employers worked hard
and employers worked hard
105
363298
2525
06:17
to recruit immigrants
106
365847
2515
06:20
to build up industry
107
368386
1622
06:22
and to serve as settlers,
to seize the continent.
to seize the continent.
108
370032
3706
06:26
But after the Civil War,
109
374948
2589
06:29
nativist voices rose
in volume and in power.
in volume and in power.
110
377561
4994
06:35
The Asian, Latin American,
Caribbean and European immigrants
Caribbean and European immigrants
111
383371
4912
06:40
who dug Americans' canals,
112
388307
2774
06:43
cooked their dinners,
113
391105
1799
06:44
fought their wars
114
392928
1692
06:46
and put their children to bed at night
115
394644
2201
06:48
were met with a new
and intense xenophobia,
and intense xenophobia,
116
396869
3559
06:52
which cast immigrants
as permanent outsiders
as permanent outsiders
117
400452
3563
06:56
who should never be allowed
to become insiders.
to become insiders.
118
404039
3085
07:00
By the mid-1920s, the nativists had won,
119
408148
2717
07:02
erecting racist laws
120
410889
1722
07:04
that closed out untold numbers
of vulnerable immigrants and refugees.
of vulnerable immigrants and refugees.
121
412635
5619
07:11
Immigrants and their allies
did their best to fight back,
did their best to fight back,
122
419158
3173
07:14
but they found themselves
on the defensive,
on the defensive,
123
422355
2474
07:16
caught in some ways
in the nativists' frames.
in the nativists' frames.
124
424853
3217
07:20
When nativists said
that immigrants weren't useful,
that immigrants weren't useful,
125
428775
4834
07:25
their allies said yes, they are.
126
433633
2379
07:28
When nativists accused
immigrants of being others,
immigrants of being others,
127
436932
4942
07:33
their allies promised
that they would assimilate.
that they would assimilate.
128
441898
2536
07:37
When nativists charged that immigrants
were dangerous parasites,
were dangerous parasites,
129
445789
6030
07:43
their allies emphasized
their loyalty, their obedience,
their loyalty, their obedience,
130
451843
3108
07:46
their hard work and their thrift.
131
454975
2464
07:50
Even as advocates welcomed immigrants,
132
458293
3453
07:53
many still regarded immigrants
as outsiders to be pitied, to be rescued,
as outsiders to be pitied, to be rescued,
133
461770
6419
08:00
to be uplifted
134
468213
1811
08:02
and to be tolerated,
135
470048
2145
08:04
but never fully brought inside
as equals in rights and respect.
as equals in rights and respect.
136
472217
5872
08:11
After World War II, and especially
from the mid-1960s until really recently,
from the mid-1960s until really recently,
137
479194
6696
08:17
immigrants and their allies
turned the tide,
turned the tide,
138
485914
2357
08:20
overthrowing mid-20th century restriction
139
488295
3402
08:23
and winning instead a new system
that prioritized family reunification,
that prioritized family reunification,
140
491721
4596
08:28
the admission of refugees
141
496341
1619
08:29
and the admission of those
with special skills.
with special skills.
142
497984
2854
08:33
But even then,
143
501642
1170
08:34
they didn't succeed in fundamentally
changing the terms of the debate,
changing the terms of the debate,
144
502836
4622
08:39
and so that framework endured,
145
507482
2215
08:41
ready to be taken up again
in our own convulsive moment.
in our own convulsive moment.
146
509721
4907
08:47
That conversation is broken.
147
515744
2516
08:50
The old questions
are harmful and divisive.
are harmful and divisive.
148
518793
3888
08:55
So how do we get from that conversation
149
523486
2517
08:58
to one that's more likely to get us
closer to a world that is fairer,
closer to a world that is fairer,
150
526027
4549
09:02
that is more just,
151
530600
1571
09:04
that's more secure?
152
532195
1516
09:07
I want to suggest that what we have to do
153
535036
2339
09:09
is one of the hardest things
that any society can do:
that any society can do:
154
537399
3689
09:13
to redraw the boundaries of who counts,
155
541112
3977
09:17
of whose life, whose rights
156
545113
3174
09:20
and whose thriving matters.
157
548311
2497
09:23
We need to redraw the boundaries.
158
551485
2799
09:26
We need to redraw the borders of us.
159
554308
3439
09:31
In order to do that, we need to first
take on a worldview that's widely held
take on a worldview that's widely held
160
559242
5279
09:36
but also seriously flawed.
161
564545
2511
09:39
According to that worldview,
162
567080
2268
09:41
there's the inside of the national
boundaries, inside the nation,
boundaries, inside the nation,
163
569372
3707
09:45
which is where we live, work
and mind our own business.
and mind our own business.
164
573103
4131
09:49
And then there's the outside;
there's everywhere else.
there's everywhere else.
165
577766
3075
09:53
According to this worldview,
when immigrants cross into the nation,
when immigrants cross into the nation,
166
581635
3824
09:57
they're moving from
the outside to the inside,
the outside to the inside,
167
585483
2966
10:00
but they remain outsiders.
168
588473
2061
10:03
Any power or resources they receive
169
591145
4168
10:07
are gifts from us rather than rights.
170
595337
3407
10:11
Now, it's not hard to see why
this is such a commonly held worldview.
this is such a commonly held worldview.
171
599371
4841
10:16
It's reinforced in everyday ways
that we talk and act and behave,
that we talk and act and behave,
172
604236
3782
10:20
down to the bordered maps
that we hang up in our schoolrooms.
that we hang up in our schoolrooms.
173
608042
3355
10:23
The problem with this worldview
is that it just doesn't correspond
is that it just doesn't correspond
174
611727
3628
10:27
to the way the world actually works,
175
615379
2237
10:29
and the way it has worked in the past.
176
617640
2452
10:33
Of course, American workers
have built up wealth in society.
have built up wealth in society.
177
621111
4685
10:38
But so have immigrants,
178
626391
1192
10:39
particularly in parts of the American
economy that are indispensable
economy that are indispensable
179
627607
3854
10:43
and where few Americans work,
like agriculture.
like agriculture.
180
631485
2802
10:46
Since the nation's founding,
181
634840
1598
10:48
Americans have been inside
the American workforce.
the American workforce.
182
636462
4279
10:53
Of course, Americans have built up
institutions in society
institutions in society
183
641660
5322
10:59
that guarantee rights.
184
647006
1725
11:01
But so have immigrants.
185
649199
1476
11:02
They've been there during
every major social movement,
every major social movement,
186
650699
3372
11:06
like civil rights and organized labor,
187
654095
2456
11:08
that have fought to expand
rights in society for everyone.
rights in society for everyone.
188
656575
3295
11:12
So immigrants are already
inside the struggle
inside the struggle
189
660364
3448
11:15
for rights, democracy and freedom.
190
663836
2872
11:19
And finally, Americans
and other citizens of the Global North
and other citizens of the Global North
191
667979
4122
11:24
haven't minded their own business,
192
672125
2391
11:26
and they haven't stayed
within their own borders.
within their own borders.
193
674540
2342
11:28
They haven't respected
other nations' borders.
other nations' borders.
194
676906
2153
11:31
They've gone out into the world
with their armies,
with their armies,
195
679083
2335
11:33
they've taken over
territories and resources,
territories and resources,
196
681442
2456
11:35
and they've extracted enormous profits
from many of the countries
from many of the countries
197
683922
3671
11:39
that immigrants are from.
198
687617
1788
11:42
In this sense, many immigrants are
actually already inside American power.
actually already inside American power.
199
690402
5673
11:49
With this different map
of inside and outside in mind,
of inside and outside in mind,
200
697268
4888
11:54
the question isn't whether
receiving countries
receiving countries
201
702180
2939
11:57
are going to let immigrants in.
202
705143
2310
11:59
They're already in.
203
707899
1645
12:02
The question is whether
the United States and other countries
the United States and other countries
204
710033
2915
12:04
are going to give immigrants
access to the rights and resources
access to the rights and resources
205
712972
4058
12:09
that their work, their activism
and their home countries
and their home countries
206
717054
3955
12:13
have already played
a fundamental role in creating.
a fundamental role in creating.
207
721033
3782
12:18
With this new map in mind,
208
726468
2335
12:20
we can turn to a set of tough,
new, urgently needed questions,
new, urgently needed questions,
209
728827
4523
12:25
radically different from the ones
we've asked before --
we've asked before --
210
733374
3719
12:29
questions that might change
the borders of the immigration debate.
the borders of the immigration debate.
211
737117
4307
12:34
Our three questions are
about workers' rights,
about workers' rights,
212
742509
4265
12:38
about responsibility
213
746798
1675
12:40
and about equality.
214
748497
1769
12:44
First, we need to be asking
about workers' rights.
about workers' rights.
215
752933
2885
12:48
How do existing policies make it harder
for immigrants to defend themselves
for immigrants to defend themselves
216
756405
4290
12:52
and easier for them to be exploited,
217
760719
1872
12:54
driving down wages, rights
and protections for everyone?
and protections for everyone?
218
762615
3629
12:58
When immigrants are threatened
with roundups, detention and deportations,
with roundups, detention and deportations,
219
766742
3636
13:02
their employers know
that they can be abused,
that they can be abused,
220
770402
2112
13:04
that they can be told
that if they fight back,
that if they fight back,
221
772538
2429
13:06
they'll be turned over to ICE.
222
774991
1699
13:09
When employers know
223
777460
2250
13:11
that they can terrorize an immigrant
with his lack of papers,
with his lack of papers,
224
779734
3336
13:16
it makes that worker hyper-exploitable,
225
784161
2056
13:18
and that has impacts
not only for immigrant workers
not only for immigrant workers
226
786241
2852
13:21
but for all workers.
227
789117
1616
13:24
Second, we need to ask questions
about responsibility.
about responsibility.
228
792375
2986
13:28
What role have rich, powerful
countries like the United States
countries like the United States
229
796004
3926
13:31
played in making it hard or impossible
230
799954
2485
13:34
for immigrants to stay
in their home countries?
in their home countries?
231
802463
3073
13:38
Picking up and moving from your country
is difficult and dangerous,
is difficult and dangerous,
232
806331
3231
13:41
but many immigrants simply do not have
the option of staying home
the option of staying home
233
809586
3714
13:45
if they want to survive.
234
813324
2183
13:47
Wars, trade agreements
235
815531
1727
13:49
and consumer habits
rooted in the Global North
rooted in the Global North
236
817282
2650
13:51
play a major and devastating role here.
237
819956
4598
13:57
What responsibilities
do the United States,
do the United States,
238
825489
3051
14:00
the European Union and China --
239
828564
2029
14:02
the world's leading carbon emitters --
240
830617
2243
14:04
have to the millions of people
already uprooted by global warming?
already uprooted by global warming?
241
832884
4731
14:11
And third, we need to ask
questions about equality.
questions about equality.
242
839979
3017
14:15
Global inequality is a wrenching,
intensifying problem.
intensifying problem.
243
843569
4048
14:20
Income and wealth gaps
are widening around the world.
are widening around the world.
244
848037
3443
14:23
Increasingly, what determines
whether you're rich or poor,
whether you're rich or poor,
245
851504
3328
14:26
more than anything else,
246
854856
1315
14:28
is what country you're born in,
247
856195
1838
14:30
which might seem great
if you're from a prosperous country.
if you're from a prosperous country.
248
858057
3052
14:33
But it actually means
a profoundly unjust distribution
a profoundly unjust distribution
249
861133
4563
14:37
of the chances for a long,
healthy, fulfilling life.
healthy, fulfilling life.
250
865720
5053
14:43
When immigrants send money
or goods home to their family,
or goods home to their family,
251
871464
2687
14:46
it plays a significant role
in narrowing these gaps,
in narrowing these gaps,
252
874175
3149
14:49
if a very incomplete one.
253
877348
2043
14:51
It does more than all
of the foreign aid programs
of the foreign aid programs
254
879771
3035
14:54
in the world combined.
255
882830
1983
14:58
We began with the nativist questions,
256
886778
2571
15:01
about immigrants as tools,
257
889373
2610
15:04
as others
258
892007
1611
15:05
and as parasites.
259
893642
1341
15:07
Where might these new questions
about worker rights,
about worker rights,
260
895666
3490
15:11
about responsibility
261
899180
1597
15:12
and about equality
262
900801
1554
15:14
take us?
263
902379
1223
15:16
These questions reject pity,
and they embrace justice.
and they embrace justice.
264
904400
4970
15:21
These questions reject
the nativist and nationalist division
the nativist and nationalist division
265
909888
3726
15:25
of us versus them.
266
913638
1421
15:27
They're going to help prepare us
for problems that are coming
for problems that are coming
267
915083
3192
15:30
and problems like global warming
that are already upon us.
that are already upon us.
268
918299
4218
15:35
It's not going to be easy to turn away
from the questions that we've been asking
from the questions that we've been asking
269
923493
3791
15:39
towards this new set of questions.
270
927308
2252
15:42
It's no small challenge
271
930281
1418
15:43
to take on and broaden the borders of us.
272
931723
4601
15:48
It will take wit,
inventiveness and courage.
inventiveness and courage.
273
936874
4028
15:53
The old questions have been
with us for a long time,
with us for a long time,
274
941228
2609
15:55
and they're not going
to give way on their own,
to give way on their own,
275
943861
2716
15:58
and they're not going
to give way overnight.
to give way overnight.
276
946601
2060
16:01
And even if we manage
to change the questions,
to change the questions,
277
949907
2170
16:04
the answers are going to be complicated,
278
952101
1942
16:06
and they're going to require
sacrifices and tradeoffs.
sacrifices and tradeoffs.
279
954067
3417
16:10
And in an unequal world, we're always
going to have to pay attention
going to have to pay attention
280
958377
3279
16:13
to the question of who has the power
to join the conversation
to join the conversation
281
961680
3473
16:17
and who doesn't.
282
965177
1274
16:18
But the borders of the immigration debate
283
966878
2437
16:21
can be moved.
284
969339
1358
16:23
It's up to all of us to move them.
285
971098
2532
16:26
Thank you.
286
974542
1208
16:27
(Applause)
287
975774
2924
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Paul A. Kramer - Historian, writerPaul A. Kramer's work focuses on the changing relationships between the United States and the wider world.
Why you should listen
Paul A. Kramer is a historian and writer at Vanderbilt University whose work focuses on the United States' changing relationships with the wider world. He received his PhD from Princeton University and is the recipient of fellowships from Harvard University, Fulbright, the Smithsonian Institution and the National Endowment of the Humanities. In addition to his academic work, he has written for the New Yorker, Slate and other publications on themes ranging from the shifting character of the US-Mexico border and the origins of the US military base at Guantanamo Bay to the connection between the Iraq War and Hurricane Katrina.
More profile about the speakerPaul A. Kramer | Speaker | TED.com