TED2007
Paola Antonelli: Treat design as art
Filmed:
Readability: 4.3
663,544 views
Paola Antonelli, design curator at New York's Museum of Modern Art, wants to spread her appreciation of design -- in all shapes and forms -- around the world.
Paola Antonelli - Design curator
Paola Antonelli is on a mission to introduce -- and explain -- design to the world. With her shows at New York's Museum of Modern Art, she celebrates design's presence in every part of life. Full bio
Paola Antonelli is on a mission to introduce -- and explain -- design to the world. With her shows at New York's Museum of Modern Art, she celebrates design's presence in every part of life. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
Those of us who believe in heaven have some sort of idea of what heaven would be.
0
0
4000
00:16
And in my idea, heaven is satisfied curiosity.
1
4000
3000
00:19
I think of heaven as a really comfortable cloud
2
7000
3000
00:22
where I can just lie down with my belly down,
3
10000
2000
00:24
like I was watching TV when I was a child, and my elbows up.
4
12000
4000
00:28
And I can basically look everywhere I want,
5
16000
2000
00:31
see every movie I've always wanted to see.
6
19000
2000
00:33
And in the same kind of trance that you can feel sometimes
7
21000
4000
00:37
in the subway in New York when you're reading,
8
25000
1000
00:38
there's something really soothing and easy.
9
26000
2000
00:40
Well, the funny thing is that I already have that kind of life, in a way,
10
28000
4000
00:44
because I discovered ...
11
32000
3000
00:47
it took me a while to understand it,
12
35000
1000
00:48
but when I discovered around 24 years of age that I was much more comfortable
13
36000
5000
00:53
with objects than with people, I finally decided to really embrace this passion.
14
41000
6000
00:59
And I basically live my life in sort of a trance,
15
47000
2000
01:01
and I look around and everything I see is just the beginning of a long story.
16
49000
5000
01:06
Just to give you an example:
17
54000
2000
01:08
this is the exhibition, Humble Masterpieces, as it was at MoMA in 2004.
18
56000
5000
01:13
We were in Queens,
19
61000
1000
01:14
we were building the big, big, big, big building in Midtown,
20
62000
3000
01:17
so we were in the small, small, small boondocks.
21
65000
2000
01:19
That was one of the funnest moments of my career.
22
67000
4000
01:23
But it's not only that.
23
71000
1000
01:24
The typeface -- the typeface is Helvetica;
24
72000
2000
01:26
it's its 50th anniversary this year.
25
74000
3000
01:29
And so I start thinking -- Max Miedinger and all those Swiss designers together,
26
77000
4000
01:33
trying to outdo Akzidenz-Grotesk, and come up with a new sans-serif typeface --
27
81000
5000
01:38
and the movie starts playing in my head already.
28
86000
3000
01:41
And of course, you can imagine, with Humble Masterpieces
29
89000
3000
01:44
it was the same thing multiplied by a hundred.
30
92000
3000
01:47
And I do hope, by the way, that the real goal of the exhibition
31
95000
3000
01:50
is going to have the same effect on you.
32
98000
2000
01:52
The exhibition was meant to be a way to have children think of doing ...
33
100000
6000
01:58
you know when they do homeworks at home?
34
106000
2000
02:00
Instead of having a tray with two peas, I was hoping that they would go
35
108000
3000
02:03
into the kitchen cabinet or the mother's handbag
36
111000
3000
02:06
and do their museum-quality design collection on a tray.
37
114000
4000
02:10
So, everybody's always suggesting new humble masterpieces,
38
118000
4000
02:14
and at MoMA we put out some books
39
122000
1000
02:15
just for people to suggest their own humble masterpieces.
40
123000
4000
02:19
And when you do that, usually you get 80 percent porn and 20 percent real suggestions,
41
127000
5000
02:24
and instead it was all -- almost -- all good suggestions.
42
132000
5000
02:29
And a lot of nationalism came in.
43
137000
2000
02:31
For instance, I didn't know that the Spaniards invented the mop,
44
139000
4000
02:35
but they were very proud
45
143000
1000
02:36
so every Spaniard said "la frego." And Italians did the pizza.
46
144000
3000
02:39
And I wanted to show you, also, the suggestions from Kentucky are pretty good --
47
147000
4000
02:43
they had moonshine, laundry detergents and liquid nails.
48
151000
3000
02:46
And I keep it going, and I just got,
49
154000
1000
02:47
(Laughter)
50
155000
1000
02:48
also, this suggestion from Milan:
51
156000
3000
02:51
it's our traffic divider, which we call "panettone," and it's painted;
52
159000
5000
02:56
it's these beautiful concrete things that you use around Milan
53
164000
4000
03:00
to define all the lanes of traffic.
54
168000
2000
03:02
So, think of your own,
55
170000
1000
03:03
send them on if you want to -- they're always welcome.
56
171000
3000
03:06
But an exhibition like that made me understand even more
57
174000
5000
03:11
what I've been thinking of for 13 years ever since I got to MoMA.
58
179000
4000
03:15
I'm Italian. In Italy, design is normal.
59
183000
3000
03:18
Different parts of the world have a knack for different things.
60
186000
4000
03:22
I was just recently in Argentina and in Uruguay,
61
190000
4000
03:26
and the default way of building homes in the country is a beautiful modernism
62
194000
6000
03:32
that you don't see elsewhere, but the contemporary art was terrible.
63
200000
4000
03:36
In Italy, in Milan especially,
64
204000
2000
03:38
contemporary art really doesn't have that much of a place.
65
206000
4000
03:42
But design -- oh, my God.
66
210000
1000
03:43
What you find at the store at the corner, without going to any kind of fancy store,
67
211000
5000
03:48
is the kind of refined design that makes everybody think that
68
216000
2000
03:50
we are all so sophisticated.
69
218000
2000
03:52
It's just what you find at the store.
70
220000
2000
03:54
And New York has another kind of knack for contemporary art.
71
222000
5000
03:59
I'm always amazed -- three-year-olds know who Richard Serra is
72
227000
5000
04:04
and take you to the galleries.
73
232000
2000
04:06
But design, for some reason, is still misunderstood for decoration.
74
234000
4000
04:10
It's really interesting:
75
238000
2000
04:12
what many people think when I say the word "design" is they think of
76
240000
4000
04:16
this kind of overdesigned -- in this case, it's overdesigned on purpose, but --
77
244000
5000
04:21
decoration, interior decoration.
78
249000
2000
04:23
They think of somebody choosing fabrics.
79
251000
2000
04:25
Design can be that, of course, but it can also be this.
80
253000
4000
04:29
It can be a school of design in Jerusalem that tries to find a better way
81
257000
5000
04:34
to design gas masks for people,
82
262000
1000
04:35
because, as you know, Israel deploys one gas mask per person including babies.
83
263000
5000
04:41
So, what these designers do is they find a way to lower the neckline,
84
269000
5000
04:46
so that instead of being completely strangled, a teenager can also sip a Coke.
85
274000
6000
04:52
They tried to make a toddler's gas mask in such a way that the toddler
86
280000
6000
04:58
can be held by the parent because proximity of the body is so important.
87
286000
4000
05:03
And then they make a little tent for the baby.
88
291000
1000
05:04
However cruel, however ruthless you can think this is it's a great design,
89
292000
6000
05:10
and it is miles away from the fancy furniture,
90
298000
4000
05:14
but still, it's part of my same field of passion.
91
302000
3000
05:17
What I've been doing at MoMA since the beginning is to try to
92
305000
5000
05:22
harness the power of MoMA
93
310000
2000
05:24
because it's great to work there. You really have power
94
312000
3000
05:27
in that people usually tend to know about your exhibition or see the exhibitions,
95
315000
5000
05:32
and that is power because in a design museum I wouldn't have as many visitors.
96
320000
5000
05:37
I'm very well aware that 80 percent of my public is there to see Picasso and Matisse,
97
325000
5000
05:42
and then they stumble upon my show and I keep them there.
98
330000
3000
05:45
But what I've been trying to do is something that the curators at MoMA
99
333000
3000
05:48
in my department have been doing ever since the museum was founded in 1929,
100
336000
4000
05:52
which is to try and see what's going on in the world
101
340000
3000
05:55
and try to use that authority in order to make things better.
102
343000
4000
05:59
There have been many episodes,
103
347000
3000
06:02
and actually Eames Demetrius may be here in the audience,
104
350000
2000
06:04
but in two instances, his great-grandfather, grandfather --
105
352000
5000
06:09
I'm always a little perplexed about the relation, exactly --
106
357000
4000
06:14
Charles Eames the first time and then Charles and Ray Eames the second time
107
362000
4000
06:18
were involved in two competitions:
108
366000
2000
06:20
one in 1940, it was about organic furniture, and the second one in 1948
109
368000
5000
06:25
was low-cost furniture for the GIs coming back from the war
110
373000
4000
06:29
that then sparked a whole line of furniture.
111
377000
3000
06:32
And then there was good design for very low price.
112
380000
4000
06:37
There were a lot of programs in architecture and design that were about
113
385000
4000
06:41
pointing people in the direction of a better design for a better life.
114
389000
4000
06:47
So, I started out in '95 with this exhibition that was called
115
395000
2000
06:50
Mutant Materials in Contemporary Design.
116
398000
2000
06:52
It was about a new phase, in my opinion, in the world of design
117
400000
4000
06:56
in that materials could be customized by the designers themselves.
118
404000
4000
07:00
And that put me in touch with such diverse design examples as the aerogels
119
408000
8000
07:08
from the Lawrence Livermore Lab in California;
120
416000
2000
07:10
at that time, they were beginning to be brought into the civilian market.
121
418000
5000
07:16
And at the same time, the gorgeous work of Takeshi Ishiguro, who did these
122
424000
2000
07:19
beautiful salt-and-pepper containers that are made of rice dough.
123
427000
4000
07:23
So you see, the range is really quite diverse.
124
431000
4000
07:28
And then, for instance, this other exhibition
125
436000
2000
07:30
that was entitled Workspheres in 2001,
126
438000
3000
07:34
where I asked different designers to come up with ideas for
127
442000
4000
07:38
the new type of work styles that were happening in the world at that time.
128
446000
5000
07:43
And you see IDEO there.
129
451000
2000
07:45
It was beautiful -- it was called Personal Skies.
130
453000
2000
07:48
The idea was that if you had a cubicle, you could project a sky on top
131
456000
4000
07:52
of your head and have your own "Cielo in Una Stanza" -- a sky in a room --
132
460000
3000
07:56
it's a very famous Italian song.
133
464000
2000
07:58
And other examples: this was Marti Guixe about working on the go,
134
466000
3000
08:02
and Hella Jongerius, my favorite, about how to work at home.
135
470000
3000
08:05
And this lets me introduce a very important idea about design:
136
473000
4000
08:10
designers are the biggest synthesizers in the world.
137
478000
3000
08:13
What they do best is make a synthesis of human needs,
138
481000
4000
08:18
current conditions in economy, in materials, in sustainability issues,
139
486000
4000
08:22
and then what they do at the end -- if they are good --
140
490000
4000
08:26
is much more than the sum of its parts.
141
494000
2000
08:28
Hella Jongerius is a person that is able to make a synthesis
142
496000
3000
08:31
that is really quite amazing
143
499000
2000
08:34
and also quite hilarious.
144
502000
1000
08:35
The idea behind her work was that
145
503000
3000
08:38
at that time, everybody was saying you have to really divide your life.
146
506000
4000
08:42
Instead, she said, "No, no. Work and leisure can be together."
147
510000
3000
08:45
Yeah, that's particularly gorgeous -- it's the TV dinner of 2001.
148
513000
4000
08:49
There have been many other exhibitions in the meantime,
149
517000
3000
08:53
but I don't want to focus on my shows.
150
521000
1000
08:54
I would like, instead, to talk about how great some designers are.
151
522000
4000
08:58
I've always had a hard time with the word "maverick."
152
526000
2000
09:00
I came to the United States 13 years ago, and to this day
153
528000
2000
09:02
I have to ask, "What does that mean?"
154
530000
3000
09:05
So, this morning I went to see on the dictionary and it said that
155
533000
3000
09:08
there was this gentleman that was not branding its cattle.
156
536000
3000
09:11
Therefore, he was not following everybody's lead,
157
539000
3000
09:14
and therefore, he was a maverick.
158
542000
1000
09:15
So, designers do need to be mavericks,
159
543000
4000
09:19
because the best way to design a successful object --
160
547000
3000
09:22
and also an object that we were missing before --
161
550000
4000
09:26
is to pretend that either it never existed
162
554000
3000
09:29
or that people will be able to have a new behavior with it.
163
557000
4000
09:33
So, Safe is the last exhibition that I did at MoMA
164
561000
4000
09:37
and it ended at the beginning of last year.
165
565000
2000
09:40
It was about design that deals with safety and deals with protection.
166
568000
3000
09:43
It's a long story because it started before 2001 and it was called Emergency.
167
571000
5000
09:48
And then when 9/11 happened, I had a shock and I canceled the exhibition
168
576000
6000
09:54
until, slowly but surely, it came back --
169
582000
2000
09:57
as a half-full glass instead of half-empty --
170
585000
3000
10:00
and it was about protection and safety.
171
588000
1000
10:02
But it ranged from such items as a complete de-mining equipment to
172
590000
7000
10:09
these kind of water-sterilizing straws,
173
597000
4000
10:13
so it was really wide-ranging.
174
601000
1000
10:14
It also had ... you know, Cameron and I worked a little bit together,
175
602000
3000
10:18
and some of the entries that you see in his website were actually in the exhibition.
176
606000
4000
10:22
But what is interesting is that we don't need to talk about design and art anymore;
177
610000
6000
10:29
design uses whatever tools it has at its disposal in order to make a point.
178
617000
4000
10:33
It's a sense of economy and a sense, also, of humor.
179
621000
3000
10:36
This is a beautiful project by Ralph Borland, who's South African.
180
624000
4000
10:40
It's a suit for civil disobedience.
181
628000
2000
10:42
The idea is that when you have a riot or a protest
182
630000
3000
10:45
and the police comes towards you, you're wearing this thing --
183
633000
3000
10:48
it's like a big heart and it has a loudspeaker over your heart
184
636000
3000
10:52
so your heartbeat is amplified --
185
640000
1000
10:53
and the police is reminded;
186
641000
1000
10:55
it's like having a flower in front of the rifle.
187
643000
3000
10:58
And also, you can imagine, a whole group of people with the same suit
188
646000
5000
11:03
will have this mounting collective heartbeat that will be scary to the police.
189
651000
4000
11:07
So, designers sometimes don't do things that are immediately
190
655000
3000
11:10
functional, but they're functional to our understanding of issues.
191
658000
3000
11:14
Tony Dunne and Fiona Raby
192
662000
2000
11:16
did this series of objects that are about our anguish and our paranoia,
193
664000
6000
11:22
like this hideaway furniture that's made in the same wood as your floor
194
670000
4000
11:26
so it disappears completely and you can hide away;
195
674000
2000
11:28
or even better, the huggable atomic mushroom, which got me an article
196
676000
5000
11:33
on the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists of the United States --
197
681000
2000
11:36
I don't think it ever happened before at MoMA;
198
684000
1000
11:38
or this Faraday Chair that is supposed to protect you from radiations.
199
686000
3000
11:41
But the interesting thing in the exhibition is the discovery that
200
689000
5000
11:47
the ultimate shelter is your sense of self,
201
695000
2000
11:49
and there are quite a few designers that are working on this particular topic.
202
697000
4000
11:54
This is Cindy van den Bremen, who is a Dutch designer
203
702000
2000
11:56
that's done this series of Capsters.
204
704000
2000
11:58
They are athletic gear for Muslim women that enable them to ski, play tennis,
205
706000
7000
12:05
do whatever they want to do without having to uncap themselves.
206
713000
4000
12:09
And sometimes by doing this kind of research,
207
717000
4000
12:13
you encounter such beautiful ideas of design.
208
721000
2000
12:15
Twan Verdonck is really young, I think he's 27, and working together with
209
723000
6000
12:21
some psychologist he did a series of toys that are for sensorial
210
729000
3000
12:25
stimulation for children that have psychological impairments.
211
733000
2000
12:27
They're quite beautiful.
212
735000
1000
12:29
They range from this fluffy toy that is about hugging you --
213
737000
3000
12:32
because autistic children like to be hugged tight, so it has a spring inside --
214
740000
3000
12:36
all the way to this doll with a mirror so the child can see him or herself
215
744000
5000
12:41
in the mirror and regain a sense of self.
216
749000
2000
12:45
Design really looks upon the whole world
217
753000
3000
12:48
and it considers the world in all of its different ranges.
218
756000
3000
12:51
I was recently at a conference on luxury organized by the Herald Tribune in Istanbul.
219
759000
5000
12:56
And it was really interesting because I was the last speaker
220
764000
2000
12:59
and before me there were people that were really talking about luxury,
221
767000
3000
13:02
and I didn't want to be a party pooper but at the same time
222
770000
3000
13:06
I felt that I had to kind of bring back the discourse to reality.
223
774000
2000
13:08
And the truth is that there are very different kinds of luxury,
224
776000
5000
13:14
and there's luxury that is relative for people that don't have that much.
225
782000
4000
13:18
I want to make this point by showing you two examples of
226
786000
5000
13:23
design coming from a sense of economy -- very, very clear limits.
227
791000
5000
13:28
This is Cuba, and this is the recycling of a squeaky toy as a bicycle bell,
228
796000
6000
13:34
and this is a raincoat that is made out of rice sacks.
229
802000
5000
13:39
So they're quite beautiful, but they're beautiful because
230
807000
2000
13:41
they're so smart and economical.
231
809000
2000
13:44
And here is the work of two brothers from Sao Paulo,
232
812000
3000
13:47
Fernando and Humberto Campana, who got inspired by the poverty and
233
815000
5000
13:53
smartness that they saw around them to do pieces of furniture that now are
234
821000
4000
13:57
selling for an enormous amount of money.
235
825000
2000
13:59
But that's because of the kind of strangeness of the market itself.
236
827000
4000
14:03
So really, design takes everything into account,
237
831000
3000
14:07
and the interesting thing is that as the technology advances,
238
835000
3000
14:10
as we become more and more wireless and impalpable,
239
838000
4000
14:14
designers, instead, want us to be hands-on.
240
842000
3000
14:17
Sometimes hammer-on.
241
845000
1000
14:18
This is a whole series of furniture that wants to engage you physically.
242
846000
4000
14:23
Even this chair that you have to open up and then sit on so that it takes
243
851000
4000
14:27
your imprint, all the way to this beautiful series of objects
244
855000
4000
14:32
that are considered design by Ana Mir in Barcelona.
245
860000
3000
14:35
From this kind of bijou made with human hair to these chocolate nipples
246
863000
4000
14:40
to these intra-toe candies that your lover is supposed to suck from your toes.
247
868000
4000
14:44
(Laughter)
248
872000
1000
14:45
It's quite beautiful because somehow, this is a gorgeous moment for design.
249
873000
5000
14:50
Many years ago I heard a mathematician from Vienna, whose name was Marchetti,
250
878000
6000
14:57
explain how the innovation in the military industry --
251
885000
4000
15:01
therefore, secret innovation -- and the innovation in the
252
889000
3000
15:05
civilian society are two sinusoids that are kind of opposed.
253
893000
3000
15:08
And that makes sense.
254
896000
1000
15:10
In moments of war there's great technological innovation,
255
898000
2000
15:12
and in the world you have to do without --
256
900000
2000
15:15
well, during the Second World War, you had to do without steel,
257
903000
2000
15:17
you had to do without aluminum.
258
905000
1000
15:18
And then as peace comes, all of these technologies get all of a sudden
259
906000
5000
15:23
available for the civilian market.
260
911000
2000
15:25
Many of you might know that the Potato Chip Chair
261
913000
3000
15:28
by Charles and Ray Eames comes exactly from that kind of instance:
262
916000
4000
15:32
fiberglass was available for civilian use all of a sudden.
263
920000
3000
15:35
I think that this is a strange moment.
264
923000
2000
15:38
The rhythm of the sinusoids has changed tremendously,
265
926000
2000
15:40
just like the rhythm of our life in the past 25 years,
266
928000
3000
15:44
so I'm not sure anymore what the wavelength is.
267
932000
3000
15:47
But it surely is a very important moment for design,
268
935000
3000
15:51
because not only is the technology proceeding, not only is computing
269
939000
4000
15:55
technology making open-source possible also in the world of design,
270
943000
4000
16:00
but also the idea of sustainability --
271
948000
2000
16:02
which is not only sustainability from the viewpoint of CO2 emissions and footprint,
272
950000
5000
16:08
but also sustainability of human interrelationships --
273
956000
3000
16:11
is very much part of the work of so many designers.
274
959000
3000
16:14
And that's why designers, more and more, are working on behaviors
275
962000
3000
16:17
rather than on objects.
276
965000
1000
16:18
Especially the good ones, not all of them.
277
966000
3000
16:21
I wanted to show you, for instance, the work of Mathieu Lehanneur,
278
969000
3000
16:25
which is quite fantastic.
279
973000
1000
16:26
He's another young designer from France who's working --
280
974000
2000
16:29
and at this point he's working, also, with pharmaceutical companies --
281
977000
2000
16:31
on new ways to engage patients, especially children,
282
979000
4000
16:35
in taking their medicines with constancy and with certainty.
283
983000
4000
16:39
For instance, this is a beautiful container for asthma medicine
284
987000
4000
16:43
that kind of inflates itself when it's time for you to take the medicine,
285
991000
3000
16:46
so the child has to go -- pffff! -- to release and relieve the container itself.
286
994000
5000
16:51
And this other medicine is something that you can draw on your skin,
287
999000
3000
16:54
so intradermal delivery enables you to joyfully be involved
288
1002000
5000
16:59
in this particular kind of delivery.
289
1007000
2000
17:01
Similarly, there's the work of people like Marti Guixe that tries to involve
290
1009000
5000
17:07
you in a way that is really about making everything pass through your mouth
291
1015000
5000
17:12
so that you learn from your mistakes or from your taste, orally.
292
1020000
6000
17:19
The next show that I'm going to work on --
293
1027000
2000
17:21
and I've been bugging a lot of you about this here --
294
1029000
3000
17:24
is about the relationship between design and science.
295
1032000
2000
17:26
I'm trying to find not the metaphors, but, rather, the points in common --
296
1034000
4000
17:30
the common gripes, the common issues, the common preoccupations --
297
1038000
4000
17:34
and I think that it will enable us to go a little further in this idea of design
298
1042000
6000
17:41
as an instruction, as a direction rather than a prescription of form.
299
1049000
5000
17:46
And I am hoping that many of you will respond to this.
300
1054000
4000
17:50
I've sent an email already to quite a few of you.
301
1058000
3000
17:53
But design and science and the possibility of visualizing different scales,
302
1061000
3000
17:57
and therefore, really work at the scale of the very small
303
1065000
4000
18:01
to make it very big and very meaningful.
304
1069000
2000
18:03
Thank you. (Applause)
305
1071000
1000
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Paola Antonelli - Design curatorPaola Antonelli is on a mission to introduce -- and explain -- design to the world. With her shows at New York's Museum of Modern Art, she celebrates design's presence in every part of life.
Why you should listen
Since she stepped back from practicing architecture in order to focus on writing about design, teaching and curating gallery exhibitions, Italian native Paola Antonelli has become a force to be reckoned with in the design world. Working at the Museum of Modern Art in New York since 1994, she is senior curator of the gallery's Architecture and Design department and, as of 2012, the museum's first ever director of research and development. Antonelli has worked on shows such as "Humble Masterpieces," which celebrated traditionally unheralded design icons such as the paperclip; "Design and the Elastic Mind," considering the relationship of design and technology, and "Talk to Me ," which looked at design and the communication of people and objects.
Ever mindful that the majority of visitors to MOMA are attracted by artists such as Picasso and Matisse, Antonelli works to ensure that if they do stumble across a design-related show, they'll be both entertained and enlightened. In 2012, she led a move to acquire 14 video games for the museum's permanent collection.
Paola Antonelli | Speaker | TED.com