TED2009
Alex Tabarrok: How ideas trump crises
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
881,960 views
The "dismal science" truly shines in this optimistic talk, as economist Alex Tabarrok argues free trade and globalization are shaping our once-divided world into a community of idea-sharing more healthy, happy and prosperous than anyone's predictions.
Alex Tabarrok - Economist
With the hit economic blog MarginalRevolution.com, co-author Alex Tabarrok generates more hits than a summer hailstorm, and sheds light into the darkest corners of the dismal science. Full bio
With the hit economic blog MarginalRevolution.com, co-author Alex Tabarrok generates more hits than a summer hailstorm, and sheds light into the darkest corners of the dismal science. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
The first half of the 20th century
0
0
4000
00:16
was an absolute disaster in human affairs,
1
4000
3000
00:19
a cataclysm.
2
7000
2000
00:21
We had the First World War,
3
9000
3000
00:24
the Great Depression,
4
12000
2000
00:26
the Second World War
5
14000
2000
00:28
and the rise of the communist nations.
6
16000
3000
00:31
And each one of these forces
7
19000
2000
00:33
split the world, tore the world apart,
8
21000
2000
00:35
divided the world.
9
23000
3000
00:38
And they threw up walls --
10
26000
2000
00:40
political walls, trade walls,
11
28000
2000
00:42
transportation walls,
12
30000
2000
00:44
communication walls, iron curtains --
13
32000
3000
00:47
which divided peoples and nations.
14
35000
4000
00:51
It was only in the second half of the 20th century
15
39000
4000
00:55
that we slowly began to pull ourselves
16
43000
3000
00:58
out of this abyss.
17
46000
3000
01:01
Trade walls began to come tumbling down.
18
49000
3000
01:04
Here are some data on tariffs:
19
52000
2000
01:06
starting at 40 percent, coming down to less than 5 percent.
20
54000
3000
01:09
We globalized the world. And what does that mean?
21
57000
3000
01:12
It means that we extended cooperation
22
60000
3000
01:15
across national boundaries;
23
63000
2000
01:17
we made the world more cooperative.
24
65000
3000
01:20
Transportation walls came tumbling down.
25
68000
4000
01:24
You know in 1950 the typical ship carried
26
72000
3000
01:27
5,000 to 10,000 tons worth of goods.
27
75000
4000
01:31
Today a container ship can carry 150,000 tons;
28
79000
4000
01:35
it can be manned with a smaller crew;
29
83000
2000
01:37
and unloaded faster than ever before.
30
85000
3000
01:40
Communication walls, I don't have to tell you -- the Internet --
31
88000
3000
01:43
have come tumbling down.
32
91000
2000
01:45
And of course the iron curtains,
33
93000
2000
01:47
political walls have come tumbling down.
34
95000
4000
01:51
Now all of this has been tremendous for the world.
35
99000
4000
01:55
Trade has increased.
36
103000
2000
01:57
Here is just a little bit of data.
37
105000
2000
01:59
In 1990, exports from China to the United States:
38
107000
2000
02:01
15 billion dollars.
39
109000
2000
02:03
By 2007: over 300 billion dollars.
40
111000
4000
02:07
And perhaps most remarkably,
41
115000
3000
02:10
at the beginning of the 21st century,
42
118000
2000
02:12
really for the first time in modern history,
43
120000
4000
02:16
growth extended to almost all parts of the world.
44
124000
4000
02:20
So China, I've already mentioned,
45
128000
2000
02:22
beginning around 1978, around the time of the death of Mao,
46
130000
3000
02:25
growth -- ten percent a year.
47
133000
2000
02:27
Year after year after year,
48
135000
2000
02:29
absolutely incredible.
49
137000
2000
02:31
Never before in human history
50
139000
4000
02:35
have so many people been raised out of
51
143000
2000
02:37
such great poverty as happened in China.
52
145000
3000
02:40
China is the world's greatest anti-poverty program
53
148000
3000
02:43
over the last three decades.
54
151000
2000
02:45
India, starting a little bit later,
55
153000
2000
02:47
but in 1990, begetting tremendous growth.
56
155000
3000
02:50
Incomes at that time
57
158000
2000
02:52
less than $1,000 per year.
58
160000
2000
02:54
And over the next 18 years
59
162000
2000
02:56
have almost tripled.
60
164000
2000
02:58
Growth of six percent a year. Absolutely incredible.
61
166000
3000
03:01
Now Africa, Sub-Saharan Africa --
62
169000
3000
03:04
Sub-Saharan Africa
63
172000
2000
03:06
has been the area of the world
64
174000
2000
03:08
most resistant to growth.
65
176000
3000
03:11
And we can see the tragedy of Africa
66
179000
3000
03:14
in the first few bars here.
67
182000
2000
03:16
Growth was negative.
68
184000
2000
03:18
People were actually getting poorer than their parents,
69
186000
3000
03:21
and sometimes even poorer than their grandparents had been.
70
189000
3000
03:24
But at the end of the 20th century,
71
192000
2000
03:26
the beginning of the 21st century,
72
194000
2000
03:28
we saw growth in Africa.
73
196000
3000
03:31
And I think, as you'll see, there's reasons for optimism,
74
199000
2000
03:33
because I believe that the best is yet to come.
75
201000
3000
03:36
Now why.
76
204000
2000
03:38
On the cutting edge today
77
206000
2000
03:40
it's new ideas which are driving growth.
78
208000
2000
03:42
And by that I mean it's
79
210000
2000
03:44
products for which the research and development costs
80
212000
3000
03:47
are really high, and the manufacturing costs are low.
81
215000
3000
03:50
More than ever before it is these types of ideas
82
218000
2000
03:52
which are driving growth on the cutting edge.
83
220000
3000
03:55
Now ideas have this amazing property.
84
223000
2000
03:57
Thomas Jefferson, I think, really expressed this quite well.
85
225000
3000
04:00
He said, "He who receives an idea from me
86
228000
4000
04:04
receives instruction himself, without lessening mine.
87
232000
4000
04:08
As he who lights his candle at mine
88
236000
3000
04:11
receives light without darkening me."
89
239000
3000
04:14
Or to put it slightly differently:
90
242000
2000
04:16
one apple feeds one man,
91
244000
2000
04:18
but an idea can feed the world.
92
246000
3000
04:21
Now this is not new. This is practically not new to TEDsters.
93
249000
3000
04:24
This is practically the model of TED.
94
252000
2000
04:26
But what is new is that the greater function of ideas
95
254000
4000
04:30
is going to drive growth even more than ever before.
96
258000
5000
04:35
This provides a reason why
97
263000
2000
04:37
trade and globalization
98
265000
2000
04:39
are even more important, more powerful than ever before,
99
267000
3000
04:42
and are going to increase growth more than ever before.
100
270000
3000
04:45
And to explain why this is so, I have a question.
101
273000
3000
04:48
Suppose that there are two diseases:
102
276000
3000
04:51
one of them is rare, the other one is common,
103
279000
2000
04:53
but if they are not treated they are equally severe.
104
281000
3000
04:56
If you had to choose, which would you rather have:
105
284000
3000
04:59
the common disease or the rare disease?
106
287000
4000
05:03
Common, the common -- I think that's absolutely right,
107
291000
2000
05:05
and why? Because there are more drugs to treat common diseases
108
293000
4000
05:09
than there are to treat rare diseases.
109
297000
3000
05:12
The reason for this is incentives.
110
300000
2000
05:14
It costs about the same to produce a new drug
111
302000
3000
05:17
whether that drug treats 1,000 people,
112
305000
3000
05:20
100,000 people, or a million people.
113
308000
3000
05:23
But the revenues are much greater if the drug treats a million people.
114
311000
3000
05:26
So the incentives are much larger
115
314000
3000
05:29
to produce drugs which treat more people.
116
317000
4000
05:33
To put this differently: larger markets save lives.
117
321000
4000
05:37
In this case misery truly does love company.
118
325000
4000
05:41
Now think about the following:
119
329000
2000
05:43
if China and India were as rich as the United States is today,
120
331000
4000
05:47
the market for cancer drugs would be eight times larger than it is now.
121
335000
6000
05:53
Now we are not there yet, but it is happening.
122
341000
2000
05:55
As other countries become richer
123
343000
3000
05:58
the demand for these pharmaceuticals
124
346000
2000
06:00
is going to increase tremendously.
125
348000
2000
06:02
And that means an increase incentive to do research and development,
126
350000
3000
06:05
which benefits everyone in the world.
127
353000
3000
06:08
Larger markets increase the incentive
128
356000
2000
06:10
to produce all kinds of ideas,
129
358000
2000
06:12
whether it's software, whether it's a computer chip,
130
360000
2000
06:14
whether it's a new design.
131
362000
2000
06:16
For the Hollywood people in the audience,
132
364000
2000
06:18
this even explains why action movies
133
366000
2000
06:20
have larger budgets than comedies:
134
368000
2000
06:22
it's because action movies translate easier
135
370000
3000
06:25
into other languages and other cultures,
136
373000
2000
06:27
so the market for those movies is larger.
137
375000
2000
06:29
People are willing to invest more,
138
377000
2000
06:31
and the budgets are larger.
139
379000
2000
06:33
Alright. Well if larger markets increase the incentive
140
381000
3000
06:36
to produce new ideas,
141
384000
2000
06:38
how do we maximize that incentive?
142
386000
3000
06:41
It's by having one world market, by globalizing the world.
143
389000
5000
06:46
The way I like to put this is:
144
394000
2000
06:48
one idea. Ideas are meant to be shared,
145
396000
3000
06:51
so one idea can serve one world, one market.
146
399000
5000
06:56
One idea, one world, one market.
147
404000
3000
06:59
Well how else can we create new ideas?
148
407000
3000
07:02
That's one reason.
149
410000
2000
07:04
Globalize trade.
150
412000
2000
07:06
How else can we create new ideas?
151
414000
2000
07:08
Well, more idea creators.
152
416000
2000
07:10
Now idea creators, they come from all walks of life.
153
418000
3000
07:13
Artists and innovators -- many of the people you've seen on this stage.
154
421000
3000
07:16
I'm going to focus on scientists and engineers
155
424000
3000
07:19
because I have some data on that, and I'm a data person.
156
427000
3000
07:22
Now, today, less than one-tenth of one percent
157
430000
5000
07:27
of the world's population are scientists and engineers.
158
435000
3000
07:30
(Laughter)
159
438000
2000
07:32
The United States has been an idea leader.
160
440000
3000
07:35
A large fraction of those people are in the United States.
161
443000
3000
07:38
But the U.S. is losing its idea leadership.
162
446000
5000
07:43
And for that I am very grateful.
163
451000
2000
07:45
That is a good thing.
164
453000
3000
07:48
It is fortunate that we are becoming less of an idea leader
165
456000
3000
07:51
because for too long the United States,
166
459000
2000
07:53
and a handful of other developed countries,
167
461000
2000
07:55
have shouldered the entire burden
168
463000
2000
07:57
of research and development.
169
465000
2000
07:59
But consider the following:
170
467000
3000
08:02
if the world as a whole were as wealthy as the United States is now
171
470000
3000
08:05
there would be more than five times as many scientists and engineers
172
473000
4000
08:09
contributing to ideas which benefit everyone,
173
477000
4000
08:13
which are shared by everyone.
174
481000
2000
08:15
I think of the great Indian mathematician, Ramanujan.
175
483000
4000
08:19
How many Ramanujans are there in India today
176
487000
4000
08:23
toiling in the fields, barely able to feed themselves,
177
491000
3000
08:26
when they could be feeding the world?
178
494000
3000
08:29
Now we're not there yet.
179
497000
2000
08:31
But it is going to happen in this century.
180
499000
3000
08:34
The real tragedy of the last century is this:
181
502000
6000
08:40
if you think about the world's population
182
508000
4000
08:44
as a giant computer, a massively parallel processor,
183
512000
3000
08:47
then the great tragedy has been
184
515000
2000
08:49
that billions of our processors have been off line.
185
517000
5000
08:54
But in this century China is coming on line.
186
522000
3000
08:57
India is coming on line.
187
525000
2000
08:59
Africa is coming on line.
188
527000
2000
09:01
We will see an Einstein in Africa in this century.
189
529000
5000
09:06
Here is just some data. This is China.
190
534000
2000
09:08
1996: less than one million
191
536000
2000
09:10
new university students in China per year;
192
538000
3000
09:13
2006: over five million.
193
541000
4000
09:17
Now think what this means.
194
545000
2000
09:19
This means we all benefit when another country gets rich.
195
547000
4000
09:23
We should not fear other countries becoming wealthy.
196
551000
4000
09:27
That is something that we should embrace --
197
555000
3000
09:30
a wealthy China, a wealthy India, a wealthy Africa.
198
558000
3000
09:33
We need a greater demand for ideas --
199
561000
2000
09:35
those larger markets I was talking about earlier --
200
563000
3000
09:38
and a greater supply of ideas for the world.
201
566000
4000
09:42
Now you can see some of the reasons why I'm optimistic.
202
570000
4000
09:46
Globalization is increasing the demand
203
574000
2000
09:48
for ideas, the incentive to create new ideas.
204
576000
3000
09:51
Investments in education are increasing the supply of new ideas.
205
579000
6000
09:57
In fact if you look at world history
206
585000
2000
09:59
you can see some reasons for optimism.
207
587000
2000
10:01
From about the beginnings of humanity
208
589000
2000
10:03
to 1500: zero economic growth, nothing.
209
591000
3000
10:06
1500 to 1800: maybe a little bit of economic growth,
210
594000
4000
10:10
but less in a century
211
598000
2000
10:12
than you expect to see in a year today.
212
600000
4000
10:16
1900s: maybe one percent.
213
604000
2000
10:18
Twentieth century: a little bit over two percent.
214
606000
2000
10:20
Twenty-first century could easily be 3.3, even higher percent.
215
608000
4000
10:24
Even at that rate,
216
612000
2000
10:26
by 2100 average GDP per capita
217
614000
3000
10:29
in the world will be $200,000.
218
617000
3000
10:32
That's not U.S. GDP per capita, which will be over a million,
219
620000
3000
10:35
but world GDP per capita -- $200,000.
220
623000
3000
10:38
That's not that far.
221
626000
2000
10:40
We won't make it.
222
628000
2000
10:42
But some of our grandchildren probably will.
223
630000
2000
10:44
And I should say,
224
632000
2000
10:46
I think this is a rather modest prediction.
225
634000
3000
10:49
In Kurzweilian terms this is gloomy.
226
637000
5000
10:54
In Kurzweilian terms I'm like the Eeyore of economic growth.
227
642000
4000
10:58
(Laughter)
228
646000
3000
11:01
Alright what about problems?
229
649000
2000
11:03
What about a great depression?
230
651000
3000
11:06
Well let's take a look. Let's take a look at the Great Depression.
231
654000
4000
11:10
Here is GDP per capita
232
658000
2000
11:12
from 1900 to 1929.
233
660000
3000
11:15
Now let's imagine that you were an economist in 1929,
234
663000
4000
11:19
trying to forecast future growth for the United States,
235
667000
3000
11:22
not knowing that the economy was about to go off a cliff,
236
670000
4000
11:26
not knowing that we were about to enter
237
674000
3000
11:29
the greatest economic disaster certainly in the 20th century.
238
677000
4000
11:33
What would you have predicted, not knowing this?
239
681000
2000
11:35
If you had based your prediction, your forecast
240
683000
2000
11:37
on 1900 to 1929
241
685000
2000
11:39
you'd have predicted something like this.
242
687000
2000
11:41
If you'd been a little more optimistic --
243
689000
2000
11:43
say, based upon the Roaring Twenties -- you'd have said this.
244
691000
3000
11:46
So what actually happened?
245
694000
2000
11:48
We went off a cliff but we recovered.
246
696000
4000
11:52
In fact in the second half of the 20th century
247
700000
3000
11:55
growth was even higher than anything you would have predicted
248
703000
4000
11:59
based upon the first half of the 20th century.
249
707000
3000
12:02
So growth can wash away
250
710000
2000
12:04
even what appears to be a great depression.
251
712000
3000
12:07
Alright. What else?
252
715000
2000
12:09
Oil. Oil. This was a big topic.
253
717000
3000
12:12
When I was writing up my notes oil was $140 per barrel.
254
720000
7000
12:19
So people were asking a question. They were saying,
255
727000
3000
12:22
"Is China drinking our milkshake?"
256
730000
4000
12:26
(Laughter)
257
734000
1000
12:27
And there is some truth to this,
258
735000
3000
12:30
in the sense that we have something of a finite resource,
259
738000
4000
12:34
and increased growth is going to push up demand for that.
260
742000
3000
12:37
But I think I don't have to tell this audience
261
745000
2000
12:39
that a higher price of oil is not necessarily a bad thing.
262
747000
5000
12:44
Moreover, as everyone knows,
263
752000
3000
12:47
look -- it's energy, not oil, which counts.
264
755000
3000
12:50
And higher oil prices mean
265
758000
2000
12:52
a greater incentive to invest in energy R&D.
266
760000
3000
12:55
You can see this in the data.
267
763000
2000
12:57
As oil prices go up, energy patents go up.
268
765000
3000
13:00
The world is much better equipped
269
768000
2000
13:02
to overcome an increase in the price of oil
270
770000
2000
13:04
today, than ever in the past,
271
772000
2000
13:06
because of what I'm talking about.
272
774000
2000
13:08
One idea, one world, one market.
273
776000
4000
13:12
So I'm optimistic
274
780000
3000
13:15
so long as we hew to these two ideas:
275
783000
2000
13:17
to keep globalizing world markets,
276
785000
2000
13:19
keep extending cooperation across national boundaries,
277
787000
4000
13:23
and keep investing in education.
278
791000
3000
13:26
Now the United States has a particularly important role
279
794000
3000
13:29
to play in this:
280
797000
3000
13:32
to keep our education system globalized,
281
800000
3000
13:35
to keep our education system open to students from all over the world,
282
803000
4000
13:39
because our education system
283
807000
2000
13:41
is the candle
284
809000
2000
13:43
that other students come to light their own candles.
285
811000
5000
13:48
Now remember here what Jefferson said.
286
816000
3000
13:51
Jefferson said, "When they come
287
819000
3000
13:54
and light their candles at ours,
288
822000
3000
13:57
they gain light, and we are not darkened."
289
825000
5000
14:02
But Jefferson wasn't quite right, was he?
290
830000
3000
14:05
Because the truth is,
291
833000
3000
14:08
when they light their candles at ours,
292
836000
4000
14:12
there is twice as much light available for everyone.
293
840000
4000
14:16
So my view is: Be optimistic.
294
844000
4000
14:20
Spread the ideas. Spread the light.
295
848000
3000
14:23
Thank you.
296
851000
2000
14:25
(Applause)
297
853000
3000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Alex Tabarrok - EconomistWith the hit economic blog MarginalRevolution.com, co-author Alex Tabarrok generates more hits than a summer hailstorm, and sheds light into the darkest corners of the dismal science.
Why you should listen
Perhaps the appeal of economics in the blogosphere was not pre-ordained from its representation in the bestseller lists (the Freakonomics phenomenon notwithstanding). But economists have taken the internet by storm, and Alex Tabarrok is one of the hottest -- along with co-author Tyler Cowen, their blog marginalrevolution.com is one of the most popular on the web, generating a forest of links and kudos from the mainstream press, including the Wall Street Journal.
Tabarrok's fascinations include the intersection among economics, law and public policy -- examining questions such as how race and poverty affect the outcome of jury trials. Tabarrok is also the Director of Research for the Independent Institute, an assistant editor for the Independent Review, and an Associate Professor of Economics at George Mason University.
Alex Tabarrok | Speaker | TED.com