TEDxBinghamtonUniversity
Raj Jayadev: Community-powered criminal justice reform
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
1,269,712 views
Community organizer Raj Jayadev wants to transform the US court system through "participatory defense" -- a growing movement that empowers families and community members to impact their loved ones' court cases. He shares the remarkable results of their work -- including more than 4,000 years of "time saved" from incarceration -- and shows how this new model could shift the landscape of power in the courts.
Raj Jayadev - Community organizer
Raj Jayadev is the cofounder and coordinator of Silicon Valley De-Bug, a community organizing, media and advocacy organization based in San Jose, California. Full bio
Raj Jayadev is the cofounder and coordinator of Silicon Valley De-Bug, a community organizing, media and advocacy organization based in San Jose, California. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
This is my favorite protest shirt.
0
984
2267
00:15
It says, "Protect your people."
1
3897
2206
00:18
We made it in the basement
of our community center.
of our community center.
2
6127
2920
00:21
I've worn it at rallies,
3
9420
2324
00:23
at protests and marches,
4
11768
3032
00:26
at candlelight vigils
5
14824
1817
00:28
with families who have lost loved ones
to police violence.
to police violence.
6
16665
3254
00:32
I've seen how this ethic
of community organizing
of community organizing
7
20674
3714
00:36
has been able to change
arresting practices,
arresting practices,
8
24412
2896
00:39
hold individual officers accountable
9
27332
3102
00:42
and allow families
to feel strong and supported
to feel strong and supported
10
30458
3357
00:45
in the darkest moments of their lives.
11
33839
2169
00:49
But when a family would come to our center
12
37022
2690
00:51
and say, "My loved one
got arrested, what can we do?"
got arrested, what can we do?"
13
39736
4135
00:55
we didn't know how to translate
14
43895
2016
00:57
the power of community organizing
that we saw on the streets
that we saw on the streets
15
45935
3658
01:01
into the courts.
16
49617
1150
01:03
We figured we're not lawyers,
17
51652
1672
01:05
and so that's not our arena
to make change.
to make change.
18
53348
2933
01:09
And so despite our belief
in collective action,
in collective action,
19
57017
3167
01:12
we would allow people that we cared about
20
60208
2992
01:15
to go to court alone.
21
63224
2023
01:18
Nine out of ten times --
and this is true nationally --
and this is true nationally --
22
66335
4135
01:22
they couldn't afford their own attorney,
23
70494
1916
01:24
and so they'd have a public defender,
who is doing heroic work,
who is doing heroic work,
24
72434
3873
01:28
but was often under-resourced
25
76331
2795
01:31
and stretched bare with too many cases.
26
79150
2729
01:33
They would face prosecutors
aiming for high conviction rates,
aiming for high conviction rates,
27
81903
3928
01:37
mandatory minimum sentences
28
85855
2373
01:40
and racial bias baked
into every stage of the process.
into every stage of the process.
29
88252
3872
01:46
And so, facing those odds,
30
94100
2071
01:48
stripped away from the power of community,
31
96195
3222
01:51
unsure how to navigate the courts,
32
99441
2516
01:53
over 90 percent of people that face
a criminal charge in this country
a criminal charge in this country
33
101981
3798
01:57
will take a plea deal.
34
105803
1466
02:00
Meaning, they'll never have
their fabled day in court
their fabled day in court
35
108096
3421
02:03
that we talk about
in television shows and in movies.
in television shows and in movies.
36
111541
3333
02:07
And this is the untold part of the story
of mass incarceration in America --
of mass incarceration in America --
37
115807
5945
02:13
how we became
the largest jailer in the world.
the largest jailer in the world.
38
121776
3148
02:17
Over two million people
currently incarcerated in this country.
currently incarcerated in this country.
39
125623
3682
02:21
And projections that say
40
129726
1595
02:23
one out of three black men
will see the inside of a prison cell
will see the inside of a prison cell
41
131345
4017
02:27
at some point in their life
on this trajectory.
on this trajectory.
42
135386
3159
02:32
But we have a solution.
43
140546
1533
02:34
We decided to be irreverent to this idea
44
142928
3056
02:38
that only lawyers can impact the courts.
45
146008
3094
02:41
And to penetrate the judicial system
46
149587
2403
02:44
with the power, intellect and ingenuity
of community organizing.
of community organizing.
47
152014
5483
02:50
We call the approach
"participatory defense."
"participatory defense."
48
158569
2934
02:54
It's a methodology
for families and communities
for families and communities
49
162286
2881
02:57
whose loved ones are facing charges,
50
165191
2292
02:59
and how they could impact
the outcome of those cases
the outcome of those cases
51
167507
2803
03:02
and transform the landscape
of power in the courts.
of power in the courts.
52
170334
3398
03:06
How it works is,
53
174859
1166
03:08
families whose loved ones
are facing criminal charges
are facing criminal charges
54
176049
2730
03:10
will come to a weekly meeting,
55
178803
2135
03:12
and it's half support group,
56
180962
1798
03:14
half strategic planning session.
57
182784
2133
03:17
And they'll build a community
58
185823
1846
03:19
out of what otherwise would be
an isolating and lonely experience.
an isolating and lonely experience.
59
187693
4240
03:24
And they'll sit in a circle,
60
192755
2310
03:27
and write the names
of their loved ones on a board,
of their loved ones on a board,
61
195089
2658
03:29
who they're there to support.
62
197771
1849
03:31
And collectively,
63
199644
1210
03:32
the group will find out ways
to tangibly and tactfully
to tangibly and tactfully
64
200878
4136
03:37
impact the outcome of that case.
65
205038
1994
03:39
They'll review police reports
to find out inconsistencies;
to find out inconsistencies;
66
207569
3921
03:43
they'll find areas that require
67
211514
2157
03:45
more investigation
by the defense attorney;
by the defense attorney;
68
213695
2518
03:48
and they'll go to court with each other,
69
216237
1919
03:50
for the emotional support
70
218180
1984
03:52
but also so that the judge knows
that the person standing before them
that the person standing before them
71
220188
4381
03:56
is part of a larger community
72
224593
1693
03:58
that is invested in their
well-being and success.
well-being and success.
73
226310
2879
04:02
And the results have been remarkable.
74
230538
1968
04:05
We've seen charges get dismissed,
75
233506
2992
04:08
sentences significantly reduced,
76
236522
2825
04:11
acquittals won at trial
77
239371
1871
04:14
and, sometimes, it has been
literally lifesaving.
literally lifesaving.
78
242561
3267
04:18
Like in the case of Ramon Vasquez.
79
246450
2334
04:21
Father of two, family man, truck driver
80
249235
5525
04:26
and someone who was wrongfully charged
with a gang-related murder
with a gang-related murder
81
254784
3247
04:30
he was totally innocent of,
82
258055
1793
04:31
but was facing a life sentence.
83
259872
2067
04:35
Ramon's family came to those meetings
84
263172
2191
04:37
shortly after his arrest
and his detention,
and his detention,
85
265387
2888
04:40
and they worked the model.
86
268299
1667
04:42
And through their hard work,
87
270268
1516
04:43
they found major
contradictions in the case,
contradictions in the case,
88
271808
2571
04:47
gaping holes in the investigation.
89
275121
2532
04:49
And were able to disprove
dangerous assumptions by the detectives.
dangerous assumptions by the detectives.
90
277677
4603
04:54
Like that the red hat that they found
when they raided his home
when they raided his home
91
282836
3829
04:58
somehow affiliated him
to a gang lifestyle.
to a gang lifestyle.
92
286689
3413
05:03
Through their photos and their records,
93
291149
2849
05:06
they were able to prove that the red hat
was from his son's Little League team
was from his son's Little League team
94
294022
4617
05:10
that Ramon coached on the weekends.
95
298663
2245
05:14
And they produced independent information
96
302107
2136
05:16
that proved that Ramon
was on the other side of town
was on the other side of town
97
304267
2842
05:19
at the time of the alleged incident,
98
307133
2349
05:21
through their phone records
99
309506
1397
05:22
and receipts from the stores
that they attended.
that they attended.
100
310927
2563
05:26
After seven long months
of hard work from the family,
of hard work from the family,
101
314593
3643
05:30
Ramon staying strong inside jail,
102
318260
3031
05:33
they were able
to get the charge dismissed.
to get the charge dismissed.
103
321315
2934
05:37
And they brought Ramon home
104
325053
1659
05:38
to live the life that he should
have been living all along.
have been living all along.
105
326736
3119
05:42
And with each new case,
106
330260
1373
05:43
the families identified new ways
to flex the knowledge of the community
to flex the knowledge of the community
107
331657
4444
05:48
to have impact on the court system.
108
336125
2333
05:51
We would go to a lot
of sentencing hearings.
of sentencing hearings.
109
339506
2817
05:54
And when we would leave
the sentencing hearing,
the sentencing hearing,
110
342347
2347
05:56
on the walk back to the parking lot
111
344718
1899
05:58
after someone's loved one
just got sent to prison,
just got sent to prison,
112
346641
3333
06:01
the most common refrain we would hear
113
349998
2635
06:04
wasn't so much, "I hate that judge,"
114
352657
3126
06:07
or "I wish we had a new lawyer."
115
355807
2452
06:11
What they would say was,
116
359268
2119
06:13
"I wish they knew him like we know him."
117
361411
2666
06:17
And so we developed tools and vehicles
118
365188
2746
06:19
for families to tell the fuller story
of their loved one
of their loved one
119
367958
3000
06:22
so they would be understood
as more than just a case file.
as more than just a case file.
120
370982
2901
06:26
They started making what we call
social biography packets,
social biography packets,
121
374360
3246
06:29
which is families making a compilation
of photos and certificates and letters
of photos and certificates and letters
122
377630
4547
06:34
that show past challenges
and hardships and accomplishments,
and hardships and accomplishments,
123
382201
3729
06:37
and future prospects and opportunities.
124
385954
2600
06:41
And the social biography [packets]
were working so well in the courts,
were working so well in the courts,
125
389025
4357
06:45
that we evolved it
into social biography videos.
into social biography videos.
126
393406
3319
06:48
Ten-minute mini documentaries,
127
396749
2317
06:51
which were interviews
of people in their homes,
of people in their homes,
128
399090
2700
06:53
and at their churches
and at their workplace,
and at their workplace,
129
401814
2419
06:56
explaining who the person was
in the backdrop of their lives.
in the backdrop of their lives.
130
404257
3233
07:00
And it was a way for us to dissolve
the walls of the court temporarily.
the walls of the court temporarily.
131
408578
5111
07:06
And through the power of video,
132
414221
2198
07:08
bring the judge out of the court
and into the community,
and into the community,
133
416443
4391
07:12
so that they would be able to understand
the fuller context of someone's life
the fuller context of someone's life
134
420858
4230
07:17
that they're deciding the fate of.
135
425112
2555
07:21
One of the first social biography projects
that came out of our camp
that came out of our camp
136
429046
4110
07:25
was by Carnell.
137
433180
1150
07:26
He had come to the meetings
138
434665
1293
07:27
because he had pled
to a low-level drug charge.
to a low-level drug charge.
139
435982
2579
07:30
And after years of sobriety,
140
438585
1818
07:32
got arrested for this one
drug possession charge.
drug possession charge.
141
440427
2729
07:35
But he was facing a five-year
prison sentence
prison sentence
142
443180
2326
07:37
because of the sentencing
schemes in California.
schemes in California.
143
445530
2833
07:40
We knew him primarily as a dad.
144
448974
2206
07:43
He'd bring his daughters to the meetings
145
451204
1920
07:45
and then play with them
at the park across the street.
at the park across the street.
146
453148
3088
07:48
And he said, "Look, I could do the time,
147
456260
2143
07:50
but if I go in,
they're going to take my girls."
they're going to take my girls."
148
458427
2885
07:54
And so we gave him a camera
149
462927
1737
07:56
and said, "Just take pictures
of what's like being a father."
of what's like being a father."
150
464688
3265
08:00
And so he took pictures
of making breakfast for his daughters
of making breakfast for his daughters
151
468758
4158
08:04
and taking them to school,
152
472940
1516
08:06
taking them to after-school programs
and doing homework.
and doing homework.
153
474480
2746
08:09
And it became this photo essay
154
477863
2087
08:11
that he turned in to his lawyer
who used it at the sentencing hearing.
who used it at the sentencing hearing.
155
479974
3412
08:16
And that judge, who originally indicated
a five-year prison sentence,
a five-year prison sentence,
156
484077
4198
08:20
understood Carnell in a whole new way.
157
488299
2467
08:23
And he converted
that five-year prison sentence
that five-year prison sentence
158
491466
3373
08:26
into a six-month outpatient program,
159
494863
3189
08:30
so that Carnell could be
with his daughters.
with his daughters.
160
498076
2563
08:32
His girls would have
a father in their life.
a father in their life.
161
500663
2111
08:34
And Carnell could get the treatment
that he was actually seeking.
that he was actually seeking.
162
502798
3683
08:39
We have one ceremony of sorts
163
507688
3413
08:43
that we use in participatory defense.
164
511125
2436
08:45
And I told you earlier
that when families come to the meetings,
that when families come to the meetings,
165
513585
2985
08:48
they write the names
of their loved ones on the board.
of their loved ones on the board.
166
516594
2539
08:51
Those are names that we all
get to know, week in, week out,
get to know, week in, week out,
167
519157
2786
08:53
through the stories of the family,
168
521967
1666
08:55
and we're rooting for
and praying for and hoping for.
and praying for and hoping for.
169
523657
3238
08:59
And when we win a case,
170
527466
1532
09:01
when we get a sentence reduced,
or a charge dropped,
or a charge dropped,
171
529022
3936
09:04
or we win an acquittal,
172
532982
2040
09:07
that person, who's been
a name on the board,
a name on the board,
173
535046
2499
09:09
comes to the meeting.
174
537569
1400
09:11
And when their name comes up,
175
539776
2341
09:14
they're given an eraser,
176
542141
1833
09:15
and they walk over to the board
177
543998
2270
09:18
and they erase their name.
178
546292
1733
09:20
And it sounds simple,
but it is a spiritual experience.
but it is a spiritual experience.
179
548799
3724
09:25
And people are applauding,
and they're crying.
and they're crying.
180
553420
3293
09:29
And for the families
that are just starting that journey
that are just starting that journey
181
557277
2626
09:31
and are sitting in the back of the room,
182
559927
2245
09:34
for them to know
that there's a finish line,
that there's a finish line,
183
562196
2191
09:36
that one day, they too might be able
to bring their loved one home,
to bring their loved one home,
184
564411
3563
09:39
that they could erase the name,
185
567998
2285
09:42
is profoundly inspiring.
186
570307
2056
09:46
We're training organizations
all over the country now
all over the country now
187
574466
2484
09:48
in participatory defense.
188
576974
1748
09:50
And we have a national
network of over 20 cities.
network of over 20 cities.
189
578746
2935
09:54
And it's a church in Pennsylvania,
190
582032
2587
09:56
it's a parents' association in Tennessee,
191
584643
3245
09:59
it's a youth center in Los Angeles.
192
587912
2222
10:02
And the latest city that we just added
to the national network
to the national network
193
590614
3356
10:05
to grow and deepen this practice
194
593994
2152
10:08
is Philadelphia.
195
596170
1325
10:10
They literally just started their first
weekly participatory defense meeting
weekly participatory defense meeting
196
598066
4145
10:14
last week.
197
602235
1150
10:16
And the person that we brought
from California to Philadelphia
from California to Philadelphia
198
604465
4651
10:21
to share their testimony,
to inspire them to know what's possible,
to inspire them to know what's possible,
199
609140
4175
10:25
was Ramon Vasquez,
200
613339
1317
10:27
who went from sitting in a jail
in Santa Clara County, California,
in Santa Clara County, California,
201
615673
3753
10:31
to inspiring a community
about what's possible
about what's possible
202
619450
2230
10:33
through the perseverance of community
across the country.
across the country.
203
621704
3905
10:39
And with all the hubs, we still use
one metric that we invented.
one metric that we invented.
204
627145
5198
10:44
It's called time saved.
205
632676
1215
10:45
It's a saying that we actually
still say at weekly meetings.
still say at weekly meetings.
206
633915
2940
10:48
And what we say when a family
comes in a meeting for the first time is:
comes in a meeting for the first time is:
207
636879
3682
10:52
if you do nothing,
208
640585
2302
10:54
the system is designed to give
your loved one time served.
your loved one time served.
209
642911
3210
10:58
That's the language the system uses
to quantify time of incarceration.
to quantify time of incarceration.
210
646681
4412
11:04
But if you engage, if you participate,
211
652070
3737
11:07
you can turn time served into time saved.
212
655831
3227
11:12
That's them home with you,
living the life they should be living.
living the life they should be living.
213
660061
3388
11:16
So, Carnell, for example,
would represent five years of time saved.
would represent five years of time saved.
214
664166
3852
11:21
So when we totaled our time saved numbers
215
669277
2761
11:24
from all the different
participatory defense hubs,
participatory defense hubs,
216
672062
2499
11:26
through the work
in the meetings and at court
in the meetings and at court
217
674585
2849
11:29
and making social biography
videos and packets,
videos and packets,
218
677458
2660
11:33
we had 4,218 years of time saved
from incarceration.
from incarceration.
219
681387
5499
11:40
That is parents' and children's lives.
220
688601
3142
11:44
Young people going to college
instead of prison.
instead of prison.
221
692212
2730
11:46
We're ending generational
cycles of suffering.
cycles of suffering.
222
694966
3183
11:51
And when you consider
in my home state of California,
in my home state of California,
223
699042
4392
11:56
it costs 60,000 dollars to house someone
in the California prison system,
in the California prison system,
224
704430
5202
12:02
that means that these families
are saving their states
are saving their states
225
710585
3662
12:07
a ton of money.
226
715363
1233
12:08
I'm not a mathematician,
I haven't done the numbers,
I haven't done the numbers,
227
716990
2856
12:11
but that is money and resources
that could be reallocated
that could be reallocated
228
719870
3337
12:15
to mental health services,
229
723231
2285
12:17
to drug treatment programs, to education.
230
725540
2944
12:22
And we're now wearing this shirt in courts
231
730016
3576
12:26
all across the country.
232
734593
1404
12:28
And people are wearing this shirt
233
736347
1739
12:30
because they want the immediacy
of protecting their people
of protecting their people
234
738110
4213
12:34
in the courtroom.
235
742347
1150
12:36
But what we're telling them is,
236
744407
1545
12:37
as practitioners,
they're building a new field,
they're building a new field,
237
745976
3749
12:41
a new movement
238
749749
1802
12:43
that is going to forever change the way
justice is understood in this country.
justice is understood in this country.
239
751575
4047
12:48
Thank you.
240
756683
1151
12:49
(Applause)
241
757858
3554
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Raj Jayadev - Community organizerRaj Jayadev is the cofounder and coordinator of Silicon Valley De-Bug, a community organizing, media and advocacy organization based in San Jose, California.
Why you should listen
Through De-Bug's criminal justice community organizing program, the Albert Cobarrubias Justice Project, "participatory defense" was created -- a methodology for families whose loved ones are facing the criminal court system to impact the outcome of the case and transform the landscape of power in the courts through policy initiatives. After eight years of implementing the practice in San Jose, Raj Jayadev and the De-Bug team have gone on to train community organizations across the country to become participatory defense hubs. There is now a National Participatory Defense Network that De-Bug coordinates, which represents hubs from more than 30 cities. Jayadev’s community organizing and writings have been featured in the New York Times, The Atlantic, BBC, TIME Magazine and media outlets across the country. In 2018, he was selected as a MacArthur Fellow.
Raj Jayadev | Speaker | TED.com