TEDGlobal 2007
Ernest Madu: World-class health care
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
426,962 views
Dr. Ernest Madu runs the Heart Institute of the Caribbean in Kingston, Jamaica, where he proves that -- with careful design, smart technical choices, and a true desire to serve -- it's possible to offer world-class healthcare in the developing world.
Ernest Madu - Cardiologist
Ernest Madu founded the Heart Institute of the Caribbean, a revolutionary clinic for cardiovascular diseases in Kingston, Jamaica -- revolutionary for offering first-class health care in a developing nation. His next stop: Nigeria. Full bio
Ernest Madu founded the Heart Institute of the Caribbean, a revolutionary clinic for cardiovascular diseases in Kingston, Jamaica -- revolutionary for offering first-class health care in a developing nation. His next stop: Nigeria. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:19
It is interesting that in the United States,
0
1000
2000
00:21
the most significant health-care budget
1
3000
2000
00:23
goes to cardiovascular disease care, whether it's private or public.
2
5000
6000
00:29
There's no comparison at all.
3
11000
3000
00:32
In Africa -- where it is a major killer -- it is totally ignored.
4
14000
5000
00:37
And that situation cannot be right. We must do something about it.
5
19000
6000
00:43
A health status of a nation parallels development of that nation.
6
25000
6000
00:49
17 million people die every year from heart disease.
7
31000
4000
00:53
32 million heart attacks and strokes occur.
8
35000
3000
00:56
Most of this is in developing countries, and the majority is in Africa.
9
38000
5000
01:01
85 percent of global disease burden for cardiovascular disease
10
43000
4000
01:05
is in developing countries -- not in the West --
11
47000
3000
01:08
and yet 90 percent of the resources are in the West.
12
50000
5000
01:13
Who is at risk? People like you.
13
55000
3000
01:16
It's not just the Africans that should be concerned about that.
14
58000
3000
01:19
All friends of Africa, that will have reason to be in Africa at some point in time,
15
61000
6000
01:25
should be very concerned about this deplorable situation.
16
67000
3000
01:28
Has anyone here wondered what will happen
17
70000
3000
01:31
if you go back to your room at night,
18
73000
2000
01:33
and you start getting chest pains, shortness of breath, sweating?
19
75000
4000
01:37
You're having a heart attack. What are you going to do?
20
79000
4000
01:41
Will you fly back to the U.S., Germany, Europe?
21
83000
5000
01:46
No, you will die. 50 percent will die within 24 hours, if not treated.
22
88000
5000
01:51
This is what's going on.
23
93000
3000
01:54
In a look at the map of the U.S. -- the graph here,
24
96000
3000
01:57
10 million people here, 10 million here.
25
99000
3000
02:00
By the time you get to 50, it's almost no one left in Nigeria --
26
102000
5000
02:05
life expectancy is 47.
27
107000
2000
02:07
It's not because some people don't survive childhood illnesses --
28
109000
5000
02:12
they do -- but they do not survive after the time that they reach
29
114000
6000
02:18
about 45 years old and 50 years old.
30
120000
4000
02:22
And those are the times they're most productive.
31
124000
2000
02:24
Those are the times that they should be contributing
32
126000
2000
02:26
to Africa's development. But they're not there.
33
128000
4000
02:30
The best way to spiral into a cycle of poverty is to kill the parents.
34
132000
5000
02:35
If you cannot secure the parents,
35
137000
3000
02:38
you cannot guarantee the security of the African child.
36
140000
2000
02:40
What are the risk factors?
37
142000
3000
02:43
It's very well known. I'm not going to spend a lot of time on those.
38
145000
2000
02:45
These are just for information:
39
147000
2000
02:47
hypertension, diabetes, obesity, lack of exercise. The usual suspects.
40
149000
5000
02:52
Right here in Tanzania, 30 percent of individuals have hypertension.
41
154000
6000
02:58
20 percent are getting treated.
42
160000
2000
03:00
Only less than one percent are adequately treated.
43
162000
3000
03:03
If we can treat hypertension alone in Africa,
44
165000
3000
03:06
we'll save 250,000 lives a year. That's quite significant!
45
168000
5000
03:11
Easy to treat. Look at the situation in Mauritius.
46
173000
3000
03:14
In eight short years -- we're here talking about HIV, malaria,
47
176000
5000
03:19
which is all good.
48
181000
1000
03:20
We cannot make the mistakes we've made with malaria and HIV.
49
182000
4000
03:24
In eight short years, non-communicable diseases
50
186000
3000
03:27
will become the leading causes of death in Africa.
51
189000
4000
03:31
That is something to keep in mind. We can't deal with it with situations like this.
52
193000
5000
03:36
This is a typical African hospital. We can't depend on the elites --
53
198000
4000
03:40
they go to USA, Germany, U.K. for treatment. Unbelievable.
54
202000
8000
03:48
You can't depend on foreign aid alone.
55
210000
2000
03:50
Here is the situation: countries are turning inwards.
56
212000
3000
03:53
Post-9/11, [the] United States has had a lot of trouble
57
215000
3000
03:56
to deal with, their own internal issues.
58
218000
2000
03:58
So, they spend their money trying to fix those problems.
59
220000
4000
04:02
You can't rightly -- it's not their responsibility,
60
224000
3000
04:05
it is my responsibility. I have to take care of my own problems.
61
227000
4000
04:09
If they help, that's good! But that is not my expectation.
62
231000
5000
04:14
These worsening indices of health care or health studies in Africa
63
236000
3000
04:17
demand a new look. We cannot keep on doing things
64
239000
4000
04:21
the way we've always done them.
65
243000
1000
04:22
If they have not worked, we have to look for alternative solutions.
66
244000
4000
04:26
I'm here to talk to you about solutions.
67
248000
2000
04:28
This has been -- what has been a difficult sign to some of us.
68
250000
5000
04:33
Several years ago, we started thinking about it.
69
255000
3000
04:36
Everyone knows the problem. No one knows what the solutions are.
70
258000
4000
04:40
We decided that we needed to put our money where our mouth is.
71
262000
5000
04:45
Everyone is ready to throw in money,
72
267000
3000
04:48
in terms of free money aid to developing countries.
73
270000
3000
04:51
Talk about sustainable investment, no one is interested.
74
273000
4000
04:55
You can't raise money.
75
277000
2000
04:57
I have done businesses in healthcare in the United States --
76
279000
3000
05:00
I live in Nashville, Tennessee, health care capital of America.
77
282000
3000
05:03
[It's] very easy to raise money for health-care ventures.
78
285000
3000
05:06
But start telling them, you know,
79
288000
2000
05:08
we're going to try to do it in Nigeria -- everyone runs away.
80
290000
2000
05:10
That is totally wrong. Those of you in the audience here,
81
292000
6000
05:16
if you want to help Africa, invest money in sustainable development.
82
298000
3000
05:19
Let me lead you through a day in the life of the Heart Institute,
83
301000
4000
05:23
so you get a glimpse of what we do,
84
305000
2000
05:25
and I'll talk a little bit more about it.
85
307000
4000
06:28
What we have done is to show that high-quality health care,
86
370000
6000
06:34
comparable to the best anywhere in the world,
87
376000
2000
06:36
can be done in a developing country environment.
88
378000
3000
06:39
We have 25 positions right now -- all of them trained,
89
381000
5000
06:44
board certified in the USA, Canada or Britain.
90
386000
3000
06:47
We have every modality that can be done in Vanderbilt,
91
389000
4000
06:51
Cleveland Clinic -- everywhere in the U.S. --
92
393000
3000
06:54
and we do it for about 10 percent of the cost
93
396000
3000
06:57
that you will need to do those things in the United States.
94
399000
4000
07:01
(Applause)
95
403000
5000
07:06
Additionally, we have a policy
96
408000
2000
07:08
that no one is ever turned away because of ability to pay.
97
410000
4000
07:12
We take care of everyone.
98
414000
2000
07:14
(Applause)
99
416000
1000
07:15
Whether you have one dollar, two dollars -- it doesn't matter.
100
417000
3000
07:18
And I will tell you how we're able to do it.
101
420000
3000
07:21
We make sure that we select our equipment properly.
102
423000
4000
07:25
We go for modular units. Units that have multi-modality functions
103
427000
4000
07:29
have modular components. Easy to repair, and because of that,
104
431000
5000
07:34
we do not take things that are not durable and cannot last.
105
436000
4000
07:38
We emphasize training,
106
440000
2000
07:40
and we make sure that this process is regenerative.
107
442000
3000
07:43
Very soon we will all be dead and gone, but the problems will stay,
108
445000
4000
07:47
unless we have people taking over from where we stopped.
109
449000
4000
07:51
We made sure that we produced some things ourselves.
110
453000
3000
07:54
We do not buy unit doses of radiopharmaceuticals.
111
456000
3000
07:57
We get the generators from the companies.
112
459000
3000
08:00
We manufacture them in-house, ourselves. That keeps the costs down.
113
462000
4000
08:04
So, for a radiopharmaceutical in the U.S. --
114
466000
3000
08:07
that you'll get a unit dose for 250 dollars --
115
469000
3000
08:10
when we're finished manufacturing it in-house,
116
472000
2000
08:12
we come at a price of about two dollars.
117
474000
2000
08:14
(Applause)
118
476000
4000
08:18
We recognize that the only way to bridge the gap
119
480000
3000
08:21
between the rich and poor countries
120
483000
3000
08:24
is through education and technology.
121
486000
3000
08:27
All these problems we're talking about --
122
489000
2000
08:29
if we bring development, they will all disappear.
123
491000
3000
08:32
Technology is a great equalizer. How do we make it work?
124
494000
5000
08:37
It's been proved: self-care is cost-effective.
125
499000
2000
08:39
It extends opportunity to the rural centers,
126
501000
4000
08:43
and we can use expertise in a very smart way.
127
505000
3000
08:46
This is the way our centers are set up.
128
508000
3000
08:49
We currently have three locations in the Caribbean,
129
511000
3000
08:52
and we're planning a fourth one.
130
514000
2000
08:54
And we have now decided to go into Africa.
131
516000
3000
08:57
We will be doing the West African Heart Institute
132
519000
3000
09:00
in Port Harcourt, Nigeria. That project will be starting
133
522000
3000
09:03
within the next few months. We hope to open in 2008-09.
134
525000
4000
09:07
And we will do other centers.
135
529000
2000
09:09
This model can be adapted to every disease process.
136
531000
4000
09:13
All the units, all the centers, are linked
137
535000
2000
09:15
through a switched hub to a central server,
138
537000
4000
09:19
and all the images are populated to review stations.
139
541000
3000
09:22
And we designed this telemedicine solution. It's proprietary to us,
140
544000
5000
09:27
and we are happy to share what we have learned with anyone
141
549000
3000
09:30
who is interested in doing it. You can still be profitable.
142
552000
5000
09:35
We make sure that the telemedicine platform gives access
143
557000
6000
09:41
to expert medical specialists anywhere in the world,
144
563000
4000
09:45
just by a click of the button.
145
567000
2000
09:47
I'll lead you through, to see how this happens.
146
569000
3000
09:50
This is at the Heart Institute. The doctors from anywhere can log in.
147
572000
4000
09:54
I can call you in Switzerland and say, "Listen, go into our system.
148
576000
4000
09:58
Look at Mrs. Jones. Look at the study, tell me what you think."
149
580000
4000
10:02
They'll give me that information,
150
584000
2000
10:04
and we'll make the care of the patient better.
151
586000
3000
10:07
The patient doesn't have to travel.
152
589000
2000
10:09
He doesn't have to experience the anxiety of not knowing
153
591000
3000
10:12
because of limited expertise.
154
594000
4000
10:16
We also use [an] electronic medical record system.
155
598000
3000
10:19
I'm happy to say that the things we have implemented --
156
601000
4000
10:23
80 percent of U.S. practices do not have them, and yet the technology is there.
157
605000
7000
10:30
But you know, they have that luxury.
158
612000
1000
10:31
Because if you can't get it in Nashville, you can travel to Birmingham,
159
613000
5000
10:36
two hours away, and you'll get it. If you can't get it in Cleveland,
160
618000
3000
10:39
you can go to Cincinnati. We don't have that luxury,
161
621000
3000
10:42
so we have to make it happen.
162
624000
2000
10:44
When we do it, we will put the cost of care down.
163
626000
4000
10:48
And we'll extend it to the rural centers and make it affordable.
164
630000
4000
10:52
And everyone will get the care they deserve.
165
634000
3000
10:55
It cannot just be technology, we recognize that.
166
637000
4000
10:59
Prevention must be part of the solution -- we emphasize that.
167
641000
4000
11:03
But, you know, you have to tell people what can be done.
168
645000
4000
11:07
It's not possible to tell people to do what is going to be expensive,
169
649000
3000
11:10
and they go home and can't do it.
170
652000
3000
11:13
They need to be alive, they need to feed.
171
655000
2000
11:15
We recommend exercise as the most effective, simple, easy thing to do.
172
657000
6000
11:21
We have had walks every year -- every March, April.
173
663000
4000
11:25
We form people into groups and make them go into challenges.
174
667000
5000
11:30
Which group loses the most weight, we give them prizes.
175
672000
3000
11:33
Which groups record more walking distance by pedometer,
176
675000
4000
11:37
we give them prizes. We do this constantly.
177
679000
3000
11:40
We encourage them to bring children.
178
682000
2000
11:42
That way we start exposing the children from very early on,
179
684000
3000
11:45
on what these issues are. Because once they learn it,
180
687000
4000
11:49
they will stay with it. In doing this we have created
181
691000
4000
11:53
at least 100 skilled jobs in Jamaica alone,
182
695000
3000
11:56
and these are physicians with expertise and special training.
183
698000
4000
12:00
We have taken care of over 1,000 indigent patients that could have died,
184
702000
4000
12:04
including four free pacemakers in patients
185
706000
2000
12:06
with complete heart block. For those that understand cardiology,
186
708000
4000
12:10
complete heart block means certain death.
187
712000
3000
12:13
If you don't get this pacemaker, you will be dead.
188
715000
3000
12:16
So we are pleased with that.
189
718000
1000
12:17
Indirectly, we have saved the government of Jamaica five million dollars
190
719000
4000
12:21
from people that would have gone to Miami or Atlanta for care.
191
723000
5000
12:26
And we've hopefully saved a lot of lives.
192
728000
3000
12:29
By the end of this year, we would have contributed over one million dollars
193
731000
5000
12:34
in indigent care. In the first four months, it's been 340,000 dollars,
194
736000
4000
12:38
averaging 85,000 dollars a month. The government will not do that,
195
740000
6000
12:44
because they have competing needs.
196
746000
1000
12:45
They need to put resources elsewhere. But we can still do it.
197
747000
3000
12:48
People say, "How can you do that?" This is how we can do that.
198
750000
5000
12:53
At least 4,000 rich Jamaicans that were heading to Miami for treatment
199
755000
5000
12:58
have self-confessed that they did not go to Miami
200
760000
5000
13:03
because of the Heart Institute of the Caribbean.
201
765000
2000
13:05
And, if they went to Miami, they will spend significantly more --
202
767000
5000
13:10
eight to 10 times more. And they feel happy spending it at home,
203
772000
5000
13:15
getting the same quality of care.
204
777000
1000
13:16
And for that money -- for every one patient that has the money to pay,
205
778000
6000
13:22
it gives us an opportunity to take care of at least four people
206
784000
3000
13:25
that do not have the resources to pay.
207
787000
3000
13:28
(Applause)
208
790000
5000
13:33
For this to work, this progress must be sustainable.
209
795000
3000
13:36
So, we emphasize training. Training is critical.
210
798000
3000
13:39
We have gone further: we have formed a relationship
211
801000
4000
13:43
with the University of Technology, Jamaica,
212
805000
3000
13:46
where I now have an appointment.
213
808000
1000
13:47
And we are starting a biomedical engineering program,
214
809000
3000
13:50
so that we will train people locally, who can repair that equipment.
215
812000
5000
13:55
That way we're not going to deal with obsolescence and all those kinds of issues.
216
817000
4000
13:59
We're also starting ancillary health-care technology training programs --
217
821000
5000
14:04
training people in echocardiography, cardiac ultrasound,
218
826000
4000
14:08
those kinds of things. Now, with that kind of training,
219
830000
3000
14:11
it gives people motivation.
220
833000
2000
14:13
Because now they will get a bachelors degree in medical imaging
221
835000
3000
14:16
and all that kind of stuff. In the process, I want you to just hear
222
838000
6000
14:22
from the trainees themselves what it has meant for them.
223
844000
4000
14:26
(Video) Dr. Jason Topping: My name is Jason Topping.
224
848000
1000
14:27
I'm a senior resident in anesthesia in intensive care
225
849000
3000
14:30
at the University Hospital of the West Indies.
226
852000
3000
14:33
I came to the Heart Institute in 2006,
227
855000
3000
14:36
as part of my elective in my anesthesia and intensive care program.
228
858000
5000
14:41
I spent three months at the Heart Institute.
229
863000
3000
14:44
There's been no doubt around my colleagues
230
866000
2000
14:46
about the utility of the training I received here,
231
868000
3000
14:49
and I think there's been an increased interest now in --
232
871000
5000
14:54
particularly in echocardiography and its use in our setting.
233
876000
4000
14:58
Sharon Lazarus: I am an echocardiographer at the Heart Institute of the Caribbean,
234
880000
5000
15:03
since the past two years. I received training at this institution.
235
885000
5000
15:08
I think this aspect of training in cardiology
236
890000
5000
15:13
that the Heart Institute of the Caribbean has introduced in Jamaica
237
895000
4000
15:17
is very important in terms of diagnosing cardiac diseases.
238
899000
9000
15:26
Ernest Madu: The lesson in this is that it can be done, and it can be sustained,
239
908000
5000
15:31
and you can make it possible for everyone.
240
913000
4000
15:35
Who are we to decide that poor people cannot get the best care?
241
917000
4000
15:39
When have you been appointed to play God?
242
921000
4000
15:43
It is not my decision. My job is to make sure that every person,
243
925000
5000
15:48
no matter what fate has assigned to you, will have the opportunity
244
930000
5000
15:53
to get the best quality health care in life.
245
935000
3000
15:56
Next stop is West African Heart Institute,
246
938000
4000
16:00
that we are going to be doing in Port Harcourt, Nigeria,
247
942000
3000
16:03
as I said before. We will do other centers across West Africa.
248
945000
4000
16:07
We will extend the same system into other areas,
249
949000
5000
16:12
like dialysis treatment.
250
954000
1000
16:13
And anyone who is interested in doing it in any health care situation,
251
955000
4000
16:17
we will be happy to assist you and tell you how we've done it,
252
959000
5000
16:22
and how you can do it. If we do this,
253
964000
4000
16:26
we can change the face of health care in Africa.
254
968000
4000
16:30
Africa has been good to us; it is time for us to give back to Africa.
255
972000
4000
16:34
I am going. Those who want to come,
256
976000
3000
16:37
I welcome you to come along with me.
257
979000
2000
16:39
Thank you.
258
981000
2000
16:41
(Applause)
259
983000
4000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Ernest Madu - CardiologistErnest Madu founded the Heart Institute of the Caribbean, a revolutionary clinic for cardiovascular diseases in Kingston, Jamaica -- revolutionary for offering first-class health care in a developing nation. His next stop: Nigeria.
Why you should listen
Dr. Ernest Chijioke Madu believes that people in the developing world have a right to world-class health care. At his three Heart Institute of the Caribbean clinics --in Kingston and Mandeville, Jamaica, and in the Cayman Islands -- he delivers more than $1 million a year in free or reduced-care treatment, a significant contribution in an area where 56% of hospital deaths are caused by cardiovascular disease.
Now Dr. Madu is hoping to transfer HIC's mission and achievements into other low-resource nations. His next target is Nigeria, his home country, where the Heart Institute of West Africa is scheduled to open in 2009. Though AIDS and malaria are huge factors for Africa, Dr. Madu emphasizes the importance of treating cardiovascular disease, which is the second leading cause of death in sub-Saharan Africa, after HIV/AIDS, and the leading cause of death for people over 30.
Dr. Madu's work on noninvasive evaluation of coronary artery disease in obese individuals has become a standard evaluating tool.
Ernest Madu | Speaker | TED.com