TED2006
Phil Borges: Photos of endangered cultures
Filmed:
Readability: 3.9
1,037,731 views
Photographer Phil Borges shows rarely seen images of people from the mountains of Dharamsala, India, and the jungles of the Ecuadorean Amazon. In documenting these endangered cultures, he intends to help preserve them.
Phil Borges - Photographer
Dentist-turned-photographer Phil Borges documents the world's disappearing cultures, capturing portraits of exiled Tibetan monks and many of the world’s embattled tribal and indigenous cultures. Full bio
Dentist-turned-photographer Phil Borges documents the world's disappearing cultures, capturing portraits of exiled Tibetan monks and many of the world’s embattled tribal and indigenous cultures. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:25
A fact
0
0
2000
00:27
came out of MIT,
1
2000
3000
00:30
couple of years ago. Ken Hale,
2
5000
2000
00:32
who's a linguist,
3
7000
2000
00:34
said that of the 6,000 languages
4
9000
3000
00:37
spoken on Earth right now,
5
12000
2000
00:39
3,000 aren't spoken by the children.
6
14000
3000
00:42
So that in one generation,
7
17000
3000
00:45
we're going to halve our cultural diversity.
8
20000
3000
00:49
He went on to say
9
24000
2000
00:51
that every two weeks,
10
26000
2000
00:53
an elder goes to the grave
11
28000
2000
00:55
carrying the last spoken word
12
30000
2000
00:57
of that culture.
13
32000
2000
00:59
So an entire philosophy,
14
34000
4000
01:04
a body of knowledge about the natural world
15
39000
2000
01:06
that had been empirically gleaned over centuries,
16
41000
4000
01:10
goes away.
17
45000
2000
01:12
And this happens every two weeks.
18
47000
3000
01:16
So for the last 20 years,
19
51000
2000
01:18
since my dental experience,
20
53000
3000
01:21
I have been traveling the world
21
56000
3000
01:24
and coming back
22
59000
2000
01:26
with stories about some of these people.
23
61000
2000
01:28
What I'd like to do right now
24
63000
2000
01:30
is share some of those stories with you.
25
65000
3000
01:33
This is Tamdin.
26
68000
2000
01:35
She is a 69-year-old nun.
27
70000
3000
01:39
She was thrown in prison in Tibet for two years
28
74000
3000
01:42
for putting up a little tiny placard
29
77000
2000
01:44
protesting the occupation of her country.
30
79000
3000
01:48
And when I met her, she had just
31
83000
3000
01:51
taken a walk over the Himalayas
32
86000
2000
01:53
from Lhasa, the capital of Tibet,
33
88000
3000
01:56
into Nepal, across to India --
34
91000
2000
01:58
30 days --
35
93000
2000
02:00
to meet her leader, the Dalai Lama.
36
95000
3000
02:03
The Dalai Lama lives in Dharamsala, India.
37
98000
2000
02:05
So I took this picture three days
38
100000
2000
02:07
after she arrived,
39
102000
2000
02:09
and she had this beat-up pair of tennis shoes on,
40
104000
2000
02:11
with her toes sticking out.
41
106000
2000
02:13
And she crossed in March,
42
108000
2000
02:15
and there's a lot of snow at 18,500 feet in March.
43
110000
4000
02:20
This is Paldin.
44
115000
2000
02:22
Paldin is a 62-year-old monk.
45
117000
2000
02:24
And he spent 33 years in prison.
46
119000
4000
02:28
His whole monastery was thrown into prison
47
123000
3000
02:31
at the time of the uprising,
48
126000
3000
02:34
when the Dalai Lama had to leave
49
129000
3000
02:37
Tibet.
50
132000
2000
02:39
And
51
134000
2000
02:41
he was beaten, starved,
52
136000
3000
02:44
tortured -- lost all his teeth while in prison.
53
139000
2000
02:46
And when I met him, he was a kind gentle old man.
54
141000
4000
02:50
And it really impressed me --
55
145000
2000
02:52
I met him two weeks after he got out of prison --
56
147000
3000
02:55
that he went through that experience, and ended up
57
150000
2000
02:57
with the demeanor that he had.
58
152000
3000
03:00
So I was in Dharamsala meeting these people,
59
155000
3000
03:03
and I'd spent about five weeks there,
60
158000
3000
03:06
and I was hearing these similar stories
61
161000
2000
03:08
of these refugees that had poured out of Tibet
62
163000
3000
03:11
into Dharamsala.
63
166000
2000
03:13
And it just so happened, on the fifth week,
64
168000
3000
03:16
there was a public teaching by the Dalai Lama.
65
171000
4000
03:20
And
66
175000
2000
03:22
I was watching this crowd of monks and nuns,
67
177000
3000
03:25
many of which I had just interviewed,
68
180000
2000
03:27
and heard their stories,
69
182000
2000
03:29
and I watched their faces,
70
184000
3000
03:32
and they gave us a little FM radio,
71
187000
2000
03:34
and we could listen to the translation of his teachings.
72
189000
3000
03:37
And what he said was:
73
192000
2000
03:39
treat your enemies as if they were precious jewels,
74
194000
4000
03:43
because it's your enemies
75
198000
2000
03:45
that build your tolerance and patience
76
200000
3000
03:48
on the road to your enlightenment.
77
203000
4000
03:52
That hit me so hard,
78
207000
3000
03:56
telling these people that had been through this experience.
79
211000
3000
04:00
So, two months later, I went into
80
215000
3000
04:03
Tibet, and I started
81
218000
2000
04:05
interviewing the people there, taking my photographs. That's what I do.
82
220000
3000
04:08
I interview and do portraits.
83
223000
3000
04:11
And this is a little girl.
84
226000
2000
04:13
I took her portrait up on top of the Jokhang Temple.
85
228000
3000
04:16
And I'd snuck in --
86
231000
2000
04:18
because it's totally illegal to have a picture of the Dalai Lama in Tibet --
87
233000
5000
04:23
it's the quickest way you can get arrested.
88
238000
3000
04:26
So I snuck in a bunch of little wallet-sized pictures of the Dalai Lama,
89
241000
3000
04:29
and I would hand them out.
90
244000
2000
04:31
And when I gave them to the people,
91
246000
3000
04:34
they'd either hold them to their heart,
92
249000
2000
04:36
or they'd hold them up to their head and just stay there.
93
251000
3000
04:39
And this is --
94
254000
2000
04:41
well, at the time -- I did this 10 years ago --
95
256000
2000
04:43
that was 36 years after the Dalai Lama had left.
96
258000
3000
04:48
So
97
263000
1000
04:49
I was going in, interviewing these people and doing their portraits.
98
264000
4000
04:53
This is Jigme and her sister, Sonam.
99
268000
2000
04:55
And they live up on the Chang Tang, the Tibetan Plateau,
100
270000
3000
04:58
way in the western part of the country.
101
273000
3000
05:01
This is at 17,000 feet.
102
276000
2000
05:03
And they had just come down from the high pastures,
103
278000
3000
05:06
at 18,000 feet.
104
281000
2000
05:08
Same thing: gave her a picture,
105
283000
2000
05:10
she held it up to her forehead.
106
285000
2000
05:12
And I usually hand out Polaroids
107
287000
3000
05:15
when I do these, because I'm setting up lights,
108
290000
2000
05:17
and checking my lights,
109
292000
2000
05:19
and when I showed her her Polaroid, she screamed and ran into her tent.
110
294000
3000
05:24
This is Tenzin Gyatso;
111
299000
2000
05:26
he was found to be the Buddha of Compassion at the age of two,
112
301000
4000
05:30
out in a peasant's house,
113
305000
3000
05:33
way out in the middle of nowhere.
114
308000
2000
05:35
At the age of four, he was installed
115
310000
2000
05:37
as the 14th Dalai Lama.
116
312000
3000
05:40
As a teenager, he faced
117
315000
2000
05:42
the invasion of his country,
118
317000
2000
05:44
and had to deal with it -- he was the leader of the country.
119
319000
3000
05:47
Eight years later, when they discovered there was a plot
120
322000
2000
05:49
to kill him,
121
324000
2000
05:51
they dressed him up like a beggar
122
326000
2000
05:53
and snuck him out of the country on horseback,
123
328000
3000
05:56
and took the same trip that Tamdin did.
124
331000
3000
05:59
And he's never been back to his country since.
125
334000
4000
06:03
And
126
338000
2000
06:05
if you think about this man,
127
340000
2000
06:07
46 years later,
128
342000
2000
06:09
still sticking
129
344000
2000
06:11
to this non-violent response
130
346000
4000
06:15
to a severe political and human rights issue.
131
350000
4000
06:19
And the young people,
132
354000
2000
06:21
young Tibetans, are starting to say, listen, this doesn't work.
133
356000
3000
06:24
You know, violence as a political tool
134
359000
2000
06:26
is all the rage right now.
135
361000
2000
06:28
And
136
363000
3000
06:31
he still is holding this line.
137
366000
2000
06:33
So this is our icon
138
368000
2000
06:35
to non-violence in our world --
139
370000
3000
06:38
one of our living icons.
140
373000
2000
06:41
This is another leader of his people.
141
376000
2000
06:43
This is Moi. This is in the Ecuadorian Amazon.
142
378000
3000
06:46
And Moi is 35 years old.
143
381000
3000
06:49
And
144
384000
2000
06:51
this area of the Ecuadorian Amazon --
145
386000
2000
06:53
oil was discovered in 1972.
146
388000
3000
06:56
And in this period of time -- since that time --
147
391000
3000
06:59
as much oil, or twice as much oil
148
394000
3000
07:02
as was spilled in the Exxon Valdez accident,
149
397000
3000
07:05
was spilled in this little area of the Amazon,
150
400000
3000
07:08
and the tribes in this area have constantly had to move.
151
403000
4000
07:12
And Moi
152
407000
2000
07:14
belongs to the Huaorani tribe,
153
409000
2000
07:16
and they're known as
154
411000
2000
07:18
very fierce, they're known as "auca."
155
413000
2000
07:20
And they've managed to keep out
156
415000
3000
07:23
the seismologists and the oil workers
157
418000
2000
07:25
with spears and blowguns.
158
420000
3000
07:28
And we spent --
159
423000
2000
07:30
I was with a team --
160
425000
3000
07:33
two weeks with these guys out in the jungle
161
428000
3000
07:36
watching them hunt.
162
431000
2000
07:38
This was on a monkey hunt,
163
433000
2000
07:40
hunting with curare-tipped darts.
164
435000
3000
07:43
And the knowledge that these people have
165
438000
3000
07:46
about the natural environment is incredible.
166
441000
2000
07:48
They could hear things, smell things, see things I couldn't see.
167
443000
4000
07:52
And I couldn't even see the monkeys
168
447000
2000
07:54
that they were
169
449000
2000
07:56
getting with these darts.
170
451000
4000
08:00
This is Yadira,
171
455000
2000
08:02
and Yadira is
172
457000
2000
08:04
five years old. She's in a
173
459000
3000
08:07
tribe that's neighboring the Huaorani.
174
462000
3000
08:10
And her tribe has had to move
175
465000
2000
08:12
three times in the last 10 years because of the oil spills.
176
467000
4000
08:16
And we never hear about that. And the latest
177
471000
3000
08:19
infraction against these people is,
178
474000
3000
08:22
as part of Plan Colombia,
179
477000
2000
08:24
we're spraying Paraquat or Round Up, whatever it is --
180
479000
3000
08:27
we're defoliating thousands of acres
181
482000
3000
08:30
of the Ecuadorian Amazon
182
485000
2000
08:32
in our war on drugs.
183
487000
2000
08:34
And these people are the people who take the brunt of it.
184
489000
4000
08:38
This is Mengatoue.
185
493000
2000
08:40
He's the shaman of the Huaorani,
186
495000
2000
08:42
and
187
497000
3000
08:45
he said to us, you know, I'm an older man now;
188
500000
3000
08:48
I'm getting tired, you know; I'm tired
189
503000
2000
08:50
of spearing these oil workers.
190
505000
2000
08:52
I wish they would just go away.
191
507000
3000
08:57
And I was -- I usually travel alone
192
512000
3000
09:00
when I do my work, but I did this --
193
515000
3000
09:03
I hosted a program for Discovery,
194
518000
2000
09:05
and when I went down with the team,
195
520000
3000
09:08
I was quite concerned about
196
523000
3000
09:11
going in with a whole bunch of people, especially into the Huaorani,
197
526000
3000
09:14
deep into the Huaorani tribe.
198
529000
2000
09:16
And
199
531000
2000
09:18
as it turned out, these guys really
200
533000
2000
09:20
taught me a thing or two about blending in
201
535000
3000
09:23
with the locals.
202
538000
2000
09:25
(Laughter)
203
540000
3000
09:28
One of the things I did
204
543000
3000
09:31
just before 9/11 --
205
546000
3000
09:34
August of 2001 --
206
549000
2000
09:36
I took my son, Dax,
207
551000
2000
09:38
who was 16 at the time,
208
553000
3000
09:41
and I took him to Pakistan.
209
556000
2000
09:43
Because at first I wanted --
210
558000
2000
09:45
you know, I've taken him on a couple of trips,
211
560000
2000
09:47
but I wanted him to see
212
562000
2000
09:49
people that live on a dollar a day or less.
213
564000
3000
09:52
I wanted him to get an experience
214
567000
2000
09:54
in the Islamic world
215
569000
2000
09:56
and I also wanted him to --
216
571000
3000
09:59
I was going there to work with a group,
217
574000
2000
10:01
do a story on a group called the Kalash,
218
576000
2000
10:03
that are a group of animists, 3,000 animists,
219
578000
2000
10:05
that live -- very small area --
220
580000
4000
10:09
surrounded by Islam -- there's 3,000
221
584000
3000
10:12
of these Kalash left; they're incredible people.
222
587000
4000
10:16
So it was a great experience for him. He stayed up all night with them,
223
591000
3000
10:19
drumming and dancing.
224
594000
2000
10:21
And he brought a soccer ball,
225
596000
2000
10:23
and we had soccer every night in this little village.
226
598000
3000
10:26
And then we went up
227
601000
2000
10:28
and met their shaman.
228
603000
2000
10:30
By the way, Mengatoue was the shaman
229
605000
2000
10:32
of his tribe as well.
230
607000
2000
10:34
And this is John Doolikahn,
231
609000
2000
10:36
who's the shaman of the Kalash.
232
611000
3000
10:39
And he's up in the mountains,
233
614000
2000
10:41
right on the border with Afghanistan.
234
616000
2000
10:43
In fact, on that other side is the area, Tora Bora,
235
618000
3000
10:46
the area where
236
621000
3000
10:49
Osama bin Laden's supposed to be. This is the tribal area.
237
624000
3000
10:52
And we watched
238
627000
3000
10:55
and stayed with
239
630000
2000
10:57
John Doolikahn.
240
632000
2000
10:59
And the shaman -- I did a whole series on shamanism,
241
634000
3000
11:02
which is
242
637000
2000
11:04
an interesting phenomenon.
243
639000
2000
11:06
But around the world,
244
641000
2000
11:08
they go into trance in different ways,
245
643000
2000
11:10
and in Pakistan,
246
645000
2000
11:12
the way they do it is they burn juniper leaves
247
647000
3000
11:15
and they sacrifice an animal,
248
650000
3000
11:18
pour the blood of the animal on the leaves
249
653000
2000
11:20
and then inhale the smoke.
250
655000
2000
11:22
And they're all praying
251
657000
3000
11:25
to the mountain gods
252
660000
3000
11:28
as they go into trance.
253
663000
3000
11:32
You know,
254
667000
2000
11:34
getting kids used to different realities,
255
669000
4000
11:38
I think, is so important. What Dan Dennett said the other day --
256
673000
3000
11:42
having a curriculum where they study different religions,
257
677000
3000
11:45
just to make a mental flexibility,
258
680000
2000
11:47
give them a mental flexibility
259
682000
2000
11:49
in different belief systems --
260
684000
2000
11:51
I think this is so necessary in our world today
261
686000
3000
11:54
as you see these clash of beliefs taking place.
262
689000
4000
11:58
And all the security issues they cause us.
263
693000
4000
12:02
So, one thing we did five years ago:
264
697000
3000
12:05
we started a program that links kids
265
700000
2000
12:08
in indigenous communities with kids in the United States.
266
703000
2000
12:10
So we first hooked up
267
705000
3000
12:13
a spot in the Navajo Nation with a classroom in Seattle.
268
708000
5000
12:18
We now have 15 sites.
269
713000
3000
12:21
We have one in Kathmandu, Nepal;
270
716000
3000
12:24
Dharamsala, India; Takaungu, Kenya --
271
719000
2000
12:26
Takaungu is one-third Christian, one-third Muslim
272
721000
3000
12:29
and one-third animist, the community is --
273
724000
3000
12:32
Ollantaytambo, Peru,
274
727000
2000
12:34
and Arctic Village, Alaska.
275
729000
2000
12:36
This is Daniel; he's one of our students
276
731000
2000
12:38
in Arctic Village, Alaska.
277
733000
2000
12:40
He lives in this log cabin --
278
735000
2000
12:42
no running water, no heat other than --
279
737000
3000
12:45
no windows
280
740000
2000
12:47
and high-speed Internet connection.
281
742000
2000
12:49
And this is --
282
744000
2000
12:51
I see this rolling out all over --
283
746000
2000
12:53
this is our site in Ollantaytambo, Peru, four years ago,
284
748000
2000
12:56
where they first saw their first computers;
285
751000
2000
12:58
now they have computers in their classrooms.
286
753000
3000
13:01
And the way we've done this --
287
756000
2000
13:03
we teach digital storytelling to these kids.
288
758000
3000
13:06
And we have them tell stories about issues in their community
289
761000
3000
13:09
in their community that they care about.
290
764000
2000
13:11
And this is in Peru, where the kids told the story
291
766000
2000
13:13
about a river that they cleaned up.
292
768000
2000
13:15
And the way we do it is, we do it in workshops,
293
770000
3000
13:18
and we bring people who want to learn
294
773000
3000
13:21
digital workflow and storytelling,
295
776000
3000
13:25
and have them
296
780000
2000
13:27
work with the kids.
297
782000
2000
13:29
And just this last year we've taken a group of teenagers in,
298
784000
4000
13:33
and this has worked the best.
299
788000
2000
13:35
So our dream is to bring teenagers together,
300
790000
2000
13:37
so they'll have a community service experience
301
792000
3000
13:40
as well as a cross-cultural experience,
302
795000
3000
13:43
as they teach kids in these areas
303
798000
2000
13:45
and help them build their communication infrastructure.
304
800000
3000
13:48
This is teaching Photoshop
305
803000
3000
13:51
in the Tibetan children's village in Dharamsala.
306
806000
4000
13:55
We have the website, where the kids all get their homepage.
307
810000
3000
13:58
This is all their movies. We've got about 60 movies
308
813000
2000
14:00
that these kids have made,
309
815000
2000
14:02
and they're quite incredible.
310
817000
2000
14:04
The one I want to show you --
311
819000
2000
14:06
after we get them to make the movies,
312
821000
3000
14:09
we have a night where we show the movies to the community.
313
824000
3000
14:12
And this is in Takaungu --
314
827000
2000
14:14
we've got a generator and a digital projector,
315
829000
2000
14:16
and we're projecting it up against a barn,
316
831000
2000
14:18
and showing one of the movies that they made.
317
833000
3000
14:21
And if you get a chance, you can go to our website, and you'll see
318
836000
3000
14:24
the incredible work these kids do.
319
839000
3000
14:27
The other thing:
320
842000
3000
14:30
I wanted to give indigenous people a voice.
321
845000
2000
14:32
That was one of the big motivating factors.
322
847000
3000
14:35
But the other motivating factor is
323
850000
2000
14:37
the insular nature of our country.
324
852000
3000
14:40
National Geographic just did a Roper Study
325
855000
3000
14:43
of 18 to 26 year olds
326
858000
3000
14:46
in our country
327
861000
2000
14:48
and in nine other industrialized countries.
328
863000
3000
14:51
It was a two million dollar study.
329
866000
2000
14:53
United States came in second to last
330
868000
3000
14:56
in geographic knowledge.
331
871000
2000
14:58
70 percent of the kids couldn't find
332
873000
2000
15:00
Afghanistan or Iraq on a map;
333
875000
3000
15:03
60 percent couldn't find India;
334
878000
3000
15:06
30 percent couldn't find the Pacific Ocean.
335
881000
3000
15:09
And this is a study
336
884000
2000
15:11
that was just done a couple of years ago.
337
886000
3000
15:15
So what I'd like to show you now,
338
890000
2000
15:18
in the couple of minutes I have left,
339
893000
2000
15:20
is a film that a student made in Guatemala.
340
895000
2000
15:22
We just had a workshop in Guatemala.
341
897000
3000
15:25
A week before we got to the workshop,
342
900000
3000
15:28
a massive landslide, caused by Hurricane Stan,
343
903000
4000
15:32
last October, came in and buried
344
907000
2000
15:34
600 people alive in their village.
345
909000
2000
15:36
And this kid lived in the village --
346
911000
2000
15:38
he wasn't there at the time --
347
913000
2000
15:40
and this is the little movie he put together about that.
348
915000
4000
15:44
And he hadn't seen a computer before
349
919000
2000
15:46
we did this movie. We taught him Photoshop and --
350
921000
4000
15:50
yeah, we can play it.
351
925000
2000
16:15
This is an old Mayan funeral chant
352
950000
3000
16:18
that he got from his grandfather.
353
953000
2000
18:38
Thank you very much.
354
1093000
2000
18:40
(Applause)
355
1095000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Phil Borges - PhotographerDentist-turned-photographer Phil Borges documents the world's disappearing cultures, capturing portraits of exiled Tibetan monks and many of the world’s embattled tribal and indigenous cultures.
Why you should listen
Spurred by the rapid disappearance of the world's indigenous peoples and their oral traditions, Phil Borges abandoned his orthodontic practice to pursue his first love, photography. For the past 25 years, he has traveled to the farthest reaches of the globe to meet with persecuted Tibetan monks engaged in nonviolent struggle and embattled tribespeople of the Ecuadorian Amazon who must defend their way of life by any means necessary. Through interviews and portraiture, Borges examines his subjects' valuable beliefs and stories and documents their tribulations with dignity.
He is the founder of Bridges to Understanding, an interactive online classroom that promotes cross-cultural learning between indigenous and American youths. By teaching teenagers how to share stories through digital filmmaking, Borges hopes they'll develop the mental flexibility and cultural sensitivity to understand and appreciate belief systems outside their own. Borges' feature-length documentary, CRAZYWISE, takes a look at America’s mental health care crisis and examines what we could learn from the way different cultures define and treat mental illness.
Phil Borges | Speaker | TED.com