TED2013
Lawrence Lessig: We the People, and the Republic we must reclaim
Filmed:
Readability: 4.3
1,552,121 views
There is a corruption at the heart of American politics, caused by the dependence of Congressional candidates on funding from the tiniest percentage of citizens. That's the argument at the core of this blistering talk by legal scholar Lawrence Lessig. With rapid-fire visuals, he shows how the funding process weakens the Republic in the most fundamental way, and issues a rallying bipartisan cry that will resonate with many in the U.S. and beyond.
Lawrence Lessig - Legal activist
Lawrence Lessig has already transformed intellectual-property law with his Creative Commons innovation. Now he's focused on an even bigger problem: The US' broken political system. Full bio
Lawrence Lessig has already transformed intellectual-property law with his Creative Commons innovation. Now he's focused on an even bigger problem: The US' broken political system. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Once upon a time,
0
643
2892
00:15
there was a place called Lesterland.
1
3535
3440
00:18
Now Lesterland looks a lot like the United States.
2
6975
2955
00:21
Like the United States, it has about 311 million people,
3
9930
4737
00:26
and of that 311 million people,
4
14667
2338
00:29
it turns out 144,000 are called Lester.
5
17005
4883
00:33
If Matt's in the audience,
6
21888
1128
00:35
I just borrowed that, I'll return it in a second,
7
23016
2690
00:37
this character from your series.
8
25706
2665
00:40
So 144,000 are called Lester,
9
28371
2423
00:42
which means about .05 percent is named Lester.
10
30794
4280
00:47
Now, Lesters in Lesterland have this extraordinary power.
11
35074
3728
00:50
There are two elections every election cycle in Lesterland.
12
38802
3163
00:53
One is called the general election.
13
41965
2213
00:56
The other is called the Lester election.
14
44178
3341
00:59
And in the general election, it's the citizens who get to vote,
15
47519
2985
01:02
but in the Lester election, it's the Lesters who get to vote.
16
50504
3272
01:05
And here's the trick.
17
53776
1134
01:06
In order to run in the general election,
18
54910
3651
01:10
you must do extremely well
19
58561
2546
01:13
in the Lester election.
20
61107
1373
01:14
You don't necessarily have to win, but you must do extremely well.
21
62480
3101
01:17
Now, what can we say about democracy in Lesterland?
22
65581
3950
01:21
What we can say, number one,
23
69531
1393
01:22
as the Supreme Court said in Citizens United,
24
70924
2636
01:25
that people have the ultimate influence over elected officials,
25
73560
4278
01:29
because, after all, there is a general election,
26
77838
2648
01:32
but only after the Lesters have had their way
27
80486
2952
01:35
with the candidates who wish to run in the general election.
28
83438
3502
01:38
And number two, obviously, this dependence upon the Lesters
29
86940
3603
01:42
is going to produce a subtle, understated,
30
90543
2762
01:45
we could say camouflaged, bending
31
93305
2429
01:47
to keep the Lesters happy.
32
95734
3191
01:50
Okay, so we have a democracy, no doubt,
33
98925
3269
01:54
but it's dependent upon the Lesters
34
102194
1676
01:55
and dependent upon the people.
35
103870
2010
01:57
It has competing dependencies,
36
105880
2642
02:00
we could say conflicting dependencies,
37
108522
2410
02:02
depending upon who the Lesters are.
38
110932
4270
02:07
Okay. That's Lesterland.
39
115202
2344
02:09
Now there are three things I want you to see now that I've described Lesterland.
40
117546
2759
02:12
Number one, the United States is Lesterland.
41
120305
3241
02:15
The United States is Lesterland.
42
123546
1876
02:17
The United States also looks like this, also has two elections,
43
125422
2381
02:19
one we called the general election,
44
127803
3139
02:22
the second we should call the money election.
45
130942
3244
02:26
In the general election, it's the citizens who get to vote,
46
134186
2166
02:28
if you're over 18, in some states if you have an ID.
47
136352
2594
02:30
In the money election, it's the funders who get to vote,
48
138946
3216
02:34
the funders who get to vote, and just like in Lesterland,
49
142162
2760
02:36
the trick is, to run in the general election,
50
144922
2159
02:39
you must do extremely well in the money election.
51
147081
2820
02:41
You don't necessarily have to win. There is Jerry Brown.
52
149901
2621
02:44
But you must do extremely well.
53
152522
2552
02:47
And here's the key: There are just as few relevant funders
54
155074
4528
02:51
in USA-land as there are Lesters in Lesterland.
55
159602
5489
02:57
Now you say, really?
56
165091
1904
02:58
Really .05 percent?
57
166995
3143
03:02
Well, here are the numbers from 2010:
58
170138
2216
03:04
.26 percent of America
59
172354
2296
03:06
gave 200 dollars or more to any federal candidate,
60
174650
2736
03:09
.05 percent gave the maximum amount to any federal candidate,
61
177386
4464
03:13
.01 percent -- the one percent of the one percent --
62
181850
3432
03:17
gave 10,000 dollars or more to federal candidates,
63
185282
3208
03:20
and in this election cycle, my favorite statistic
64
188490
3076
03:23
is .000042 percent
65
191566
3855
03:27
— for those of you doing the numbers, you know that's 132 Americans —
66
195421
4037
03:31
gave 60 percent of the Super PAC money spent
67
199458
3960
03:35
in the cycle we have just seen ending.
68
203418
2750
03:38
So I'm just a lawyer, I look at this range of numbers,
69
206168
2730
03:40
and I say it's fair for me to say
70
208898
1709
03:42
it's .05 percent who are our relevant funders in America.
71
210607
4251
03:46
In this sense, the funders are our Lesters.
72
214858
3302
03:50
Now, what can we say about this democracy in USA-land?
73
218160
3500
03:53
Well, as the Supreme Court said in Citizens United,
74
221660
2342
03:56
we could say, of course the people have the ultimate influence
75
224002
2837
03:58
over the elected officials. We have a general election,
76
226839
4029
04:02
but only after the funders have had their way
77
230868
3209
04:06
with the candidates who wish to run in that general election.
78
234077
4163
04:10
And number two, obviously,
79
238240
2523
04:12
this dependence upon the funders
80
240763
2272
04:15
produces a subtle, understated, camouflaged bending
81
243035
3932
04:18
to keep the funders happy.
82
246967
2637
04:21
Candidates for Congress and members of Congress
83
249604
3044
04:24
spend between 30 and 70 percent of their time
84
252648
4283
04:28
raising money to get back to Congress
85
256931
2176
04:31
or to get their party back into power,
86
259107
1775
04:32
and the question we need to ask is, what does it do to them,
87
260882
3425
04:36
these humans, as they spend their time
88
264307
2117
04:38
behind the telephone, calling people they've never met,
89
266424
3419
04:41
but calling the tiniest slice of the one percent?
90
269843
3468
04:45
As anyone would, as they do this,
91
273311
2368
04:47
they develop a sixth sense, a constant awareness
92
275679
3848
04:51
about how what they do might affect their ability to raise money.
93
279527
3340
04:54
They become, in the words of "The X-Files,"
94
282867
1416
04:56
shape-shifters, as they constantly adjust their views
95
284283
3444
04:59
in light of what they know will help them to raise money,
96
287727
2862
05:02
not on issues one to 10,
97
290589
1569
05:04
but on issues 11 to 1,000.
98
292158
3095
05:07
Leslie Byrne, a Democrat from Virginia,
99
295253
1714
05:08
describes that when she went to Congress,
100
296967
1610
05:10
she was told by a colleague, "Always lean to the green."
101
298577
3925
05:14
Then to clarify, she went on,
102
302502
1636
05:16
"He was not an environmentalist." (Laughter)
103
304138
4694
05:20
So here too we have a democracy,
104
308832
2080
05:22
a democracy dependent upon the funders
105
310912
2015
05:24
and dependent upon the people,
106
312927
1787
05:26
competing dependencies,
107
314714
2137
05:28
possibly conflicting dependencies
108
316851
2019
05:30
depending upon who the funders are.
109
318870
3611
05:34
Okay, the United States is Lesterland, point number one.
110
322481
2761
05:37
Here's point number two.
111
325242
2011
05:39
The United States is worse than Lesterland,
112
327253
2782
05:42
worse than Lesterland because you can imagine in Lesterland
113
330035
2881
05:44
if we Lesters got a letter from the government that said,
114
332916
2352
05:47
"Hey, you get to pick who gets to run in the general election,"
115
335268
3264
05:50
we would think maybe of a kind of aristocracy of Lesters.
116
338532
4151
05:54
You know, there are Lesters from every part of social society.
117
342683
2289
05:56
There are rich Lesters, poor Lesters, black Lesters, white Lesters,
118
344972
2648
05:59
not many women Lesters, but put that to the side for one second.
119
347620
2728
06:02
We have Lesters from everywhere. We could think,
120
350348
2128
06:04
"What could we do to make Lesterland better?"
121
352476
3008
06:07
It's at least possible the Lesters would act for the good of Lesterland.
122
355484
4775
06:12
But in our land, in this land, in USA-land,
123
360259
3243
06:15
there are certainly some sweet Lesters out there,
124
363502
2623
06:18
many of them in this room here today,
125
366125
1972
06:20
but the vast majority of Lesters act for the Lesters,
126
368097
4484
06:24
because the shifting coalitions that are comprising the .05 percent
127
372581
4388
06:28
are not comprising it for the public interest.
128
376969
2125
06:31
It's for their private interest. In this sense, the USA is worse than Lesterland.
129
379094
4392
06:35
And finally, point number three:
130
383486
2421
06:37
Whatever one wants to say about Lesterland,
131
385907
2947
06:40
against the background of its history, its traditions,
132
388854
2304
06:43
in our land, in USA-land, Lesterland is a corruption,
133
391158
4943
06:48
a corruption.
134
396101
1473
06:49
Now, by corruption I don't mean brown paper bag cash
135
397574
4023
06:53
secreted among members of Congress.
136
401597
1868
06:55
I don't mean Rod Blagojevich sense of corruption.
137
403465
3060
06:58
I don't mean any criminal act.
138
406525
1905
07:00
The corruption I'm talking about is perfectly legal.
139
408430
3391
07:03
It's a corruption relative to the framers' baseline for this republic.
140
411821
5053
07:08
The framers gave us what they called a republic,
141
416874
3495
07:12
but by a republic they meant a representative democracy,
142
420369
4182
07:16
and by a representative democracy, they meant a government,
143
424551
3187
07:19
as Madison put it in Federalist 52, that would have a branch
144
427738
2979
07:22
that would be dependent upon the people alone.
145
430717
4945
07:27
So here's the model of government.
146
435662
1015
07:28
They have the people and the government
147
436677
2605
07:31
with this exclusive dependency,
148
439282
2433
07:33
but the problem here is that Congress has evolved a different dependence,
149
441715
4103
07:37
no longer a dependence upon the people alone,
150
445818
2673
07:40
increasingly a dependence upon the funders.
151
448491
2429
07:42
Now this is a dependence too,
152
450920
3138
07:46
but it's different and conflicting from a dependence upon the people alone
153
454058
3864
07:49
so long as the funders are not the people.
154
457922
4306
07:54
This is a corruption.
155
462228
2263
07:56
Now, there's good news and bad news about this corruption.
156
464491
2500
07:58
One bit of good news is that it's bipartisan,
157
466991
2364
08:01
equal-opportunity corruption.
158
469355
2170
08:03
It blocks the left on a whole range of issues that we on the left really care about.
159
471525
4653
08:08
It blocks the right too, as it makes
160
476178
2472
08:10
principled arguments of the right increasingly impossible.
161
478650
3920
08:14
So the right wants smaller government.
162
482570
2192
08:16
When Al Gore was Vice President, his team had an idea
163
484762
2696
08:19
for deregulating a significant portion of the telecommunications industry.
164
487458
3912
08:23
The chief policy man took this idea to Capitol Hill,
165
491370
2680
08:26
and as he reported back to me,
166
494050
2033
08:28
the response was, "Hell no!
167
496083
2199
08:30
If we deregulate these guys,
168
498282
1776
08:32
how are we going to raise money from them?"
169
500058
3758
08:35
This is a system that's designed to save the status quo,
170
503816
3807
08:39
including the status quo of big and invasive government.
171
507623
3633
08:43
It works against the left and the right,
172
511256
2450
08:45
and that, you might say, is good news.
173
513706
1546
08:47
But here's the bad news.
174
515252
1789
08:49
It's a pathological, democracy-destroying corruption,
175
517041
3903
08:52
because in any system
176
520944
2256
08:55
where the members are dependent upon
177
523200
1900
08:57
the tiniest fraction of us for their election,
178
525100
3172
09:00
that means the tiniest number of us,
179
528272
2792
09:03
the tiniest, tiniest number of us,
180
531064
2280
09:05
can block reform.
181
533344
1711
09:07
I know that should have been, like, a rock or something.
182
535055
2898
09:09
I can only find cheese. I'm sorry. So there it is.
183
537953
2037
09:11
Block reform.
184
539990
2394
09:14
Because there is an economy here, an economy of influence,
185
542384
3976
09:18
an economy with lobbyists at the center
186
546360
2554
09:20
which feeds on polarization.
187
548914
2654
09:23
It feeds on dysfunction.
188
551568
1849
09:25
The worse that it is for us,
189
553417
2639
09:28
the better that it is for this fundraising.
190
556056
3936
09:31
Henry David Thoreau: "There are a thousand hacking
191
559992
3112
09:35
at the branches of evil to one who is striking at the root."
192
563104
4872
09:39
This is the root.
193
567976
3393
09:43
Okay, now, every single one of you knows this.
194
571369
4143
09:47
You couldn't be here if you didn't know this, yet you ignore it.
195
575512
3629
09:51
You ignore it. This is an impossible problem.
196
579141
3584
09:54
You focus on the possible problems,
197
582725
2548
09:57
like eradicating polio from the world,
198
585273
3263
10:00
or taking an image of every single street across the globe,
199
588536
3134
10:03
or building the first real universal translator,
200
591670
3306
10:06
or building a fusion factory in your garage.
201
594976
3602
10:10
These are the manageable problems, so you ignore —
202
598578
2918
10:13
(Laughter) (Applause) —
203
601496
5632
10:19
so you ignore this corruption.
204
607128
2449
10:21
But we cannot ignore this corruption anymore.
205
609577
5470
10:27
(Applause)
206
615047
3105
10:30
We need a government that works.
207
618152
3583
10:33
And not works for the left or the right,
208
621735
2865
10:36
but works for the left and the right,
209
624600
2464
10:39
the citizens of the left and right,
210
627064
2032
10:41
because there is no sensible reform possible
211
629096
3592
10:44
until we end this corruption.
212
632688
2529
10:47
So I want you to take hold, to grab the issue you care the most about.
213
635217
4185
10:51
Climate change is mine, but it might be financial reform
214
639402
2560
10:53
or a simpler tax system or inequality.
215
641962
2368
10:56
Grab that issue, sit it down in front of you,
216
644330
2188
10:58
look straight in its eyes, and tell it there is no Christmas this year.
217
646518
3841
11:02
There will never be a Christmas.
218
650359
1826
11:04
We will never get your issue solved
219
652185
2712
11:06
until we fix this issue first.
220
654897
2966
11:09
So it's not that mine is the most important issue. It's not.
221
657863
3330
11:13
Yours is the most important issue, but mine is the first issue,
222
661193
4176
11:17
the issue we have to solve before we get to fix
223
665369
2721
11:20
the issues you care about.
224
668090
1973
11:22
No sensible reform, and we cannot afford
225
670063
3298
11:25
a world, a future, with no sensible reform.
226
673361
3921
11:29
Okay. So how do we do it?
227
677282
2871
11:32
Turns out, the analytics here are easy, simple.
228
680153
3488
11:35
If the problem is members spending an extraordinary
229
683641
2850
11:38
amount of time fundraising from the tiniest slice of America,
230
686491
3160
11:41
the solution is to have them spend less time fundraising
231
689651
4260
11:45
but fundraise from a wider slice of Americans,
232
693911
2668
11:48
to spread it out,
233
696579
1173
11:49
to spread the funder influence so that we restore the idea
234
697752
3281
11:53
of dependence upon the people alone.
235
701033
3192
11:56
And to do this does not require a constitutional amendment,
236
704225
3430
11:59
changing the First Amendment.
237
707655
1259
12:00
To do this would require a single statute,
238
708914
3359
12:04
a statute establishing what we think of
239
712273
2192
12:06
as small dollar funded elections,
240
714465
2696
12:09
a statute of citizen-funded campaigns,
241
717161
2208
12:11
and there's any number of these proposals out there:
242
719369
2096
12:13
Fair Elections Now Act,
243
721465
1446
12:14
the American Anti-Corruption Act,
244
722911
2426
12:17
an idea in my book that I call the Grant and Franklin Project
245
725337
3090
12:20
to give vouchers to people to fund elections,
246
728427
2334
12:22
an idea of John Sarbanes called the Grassroots Democracy Act.
247
730761
3195
12:25
Each of these would fix this corruption
248
733956
4104
12:30
by spreading out the influence of funders to all of us.
249
738060
4349
12:34
The analytics are easy here.
250
742409
2658
12:37
It's the politics that's hard, indeed impossibly hard,
251
745067
5513
12:42
because this reform would shrink K Street,
252
750580
6359
12:48
and Capitol Hill, as Congressman Jim Cooper,
253
756939
4860
12:53
a Democrat from Tennessee, put it,
254
761799
2980
12:56
has become a farm league for K Street, a farm league for K Street.
255
764779
4820
13:01
Members and staffers and bureaucrats have
256
769599
1965
13:03
an increasingly common business model in their head,
257
771564
2211
13:05
a business model focused on their life after government,
258
773775
3068
13:08
their life as lobbyists.
259
776843
2321
13:11
Fifty percent of the Senate between 1998 and 2004
260
779164
3546
13:14
left to become lobbyists, 42 percent of the House.
261
782710
2658
13:17
Those numbers have only gone up,
262
785368
1476
13:18
and as United Republic calculated last April,
263
786844
2346
13:21
the average increase in salary for those who they tracked
264
789190
3213
13:24
was 1,452 percent.
265
792403
5362
13:29
So it's fair to ask, how is it possible for them to change this?
266
797765
6366
13:36
Now I get this skepticism.
267
804131
4064
13:40
I get this cynicism. I get this sense of impossibility.
268
808195
4936
13:45
But I don't buy it.
269
813131
2328
13:47
This is a solvable issue.
270
815459
3848
13:51
If you think about the issues our parents tried to solve
271
819307
3160
13:54
in the 20th century,
272
822467
1839
13:56
issues like racism, or sexism,
273
824306
3281
13:59
or the issue that we've been fighting in this century, homophobia,
274
827587
3113
14:02
those are hard issues.
275
830700
2487
14:05
You don't wake up one day no longer a racist.
276
833187
2920
14:08
It takes generations to tear that intuition, that DNA,
277
836107
4311
14:12
out of the soul of a people.
278
840418
2445
14:14
But this is a problem of just incentives, just incentives.
279
842863
3245
14:18
Change the incentives, and the behavior changes,
280
846108
2543
14:20
and the states that have adopted small dollar funded systems
281
848651
2687
14:23
have seen overnight a change in the practice.
282
851338
3130
14:26
When Connecticut adopted this system,
283
854468
1981
14:28
in the very first year, 78 percent of elected representatives
284
856449
4190
14:32
gave up large contributions and took small contributions only.
285
860639
4247
14:36
It's solvable,
286
864886
1979
14:38
not by being a Democrat,
287
866865
2810
14:41
not by being a Republican.
288
869675
1795
14:43
It's solvable by being citizens, by being citizens,
289
871470
3652
14:47
by being TEDizens.
290
875122
2983
14:50
Because if you want to kickstart reform,
291
878105
4337
14:54
look, I could kickstart reform
292
882442
3451
14:57
at half the price of fixing energy policy,
293
885893
3588
15:01
I could give you back a republic.
294
889481
2782
15:04
Okay. But even if you're not yet with me,
295
892263
3644
15:07
even if you believe this is impossible,
296
895907
3585
15:11
what the five years since I spoke at TED has taught me
297
899492
3437
15:14
as I've spoken about this issue again and again is,
298
902929
2598
15:17
even if you think it's impossible, that is irrelevant.
299
905527
3826
15:21
Irrelevant.
300
909353
1988
15:23
I spoke at Dartmouth once, and a woman stood up after I spoke,
301
911341
3568
15:26
I write in my book, and she said to me,
302
914909
1843
15:28
"Professor, you've convinced me this is hopeless. Hopeless.
303
916752
5693
15:34
There's nothing we can do."
304
922445
2850
15:37
When she said that, I scrambled.
305
925295
1925
15:39
I tried to think, "How do I respond to that hopelessness?
306
927220
2142
15:41
What is that sense of hopelessness?"
307
929362
1663
15:43
And what hit me was an image of my six-year-old son.
308
931025
4862
15:47
And I imagined a doctor coming to me and saying,
309
935887
3185
15:51
"Your son has terminal brain cancer, and there's nothing you can do.
310
939072
7309
15:58
Nothing you can do."
311
946381
2254
16:00
So would I do nothing?
312
948635
3095
16:03
Would I just sit there? Accept it? Okay, nothing I can do?
313
951730
2372
16:06
I'm going off to build Google Glass.
314
954102
3823
16:09
Of course not. I would do everything I could,
315
957925
3646
16:13
and I would do everything I could because this is what love means,
316
961571
3580
16:17
that the odds are irrelevant and that you do
317
965151
2316
16:19
whatever the hell you can, the odds be damned.
318
967467
3579
16:23
And then I saw the obvious link, because even we liberals
319
971046
3841
16:26
love this country.
320
974887
2259
16:29
(Laughter)
321
977146
2973
16:32
And so when the pundits and the politicians
322
980119
2260
16:34
say that change is impossible,
323
982379
2310
16:36
what this love of country says back is,
324
984689
3062
16:39
"That's just irrelevant."
325
987751
2736
16:42
We lose something dear,
326
990487
2040
16:44
something everyone in this room loves and cherishes,
327
992527
3207
16:47
if we lose this republic, and so we act
328
995734
3948
16:51
with everything we can to prove these pundits wrong.
329
999682
5294
16:56
So here's my question:
330
1004976
2436
16:59
Do you have that love?
331
1007412
4611
17:04
Do you have that love?
332
1012023
2825
17:06
Because if you do,
333
1014848
1683
17:08
then what the hell are you, what are the hell are we doing?
334
1016531
5389
17:13
When Ben Franklin was carried from the constitutional convention
335
1021920
4540
17:18
in September of 1787, he was stopped in the street by a woman who said,
336
1026460
4006
17:22
"Mr. Franklin, what have you wrought?"
337
1030466
3458
17:25
Franklin said, "A republic, madam, if you can keep it."
338
1033924
7761
17:33
A republic. A representative democracy.
339
1041685
4899
17:38
A government dependent upon the people alone.
340
1046584
7209
17:45
We have lost that republic.
341
1053793
4585
17:50
All of us have to act to get it back.
342
1058378
4348
17:54
Thank you very much.
343
1062726
1644
17:56
(Applause)
344
1064370
6053
18:02
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. (Applause)
345
1070423
10676
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Lawrence Lessig - Legal activistLawrence Lessig has already transformed intellectual-property law with his Creative Commons innovation. Now he's focused on an even bigger problem: The US' broken political system.
Why you should listen
Lawyer and activist Lawrence Lessig spent a decade arguing for sensible intellectual property law, updated for the digital age. He was a founding board member of Creative Commons, an organization that builds better copyright practices through principles established first by the open-source software community.
In 2007, just after his last TED Talk, Lessig announced he was leaving the field of IP and Internet policy, and moving on to a more fundamental problem that blocks all types of sensible policy -- the corrupting influence of money in American politics.
In 2011, Lessig founded Rootstrikers, an organization dedicated to changing the influence of money in Congress. In his latest book, Republic, Lost, he shows just how far the U.S. has spun off course -- and how citizens can regain control. As The New York Times wrote about him, “Mr. Lessig’s vision is at once profoundly pessimistic -- the integrity of the nation is collapsing under the best of intentions --and deeply optimistic. Simple legislative surgery, he says, can put the nation back on the path to greatness.”
Read an excerpt of Lessig's new book, Lesterland >>
Lawrence Lessig | Speaker | TED.com