TEDGlobal 2012
Beau Lotto + Amy O'Toole: Science is for everyone, kids included
Filmed:
Readability: 3.5
1,504,898 views
What do science and play have in common? Neuroscientist Beau Lotto thinks all people (kids included) should participate in science and, through the process of discovery, change perceptions. He's seconded by 12-year-old Amy O'Toole, who, along with 25 of her classmates, published the first peer-reviewed article by schoolchildren, about the Blackawton bees project. It starts: "Once upon a time ... "
Beau Lotto - Neuroscientist, Artist
Beau Lotto is founder of Lottolab, a hybrid art studio and science lab. With glowing, interactive sculpture -- and old-fashioned peer-reviewed research--he's illuminating the mysteries of the brain's visual system. Full bioAmy O'Toole - Student
Amy O'Toole is a 12-year-old student who helped run a science experiment inspired by Beau Lotto's participative science approach. At age 10 she became one of the youngest people ever to publish a peer-reviewed science paper. Full bio
Beau Lotto is founder of Lottolab, a hybrid art studio and science lab. With glowing, interactive sculpture -- and old-fashioned peer-reviewed research--he's illuminating the mysteries of the brain's visual system. Full bioAmy O'Toole - Student
Amy O'Toole is a 12-year-old student who helped run a science experiment inspired by Beau Lotto's participative science approach. At age 10 she became one of the youngest people ever to publish a peer-reviewed science paper. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:17
Beau Lotto: So, this game is very simple.
0
1487
2169
00:19
All you have to do is read what you see. Right?
1
3656
4047
00:23
So, I'm going to count to you, so we don't all do it together.
2
7703
3201
00:26
Okay, one, two, three.Audience: Can you read this?
3
10904
2499
00:29
BL: Amazing. What about this one? One, two, three.Audience: You are not reading this.
4
13403
4379
00:33
BL: All right. One, two, three. (Laughter)
5
17782
5316
00:38
If you were Portuguese, right? How about this one? One, two, three.
6
23098
4797
00:43
Audience: What are you reading?
7
27895
1978
00:45
BL: What are you reading? There are no words there.
8
29873
3458
00:49
I said, read what you're seeing. Right?
9
33331
2537
00:51
It literally says, "Wat ar ou rea in?" (Laughter) Right?
10
35868
3850
00:55
That's what you should have said. Right? Why is this?
11
39718
3828
00:59
It's because perception is grounded in our experience.
12
43546
3536
01:02
Right? The brain takes meaningless information
13
47082
2897
01:05
and makes meaning out of it, which means we never see
14
49979
2959
01:08
what's there, we never see information,
15
52938
2256
01:11
we only ever see what was useful to see in the past.
16
55194
3275
01:14
All right? Which means, when it comes to perception,
17
58469
2736
01:17
we're all like this frog.
18
61205
6795
01:23
(Laughter)
19
68000
912
01:24
Right? It's getting information. It's generating behavior
20
68912
3395
01:28
that's useful. (Laughter)
21
72307
4468
01:32
(Laughter)
22
76775
7032
01:39
(Video) Man: Ow! Ow! (Laughter) (Applause)
23
83807
5982
01:45
BL: And sometimes, when things don't go our way,
24
89789
2712
01:48
we get a little bit annoyed, right?
25
92501
2259
01:50
But we're talking about perception here, right?
26
94760
2730
01:53
And perception underpins everything we think, we know,
27
97490
4365
01:57
we believe, our hopes, our dreams, the clothes we wear,
28
101855
2871
02:00
falling in love, everything begins with perception.
29
104726
3743
02:04
Now if perception is grounded in our history, it means
30
108469
2945
02:07
we're only ever responding according to what we've done before.
31
111414
3459
02:10
But actually, it's a tremendous problem,
32
114873
3076
02:13
because how can we ever see differently?
33
117949
3617
02:17
Now, I want to tell you a story about seeing differently,
34
121566
4063
02:21
and all new perceptions begin in the same way.
35
125629
3988
02:25
They begin with a question.
36
129617
2582
02:28
The problem with questions is they create uncertainty.
37
132199
3238
02:31
Now, uncertainty is a very bad thing. It's evolutionarily
38
135437
2729
02:34
a bad thing. If you're not sure that's a predator, it's too late.
39
138166
3601
02:37
Okay? (Laughter)
40
141767
1360
02:39
Even seasickness is a consequence of uncertainty.
41
143127
3160
02:42
Right? If you go down below on a boat, your inner ears
42
146287
2252
02:44
are you telling you you're moving. Your eyes, because
43
148539
2176
02:46
it's moving in register with the boat, say I'm standing still.
44
150715
2316
02:48
Your brain cannot deal with the uncertainty of that information, and it gets ill.
45
153031
4655
02:53
The question "why?" is one of the most dangerous things you can do,
46
157686
3929
02:57
because it takes you into uncertainty.
47
161615
2992
03:00
And yet, the irony is, the only way we can ever
48
164607
2879
03:03
do anything new is to step into that space.
49
167486
3536
03:06
So how can we ever do anything new? Well fortunately,
50
171022
3224
03:10
evolution has given us an answer, right?
51
174246
3584
03:13
And it enables us to address even the most difficult
52
177830
3595
03:17
of questions. The best questions are the ones that create the most uncertainty.
53
181425
4679
03:22
They're the ones that question the things we think to be true already. Right?
54
186104
3956
03:25
It's easy to ask questions about how did life begin,
55
190060
1989
03:27
or what extends beyond the universe, but to question what you think to be true already
56
192049
3308
03:31
is really stepping into that space.
57
195357
3001
03:34
So what is evolution's answer to the problem of uncertainty?
58
198358
4810
03:39
It's play.
59
203168
1773
03:40
Now play is not simply a process. Experts in play will tell you
60
204941
4193
03:45
that actually it's a way of being.
61
209134
2615
03:47
Play is one of the only human endeavors where uncertainty
62
211749
2891
03:50
is actually celebrated. Uncertainty is what makes play fun.
63
214640
4326
03:54
Right? It's adaptable to change. Right? It opens possibility,
64
218966
4275
03:59
and it's cooperative. It's actually how we do our social bonding,
65
223241
4109
04:03
and it's intrinsically motivated. What that means
66
227350
1726
04:04
is that we play to play. Play is its own reward.
67
229076
4606
04:09
Now if you look at these five ways of being,
68
233682
3891
04:13
these are the exact same ways of being you need
69
237573
2721
04:16
in order to be a good scientist.
70
240294
2036
04:18
Science is not defined by the method section of a paper.
71
242330
3027
04:21
It's actually a way of being, which is here, and this is true
72
245357
3140
04:24
for anything that is creative.
73
248497
2653
04:27
So if you add rules to play, you have a game.
74
251150
4203
04:31
That's actually what an experiment is.
75
255353
2790
04:34
So armed with these two ideas,
76
258143
1919
04:35
that science is a way of being and experiments are play,
77
260062
4322
04:40
we asked, can anyone become a scientist?
78
264384
3453
04:43
And who better to ask than 25 eight- to 10-year-old children?
79
267837
3500
04:47
Because they're experts in play. So I took my bee arena
80
271337
3507
04:50
down to a small school in Devon, and the aim of this
81
274844
3547
04:54
was to not just get the kids to see science differently,
82
278391
4244
04:58
but, through the process of science, to see themselves differently. Right?
83
282635
4598
05:03
The first step was to ask a question.
84
287233
3408
05:06
Now, I should say that we didn't get funding for this study
85
290641
2880
05:09
because the scientists said small children couldn't make
86
293521
3330
05:12
a useful contribution to science, and the teachers said kids couldn't do it.
87
296851
4302
05:17
So we did it anyway. Right? Of course.
88
301153
3734
05:20
So, here are some of the questions. I put them in small print
89
304887
2819
05:23
so you wouldn't bother reading it. Point is that five of the questions that the kids came up with
90
307706
4440
05:28
were actually the basis of science publication the last five to 15 years. Right?
91
312146
4618
05:32
So they were asking questions that were significant
92
316764
2660
05:35
to expert scientists.
93
319424
2130
05:37
Now here, I want to share the stage with someone quite special. Right?
94
321554
4134
05:41
She was one of the young people who was involved in this study,
95
325688
2612
05:44
and she's now one of the youngest published scientists
96
328300
2334
05:46
in the world. Right? She will now, once she comes onto stage,
97
330634
3883
05:50
will be the youngest person to ever speak at TED. Right?
98
334517
3698
05:54
Now, science and asking questions is about courage.
99
338215
2875
05:56
Now she is the personification of courage, because she's
100
341090
3200
06:00
going to stand up here and talk to you all.
101
344290
1387
06:01
So Amy, would you please come up? (Applause)
102
345677
5254
06:06
(Applause)
103
350931
7185
06:14
So Amy's going to help me tell the story of what we call
104
358116
2519
06:16
the Blackawton Bees Project, and first she's going to tell you
105
360635
2666
06:19
the question that they came up with. So go ahead, Amy.
106
363301
2545
06:21
Amy O'Toole: Thank you, Beau. We thought
107
365846
1719
06:23
that it was easy to see the link between humans and apes
108
367565
3401
06:26
in the way that we think, because we look alike.
109
370966
3024
06:29
But we wondered if there's a possible link
110
373990
2689
06:32
with other animals. It'd be amazing if humans and bees
111
376679
4704
06:37
thought similar, since they seem so different from us.
112
381383
4113
06:41
So we asked if humans and bees might solve
113
385496
3053
06:44
complex problems in the same way.
114
388549
2407
06:46
Really, we wanted to know if bees can also adapt
115
390956
3287
06:50
themselves to new situations using previously learned rules
116
394243
3707
06:53
and conditions. So what if bees can think like us?
117
397950
4214
06:58
Well, it'd be amazing, since we're talking about an insect
118
402164
2552
07:00
with only one million brain cells.
119
404716
2525
07:03
But it actually makes a lot of sense they should,
120
407241
2142
07:05
because bees, like us, can recognize a good flower
121
409383
3277
07:08
regardless of the time of day, the light, the weather,
122
412660
3613
07:12
or from any angle they approach it from. (Applause)
123
416273
5742
07:17
BL: So the next step was to design an experiment,
124
422015
3782
07:21
which is a game. So the kids went off and they designed
125
425797
3302
07:24
this experiment, and so -- well, game -- and so,
126
429099
3301
07:28
Amy, can you tell us what the game was,
127
432400
1466
07:29
and the puzzle that you set the bees?
128
433866
2143
07:31
AO: The puzzle we came up with was an if-then rule.
129
436009
3023
07:34
We asked the bees to learn not just to go to a certain color,
130
439032
3645
07:38
but to a certain color flower only
131
442677
2668
07:41
when it's in a certain pattern.
132
445345
1632
07:42
They were only rewarded if they went to the yellow flowers
133
446977
3259
07:46
if the yellow flowers were surrounded by the blue,
134
450236
3060
07:49
or if the blue flowers were surrounded by the yellow.
135
453296
3268
07:52
Now there's a number of different rules the bees can learn
136
456564
2585
07:55
to solve this puzzle. The interesting question is, which?
137
459149
3425
07:58
What was really exciting about this project was we,
138
462574
2780
08:01
and Beau, had no idea whether it would work.
139
465354
2343
08:03
It was completely new, and no one had done it before,
140
467697
2454
08:06
including adults. (Laughter)
141
470151
3723
08:09
BL: Including the teachers, and that was really hard for the teachers.
142
473874
3464
08:13
It's easy for a scientist to go in and not have a clue what he's doing,
143
477338
2904
08:16
because that's what we do in the lab, but for a teacher
144
480242
2544
08:18
not to know what's going to happen at the end of the day --
145
482786
1625
08:20
so much of the credit goes to Dave Strudwick, who was
146
484411
2599
08:22
the collaborator on this project. Okay?
147
487010
2209
08:25
So I'm not going to go through the whole details of the study
148
489219
2732
08:27
because actually you can read about it, but the next step
149
491951
2638
08:30
is observation. So here are some of the students
150
494589
3645
08:34
doing the observations. They're recording the data
151
498234
2768
08:36
of where the bees fly.
152
501002
5044
08:41
(Video) Dave Strudwick: So what we're going to do —Student: 5C.
153
506046
2023
08:43
Dave Strudwick: Is she still going up here?Student: Yeah.
154
508069
3990
08:47
Dave Strudwick: So you keep track of each.Student: Henry, can you help me here?
155
512059
3597
08:51
BL: "Can you help me, Henry?" What good scientist says that, right?
156
515656
2904
08:54
Student: There's two up there.
157
518560
4710
08:59
And three in here.
158
523270
2874
09:02
BL: Right? So we've got our observations. We've got our data.
159
526144
2275
09:04
They do the simple mathematics, averaging, etc., etc.
160
528419
3773
09:08
And now we want to share. That's the next step.
161
532192
1931
09:10
So we're going to write this up and try to submit this
162
534123
1608
09:11
for publication. Right? So we have to write it up.
163
535731
2856
09:14
So we go, of course, to the pub. All right? (Laughter)
164
538587
4513
09:19
The one on the left is mine, okay? (Laughter)
165
543100
2284
09:21
Now, I tell them, a paper has four different sections:
166
545384
2086
09:23
an introduction, a methods, a results, a discussion.
167
547470
2807
09:26
The introduction says, what's the question and why?
168
550277
2604
09:28
Methods, what did you do? Results, what was the observation?
169
552881
3119
09:31
And the discussion is, who cares? Right?
170
556000
2143
09:34
That's a science paper, basically. (Laughter)
171
558143
2459
09:36
So the kids give me the words, right? I put it into a narrative,
172
560602
4529
09:41
which means that this paper is written in kidspeak.
173
565131
3247
09:44
It's not written by me. It's written by Amy
174
568378
2528
09:46
and the other students in the class. As a consequence,
175
570906
3320
09:50
this science paper begins, "Once upon a time ... " (Laughter)
176
574226
6017
09:56
The results section, it says: "Training phase, the puzzle ... duh duh duuuuuhhh." Right? (Laughter)
177
580243
5312
10:01
And the methods, it says, "Then we put the bees
178
585555
2196
10:03
into the fridge (and made bee pie)," smiley face. Right? (Laughter)
179
587751
3317
10:06
This is a science paper. We're going to try to get it published.
180
591068
3833
10:10
So here's the title page. We have a number of authors there.
181
594901
2834
10:13
All the ones in bold are eight to 10 years old.
182
597735
2851
10:16
The first author is Blackawton Primary School, because
183
600586
2050
10:18
if it were ever referenced, it would be "Blackawton et al,"
184
602636
3246
10:21
and not one individual. So we submit it to a public access journal,
185
605882
3057
10:24
and it says this. It said many things, but it said this.
186
608939
3332
10:28
"I'm afraid the paper fails our initial quality control checks in several different ways." (Laughter)
187
612271
3919
10:32
In other words, it starts off "once upon a time,"
188
616190
2560
10:34
the figures are in crayon, etc. (Laughter)
189
618750
2526
10:37
So we said, we'll get it reviewed. So I sent it to Dale Purves,
190
621276
4353
10:41
who is at the National Academy of Science, one of the leading neuroscientists in the world,
191
625629
3533
10:45
and he says, "This is the most original science paper I have ever read" — (Laughter) —
192
629162
3449
10:48
"and it certainly deserves wide exposure."
193
632611
2097
10:50
Larry Maloney, expert in vision, says, "The paper is magnificent.
194
634708
4271
10:54
The work would be publishable if done by adults."
195
638979
3366
10:58
So what did we do? We send it back to the editor.
196
642345
1979
11:00
They say no.
197
644324
1589
11:01
So we asked Larry and Natalie Hempel to write
198
645913
2454
11:04
a commentary situating the findings for scientists, right,
199
648367
4007
11:08
putting in the references, and we submit it to Biology Letters.
200
652374
4128
11:12
And there, it was reviewed by five independent referees,
201
656502
3327
11:15
and it was published. Okay? (Applause)
202
659829
4421
11:20
(Applause)
203
664250
6000
11:26
It took four months to do the science,
204
670250
3021
11:29
two years to get it published. (Laughter)
205
673271
3228
11:32
Typical science, actually, right? So this makes Amy and
206
676499
4835
11:37
her friends the youngest published scientists in the world.
207
681334
2433
11:39
What was the feedback like?
208
683767
2016
11:41
Well, it was published two days before Christmas,
209
685783
2885
11:44
downloaded 30,000 times in the first day, right?
210
688668
4003
11:48
It was the Editors' Choice in Science, which is a top science magazine.
211
692671
4040
11:52
It's forever freely accessible by Biology Letters.
212
696711
2542
11:55
It's the only paper that will ever be freely accessible by this journal.
213
699253
3680
11:58
Last year, it was the second-most downloaded paper
214
702933
2699
12:01
by Biology Letters, and the feedback from not just scientists
215
705632
4104
12:05
and teachers but the public as well.
216
709736
2548
12:08
And I'll just read one.
217
712284
1772
12:09
"I have read 'Blackawton Bees' recently. I don't have
218
714056
2490
12:12
words to explain exactly how I am feeling right now.
219
716546
2313
12:14
What you guys have done is real, true and amazing.
220
718859
2479
12:17
Curiosity, interest, innocence and zeal are the most basic
221
721338
3109
12:20
and most important things to do science.
222
724447
1724
12:22
Who else can have these qualities more than children?
223
726171
2478
12:24
Please congratulate your children's team from my side."
224
728649
3541
12:28
So I'd like to conclude with a physical metaphor.
225
732190
3383
12:31
Can I do it on you? (Laughter)
226
735573
2968
12:34
Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, come on. Yeah yeah. Okay.
227
738541
3093
12:37
Now, science is about taking risks, so this is an incredible risk, right? (Laughter)
228
741634
5177
12:42
For me, not for him. Right? Because we've only done this once before. (Laughter)
229
746811
6098
12:48
And you like technology, right?
230
752909
1576
12:50
Shimon Schocken: Right, but I like myself.
231
754485
2176
12:52
BL: This is the epitome of technology. Right. Okay.
232
756661
2951
12:55
Now ... (Laughter)
233
759612
3608
12:59
Okay. (Laughter)
234
763220
2880
13:02
Now, we're going to do a little demonstration, right?
235
766100
4084
13:06
You have to close your eyes, and you have to point
236
770184
4019
13:10
where you hear me clapping. All right?
237
774203
3157
13:13
(Clapping)
238
777360
4398
13:17
(Clapping)
239
781758
3144
13:20
Okay, how about if everyone over there shouts. One, two, three?
240
784902
2903
13:23
Audience: (Shouts)
241
787805
2901
13:26
(Laughter)
242
790706
4446
13:31
(Shouts) (Laughter)
243
795152
3171
13:34
Brilliant. Now, open your eyes. We'll do it one more time.
244
798323
3641
13:37
Everyone over there shout. (Shouts)
245
801964
2802
13:40
Where's the sound coming from? (Laughter) (Applause)
246
804766
5932
13:46
Thank you very much. (Applause)
247
810698
4230
13:50
What's the point? The point is what science does for us.
248
814928
3713
13:54
Right? We normally walk through life responding,
249
818641
2406
13:56
but if we ever want to do anything different, we have to
250
821047
2212
13:59
step into uncertainty. When he opened his eyes,
251
823259
2689
14:01
he was able to see the world in a new way.
252
825948
2382
14:04
That's what science offers us. It offers the possibility
253
828330
3168
14:07
to step on uncertainty through the process of play, right?
254
831498
4016
14:11
Now, true science education I think should be about
255
835514
3024
14:14
giving people a voice and enabling to express that voice,
256
838538
3399
14:17
so I've asked Amy to be the last voice in this short story.
257
841937
4369
14:22
So, Amy?
258
846306
3105
14:25
AO: This project was really exciting for me,
259
849411
2553
14:27
because it brought the process of discovery to life,
260
851964
2671
14:30
and it showed me that anyone, and I mean anyone,
261
854635
2911
14:33
has the potential to discover something new,
262
857546
2753
14:36
and that a small question can lead into a big discovery.
263
860299
4072
14:40
Changing the way a person thinks about something
264
864371
2652
14:42
can be easy or hard. It all depends on the way the person
265
867023
3712
14:46
feels about change.
266
870735
1488
14:48
But changing the way I thought about science was
267
872223
2452
14:50
surprisingly easy. Once we played the games
268
874675
2275
14:52
and then started to think about the puzzle,
269
876950
2418
14:55
I then realized that science isn't just a boring subject,
270
879368
3857
14:59
and that anyone can discover something new.
271
883225
3194
15:02
You just need an opportunity. My opportunity came
272
886419
3200
15:05
in the form of Beau, and the Blackawton Bee Project.
273
889619
2636
15:08
Thank you.BL: Thank you very much. (Applause)
274
892255
4361
15:12
(Applause)
275
896616
7747
ABOUT THE SPEAKERS
Beau Lotto - Neuroscientist, ArtistBeau Lotto is founder of Lottolab, a hybrid art studio and science lab. With glowing, interactive sculpture -- and old-fashioned peer-reviewed research--he's illuminating the mysteries of the brain's visual system.
Why you should listen
"Let there be perception," was evolution's proclamation, and so it was that all creatures, from honeybees to humans, came to see the world not as it is, but as was most useful. This uncomfortable place--where what an organism's brain sees diverges from what is actually out there--is what Beau Lotto and his team at Lottolab are exploring through their dazzling art-sci experiments and public illusions. Their Bee Matrix installation, for example, places a live bee in a transparent enclosure where gallerygoers may watch it seek nectar in a virtual meadow of luminous Plexiglas flowers. (Bees, Lotto will tell you, see colors much like we humans do.) The data captured isn't just discarded, either: it's put to good use in probing scientific papers, and sometimes in more exhibits.
At their home in London’s Science Museum, the lab holds "synesthetic workshops" where kids and adults make abstract paintings that computers interpret into music, and they host regular Lates--evenings of science, music and "mass experiments." Lotto is passionate about involving people from all walks of life in research on perception--both as subjects and as fellow researchers. One such program, called "i,scientist," in fact led to the publication of the first ever peer-reviewed scientific paper written by schoolchildren ("Blackawton Bees," December 2010). It starts, "Once upon a time ..."
These and Lotto's other conjurings are slowly, charmingly bending the science of perception--and our perceptions of what science can be.
Beau Lotto | Speaker | TED.com
Amy O'Toole - Student
Amy O'Toole is a 12-year-old student who helped run a science experiment inspired by Beau Lotto's participative science approach. At age 10 she became one of the youngest people ever to publish a peer-reviewed science paper.
Why you should listen
Amy O'Toole is a 12-year-old student with a peer-reviewed scientific publication under her belt. She took part in a participative science program led by Beau Lotto , called "i, scientist," which inspired a science experiment by a group of 26 primary school students in Blackawton, Devon, UK. O'Toole was never interested in science before this project, but now intends to study the human mind and body. The project led to the publication of the first ever peer-reviewed scientific paper written by schoolchildren ("Blackawton Bees," Royal Society's Biology Letters, December 2010). It starts: "Once upon a time ... ."
Amy O'Toole | Speaker | TED.com