TEDxPeachtree
Ami Klin: A new way to diagnose autism
Filmed:
Readability: 3.9
674,356 views
Early diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder can improve the lives of everyone affected, but the complex network of causes make it incredibly difficult to predict. At TEDxPeachtree, Ami Klin describes a new early detection method that uses eye-tracking technologies to gauge babies' social engagement skills and reliably measure their risk of developing autism.
Ami Klin - Autism researcher
Ami Klin is an award winning autism spectrum disorder researcher finding new avenues for early diagnosis. Full bio
Ami Klin is an award winning autism spectrum disorder researcher finding new avenues for early diagnosis. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:17
I always wanted to become
0
1119
1908
00:18
a walking laboratory of social engagement,
1
3027
2840
00:21
to resonate other people's feelings, thoughts,
2
5867
4076
00:25
intentions, motivations, in the act of being with them.
3
9943
5056
00:30
As a scientist, I always wanted to measure that resonance,
4
14999
5879
00:36
that sense of the other that happens so quickly,
5
20879
2498
00:39
in the blink of an eye.
6
23377
2305
00:41
We intuit other people's feelings.
7
25682
2350
00:43
We know the meaning of their actions
8
28032
987
00:44
even before they happen.
9
29019
2940
00:47
We're always in this stance of being
10
31959
1898
00:49
the object of somebody else's subjectivity.
11
33857
2971
00:52
We do that all the time. We just can't shake it off.
12
36828
3197
00:55
It's so important that the very tools that we use
13
40025
1651
00:57
to understand ourselves, to understand
14
41676
2403
00:59
the world around them, is shaped by that stance.
15
44079
4147
01:04
We are social to the core.
16
48226
3234
01:07
So my journey in autism really started when I lived
17
51460
2774
01:10
in a residential unit for adults with autism.
18
54234
3577
01:13
Most of those individuals had spent most of their lives
19
57811
3318
01:17
in long-stay hospitals. This is a long time ago.
20
61129
3892
01:20
And for them, autism was devastating.
21
65021
4282
01:25
They had profound intellectual disabilities.
22
69303
3255
01:28
They didn't talk. But most of all,
23
72558
3302
01:31
they were extraordinarily isolated
24
75860
3830
01:35
from the world around them, from their environment
25
79690
3241
01:38
and from the people.
26
82931
2461
01:41
In fact, at the time, if you walked into a school
27
85392
2852
01:44
for individuals with autism, you'd hear a lot of noise,
28
88244
4023
01:48
plenty of commotion, actions, people doing things,
29
92267
5463
01:53
but they're always doing things by themselves.
30
97730
3725
01:57
So they may be looking at a light in the ceiling,
31
101455
4072
02:01
or they may be isolated in the corner,
32
105527
3409
02:04
or they might be engaged in these repetitive movements,
33
108936
3559
02:08
in self-stimulatory movements that led them nowhere.
34
112495
4201
02:12
Extremely, extremely isolated.
35
116696
3399
02:15
Well, now we know that autism
36
120095
3593
02:19
is this disruption, the disruption of this resonance
37
123688
3738
02:23
that I am telling you.
38
127426
2344
02:25
These are survival skills.
39
129770
1958
02:27
These are survival skills that we inherited
40
131728
2151
02:29
over many, many hundreds of thousands of years
41
133879
2554
02:32
of evolution.
42
136433
2286
02:34
You see, babies are born in a state of utter fragility.
43
138719
5314
02:39
Without the caregiver, they wouldn't survive, so it stands
44
144033
2031
02:41
to reason that nature would endow them with
45
146064
2383
02:44
these mechanisms of survival.
46
148447
3233
02:47
They orient to the caregiver.
47
151680
2575
02:50
From the first days and weeks of life,
48
154255
3442
02:53
babies prefer to hear human sounds rather than just
49
157697
3486
02:57
sounds in the environment.
50
161183
1945
02:59
They prefer to look at people rather than at things,
51
163128
2010
03:01
and even as they're looking at people,
52
165138
2045
03:03
they look at people's eyes, because
53
167183
2564
03:05
the eye is the window to the other person's experiences,
54
169747
4349
03:09
so much so that they even prefer to look at people who are
55
174096
2118
03:12
looking at them rather than people who are looking away.
56
176214
4311
03:16
Well, they orient to the caregiver.
57
180525
2606
03:19
The caregiver seeks the baby.
58
183131
2327
03:21
And it's out of this mutually reinforcing choreography
59
185458
3627
03:24
that a lot that is of importance to the emergence of mind,
60
189085
3819
03:28
the social mind, the social brain, depends on.
61
192904
4683
03:33
We always think about autism
62
197587
2681
03:36
as something that happens later on in life.
63
200268
5079
03:41
It doesn't. It begins with the beginning of life.
64
205347
5398
03:46
As babies engage with caregivers, they soon realize
65
210745
4304
03:50
that, well, there is something in between the ears
66
215049
4207
03:55
that is very important --
67
219256
1410
03:56
it's invisible, you can't see -- but is really critical,
68
220666
4183
04:00
and that thing is called attention.
69
224849
1459
04:02
And they learn soon enough, even before they can
70
226308
2830
04:05
utter one word that they can take that attention
71
229138
2680
04:07
and move somewhere in order to get things they want.
72
231818
5737
04:13
They also learn to follow other people's gaze,
73
237555
3124
04:16
because whatever people are looking at is
74
240679
2270
04:18
what they are thinking about.
75
242949
3755
04:22
And soon enough, they start to learn about the meaning
76
246704
2642
04:25
of things, because when somebody is looking at something
77
249346
3425
04:28
or somebody is pointing at something,
78
252771
2052
04:30
they're not just getting a directional cue,
79
254823
2929
04:33
they are getting the other person's meaning
80
257752
2558
04:36
of that thing, the attitude, and soon enough
81
260310
3079
04:39
they start building this body of meanings,
82
263389
4099
04:43
but meanings that were acquired within the realm
83
267488
2313
04:45
of social interaction.
84
269801
2401
04:48
Those are meanings that are acquired as part
85
272202
1841
04:49
of their shared experiences with others.
86
274043
3987
04:53
Well, this is a little 15-month-old little girl,
87
278030
6832
05:00
and she has autism.
88
284862
3732
05:04
And I am coming so close to her that I am maybe
89
288594
3422
05:07
two inches from her face, and she's quite oblivious to me.
90
292016
4249
05:12
Imagine if I did that to you,
91
296265
1358
05:13
and I came two inches from your face.
92
297623
1926
05:15
You'd do probably two things, wouldn't you?
93
299549
2106
05:17
You would recoil. You would call the police. (Laughter)
94
301655
4112
05:21
You would do something, because it's literally impossible
95
305767
2549
05:24
to penetrate somebody's physical space
96
308316
2576
05:26
and not get a reaction.
97
310892
1355
05:28
We do so, remember, intuitively, effortlessly.
98
312247
3684
05:31
This is our body wisdom. It's not something that is
99
315931
1417
05:33
mediated by our language. Our body just knows that,
100
317348
4550
05:37
and we've known that for a long time.
101
321898
2763
05:40
And this is not something that happens to humans only.
102
324661
2939
05:43
It happens to some of our phylatic cousins,
103
327600
3224
05:46
because if you're a monkey,
104
330824
1994
05:48
and you look at another monkey,
105
332818
2096
05:50
and that monkey has a higher hierarchy position than you,
106
334914
4018
05:54
and that is considered to be a signal or threat,
107
338932
3553
05:58
well, you are not going to be alive for long.
108
342485
2880
06:01
So something that in other species are survival mechanisms,
109
345365
4421
06:05
without them they wouldn't basically live,
110
349786
3421
06:09
we bring into the context of human beings,
111
353207
2700
06:11
and this is what we need to simply act, act socially.
112
355907
4163
06:15
Now, she is oblivious to me, and I am so close to her,
113
360070
2903
06:18
and you think, maybe she can see you,
114
362973
1998
06:20
maybe she can hear you.
115
364971
1620
06:22
Well, a few minutes later, she goes to the corner of
116
366591
2340
06:24
the room, and she finds a tiny little piece of candy, an M&M.
117
368931
5599
06:30
So I could not attract her attention,
118
374530
4870
06:35
but something, a thing, did.
119
379400
2429
06:37
Now, most of us make a big dichotomy
120
381829
2642
06:40
between the world of things and the world of people.
121
384471
4335
06:44
Now, for this girl, that division line is not so clear,
122
388806
4591
06:49
and the world of people is not attracting her
123
393397
3130
06:52
as much as we would like.
124
396527
1483
06:53
Now remember that we learn a great deal
125
398010
2034
06:55
by sharing experiences.
126
400044
2401
06:58
Now, what she is doing right now is that
127
402445
3171
07:01
her path of learning is diverging moment by moment
128
405616
4479
07:05
as she is isolating herself further and further.
129
410095
3818
07:09
So we feel sometimes that the brain is deterministic,
130
413913
2966
07:12
the brain determines who we are going to be.
131
416879
2522
07:15
But in fact the brain also becomes who we are,
132
419401
2840
07:18
and at the same time that her behaviors are taking away
133
422241
4013
07:22
from the realm of social interaction, this is what's happening
134
426254
2883
07:25
with her mind and this is what's happening with her brain.
135
429137
5392
07:30
Well, autism is the most strongly genetic condition
136
434529
5838
07:36
of all developmental disorders,
137
440367
3453
07:39
and it's a brain disorder.
138
443820
2875
07:42
It's a disorder that begins much prior to the time
139
446695
2609
07:45
that the child is born.
140
449304
2866
07:48
We now know that there is a very broad spectrum of autism.
141
452170
3714
07:51
There are those individuals who are profoundly
142
455884
2512
07:54
intellectually disabled, but there are those that are gifted.
143
458396
2998
07:57
There are those individuals who don't talk at all.
144
461394
2128
07:59
There are those individuals who talk too much.
145
463522
2272
08:01
There are those individuals that if you observe them
146
465794
2501
08:04
in their school, you see them running the periphery fence
147
468295
3009
08:07
of the school all day if you let them,
148
471304
2299
08:09
to those individuals who cannot stop coming to you
149
473603
2358
08:11
and trying to engage you repeatedly, relentlessly,
150
475961
2005
08:13
but often in an awkward fashion,
151
477966
3931
08:17
without that immediate resonance.
152
481897
3775
08:21
Well, this is much more prevalent than we thought at the time.
153
485672
3932
08:25
When I started in this field, we thought that there were
154
489604
1484
08:26
four individuals with autism per 10,000,
155
491088
2853
08:29
a very rare condition.
156
493941
2031
08:31
Well, now we know it's more like one in 100.
157
495972
4033
08:35
There are millions of individuals with autism all around us.
158
500005
5023
08:40
The societal cost of this condition is huge.
159
505028
3366
08:44
In the U.S. alone, maybe 35 to 80 billion dollars,
160
508394
3163
08:47
and you know what? Most of those funds are associated
161
511557
3307
08:50
with adolescents and particularly adults
162
514864
2180
08:52
who are severely disabled,
163
517044
2161
08:55
individuals who need wrap-around services, services
164
519205
2139
08:57
that are very, very intensive, and those services
165
521344
2726
08:59
can cost in excess of 60 to 80,000 dollars a year.
166
524070
4269
09:04
Those are individuals who did not benefit from early treatment,
167
528339
3562
09:07
because now we know that autism creates itself
168
531901
4459
09:12
as they diverge in that pathway of learning
169
536360
2704
09:14
that I mentioned to you.
170
539064
2136
09:17
Were we to be able to identify this condition
171
541200
2413
09:19
at an earlier point, and intervene and treat,
172
543613
4067
09:23
I can tell you, and this has been probably
173
547680
1974
09:25
something that has changed my life in the past 10 years,
174
549654
3380
09:28
this notion that we can absolutely attenuate
175
553034
3731
09:32
this condition.
176
556765
2157
09:34
Also, we have a window of opportunity, because
177
558922
2379
09:37
the brain is malleable for just so long,
178
561301
3136
09:40
and that window of opportunity happens
179
564437
1352
09:41
in the first three years of life.
180
565789
1703
09:43
It's not that that window closes. It doesn't.
181
567492
3398
09:46
But it diminishes considerably.
182
570890
3569
09:50
And yet, the median age of diagnosis in this country
183
574459
3104
09:53
is still about five years,
184
577563
2151
09:55
and in disadvantaged populations,
185
579714
2266
09:57
the populations that don't have access to clinical services,
186
581980
3249
10:01
rural populations, minorities,
187
585229
3109
10:04
the age of diagnosis is later still,
188
588338
2619
10:06
which is almost as if I were to tell you that we are
189
590957
2345
10:09
condemning those communities to have individuals
190
593302
2417
10:11
with autism whose condition is going to be more severe.
191
595719
4476
10:16
So I feel that we have a bio-ethical imperative.
192
600195
2973
10:19
The science is there,
193
603168
2857
10:21
but no science is of relevance if it doesn't have an impact
194
606025
3058
10:24
on the community, and we just can't afford
195
609083
3658
10:28
that missed opportunity,
196
612741
1964
10:30
because children with autism become adults with autism,
197
614705
3156
10:33
and we feel that those things that we can do
198
617861
4278
10:38
for these children, for those families, early on,
199
622139
2323
10:40
will have lifetime consequences,
200
624462
2394
10:42
for the child, for the family, and for the community at large.
201
626856
4096
10:46
So this is our view of autism.
202
630952
2720
10:49
There are over a hundred genes that are associated
203
633672
2866
10:52
with autism. In fact, we believe that there are going to be
204
636538
2126
10:54
something between 300 and 600 genes associated with autism,
205
638664
4504
10:59
and genetic anomalies, much more than just genes.
206
643168
3671
11:02
And we actually have a bit of a question here,
207
646839
4591
11:07
because if there are so many different causes of autism,
208
651430
3485
11:10
how do you go from those liabilities
209
654915
3015
11:13
to the actual syndrome? Because people like myself,
210
657930
3000
11:16
when we walk into a playroom,
211
660930
2685
11:19
we recognize a child as having autism.
212
663615
3220
11:22
So how do you go from multiple causes
213
666835
2143
11:24
to a syndrome that has some homogeneity?
214
668978
3450
11:28
And the answer is, what lies in between,
215
672428
2577
11:30
which is development.
216
675005
2655
11:33
And in fact, we are very interested in those first
217
677660
3116
11:36
two years of life, because those liabilities
218
680776
2739
11:39
don't necessarily convert into autism.
219
683515
2754
11:42
Autism creates itself.
220
686269
2496
11:44
Were we to be able to intervene during those years of life,
221
688765
4849
11:49
we might attenuate for some, and God knows,
222
693614
2503
11:52
maybe even prevent for others.
223
696117
3636
11:55
So how do we do that?
224
699753
2084
11:57
How do we enter that feeling of resonance,
225
701837
2916
12:00
how do we enter another person's being?
226
704753
4025
12:04
I remember when I interacted with that 15-month-older,
227
708778
3498
12:08
that the thing that came to mind was,
228
712276
2162
12:10
"How do you come into her world?
229
714438
2515
12:12
Is she thinking about me? Is she thinking about others?"
230
716953
4280
12:17
Well, it's hard to do that, so we had to create
231
721233
4344
12:21
the technologies. We had to basically step inside a body.
232
725577
3479
12:24
We had to see the world through her eyes.
233
729056
3929
12:28
And so in the past many years we've been building
234
732985
3039
12:31
these new technologies that are based on eye tracking.
235
736024
3633
12:35
We can see moment by moment
236
739657
2518
12:38
what children are engaging with.
237
742175
3281
12:41
Well, this is my colleague Warren Jones, with whom
238
745456
2719
12:44
we've been building these methods, these studies,
239
748175
2977
12:47
for the past 12 years,
240
751152
1991
12:49
and you see there a happy five-month-older,
241
753143
2720
12:51
it's a five-month little boy who is going to watch things
242
755863
5823
12:57
that are brought from his world,
243
761686
2823
13:00
his mom, the caregiver, but also experiences
244
764509
2579
13:02
that he would have were he to be in his daycare.
245
767088
4432
13:07
What we want is to embrace that world
246
771520
2632
13:10
and bring it into our laboratory,
247
774152
1329
13:11
but in order for us to do that, we had to create
248
775481
3122
13:14
these very sophisticated measures,
249
778603
3250
13:17
measures of how people, how little babies,
250
781853
3427
13:21
how newborns, engage with the world,
251
785280
2983
13:24
moment by moment,
252
788263
1627
13:25
what is important, and what is not.
253
789890
3273
13:29
Well, we created those measures, and here,
254
793163
2941
13:32
what you see is what we call a funnel of attention.
255
796104
3399
13:35
You're watching a video.
256
799503
2333
13:37
Those frames are separated by about a second
257
801836
2658
13:40
through the eyes of 35 typically developing
258
804494
2768
13:43
two-year-olds,
259
807262
1282
13:44
and we freeze one frame,
260
808544
2975
13:47
and this is what the typical children are doing.
261
811519
3501
13:50
In this scan pass, in green here, are two-year-olds with autism.
262
815020
4441
13:55
So on that frame, the children who are typical
263
819461
3623
13:58
are watching this,
264
823084
2955
14:01
the emotion of expression of that little boy
265
826039
2549
14:04
as he's fighting a little bit with the little girl.
266
828588
2910
14:07
What are the children with autism doing?
267
831498
2060
14:09
They are focusing on the revolving door,
268
833558
3445
14:12
opening and shutting.
269
837003
2091
14:14
Well, I can tell you that this divergence
270
839094
2452
14:17
that you're seeing here
271
841546
869
14:18
doesn't happen only in our five-minute experiment.
272
842415
3190
14:21
It happens moment by moment in their real lives,
273
845605
3401
14:24
and their minds are being formed,
274
849006
2720
14:27
and their brains are being specialized in something other
275
851726
3080
14:30
than what is happening with their typical peers.
276
854806
3779
14:34
Well, we took a construct from
277
858585
3187
14:37
our pediatrician friends,
278
861772
3194
14:40
the concept of growth charts.
279
864966
1927
14:42
You know, when you take a child to the pediatrician,
280
866893
1969
14:44
and so you have physical height, and weight.
281
868862
4204
14:48
Well we decided that we're going to create growth charts
282
873066
2829
14:51
of social engagement,
283
875895
2459
14:54
and we sought children from the time that they are born,
284
878354
2801
14:57
and what you see here on the x-axis is two, three, four,
285
881155
5829
15:02
five, six months and nine, until about the age of 24 months,
286
886984
3840
15:06
and this is the percent of their viewing time
287
890824
2731
15:09
that they are focusing on people's eyes,
288
893555
1696
15:11
and this is their growth chart.
289
895251
2360
15:13
They start over here, they love people's eyes,
290
897611
3030
15:16
and it remains quite stable.
291
900641
2454
15:18
It sort of goes up a little bit in those initial months.
292
903095
3926
15:22
Now, let's see what's happening with babies
293
907021
2294
15:25
who became autistic.
294
909315
2508
15:27
It's something very different.
295
911823
2205
15:29
It starts way up here, but then it's a free fall.
296
914028
3790
15:33
It's very much like they brought into this world the reflex
297
917818
3419
15:37
that orients them to people, but it has no traction.
298
921237
3931
15:41
It's almost as if that stimulus, you,
299
925168
3070
15:44
you're not exerting influence on what happens
300
928238
2901
15:47
as they navigate their daily lives.
301
931139
3891
15:50
Now, we thought that those data were so powerful
302
935030
6022
15:56
in a way, that we wanted to see what happened
303
941052
3008
15:59
in the first six months of life, because if you interact
304
944060
3393
16:03
with a two- and a three-month-older,
305
947453
1337
16:04
you'd be surprised by how social those babies are.
306
948790
4552
16:09
And what we see in the first six months of life
307
953342
2607
16:11
is that those two groups can be segregated very easily.
308
955949
6138
16:17
And using these kinds of measures, and many others,
309
962087
2874
16:20
what we found out is that our science could, in fact,
310
964961
4016
16:24
identify this condition early on.
311
968977
2641
16:27
We didn't have to wait for the behaviors of autism
312
971618
2904
16:30
to emerge in the second year of life.
313
974522
3148
16:33
If we measured things that are, evolutionarily,
314
977670
3262
16:36
highly conserved, and developmentally very early emerging,
315
980932
4122
16:40
things that are online from the first weeks of life,
316
985054
2701
16:43
we could push the detection of autism
317
987755
1862
16:45
all the way to those first months,
318
989617
2464
16:47
and that's what we are doing now.
319
992081
4141
16:52
Now, we can create the very best technologies
320
996222
3068
16:55
and the very best methods to identify the children,
321
999290
3605
16:58
but this would be for naught if we didn't have an impact
322
1002895
3143
17:01
on what happens in their reality in the community.
323
1006038
3642
17:05
Now we want those devices, of course,
324
1009680
2306
17:07
to be deployed by those who are in the trenches,
325
1011986
2853
17:10
our colleagues, the primary care physicians,
326
1014839
2523
17:13
who see every child,
327
1017362
2705
17:15
and we need to transform those technologies
328
1020067
2143
17:18
into something that is going to add value to their practice,
329
1022210
3105
17:21
because they have to see so many children.
330
1025315
2205
17:23
And we want to do that universally
331
1027520
2074
17:25
so that we don't miss any child,
332
1029594
2133
17:27
but this would be immoral
333
1031727
2453
17:30
if we also did not have an infrastructure for intervention,
334
1034180
4901
17:34
for treatment.
335
1039081
1247
17:36
We need to be able to work with the families,
336
1040328
2536
17:38
to support the families, to manage those first years
337
1042864
3415
17:42
with them. We need to be able to really go
338
1046279
3912
17:46
from universal screening to universal access to treatment,
339
1050191
4157
17:50
because those treatments are going to change
340
1054348
3103
17:53
these children's and those families' lives.
341
1057451
3579
17:56
Now, when we think about what we [can] do
342
1061030
4257
18:01
in those first years,
343
1065287
3223
18:04
I can tell you,
344
1068510
2400
18:06
having been in this field for so long,
345
1070910
2827
18:09
one feels really rejuvenated.
346
1073737
3095
18:12
There is a sense that the science that one worked on
347
1076832
3832
18:16
can actually have an impact on realities,
348
1080664
3707
18:20
preventing, in fact, those experiences
349
1084371
2895
18:23
that I really started in my journey in this field.
350
1087266
4002
18:27
I thought at the time that this was an intractable condition.
351
1091268
3192
18:30
No longer. We can do a great deal of things.
352
1094460
3886
18:34
And the idea is not to cure autism.
353
1098346
2737
18:36
That's not the idea.
354
1101083
2600
18:39
What we want is to make sure
355
1103683
2206
18:41
that those individuals with autism can be free from
356
1105889
2576
18:44
the devastating consequences that come with it at times,
357
1108465
4230
18:48
the profound intellectual disabilities, the lack of language,
358
1112695
2874
18:51
the profound, profound isolation.
359
1115569
3669
18:55
We feel that individuals with autism, in fact,
360
1119238
2267
18:57
have a very special perspective on the world,
361
1121505
2795
19:00
and we need diversity, and they can work extremely well
362
1124300
3423
19:03
in some areas of strength:
363
1127723
2367
19:05
predictable situations, situations that can be defined.
364
1130090
3403
19:09
Because after all, they learn about the world almost like
365
1133493
3009
19:12
about it, rather than learning how to function in it.
366
1136502
4701
19:17
But this is a strength, if you're working, for example,
367
1141203
2798
19:19
in technology.
368
1144001
2080
19:21
And there are those individuals who have incredible
369
1146081
2273
19:24
artistic abilities.
370
1148354
1425
19:25
We want them to be free of that.
371
1149779
1920
19:27
We want that the next generations of individuals with autism
372
1151699
3385
19:30
will be able not only to express their strengths
373
1155084
3155
19:34
but to fulfill their promise.
374
1158239
2222
19:36
Well thank you for listening to me. (Applause)
375
1160461
3569
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Ami Klin - Autism researcherAmi Klin is an award winning autism spectrum disorder researcher finding new avenues for early diagnosis.
Why you should listen
Born in Brazil to Holocaust survivors, Ami Klin is the Georgia Research Alliance Eminent Scholar Professor and Chief of the Division of Autism and Developmental Disabilities at Emory University School of Medicine, and Director of the Marcus Autism Center, a subsidiary of Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta. After studying psychology, political science and history at Hebrew University in Jerusalem, Klin received his PhD in Psychology at the University of London in 1988. He completed clinical and research post-doctoral fellowships at the Yale Child Study Center at the Yale University School of Medicine -- where he would direct the Autism Program as Harris Professor of Child Psychology & Psychiatry. He has written in over over 180 publications, including five books on the subject of Autism.
Ami Klin | Speaker | TED.com