TEDGlobal 2012
Robert Neuwirth: The power of the informal economy
Filmed:
Readability: 4.5
871,851 views
Robert Neuwirth spent four years among the chaotic stalls of street markets, talking to pushcart hawkers and gray marketers, to study the remarkable "System D," the world's unlicensed economic network. Responsible for some 1.8 billion jobs, it's an economy of underappreciated power and scope.
Robert Neuwirth - Author
Robert Neuwirth’s writings on the street-level reality of the developing world have opened a new dialogue on development and economics. Full bio
Robert Neuwirth’s writings on the street-level reality of the developing world have opened a new dialogue on development and economics. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:16
In System D, this
0
705
2225
00:18
is a store,
1
2930
2047
00:20
and what I mean by that is that this is a photograph
2
4977
2327
00:23
I took in Makoko, shantytown in Lagos, Nigeria.
3
7304
5315
00:28
It's built over the lagoon, and there are no streets
4
12619
2383
00:30
where there can be stores to shop,
5
15002
1816
00:32
and so the store comes to you.
6
16818
1890
00:34
And in the same community,
7
18708
1785
00:36
this is business synergy.
8
20493
1752
00:38
This is the boat that that lady was paddling around in,
9
22245
4106
00:42
and this artisan makes the boat and the paddles
10
26351
2740
00:44
and sells directly
11
29091
1305
00:46
to the people who need the boat and the paddles.
12
30396
2164
00:48
And this is a global business.
13
32560
2182
00:50
Ogandiro smokes fish in Makoko in Lagos,
14
34742
4126
00:54
and I asked her, "Where does the fish come from?"
15
38868
2961
00:57
And I thought she'd say, "Oh, you know,
16
41829
2726
01:00
up the lagoon somewhere, or maybe across Africa,"
17
44555
2901
01:03
but you'll be happy to know she said
18
47456
1431
01:04
it came from here, it comes from the North Sea.
19
48887
2057
01:06
It's caught here, frozen, shipped down to Lagos,
20
50944
2326
01:09
smoked, and sold for a tiny increment of profit
21
53270
3087
01:12
on the streets of Lagos.
22
56357
1522
01:13
And this is a business incubator.
23
57879
1851
01:15
This is Olusosun dump, the largest garbage dump in Lagos,
24
59730
3702
01:19
and 2,000 people work here, and I found this out
25
63432
3071
01:22
from this fellow, Andrew Saboru.
26
66503
2418
01:24
Andrew spent 16 years scavenging materials on the dump,
27
68921
4160
01:28
earned enough money to turn himself into a contract scaler,
28
73081
3228
01:32
which meant he carried a scale and went around and
29
76309
2610
01:34
weighed all the materials that people had scavenged
30
78919
2224
01:37
from the dump. Now he's a scrap dealer.
31
81143
3023
01:40
That's his little depot behind him,
32
84166
2401
01:42
and he earns twice the Nigerian minimum wage.
33
86567
4511
01:46
This is a shopping mall.
34
91078
2262
01:49
This is Oshodi Market in Lagos.
35
93340
2175
01:51
Jorge Luis Borges had a story called "The Aleph,"
36
95515
2346
01:53
and the Aleph is a point in the world
37
97861
1823
01:55
where absolutely everything exists,
38
99684
2295
01:57
and for me, this image is a point in the world
39
101979
2345
02:00
where absolutely everything exists.
40
104324
2464
02:02
So, what am I talking about when I talk about System D?
41
106788
2849
02:05
It's traditionally called the informal economy,
42
109637
2299
02:07
the underground economy, the black market.
43
111936
3628
02:11
I don't conceive of it that way.
44
115564
2293
02:13
I think it's really important to understand that something like
45
117857
2757
02:16
this is totally open. It's right there for you to find.
46
120614
4480
02:20
All of this is happening openly, and aboveboard.
47
125094
2727
02:23
There's nothing underground about it.
48
127821
2522
02:26
It's our prejudgment that it's underground.
49
130343
3382
02:29
I've pirated the term System D from the former French colonies.
50
133725
4505
02:34
There's a word in French that is débrouillardise,
51
138230
3096
02:37
that means to be self-reliant,
52
141326
2120
02:39
and the former French colonies have turned that into
53
143446
3363
02:42
System D for the economy of self-reliance,
54
146809
2557
02:45
or the DIY economy.
55
149366
3258
02:48
But governments hate the DIY economy,
56
152624
3129
02:51
and that's why -- I took this picture in 2007,
57
155753
3244
02:54
and this is the same market in 2009 --
58
158997
4552
02:59
and I think, when the organizers of this conference
59
163549
2306
03:01
were talking about radical openness,
60
165855
1427
03:03
they didn't mean that the streets should be open
61
167282
2556
03:05
and the people should be gone.
62
169838
1743
03:07
I think what we have is a pickle problem.
63
171581
3943
03:11
I had a friend who worked at a pickle factory,
64
175524
2940
03:14
and the cucumbers would come flying down
65
178464
1901
03:16
this conveyer belt, and his job was to pick off the ones
66
180365
4003
03:20
that didn't look so good and throw them in the bin
67
184368
2349
03:22
labeled "relish" where they'd be crushed and mixed
68
186717
1906
03:24
with vinegar and used for other kinds of profit.
69
188623
3326
03:27
This is the pickle economy.
70
191949
2311
03:30
We're all focusing on — this is a statistic from
71
194260
2505
03:32
earlier this month in the Financial Times —
72
196765
2579
03:35
we're all focusing on the luxury economy.
73
199344
3543
03:38
It's worth 1.5 trillion dollars every year, and that's
74
202887
2743
03:41
a vast amount of money, right?
75
205630
1744
03:43
That's three times the Gross Domestic Product of Switzerland.
76
207374
3248
03:46
So it's vast. But it should come with an asterisk,
77
210622
4798
03:51
and the asterisk is that it excludes two thirds of the workers
78
215420
4193
03:55
of the world.
79
219613
1053
03:56
1.8 billion people around the world work
80
220666
3389
03:59
in the economy that is unregulated and informal.
81
224055
5536
04:05
That's a huge number, and what does that mean?
82
229591
3280
04:08
Well, it means if it were united in a single political system,
83
232871
4753
04:13
one country, call it
84
237624
4255
04:17
"The United Street Sellers Republic," the U.S.S.R.,
85
241879
3001
04:20
or "Bazaaristan,"
86
244880
1833
04:22
it would be worth 10 trillion dollars every year,
87
246713
4276
04:26
and that would make it the second largest economy
88
250989
2056
04:28
in the world, after the United States.
89
253045
2481
04:31
And given that projections are that the bulk
90
255526
2840
04:34
of economic growth over the next 15 years will come
91
258366
3665
04:37
from emerging economies in the developing world,
92
262031
3372
04:41
it could easily overtake the United States
93
265403
2131
04:43
and become the largest economy in the world.
94
267534
3366
04:46
So the implications of that are vast, because it means
95
270900
3535
04:50
that this is where employment is — 1.8 billion people —
96
274435
3523
04:53
and this is where we can create a more egalitarian world,
97
277958
4622
04:58
because people are actually able to earn money and live
98
282580
3971
05:02
and thrive, as Andrew Saboru did.
99
286551
2995
05:05
Big businesses have recognized this,
100
289546
2161
05:07
and what's fascinating about this slide,
101
291707
1979
05:09
it's not that the guys can carry boxes on their heads
102
293686
2258
05:11
and run around without dropping them off.
103
295944
2515
05:14
it's that the Gala sausage roll is a product that's made
104
298459
3095
05:17
by a global company called UAC foods
105
301554
2710
05:20
that's active throughout Africa and the Middle East,
106
304264
2567
05:22
but the Gala sausage roll is not sold in stores.
107
306831
3689
05:26
UAC foods has recognized that it won't sell if it's in stores.
108
310520
3337
05:29
It's only sold by a phalanx of street hawkers
109
313857
4105
05:33
who run around the streets of Lagos at bus stations
110
317962
2813
05:36
and in traffic jams and sell it as a snack,
111
320775
4473
05:41
and it's been sold that way for 40 years.
112
325248
3022
05:44
It's a business plan for a corporation.
113
328270
2170
05:46
And it's not just in Africa.
114
330440
2493
05:48
Here's Mr. Clean looking amorously at all the other
115
332933
3113
05:51
Procter & Gamble products,
116
336046
1920
05:53
and Procter & Gamble, you know,
117
337966
2448
05:56
the statistic always cited is that Wal-Mart
118
340414
2577
05:58
is their largest customer, and it's true, as one store,
119
342991
4841
06:03
Wal-Mart buys 15 percent, thus 15 percent
120
347847
3187
06:06
of Procter & Gamble's business is with Wal-Mart,
121
351034
3100
06:10
but their largest market segment is something that they call
122
354134
3561
06:13
"high frequency stores," which is all these tiny kiosks
123
357695
2920
06:16
and the lady in the canoe and all these other businesses
124
360615
3311
06:19
that exist in System D, the informal economy,
125
363926
5347
06:25
and Procter & Gamble makes 20 percent of its money
126
369273
3398
06:28
from that market segment,
127
372671
2049
06:30
and it's the only market segment that's growing.
128
374720
3436
06:34
So Procter & Gamble says, "We don't care whether a store
129
378156
3108
06:37
is incorporated or registered or anything like that.
130
381264
2894
06:40
We want our products in that store."
131
384158
3833
06:43
And then there's mobile phones.
132
387991
2172
06:46
This is an ad for MTN,
133
390163
1840
06:47
which is a South African multinational
134
392003
2642
06:50
active in about 25 countries,
135
394645
2749
06:53
and when they came into Nigeria —
136
397394
1561
06:54
Nigeria is the big dog in Africa.
137
398955
1957
06:56
One in seven Africans is a Nigerian,
138
400912
2324
06:59
and so everyone wants in to the mobile phone market
139
403236
2702
07:01
in Nigeria. And when MTN came in, they wanted
140
405938
2034
07:03
to sell the mobile service like I get in the United States
141
407972
2960
07:06
or like people get here in the U.K. or in Europe --
142
410932
3774
07:10
expensive monthly plans, you get a phone,
143
414706
3889
07:14
you pay overages,
144
418595
2000
07:16
you're killed with fees --
145
420595
2128
07:18
and their plan crashed and burned.
146
422723
1804
07:20
And they went back to the drawing board, and they retooled,
147
424527
2040
07:22
and they came up with another plan:
148
426567
1504
07:23
We don't sell you the phone,
149
428071
2186
07:26
we don't sell you the monthly plan.
150
430257
1830
07:27
We only sell you airtime.
151
432087
3136
07:31
And where's the airtime sold?
152
435223
1913
07:33
It's sold at umbrella stands all over the streets,
153
437136
4093
07:37
where people are unregistered, unlicensed,
154
441229
3724
07:40
but MTN makes most of its profits,
155
444953
2705
07:43
perhaps 90 percent of its profits,
156
447658
2687
07:46
from selling through System D, the informal economy.
157
450345
4662
07:50
And where do the phones come from?
158
455007
1836
07:52
Well, they come from here. This is in Guangzhou, China,
159
456843
2874
07:55
and if you go upstairs in this rather sleepy looking
160
459717
3436
07:59
electronics mall, you find the Guangzhou Dashatou
161
463153
4626
08:03
second-hand trade center,
162
467779
2873
08:06
and if you go in there, you follow the guys with the muscles
163
470652
3184
08:09
who are carrying the boxes, and where are they going?
164
473836
2662
08:12
They're going to Eddy in Lagos.
165
476498
2817
08:15
Now, most of the phones there are not second-hand at all.
166
479315
2704
08:17
The name is a misnomer.
167
482019
1307
08:19
Most of them are pirated. They have the name brand
168
483326
2908
08:22
on them, but they're not manufactured by the name brand.
169
486234
3081
08:25
Now, are there downsides to that?
170
489315
2656
08:27
Well, I guess. You know, China has no —
171
491971
3248
08:31
(Laughter) — no intellectual property, right?
172
495219
3292
08:34
Versace without the vowels.
173
498511
1901
08:36
Zhuomani instead of Armani.
174
500412
2062
08:38
S. Guuuci, and -- (Laughter) (Applause)
175
502474
5007
08:43
All around the world this is how products
176
507481
3129
08:46
are being distributed, so, for instance,
177
510610
2520
08:49
in one street market on Rua 25 de Março
178
513130
3159
08:52
in São Paulo, Brazil,
179
516289
1969
08:54
you can buy fake designer glasses.
180
518258
3296
08:57
You can buy cloned cologne.
181
521554
2063
08:59
You can buy pirated DVDs, of course.
182
523617
2775
09:02
You can buy New York Yankees caps
183
526392
2857
09:05
in all sorts of unauthorized patterns.
184
529249
3206
09:08
You can buy cuecas baratas, designer underwear
185
532455
3089
09:11
that isn't really manufactured by a designer,
186
535544
2297
09:13
and even pirated evangelical mixtapes. (Laughter)
187
537841
4374
09:18
Now, businesses tend to complain about this,
188
542215
2754
09:20
and their, they, I don't want to take away from their
189
544969
3539
09:24
entire validity of complaining about it,
190
548508
2038
09:26
but I did ask a major sneaker manufacturer earlier this year
191
550546
4498
09:30
what they thought about piracy,
192
555044
2897
09:33
and they told me, "Well, you can't quote me on this,
193
557941
1347
09:35
because if you quote me on this, I have to kill you,"
194
559288
2100
09:37
but they use piracy as market research.
195
561388
5704
09:42
The sneaker manufacturer told me that if
196
567092
3224
09:46
they find that Pumas are being pirated, or Adidas
197
570316
3687
09:49
are being pirated and their sneakers aren't being pirated,
198
574003
3286
09:53
they know they've done something wrong. (Laughter)
199
577289
2885
09:56
So it's very important to them to track piracy
200
580174
3077
09:59
exactly because of this, and the people who are buying,
201
583251
2364
10:01
the pirates, are not their customers anyway,
202
585615
2120
10:03
because their customers want the real deal.
203
587735
2732
10:06
Now, there's another problem.
204
590467
1493
10:07
This is a real street sign in Lagos, Nigeria.
205
591960
3332
10:11
All of System D really doesn't pay taxes, right?
206
595292
3064
10:14
And when I think about that, first of all I think that
207
598356
1805
10:16
government is a social contract between the people and
208
600161
3714
10:19
the government, and if the government isn't transparent,
209
603875
2516
10:22
then the people aren't going to be transparent either,
210
606391
2221
10:24
but also that we're blaming the little guy
211
608612
3048
10:27
who doesn't pay his taxes, and we're not recognizing
212
611660
1937
10:29
that everyone's fudging things all over the world,
213
613597
2773
10:32
including some extremely respected businesses,
214
616370
4033
10:36
and I'll give you one example.
215
620403
1140
10:37
There was one company that paid 4,000 bribes
216
621543
4151
10:41
in the first decade of this millennium, and
217
625694
2398
10:43
a million dollars in bribes every business day, right?
218
628092
4901
10:48
All over the world. And that company
219
632993
2295
10:51
was the big German electronics giant Siemens.
220
635288
2906
10:54
So this goes on in the formal economy
221
638194
3878
10:57
as well as the informal economy,
222
642072
2198
11:00
so it's wrong of us to blame — and I'm not singling out
223
644270
2130
11:02
Siemens, I'm saying everyone does it. Okay?
224
646400
3719
11:06
I just want to end by saying that if Adam Smith
225
650119
3449
11:09
had framed out a theory of the flea market
226
653568
2840
11:12
instead of the free market, what would be some
227
656408
3311
11:15
of the principles?
228
659719
2009
11:17
First, it would be to understand that it could be
229
661728
3760
11:21
considered a cooperative, and this is a thought
230
665488
2191
11:23
from the Brazilian legal scholar Roberto Mangabeira Unger.
231
667679
4585
11:28
Cooperative development is a way forward.
232
672264
2593
11:30
Secondly, from the [Austrian] anarchist philosopher Paul Feyerabend,
233
674857
4678
11:35
facts are relative, and what is a massive right
234
679535
4288
11:39
of self-reliance to a Nigerian businessperson
235
683823
2985
11:42
is considered unauthorized and horrible to other people,
236
686808
4011
11:46
and we have to recognize that there are differences
237
690819
2017
11:48
in how people define things and what their facts are.
238
692836
2057
11:50
And third is, and I'm taking this from
239
694893
3100
11:53
the great American beat poet Allen Ginsberg,
240
697993
3280
11:57
that alternate economies barter and
241
701273
3152
12:00
different kinds of currency, alternate currencies
242
704425
2751
12:03
are also very important, and he talked about
243
707176
2842
12:05
buying what he needed just with his good looks.
244
710018
2991
12:08
And so I just want to leave you there, and say that
245
713009
3631
12:12
this economy is a tremendous force for global development
246
716640
4216
12:16
and we need to think about it that way.
247
720856
1967
12:18
Thank you very much. (Applause)
248
722823
3016
12:21
(Applause)
249
725839
3125
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Robert Neuwirth - AuthorRobert Neuwirth’s writings on the street-level reality of the developing world have opened a new dialogue on development and economics.
Why you should listen
For too many people in the world, Robert Neuwirth suggests, the world's globalized economic system has turned out to be a capitalism of decay. Only by embracing true sharing strategies, he argues, can people develop an equitable vision of the future.
Neuwirth is the author of two previous books: Stealth of Nations (2011), on the global growth of the street markets and cross-border smuggling, and Shadow Cities (2005), on the power of squatter communities and shantytowns. His work has appeared in documentary films, on radio and television, and in many publications. In addition to writing, he has taught at Rikers Island, New York City’s jail, and at Columbia University’s Graduate School of Journalism.
Robert Neuwirth | Speaker | TED.com