ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Margaret Bourdeaux - Physician, global health policy analyst
Margaret Bourdeaux investigates the best ways to protect, recover and reconstruct health systems and institutions disrupted by war or disaster.

Why you should listen

Margaret Ellis Bourdeaux, MD, MPH spearheads the Threatened Health Systems Project at Harvard Medical School -- an initiative that brings together public sector leaders, health care providers, academics, military strategists and private sector stakeholders to generate creative approaches to protecting valuable health system resources in countries affected by armed conflict and acute political crisis.

Bourdeaux's journey in global health began when she took a year of leave from Yale Medical School to work in refugee camps during the Kosovo War in 1999. She returned on her own after the war to trace families she had befriended in the camps and find out what had happened to them. Living in villages of Kosovo's countryside, she documented how these families struggled to care for their children, find health services and make a living in a society decimated by genocide and ethnic conflict. This experience impressed upon her the stark truth that war kills people by stripping them of their personal, community and national resources and institutions. Far more people died in Kosovo from the depleted health systems and institutions than from wounds sustained during the armed conflict.

Later experiences in Haiti, Afghanistan, Libya, Sierra Leon, Madagascar and Liberia revealed a similar pattern: armed conflict would decimate indigenous health institutions that never recovered, leaving people helpless when later crises -- earthquakes, epidemics, renewed conflict -- invariably struck. Strong, resilient health systems are the key to making war, disasters and epidemics less deadly.

After completing a joint residency in Internal Medicine and Pediatrics at the Harvard Combined Med/Peds Program, Bourdeaux was among the first graduates of Brigham and Women's Global Women's Health Fellowship. She has worked with the Office of the Secretary of Defense Policy to analyze the US Department of Defense’s global health projects and programs. She led a joint Harvard-NATO team of analysts to evaluate the impacts, challenges and opportunities international security forces have in protecting and rebuilding health systems in conflict affected states. She joined the faculty of the Division of Global Health Equity at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School in 2011.

This year she was awarded the prestigious Harvard Global Health Institute's Burke Fellowship in Global Health to investigate the responsiveness of foreign aid to health system distress and disruption. She is co-developing the first executive education course between Harvard Medical School and Harvard Kennedy School of Government for senior security policy makers on health system threat detection and response. In addition, she is launching Harvard Global Health Institute's first Summit on Threatened Health Systems in June 2017.

More profile about the speaker
Margaret Bourdeaux | Speaker | TED.com
TEDxBeaconStreet

Margaret Bourdeaux: Why civilians suffer more once a war is over

Filmed:
979,657 views

In a war, it turns out that violence isn't the biggest killer of civilians. What is? Illness, hunger, poverty -- because war destroys the institutions that keep society running, like utilities, banks, food systems and hospitals. Physician Margaret Bourdeaux proposes a bold approach to post-conflict recovery, setting priorities on what to fix first
- Physician, global health policy analyst
Margaret Bourdeaux investigates the best ways to protect, recover and reconstruct health systems and institutions disrupted by war or disaster. Full bio

Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.

00:12
So have you ever wondered
what it would be like
0
978
3102
00:16
to live in a place with no rules?
1
4104
2574
00:19
That sounds pretty cool.
2
7833
1151
00:21
(Laughter)
3
9008
1038
00:22
You wake up one morning, however,
4
10070
1637
00:23
and you discover that the reason
there are no rules
5
11731
2480
00:26
is because there's no government,
and there are no laws.
6
14235
3361
00:29
In fact, all social institutions
have disappeared.
7
17620
4067
00:34
So there's no schools,
8
22918
1333
00:36
there's no hospitals,
9
24275
1166
00:37
there's no police,
10
25465
1308
00:38
there's no banks,
11
26797
1335
00:40
there's no athletic clubs,
12
28156
2554
00:42
there's no utilities.
13
30734
1503
00:44
Well, I know a little bit
about what this is like,
14
32884
3192
00:48
because when I was
a medical student in 1999,
15
36100
2849
00:50
I worked in a refugee camp
in the Balkans during the Kosovo War.
16
38973
4485
00:57
When the war was over,
17
45009
1150
00:58
I got permission -- unbelievably --
from my medical school
18
46183
3058
01:01
to take some time off
19
49265
1151
01:02
and follow some of the families
that I had befriended in the camp
20
50440
4171
01:06
back to their village in Kosovo,
21
54635
2423
01:09
and understand how they navigated
life in this postwar setting.
22
57082
5367
01:16
Postwar Kosovo
was a very interesting place
23
64511
3220
01:19
because NATO troops were there,
24
67755
3169
01:22
mostly to make sure
the war didn't break out again.
25
70948
3636
01:26
But other than that,
it was actually a lawless place,
26
74608
3493
01:30
and almost every social institution,
both public and private,
27
78125
3265
01:33
had been destroyed.
28
81414
1275
01:35
So I can tell you
29
83619
3889
01:39
that when you go into one
of these situations and settings,
30
87532
4515
01:44
it is absolutely thrilling ...
31
92071
3807
01:47
for about 30 minutes,
32
95902
1352
01:49
because that's about how long it takes
before you run into a situation
33
97278
4672
01:53
where you realize
how incredibly vulnerable you are.
34
101974
4543
01:59
For me, that moment came
when I had to cross the first checkpoint,
35
107720
3767
02:03
and I realized as I drove up
36
111511
1793
02:05
that I would be negotiating passage
through this checkpoint
37
113328
4098
02:09
with a heavily armed individual
38
117450
2214
02:11
who, if he decided to shoot me
right then and there,
39
119688
3386
02:15
actually wouldn't be doing
anything illegal.
40
123098
2330
02:18
But the sense of vulnerability that I had
was absolutely nothing
41
126991
4863
02:23
in comparison to the vulnerability
of the families that I got to know
42
131878
3898
02:27
over that year.
43
135800
1660
02:29
You see, life in a society
where there are no social institutions
44
137484
5113
02:34
is riddled with danger and uncertainty,
45
142621
3444
02:38
and simple questions like,
"What are we going to eat tonight?"
46
146089
3374
02:42
are very complicated to answer.
47
150425
2681
02:46
Questions about security,
when you don't have any security systems,
48
154739
4350
02:51
are terrifying.
49
159113
1418
02:52
Is that altercation I had
with the neighbor down the block
50
160555
2763
02:55
going to turn into a violent episode
that will end my life
51
163342
2814
02:58
or my family's life?
52
166180
1237
03:00
Health concerns
when there is no health system
53
168023
2926
03:02
are also terrifying.
54
170973
1540
03:05
I listened as many families
had to sort through questions like,
55
173294
3618
03:08
"My infant has a fever.
What am I going to do?"
56
176936
2873
03:12
"My sister, who is pregnant,
is bleeding. What should I do?
57
180423
3680
03:16
Who should I turn to?"
58
184127
1174
03:17
"Where are the doctors,
where are the nurses?
59
185325
2130
03:19
If I could find one, are they trustworthy?
60
187479
2761
03:22
How will I pay them?
In what currency will I pay them?"
61
190264
2733
03:25
"If I need medications,
where will I find them?
62
193021
2794
03:28
If I take those medications,
are they actually counterfeits?"
63
196844
2895
03:31
And on and on.
64
199763
1499
03:34
So for life in these settings,
65
202945
2372
03:37
the dominant theme,
the dominant feature of life,
66
205341
4480
03:41
is the incredible vulnerability
that people have to manage
67
209845
3943
03:45
day in and day out,
68
213812
1549
03:47
because of the lack of social systems.
69
215385
2834
03:50
And it actually turns out
70
218243
1236
03:51
that this feature of life
is incredibly difficult to explain
71
219503
4027
03:55
and be understood by people
who are living outside of it.
72
223554
2975
03:59
I discovered this when I left Kosovo.
73
227221
4636
04:03
I came back to Boston,
I became a physician,
74
231881
3205
04:07
I became a global public
health policy researcher.
75
235110
4011
04:11
I joined the Harvard Medical School
76
239145
1790
04:12
and Brigham and Women's Hospital
Division of Global Health.
77
240959
2842
04:15
And I, as a researcher,
78
243825
1234
04:17
really wanted to get started
on this problem right away.
79
245083
2654
04:19
I was like, "How do we reduce
the crushing vulnerability
80
247761
3568
04:23
of people living in these types
of fragile settings?
81
251353
3771
04:27
Is there any way
we can start to think about
82
255148
2469
04:29
how to protect and quickly recover
83
257641
2705
04:32
the institutions
that are critical to survival,
84
260370
2809
04:35
like the health system?"
85
263203
1513
04:36
And I have to say,
I had amazing colleagues.
86
264740
3321
04:40
But one interesting thing about it was,
87
268582
1886
04:42
this was sort of an unusual
question for them.
88
270492
2484
04:45
They were kind of like,
"Oh, if you work in war,
89
273000
2309
04:47
doesn't that mean
you work on refugee camps,
90
275333
2249
04:49
and you work on documenting
mass atrocities?" --
91
277606
2432
04:52
which is, by the way, very,
very, very important.
92
280062
2600
04:55
So it took me a while to explain
why I was so passionate about this issue,
93
283477
5154
05:00
until about six years ago.
94
288655
1691
05:02
That's when this landmark study
95
290370
2065
05:04
that looked at and described
the public health consequences of war
96
292459
4109
05:08
was published.
97
296592
1342
05:09
They came to an incredible,
provocative conclusion.
98
297958
4937
05:15
These researchers concluded
99
303851
2649
05:18
that the vast majority of death
and disability from war
100
306524
3474
05:22
happens after the cessation of conflict.
101
310022
2633
05:24
So the most dangerous time to be a person
living in a conflict-affected state
102
312679
5038
05:29
is after the cessation of hostilities;
103
317741
2043
05:31
it's after the peace deal has been signed.
104
319808
2001
05:33
It's when that political solution
has been achieved.
105
321833
2561
05:36
That seems so puzzling,
but of course it's not,
106
324418
3534
05:39
because war kills people
by robbing them of their clinics,
107
327976
5805
05:45
of their hospitals,
108
333805
1177
05:47
of their supply chains.
109
335006
1864
05:48
Their doctors are targeted, are killed;
they're on the run.
110
336894
3591
05:52
And more invisible
and yet more deadly is the destruction
111
340509
3919
05:56
of the health governance institutions
and their finances.
112
344452
3536
06:01
So this is really not
surprising at all to me.
113
349118
3239
06:05
But what is surprising
and somewhat dismaying,
114
353790
2550
06:08
is how little impact this insight has had,
115
356364
3974
06:12
in terms of how we think
about human suffering and war.
116
360362
3584
06:16
Let me give you a couple examples.
117
364679
1707
06:19
Last year, you may remember,
118
367106
1911
06:21
Ebola hit the West African
country of Liberia.
119
369041
4125
06:26
There was a lot of reporting
about this group, Doctors Without Borders,
120
374161
3868
06:30
sounding the alarm
and calling for aid and assistance.
121
378053
2898
06:33
But not a lot of that reporting
answered the question:
122
381502
3862
06:37
Why is Doctors Without Borders
even in Liberia?
123
385388
2552
06:39
Doctors Without Borders
is an amazing organization,
124
387964
2676
06:42
dedicated and designed to provide
emergency care in war zones.
125
390664
4415
06:47
Liberia's civil war had ended in 2003 --
126
395641
2817
06:50
that was 11 years
before Ebola even struck.
127
398482
2837
06:54
When Ebola struck Liberia,
128
402632
1720
06:56
there were less than 50 doctors
in the entire country
129
404376
3627
07:00
of 4.5 million people.
130
408027
1862
07:02
Doctors Without Borders is in Liberia
131
410709
2184
07:04
because Liberia still doesn't really have
a functioning health system,
132
412917
3381
07:08
11 years later.
133
416322
1667
07:10
When the earthquake hit Haiti in 2010,
134
418013
3312
07:13
the outpouring of international
aid was phenomenal.
135
421349
3533
07:16
But did you know that only
two percent of that funding
136
424906
3671
07:20
went to rebuild
Haitian public institutions,
137
428601
2842
07:23
including its health sector?
138
431467
1760
07:25
From that perspective,
139
433877
1417
07:27
Haitians continue to die
from the earthquake even today.
140
435318
3376
07:31
I recently met this gentleman.
141
439843
2077
07:33
This is Dr. Nezar Ismet.
142
441944
2078
07:36
He's the Minister of Health
in the northern autonomous region of Iraq,
143
444046
3836
07:39
in Kurdistan.
144
447906
1431
07:41
Here he is announcing
that in the last nine months,
145
449361
3882
07:45
his country, his region, has increased
from four million people
146
453267
4042
07:49
to five million people.
147
457333
1532
07:50
That's a 25 percent increase.
148
458889
1868
07:52
Thousands of these new arrivals
have experienced incredible trauma.
149
460781
3866
07:57
His doctors are working
16-hour days without pay.
150
465159
4195
08:03
His budget has not increased
by 25 percent;
151
471047
2823
08:05
it has decreased by 20 percent,
152
473894
2395
08:08
as funding has flowed to security concerns
and to short-term relief efforts.
153
476313
4641
08:13
When his health sector fails --
154
481749
1604
08:15
and if history is any guide, it will --
155
483377
2413
08:17
how do you think that's going to influence
156
485814
2046
08:19
the decision making
of the five million people in his region
157
487884
3232
08:23
as they think about
whether they should flee
158
491140
2819
08:25
that type of vulnerable living situation?
159
493983
2491
08:29
So as you can see,
this is a frustrating topic for me,
160
497730
2934
08:32
and I really try to understand:
161
500688
1502
08:34
Why the reluctance to protect and support
162
502214
3524
08:37
indigenous health systems
and security systems?
163
505762
3636
08:41
I usually tier two concerns,
two arguments.
164
509422
2619
08:44
The first concern is about corruption,
165
512927
2187
08:47
and the concern that people
in these settings are corrupt
166
515138
2719
08:49
and they are untrustworthy.
167
517881
1745
08:52
And I will admit that I have met
unsavory characters
168
520256
3061
08:55
working in health sectors
in these situations.
169
523341
2356
08:57
But I will tell you that the opposite
is absolutely true
170
525721
3700
09:01
in every case I have worked on,
171
529445
2030
09:03
from Afghanistan to Libya, to Kosovo,
to Haiti, to Liberia --
172
531499
3813
09:07
I have met inspiring people,
173
535336
2099
09:09
who, when the chips were down
for their country,
174
537459
2495
09:11
they risked everything
to save their health institutions.
175
539978
3309
09:15
The trick for the outsider
who wants to help
176
543311
3348
09:18
is identifying who those individuals are,
177
546683
2904
09:21
and building a pathway for them to lead.
178
549611
2308
09:23
That is exactly what happened
in Afghanistan.
179
551943
3184
09:27
One of the unsung and untold
success stories
180
555714
3329
09:31
of our nation-building effort
in Afghanistan
181
559067
2918
09:34
involved the World Bank in 2002
investing heavily
182
562009
3496
09:37
in identifying, training and promoting
Afghani health sector leaders.
183
565529
5135
09:44
These health sector leaders
have pulled off an incredible feat
184
572049
3853
09:47
in Afghanistan.
185
575926
1372
09:49
They have aggressively increased
access to health care
186
577322
3947
09:53
for the majority of the population.
187
581293
2016
09:55
They are rapidly improving
the health status
188
583333
2204
09:57
of the Afghan population,
189
585561
1271
09:58
which used to be the worst in the world.
190
586856
1986
10:01
In fact, the Afghan Ministry
of Health does things
191
589945
2822
10:04
that I wish we would do in America.
192
592791
1696
10:06
They use things like data to make policy.
193
594511
2372
10:08
It's incredible.
194
596907
1185
10:10
(Laughter)
195
598116
2392
10:12
The other concern I hear a lot about is:
196
600532
1929
10:14
"We just can't afford it,
we just don't have the money.
197
602485
2602
10:17
It's just unsustainable."
198
605111
1355
10:19
I would submit to you
that the current situation
199
607419
2733
10:22
and the current system we have
200
610176
1735
10:23
is the most expensive, inefficient system
we could possibly conceive of.
201
611935
4038
10:27
The current situation
is that when governments like the US --
202
615997
3378
10:31
or, let's say, the collection
of governments
203
619399
2064
10:33
that make up the European Commission --
204
621487
1874
10:35
every year, they spend 15 billion dollars
205
623385
2649
10:38
on just humanitarian and emergency
and disaster relief worldwide.
206
626058
4006
10:42
That's nothing about foreign aid,
that's just disaster relief.
207
630088
3321
10:46
Ninety-five percent of it
goes to international relief agencies,
208
634075
5045
10:51
that then have to import resources
into these areas,
209
639144
4337
10:55
and knit together some type
of temporary health system, let's say,
210
643505
4389
10:59
which they then dismantle and send away
when they run out of money.
211
647918
3569
11:04
So our job, it turns out, is very clear.
212
652181
3930
11:09
We, as the global health
community policy experts,
213
657181
4775
11:13
our first job is to become experts
in how to monitor
214
661980
5545
11:19
the strengths and vulnerabilities
of health systems
215
667549
2447
11:22
in threatened situations.
216
670020
2567
11:24
And that's when we see doctors fleeing,
217
672611
2010
11:26
when we see health resources drying up,
218
674645
1937
11:28
when we see institutions crumbling --
219
676606
2435
11:31
that's the emergency.
220
679065
1613
11:32
That's when we need to sound the alarm
and wave our arms.
221
680702
3110
11:35
OK?
222
683836
1394
11:37
Not now.
223
685254
1151
11:38
Everyone can see that's an emergency,
they don't need us to tell them that.
224
686429
3912
11:43
Number two:
225
691122
1939
11:45
places like where I work at Harvard
need to take their cue
226
693085
3337
11:48
from the World Bank experience
in Afghanistan,
227
696446
2198
11:50
and we need to -- and we will --
228
698668
1657
11:52
build robust platforms to support
health sector leaders like these.
229
700349
5263
11:58
These people risk their lives.
230
706471
1702
12:00
I think we can match their courage
with some support.
231
708197
3712
12:04
Number three:
232
712425
1154
12:05
we need to reach out
and make new partnerships.
233
713603
2578
12:08
At our global health center,
234
716205
1874
12:10
we have launched a new initiative
with NATO and other security policy makers
235
718103
4012
12:14
to explore with them what they can do
to protect health system institutions
236
722139
5366
12:19
during deployments.
237
727529
1715
12:21
We want them to see
238
729268
1540
12:22
that protecting health systems
and other critical social institutions
239
730832
4700
12:27
is an integral part of their mission.
240
735556
2443
12:30
It's not just about avoiding
collateral damage;
241
738023
3137
12:33
it's about winning the peace.
242
741184
1805
12:36
But the most important partner
we need to engage is you,
243
744725
3583
12:40
the American public,
and indeed, the world public.
244
748332
3432
12:43
Because unless you understand
the value of social institutions,
245
751788
5696
12:49
like health systems
in these fragile settings,
246
757508
2511
12:53
you won't support efforts to save them.
247
761066
2248
12:55
You won't click on that article
248
763338
2398
12:57
that talks about "Hey, all those
doctors are on the run in country X.
249
765760
4966
13:02
I wonder what that means.
250
770750
2417
13:05
I wonder what that means
251
773191
1852
13:07
for that health system's ability
to, let's say, detect influenza."
252
775067
3952
13:11
"Hmm, it's probably not good."
That's what I'd tell you.
253
779853
3377
13:15
Up on the screen,
254
783770
1164
13:16
I've put up my three favorite American
institution defenders and builders.
255
784958
6280
13:23
Over here is George C. Marshall,
256
791846
2885
13:26
he was the guy that proposed
the Marshall Plan
257
794755
2829
13:29
to save all of Europe's economic
institutions after World War II.
258
797608
4191
13:34
And this Eleanor Roosevelt.
259
802299
2353
13:36
Her work on human rights
really serves as the foundation
260
804676
3146
13:39
for all of our international
human rights organizations.
261
807846
3028
13:43
Then my big favorite is Ben Franklin,
262
811330
2040
13:45
who did many things
in terms of creating institutions,
263
813394
3208
13:48
but was the midwife of our constitution.
264
816626
2767
13:52
And I would say to you
265
820582
1724
13:54
that these are folks who, when our
country was threatened,
266
822330
3753
13:58
or our world was threatened,
267
826107
2007
14:00
they didn't retreat.
268
828138
1303
14:01
They didn't talk about building walls.
269
829465
2341
14:03
They talked about building institutions
to protect human security,
270
831830
5381
14:10
for their generation and also for ours.
271
838008
2614
14:13
And I think our generation
should do the same.
272
841194
2798
14:16
Thank you.
273
844683
1160
14:17
(Applause)
274
845867
2229
Translated by Leslie Gauthier
Reviewed by Camille Martínez

▲Back to top

ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Margaret Bourdeaux - Physician, global health policy analyst
Margaret Bourdeaux investigates the best ways to protect, recover and reconstruct health systems and institutions disrupted by war or disaster.

Why you should listen

Margaret Ellis Bourdeaux, MD, MPH spearheads the Threatened Health Systems Project at Harvard Medical School -- an initiative that brings together public sector leaders, health care providers, academics, military strategists and private sector stakeholders to generate creative approaches to protecting valuable health system resources in countries affected by armed conflict and acute political crisis.

Bourdeaux's journey in global health began when she took a year of leave from Yale Medical School to work in refugee camps during the Kosovo War in 1999. She returned on her own after the war to trace families she had befriended in the camps and find out what had happened to them. Living in villages of Kosovo's countryside, she documented how these families struggled to care for their children, find health services and make a living in a society decimated by genocide and ethnic conflict. This experience impressed upon her the stark truth that war kills people by stripping them of their personal, community and national resources and institutions. Far more people died in Kosovo from the depleted health systems and institutions than from wounds sustained during the armed conflict.

Later experiences in Haiti, Afghanistan, Libya, Sierra Leon, Madagascar and Liberia revealed a similar pattern: armed conflict would decimate indigenous health institutions that never recovered, leaving people helpless when later crises -- earthquakes, epidemics, renewed conflict -- invariably struck. Strong, resilient health systems are the key to making war, disasters and epidemics less deadly.

After completing a joint residency in Internal Medicine and Pediatrics at the Harvard Combined Med/Peds Program, Bourdeaux was among the first graduates of Brigham and Women's Global Women's Health Fellowship. She has worked with the Office of the Secretary of Defense Policy to analyze the US Department of Defense’s global health projects and programs. She led a joint Harvard-NATO team of analysts to evaluate the impacts, challenges and opportunities international security forces have in protecting and rebuilding health systems in conflict affected states. She joined the faculty of the Division of Global Health Equity at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Harvard Medical School in 2011.

This year she was awarded the prestigious Harvard Global Health Institute's Burke Fellowship in Global Health to investigate the responsiveness of foreign aid to health system distress and disruption. She is co-developing the first executive education course between Harvard Medical School and Harvard Kennedy School of Government for senior security policy makers on health system threat detection and response. In addition, she is launching Harvard Global Health Institute's first Summit on Threatened Health Systems in June 2017.

More profile about the speaker
Margaret Bourdeaux | Speaker | TED.com