TEDGlobal 2005
Yochai Benkler: The new open-source economics
Filmed:
Readability: 4.8
887,740 views
Yochai Benkler explains how collaborative projects like Wikipedia and Linux represent the next stage of human organization.
Yochai Benkler - Legal expert
Yochai Benkler has been called "the leading intellectual of the information age." He proposes that volunteer-based projects such as Wikipedia and Linux are the next stage of human organization and economic production. Full bio
Yochai Benkler has been called "the leading intellectual of the information age." He proposes that volunteer-based projects such as Wikipedia and Linux are the next stage of human organization and economic production. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
One of the problems of writing, and working, and looking at the Internet
0
0
3000
00:15
is that it's very hard to separate fashion from deep change.
1
3000
7000
00:22
And so, to start helping that, I want to take us back to 1835.
2
10000
4000
00:26
In 1835, James Gordon Bennett founded the first mass-circulation newspaper
3
14000
7000
00:33
in New York City.
4
21000
2000
00:35
And it cost about 500 dollars to start it,
5
23000
3000
00:38
which was about the equivalent of 10,000 dollars of today.
6
26000
4000
00:42
By 15 years later, by 1850, doing the same thing
7
30000
4000
00:46
-- starting what was experienced as a mass--circulation daily paper
8
34000
3000
00:49
-- would come to cost two and a half million dollars.
9
37000
4000
00:53
10,000, two and a half million, 15 years.
10
41000
3000
00:56
That's the critical change that is being inverted by the Net.
11
44000
7000
01:03
And that's what I want to talk about today,
12
51000
3000
01:06
and how that relates to the emergence of social production.
13
54000
3000
01:09
Starting with newspapers, what we saw was high cost as an initial requirement
14
57000
8000
01:17
for making information, knowledge and culture, which led to a stark bifurcation
15
65000
6000
01:23
between producers -- who had to be able to raise financial capital,
16
71000
4000
01:27
just like any other industrial organization --
17
75000
4000
01:31
and passive consumers that could choose from a certain set of
18
79000
3000
01:34
things that this industrial model could produce.
19
82000
5000
01:39
Now, the term "information society," "information economy,"
20
87000
3000
01:42
for a very long time has been used as the thing that comes after
21
90000
4000
01:46
the industrial revolution. But in fact, for purposes of understanding what's happening
22
94000
6000
01:52
today, that's wrong. Because for 150 years, we've had an information economy.
23
100000
6000
01:58
It's just been industrial,
24
106000
2000
02:00
which means those who were producing had to have a way of raising money
25
108000
4000
02:04
to pay those two and a half million dollars, and later, more for the telegraph,
26
112000
4000
02:08
and the radio transmitter, and the television, and eventually the mainframe.
27
116000
5000
02:13
And that meant they were market based, or they were government owned,
28
121000
3000
02:16
depending on what kind of system they were in. And this characterized and anchored
29
124000
5000
02:21
the way information and knowledge were produced for the next 150 years.
30
129000
7000
02:28
Now, let me tell you a different story. Around June 2002,
31
136000
5000
02:33
the world of supercomputers had a bombshell.
32
141000
4000
02:37
The Japanese had, for the first time, created the fastest supercomputer --
33
145000
4000
02:41
the NEC Earth Simulator -- taking the primary from the U.S.,
34
149000
3000
02:44
and about two years later -- this, by the way, is measuring the trillion floating-point
35
152000
4000
02:48
operations per second that the computer's capable of running --
36
156000
4000
02:52
sigh of relief: IBM [Blue Gene] has just edged ahead of the NEC Earth Simulator.
37
160000
6000
02:58
All of this completely ignores the fact that throughout this period,
38
166000
4000
03:02
there's another supercomputer running in the world -- SETI@home.
39
170000
4000
03:06
Four and a half million users around the world, contributing their
40
174000
4000
03:10
leftover computer cycles, whenever their computer isn't working,
41
178000
4000
03:14
by running a screen saver, and together sharing their resources to create
42
182000
7000
03:21
a massive supercomputer that NASA harnesses to analyze the data
43
189000
5000
03:26
coming from radio telescopes.
44
194000
4000
03:30
What this picture suggests to us is that we've got a radical change in the way
45
198000
7000
03:37
information production and exchange is capitalized. Not that it's become
46
205000
4000
03:41
less capital intensive -- that there's less money that's required
47
209000
3000
03:44
-- but that the ownership of this capital, the way the capitalization happens,
48
212000
5000
03:49
is radically distributed. Each of us, in these advanced economies,
49
217000
5000
03:54
has one of these, or something rather like it -- a computer.
50
222000
5000
03:59
They're not radically different from routers inside the middle of the network.
51
227000
5000
04:04
And computation, storage and communications capacity are in the hands of
52
232000
5000
04:09
practically every connected person -- and these are the basic physical
53
237000
6000
04:15
capital means necessary for producing information, knowledge and culture,
54
243000
5000
04:20
in the hands of something like 600 million to a billion people around the planet.
55
248000
6000
04:26
What this means is that for the first time since the industrial revolution,
56
254000
6000
04:32
the most important means, the most important components of the core
57
260000
6000
04:38
economic activities -- remember, we are in an information economy
58
266000
4000
04:42
-- of the most advanced economies, and there more than anywhere else,
59
270000
5000
04:47
are in the hands of the population at large. This is completely different than what we've
60
275000
4000
04:51
seen since the industrial revolution. So we've got communications and computation
61
279000
5000
04:56
capacity in the hands of the entire population,
62
284000
3000
04:59
and we've got human creativity, human wisdom, human experience
63
287000
5000
05:04
-- the other major experience, the other major input --
64
292000
3000
05:07
which unlike simple labor -- stand here turning this lever all day long --
65
295000
5000
05:12
is not something that's the same or fungible among people.
66
300000
3000
05:15
Any one of you who has taken someone else's job, or tried to give yours
67
303000
3000
05:18
to someone else, no matter how detailed the manual, you cannot transmit
68
306000
6000
05:24
what you know, what you will intuit under a certain set of circumstances.
69
312000
5000
05:29
In that we're unique, and each of us holds this critical input
70
317000
4000
05:33
into production as we hold this machine.
71
321000
4000
05:37
What's the effect of this? So, the story that most people know
72
325000
5000
05:42
is the story of free or open source software.
73
330000
4000
05:46
This is market share of Apache Web server
74
334000
3000
05:49
-- one of the critical applications in Web-based communications.
75
337000
6000
05:55
In 1995, two groups of people said,
76
343000
4000
05:59
"Wow, this is really important, the Web! We need a much better Web server!"
77
347000
4000
06:03
One was a motley collection of volunteers who just decided,
78
351000
4000
06:07
you know, we really need this, we should write one,
79
355000
2000
06:09
and what are we going to do with what --
80
357000
3000
06:12
well, we're gonna share it! And other people will be able to develop it.
81
360000
2000
06:14
The other was Microsoft.
82
362000
2000
06:16
Now, if I told you that 10 years later, the motley crew of people, who didn't control
83
364000
5000
06:21
anything that they produced, acquired 20 percent of the market
84
369000
3000
06:24
and was the red line, it would be amazing! Right?
85
372000
3000
06:27
Think of it in minivans. A group of automobile
86
375000
3000
06:30
engineers on their weekends are competing with Toyota. Right?
87
378000
5000
06:35
But, in fact, of course, the story is it's the 70 percent,
88
383000
3000
06:38
including the major e-commerce site -- 70 percent of a critical application
89
386000
5000
06:43
on which Web-based communications and applications work is produced in this form, in
90
391000
6000
06:49
direct competition with Microsoft. Not in a side issue --
91
397000
4000
06:53
in a central strategic decision to try to capture a component of the Net.
92
401000
7000
07:00
Software has done this in a way that's been very visible, because
93
408000
5000
07:05
it's measurable. But the thing to see is that this actually happens throughout the Web.
94
413000
6000
07:11
So, NASA, at some point, did an experiment where they took images of Mars
95
419000
6000
07:17
that they were mapping, and they said, instead of having three or four
96
425000
4000
07:21
fully trained Ph.D.s doing this all the time, let's break it up into small components,
97
429000
5000
07:26
put it up on the Web, and see if people, using a very simple interface,
98
434000
4000
07:30
will actually spend five minutes here,
99
438000
2000
07:32
10 minutes there, clicking. After six months,
100
440000
4000
07:36
85,000 people used this to generate mapping at a
101
444000
5000
07:41
faster rate than the images were coming in, which was, quote,
102
449000
4000
07:45
"practically indistinguishable from the markings of a fully-trained Ph.D.,"
103
453000
4000
07:49
once you showed it to a number of people and computed the average.
104
457000
7000
07:56
Now, if you have a little girl, and she goes and writes to
105
464000
3000
07:59
-- well, not so little, medium little -- tries to do research on Barbie.
106
467000
4000
08:03
And she'll come to Encarta, one of the main online encyclopedias.
107
471000
4000
08:07
This is what you'll find out about Barbie. This is it, there's nothing more to the definition,
108
475000
6000
08:13
including, "manufacturers" -- plural -- "now more commonly produce
109
481000
4000
08:17
ethnically diverse dolls, like this black Barbie." Which is vastly better
110
485000
4000
08:21
than what you'll find in the encyclopedia.com,
111
489000
3000
08:24
which is Barbie, Klaus. (Laughter)
112
492000
4000
08:28
On the other hand, if they go to Wikipedia, they'll find a genuine article
113
496000
5000
08:33
-- and I won't talk a lot about Wikipedia, because Jimmy Wales is here --
114
501000
3000
08:36
but roughly equivalent to what you would find in the Britannica, differently written,
115
504000
6000
08:42
including the controversies over body image and commercialization,
116
510000
4000
08:46
the claims about the way in which she's a good role model, etc.
117
514000
8000
08:54
Another portion is not only how content is produced, but how relevance is produced.
118
522000
4000
08:58
The claim to fame of Yahoo! was, we hire people to look -- originally, not anymore
119
526000
4000
09:02
-- we hire people to look at websites and tell you --
120
530000
5000
09:07
if they're in the index, they're good. This, on the other hand, is what 60,000
121
535000
4000
09:11
passionate volunteers produce in the Open Directory Project,
122
539000
4000
09:15
each one willing to spend an hour or two on something they really care about,
123
543000
5000
09:20
to say, this is good. So, this is the Open Directory Project, with 60,000 volunteers,
124
548000
6000
09:26
each one spending a little bit of time, as opposed to a few hundred
125
554000
3000
09:29
fully paid employees. No one owns it, no one owns the output,
126
557000
5000
09:34
it's free for anyone to use and it's the output of people acting out of social
127
562000
5000
09:39
and psychological motivations to do something interesting.
128
567000
4000
09:43
This is not only outside of businesses. When you think of what is the critical innovation
129
571000
6000
09:49
of Google, the critical innovation is outsourcing the one most important thing --
130
577000
5000
09:54
the decision about what's relevant -- to the community of the Web as a whole,
131
582000
7000
10:01
doing whatever they want to do: so, page rank.
132
589000
3000
10:04
The critical innovation here is instead of our engineers, or our people saying
133
592000
6000
10:10
which is the most relevant, we're going to go out and count what you,
134
598000
3000
10:13
people out there on the Web, for whatever reason -- vanity, pleasure --
135
601000
4000
10:17
produced links, and tied to each other. We're going to count those, and count them up.
136
605000
6000
10:23
And again, here, you see Barbie.com, but also, very quickly,
137
611000
4000
10:27
Adiosbarbie.com, the body image for every size. A contested cultural object,
138
615000
5000
10:32
which you won't find anywhere soon on Overture, which is the classic
139
620000
4000
10:36
market-based mechanism: whoever pays the most is highest on the list.
140
624000
5000
10:41
So, all of that is in the creation of content, of relevance, basic human expression.
141
629000
5000
10:46
But remember, the computers were also physical. Just physical materials
142
634000
4000
10:50
-- our PCs -- we share them together. We also see this in wireless.
143
638000
4000
10:54
It used to be wireless was one person owned the license, they transmitted in an
144
642000
6000
11:00
area, and it had to be decided whether they would be licensed or based on property.
145
648000
5000
11:05
What we're seeing now is that computers and radios are becoming so sophisticated
146
653000
5000
11:10
that we're developing algorithms to let people own machines, like Wi-Fi devices,
147
658000
6000
11:16
and overlay them with a sharing protocol that would allow a community like this
148
664000
5000
11:21
to build its own wireless broadband network simply from the simple principle:
149
669000
6000
11:27
When I'm listening, when I'm not using, I can help you transfer your messages;
150
675000
6000
11:33
and when you're not using, you'll help me transfer yours.
151
681000
3000
11:36
And this is not an idealized version. These are working models that at least in some
152
684000
5000
11:41
places in the United States are being implemented, at least for public security.
153
689000
7000
11:48
If in 1999 I told you, let's build a data storage and retrieval system.
154
696000
6000
11:54
It's got to store terabytes. It's got to be available 24 hours a day,
155
702000
3000
11:57
seven days a week. It's got to be available from anywhere in the world.
156
705000
3000
12:00
It has to support over 100 million users at any given moment. It's got to
157
708000
4000
12:04
be robust to attack, including closing the main index, injecting malicious files,
158
712000
5000
12:09
armed seizure of some major nodes. You'd say that would take years.
159
717000
5000
12:14
It would take millions. But of course, what I'm describing is P2P file sharing.
160
722000
7000
12:21
Right? We always think of it as stealing music, but fundamentally,
161
729000
3000
12:24
it's a distributed data storage and retrieval system, where people,
162
732000
4000
12:28
for very obvious reasons, are willing to share their bandwidth and their
163
736000
4000
12:32
storage to create something.
164
740000
3000
12:35
So, essentially what we're seeing is the emergence of a fourth transactional
165
743000
4000
12:39
framework. It used to be that there were two primary dimensions along which
166
747000
6000
12:45
you could divide things. They could be market based, or non-market based;
167
753000
3000
12:48
they could be decentralized, or centralized.
168
756000
2000
12:50
The price system was a market-based and decentralized system.
169
758000
3000
12:53
If things worked better because you actually had somebody organizing them,
170
761000
4000
12:57
you had firms, if you wanted to be in the market -- or you had governments
171
765000
3000
13:00
or sometimes larger non-profits in the non-market.
172
768000
3000
13:03
It was too expensive to have decentralized social production,
173
771000
5000
13:08
to have decentralized action in society. That was not about society itself.
174
776000
7000
13:15
That was, in fact, economic.
175
783000
2000
13:17
But what we're seeing now is the emergence of this fourth system
176
785000
4000
13:21
of social sharing and exchange.
177
789000
1000
13:22
Not that it's the first time that we do nice things to each other, or for each other,
178
790000
5000
13:27
as social beings. We do it all the time.
179
795000
4000
13:31
It's that it's the first time that it's having major economic impact.
180
799000
4000
13:35
What characterizes them is decentralized authority.
181
803000
5000
13:40
You don't have to ask permission, as you do in a property-based system.
182
808000
3000
13:43
May I do this? It's open for anyone to create and innovate and share,
183
811000
6000
13:49
if they want to, by themselves or with others,
184
817000
4000
13:53
because property is one mechanism of coordination.
185
821000
2000
13:55
But it's not the only one.
186
823000
2000
13:57
Instead, what we see are social frameworks for all of the critical things that we use
187
825000
5000
14:02
property and contract in the market: information flows to decide what are
188
830000
3000
14:05
interesting problems; who's available and good for something;
189
833000
4000
14:09
motivation structures -- remember, money isn't always the best motivator.
190
837000
4000
14:13
If you leave a $50 check after dinner with friends,
191
841000
4000
14:17
you don't increase the probability of being invited back.
192
845000
4000
14:21
And if dinner isn't entirely obvious, think of sex. (Laughter)
193
849000
6000
14:27
It also requires certain new organizational approaches.
194
855000
3000
14:30
And in particular, what we've seen is task organization.
195
858000
4000
14:34
You have to hire people who know what they're doing.
196
862000
2000
14:36
You have to hire them to spend a lot of time.
197
864000
3000
14:39
Now, take the same problem,
198
867000
2000
14:41
chunk it into little modules, and motivations become trivial.
199
869000
4000
14:45
Five minutes, instead of watching TV?
200
873000
2000
14:47
Five minutes I'll spend just because it's interesting. Just because it's fun.
201
875000
4000
14:51
Just because it gives me a certain sense of meaning, or, in places that are more
202
879000
4000
14:55
involved, like Wikipedia, gives me a certain set of social relations.
203
883000
6000
15:01
So, a new social phenomenon is emerging.
204
889000
4000
15:05
It's creating, and it's most visible when we see it as a new form of competition.
205
893000
5000
15:10
Peer-to-peer networks assaulting the recording industry;
206
898000
3000
15:13
free and open source software taking market share from Microsoft;
207
901000
4000
15:17
Skype potentially threatening traditional telecoms;
208
905000
4000
15:21
Wikipedia competing with online encyclopedias.
209
909000
3000
15:24
But it's also a new source of opportunities for businesses.
210
912000
3000
15:27
As you see a new set of social relations and behaviors emerging,
211
915000
6000
15:33
you have new opportunities. Some of them are toolmakers.
212
921000
4000
15:37
Instead of building well-behaved appliances
213
925000
3000
15:40
-- things that you know what they'll do in advance --
214
928000
2000
15:42
you begin to build more open tools. There's a new set of values,
215
930000
3000
15:45
a new set of things people value.
216
933000
3000
15:48
You build platforms for self-expression and collaboration.
217
936000
4000
15:52
Like Wikipedia, like the Open Directory Project,
218
940000
4000
15:56
you're beginning to build platforms, and you see that as a model.
219
944000
3000
15:59
And you see surfers, people who see this happening, and in some sense
220
947000
4000
16:03
build it into a supply chain, which is a very curious one. Right?
221
951000
5000
16:08
You have a belief: stuff will flow out of connected human beings.
222
956000
3000
16:11
That'll give me something I can use, and I'm going to contract with someone.
223
959000
3000
16:14
I will deliver something based on what happens. It's very scary
224
962000
4000
16:18
-- that's what Google does, essentially.
225
966000
2000
16:20
That's what IBM does in software services, and they've done reasonably well.
226
968000
4000
16:24
So, social production is a real fact, not a fad.
227
972000
4000
16:28
It is the critical long-term shift caused by the Internet.
228
976000
4000
16:32
Social relations and exchange become significantly more important than they ever
229
980000
7000
16:39
were as an economic phenomenon. In some contexts, it's even more efficient
230
987000
4000
16:43
because of the quality of the information, the ability to find the best person,
231
991000
5000
16:48
the lower transaction costs. It's sustainable and growing fast.
232
996000
4000
16:52
But -- and this is the dark lining -- it is threatened by
233
1000000
6000
16:58
-- in the same way that it threatens -- the incumbent industrial systems.
234
1006000
4000
17:02
So next time you open the paper, and you see an intellectual property decision,
235
1010000
5000
17:07
a telecoms decision, it's not about something small and technical.
236
1015000
6000
17:13
It is about the future of the freedom to be as social beings with each other,
237
1021000
6000
17:19
and the way information, knowledge and culture will be produced.
238
1027000
5000
17:24
Because it is in this context that we see a battle over how easy or hard it will be
239
1032000
7000
17:31
for the industrial information economy to simply go on as it goes,
240
1039000
4000
17:35
or for the new model of production to begin to develop alongside that industrial model,
241
1043000
6000
17:41
and change the way we begin to see the world and report what it is that we see.
242
1049000
5000
17:46
Thank you.
243
1054000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Yochai Benkler - Legal expertYochai Benkler has been called "the leading intellectual of the information age." He proposes that volunteer-based projects such as Wikipedia and Linux are the next stage of human organization and economic production.
Why you should listen
Larry Lessig calls law professor Yochai Benkler "the leading intellectual of the information age." He studies the commons -- including such shareable spaces as the radio spectrum, as well as our shared bodies of knowledge and how we access and change them.
His most recent writings (such as his 2006 book The Wealth of Networks) discuss the effects of net-based information production on our lives and minds and laws. He has gained admirers far beyond the academy, so much so that when he released his book online with a Creative Commons license, it was mixed and remixed online by fans. (Texts can be found at benkler.org; and check out this web-based seminar on The Wealth of Networks.) He was awarded EFF's Pioneer Award in 2007.
He's the Berkman Professor of Entrepreneurial Legal Studies at Harvard, and faculty co-director of the Berkman Center for Internet and Society (home to many of TED's favorite people).
Yochai Benkler | Speaker | TED.com