TEDGlobal 2009
Tim Brown: Designers -- think big!
Filmed:
Readability: 4.9
1,782,422 views
Tim Brown says the design profession has a bigger role to play than just creating nifty, fashionable little objects. He calls for a shift to local, collaborative, participatory "design thinking" -- starting with the example of 19th-century design thinker Isambard Kingdom Brunel.
Tim Brown - Designer
Tim Brown is the CEO of the "innovation and design" firm IDEO -- taking an approach to design that digs deeper than the surface. Full bio
Tim Brown is the CEO of the "innovation and design" firm IDEO -- taking an approach to design that digs deeper than the surface. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I'd like to talk a little bit this morning
0
0
2000
00:14
about what happens if we move from design
1
2000
3000
00:17
to design thinking.
2
5000
3000
00:20
Now this rather old photo up there
3
8000
2000
00:22
is actually the first project I was ever hired to do,
4
10000
3000
00:25
something like 25 years ago.
5
13000
2000
00:27
It's a woodworking machine, or at least a piece of one,
6
15000
2000
00:29
and my task was to
7
17000
2000
00:31
make this thing a little bit more modern,
8
19000
2000
00:33
a little bit easier to use.
9
21000
2000
00:35
I thought, at the time, I did a pretty good job.
10
23000
3000
00:38
Unfortunately, not very long afterwards
11
26000
2000
00:40
the company went out of business.
12
28000
3000
00:43
This is the second project that I did. It's a fax machine.
13
31000
3000
00:46
I put an attractive shell around some new technology.
14
34000
3000
00:49
Again, 18 months later,
15
37000
2000
00:51
the product was obsolete.
16
39000
2000
00:53
And now, of course, the whole technology is obsolete.
17
41000
5000
00:58
Now, I'm a fairly slow learner,
18
46000
2000
01:00
but eventually it occurred to me that
19
48000
2000
01:02
maybe what passed for design
20
50000
2000
01:04
wasn't all that important --
21
52000
2000
01:06
making things more attractive,
22
54000
2000
01:08
making them a bit easier to use,
23
56000
2000
01:10
making them more marketable.
24
58000
3000
01:13
By focusing on a design,
25
61000
2000
01:15
maybe just a single product,
26
63000
2000
01:17
I was being incremental
27
65000
2000
01:19
and not having much of an impact.
28
67000
4000
01:23
But I think this small view of design
29
71000
2000
01:25
is a relatively recent phenomenon,
30
73000
2000
01:27
and in fact really emerged
31
75000
2000
01:29
in the latter half of the 20th century
32
77000
2000
01:31
as design became a tool of consumerism.
33
79000
4000
01:35
So when we talk about design today,
34
83000
2000
01:37
and particularly when we read about it in the popular press,
35
85000
3000
01:40
we're often talking about products like these.
36
88000
2000
01:42
Amusing? Yes. Desirable? Maybe.
37
90000
3000
01:45
Important? Not so very.
38
93000
3000
01:48
But this wasn't always the way.
39
96000
2000
01:50
And I'd like to suggest that if we take
40
98000
2000
01:52
a different view of design,
41
100000
2000
01:54
and focus less on the object
42
102000
3000
01:57
and more on design thinking as an approach,
43
105000
3000
02:00
that we actually might see the result in a bigger impact.
44
108000
5000
02:05
Now this gentleman, Isambard Kingdom Brunel,
45
113000
2000
02:07
designed many great things in his career in the 19th century,
46
115000
4000
02:11
including the Clifton suspension bridge in Bristol
47
119000
4000
02:15
and the Thames tunnel at Rotherhithe.
48
123000
2000
02:17
Both great designs and actually very innovative too.
49
125000
5000
02:22
His greatest creation
50
130000
3000
02:25
runs actually right through here in Oxford.
51
133000
2000
02:27
It's called the Great Western Railway.
52
135000
3000
02:30
And as a kid I grew up very close to here,
53
138000
3000
02:33
and one of my favorite things to do
54
141000
2000
02:35
was to cycle along by the side of the railway
55
143000
3000
02:38
waiting for the great big express trains to roar past.
56
146000
3000
02:41
You can see it represented here in J.M.W. Turner's painting,
57
149000
2000
02:43
"Rain, Steam and Speed".
58
151000
3000
02:46
Now, what Brunel said that he wanted to achieve for his passengers
59
154000
4000
02:50
was the experience of floating across the countryside.
60
158000
5000
02:55
Now, this was back in the 19th century.
61
163000
2000
02:57
And to do that meant creating the flattest gradients
62
165000
2000
02:59
that had ever yet been made,
63
167000
2000
03:01
which meant building long viaducts across river valleys --
64
169000
3000
03:04
this is actually the viaduct across the Thames at Maidenhead --
65
172000
4000
03:08
and long tunnels such as the one at Box, in Wiltshire.
66
176000
6000
03:14
But he didn't stop there. He didn't stop
67
182000
2000
03:16
with just trying to design the best railway journey.
68
184000
3000
03:19
He imagined an integrated transportation system
69
187000
4000
03:23
in which it would be possible for a passenger to embark
70
191000
3000
03:26
on a train in London
71
194000
3000
03:29
and disembark from a ship in New York.
72
197000
3000
03:32
One journey from London to New York.
73
200000
4000
03:36
This is the S.S. Great Western that he built
74
204000
2000
03:38
to take care of the second half of that journey.
75
206000
4000
03:42
Now, Brunel was working 100 years before
76
210000
2000
03:44
the emergence of the design profession,
77
212000
3000
03:47
but I think he was using design thinking
78
215000
3000
03:50
to solve problems and to create world-changing innovations.
79
218000
5000
03:55
Now, design thinking begins with what Roger Martin,
80
223000
2000
03:57
the business school professor at the University of Toronto,
81
225000
3000
04:00
calls integrative thinking.
82
228000
2000
04:02
And that's the ability to exploit opposing ideas
83
230000
3000
04:05
and opposing constraints
84
233000
2000
04:07
to create new solutions.
85
235000
2000
04:09
In the case of design, that means
86
237000
3000
04:12
balancing desirability, what humans need,
87
240000
4000
04:16
with technical feasibility,
88
244000
2000
04:18
and economic viability.
89
246000
3000
04:21
With innovations like the Great Western,
90
249000
2000
04:23
we can stretch that balance to the absolute limit.
91
251000
4000
04:27
So somehow, we went from this to this.
92
255000
7000
04:34
Systems thinkers who were reinventing the world,
93
262000
3000
04:37
to a priesthood of folks in black turtlenecks and designer glasses
94
265000
5000
04:42
working on small things.
95
270000
2000
04:44
As our industrial society matured,
96
272000
4000
04:48
so design became a profession
97
276000
2000
04:50
and it focused on an ever smaller canvas
98
278000
3000
04:53
until it came to stand for aesthetics,
99
281000
2000
04:55
image and fashion.
100
283000
2000
04:57
Now I'm not trying to throw stones here.
101
285000
3000
05:00
I'm a fully paid-up member of that priesthood,
102
288000
2000
05:02
and somewhere in here I have my designer glasses.
103
290000
2000
05:04
There we go.
104
292000
3000
05:07
But I do think that perhaps design
105
295000
2000
05:09
is getting big again.
106
297000
2000
05:11
And that's happening through
107
299000
3000
05:14
the application of design thinking
108
302000
2000
05:16
to new kinds of problems --
109
304000
2000
05:18
to global warming, to education,
110
306000
2000
05:20
healthcare, security, clean water, whatever.
111
308000
4000
05:24
And as we see this reemergence of design thinking
112
312000
3000
05:27
and we see it beginning to tackle new kinds of problems,
113
315000
3000
05:30
there are some basic ideas that I think we can observe that are useful.
114
318000
3000
05:33
And I'd like to talk about some of those
115
321000
2000
05:35
just for the next few minutes.
116
323000
2000
05:37
The first of those is that design is
117
325000
2000
05:39
human-centered.
118
327000
3000
05:42
It may integrate technology and economics,
119
330000
2000
05:44
but it starts with what humans need, or might need.
120
332000
4000
05:48
What makes life easier, more enjoyable?
121
336000
2000
05:50
What makes technology useful and usable?
122
338000
4000
05:54
But that is more than simply good ergonomics,
123
342000
3000
05:57
putting the buttons in the right place.
124
345000
3000
06:00
It's often about understanding culture and context
125
348000
3000
06:03
before we even know where to start to have ideas.
126
351000
3000
06:06
So when a team was working on a new vision screening program in India,
127
354000
4000
06:10
they wanted to understand what the aspirations
128
358000
2000
06:12
and motivations were of these school children
129
360000
3000
06:15
to understand how they might play a role
130
363000
2000
06:17
in screening their parents.
131
365000
5000
06:22
Conversion Sound has developed a high quality,
132
370000
2000
06:24
ultra-low-cost digital hearing aid
133
372000
3000
06:27
for the developing world.
134
375000
2000
06:29
Now, in the West we rely on highly trained technicians
135
377000
4000
06:33
to fit these hearing aids.
136
381000
2000
06:35
In places like India, those technicians simply don't exist.
137
383000
4000
06:39
So it took a team working in India
138
387000
2000
06:41
with patients and community health workers
139
389000
2000
06:43
to understand how a PDA
140
391000
2000
06:45
and an application on a PDA
141
393000
2000
06:47
might replace those technicians
142
395000
2000
06:49
in a fitting and diagnostic service.
143
397000
3000
06:52
Instead of starting with technology,
144
400000
2000
06:54
the team started with people and culture.
145
402000
3000
06:57
So if human need is the place to start,
146
405000
3000
07:00
then design thinking rapidly moves on to
147
408000
2000
07:02
learning by making.
148
410000
2000
07:04
Instead of thinking about what to build,
149
412000
3000
07:07
building in order to think.
150
415000
3000
07:10
Now, prototypes speed up the process of innovation,
151
418000
3000
07:13
because it is only when we put our ideas out into the world
152
421000
3000
07:16
that we really start to understand their strengths and weaknesses.
153
424000
3000
07:19
And the faster we do that,
154
427000
2000
07:21
the faster our ideas evolve.
155
429000
3000
07:24
Now, much has been said and written about
156
432000
2000
07:26
the Aravind Eye Institute in Madurai, India.
157
434000
3000
07:29
They do an incredible job of serving very poor patients
158
437000
4000
07:33
by taking the revenues from those who can afford to pay
159
441000
2000
07:35
to cross-subsidize those who cannot.
160
443000
4000
07:39
Now, they are very efficient,
161
447000
3000
07:42
but they are also very innovative.
162
450000
3000
07:45
When I visited them a few years ago,
163
453000
3000
07:48
what really impressed me was their willingness
164
456000
2000
07:50
to prototype their ideas very early.
165
458000
2000
07:52
This is the manufacturing facility
166
460000
2000
07:54
for one of their biggest cost breakthroughs.
167
462000
2000
07:56
They make their own intraocular lenses.
168
464000
3000
07:59
These are the lenses that replace those
169
467000
2000
08:01
that are damaged by cataracts.
170
469000
2000
08:03
And I think it's partly their prototyping mentality
171
471000
4000
08:07
that really allowed them to achieve the breakthrough.
172
475000
2000
08:09
Because they brought the cost down
173
477000
2000
08:11
from $200 a pair,
174
479000
1000
08:12
down to just $4 a pair.
175
480000
5000
08:17
Partly they did this by instead of building
176
485000
2000
08:19
a fancy new factory,
177
487000
2000
08:21
they used the basement of one of their hospitals.
178
489000
4000
08:25
And instead of installing the large-scale machines
179
493000
3000
08:28
used by western producers,
180
496000
2000
08:30
they used low-cost CAD/CAM prototyping technology.
181
498000
4000
08:34
They are now the biggest manufacturer of these lenses in the developing world
182
502000
4000
08:38
and have recently moved into a custom factory.
183
506000
4000
08:42
So if human need is the place to start,
184
510000
2000
08:44
and prototyping, a vehicle for progress,
185
512000
2000
08:46
then there are also some questions to ask about the destination.
186
514000
4000
08:50
Instead of seeing its primary objective as consumption,
187
518000
5000
08:55
design thinking is beginning to explore the potential of participation --
188
523000
3000
08:58
the shift from a passive relationship
189
526000
3000
09:01
between consumer and producer
190
529000
2000
09:03
to the active engagement of everyone
191
531000
2000
09:05
in experiences that are meaningful,
192
533000
2000
09:07
productive and profitable.
193
535000
4000
09:11
So I'd like to take the idea that Rory Sutherland talked about,
194
539000
3000
09:14
this notion that intangible things are worth perhaps more than physical things,
195
542000
3000
09:17
and take that a little bit further and say that
196
545000
2000
09:19
I think the design of participatory systems,
197
547000
3000
09:22
in which many more forms of value
198
550000
3000
09:25
beyond simply cash
199
553000
2000
09:27
are both created and measured,
200
555000
3000
09:30
is going to be the major theme, not only for design,
201
558000
3000
09:33
but also for our economy as we go forward.
202
561000
4000
09:37
So William Beveridge, when he wrote the first of his famous reports in 1942,
203
565000
4000
09:41
created what became Britain's welfare state
204
569000
4000
09:45
in which he hoped that every citizen
205
573000
3000
09:48
would be an active participant
206
576000
2000
09:50
in their own social well-being.
207
578000
2000
09:52
By the time he wrote his third report,
208
580000
3000
09:55
he confessed that he had failed
209
583000
2000
09:57
and instead had created a society of welfare consumers.
210
585000
6000
10:03
Hilary Cottam, Charlie Leadbeater,
211
591000
2000
10:05
and Hugo Manassei of Participle
212
593000
2000
10:07
have taken this idea of participation,
213
595000
3000
10:10
and in their manifesto entitled Beveridge 4.0,
214
598000
3000
10:13
they are suggesting a framework
215
601000
2000
10:15
for reinventing the welfare state.
216
603000
3000
10:18
So in one of their projects called Southwark Circle,
217
606000
2000
10:20
they worked with residents in Southwark, South London
218
608000
3000
10:23
and a small team of designers
219
611000
2000
10:25
to develop a new membership organization
220
613000
4000
10:29
to help the elderly with household tasks.
221
617000
3000
10:32
Designs were refined and developed
222
620000
2000
10:34
with 150 older people and their families
223
622000
3000
10:37
before the service was launched earlier this year.
224
625000
5000
10:42
We can take this idea of participation
225
630000
4000
10:46
perhaps to its logical conclusion
226
634000
2000
10:48
and say that design may have its greatest impact
227
636000
2000
10:50
when it's taken out of the hands of designers
228
638000
3000
10:53
and put into the hands of everyone.
229
641000
3000
10:56
Nurses and practitioners at U.S. healthcare system
230
644000
3000
10:59
Kaiser Permanente
231
647000
2000
11:01
study the topic of improving the patient experience,
232
649000
5000
11:06
and particularly focused on the way that they exchange knowledge
233
654000
5000
11:11
and change shift.
234
659000
3000
11:14
Through a program of observational research,
235
662000
2000
11:16
brainstorming new solutions and rapid prototyping,
236
664000
3000
11:19
they've developed a completely new way to change shift.
237
667000
3000
11:22
They went from retreating to the nurse's station
238
670000
4000
11:26
to discuss the various states and needs of patients,
239
674000
2000
11:28
to developing a system that happened on the ward
240
676000
3000
11:31
in front of patients, using a simple software tool.
241
679000
3000
11:34
By doing this they brought the time that they were away from patients
242
682000
2000
11:36
down from 40 minutes to 12 minutes, on average.
243
684000
4000
11:40
They increased patient confidence and nurse happiness.
244
688000
4000
11:44
When you multiply that by all the nurses
245
692000
2000
11:46
in all the wards in 40 hospitals in the system,
246
694000
3000
11:49
it resulted, actually, in a pretty big impact.
247
697000
2000
11:51
And this is just one of thousands
248
699000
2000
11:53
of opportunities in healthcare alone.
249
701000
6000
11:59
So these are just some of the kind of basic ideas
250
707000
3000
12:02
around design thinking
251
710000
2000
12:04
and some of the new kinds of projects
252
712000
2000
12:06
that they're being applied to.
253
714000
3000
12:09
But I'd like to go back to Brunel here,
254
717000
2000
12:11
and suggest a connection that might explain why this is happening now,
255
719000
4000
12:15
and maybe why design thinking is a useful tool.
256
723000
5000
12:20
And that connection is change.
257
728000
3000
12:23
In times of change we need
258
731000
2000
12:25
new alternatives, new ideas.
259
733000
4000
12:29
Now, Brunel worked at the height of the Industrial Revolution,
260
737000
2000
12:31
when all of life and our economy
261
739000
2000
12:33
was being reinvented.
262
741000
2000
12:35
Now the industrial systems of Brunel's time have run their course,
263
743000
4000
12:39
and indeed they are part of the problem today.
264
747000
2000
12:41
But, again, we are in the midst of massive change.
265
749000
4000
12:45
And that change is forcing us to question
266
753000
3000
12:48
quite fundamental aspects of our society --
267
756000
2000
12:50
how we keep ourselves healthy, how we govern ourselves,
268
758000
3000
12:53
how we educate ourselves, how we keep ourselves secure.
269
761000
4000
12:57
And in these times of change, we need these new choices
270
765000
3000
13:00
because our existing solutions are simply becoming obsolete.
271
768000
5000
13:05
So why design thinking?
272
773000
2000
13:07
Because it gives us a new way of tackling problems.
273
775000
3000
13:10
Instead of defaulting to our normal convergent approach
274
778000
5000
13:15
where we make the best choice out of available alternatives,
275
783000
4000
13:19
it encourages us to take a divergent approach,
276
787000
3000
13:22
to explore new alternatives, new solutions,
277
790000
2000
13:24
new ideas that have not existed before.
278
792000
4000
13:28
But before we go through that process of divergence,
279
796000
2000
13:30
there is actually quite an important first step.
280
798000
3000
13:33
And that is, what is the question that we're trying to answer?
281
801000
3000
13:36
What's the design brief?
282
804000
2000
13:38
Now Brunel may have asked a question like this,
283
806000
2000
13:40
"How do I take a train from London to New York?"
284
808000
4000
13:44
But what are the kinds of questions that we might ask today?
285
812000
4000
13:48
So these are some that we've been asked to think about recently.
286
816000
6000
13:54
And one in particular, is one that we're working on with the Acumen Fund,
287
822000
3000
13:57
in a project that's been funded by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
288
825000
4000
14:01
How might we improve access to safe drinking water
289
829000
3000
14:04
for the world's poorest people,
290
832000
2000
14:06
and at the same time stimulate innovation
291
834000
2000
14:08
amongst local water providers?
292
836000
4000
14:12
So instead of having a bunch of American designers
293
840000
2000
14:14
come up with new ideas that may or may not have been appropriate,
294
842000
3000
14:17
we took a sort of more open, collaborative and participative approach.
295
845000
4000
14:21
We teamed designers and investment experts up with
296
849000
3000
14:24
11 water organizations across India.
297
852000
3000
14:27
And through workshops they developed
298
855000
2000
14:29
innovative new products, services, and business models.
299
857000
3000
14:32
We hosted a competition
300
860000
2000
14:34
and then funded five of those organizations
301
862000
2000
14:36
to develop their ideas.
302
864000
2000
14:38
So they developed and iterated these ideas.
303
866000
2000
14:40
And then IDEO and Acumen spent several weeks working with them
304
868000
3000
14:43
to help design new social marketing campaigns,
305
871000
5000
14:48
community outreach strategies, business models,
306
876000
3000
14:51
new water vessels for storing water
307
879000
2000
14:53
and carts for delivering water.
308
881000
3000
14:56
Some of those ideas are just getting launched into the market.
309
884000
2000
14:58
And the same process is just getting underway
310
886000
2000
15:00
with NGOs in East Africa.
311
888000
3000
15:03
So for me, this project shows
312
891000
3000
15:06
kind of how far we can go from
313
894000
2000
15:08
some of those sort of small things
314
896000
2000
15:10
that I was working on
315
898000
2000
15:12
at the beginning of my career.
316
900000
2000
15:14
That by focusing on the needs of humans
317
902000
4000
15:18
and by using prototypes
318
906000
2000
15:20
to move ideas along quickly,
319
908000
2000
15:22
by getting the process out of the hands of designers,
320
910000
3000
15:25
and by getting the active participation of the community,
321
913000
3000
15:28
we can tackle bigger and more interesting questions.
322
916000
3000
15:31
And just like Brunel, by focusing on systems,
323
919000
3000
15:34
we can have a bigger impact.
324
922000
3000
15:37
So that's one thing that we've been working on.
325
925000
3000
15:40
I'm actually really quite interested, and perhaps more interested
326
928000
3000
15:43
to know what this community thinks we could work on.
327
931000
4000
15:47
What kinds of questions do we think
328
935000
3000
15:50
design thinking could be used to tackle?
329
938000
3000
15:53
And if you've got any ideas
330
941000
2000
15:55
then feel free, you can post them to Twitter.
331
943000
2000
15:57
There is a hash tag there that you can use, #CBDQ.
332
945000
3000
16:00
And the list looked something like this a little while ago.
333
948000
3000
16:03
And of course you can search to find the questions that you're interested in
334
951000
4000
16:07
by using the same hash code.
335
955000
2000
16:09
So I'd like to believe that design thinking
336
957000
4000
16:13
actually can make a difference,
337
961000
2000
16:15
that it can help create new ideas
338
963000
2000
16:17
and new innovations,
339
965000
2000
16:19
beyond the latest High Street products.
340
967000
2000
16:21
To do that I think we have to take a more expansive view of design,
341
969000
4000
16:25
more like Brunel, less a domain of a professional priesthood.
342
973000
6000
16:31
And the first step is to start asking the right questions.
343
979000
3000
16:34
Thank you very much.
344
982000
2000
16:36
(Applause)
345
984000
5000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Tim Brown - DesignerTim Brown is the CEO of the "innovation and design" firm IDEO -- taking an approach to design that digs deeper than the surface.
Why you should listen
Tim Brown is the CEO of innovation and design firm IDEO, taking an approach to design that digs deeper than the surface. Having taken over from founder David E. Kelley, Tim Brown carries forward the firm's mission of fusing design, business and social studies to come up with deeply researched, deeply understood designs and ideas -- they call it "design thinking."
IDEO is the kind of firm that companies turn to when they want a top-down rethink of a business or product -- from fast food conglomerates to high-tech startups, hospitals to universities.
IDEO has designed and prototyped everything from a life-saving portable defibrillator to the defining details at the groundbreaking Prada shop in Manhattan to corporate processes. And check out the Global Chain Reaction for a sample of how seriously this firm takes play.
Curious about design thinking? Sign up for an IDEO U design thinking course or check out this free toolkit: Design Thinking for Educators.
Tim Brown | Speaker | TED.com