TED2017
Kristin Poinar: What's hidden under the Greenland ice sheet?
Filmed:
Readability: 3.7
4,494,857 views
The Greenland ice sheet is massive, mysterious -- and melting. Using advanced technology, scientists are revealing its secrets for the first time, and what they've found is amazing: hidden under the ice sheet is a vast aquifer that holds a Lake Tahoe-sized volume of water from the summer melt. Does this water stay there, or does it find its way out to the ocean and contribute to global sea level rise? Join glaciologist Kristin Poinar for a trip to this frozen, forgotten land to find out.
Kristin Poinar - Glaciologist
Kristin Poinar uses remote sensing and numerical models to study the interaction of meltwater with ice flow, especially on the Greenland Ice Sheet. Full bio
Kristin Poinar uses remote sensing and numerical models to study the interaction of meltwater with ice flow, especially on the Greenland Ice Sheet. Full bio
Double-click the English transcript below to play the video.
00:12
When was I was 21 years old,
0
880
2136
00:15
I had all this physics homework.
1
3040
1800
00:17
Physics homework requires taking breaks,
2
5800
2335
00:20
and Wikipedia was relatively new,
so I took a lot of breaks there.
so I took a lot of breaks there.
3
8160
3600
00:24
I kept going back to the same articles,
4
12240
2216
00:26
reading them again and again,
5
14480
1656
00:28
on glaciers, Antarctica and Greenland.
6
16160
3400
00:33
How cool would it be to visit these places
7
21320
2536
00:35
and what would it take to do so?
8
23880
1560
00:38
Well, here we are
9
26280
1216
00:39
on a repurposed Air Force cargo plane
10
27520
2416
00:41
operated by NASA
11
29960
1656
00:43
flying over the Greenland ice sheet.
12
31640
1800
00:46
There's a lot to see here,
13
34400
1616
00:48
but there's more that is hidden,
14
36040
1776
00:49
waiting to be uncovered.
15
37840
1280
00:52
What the Wikipedia articles didn't tell me
16
40360
2296
00:54
is that there's liquid water
hidden inside the ice sheet,
hidden inside the ice sheet,
17
42680
2960
00:58
because we didn't know that yet.
18
46680
1524
01:02
I did learn on Wikipedia
that the Greenland ice sheet is huge,
that the Greenland ice sheet is huge,
19
50000
3576
01:05
the size of Mexico,
20
53600
1296
01:06
and its ice from top to bottom
is two miles thick.
is two miles thick.
21
54920
3400
01:10
But it's not just static.
22
58720
1856
01:12
The ice flows like a river
downhill towards the ocean.
downhill towards the ocean.
23
60600
3440
01:17
As it flows around bends,
24
65080
1896
01:19
it deforms and cracks.
25
67000
1720
01:21
I get to study these amazing ice dynamics,
26
69600
2696
01:24
which are located in one of the most
remote physical environments
remote physical environments
27
72320
3096
01:27
remaining on earth.
28
75440
1440
01:29
To work in glaciology right now
is like getting in on the ground floor
is like getting in on the ground floor
29
77560
3456
01:33
at Facebook in the 2000s.
30
81040
1920
01:35
(Laughter)
31
83520
1576
01:37
Our capability to fly airplanes
and satellites over the ice sheets
and satellites over the ice sheets
32
85120
3136
01:40
is revolutionizing glaciology.
33
88280
2216
01:42
It's just starting to do for science
34
90520
1936
01:44
what the smartphone
has done for social media.
has done for social media.
35
92480
2160
01:47
The satellites are reporting
a wealth of observations
a wealth of observations
36
95320
2976
01:50
that are revealing new hidden facts
about the ice sheets continuously.
about the ice sheets continuously.
37
98320
4240
01:55
For instance, we have observations
of the size of the Greenland ice sheet
of the size of the Greenland ice sheet
38
103400
3736
01:59
every month going back to 2002.
39
107160
2560
02:02
You can look towards the bottom
of the screen here
of the screen here
40
110320
2376
02:04
to see the month and the year go forward.
41
112720
1976
02:06
You can see that some areas
of the ice sheet melt
of the ice sheet melt
42
114720
2496
02:09
or lose ice in the summer.
43
117240
1760
02:11
Other areas experience snowfall
44
119640
2056
02:13
or gain ice back in the winter.
45
121720
2120
02:16
This seasonal cycle, though, is eclipsed
by an overall rate of mass loss
by an overall rate of mass loss
46
124840
4856
02:21
that would have stunned
a glaciologist 50 years ago.
a glaciologist 50 years ago.
47
129720
2880
02:25
We never thought that an ice sheet could
lose mass into the ocean this quickly.
lose mass into the ocean this quickly.
48
133040
4640
02:31
Since these measurements began in 2002,
49
139320
2576
02:33
the ice sheet has lost so much ice
50
141920
2136
02:36
that if that water were piled up
on our smallest continent,
on our smallest continent,
51
144080
3616
02:39
it would drown Australia knee-deep.
52
147720
2280
02:42
How is this possible?
53
150840
1280
02:45
Well, under the ice lies the bedrock.
54
153400
3216
02:48
We used radar to image the hills,
valleys, mountains and depressions
valleys, mountains and depressions
55
156640
4456
02:53
that the ice flows over.
56
161120
1816
02:54
Hidden under the ice sheet are channels
the size of the Grand Canyon
the size of the Grand Canyon
57
162960
3496
02:58
that funnel ice and water
off of Greenland and into the ocean.
off of Greenland and into the ocean.
58
166480
4200
03:04
The reason that radar
can reveal the bedrock
can reveal the bedrock
59
172320
2536
03:06
is that ice is entirely
transparent to radar.
transparent to radar.
60
174880
2856
03:09
You can do an experiment.
61
177760
1536
03:11
Go home and put
an ice cube in the microwave.
an ice cube in the microwave.
62
179320
2840
03:14
It won't melt,
63
182920
1776
03:16
because microwaves, or radar,
64
184720
2096
03:18
pass straight through the ice
without interacting.
without interacting.
65
186840
2360
03:22
If you want to melt your ice cube,
you have to get it wet,
you have to get it wet,
66
190760
2736
03:25
because water heats up easily
in the microwave.
in the microwave.
67
193520
3696
03:29
That's the whole principle
the microwave oven is designed around.
the microwave oven is designed around.
68
197240
3336
03:32
Radar can see water.
69
200600
1640
03:35
And radar has revealed
a vast pool of liquid water
a vast pool of liquid water
70
203120
3696
03:38
hidden under my colleague Olivia,
71
206840
1936
03:40
seven stories beneath her feet.
72
208800
1680
03:43
Here, she's used a pump
73
211320
1256
03:44
to bring some of that water
back to the ice sheet's surface.
back to the ice sheet's surface.
74
212600
3216
03:47
Just six years ago, we had no idea
this glacier aquifer existed.
this glacier aquifer existed.
75
215840
4760
03:53
The aquifer formed
76
221840
1296
03:55
when snow melts in the summer sun
77
223160
2376
03:57
and trickles downward.
78
225560
1280
03:59
It puddles up in huge pools.
79
227680
2040
04:02
From there, the snow acts as an igloo,
80
230600
2536
04:05
insulating this water
from the cold and the wind above.
from the cold and the wind above.
81
233160
2880
04:09
So the water can stay
hidden in the ice sheet
hidden in the ice sheet
82
237120
2496
04:11
in liquid form year after year.
83
239640
2400
04:14
The question is, what happens next?
84
242880
2816
04:17
Does the water stay there forever?
85
245720
1736
04:19
It could.
86
247480
1216
04:20
Or does it find a way out
to reach the global ocean?
to reach the global ocean?
87
248720
2640
04:24
One possible way
for the water to reach the bedrock
for the water to reach the bedrock
88
252400
3376
04:27
and from there the ocean
89
255800
1656
04:29
is a crevasse, or a crack in the ice.
90
257480
2479
04:32
When cracks fill with water,
91
260680
1496
04:34
the weight of the water
forces them deeper and deeper.
forces them deeper and deeper.
92
262200
2800
04:37
This is how fracking works
93
265600
1416
04:39
to extract natural gas
from deep within the earth.
from deep within the earth.
94
267040
3016
04:42
Pressurized fluids fracture rocks.
95
270080
2080
04:44
All it takes is a crack to get started.
96
272760
2120
04:47
Well, we recently discovered
97
275920
2256
04:50
that there are cracks available
in the Greenland ice sheet
in the Greenland ice sheet
98
278200
3896
04:54
near this glacier aquifer.
99
282120
1640
04:56
You can fly over
most of the Greenland ice sheet
most of the Greenland ice sheet
100
284440
2256
04:58
and see nothing,
101
286720
1216
04:59
no cracks, no features on the surface,
102
287960
2896
05:02
but as this helicopter
flies towards the coast,
flies towards the coast,
103
290880
3176
05:06
the path that water would take
on its quest to flow downhill,
on its quest to flow downhill,
104
294080
3616
05:09
one crack appears,
105
297720
1576
05:11
then another and another.
106
299320
2000
05:14
Are these cracks filled with liquid water?
107
302840
2576
05:17
And if so, how deep
do they take that water?
do they take that water?
108
305440
2656
05:20
Can they take it to the bedrock
109
308120
1496
05:21
and the ocean?
110
309640
1336
05:23
To answer these questions,
111
311000
1696
05:24
we need something
beyond remote sensing data.
beyond remote sensing data.
112
312720
3416
05:28
We need numeric models.
113
316160
1360
05:31
I write numeric models
that run on supercomputers.
that run on supercomputers.
114
319160
2520
05:34
A numeric model
is simply a set of equations
is simply a set of equations
115
322360
2416
05:36
that works together to describe something.
116
324800
2240
05:39
It can be as simple
as the next number in a sequence --
as the next number in a sequence --
117
327600
2896
05:42
one, three, five, seven --
118
330520
2080
05:45
or it can be a more complex
set of equations
set of equations
119
333320
2376
05:47
that predict the future
120
335720
1376
05:49
based on known conditions in the present.
121
337120
1960
05:51
In our case, what are
the equations for how ice cracks?
the equations for how ice cracks?
122
339680
3480
05:56
Well, engineers already have
a very good understanding
a very good understanding
123
344240
3576
05:59
of how aluminum, steel and plastics
fracture under stress.
fracture under stress.
124
347840
3800
06:04
It's an important problem in our society.
125
352240
1960
06:07
And it turns out
that the engineering equations
that the engineering equations
126
355800
2216
06:10
for how materials fracture
127
358040
1576
06:11
are not that different
from my physics homework.
from my physics homework.
128
359640
2736
06:14
So I borrowed them, adapted them for ice,
129
362400
2856
06:17
and then I had a numeric model
for how a crevasse can fracture
for how a crevasse can fracture
130
365280
3456
06:20
when filled with water from the aquifer.
131
368760
2000
06:24
This is the power of math.
132
372000
1736
06:25
It can help us understand
real processes in our world.
real processes in our world.
133
373760
3120
06:29
I'll show you now
the results of my numeric model,
the results of my numeric model,
134
377880
2696
06:32
but first I should point out
135
380600
1576
06:34
that the crevasse is about
a thousand times narrower than it is deep,
a thousand times narrower than it is deep,
136
382200
3816
06:38
so in the main panel here,
137
386040
1496
06:39
we've zoomed in to better see the details.
138
387560
2096
06:41
You can look to the smaller
panel on the right
panel on the right
139
389680
2176
06:43
to see the true scale
for how tall and skinny the crevasse is.
for how tall and skinny the crevasse is.
140
391880
3160
06:48
As the aquifer water
flows into the crevasse,
flows into the crevasse,
141
396440
2576
06:51
some of it refreezes
in the negative 15 degree Celsius ice.
in the negative 15 degree Celsius ice.
142
399040
3976
06:55
That's about as cold
as your kitchen freezer.
as your kitchen freezer.
143
403040
2496
06:57
But this loss can be overcome
144
405560
1976
06:59
if the flow rate in from
the glacier aquifer is high enough.
the glacier aquifer is high enough.
145
407560
3240
07:03
In our case, it is,
146
411440
1576
07:05
and the aquifer water drives the crevasse
all the way to the base of the ice sheet
all the way to the base of the ice sheet
147
413040
4616
07:09
a thousand meters below.
148
417680
1720
07:12
From there, it has a clear path
to reach the ocean.
to reach the ocean.
149
420800
2560
07:16
So the aquifer water is a part
150
424480
2336
07:18
of the three millimeters
per year of sea level rise
per year of sea level rise
151
426840
3296
07:22
that we experience as a global society.
152
430160
2320
07:26
But there's more:
153
434520
1256
07:27
the aquifer water
might be punching above its weight.
might be punching above its weight.
154
435800
2760
07:31
The ice flows in complex ways.
155
439560
2080
07:35
In some places, the ice flows very fast.
156
443040
2896
07:37
There tends to be water
at the base of the ice sheet here.
at the base of the ice sheet here.
157
445960
2720
07:41
In other places, not so fast.
158
449400
1616
07:43
Usually, there's not water
present at the base there.
present at the base there.
159
451040
2480
07:46
Now that we know the aquifer water
is getting to the base of the ice sheet,
is getting to the base of the ice sheet,
160
454600
3776
07:50
the next question is:
161
458400
1736
07:52
Is it making the ice itself
flow faster into the ocean?
flow faster into the ocean?
162
460160
3480
07:58
We're trying to uncover these mysteries
hidden inside the Greenland ice sheet
hidden inside the Greenland ice sheet
163
466080
3736
08:01
so that we can better plan
for the sea level rise it holds.
for the sea level rise it holds.
164
469840
3320
08:06
The amount of ice
that Greenland has lost since 2002
that Greenland has lost since 2002
165
474120
3336
08:09
is just a small fraction
of what that ice sheet holds.
of what that ice sheet holds.
166
477480
3520
08:14
Ice sheets are immense, powerful machines
that operate on long timescales.
that operate on long timescales.
167
482120
4856
08:19
In the next 80 years, global sea levels
will rise at least 20 centimeters,
will rise at least 20 centimeters,
168
487000
5576
08:24
perhaps as much as one meter,
169
492600
2176
08:26
and maybe more.
170
494800
1776
08:28
Our understanding
of future sea level rise is good,
of future sea level rise is good,
171
496600
3136
08:31
but our projections have a wide range.
172
499760
2376
08:34
It's our role as glaciologists
and scientists
and scientists
173
502160
3176
08:37
to narrow these uncertainties.
174
505360
1720
08:40
How much sea level rise is coming,
175
508200
2816
08:43
and how fast will it get here?
176
511040
1840
08:46
We need to know how much and how fast,
177
514400
3576
08:50
so the world and its communities can
plan for the sea level rise that's coming.
plan for the sea level rise that's coming.
178
518000
4320
08:55
Thank you.
179
523039
1217
08:56
(Applause)
180
524509
3190
ABOUT THE SPEAKER
Kristin Poinar - GlaciologistKristin Poinar uses remote sensing and numerical models to study the interaction of meltwater with ice flow, especially on the Greenland Ice Sheet.
Why you should listen
Hidden under many meters of ice, a pool of meltwater lies under the Greenland Ice Sheet. Kristin Poinar studies how the meltwater forms and flows in this dynamic glacial system. She asks: How did this water get there, and where does it go? How much water is in there? And how is climate change affecting this system?
Using data from Operation IceBridge flights and from field instruments, she's building a numerical model of how crevasses form and channel water. In fact, a NASA report released in February 2017 revealed a new pathway her team discovered for meltwater to reach the ocean. Using physically based models to constrain the bounds of what is realistic has shaped Poinar's interest in glaciology.
Poinar is currently a postdoctoral researcher at NASA Goddard Space Flight Center. She will be moving to the University at Buffalo in winter 2017 to be a professor in the Geology Department and the RENEW Institute.
Kristin Poinar | Speaker | TED.com