TEDGlobal 2013
Anant Agarwal: Why massive open online courses (still) matter
Filmed:
Readability: 4.2
1,394,242 views
2013 was a year of hype for MOOCs (massive open online courses). Great big numbers and great big hopes were followed by some disappointing first results. But the head of edX, Anant Agarwal, makes the case that MOOCs still matter -- as a way to share high-level learning widely and supplement (but perhaps not replace) traditional classrooms. Agarwal shares his vision of blended learning, where teachers create the ideal learning experience for 21st century students.
Anant Agarwal - Education innovator
Through blended courses Anant Agarwal is pairing online education with face-to-face student-faculty interactions, reshaping the university campus experience. Full bio
Through blended courses Anant Agarwal is pairing online education with face-to-face student-faculty interactions, reshaping the university campus experience. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
I'd like to reimagine education.
0
207
3351
00:15
The last year
1
3558
1590
00:17
has seen the invention of a new four-letter word.
2
5148
2906
00:20
It starts with an M.
3
8054
1913
00:21
MOOC: massive open online courses.
4
9967
4457
00:26
Many organizations
5
14424
1477
00:27
are offering these online courses
6
15901
2758
00:30
to students all over the world, in the millions, for free.
7
18659
4030
00:34
Anybody who has an Internet connection
8
22689
1560
00:36
and the will to learn can access these great courses
9
24249
2528
00:38
from excellent universities
10
26777
2094
00:40
and get a credential at the end of it.
11
28871
3257
00:44
Now, in this discussion today,
12
32128
2624
00:46
I'm going to focus
13
34752
1235
00:47
on a different aspect of MOOCs.
14
35987
3268
00:51
We are taking what we are learning
15
39255
2351
00:53
and the technologies we are developing in the large
16
41606
2565
00:56
and applying them in the small
17
44171
2100
00:58
to create a blended model of education
18
46271
2979
01:01
to really reinvent and reimagine
19
49250
1793
01:03
what we do in the classroom.
20
51043
2427
01:05
Now, our classrooms could use change.
21
53470
2510
01:07
So, here's a classroom
22
55980
2421
01:10
at this little three-letter institute
23
58401
2025
01:12
in the Northeast of America, MIT.
24
60426
2784
01:15
And this was a classroom about 50 or 60 years ago,
25
63210
2319
01:17
and this is a classroom today.
26
65529
3467
01:20
What's changed?
27
68996
3120
01:24
The seats are in color.
28
72116
2547
01:26
Whoop-de-do.
29
74663
3128
01:29
Education really hasn't changed
30
77791
2711
01:32
in the past 500 years.
31
80502
1695
01:34
The last big innovation in education
32
82197
2331
01:36
was the printing press and the textbooks.
33
84528
3482
01:40
Everything else has changed around us.
34
88010
1410
01:41
You know, from healthcare to transportation,
35
89420
1823
01:43
everything is different,
but education hasn't changed.
but education hasn't changed.
36
91243
4493
01:47
It's also been a real issue in terms of access.
37
95736
2673
01:50
So what you see here
38
98409
1627
01:52
is not a rock concert.
39
100036
2502
01:54
And the person you see at the end of the stage
40
102538
2546
01:57
is not Madonna.
41
105084
2060
01:59
This is a classroom
42
107144
1629
02:00
at the Obafemi Awolowo University in Nigeria.
43
108773
4418
02:05
Now, we've all heard of distance education,
44
113191
3936
02:09
but the students way in the back,
45
117127
1368
02:10
200 feet away from the instructor,
46
118495
2112
02:12
I think they are undergoing long-distance education.
47
120607
4895
02:17
Now, I really believe
48
125502
1675
02:19
that we can transform education,
49
127177
2215
02:21
both in quality and scale and access,
50
129392
2846
02:24
through technology.
51
132238
2308
02:26
For example, at edX,
52
134546
3695
02:30
we are trying to transform education
53
138241
2253
02:32
through online technologies.
54
140494
3160
02:35
Given education has been calcified for 500 years,
55
143654
3259
02:38
we really cannot think about reengineering it,
56
146913
2191
02:41
micromanaging it.
57
149104
1145
02:42
We really have to completely reimagine it.
58
150249
2308
02:44
It's like going from ox carts to the airplane.
59
152557
4041
02:48
Even the infrastructure has to change.
60
156598
1523
02:50
Everything has to change.
61
158121
1613
02:51
We need to go from lectures on the blackboard
62
159734
3365
02:55
to online exercises, online videos.
63
163099
2608
02:57
We have to go to interactive virtual laboratories
64
165707
2481
03:00
and gamification.
65
168188
1649
03:01
We have to go to completely online grading
66
169837
1911
03:03
and peer interaction and discussion boards.
67
171748
2753
03:06
Everything really has to change.
68
174501
2281
03:08
So at edX and a number of other organizations,
69
176782
2506
03:11
we are applying these technologies to education
70
179288
2159
03:13
through MOOCs to really
increase access to education.
increase access to education.
71
181447
3186
03:16
And you heard of this example,
72
184633
1717
03:18
where, when we launched our very first course --
73
186350
2616
03:20
and this was an MIT-hard
74
188966
1766
03:22
circuits and electronics course --
75
190732
1588
03:24
about a year and a half ago,
76
192320
2694
03:27
155,000 students from 162 countries
77
195014
5303
03:32
enrolled in this course.
78
200317
1703
03:34
And we had no marketing budget.
79
202020
2686
03:36
Now, 155,000 is a big number.
80
204706
3488
03:40
This number is bigger
81
208194
1739
03:41
than the total number of alumni of MIT
82
209933
2631
03:44
in its 150-year history.
83
212564
3825
03:48
7,200 students passed the course,
84
216389
2158
03:50
and this was a hard course.
85
218547
2463
03:53
7,200 is also a big number.
86
221010
3454
03:56
If I were to teach at MIT two semesters every year,
87
224464
3542
04:00
I would have to teach for 40 years
88
228006
2877
04:02
before I could teach this many students.
89
230883
2602
04:05
Now these large numbers
90
233485
1538
04:07
are just one part of the story.
91
235023
2158
04:09
So today, I want to discuss a different aspect,
92
237181
2662
04:11
the other side of MOOCs,
93
239843
1225
04:13
take a different perspective.
94
241068
2179
04:15
We are taking what we develop
and learn in the large
and learn in the large
95
243247
2935
04:18
and applying it in the small
96
246182
1545
04:19
to the classroom, to create
a blended model of learning.
a blended model of learning.
97
247727
3996
04:23
But before I go into that, let me tell you a story.
98
251723
4603
04:28
When my daughter turned 13, became a teenager,
99
256326
4084
04:32
she stopped speaking English,
100
260410
3367
04:35
and she began speaking this new language.
101
263777
3061
04:38
I call it teen-lish.
102
266838
2806
04:41
It's a digital language.
103
269644
2212
04:43
It's got two sounds: a grunt and a silence.
104
271856
6714
04:50
"Honey, come over for dinner."
105
278570
3316
04:53
"Hmm."
106
281886
1595
04:55
"Did you hear me?"
107
283481
2134
04:57
Silence. (Laughter)
108
285615
2263
04:59
"Can you listen to me?"
109
287878
1372
05:01
"Hmm."
110
289250
1372
05:02
So we had a real issue with communicating,
111
290622
1956
05:04
and we were just not communicating,
112
292578
2268
05:06
until one day I had this epiphany.
113
294846
3014
05:09
I texted her. (Laughter)
114
297860
2663
05:12
I got an instant response.
115
300523
2318
05:14
I said, no, that must have been by accident.
116
302841
1685
05:16
She must have thought, you know,
117
304526
1087
05:17
some friend of hers was calling her.
118
305613
2287
05:19
So I texted her again. Boom, another response.
119
307900
3097
05:22
I said, this is great.
120
310997
1809
05:24
And so since then, our life has changed.
121
312806
2056
05:26
I text her, she responds.
122
314862
1558
05:28
It's just been absolutely great.
123
316420
2502
05:30
(Applause)
124
318922
5855
05:36
So our millennial generation
125
324777
1970
05:38
is built differently.
126
326747
1634
05:40
Now, I'm older, and my
youthful looks might belie that,
youthful looks might belie that,
127
328381
2501
05:42
but I'm not in the millennial generation.
128
330882
3856
05:46
But our kids are really different.
129
334738
1632
05:48
The millennial generation is completely comfortable
130
336370
1859
05:50
with online technology.
131
338229
1240
05:51
So why are we fighting it in the classroom?
132
339469
2029
05:53
Let's not fight it. Let's embrace it.
133
341498
1633
05:55
In fact, I believe -- and I have two fat thumbs,
134
343131
1689
05:56
I can't text very well --
135
344820
1649
05:58
but I'm willing to bet that with evolution,
136
346469
2167
06:00
our kids and their grandchildren
137
348636
2245
06:02
will develop really, really little, itty-bitty thumbs
138
350881
1830
06:04
to text much better,
139
352711
1383
06:06
that evolution will fix all of that stuff.
140
354094
2860
06:08
But what if we embraced technology,
141
356954
1771
06:10
embraced the millennial generation's
142
358725
2604
06:13
natural predilections,
143
361329
1265
06:14
and really think about creating
these online technologies,
these online technologies,
144
362594
3045
06:17
blend them into their lives.
145
365639
1434
06:19
So here's what we can do.
146
367073
1823
06:20
So rather than driving our kids into a classroom,
147
368896
2492
06:23
herding them out there at 8 o'clock in the morning --
148
371388
2572
06:25
I hated going to class at 8 o'clock in the morning,
149
373960
2758
06:28
so why are we forcing our kids to do that?
150
376718
2082
06:30
So instead what you do
151
378800
1174
06:31
is you have them watch videos
152
379974
2020
06:33
and do interactive exercises
153
381994
1811
06:35
in the comfort of their dorm rooms, in their bedroom,
154
383805
2689
06:38
in the dining room, in the bathroom,
155
386494
1861
06:40
wherever they're most creative.
156
388355
2577
06:42
Then they come into the classroom
157
390932
1995
06:44
for some in-person interaction.
158
392927
3424
06:48
They can have discussions amongst themselves.
159
396351
1837
06:50
They can solve problems together.
160
398188
1576
06:51
They can work with the professor
161
399764
1146
06:52
and have the professor answer their questions.
162
400910
2994
06:55
In fact, with edX, when we
were teaching our first course
were teaching our first course
163
403904
3863
06:59
on circuits and electronics around the world,
164
407767
2426
07:02
this was happening unbeknownst to us.
165
410193
2379
07:04
Two high school teachers
166
412572
1539
07:06
at the Sant High School in Mongolia
167
414111
3682
07:09
had flipped their classroom,
168
417793
2147
07:11
and they were using our video lectures
169
419940
2279
07:14
and interactive exercises,
170
422219
1873
07:16
where the learners in the high school,
171
424092
1611
07:17
15-year-olds, mind you,
172
425703
1585
07:19
would go and do these things in their own homes
173
427288
1834
07:21
and they would come into class,
174
429122
1347
07:22
and as you see from this image here,
175
430469
1936
07:24
they would interact with each other
176
432405
1086
07:25
and do some physical laboratory work.
177
433491
2337
07:27
And the only way we discovered this
178
435828
1321
07:29
was they wrote a blog
179
437149
1423
07:30
and we happened to stumble upon that blog.
180
438572
4023
07:34
We were also doing other pilots.
181
442595
2107
07:36
So we did a pilot experimental blended courses,
182
444702
2482
07:39
working with San Jose State University in California,
183
447184
2972
07:42
again, with the circuits and electronics course.
184
450156
1847
07:44
You'll hear that a lot. That course has become
185
452003
2468
07:46
sort of like our petri dish of learning.
186
454471
3476
07:49
So there, the students would, again,
187
457947
2268
07:52
the instructors flipped the classroom,
188
460215
2727
07:54
blended online and in person,
189
462942
1721
07:56
and the results were staggering.
190
464663
2308
07:58
Now don't take these results to the bank just yet.
191
466971
2642
08:01
Just wait a little bit longer as we
experiment with this some more,
experiment with this some more,
192
469613
2488
08:04
but the early results are incredible.
193
472101
2161
08:06
So traditionally, semester upon semester,
194
474262
2397
08:08
for the past several years, this course,
195
476659
2341
08:11
again, a hard course,
196
479000
1689
08:12
had a failure rate of about 40 to 41 percent
197
480689
3116
08:15
every semester.
198
483805
1500
08:17
With this blended class late last year,
199
485305
2698
08:20
the failure rate fell to nine percent.
200
488003
3981
08:23
So the results can be extremely, extremely good.
201
491984
3763
08:27
Now before we go too far into this,
202
495747
3227
08:30
I'd like to spend some time discussing
203
498974
2652
08:33
some key ideas.
204
501626
1149
08:34
What are some key ideas
205
502775
1211
08:35
that makes all of this work?
206
503986
2857
08:38
One idea is active learning.
207
506843
2227
08:41
The idea here is, rather than have students
208
509070
2440
08:43
walk into class and watch lectures,
209
511510
2186
08:45
we replace this with what we call lessons.
210
513696
3042
08:48
Lessons are interleaved sequences
211
516738
2244
08:50
of videos and interactive exercises.
212
518982
2681
08:53
So a student might watch a five-, seven-minute video
213
521663
3179
08:56
and follow that with an interactive exercise.
214
524842
3040
08:59
Think of this as the ultimate
Socratization of education.
Socratization of education.
215
527882
3145
09:03
You teach by asking questions.
216
531027
1980
09:05
And this is a form of learning
217
533007
1504
09:06
called active learning,
218
534511
1277
09:07
and really promoted by a very early paper, in 1972,
219
535788
3279
09:11
by Craik and Lockhart,
220
539067
1518
09:12
where they said and discovered
221
540585
1521
09:14
that learning and retention really relates strongly
222
542106
2380
09:16
to the depth of mental processing.
223
544486
1749
09:18
Students learn much better
224
546235
1492
09:19
when they are interacting with the material.
225
547727
3188
09:22
The second idea is self-pacing.
226
550915
2778
09:25
Now, when I went to a lecture hall,
227
553693
1636
09:27
and if you were like me,
228
555329
1290
09:28
by the fifth minute I would lose the professor.
229
556619
1966
09:30
I wasn't all that smart, and I would
be scrambling, taking notes,
be scrambling, taking notes,
230
558585
3580
09:34
and then I would lose the lecture
for the rest of the hour.
for the rest of the hour.
231
562165
3191
09:37
Instead, wouldn't it be nice with online technologies,
232
565356
2470
09:39
we offer videos and interactive
engagements to students?
engagements to students?
233
567826
3868
09:43
They can hit the pause button.
234
571694
1731
09:45
They can rewind the professor.
235
573425
2491
09:47
Heck, they can even mute the professor.
236
575916
3099
09:51
So this form of self-pacing
237
579015
2054
09:53
can be very helpful to learning.
238
581069
2625
09:55
The third idea that we have is instant feedback.
239
583694
3354
09:59
With instant feedback,
240
587048
1477
10:00
the computer grades exercises.
241
588525
1855
10:02
I mean, how else do you teach 150,000 students?
242
590380
2295
10:04
Your computer is grading all the exercises.
243
592675
2294
10:06
And we've all submitted homeworks,
244
594969
1534
10:08
and your grades come back two weeks later,
245
596503
2041
10:10
you've forgotten all about it.
246
598544
1624
10:12
I don't think I've still received
some of my homeworks
some of my homeworks
247
600168
2077
10:14
from my undergraduate days.
248
602245
1485
10:15
Some are never graded.
249
603730
1347
10:17
So with instant feedback,
250
605077
1494
10:18
students can try to apply answers.
251
606571
1490
10:20
If they get it wrong, they can get instant feedback.
252
608061
2409
10:22
They can try it again and try it again,
253
610470
1648
10:24
and this really becomes much more engaging.
254
612118
1933
10:26
They get the instant feedback,
255
614051
1583
10:27
and this little green check mark that you see here
256
615634
2919
10:30
is becoming somewhat of a cult symbol at edX.
257
618553
3590
10:34
Learners are telling us that they go to bed at night
258
622143
2888
10:37
dreaming of the green check mark.
259
625047
3444
10:40
In fact, one of our learners
260
628491
1802
10:42
who took the circuits course early last year,
261
630293
2781
10:45
he then went on to take a software course
262
633074
1932
10:47
from Berkeley at the end of the year,
263
635006
2301
10:49
and this is what the learner had to say
264
637307
2146
10:51
on our discussion board
265
639453
1272
10:52
when he just started that course
266
640725
1526
10:54
about the green check mark:
267
642251
2521
10:56
"Oh god; have I missed you."
268
644772
2057
10:58
When's the last time you've seen students
269
646829
2698
11:01
posting comments like this about homework?
270
649527
4461
11:05
My colleague Ed Bertschinger,
271
653988
2396
11:08
who heads up the physics department at MIT,
272
656384
2170
11:10
has this to say about instant feedback:
273
658554
2844
11:13
He indicated that instant feedback
274
661398
3001
11:16
turns teaching moments into learning outcomes.
275
664399
5775
11:22
The next big idea is gamification.
276
670174
2292
11:24
You know, all learners engage really well
277
672466
1901
11:26
with interactive videos and so on.
278
674367
1509
11:27
You know, they would sit down and shoot
279
675876
1265
11:29
alien spaceships all day long until they get it.
280
677141
2344
11:31
So we applied these gamification
techniques to learning,
techniques to learning,
281
679485
2787
11:34
and we can build these online laboratories.
282
682272
2223
11:36
How do you teach creativity?
How do you teach design?
How do you teach design?
283
684495
2247
11:38
We can do this through online labs
284
686752
1669
11:40
and use computing power
285
688421
1277
11:41
to build these online labs.
286
689698
1589
11:43
So as this little video shows here,
287
691287
2388
11:45
you can engage students
288
693675
1465
11:47
much like they design with Legos.
289
695140
1607
11:48
So here, the learners are building a circuit
290
696747
1918
11:50
with Lego-like ease.
291
698665
1891
11:52
And this can also be graded by the computer.
292
700556
4091
11:56
Fifth is peer learning.
293
704647
2934
11:59
So here, we use discussion forums and discussions
294
707581
2835
12:02
and Facebook-like interaction
295
710416
2100
12:04
not as a distraction,
296
712516
1864
12:06
but to really help students learn.
297
714380
2847
12:09
Let me tell you a story.
298
717227
1717
12:10
When we did our circuits course
299
718944
3226
12:14
for the 155,000 students,
300
722170
1866
12:16
I didn't sleep for three nights
301
724036
1665
12:17
leading up to the launch of the course.
302
725701
1887
12:19
I told my TAs, okay, 24/7,
303
727588
2559
12:22
we're going to be up
304
730147
1266
12:23
monitoring the forum, answering questions.
305
731413
1874
12:25
They had answered questions for 100 students.
306
733287
1973
12:27
How do you do that for 150,000?
307
735260
2861
12:30
So one night I'm sitting up there, at 2 a.m. at night,
308
738121
2336
12:32
and I think there's this question
309
740457
1221
12:33
from a student from Pakistan,
310
741678
1971
12:35
and he asked a question, and I said,
311
743649
1328
12:36
okay, let me go and type up an answer,
312
744977
1456
12:38
I don't type all that fast,
313
746433
1608
12:40
and I begin typing up the answer,
314
748041
1564
12:41
and before I can finish,
315
749605
1694
12:43
another student from Egypt
popped in with an answer,
popped in with an answer,
316
751299
2674
12:45
not quite right, so I'm fixing the answer,
317
753973
1918
12:47
and before I can finish, a student from the U.S.
318
755891
1968
12:49
had popped in with a different answer.
319
757859
1609
12:51
And then I sat back, fascinated.
320
759468
2800
12:54
Boom, boom, boom, boom, the students were
321
762268
1947
12:56
discussing and interacting with each other,
322
764215
1951
12:58
and by 4 a.m. that night, I'm totally fascinated,
323
766166
2518
13:00
having this epiphany,
324
768684
1468
13:02
and by 4 a.m. in the morning,
325
770152
1256
13:03
they had discovered the right answer.
326
771408
1753
13:05
And all I had to do was go and bless it,
327
773161
1727
13:06
"Good answer."
328
774888
1966
13:08
So this is absolutely amazing,
329
776854
2352
13:11
where students are learning from each other,
330
779206
1810
13:13
and they're telling us that they are learning
331
781016
2817
13:15
by teaching.
332
783833
2297
13:18
Now this is all not just in the future.
333
786130
1980
13:20
This is happening today.
334
788110
1752
13:21
So we are applying these blended learning pilots
335
789862
2317
13:24
in a number of universities and
high schools around the world,
high schools around the world,
336
792179
2741
13:26
from Tsinghua in China
337
794920
1786
13:28
to the National University of Mongolia in Mongolia
338
796706
2432
13:31
to Berkeley in California --
339
799138
1611
13:32
all over the world.
340
800749
1359
13:34
And these kinds of technologies really help,
341
802108
2024
13:36
the blended model can really help
342
804132
1549
13:37
revolutionize education.
343
805681
2098
13:39
It can also solve a practical problem of MOOCs,
344
807779
3411
13:43
the business aspect.
345
811190
1680
13:44
We can also license these MOOC courses
346
812870
2316
13:47
to other universities,
347
815186
1739
13:48
and therein lies a revenue model for MOOCs,
348
816925
2564
13:51
where the university that
licenses it with the professor
licenses it with the professor
349
819489
2389
13:53
can use these online courses
350
821878
1837
13:55
like the next-generation textbook.
351
823715
2201
13:57
They can use as much or as little as they like,
352
825916
2455
14:00
and it becomes a tool in the teacher's arsenal.
353
828371
5486
14:05
Finally, I would like to have you
354
833857
2050
14:07
dream with me for a little bit.
355
835907
2841
14:10
I would like us to really reimagine education.
356
838748
4169
14:14
We will have to move from lecture halls to e-spaces.
357
842917
4125
14:19
We have to move from books to tablets
358
847042
2675
14:21
like the Aakash in India
359
849717
1826
14:23
or the Raspberry Pi, 20 dollars.
360
851543
2348
14:25
The Aakash is 40 dollars.
361
853891
2007
14:27
We have to move from
bricks-and-mortar school buildings
bricks-and-mortar school buildings
362
855898
2914
14:30
to digital dormitories.
363
858812
2621
14:33
But I think at the end of the day,
364
861433
1448
14:34
I think we will still need one lecture hall
365
862881
2242
14:37
in our universities.
366
865123
2562
14:39
Otherwise, how else do we tell our grandchildren
367
867685
2824
14:42
that your grandparents sat in that room
368
870509
3395
14:45
in neat little rows like cornstalks
369
873904
3224
14:49
and watched this professor at the end
370
877128
2553
14:51
talk about content and, you know,
371
879681
2647
14:54
you didn't even have a rewind button?
372
882328
2647
14:56
Thank you.
373
884975
2228
14:59
(Applause)
374
887203
1991
15:01
Thank you. Thank you. (Applause)
375
889194
6751
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Anant Agarwal - Education innovatorThrough blended courses Anant Agarwal is pairing online education with face-to-face student-faculty interactions, reshaping the university campus experience.
Why you should listen
In the spring of 2012, Anant Agarwal, a professor of computer science at MIT, taught a course called “Circuits and Electronics.” As usual, it was MIT-level challenging, requiring knowledge of differential equations and calculus. Unlike in the past, though, the course enrolled 155,000 students from 162 countries around the world.
It was the inaugural offering of what is now edX , an online learning venture of MIT and Harvard, which Agarwal helms. Through this nonprofit -- one of the leading forces of the massive open online course (MOOC) movement -- Agarwal aims to make higher education globally available, for free.
Which does not preclude in-person education. On campus, Agarwal is pushing for what he calls blended courses, which interweave digital content and face-to-face interactions. "I see online learning as a rising tide that will lift all boats,” Agarwal says.
Agarwal holds the Guinness World Record for the largest microphone array, and was named one of Forbes' top education innovators in 2012. Find him on Twitter at @agarwaledu.
Anant Agarwal | Speaker | TED.com